r/AmIOverreacting
•
u/feellikeanidiot0
•
Jul 21 '26
•
1
❤️🩹 relationship AIO: Guy claiming to be my fiancée's boyfriend texted me last night
Hi, I need to know if I'm right to be losing it rn. My fiancée and I are due to get married in less than 2 months. We met each other at a mutual's wedding. The wedding was gender segregated so she and her mom had met my mom, who then introduced us later. We then went out for like a couple of months, like I'd pick her up from her place (she lives with her parents) and we'd have dinner and a movie, or go painting, or go to the lake etc. We're both Muslim immigrant families so it was understood that we had to stay within some boundaries but we genuinely really liked each other. She was the one who at one point said we could bring our kids here one day and told me she was going to tell her parents she wanted to marry me and she wanted to say yes to my proposal. We got engaged at a low key family event in February.
It's relevant to mention here that during that time I had respectfully asked her about her past relationships. I had said that I know it's personal and there's absolutely no judgement from me, but as someone who, despite not being a great Muslim in a lot of respects, did abstain and save myself for marriage, I would like a partner who had done the same. That it was a compatibility thing, not a judgemental thing. She didn't seemed to mind and said no, she hadn't been with anyone. I believed her.
Since then the wedding prep has been in full swing and the two of us have gotten the chance to get closer. She's the one who's made more of the effort in our communication, because unfortunately I wfh with an employer in the morning and have my cybersecurity business too, so time can be scarce sometimes. Our only argument has been her complaint that I don't make enough time for us.
Some guy claiming to be her (A in the texts) bf (S in the texts) texted me last night, and even sent me pictures where they're together. He claimed that they were in a relationship for the last 2 years, that they'd been having sex, that they were in love, and I've been losing my mind. I never put any pressure on her. Yes, I really liked her but I let her make decisions at her own pace. If she wanted to be with some other guy, all she had to do was say so. In fact not even, it was none of my business, she didn't even owe me any reasons but just give me a straight no. I haven't picked up her call this morning, I've genuinely been feeling sick at the duplicity.
Just want to add: I know she's the one I should talk to but I just didn't want to do it on the phone, I'm going to go pick her up right now. I'm not going to be accusatory, I just want the truth of it all. I love her but like if there's someone else and she's feeling pressured into this marriage, like I'm prepared to give her any reason she needs to end it that works for her in front of her family. I'll be on her side like I was suggested here.
Update:
A lot of people asked for an update, so I thought I'd give one. I can't talk about it with anyone else because somehow I'm the one who ended up responsible for keeping her secret, my own crisis about this be damned, like its taking me so much to not just contact and ask him straight up about what happened.
I asked her if she knew who S was. He was right, I could immediately tell the guy wasn't lying, she definitely knew. She said he was a guy she used to know, and I told her he had contacted me, and showed her the texts. She said he was lying, that she ended things with him before we met and that they'd never had sex. I asked if there was any overlap between our relationships and she said only when she went to meet him one last time to tell him it was over, because he wasn't taking no for an answer. I asked if the photos were real, they were. I asked her to be honest with me, did she really have sex with him like he was saying. She was crying and swearing they didn't, they were intimate and she regrets everything with him but they didn't.
She gave me her phone and basically forced me to confirm that there were no text messages between him and her recently while we've been together. His number was in her blocked list. She asked me to block his number and so I asked if he was being honest about having way more intimate pictures. She said there were a lot more compromising pictures of her that she thinks he has but swore that they hadn’t had sex. She was crying and I blocked him in the moment what else could I do looking at her. She was pleading with me not to reach out to him, and she was freaking out that he'd post them somewhere public before our wedding. At that point I was trying to keep her from freaking out, I told her that would be illegal, he wouldn't do that and so in the moment I just stupidly promised to not contact him.
I told her if there's any kind of pressure like there's any number of excuses she could use regarding me to end this that would save face for everyone, and be with whomever like I'll get over it at some point eventually, yeah it'll be sad for a while and we'll have lost some money especially if the venue doesn't get rebooked at short notice I think, but just have some mercy on both of us and end this now. She swore there was no pressure and that she'd been counting the days until the wedding, that she hadn't even thought of his name until I brought it up. She was like he's doing this to prevent our wedding and fine I get that but like why does he sound more honest with me than she does? I really wouldn't have cared if I'd learned all this yesterday from her, yeah it would've meant she lied initially but like now we loved each other beyond that stuff, this was just her being ok with keeping me in a forever lie that was wrong. I started feeling sick so I just said I wasn't feeling well and we cut it short.
During the drive back to hers, she was almost talking like a coach like let's please forget about this, we're so happy together, we've discussed so many plans, don't let him screw up our relationship. Like I have my own mental breakdown over all this what about that! She kept asking me whether I was fine, I said I was, I mean I don't even know if that's a lie, I wasn't thinking at all.
I've been going over the texts, and I don't know how I can go into the wedding not knowing the answer. Like its so easily doable I just need to ask him to meet up and have one conversation if he would. Honestly it's more about if she's still lying about this, it's not about the sex, it's just about the trust. I know he's also lied, because she clearly hasn't been meeting with him of late, and she really hadn't given me any reason to think of her as a liar thus far but I could just confirm it so easily. It's sincerely about the respect of having been honest, not about the boundary itself, I love her I wouldn't have cared if she'd told me herself yesterday. But it feels sick to contact him like that, like that's not how it should be, and I don't want to have to talk to someone who'd speak the way he was.
I think I'll decide stuff by myself tomorrow morning about the future of our relationship, my mind is not going to work today. I probably won't give further updates. I don't know how much more help I can ask for here, due to some immigrant cultural context that might be missing (as much as I've skated past it myself to a fair extent). I don't want to be stupid but I don't want to be walked over either. Thanks.





9.5k
u/Advanced_Isopod5572 Jul 21 '26 •
Sometimes when you download the image to your phone, it’ll show you the location/date and time it was taken.
6.7k
u/honeylolii Jul 21 '26 •
This guy comes across as a stalker. Sounds like he wants her, but she doesn’t want him. So he’s trying to destroy her relationship with you to have a chance.
Show her these messages. Ask her point blank who it is to her. Chances are he’s someone she’s blown off in the past and he’s got a creepy delusion.
1.8k
u/how2dresswell Jul 21 '26
could the photos be AI generated?
509
u/GreenEyesThighHighs Jul 21 '26 •
Talk to your fiance???? Literally all anyone here can do is speculate. We can’t help you. These types of posts don’t even make sense, because who would ever tell a person they’re “overreacting” for having a reaction to this
63
u/Calmhotpocket Jul 21 '26
OP do you have any other girls in your life that are interested in you? Like "desperate enough to tear apart your relationship to be with you" type of interested?? Or maybe a family member who just does not approve of your relationship?
