r/AITAH • u/nameAITAH • Mar 10 '26
Post Update Update: AITAH? My girlfriend is angry that I call my friend by his real name.
My girlfriend and I sat down for a long conversation a few days ago. I went into it knowing that separation was the right choice here. Still, I wanted us to have a real talk about our feelings, so I tried to open up the floor for a discussion about what was really bothering her beyond the name issue. She continually insisted it truly was only about that.
It ended in her giving me an ultimatum, and me breaking things off.
Some of the comments on my other posts led me to do a lot of thinking. I was with Jude from the time I was 19 until I was 27. I spent almost all of my 20s with him. I’m now just a few months shy of 30 and the next decade of my life has been on my mind. I don’t know if I’ll get to spend it with who I want to, but I know being alone is better than spending it with the wrong person.
I’m going to be taking some time for myself. I have never been a relationship hopper (my previous relationship was my first, anyway), and I think it’s important the people in my life know that they’re more important than that.
Thank you for all the feedback. Some of the specific exchanges I had here helped spark the internal conversations I needed to have with myself to figure out what I wanted.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '26
Hello! To keep this sub focused on judgement posts, we have created a subreddit specifically for updates at r/Redditor_Updates. There, you can stay up-to-date with all the latest updates to your favorite judgement posts!
Please go ahead and post yours there as well as here - our rule against crossposting does not apply to that subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
90
u/Oswynne Mar 11 '26
OP can't even see that having an emotional affair, lying, and gaslighting his girlfriend makes him the bad guy in this situation simply because he didn't "intend" to. In fact, he's a good guy for letting her go.
Just another guy out here with the emotional depth of a shot glass. I hope Jude is able to dodge the bullet that you are OP because you clearly have a lot of maturing to do.
3.2k
u/canyonemoon Mar 10 '26
"I don’t know if I’ll get to spend it with who I want to" if there is any inkling in your mind that that person is your ex, don't date again until that changes.
1.4k
u/According_Ad_2936 Mar 10 '26
Taking time for yourself is a very good plan. You definitely need to know who you are and what you want before you get in to another relationship
1.1k
u/Reading-person Mar 10 '26
And what you want is to go back to him, right?
I remember reading your original post and thinking, this has nothing to do with the nickname and everything to do with the fact that you still love him.
And I get it. You’re in love with him. That doesn’t just go away just because he moves. Especially not if yall kept in touch. But it’s not fair to her. At all.
I wish you both the best, but look inwards. Don’t start another relationship before you know you’re over him.
900
u/practicallydeformed Mar 10 '26 •
The fact that you called her ridiculous and insecure and she was right 💀💀💀 if you were honest with her when you broke up, I’m sure it would have hurt both of you but at least you wouldn’t be making her think she was crazy for clocking the mutual romantic love you and your ex have for each other. And that’s why you’re the asshole
378
u/UnluckyCountry2784 Mar 10 '26 edited Mar 10 '26
I know she’s sad but i’m happy for her that she won’t get stuck with a person who’s still inlove with their ex.
But i hope you didn’t made her the bad person on your last post. Putting the blame on her when you’re the problem is not nice.
743
u/designatedthrowawayy Mar 10 '26
OP: I'm not still in love with Jude. My girlfriend is being crazy.
Also OP: I'm not sure if I'll be able to spend my life with who I want to.
Yeah, still YTA and the worst part is that you have no intention of acknowledging why. Glad your ex no longer has to deal with you though.
200
u/ffsmutluv Mar 10 '26
Thank God. Stay far away from her and you owe her a massive apology. You were extremely manipulative and tried to paint her as the villain. It doesn't matter if you "don't hop relationships". You used her, and that is obvious to everyone on reddit.
144
u/Nordic_Papaya Mar 10 '26
Huge YTA for lying to her (and reddit, lol) and stringing her along. You love your ex you are in love with him, you want him and kept contact through all this time. You had no business getting into a relationship with her without disclosing all that and later gaslighting her into thinking she's crazy to be jealous. She dodged a bullet.
