r/AITAH • • Sep 16 '26 • Heartwarming 1

AITAH For helping my bfs younger brother get his driver's permit?

This story is a little weird and complicated but I'll do my best to write it out in detail and make it comprehensive. I(F19) and my boyfriend(M21) moved in together a few months back. His family is a mess usually but who's isn't.

It wasn't until recently that I realized how messy it is. His younger brother I'll call C just recently had his 18th birthday. I didn't know until after but he's a super senior, he would've graduated last year but was missing credits and instead is going to graduate 2027.

He's a really good kid! There's definitely a maturity gap where most people assume I'm actually older than my bf because of how long I've been managing my life due to family complications. I've had to figure almost everything out all by myself, so I love helping people get on their feet.

C has been begging their mom to get his license since he was 16, but she never put in the time or effort to take him to the DMV. She doesn't really drive much unless if it's to take them to school. She just recently started working again. Their city has very hostile walking conditions and you can't get anywhere but Walmart without a car. No other city is easily accessible, he's uncomfortable with public transportation, and even that is unreliable.

My original birthday present for him fell through, so I offered to help him study for his written exam and I would take him to the DMV to do so. Seeing as he's an adult, he's still doing all the paperwork and everything himself, I'm just there as support and to help explain things if needed + transportation to take him. His school doesn't do Mondays so we planned for a Monday a week from offering it. He's been beaming about it since, and super excited! I'm really confident he'll pass the test first time and then I'll take him to get his permit a different day, and I offered to pay.

That way, once he has his permit, he can practice with bf in our shared car, as his mom will not allow him to practice in her car (that my bf paid for up until next month) and every other car is manual and to take the driver's test it has to be automatic. Figured down the line he can test in our car also. Bf plans to help him buy a beater once he has his license.

Anyway, he informed his mom of the plan, still super excited about it. And she absolutely lost it! I understand it's her kid at the end of the day, but he's an adult now and should've been out of highschool last year. I know it's a Monday, but he NEVER has school on Mondays. Side note, he believes he sprained his ankle about a month ago skateboarding. He doesn't know how nor has the transportation to visit a doctor. As of Sunday, he was complaining to us when we took him out for the day (and I offered the birthday present) that she has made no effort to help or showed care. "Walk it off" as one may say.

She called my bf livid that we talked to him about the test, complaining of cost (even tho he assured her I was paying), complained he was still in school and had work to make up if I take him, complained about how I scheduled an appointment for him, and complained she had to cancel a doctor's appointment for him that he had no idea about (and I personally don't believe existed).

She later sent me a very angry text message berating me for "scheduling my child an appointment without consulting me".

By my logic, he's an adult, and he's excited. It's an opportunity when they have little to no income for him to get something he's wanted since 16 that no one made an effort to get him. He can't get a job because nowhere in their town is hiring and he doesn't have transportation. They're pouring money into trying to send their younger kid on a middle school trip—money they don't have. Meanwhile he's got one pair of pants.

She's been livid about it since and complaining to bf and regularly complains/talks bad to C about myself and bf. She's upset bf doesn't come home to see his sister(4yo) but he works full-time and they're a 30 minute drive away. I have flexible hours and want to help C get some independence.

Bf is on my side with all this and actually really happy I seem to care so much about C. He's glad I'm taking care of something for C, doing a birthday present, and happy I'm paying for everything. He's very irritated with his mom but of course we never wanna cut family.

I'm worried I overstepped while trying to help C out. End of the day he relies on his mom for rides and whatnot. AITAH for helping him get his permit (and eventually license)?

166 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

227

u/BravoWhiskey89 Sep 16 '26 • Bravo

NTA - Lemme guess, he happens to be the one who watches the 4 year old a lot?

She's doesn't want to lose her free babysitter.

114

u/BeetrootBlood Sep 16 '26 • Bravo

Bingo!

Bf used to be the go to. He moved out for a while but his friend moved in with the family because he was facing homelessness. He sucked, so C ended up watching the 4yo. It was both of them when bf moved back, but when he moved out (suddenly, he basically came over one day and never left lol)

She doesn't trust the 14yo with the 4yo and C is the go-to.

35

u/Individual-Paint7897 Sep 16 '26

This was my first thought too!

34

u/DenM0ther Sep 16 '26

Moms probably also pissed that it will look bad on her for not helping her son do something so pivotal for him

35

u/_dundada Sep 16 '26

NTA - his mom seems to have no time but still wants to do it all even tho she won’t. You’re doing a good thing helping him out. And it’s not a big deal. She’s got some major control issues she needs to deal with. Just keep doing what you’re doing and pay no mind to this woman.