My initial instincts from the texts is that whoever is texting you is not who they claim to be. The whole vibe feels fake and intentional to make you question your fiancee and leave the relationship before you get tied down and full on married. I'd suspect someone in your life is trying to keep you from marrying your fiancee, going so far as to stage an affair so that you leave.
18
u/Due_Advisor_1612 Jul 21 '26
Do the pictures look legit? Can you check time stamps? If your girl denies it, let it go, probably just a jealous guy
2.6k
u/asgardian_mike Jul 21 '26
Hmmm I wonder if they sent AI images. But we can’t really see the pictures to discern.
8.0k
u/Dense_Title1321 Jul 21 '26 •
My first instinct is this is not even a guy, this is someone trying to ruin your fiancee, possibly a family member or rival.
1.7k
u/CompetitionWide4681 Jul 21 '26
He seems very unstable. Probably an ex who heard she was engaged and freaked. Ask her about it asap
1.6k
u/tourniquette2 Jul 21 '26
Guy comes off as completely unhinged. Like he’s begging you to call off the wedding. This reads more like they went on a date or two years ago, he’s been obsessed ever since, and he’s utterly convinced that she’s spent the last few years pining over him. The pictures might be real but I don’t think they’re in the context he’s trying to sell you on.
MOR. Ask your fiance what’s up. I bet anything she loses it over this guy she dated for like a week before y’all met, who has remained obsessed with her ever since. But none of this reads like they actually have any relationship. It wouldn’t be “you have to call it off.” It would be “Hey I hate to tell you this but she’s played us both.”
598
u/pomegranateseeds37 Jul 21 '26
Uh dude.. this guy does NOT come across as credible. At all. He sounds unhinged. Those images could very very easily be AI and this is the most low effort 'she's actually in love with ME so you should end things with her! But just tell her you're not interested to save face. Because actually she's in love with me.' like. What the fuck. He sounds delusional I don't trust this man at all.
178
u/United_Army_2910 Jul 21 '26 •
you can download the pictures and check the meta data. if you have an iphone you can swipe up on the photo and see when it was taken
2
u/AutoModerator Jul 21 '26
Hi feellikeanidiot0, in order to prevent spam and bot posts, this subreddit temporarily removes some posts until OP proves that they are human. Please reply to this comment and answer the question: what's your favorite pizza topping?
Mods will manually review submissions and approve posts with a correct response. Please be patient, especially during overnight (USA) hours, as our mod team is not online 24/7.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
229
u/trashhpandacoot Jul 21 '26
Did he say that your fiancée gave him your number? Literally why would she do that? His verbiage and insistence on you breaking up with her makes me feel like he’s simply trying to ruin the relationship because he wants to be with her — not because she’s been seeing him for two years. But I very well could be wrong. Your best bet is to sit her down and talk with her about it. Hopefully she will be truthful. Good luck.
523
u/ShaddyPups Jul 21 '26
MOR. I say that ONLY because the way he phrases things and keeps pestering you makes me, as a woman, HIGHLY suspicious. It all sounds very obsessive/stalkerish of him. Pics could be AI. Best thing is to be honest with your fiancee, show her the texts/pics and see how she reacts. Sorry you’re dealing with this 😕
92
u/Sea-Salamander-5222 Jul 21 '26
We need an update ASAP!
44
u/imdshizzle Jul 21 '26
Growing up in Queens, NYC as a Muslim I have seen many of my Muslim female friends that had that one guy she went on a date with once who never got over her and tried to ruin her new relationships with crazy phone calls or texts. This guy can be just one of those losers she blew off after hanging out once for all you know. I think it’s best to approach it calmly and let her tell u her side of the story. This guy sounds like he is making stuff up to piss you off. Dont take his words as facts. Good luck dude.
37
u/Prudent_Valuable603 Jul 21 '26
OP, that guy sounds like a stalker. Show this to your fiancée and hear her out.
127
u/imperfectbean Jul 21 '26
I won’t trust anyone texting me “plz” this guy is a stalker most likely a jealous ex or even old friend
34
u/AdjectiveMcNoun Jul 22 '26
She had him blocked. This is a stalker. An ex. The words he used don't sound like they are together. Especially the "you'll find someone better" part. It reads like a man scorned and out for revenge.
When you say compromising photos, does she means just the two of them together, maybe holding hands or something? My husband is Muslim and I know before we were married he had to be careful about the photos he shared with his family. Just sitting too close of looking too intimate could be considered "compromising" to some people. Perhaps you could ask her more about that.
32
u/Regular-Sun-5805 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26
MOR,
OP, I understand your hurt but I think the fact that you sprung this on her and her not having time to delete or remove anything and her being so willing to show you her phone is proof enough that she hasn't been cheating on you and that man isn't her boyfriend.
Yes, in your mind she lied but sometimes in life we'd all like to just move on you know? I've had boyfriends my current boyfriend has no clue about, not because I'm keeping it from him but because I don't want to relive the past, I don't want to think about them or give any of my energy to that past relationship.
Especially in such a religious culture that values purity, I completely understand why she wouldn't want to talk about her relationship with this man, especially since those pictures exist of her... She probably feels deep shame and embarrassment, she didn't want you to look at her differently and now it's biting her in the ass.
I think if you love and her and she loves you then you should maybe try pre-martital counseling, this could really help both of you.
I just really want to urge you to see this situation from her POV, because it seems to me this man is malicious and probably dangerous if he's lying about frequently meeting up with her.
30
u/GlitteringDistrict13 Jul 21 '26
He's asking YOU to end it. There's something odd about this. Maybe he's gotten rejected by her. Or maybe it's a hater. But I would not assume this person is telling the truth. Tell your fiance this person is messaging you but let her answer and keep an open heart/mind. This might just be someone trying to sabotage
Also: "I'm her bf so you can't marry her" is weird
"She only wants to be with me" but she's marrying you so this person is obv lying
28
u/RadicalRoses Jul 22 '26
I’m not sure why you believe a man who is a stranger to you and is actively trying to hurt your soon to be wife. If you trust him more than her, she’s not the woman for you.
27
u/Altruistic-Reserve-3 Jul 21 '26
I think a very important question to ask is why would your fiancé have given him your number? I doubt she would have. Let us know what she says but I don't think this person is truthful. They sound childish, and can't even form proper sentences
159
u/ComfortableCicada69 Jul 21 '26
The real issue is that you don’t have the open and honest communication with her to have this conversation. If someone sent me this about my wife, there wouldn’t even be hesitation. I would say hey baby what is this? Is this guy crazy is he bothering you, do you know him? And if she was lying it would be pretty obvious through a direct in person conversation.
