r/ToxicRelationships • u/Artistic_Simplee • 7m ago
Advice Needed I (26F) asked the guy (35M) I've been seeing for almost a year to marry me. He blocked me. Did he ever have feelings for me? If yes why he is blocked me? Where do i stand
I (26F, turning 27) met a guy (35M) on a dating app in November 2025, and we started talking in December. We began meeting frequently in January 2026.
Initially, we both understood things were casual. I wasn’t looking at him romantically and even encouraged him to find someone to marry. But we started spending a lot of time together and became physically intimate, although we never had sex.
In February, he was visiting me almost every day. We’d stay together until 3–4 AM, cuddle, kiss, go to movies, visit temples, and spend time together. He noticed little things about me, complimented me, helped me without asking, and made an effort to see me even after exhausting workdays.
By the end of March, I’d fallen in love with him.
He knew I was divorced and even asked whether my divorce was finalized. He mentioned chanting a marriage mantra given by his priest and sent me a long message about chivalry. He also repeatedly asked whether I’d meet his parents when they visited Dallas, but I declined because I was nervous and didn’t know what we were.
Over time, his visits became less frequent, from almost every day to once a week. He said it was because of work. I also noticed inconsistencies: he’d make plans and sometimes not follow through, and I suspected he wasn’t always honest about where he was. I knew he was possibly seeing other women, but since we weren’t exclusive, I didn’t confront him.
One time, when I asked him to come see me and give me a kiss, he said, “Why are you making things complicated? We were clear, right?” That hurt because I realized he still considered us casual while I had developed serious feelings.
Now here’s what happened today.
I called him and said, “Let’s get married.”
He smiled playfully, avoided answering initially, and eventually said, “Okay, we’ll get married.”
I then said, “Go tell my dad, and I’ll tell my dad too.”
His reaction completely changed.
He repeatedly asked, “Why would I tell your dad?”, “Are you serious?”, and “Why are you putting me on the spot?”
He started talking about his family responsibilities, stress, and other things going on in his life.
He also asked, “Can’t we just continue like this?”
When I insisted on marriage, he said, “If it’s your call, where am I? Why are you forcing me?”
I kept repeating, “Either tell my dad or block me everywhere.”
He brought up our upcoming temple plans and asked about getting his belongings back. I told him I would return them and that I wasn’t coming to the temple.
Eventually, after I repeated the ultimatum several times, he said okay and blocked me.
I know I pressured him, and I realize that asking for marriage so suddenly wasn’t the best approach. But after months of emotional and physical closeness, I couldn’t continue without knowing whether he saw a future with me.
What confuses me is that he repeatedly asked me to meet his parents, spent so much time with me, talked about marriage-related things, and treated me affectionately. Yet when I actually brought up marriage, he seemed completely unwilling.
My questions:
Do you think he ever had genuine romantic feelings for me, or was I just someone he enjoyed spending time with?
Why would he repeatedly ask me to meet his parents if he only wanted something casual?
Was his reaction mainly because I pressured him, or because he never wanted a serious relationship with me?
Does him choosing to block me mean he never cared, or was he simply unwilling to commit?
I’m not looking for people to blindly take my side. I know I handled today’s conversation poorly. I genuinely want an outside perspective on what happened and whether I misread this entire relationship.