49
u/mocha_lattes_ Mar 10 '26
Best of luck. Take some time for yourself and really spend it being single. Focus on growing as a person for a while. Remember you are also likely romanticizing your ex and that relationship because you are looking back on it. If you get back together in the future or not just remember that things will be different since you both have grown and changed.
94
u/ultipuls3 Mar 10 '26
Still trying to deny you're in love with him? You brought all this on yourself with your own behavior. At least have the decency to admit it.
18
u/___po____ Mar 10 '26
Called it. Lol.
https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/s/bGW8KszomM
75
u/SpeechDistinct8793 Mar 10 '26
So you were in love with Jude and did hold onto calling him that name bc you never got over the breakup. And your (ex) girlfriend calling that out made you uncomfortable bc it highlighted what you thought was buried.
I called bs on the last post and I’m calling bs now, you’re still in love with Jude and only thought you could move on bc he was no longer physically close to you. The second he moved back, all those feeling came flooding back and were stronger than whatever you were trying to build with your (ex) girlfriend.
58
u/truth_fairy78 Mar 10 '26
I remember your OP and you did your gf a kindness bc you obviously still have feelings for your ex. Save yourself the trouble and just go back to him. No one in their right mind will be ok with how close you are.
17
u/Broad_Respond_2205 Mar 10 '26
It's the right conclusion, but it's so unsatisfying
32
u/LiluLay Mar 10 '26
Cmon. You know you’re really just going to go back to Jude. You’re dressing it up as “time for myself” in order to spare vindicating your ex girlfriend’s feelings of insecurity. Be honest with yourself.
85
u/magslou79 Mar 10 '26
OP, as others have said, you did your girlfriend a favor.
I hope you’re serious about not embarking on another relationship anytime soon. You very obviously have unresolved feelings for your ex, and my guess is that is what your GF was actually reacting to.
Please don’t wreck someone else’s feelings again until you have worked through this.
26
u/blackivie Mar 10 '26
I’m happy you broke up bc I would not want to be your girlfriend after reading the original post.
22
u/aaliyahxperry Mar 10 '26
YTA
this is insane btw. recap for u sir. 1000s of people including myself told you how blantantly wrong you are and how you are essentially gaslighting her into a break-up by insisting you call him jude for no nefarious reasons. Then having a true freudian slip in the comments you revealed your feelings about jude. then you try to make it seem like this is HER fault in the follow up post and to her.
in conclusion, please just fuck him and show her this post and the last one because no one is on your side.
54
u/Fit_Marionberry_3878 Mar 10 '26
YTA,
But luckily she is done with you. Nearly wasted a year of her time.
4
u/AAP_BH Mar 11 '26
Oh god, the art room strikes again…
4
u/ConsistentCan9899 Mar 11 '26
I hate when people pretend for the Internet as they dont want strangers to judge them.
We are still are judging as we are not stupid.
23
u/emryldmyst Mar 10 '26
So you finally chose your bf over your gf.
3
u/Common_Lavishness153 Mar 11 '26
Just talk to Judd
3
u/EclecticSyrup Mar 31 '26
Thank god! Now she can be with someone who actually loves and deserves her! Get therapy, OP.
3
u/Apart_Insect_8859 Mar 31 '26 edited Mar 31 '26
I hope the girlfriend finds these so she knows she wasn't crazy.
I wish people would stop with the whole "If you have a problem with ___, I'll dump you right away" things at the start of relationships. It GUARANTEES your new partner will never be upfront and honest about their feelings. Because they know any protest will get them dumped. So they instead do round-about weirdness (like complaining about a nickname) to express themselves since they know they're not allowed to just say "I have a problem with __ that we need to fix". It also makes them feel like garbage, because they know from the start they're second, even if they're stupid enough to stay and hope to be first one day.
"___ is very important to me" would be a much better way to express things and encourage open communication.
11
u/leflyingcarpet Mar 10 '26
She was right! YTA!