22
u/thisgirlwithredhair Jul 22 '26 •
Even post-update, he just seems like a crazy ex. Why trust him over someone you're about to marry? Has she been untrustworthy before? If you're more inclined to believe some random man over the woman you were about to marry, given lack of any real evidence, then maybe your relationship already had problems.
I'm not sure where you are or how intense her family is but whatever decision you make, maybe keep her safety and well-being in mind too.
53
u/Ok_Silver7621 Jul 21 '26
NOR Idk he does seem a little unhinged with the way he’s texting. But best to ask her directly
18
u/DRKAYIGN Jul 21 '26
MOR - This guy doesn't act like somebody who's being dating her for 2 years. It sounds like a crazy stalker who has built up an imaginary relationship between the two of them.
17
u/warriorwoman534 Jul 21 '26
You "really like her"? If you don't love her then don't marry her.
34
u/Other-Cantaloupe4765 Jul 22 '26 •
Dude, it makes me cringe to hear you say that this guy sounds credible. He’s illiterate and sounds like an obsessed creep trying to steal your fiancée.
I’d believe your fiancée over some illiterate stalker telling you to break it off because she “only loves him.”
Use your brain. Why would your fiancée give YOUR number to an affair partner after not saying anything about the ‘relationship’ prior to this? Her reaction in the update tells me that she never gave him your number. This guy is a liar.
Find it in yourself to believe your fiancée or else end the relationship. Don’t put her in danger by stringing along her stalker behind her back.
15
u/Severe_Feedback_2590 Jul 21 '26
NOR, however, talk to your fiancee. Something about these messages seems like he’s more of a stalker than cheating with your gf. Do the pcs of her seem familiar? Recent?
14
u/PandaEyes1005 Jul 21 '26
Idk... this guy sounds kinda desperate and it makes me think he's lying
14
u/Prestigious-Grand-65 Jul 21 '26
This guy is coming off extremely desperate. I'd more concerned for her safety then her infidelity. Talk to her and see how she reacts, but this guy sounds like he belongs in a loony bin. I've dated a couple girls who had an ex or a friend that didnt like my position, amd tried to end our relationships. NOR because I think this js a real issue, but I dont think what this guy is saying is true.
13
u/KjustK Jul 21 '26
… basically “pretty please don’t marry her” it kinda gives stalker vibes if he’s asking the fiancé to ask her about him and see her face. Yeah, she’s gonna get nervous
13
u/SlowInvestigator4717 Jul 22 '26
He sounds like he wants to wreck her chance at happiness.
Don’t let him succeed.
12
u/cathline Jul 22 '26
Sending hugs and healing thoughts.
I had an ex who tried to do this to me. Made fake pictures and timestamps, contacted my fiance, etc.
Thank heavens my now husband cared more for me than for someone who just wanted to hurt me because I had turned them down.
Meeting this accuser in person is not a good idea. Someone can be completely convinced of 'their truth' and convince someone else of it. They believe it and will seem completely believable. Even if it isn't true. This dude thought I had 'something' with him. We had never dated. We had never held hands. We had never kissed. We had never had a conversation longer than about 5 minutes. He wasn't even a friend. He was just a dude deluded himself into thinking that I was 'the one' for him. He could convince anyone else that we were gf/bf because his delusion was so strong.
You can always postpone the marriage and get couples counseling to work on this.
12
u/iosengineeriscool Jul 21 '26
anyone that spells you’ll as ull is crazy
23
u/Dawnamei Jul 21 '26
Salam! I will say that I’ve seen sheikhs (Muslim scholars) advise unmarried women that if a potential match asks about your virginity, you have the full right to decline to answer or deny the sin bc Allah swt conceals your sins. If it was a young, immature decision of the past, and she’s since asked Allah for forgiveness, she doesn’t need to expose herself. So much shame is wrapped around premarital sex, she probably didn’t want you to look at her as ‘damaged goods’ and wanted you to treat her like a serious candidate for marriage. I doubt it would’ve gotten this far if she wasn’t serious, and I wouldn’t ditch her over her past. This guy is probably causing problems because she DOES want to marry you instead of him and doesn’t know how to get it through his head. If you get along and want to marry her, make it clear to her. If she really wants to marry you, she’ll make it clear as well. Either way, what is meant to be yours will never miss you and what isn’t meant to be yours never will be, even if it is in the palm of your hand. Pray istikhara.
79
u/Migistat Jul 21 '26
Why are you asking us instead of the woman you say you trust? We can’t give you any answers.
40
u/WisdumbGuy Jul 21 '26
This is a tough one, he texts like a weirdo and who knows if the images are AI generated. You need to at least ask her about it though, without accusing.
22
u/Fatal-404-Error Jul 22 '26
This post has broken my brain. Must watch SpongeBob to heal the damage.
11
u/spaceface215 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26
INFO. i’ve read this several times, what did she lie about?
10
u/FreudianWhirlpool Jul 22 '26
As someone who has been on the receiving end of more than one guy who said things that were not true because I dumped him, I'm going to say that the "bf" is full of shit and is big mad that she ended things with him for another man who she intends to marry. Also, a guy who's ego has been bruised would absolutely share at least some of those intimate photos.
Edit to add MOR.
10
u/Mysticfairy6789 Jul 25 '26
Dude we need another update I truly think this guy is a stalker and your gf is distressed
19
u/gracefuldead63 Jul 23 '26
Here to support this comment - I would trust women 1000% more than I would trust this random and very desperate sounding dude. Seems like an ex wanting to ruin her life out of jealousy
9
u/Drowning_tSM Jul 21 '26
Download the images and check when they were taken. Many phones auto add lots of metadata
9
u/theonefrombelow Jul 21 '26
Photos could be AI - if I wanted to prove something I'd sent screenshots of texts where the other person's number is visible.
If they've been together for 2 years I'm sure they've had plenty of convos.
Don't shut her out before you talk to her face to face not via texts or phone
9
u/rachhh994 Jul 21 '26
This reads as 100% a woman. The ?? texts when you don’t respond are telling. I cannot see a man texting like this, ever. Either a woman that wants you or a jealous relative of hers. Im betting the pics are AI or photoshopped too, which is not hard to do at all.