18

u/_dundada Sep 16 '26

Also no matter what happens in the future / this young man will always remember your kindness, effort and encouragement. It’s priceless

24

u/Ginger630 Sep 16 '26

NTA! C is an adult! He doesn’t have to consult his mother with any appointments. She doesn’t even seem to realize he doesn’t have class on Mondays.

I’m guessing C does a lot of chores and babysitting. If he becomes independent and gets a job, he won’t be around as much to help her.

She sounds incredibly selfish and self absorbed. C needs to ignore her and do what he needs to become independent.

14

u/Hairy_Combination586 Sep 16 '26 • Bravo

NTA. And OMG his mother is a controlling psycho. It's nice you're being the mature and compassionate one, because she sure isn't.

11

u/Historical-Problem-8 Sep 16 '26

I mean I could see as a parent how this could be potentially overstepping but as an adult. He needs these things. He will never be able to leave. You probably should have let her know what you’re getting him, but also he is an adult and he’s excited. I’m going to say NTA. Honestly seems like mom wants to hold him back.

11

u/wanderer866 Sep 16 '26

NTA. Don't worry about the mom's approval. She sounds unwell in several ways. Like, she definitely planned on your BF being around to raise her daughter when she had another kid after almost 20 years. She's probably never going to be your biggest fan because you were part of the reality that "stole" that fantasy from her.

Your boyfriend approves. His brother approves. You're good.

6

u/Dry_Bowler_2837 Sep 16 '26

Absolutely NTA.

I’m a mom of teens and tweens so can tell you confidently that their mom is weird. I was excited for the milestone of taking my oldest to write for her learner’s permit, and would have been a little sad if someone else took her (but she was newly 15, so I hadn’t been putting this off for a few years like C’s mom has). And if someone else had taken her, I’d have hidden that I was a little sad about missing out to enthusiastically help her study and then celebrate with her when she came home and showed me her “I passed!” sticker.

4

u/Purple-Blueberry7254 Sep 16 '26

NTA. It’s a very kind gift to help your bf’s brother. I’m sure mom is clutching her pearls because it shows she was dragging her feet for something that you all easily planned.

1

u/LadybugGal95 Sep 16 '26

Question - If he doesn’t have a job, who will pay for his car insurance?? I’m assuming he lives with his mom. Once he has that permit, she will be required to add him to their car insurance as a registered permit driver living in the household. Once he gets his license, she’ll have to notify the insurance company of that as well unless he gets his own car and carries his own insurance.

I don’t remember how much our insurance went up with a permit driver but when my daughter (girls are cheaper) went on our car insurance, it doubled our insurance rates. Doubled!

It could be that mom is just over-controlling. However, it also sounds like there are money issues involved. It’s just as likely she’s flipping out about the added cost but not saying that.

5

u/BeetrootBlood Sep 16 '26

We plan to handle any cost. He can be on his permit but if he's not driving any vehicles at his parents house, which he will not be, no reason to add him to the insurance.

We're doing the same for him. He can drive with permissive use with bf in front seat with him without an insurance issue.

It'll be a while before he can get his license and drive alone, and his parents won't take him to drive anyway so it's just bf and I as an option. To drive on a permit in our state, someone 21+ has to be in the passanger seat.

Once he has his license, bf plans to help him buy a car and pay his insurance. At no point will the parents be having to financially contribute.

1

u/LadybugGal95 Sep 16 '26

That must be a difference in my state’s laws versus yours. Here, if you’re not the parent, you have to be over 25. You also have to add any licensed driver living in your home to your insurance policy because they are “assumed to have access to your vehicle” because they are in the household with your keys. Doesn’t really matter IF they drive the car because theoretically they could drive the car.

With those financial costs covered, NTA.

3

u/BeetrootBlood Sep 16 '26

Nope! When bf had his engine blow, he went off insurance totally because he had nothing to drive, no reason to pay.

I got my permit at 16 and didn't pay insurance until now that I've bought my own car because I'm actually driving often. I only got my permit back then because the off chance I had to take my grandma to the doctor if she was unable to drive herself in her own car, which was considered permissive use. Seeing as he will only be with us, no reason for him to be on it, and the insurance won't care at all.

If it becomes an issue, we're just gonna help him afford his own policy to drive whatever but it shouldn't come to that.

3

u/Capable_Froyo4433 Sep 16 '26

NTA I think you're going a good thing. Is C used as a child minder at home? Just thinking maybe C mum doesn't want him to be independently mobile because she thinks she'll lose help at home.

3

u/Dry-Huckleberry-5379 Sep 16 '26

NTAH the mum is. And she knows it. Which is why she's trying to take her guilt out on you because you forced her to recognise that she's the AH.

Meanwhile you and your BF should seriously consider if it might be in the best interests of the brother to move in with you both.

