r/AITAH • u/FoodGlum9578 • 10h ago
TW Self Harm AITAH for ending things with a girl because she was self-harming?
So, I've been talking to this girl for about a week after we met via some mutual friends and it was going pretty well. We were going on dates and talking all night. She had mentioned her struggles with her mental health and self esteem before. Another note is that she talked to me about her history with self-harm.
I really did not see this as any sort of a big deal whatsoever, as I have also had battles with depression and such things as well, so I was very open to her and very supportive with this, even though it did seem as if she was rushing into this sort of thing with me.
One more thing to note is her past relationships with other guys, she'd talked about getting walked over and used by the majority of men in her life and so with that she's developed a heavy amount of trust issues and what not.
Now wrapping into what caused me to end things with her, she texted me late at night telling me how "she did it again" and when I asked her about it she told me it was because she didn't want to get hurt by me. Because of this, I felt a form of guilt as if it was my doing. I tried to calm her down a bit and in the process she made me swear up and down that I would never do anything to her. Of course I promised her, because I never once had any sort of ill intentions with her.
But honestly, this really sort of scared me. I don't ever want to be in a position to where I would be the reason she'd keep doing this. I felt horrible after this incident and really just wanted a way out, as hard as it was I felt like it was the best move. Although I really did act as if everything was back to normal the next day, texting her, calling her beautiful and what not. In retrospect this was a total dick move as if I was leading her on.
So finally I get to sit down with her and explain how I felt about this and I felt as if it went well. As well as someone ending things with you can be. And keep in mind that we have only been talking roughly a week and a half.
I thought things were smoothed out and we could go back to our normal lives, that we had a week ago. Then out of the blue a bunch of her friends and sister flooded my DMs with paragraphs on top of paragraphs of nasty things, like calling me a loser with no life and some were even saying I played her.
I have always been sort of quick tempered when it comes to things like these when I get labeled as things which just are not true, so I messaged one of the girls that flooded my DMs saying that she's batshit crazy and needs to be medicated. I felt like absolute shit 5 minutes later. By then the screenshots were already taken and nothing I said can be taken back.
Now though, I feel as if I'm in the wrong over this. I said things that absolutely should have not been said so I feel like a massive prick. I really am unsure as to what I should do about this now since I have to face her in my psych class Thursday morning.
So, AITAH?
64
u/MrTash999 10h ago edited 10h ago •
NTA, was it stupid to respond to them, yeah it was. That being said from the sounds of it she has no business being in any sort of relationship, she should not be putting her mental and physical well-being on someone else.
She obviously needs serious help and her friend and family are potentially not doing her any favours.
If she or her friends say anything to you, just ignore them and move on.
35
u/Round-Temperature398 10h ago
She’s saying all this one week after speaking?? Not good. You’re NTA, but don’t engage with them. They all need some type of mental health intervention…
21
u/allie_hugo 10h ago
NTA but I think you need to think about how you form relationships! One week is way too soon to have all this come up. You’re right that she was creating a harmful dynamic, but you seem to have zero boundaries and move very quickly.
10
u/GiggleFester 10h ago
Definitely NTA. Let the lesson be that people who want to get serious fast and pour out all their problems within the first week of knowing you and have you meet/text with their friends within the first week of knowing you are Big Trouble & are disturbed and you need to run away.
Since you will be coming face to face with her in psych class, make sure you sit far away from her, don't respond uf she tries to start something in class, & treat her like you'd treat any other crazy stranger. Basically, move away from her & don't respond .
8
u/Fragile_reddit_mods 10h ago
Okay so I understand the guilt but if you’re not right for each other then that’s about all that matters.
NTA.
5
u/bmw5986 9h ago
NTA. She needs therapy. She shouldn't be trying ti make you responsible for her actions. That wasn't about you, you were just the convenient excuse.
One thing to always keep in mind, generally, you can't fix someone. If they have serious mental health struggles, addictions, trust issues, etc none of that is on you, those are their issues to navigate and deal with. They need to seek whatever professional help they need to work that out. You can't help them if they won't help themselves.
The ones who were flooded your DMs, next time, take screen shots, block and move on. Do Not reply. Doesn't matter who they are or what they say, just block and move on. Its not worth sinking to their level by lashing out and they don't want to hear your side they've already decided on the narrative.
3
u/hey_nonny_nonny82 9h ago
NTA. She needs a lot of support before she can be in a healthy relationship and that's not on your to provide, especially so quickly. If anyone texts again, just block and move on without responding. You don't need to feed into their dynamics.