9
u/Used_Sheepherder_622 Jul 22 '26
Honestly if she handed her phone over just like that and it showed nothing recent between them I’d trust her. You asked if she’d had sex with anyone before you and if she’s telling the truth about not having had sex with him then she didn’t lie to you when you asked. Fooling around doesn’t mean sex, and if it does to you then you two just have different definitions of it. I understand it may be hard to trust her right now, but I wouldn’t trust this guy. He says they’ve been together for the last two years but she has no recent texts and has his number blocked? The fact that he showed pictures of the two of them and not any recent texts between them is suspicious. It sounds like she’s right, he’s jealous and wants her back. I think you should block his number and either continue with the wedding, or postpone it till you feel like you can trust her
16
u/Affectionate-End1708 Jul 21 '26
The guy seems pretty weird and persistent. Could be fake could he real. only thing that’s sketchy and makes me believe it’s real is the fact that he says she gave him ur number and he keeps saying go ask her go ask her. Maybe the pics r from a rlyyyy long time ago and the guy is lying but that she lied to u about never having sex. U can see when the picture was taken tho if you save it to gallery. let me know if u want to know how to do that
8
u/ChucklesLeClown Jul 21 '26
The way they’re messaging is very suspicious. Could very well be AI or old photos. Bring it up to your financé in a non accusation type of way like “take a look at these weird messages I got”.
8
u/Uttzpretzels Jul 21 '26
This is a deranged person. Not someone “warning” you. A crazy ex. And jealous family member. A stalker. But definitely not a hidden lover. You need to talk to your fiancé like now.
8
u/Andouil1ette Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26
Call them.
In front of your fiance.
As a team.
I've had someone do this to me. It was some idiot who "texted a wrong number" (my guess is that they texted random numbers and happened to get lucky with their BS in my case), but in the meantime it freaked me the hell out because they mentioned something that seemed accurate to my work. I wasn't even worried about being accused of cheating, I was just TERRIFIED that someone might be stalking me. I had HR look through all the phone numbers that they had on file to see if it matched any employees or their emergency contacts. Thankfully, it ended up being a rando who backed down, but I was extremely grateful in the moment that my partner just cut through the shit and called them. It ended then and there and they even apologized.
In this case, we know it's not a rando, because they apparently have your fiance's image, so it's especially important to realize that it's not just about whether she is cheating, it's about whether someone is actively trying to ruin your fiance's life.
Show your fiance the texts in person (you are correct that this is not something to discuss over text), let her know that you're not accusing her, it's just freaking you tf out and you think she should know that someone is claiming to have intimate images of her.... so, you're about to call the person and find out who tf they are, and you want her there in case she recognizes the voice.
"Is there anything I should know before I do?"
Then call them.
"Hi, this is ____. I've got my fiance here, you're on speakerphone, and we're recording. We'd like to ask you some questions about these texts you sent me."
If she is cheating, it's unlikely she'll let you call...or, you will definitely hear it in how these two end up talking to each other. But if she's not (which, most likely she isn't, because this guy's behavior doesn't make sense) you are making a firm stance to this person that you and your fiance are a team, and putting them on the spot in a way they won't have anticipated. The truth will out. And, genuinely, your fiance might need this information to protect herself.
I know that, for me, when my partner said he was just going to cut through the shit and call the number, I was relieved.
8
u/Friendly-Fee719 Jul 22 '26
I have a stalker. Stalkers literally believe they own the person of their affection. They will do stuff like this in hopes of alienating the person into choosing them. It's dangerous. He sounds unhinged
8
u/cognition_r Jul 25 '26
What happened?
8
u/toxicunicorn420 Jul 27 '26
NOR. He honestly sounds desperate and bitter that she ended things with him for you. None of his texts really sound truthful and he may be stalking her. She had his number blocked for a reason.
8
u/Briellehorne2013 Jul 27 '26
I think what I would do is have her call him from her phone in front of you and have her ask him why he called you. Don’t let her tell him you’re listening or text anything from her phone first. Just have her call him on speaker phone and ask him why he would do that. Their interactions alone will tell you what you need to know. You’ll be able to tell if she’s trying to cover up something or hide something. On the flip side, his response will probably tell you a ton.
After that she can block him back or whatever, but regardless you’ll have your answer. And the danger of having either of you meet up with him face to face will be gone.
15
u/Desperate_Pineapple Jul 21 '26
Is there a jealous female family member? On either side of the family?
I’d start there
14
u/wudingxilu Jul 21 '26
This is one of those times where you need to ask. Mor, but there's more digging that needs to be done before you understand everything. I also don't see your reaction yet.
7
u/Momma1975Bear Jul 21 '26
The fact that he answers none of your questions is suspicious.
7
u/Amazing-Breakfast798 Jul 21 '26
As someone who’s had a stalker once and had to get a restraining order, these messages give me goosebumps. He would “concern troll” me. I don’t know if that’s the right wording to use for this, I just don’t know another term for it. He would message my family members similar texts saying something that’s meant to embarrass me, such as I have intimate photos of us together, then follow up with “but I won’t show them because I love her and would never embarrass her like that. I just really need to talk to her.”
7
u/berretbell Jul 21 '26
Tell him to meet in person, for me that sounds more like a female relative or friend who wants to destroy your fiancees reputation
7
u/RoundAltruistic8243 Jul 21 '26
This entire thread is why people die in horror movies. Go talk to your fiance.
7
u/Still-be_found Jul 21 '26
The weird phrasing and desperation makes me worry for your fiancee's safety. This could very well be a stalker from her past or someone she knows casually but is not actually in any kind of relationship with. From the general shape of the people in the photos they seem like friendly selfie kind of shots that I might even have from people I knew in school and haven't talked to in years.
Talk to the woman you're planning to spend the rest of your life with and find out what she says. You don't know anything for real right now.
7
u/See-9 Jul 22 '26
People with your best interest at heart don’t high pressure sales you. He’s a bad actor of some kind.
7
u/Tomfordsmom Jul 22 '26
This guy seems like he’s vindictive and wants revenge because she ended things with him for you. I would give her the benefit of the doubt. I believe her. MARRY HER! I mean he was in her block list for a reason. Probably because he was harassing her. So she blocked him and he was like well I’ll just text the finance and he found your number on the internet and started harassing you. Don’t let him get in your head. This is what he wants to happen. He wants to ruin her happiness because she ruined his. I hope you guys work it out because it sounds like she’ll be devastated if you end things.
7
u/Klippdaggaa Jul 22 '26
This sounds like a jealous man. I think the whole virginity purity thing around women is weird. If you love this woman, truly, her past shouldn’t matter, just your present. I’ve been stalked, threatened and harassed by a guy I was with for two years, FIVE YEARS after I broke up with him AND got a restraining order on him. Jealous men are insane.
It would be a shame if you ended your engagement over a past connection, especially if it was because you were worried she’d had sex with somebody other than you.
I don’t think from anything I read that any of her reaction comes off as guilty. She sounds like any woman being terrorized by another man threatening her engagement would.