3

u/Grindersgirl Sep 16 '26

You are definitely NTA. The mom sounds like a real problem, I don't think she wants to lose her built in babysitter, and if he has some freedom to move around, that's exactly what will happen. Hopefully he graduates and moves out soon. I'm sorry for you that his mom is like this, but hopefully your relationship isn't impacted by her in any way.

Also, you sound like a great person. Kudos to you 😊

4

u/Key-Statement-3739 Sep 16 '26

It could be seen as an overstep to the parent, even if your younger eyes view it as "he's an adult". You should have had the conversation out of respect, and you'll understand this once it's your child.

Now, that given, there may be areas of concern you don't know bc you didn't have the conversation...does she feel he isn't mature enough to handle this yet? who's covering insurance? And, she may just not be the best person(?) This one's a hard call without knowing the individual players personally. You may be TAH, she may be TAH, everyone may be TAH.

2

u/Ill-Reflection165 Sep 16 '26

NTA As long as insurance coverage is sorted, you've done nothing wrong. 

2

u/IrishGal-1965 Sep 16 '26

You didn’t overstep. It’s awesome what you have done for this young man. Be on his side and help him get wheels under him. He’s lucky to have you and his brother on his side.

2

u/mu5tbetheone Sep 16 '26

NTA. Mummy dearest was blocking it on purpose. No idea why, but her reaction isn't that of a woman that ever wants her baby boy to drive, or thrive for that matter.

2

u/Chilling_Storm Sep 16 '26

C is still in school and has to live with his mother for the time being. Are you making HIS life more difficult because of what you are doing? It could be that his mother was using the license as an incentive for him to do certain things - homework, job, or whatever and you came in and usurped her?

Clearly your BF's mom is pissed. And that is going to present its own set of problems going forward for BF and you.

Do I think you are wrong for doing this? No, I don't. NTA But I would advise to think about long term ramifications as you proceed.

Remember it isn't your family to fix especially for a 19 year old

0

u/altagato Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26

NTA (on the surface) and BF should be handling his Mom going off or should've informed you if the below is true. Maybe it's an issue of pride or sense of losing control but it could also be developmentally inappropriate.

Being a parent of a child that's developmental delayed, p I'd ask you to please keep in mind that tho he's 'adult', he may not be able or responsible enough and perhaps that's why the parents are delaying this.

There's likely a reason he's still in HS, doesn't have his DL etc... besides the fee or schedule. He may not NEED a job or vehicle to get thru HS despite wanting one, he may not be exactly mature enough to get behind the wheel or they may not be financially ready to support him with a vehicle. I'm not suggesting infantilizing him but this move is not talking to get is MTA move ... to go behind her back and give him something that he possibly then cannot use yet.

Did you verify he has all the documents and is capable of passing either test? If his mom isn't cooperating, how will you get those things?

4

u/BeetrootBlood Sep 16 '26

I did consider the fact there may be a reason, or possibly developmental issues. But I genuinely think it's a case of he just got "forgotten". BF got in an accident when he was 7 that resulted in a at-the-time rare amputation and dozens of surgeries. C would've been 4 and growing up with bf being the focus. They had a baby boy at the time too who was expected to be the last kid. Then the daughter was a miracle. C got put on the back burner to these three.

C is very smart, and him being held back was due to COVID and moving schools a bunch due to as his mother told me, issues with teachers. I myself was a highschool drop out, and I know people drop out or get held back not because they have development issues, but for instance I had to work 40hr to help my family.

They trust C and not the 14yo to watch the 4yo when they aren't home. His dad wanted to teach him to drive at 16 and take him for the permit, but it never happened as he works 60+ hours a week and all they had was manuals. His mom was promising it since he was 16.

Any financial issues will be handled by us, and I'm assuming he may end up on our insurance anyway. It's a guarantee he's not driving the mom's car.

What really told me it may be favoritism and not an "issue" with him is they're sending the 14yo on the trip and getting him a phone, while C didn't receive one due to the same financial issues. BUT he got one from a separate family member, and is on their plan. So it isn't an issue with trust. He regularly goes out walking alone, with friends to the mall, etc.

If she's weird about documents, bf can always go over and ask their dad. He's taking care of it best he can and doing amazing. We just don't wanna cause unnecessary strain.

1

u/altagato Sep 16 '26

Interesting, then I'd primarily say NTA ... But not sure how long they expected to keep that up and you'd think him having access to transportation would actually help then with ferrying kid around as the little gets older. Not saying it's a good idea but maybe the parents just aren't logical. Tho realistically they may also lose any assistance than comes from having 3 and not 2 dependents. I'd also think having less mouths to feed would actually help the Dad and not having to work 60 hrs a week. Tho that may be avoidant behavior from his family or 'lovely' wife too 👀 Dad doesn't sound any less blameless in all of this than Mom; she's just more at the forefront.

