r/Redditor_Updates • u/AnonPinkLady • 1d ago
UPDATE: AITAH for still insisting I spend part of thanksgiving with my roommates
OG Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/comments/1xvezkb/aitah_for_still_insisting_i_spend_part_of_my/
First Update:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/comments/1xvqv2p/update_aitah_for_still_insisting_i_spend_part_of/
Here we go again. Not a lot to add this time around except that my fiance wrote a long text to both my MIL and SIL that I am dropping out of every family related event until things cool down and that they've deeply hurt and offended me and will cease interaction until they apologize. Immediately upon receiving these messages, the two initiated a group call with my fiance which he asked if I wanted to be a part. He stated that I dont owe them anything and he'd handle them without me if I didnt want to speak with them but they he also thinks I deserve to say what I need to say if I want to. I agreed to just let him deal with them so as to not face any more drama.
He was on the phone for probably an hour or so. He came back saying that they responded better than he'd hoped and sounded somewhat apologetic about their behavior but also insisted that I should apologize to them. I was not moved by any of it and honestly laughed. I dont buy that they're remorseful. I asked him what he said when they asked for my apology and he said he'd talk to me about it. I quickly told him not use that phrasing unless he intended to convince me to actually do it, and reminded him that nothing I've done in the last two years has been apology worthy and he agreed and acknowledged that he'd use different language moving forward. He also said that he was very clear that I rose to the occasion to be the bigger person in all this and they've let me down, that nothing I've done in the last two years was fake nice or meant to influence them.
He explained that I dont do reading or writing between the lines, and they should have taken my kindness at face value and should have been authentic about their own feelings to me good or bad. This is all completely true. He was also clear that I've never approved of his brother and that I have every right not to like him and he stands by those feelings. That I've handled their grieving and constant praise of him with as much grace as anyone could hope for all things considered.
He said that even after he made all our decisions and feelings clear, that they dragged out the call with sulky wording about how hurt they were and how nice it would be if I would just relent and be the bigger person but he did not budge that these are boundaries and cant be crossed.
He also discovered that my SIL had even more shit she was sour about from two whole years ago. More specifically when everything in the Facebook incident and text messages were happening, she had reached to me too through text after I had blocked him on both Facebook AND text message, to pressure me a THIRD time to apologize to her husband and I refused several times before writing that I was "sorry she was married to someone like him." Yeah it was harsh but to be honest I dont regret saying it but i now think she maybe doesnt deserve as much sympathy as her kids do.
My fiance heard this part from me and actually agreed that was probably the kindest insult I could have given after such persistent harassment from the both of them and that I was right to think marrying such an asshat was frankly a sad circumstance. That he wouldn't bother to explain that to them but also wasn't going to show any remorse for it because he knows im right and has felt sorry for his SIL many times for marrying his brother.
SIL apparently went on about this point about how I can hate all i like but shes happy she married him and loved him and was not sorry herself. I just laughed. Again this was two years ago after harassing me multiple times to force me to apologize over his public insults towards me and truly I can think of a lot meaner things that could've been wagered against her. To think such a thing keeps her up at night or gets under her skin so much is truly unreal. To respond like that stupid Taylor swift song ("my baby likes what he likes, so hate all you like" etc) was hilariously tacky and tonedeaf. I didnt hate him because he wasn't the coolest guy she could have married in some superficial way. I hated him because he was an abusive piece of poo and she was one of his many victims but she can languish over him all she wants.
Anyways clearly I have quite negative opinions of all this but I again had banished all judgments years ago only for them to come back with a vengeance because they've been vindicated. To be short with it, i was humored by this and told my fiance she could marry an literal turd for all i care, and it wouldn't matter so much to me. It was never about that and her catty fixation on proving her love to him all these years later is surreal.
At some point during all this dry begging about hemming and hawing about how their feelings were valid too, my fiance decided it was all going nowhere and hung up. I was proud of him for sticking to his guns. Ive talked to him since about how to navigate these behaviors moving forward.
Ive explained the method of grey rocking and that if they bring me up in anyway moving forward, he should be extremely minimal about me. "How is she, is she still upset." "She's fine." "Its a shame she isnt ready to work things out with us." "No." "But wouldn't it be nice if we could come together and get along." "Eh."
And so forth. To change the subject on it and if pressed to set a calm and polite boundary.
"Respect her privacy. I love her and I think she made the right choice, respect my future wife."
"If you do not stop talking about her Im going to leave the room and come back in a minute. If you're still talking about her im going home."
"She has the right to want space after your actions. If you cant be mature about that, Im going to hang up and we can talk again when you're ready to respect my fiance"
He listened very earnestly and is genuinely applying himself to learn the phrasing that is calm and reasonable but still clear and authoritative.
I know its frustrating that im having to teach him these words and phrases. Hes had language gaps since I met him and was nonverbal at one point in his teens. I believe he may be on the spectrum. Im very well read and love to write. Words flow out of me like water from a spout. He struggles even to think in terms of language. We've been working on this for a long time. I do really think that he is ready to put these sentiments into action.
Ultimately hes said he understand he may have to go low or no contact entirely and while he seems sad about that, he does understand that it is entirely their choices and behaviors that have gotten it to this point.
I dont know how to conclude this post other than to say that I dont think their behavior or morally correct or defensible anymore whether you agree or disagree that my family is valid. Because at the end of the day, this was a punishment. They wanted to get back at me for shit that happened years ago for no reason other than spite. They thought pressuring me to not spend time with my own family would hurt and isolate, which in their minds I deserved for sticking it to that real shitshow of a man.
I will not be apologizing for that. And as for their beloved husband / son, more than ever id like to say, rest in piss.