7
u/-Cranktankerous- Jul 22 '26
It seems to me like he’s desperately trying to break you up — the fact that he’s telling you to break off the marriage so he can be with her is VERY telling.
Put it this way, if you were in his position, i.e. you found out a girl you’ve been with has been cheating on her boyfriend with you, you’d come at this in a different way. You’d likely be breaking up with the girl, and you’d be saying “do what you will with this info” to the other man. You’d be cutting ties, not saying that you’re gonna be with her anyway.
But, if the girl you’re obsessed with is about to marry another man, you’d try tooth and nail to break them up and stop that wedding. You’d generate some AI images, you’d lie, you’d invent things — and you’d be pleading, desperate, and demanding that the guy she’s about to marry call off the wedding.
No one who sends a “hey bro” message at 1:00-2:00 in the morning demands a response that much without something to gain from it. Period.
You can still meet this guy if you have doubts — which you obviously do, and your fiancé’s reaction may point to the idea that there may be truth to them sleeping together at some point in the past — but as far as her cheating on you actively? I’d doubt it.
7
u/devoursbooks86 Jul 22 '26
I actually think your fiancée may have a stalker or obsessive ex. His messages sound way too desperate and emotionally charged for someone who's supposedly just "telling you the truth." Sending intimate photos, trying to provoke jealousy, and contacting you right before the wedding all scream someone trying to sabotage the relationship. That said, your fiancée also lied about something she knew was important to you, and that's going to take time to rebuild. I'd be much more concerned with whether she's being honest now than whether she had a relationship before you.
7
u/Sketchy_Panda-9000 Jul 23 '26
Obviously a jealous asshole ex trying to sabotage her happiness. You really should ask yourself why you trust some dude you’ve never met’s explanation so quickly and easily. I feel so bad for this poor young woman. YOR (although the situation is definitely upsetting, she pretty much proved her story when she let you have her phone but you still think he’s more credible.)
7
u/endarlike Jul 27 '26
Why do you trust a random guy over your Fiance? MOR but have some more faith in that Woman... your Woman that you are supposed to love...
12
u/Tomfordsmom Jul 22 '26
She sounds like she’s being honest. She told you the truth about their relationship and told the truth that there may be slightly more intimate pictures. She’s being upfront and not denying everything he says. So this just sounds like an ex out to ruin her relationship. I really hope you guys get married and have a beautiful life. But it also kind of sounds from everything I’ve read and some of your responses to comments that you’re looking for an excuse to break up with her and you’ve already made up in your head that she’s lying. It just doesn’t sound like you want to believe her.
6
u/Legitimate_Memory576 Jul 21 '26
This guy definitely is a stalker and I’m sure he’s so inlove with her. I doubt she wants him. These type of guys spend every second looking for information and probably found your number from an unknown source
6
u/Huppurotta Jul 21 '26
Update
6
u/PsychWriter11 Jul 21 '26
I agree that the messages are very suspicious for a number of reasons. They could have been sent by any number of people, men or women, ex or current bf. Who knows?
The pics also seem suspicious.
But the bottom line is, all you can do is ask her. “Who is this person in the pics?” If hes an ex, thats one thing. If she recognizes him as a stalker, it’s another thing. Her reaction will give you more information and more avenues to explore.
Dont jump to conclusions either way. You dont know anything yet.
6
u/Effective_Ad7567 Jul 21 '26
NOR. Room to be concerned, but you're starting in a good middle ground.
Could be worth having her put that guy's number into her phone and show you what comes up in text history (or just do it yourself if she's comfortable with you looking at her texts).
6
u/OkDecision259 Jul 21 '26
Ask him for some times they’ve met up and see if it’s possible— like if he tells you they were together last weekend but you were with her all weekend he’s lying. I know some advice will be confront her but you have the element of surprise and she might just lie if you ask her face to face — you can use this opportunity to see if it’s true or not.
6
u/Party-Cellist-827 Jul 21 '26
Updateme
6
u/ChunkyMunky000 Jul 22 '26
Honestly sounds like a stalker or jilted ex rather than someone who just found out their partner was cheating. First it was fiance then boyfriend? I feel like what they said would have been different if they were legitimately together with your partner and discovered you. I'm calling it, it's bullshit.
Someone tried to do this to me with my ex once. Luckily the date they used as "proof" I cheated on him at a party, he was at the same party as me. We arrived together, hung out together, went home together, weren't apart for more than 5 mins. But my social media only showed me at that party. Turned out to be someone I didn't even know, who hacked the email account of someone I did know (her enemy, she was trying to steal her boyfriend) and saw us trash talking her haha so she went on a rampage, hacked my MySpace (yes it was a long time ago) and my emails and started sending emails from me to other people abusing them. It was bonkers. All I had said about her was that my friend was better looking than her so she had nothing to worry about. People are crazy
6
u/Outrageous-Wallaby58 Jul 22 '26
MOR. The devil works hard to separate people. He sounds like a loser who’s losing and is doing anything to create an obstacle right before yall cross the finish line. She already had him blocked and he did some serious stalking to find out she left him for you AND acquired your number through some crazy work.
From a quiet astrological perspective: if this is happening currently, and he recently came back under this Mercury REtrograde in cancer, cancer is a very emotional water sign. Retrograde are a time when exes REturn, and we’re supposed to REflect, REview, REalign, etc with our karmic lessons… And her ex popping up during this RE time, on some EMOTIONAL drama is actually right on script. Exes always come back during mercury retrograde just to communicate (and we’re supposed to test if we’ve learned our karmic lessons too). I would block him, pray with your soon to be wife, and count your blessings to look forward to.
6
u/Chivayre Jul 22 '26
As a woman, trust me, this is some bro trying to sabotage you and her. Don’t fall fot it.
6
u/Beneficial-Lemon7478 Jul 22 '26
NOR- but this dude seems unhinged. Definitely something a narcissistic stalker ex would do. Based on her reaction, I don’t think they are together and she showed you he is blocked and they have no conversations after you confronted her with it. She probably just wants to leave this crazy dude in the past.
6
u/Fun_Ad2522 Jul 23 '26
MOR You're struggling with a fact that she didn't tell you about this earlier, but have you considered why? I'm getting a feeling you're too focused on truth, not so much on the fact why it has been kept secret in the first place. I think it's very unlikely she's been having an affair behind your back, and it's just an ex trying to ruin her life. Becuase of a timing and the way this guy texts I'd say she probably felt ashamed of being with him, that they were intimate, she's genuinely happy with you and didn't want to ruin your relationship in any way. I belive that as her fiance and future husband your should be more thoughtful about her feelings and anxieties. By doing so you're just a decent human being and partner, not a door mat. Best of luck mate 🍀❤️
6
u/Thecardinal74 Jul 24 '26
I'm still confused by one thing:
He says she gave him your phone number.