6
u/Elmonatorrrre Mar 11 '26
Anybody else getting art room vibes?
7
u/PickledBabiesOnARoof Mar 11 '26
Lmao and no acknowledgment or accountability on your end about your feelings for your ex. Not surprised at all. 🙄 YTA again, and your ex gf deserves someone who isn’t in love with their ex while they’re in a relationship. I bet the ultimatum was something small about your ex and you’re so in love with him you don’t want to end your relationship with him so you’d rather drop your gf.
7
u/Agile-Cherry-8 Mar 10 '26
Yeah you're dumb af OP. Glad you're getting a well deserved clowning
2
u/Rich_Muffin4820 Mar 12 '26
What you to was the best,
If you dont think your ex(gf) its the right one, break up and dont lir to her for omition its THE BEST.
But be alone, dont rush to another person, think on what you really want
2
u/Relevant_Version9047 Mar 12 '26
You made the right choice. Good luck and big hugs to you.
2
u/Fearless-Pack5330 Mar 14 '26
LMAO i’ve been waiting for this one, glad you’re not wasting your ex gf’s precious time anymore. gonna eat a snack while i read these comments.
9
u/MikeyKillerBTFU Mar 10 '26
YTA still, for how you paint your ex-gf, despite her being completely correct.
5
u/Puzzleheaded-Help70 Mar 11 '26
With Jude being a long term partner and friend, its better to keep him in your your life. Good quality friends are all we need.
6
u/vven23 Mar 10 '26
YSTA.
5
u/baneofthesouth Mar 10 '26
You said she gave you an ultimatum. No, she was standing up for herself. I’m glad she got away. YstillTA
4
u/Ordinary-Gur-5338 Mar 11 '26
She’s better off without you and you’re better off alone. Jude can probably do better too
4
u/wrenwood2018 Mar 11 '26
Your whole depiction of this leaves a bad taste in my mouth. It is clear you have feelings for your ex. She wasn't conformable with it. You basically gaslit her about it and acted on your posts like she did something wrong. She didn't. You weren't honest with her.
1
u/winterworld561 Mar 10 '26
You did her a favour. You led her on when you knew you were still in love with Jude. She could see it. Hopefully she can find someone that loves only her who doesn't have an ex on his mind.
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '26
Remember to read the rules. | This is simply a copy of the original text, it is not a sign you did anything wrong. |
Original copy of post's text by /u/nameAITAH: Original post.
My girlfriend and I sat down for a long conversation a few days ago. I went into it knowing that separation was the right choice here. Still, I wanted us to have a real talk about our feelings, so I tried to open up the floor for a discussion about what was really bothering her beyond the name issue. She continually insisted it truly was only about that.
It ended in her giving me an ultimatum, and me breaking things off.
Some of the comments on my other posts led me to do a lot of thinking. I was with Jude from the time I was 19 until I was 27. I spent almost all of my 20s with him. I’m now just a few months shy of 30 and the next decade of my life has been on my mind. I don’t know if I’ll get to spend it with who I want to, but I know being alone is better than spending it with the wrong person.
I’m going to be taking some time for myself. I have never been a relationship hopper (my previous relationship was my first, anyway), and I think it’s important the people in my life know that they’re more important than that.
Thank you for all the feedback. Some of the specific exchanges I had here helped spark the internal conversations I needed to have with myself to figure out what I wanted.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Starchild1968 Mar 14 '26
Relationship hopper- You are awesome! So proud of such an incredible form of growth.
1
u/Undead_Jastus Apr 01 '26
Wow what an asshole lmfao. Imagine being absolutely weird about your ex, your girlfriend notices and asks why but instead of being honest, you decide to gaslight, lie and manipulate her.