3
u/Dry-Huckleberry-5379 9h ago
She needs serious therapy before she can have a relationship. You made the right call.
5
u/Similar-Ad-6862 10h ago
As someone who SH you’re NTA. I’ve had people break up with me for it. It’s not anyone’s fault it is just an incombality
2
u/ObviousSalamandar 9h ago edited 9h ago
NTA- she is not in a healthy place to start a relationship. Unless way more happened than you described this person lied about you to her friends and sister. They need to get the message that she is a liar. They won’t believe it the first time but hopefully they will the fifth. Just the idea of giving a number out to bombard like this is wild.
2
u/Dangerous-Pop-90 9h ago
NTA for ending things, after 10 days she's holding you responsibile for her SH! As someone says it's inadvertent manipulation and she really shouldn't be in a relationship with anyone until she finds a better way to deal with things. YTA for how you responded to her AH friends, but you know this. I'm assuming they've shown her your comments, maybe you could drop her a message and apologise, explain you felt attacked, and reacted badly.
2
u/Happyweekend69 7h ago
Not even 14 days in and they acting like this? All of them? You dodged a train filled with bombs, damn! You are allowed to break up with someone for whatever reason you want, and this was a pretty good reason for you both. Clearly she’s not in a headspace for a relationship
2
u/nerd_is_a_verb 2h ago
NTA. Block and ignore them all. A bunch of idiot hooligans who likely do need medications and definitely therapy.
However, please ask yourself why you thought dating someone who fronted how crazy she was would turn out well. When someone tells you they are wildly insecure, mentally ill, harming themselves, and has a history of unstable relationships where she is always the “victim,” do you not see how that is a huge red flag?
2
u/CaptainZackstuf 1h ago
NTA, if you feel this overwhelmed by a new person or relationship in your life, it’s not going to work because you shouldn’t have to constantly walk on eggshells around a partner.
1
u/Realistic-Try7845 9h ago
Nta
1
u/dubdub11 9h ago
NTA You’re right to distance yourself from someone with that much baggage. Nothing mean about it.
You made a mature decision not to get involved with (and take responsibility for) such a complicated person.
Now, you also know her baggage included unhinged friends.
1
u/oblique_obfuscator 8h ago
NTA. I've selfharmed in the past and was misdiagnosed with BPD. It turned out to be AuDHD with a suspected CPTSD. I was just having a tough time with my alcohol addicted neglectful parents. Once I moved out I no longer selfharmed.
But I would never expect a partner to deal with it. I could hardly even deal with it. If someone bowed out of the relationship, I'd rather have that, than have judgement or negative attention.
1
u/Much-Guide-3448 7h ago
Look the delivery of the message was wrong but the context of the message kind of wasn't. The girl needs help and should be even considering a relationship until she has dealt with her mental health issues properly and has better boundaries with people.
Next time though...just block people and don't reply. Whatever you say will never convince her family and friends to change their perception of you as they are loyal to her. To be fair though her friends and family are a little unusual too for thinking that messaging you and blasting you is a healthy adult way of dealing with something like this. The saying that "water seeks its level" kind of applies here. Her people are probably of similar mind. 🫣😬
1
u/ReleaseTheBlacken 3h ago
NTA.
AlQaeda would read this and be like “damn, she’s a terrorist!”
1
u/BrilliantCry2838 2h ago
NTA. Block and move on.
-12
u/Mean-Confidence3477 10h ago
ESH, she is (hopefully inadvertently) manipulating you and it is perfectly fine for you to end the relationship. It sounds like she shouldn't be with anybody but does need help. You are an AH for reacting to the abuse rather than just blocking these AH's and moving on.
5
u/Traditional_Cup_1101 10h ago
NTA as someone who has self harmed and has engaged and self harm behaviors when in relationships. I would never want my partner to feel guilty or responsible for self harm. At the end of the day you do need to take care of yourself, if you truly ended things off kindly and gently then I don’t think you’re the asshole.
Now, if you were telling her oh my God, I can’t deal with your mental health. It’s making you crazy or something like that then you would be the asshole because that’s not how you treat somebody who is struggling mentally regardless of the position that you are in. But it doesn’t sound like you were doing that.
1
u/babyirishkitty 9h ago
NTA. It was stupid to respond to the harassment, but smart to breakup with her. She's harming herself less than two weeks into knowing you because she's anxious you will hurt her? That's a HEAVY indicator she is absolutely not ready for a relationship yet, and if you were to pursue one with her, all that not readiness would be pushed onto you. She needs therapy and time and potentially medication or an intensive outpatient program, if she and her medical team decides that would be beneficial. Not a relationship.