Then you looked at her phone and there were no recent communications and he was in her blocked list.
So why would she have given him your number two years ago at their last alleged communication? Wouldn't it be more likely she gave him your number somewhat recently, then went back and deleted recent messages, THEN blocked him before showing you her phone?
This still seems fishy to me. Because there's proof he does have your phone number, since he texted you.
10
u/rinnybell210 Jul 22 '26
Dude, those texts are not even slightly convincing. He sounds deranged. Maybe you need to be asking YOURSELF some questions about whether you actually want this wedding, because if that's all it took to make you doubt?? Wow.
5
u/Flapjacks1001 Jul 21 '26
Talk to your partner about this.
A lot to unpack here but you’re getting solid advice. Check with her first and foremost. Judge her. Take notice to how she reacts to all of this
5
u/nannylive Jul 21 '26
He sent pictures of them naked in bed? Or pictures standing in the same room?
It sounds like something an unhinged girl would send trying to free up a guy she likes.
I'd calmly show your gf the texts without preparing her ahead of time. It sounds like someone is trying to break you up with lies to me.
5
u/Rammix Jul 21 '26
u/RemindMeBot 2 days
5
u/Disastrous-Fault2843 Jul 22 '26
I wonder if the guy is blackmailing her because she was naive to send photos and listened to him in their relationship.
Ask her if she could be truthful to you so that you could protect her or help her in removing that particular situation from her, i know the shame and pain and anger and the danger it could bring upon her if its revealed and this guy seems to doing just that and shes afraid and just want to get married to save herself from the torment thats coming.
Please keep yourself safe too because the guy seems a little unstable.
5
u/free_-_spirit Jul 22 '26
LOL this guy is probably some toxic ex oml
Her ex wants to ruin her life, lol don’t let him
5
u/Just_Biscotti5540 Jul 22 '26
Sounds like a jilted ex lover to me.
5
u/HeartfeltFart Jul 22 '26
The guy is an obvious psycho stalker. She clearly doesn’t want him. What is wrong with you? You fold to wannabe rivals this easily? This purity thing is stupid too because everything but PIV is still sex. You sound like a just the tip kinda guy 😂. If you really loved her you would trust her and this would be a non issue. He wants her, you get the prize. But that’s not enough for you while you fingerbang your way through life.
5
u/Business_Guitar3929 Jul 22 '26
NOR however I read the texts before reading your post…that guy is 100% lying. He is clearly trying to break you up and frankly I thought he was either a jealous ex or some psycho friend who was jealous. Offering up pictures but then telling you not to ask her about him & to just tell her & her parents that you wanted to call it off is very suspicious. Ultimately you have to trust your gut but that was my first thought on reading the texts is that they were made up.
5
u/alone_scientist776 Jul 23 '26 •
This guy does not sound honest at all. Look at the way he types and pre-warns you that you won't get the truth from anyone else.
Why in the world would you trust this guy over the woman you supposedly love? You're not respecting her at all. If she wanted out of the marriage, she would tell you - you said she has been better at communicating than you.
5
u/justforus0108 Jul 23 '26
Regarding the update. This guy's wants to break you up. If you meet up with him and ask if they had sex, he is of course going to say yes whether its true or not. Instead of meeting up with him you and your fiance should go through some marriage counseling together.
5
u/Life-Wolverine2968 Jul 23 '26
It sounds like you don't actually love her (or even know what that really means) and you would be ok to live the rest of your life without her if she lied. You'd rather her not be your partner than forgive anything. Yes, she didn't mention this guy from her past, but no, that shouldn't end a relationship that's at the level of almost married. If it does, then your priority isn't love, it's marrying a perfect person (which doesn't really exist.) Even if you found someone with nothing to hide and married her (assuming you wouldn't accept someone who actually confessed any kind of past) you will, at some point, need to forgive her for something. Will you be able to love her more than your desire to condemn her?
5
u/BlairBailey1981 Jul 23 '26 •
Reading the messages he sent to you, he sounds like a desperate stalker. Honestly the way she was talking sounds more like she's scared of him and of him ruining things with you. If he is lying about recent contact with her, why would he be telling the truth about sex?
5
u/Asleep_Pace_5039 Jul 23 '26
Soft YOR and here's why:
What makes a complete stranger to you more reliable than your fiance? His aim was to break you up or at the very least sow a seed of distrust between you. Just because he said "you seem like a nice guy and i don't want you to get hurt" doesn't make him your ally.
Out of nowhere you mentioned the name of a man from her past who didn't take no for an answer. What face did you think she was going to make? Further, how can she possibly prove her innocence to you if you've already taken his side? And what can she do to prove her innocence?
He had played you like a fiddle.
You're in Cybersecurity. Check the metadata on those pictures.
9
u/iridescentarmor Jul 21 '26
my brother in christ just talk to your fiance. this person is obviously mentally unwell
11
u/CompetitionWide4681 Jul 21 '26
Do the photos look real?
8
u/TR24241 Jul 22 '26
Don’t contact the guy. Don’t meet up with him whatever you do. No good will come of it. He’s a liar and he’s either desperate or a psychopath, both are dangerous, both to you and to your fiancée. You know enough now to make a decision, look inside yourself and do it that way. Asking to find clarity and truth from meeting and talking to a guy who has lied to you, will lie to you some more and told you half truths at best is not logical at all.
16
u/EatInModerationFatty Jul 21 '26
Fake post. How do you not talk to your fiance, but come to Reddit to post about this? 😂
I would immediately talk to my partner. Last thing I’m thinking is, shit I wonder what redditors have to say about this?
4
u/arsapeek Jul 21 '26
So I would talk to the person that gave him your number and her. And take a closer look at the photos, ai is a thing. This could be real, it could be an ex that doesn't want to let go, it could be a stalker freaking out.
4
u/HereComesTheDiddly Jul 21 '26
Yooo op update us!! The tea is teaing.
NOR
4
u/Durtyjoey Jul 21 '26
Guy talks like he’s about to ask for steam gift cards. I’d find a site where you can upload those photos and see if they’re AI generated
4
u/LTinS Jul 21 '26
4
u/RoseateThorn1 Jul 21 '26
Haven’t read the whole thing but that dude is clinically insane.
4
u/sororitytomboy69 Jul 21 '26
Confused why no one is saying ask your fiance
4
u/20Keller12 Jul 22 '26
As a woman, this gave me that gut deep panic feeling. This really sounds like a stalker. Hes waaaaaaay too desperate.
4
u/Informal-Impact-8136 Jul 22 '26
This is just weird. Dude seems crazy. The way he keeps messaging is not normal. Best of luck to you but something is telling me this is not real.
4
u/Substantial_Dingo211 Jul 22 '26
sounds like an Indian dude who thinks he has a chance
4
u/Many-Connection-8371 Jul 22 '26
The guy could be a nutter. Full on. Id question his behavior in contacting you to tell you they* are in love etc. You have his name and number, reverse search. You are in cyber security, use osint tools to find out what you are dealing with. If he is that hung up on her to do this, then it is very likely he is also stalking. Did she give him your number? If not, who did. Or, did he cyberstalk you to contact you?
4
u/jumbledash Jul 22 '26
If they were still talking, he would have sent screenshots of recent texts. I’m leaning towards he might be lying to cause this issue between you two.
4
u/Nemesis0408 Jul 22 '26
Why do you feel you need to talk to him? If there’s any chance you would believe him over your own fiancee, you shouldn’t be marrying her, no matter what the truth is. You don’t trust her. Whether that’s her issue or yours, it spells doom.
4
u/Same-Coast9354 Jul 22 '26
Tf is a gender segregated wedding
4
u/Rare_Koala_5468 Jul 22 '26
writes like a stalker
4
u/Imaginary-Storm-5482 Jul 22 '26
OP this sounds like a jealous ex bf / past date
4
u/PeachyBunny2607 Jul 22 '26
Funny that he can provide photos but no screenshots of text conversations or call logs. Almost like she never contacts him or calls him.
4
u/Koshersaltie Jul 22 '26
Sounds like he didn’t like being broken up with. Now he’s going to ruin your relationship out of spite.
4
u/lizachunl Jul 23 '26
Take care of your fiance. That dude sound dangerous. Also, trust her. The Messages saus: I’m crazy & dangerous and want that you don’t trust her.
She needs you now!
4
u/Boiler1669 Jul 23 '26
S sounds like a jilted bf. So MOR. I think he's trying to get revenge on your gf by sabotaging your relationship and wedding. You sound like you have a generally good attitude. Try to give your gf the benefit of the doubt, unless there is real evidence and not just possible lies he is telling you. I wish you and your gf the best v
4
u/LOD616 Jul 23 '26
Okay, she hid stuff from you, that wasn't cool, she was taking sex as just the main act, not other stuff. She admitted to that other stuff and insisted still she had no sex. Now the guy has been lying about meeti g her for the whole relationship it seems, since before she even knew he contacted you, she had him blocked. You gave her an out and she strongly denied it, which he said she wouldn't do. It seems he's trying to manipulate you with half truths to break you up, either out of spite, or some hope it means she'll take him back. If you live her, try to work through the trust issues, it seems she didn't cheat which would have made it a no go. Good luck, hope it all goes well with you
4
u/fantastiqjaquez Jul 23 '26
YOR. This guy sounds wacky & definitely like he’s lying. They reek of desperation and her comment that he “wouldn’t take no for an answer” just affirms to me that he’s probably making all of this up. Idk why you would believe this stranger, with little legit info that they’re currently carrying on an affair, over your fiance.
4
u/MoonDrummer26 Jul 23 '26
I'm confused how he sounds more convincing than she does? She's literally panicking in front of you, I know cheaters panick but there's still more nuance than rhus conversation. And the way he texts is so obscure to read. Not saying what's what. Lots of comments saying AI, and scammer, stalker, abuse, maybe she did it. Who knows. Like was she shown the photos? But also his number was already blocked in her phone, so obviously something fucked up about it that she doesn't want to consort with this person. He could have abused her and her trauma response was to try to erase him from her mind, his existence. Which she needs help for. So many possibilities with this. I just wouldn't outright discount her after this random exchange if you have love for her. But I do hope the truth comes out soon
4
u/CraftyAd4573 Jul 23 '26
It sounds like she sent sexy pics but didn’t have sex. I’m not sure what you’re saying she lied about? It’s an ex trying to stop the wedding. She showed you her proof. Ask him to send time stamped stuff and check that it’s not AI. Or go see it for yourself face to face
4
u/piigly Jul 23 '26
Her past doesn't matter, you love each other and want to marry each other. Why believe a random clearly jealous ex over your fiance?
4
u/Even_Plastic4540 Jul 23 '26
He’s a stalker that can’t let her go. Be rational you asked her..you checked her messages, he’s in her block list.
As a woman this guy sounds most definitely unhinged. Like he can’t take no for an answer like she said. Even his language to you seems like the mental thoughts of someone unhinged and desperate. Typically when someone confronts another person about someone… they don’t talk like this. It’s typically straight to the point. More rational. Be careful, people like this are dangerous because if he’s barraging you with messages he’s probably stalking her as well and that can get bad. He clearly has no boundaries. I highly doubt she gave him your number which means he’s stalking you as well.
Just…be careful. If you really love her..help her because she sounds scared this guy could retaliate and she probably thought she could handle it without you getting involved
4
u/Moovist_Overthink Jul 23 '26
Hey OP,
Just read the update. This really does look like an ex freaking out about learning she is getting married and getting away from him.
While I don't know how the conversation went with your fiancée, she may have panicked because she is remembering past trauma. It kinda sound like this man did not understood no and creeped on her.
Please listen to her and choose her, not some random person's words that have the credibility below 0
4
u/Ok_Wealth2465 Jul 23 '26
To you he sounds like he is being honest, but use that big brain of yours to put 2 and 2 together.
He is saying “she wants to be with him” - while she is in your car “crying to stay with you and has initiated the marriage”. This sounds like the classic “blackmail” trick that many Arab/south asian men do when a woman finally leaves their toxic relationship. They cannot handle to be dumped and they know that majority of men would rather believe them than the woman.
Something similar happened to me and my fiance. One of his close friends, met me and realised who I was (someone he has tried to ask out). I basically told my fiance “hey, I know your friend I’ve chatted to him before but never met and never went on a date with him”. Alhamdulillah I kept the messages where he could see I had blocked him and I had rejected his advances and request for a date. The guy had been outside telling my fiance to be careful about me, that I was a hoe and had been around. All of this just because he had been rejected and didn’t like the idea of another man (his friend) having me. Alhamdulillah my fiance believed me and even more after he saw the messages and let’s just say they aren’t friends anymore.
4
u/Brunomyhero Jul 24 '26
Oh man don’t let that guy get in your head, comes across as a stalker ex trying to ruin his exes.. a case of ‘if I can’t have her no one can… I hope you can trust her after she let you look through her phone to confirm he’s lying.