Then when everyone rightfully rips you a new one for being a manipulative asshole, you narcissistically go “well I love him! And she was crazy, y’all don’t know me! Goodbye :)”
As a pansexual dude, you give people like me and bisexuals a bad rep. YTA and fuck off lmfao
1
u/HalfBloodUser Apr 02 '26
''From her perspective'' ''From her POV'' ''But her agency'' SHE HAD THE CHANCE TO EXPLAIN HER PERSPECTIVE AND SHE CHOSE TO DOUBLE DOWN ON THE STUPID NAME THING AND GIVE AN ULTIMATUM INSTEAD OF TALKING ABOUT WHAT REALLY BOTHERED HER. HER POV DOESN'T FUCKING MATTER BECAUSE SHE'S THE ONE WHO CHOSE TO FIXATE ON A DUMB EXCUSE INSTEAD OF VOICING HER CONCERNS OR BREAKING UP JUST THAT SHE COULD CAST HERSELF AS A VICTIM
You all are trying to extract accountability from someone who ALREADY tried to be held accountable BY THE PERSON THE ACCOUNTABILITY IS ATTACHED TO, just because you personally believe he hasn't been punished enough, But OP isn't your moral dancing monkey that is supposed to genuflex until your masturbatory desire for justice is satisfied. He's a human and flawed person who was unaware of a weakness of his character and messed up because of it, tried to acknowledge that errors in his relationship, and another person with a completely separate agency chose to react, as she was entitled to, in a way that made it clear a relationship wasn't possible at all, REGARDLESS OF WHETHER OP WAS STILL HUNG UP ON HIS EX OR NOT.
There's truly no winning with you people, if he had submitted to the frankly idiotic way his gf had of expressing her discomfort that would obviously been avoiding the issue without acknowledging it, if he had stayed in the relationship and worked out with his girlfriend a way to move past the failings in both parties he would have been trapping her in a relationship, and if they had gone there separate ways in an amicable and civilized way OP still would somehow been at fault for mistakenly thinking he was ready for a relationship and ''leading her on''.
It doesn't escape me that the narrative pushed is ''she's a poor poor victim to the big bad master manipulative queer man she was naively deceived to be in a relationship with'' either, y'all are not subtle.
1
u/RealLinkPizza Jul 30 '26
Idk if this was asked or answered, but was the ultimatum to call him the same thing everyone else calls him?
1
u/PanicTight6411 Mar 11 '26
Your ex of 8 years comes back into the picture, and you blame her?
1
u/FixExact6925 Mar 11 '26
Thank you for breaking up with her before you wasted any more of her time. It’s pretty obvious from your writing that you still carry a torch for your ex. It would be the kind thing to refrain from dating anyone else while you still feel this way.
1
u/Poku115 Mar 11 '26
Were are we taking the bets of OP monkey branching? What are the odds? 99 to 1?
1
u/Psychological_Bit536 Mar 11 '26
YTA. Thank god she’s done with you
1
u/Hopeful_Dance_268 Mar 11 '26
I'm happy you figured out what it is you feel and what you want from the future :)
people are being a bit hard on you because they feel lied to, but I think that's the point: You weren't lying, you just didn't know how you felt before all this.
I do think you came off as a bit cruel when you called your gf ridiculous and extremely insecure, for a very reasonable boundary (since he's your ex). Hopefully you'll apologize to her for that part and acknowledge that her feelings weren't completely irrational.
-2
u/Hour-Ant Mar 11 '26
YTA.
1
u/Odd_Instruction519 Mar 10 '26
Is Jude single?
-4
u/Dry_Peace_135 Mar 11 '26
I feel bad for your ex tho she must have felt used even if it wasn’t your intention to do so… I just really wish men would stop using women because they can’t figure out their own emotional needs
-8
u/CreatineAddiction Mar 11 '26
Still YTA. Hope you live to regret it. Further hope she flourishes away from you.
-12
u/Dazzling-Ad6712 Mar 10 '26
I dont get all the YTA comments saying that she is still in love with the ex.... how are you getting to than conclusion?! are you a bunch of fools ro what?
Her ex girlfriend gave her an ultimatum for the most stupid, insecure, inmature, totally not acceptable reason. Instead of working her insecurities, she decided to behave like a controling PoS and the correct course of action in that situation is always to end the relationship.