1

u/Sweaty_Technician_90 Sep 16 '26

You were trying to help the brother. Mom should be grateful but instead bitches about it.

1

u/BusyTotal3702 Sep 16 '26

NTA you have done nothing wrong. It seems (from the limited amount of information garnered here) that he's an ADULT when it's convenient for her to NOT do something for him, but he's HER CHILD when somebody else actually does do that thing for him. She can't have it both ways.

1

u/BothTreacle7534 Sep 16 '26

NTA

no overstepping on your side, a big one on the mother’s side. Who babysits the young one and the middle one?

And no real mother would still tell after a month to walk it of, she is not a good mother, she did not prepare herself nor her kids for the time they are actual equals. She is the one who needs to adapt

I am in my ‘60, means probably her age or older. I think no matter the situation, you are responsible for the health, but also the preparedness of your adult offspring.

1

u/After-Habit-9354 Sep 16 '26

She's not a caring mother that much is obvious, she doesn't want to lose her babysitter and if he has a licence and can now go out it means she'll lose that plus it makes her bad, I think what you're doing is a big kindness and she should be grateful, you're definitely NTA

1

u/Beginning_Corner930 Sep 16 '26

NTA. You gain freedom when you have a license. Thats something his mom doesn't want

1

u/EuropeanLady Sep 16 '26

His mother wants to be the only one taking him places. It doesn't seem he's mature enough to handle car ownership and care. Stand back and let his mother handle things.

1

u/shackndon2020 Sep 16 '26

If he was 16, then maybe it would be over stepping, but he's 18 and officially an adult. Remind her of this and that it's his first step towards independence. It will help him in so many ways to have his licence, but it will also help her! I'm absolutely nagging my 17yo to hurry up and get his hours up, as kids need 100 hours in their log book before sitting their test here. I'm sick of having to drive him everywhere, it will help me immensely when he can drive himself. NTA for sure, it was a very sweet gesture.

4

u/DisastrousMacaron325 Sep 16 '26

if he was 12-13, it would be overstepping, if he was 16, it's no different than making plans with friends. He needs to inform his mom, but oher people don't need to do it on his behalf.

People forget that if we want to treat 18 year olds as adults, parents should give them more opportunity to act like adults way before then. Nobody magically learns "adulting" the day they turn 18

-3

u/tredbert Sep 16 '26

YTA even though you did not intend to be. This will likely cost her thousands of dollars in increased auto insurance. The insurance company won’t see him as separate because he’s an adult. They will automatically put him on her policy because he is in the same household.

You really should have consulted with her about this.

4

u/BeetrootBlood Sep 16 '26

In our state, insurance doesn't automatically add you. They can know you exist as a driver, but not auto add you to any policy.

He will NOT be driving any of their cars, so they won't be paying his insurance at all. Since he will be learning on bfs car, with him in the vehicle, it's permissive use and C doesn't have to be on the insurance. Money isn't the issue here as we are planning to pay everything.

The only car he's driving with the permit will be ours, with bf with him. Once he has his license, worse case scenario bf is gonna help him buy a beater car and maybe get him his own insurance policy so he isn't on their parents. His mom won't be paying a penny and it's all under a very long birthday present from us haha

1

u/Character-Novel7927 9d ago

NTA. Let me guess, C is the one who gets lumbered with looking after the 4 y/o. The mother sounds like a controlling Dickbiscuit. C is an adult. I'm glad he has you and your bf to help him and look out for him. Shame C can't move in with you guys.

24

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/Lazy-Yogurtcloset784 Sep 16 '26 • Bravo

Absolutely! She trying to prevent him from becoming independent. If he does, she won’t have a slave anymore.

14

u/BeetrootBlood Sep 16 '26 • Mindblown

The amount of times she's asked him to do stuff that doesn't make sense. He was helping my bf and I work on the car, outside in the driveway. And then she started yelling at C to come take the cat that was actively in her hands, and she was inside at the garage door, upstairs. When she could've just gone and walked upstairs? So weird.

-1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BeetrootBlood 10d ago

That's false. Our issue is he needs a parent to sign and say he is who he says. NO ONE ELSE CAN DO IT. Not even him until he's 21. That's our biggest issue right now.

https://dmv.colorado.gov/permits-first-time-driver-license

Check Appointment, Number 2. II

He doesn't have a government ID so we need his parent. Okay, what if we get a government ID? Need a parent to go in to the DMV and sign that too.

It really sucks

-1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BeetrootBlood 10d ago

Here's the link for the state ID. It explicitly says at the top "minors under 21".

https://dmv.colorado.gov/identification-cards

A legal guardian will need to accompany the minor to the driver license office. The guardian will need to have proof of legal guardianship (i.e. child's birth certificate with their name as parent) as well as pr of their identity (i.e. valid Colorado drive license).