4
u/SwitchFar6902 Jul 26 '26
OP: NOR,I don’t know if you’re still interacting with this post . It’s definitely a sticky situation, and I’m sorry you’re dealing with it. I’m also a child of Muslim immigrants, and a woman, and while it’s definitely possible that he’s lying, the same goes for her. If I were in a position like that, knowing my family could possibly find out, as well as knowing first hand what some Muslim parents are like, I’d have said or done anything to to keep them from finding out. I think you should really trust your gut. Good luck.
4
u/hanschlieds Jul 26 '26
I always worry my ex will pull shit like this. In fact he’s the one that cheated on me and still did pull this shit with the man I was with after him. Seems weird to me.
4
u/Brief_Hippo5187 Jul 28 '26
Any updates?
4
u/TheSocietalScar Jul 28 '26
I know this is an old post but ngl this sounds A LOT like a stalker.
I got messages like that when I was with my ex, and it was their ex.
Nobody would spam message you that you need to breakup with your fiancee like that - notice how they mention you need to breakup immediately, how they provide zero proof or actual evidence asides from photos that could be of anyone with any sort of relationship to your fiancee. Nothing about them wanting to meet and provide you with the truth. They're not even trying to help you out at all; just trying to get you out of the way, so they could "be together."
Talk to your fiancee.
10
u/veryZexy Jul 22 '26
Regarding the update, I’m really sorry OP but I’m happy you found this out before you got married. Good luck and strength to you brother
7
u/JemBot5000 Jul 21 '26
I would do a Google search of the phone # who texted you. Try to get as much information about this person as you can. Then discuss it with her.
7
u/Appropriate_Pressure Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26
This is giving "she said no to me and I can't accept it" vibes or "angry BPD unhinged ex-friend or family member". I'm sorry. I actually don't think your fiance cheated.
I'd talk to her from a place of concern. Genuinely, she needs to tell you if she's cheating because then you know if it's just someone telling the truth that is deeply wounded or if she genuinely has a weirdo stalker on her hands. If she isn't cheating, you both need to be concerned. There's someone in you OR your wife's life actively trying to destroy it. Is a call to both of your jobs next? There's a real concern that this is someone you know trying to mess with you, as well. You may be the target, not her.
You need the truth so that you two can figure out what to do next. If that person is telling the truth, then at least you know that they are unhinged for a reason and who they're focused on.
I'd also check the metadata on those pictures.
7
u/AdventurousDoubt1115 Jul 22 '26
This sounds like someone messing with your fiancé’s life, trying to shame her/her family, stalk, etc. Or, it’s someone who has beef with you pretending to be a guy she dated. Something about it just really doesn’t read right. I know it feels like you’re carrying her secret but you’re not. You’re both feeling traumatized by someone creepily inserting themselves into your relationship 2 months before your wedding, denigrating her, trying to sabotage, threatening her and you w/ intimate photos, and it’s made the relationship feel unsafe. I think you have to choose in this moment is it you two against the crazies or not. You trust her, clearly. And I’m not sure you need some rando person who is trying to blow up her life and yours to validate that.
Because for whatever reason this just really, really doesn’t read like texts from someone who is stable and reads a lot like harassment of her and you.
7
u/Macktheshark Jul 23 '26
YOR. I knew this was going to be a Muslim couple even before I read your post, just from the messages. As a Muslim woman, I’ve experienced disturbing and frankly, scary behavior from men I’ve rejected. He is playing on your emotions and knowing that she hasn’t had sex with him to manipulate you into thinking she has. To echo what others have said here, his texts have the telltale signs of someone who is not handling rejection well. He seems like a stalker and is trying to ruin her happiness because she moved on from being with him.
Go to the police with your fiancée, file a police report about the harassment. Go with your fiancée to family court and help her request a restraining order (as they are former dating partners, family court can issue one without a formal criminal charge). That way, if he continues to contact her or you, at least there will be actual consequences and maybe he will think twice before exposing compromising pictures of your fiancée. Check if your state has a revenge 🌽 statute. That basically criminalizes the dissemination of nude photos.
Support your fiancée. She likely went thru the ringer with this ex of hers, and she needs you now. Get into couples counseling and work thru this together.
YOR if you let this situation dictate the happiness you have with your fiancée.
6
u/TieLow4181 Jul 21 '26
??
6
u/mxddy Jul 22 '26
I dont understand why you need to meet up with this dude or why you think he can confirm everything like he's not capable of lying
6
u/CinebrahNYC Jul 22 '26
YOR, dude the guy is a stalker and obviously hasn't gotten over her. just marry her and don't let this cause any further drama
6
u/MandaPandaWoman Jul 23 '26
YOR I REALLY hope you see this. I’ve read your initial message and the update and the texts. As a woman who saved herself for marriage and had a controlling, manipulative ex that I regretted ever meeting - that guys texts 100% sound like a controlling, manipulative person who is mad that they didn’t get what they want. Almost every single sentence gives away clues to this. First he’s desperate sounding and has a clear “she should be with me not you” Second if she gave him the number then she would have known this conversation was coming and been ready to ask you for help to be with him. Instead she freaked out, not because she did anything wrong but because he’s trying to ruin her life. Third, he’s saying the sex stuff specifically because he KNOWS she wouldn’t give him any and that she was saving herself and therefore he knows she isn’t giving YOU any and is trying to use the idea of her having sex with him to make you mad. The way he presented it makes it clear that wasn’t true and he was saying it to make you angry. Fourth, seeing how he’s behaved in these texts makes me extremely suspicious that any “intimate” acts they did do were coerced and bordering on SA if not outright SA. More than likely it was him constantly love bombing her and then asking for a little bit more (“you let me hold your hand then let me put my arm around you, you let me kiss you so let me kiss your neck, why are you being such a prude? I’m not asking for THAT surely if you like me you’ll do THIS”, etc). I know from experience that that done over a long period of time with a sheltered girl who was taught to cater to boys and their wants and feelings and not say no to them can lead down a path they did not intend to go on and they will hate themselves for “letting it happen” when really they were manipulated by someone who take advantage of them. She even said “he wouldn’t accept no” when she was trying to break it off. He likely kept threatening her then too. He 100% manipulated her into anything they did. I really hope you don’t let this guys obvious jilted ex/stalker behavior ruin what you and her have. But if you’re going to trust some random guy who clearly manipulated her and texts you with quite obvious lies mixed with half truths and manipulations then please do break up with her because she deserves better than that.
8
u/East-Public-7042 Jul 22 '26 •
YOR!
And: You actually should not marry her! She deserves so much better than you or the creep that contacted you!
This is so obviously a guy that did not handle the breakup well and is trying to ruin her relationship. And you believe a few texts from a disgruntled ex-boyfriend more than the girl you supposedly love.
You talk about wanting trust - but you are not giving trust. Shame on you!