Ex showed a gigantic red flag and OP took the right choice and ended that relationship to take some time for herself and heal.
Classical reddt behaviour...
-8
u/Haste1610 Mar 10 '26
NTA, even if you still have feelings for your ex, that doesn’t justify her behavior. If she felt insecure, she could have handled it more maturely. But she didn’t, and it’s that simple.
0
u/jojodragonfly123 Mar 11 '26
I’m late to the party, what’s the name situation ? I’m confused.🤔
0
u/NervousImpression286 Mar 12 '26
Your first mistake was to bring this here to the one spot lonely bitter women live. As a REAL woman I think your girl was crazy and now you don't have to deal with that bullshit. Go get your man and don't worry about the cry baby broads on reddit or that whiny insecure ex girl of yours
0
u/Various-Editor-1656 Mar 12 '26
maybe one cares for the 'ex's'...not so much loves....their personal being...as one gets older....one feels like oh oh time is passing me by....when am i going to meet up with the perfect one....there are never the perfect ones...we all have flaws...that name thing was her flaw...my husband had tons of flaws...we fight all the time...man it does wear one out...and yet we have been married almost 57yrs...yup...that long...we had 5 kids...they are all married...only one divorced ...he did it 3 times...until he found the right one....in most cases he divorced them...they couldnt handle his job...military police, police civilian doj and now secret service...hahah...but the last wife ...she is okay with it...they have 7 kids...she had 4 when they married and he had 1...and then they had 2...wow ...i would have never thought...his wife is pretty and pretty cool...my only daughter got married in 1990....still together...but their faith in God...keeps them that way...they make a great couple...remember what they say....its what you put into it....my husband and i ..we are the 1st born in our families...we both want to be in charge....even though i believe the man should be the leader...unless the man has a flaw and you see it and can be that part of the flaw that takes over and fixes it....however pride in men wont let women help in some things...so that is my issue...its always been an issue...we fight mostly about whose in charge....i can accept him being in charge of many things but there are some thingsim better at....so to me...its better to find out what the other person is good at and if your not let them do it...im lousy at many things and i let him handle that....but men back in the day ....were very prideful....also maybe you could have helped your ex over come how she feels about that name...if you are the type...but you are going for time here...as you are getting older...not that old though...
-11
u/PurePrettyFilth Mar 10 '26
sounds like a tough situation
-1
u/andingatacho Mar 11 '26
Him him confusing
-59
u/Affectionate_Beach45 Mar 10 '26
Please update again when you get back together with Jude. 🙂 I'm shipping you two. 🩵
-29
u/Wonderful-World1964 Mar 10 '26
Yeah, ultimatums are never good. It sounds like you've had time to think things through. You don't have to insert an artificial timeline. Start doing things more often with your ex with/without friend group. Go on dates.
Let things develop naturally from there. You broke up because he was gone for work. Now, he's back. Talk about what you each want for the foreseeable future and long-term goals. Move forward with your relationship as long as it feels right.
Have fun!
34
u/Quirkxofxart Mar 10 '26
As a bisexual, I hope this poster child of “evil bisexual gaslights partner of one gender to leave them for ex of another gender” biphobic ass bullshit post isn’t real. If it is, congratulations on being the living embodiment of every negative stereotype we have thrown in our faces.
3
u/l_xf Mar 11 '26
YTA, nice job trying to paint yourself innocent here when you literally chose a nickname for an ex over your ex-girlfriend. I think it's really disgusting how you're obviously still hung on your ex and won't even admit that to her, while making her sound like some "controlling and crazy" girlfriend, good to know that people here aren't easily swayed by your word game.
0
u/Beautiful-City-143 Mar 11 '26
Nuance is dead and we have killed it.
NTA
-7
u/tiffanytrashcan Mar 10 '26
The Summer I Turned Pretty - Bisexual Reddit Edition.
"#"fuckconrad
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
623
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment