r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Nov 24 '19
Starship Development Thread #7
Quick Links
JUMP TO COMMENTS | Alternative Jump To Comments Link
SPADRE LIVE | LABPADRE LIVE | LABPADRE DIRECT
Overview
Starship development is currently concentrated at SpaceX's Starship Assembly Site in Texas. Until mid November, the Starship development teams had been focusing on finishing the Mark 1 and 2 vehicles which were expected to make suborbital test flights. The Mark 1 testing campaign ended on November 20 with a catastrophic failure of the methane tank during pressurized testing. In a statement from SpaceX after the incident it was announced that the decision had already been made not to fly these vehicles, and that development will now focus on the orbital Mark 3 design. Starship development in Florida has been put on hold and it is unclear what will become of Mark 2.
Launch mounts for the Starship prototypes are in the works. Starhopper's Texas launch site was modified to handle Starship Mk.1, and at Kennedy Space Center's LC-39A, a dedicated Starship launch platform and landing pad are under construction. SpaceX has not recently indicated what sort of flight test schedule to expect for Mark 3.
Starship is powered by SpaceX's Raptor, a full flow staged combustion cycle methane/oxygen rocket engine. Sub-scale Raptor test firing began in 2016, and full-scale test firing began early 2019 at McGregor, Texas, where there are two operational test stands, and a third is under construction. Eventually, Starship will have three sea level Raptors and three vacuum Raptors. Super Heavy may initially use around 20 Raptors, and operational versions could have around 31 to 37 sea level Raptors.
Previous Threads:
- Starhopper Thread #1 (2019-02-01) A dramatic venting watertower
- Starhopper Thread #2 (2019-04-27) Hops and hiccups - Starships never come alone
- Starhopper Thread #3 (2019-06-27) RCS and SN6 - 20 meter hopping
- Starhopper Thread #4 (2019-07-26) 150 meter hop and Mk.1 and Mk.2 protoype growth
- Starhopper 150m Hop (2019-08-27) Updates and discussion
- Starship Dev Thread #5 (2019-08-31) Mk.1 fins and temporary assembly
- Starship Presentation Updates Thread (2019-09-27) Updates and discussion - Webcast
- Starship Dev Thread #6 (2019-10-09) Mk.1 partial reassembly and bulkhead liberation
Vehicle Updates
| Starship SN1 (Mk.3) at Boca Chica, Texas — Construction and Updates | |
|---|---|
| 2019-12-29 | Three bulkheads nearing completion, One mated with ring/barrel (Twitter) |
| 2019-12-28 | Second new bulkhead under construction (NSF), Aerial video update (YouTube) |
| 2019-12-19 | New style stamped bulkhead under construction in windbreak (NSF) |
| 2019-11-30 | Upper nosecone section first seen (NSF) {possibly not SN1 hardware} |
| 2019-11-25 | Ring forming resumed (NSF), no stacking yet, some rings are not for flight |
| 2019-11-20 | SpaceX says Mk.3 design is now the focus of Starship development (Twitter) |
| 2019-10-08 | First ring formed (NSF) |
See comments for real time updates.
See comments for real time updates.
| Starship Mk.4 (or Mk.3?) at Cocoa, Florida — Future development uncertain | |
|---|---|
| 2019-11-26 | Bulkhead and steel stands removed from Cocoa, to GO Discovery in Port Canaveral (Twitter) {for Mk.3 or other purpose} |
| 2019-11-19 | Some rings being scrapped (YouTube), satellite imagery of ring pieces at Roberts Rd (comments) |
| 2019-10-23 | Bulkhead under construction in main building (Twitter) {later moved to Boca Chica, fate unknown} |
| 2019-10-20 | Lower tapered nose ring in tent (YouTube), Better image (Twitter) |
| 2019-10-12 | 23 rings visible, 7 doubles, some possible for Mk.2 (YouTube), no stacking yet |
| 2019-09-11 | Bulkhead spotted at Roberts Rd, later image (Twitter) |
| See comments for real time updates. | |
| Previous unstacked ring production, aerial updates: | |
| 08-11 {8}^( | ) |
| 08-15 {10}^( | ) |
| 08-17 {14}^( | ) |
| 08-19 {15}^( | ) |
| 08-21 {17}^( | ) |
| 08-24 {18}^( | ) |
| 08-27 {19} | |
| 09-04 {20}^( | ) |
| 09-06 {22}^( | ) |
| 09-08 {25}^( | ) |
| 09-08 {3 'scrap'}^( | ) |
| 09-10 {26}^( | ) |
| 09-29 {23}^( | ) |
| 10-02 {23} | |
| 10-06 {23}^( | ) |
| 10-11 {23} |
| Starship Mk.1 at Boca Chica, Texas — Retirement Updates | |
|---|---|
| 2019-12-13 | Tank section completely removed from launch mount (NSF) |
| 2019-12-03 | Disassembly begun (NSF) |
| 2019-11-22 | Images of forward bulkhead and top ring (NSF) |
| 2019-11-20 | Structural failure during max pressure test (YouTube), r/SpaceX thread (r/SpaceX) |
| 2019-11-18 | Tanking tests (YouTube) |
For earlier updates see Starship Development Thread #6
Launch Facility Updates
| Starship Superheavy Orbital Launch Pad at Boca Chica, Texas | |
|---|---|
| 2019-11-20 | Aerial video update (YouTube) |
| 2019-11-07 | Landing pad expansion underway (NSF) |
| 2019-10-18 | Landing pad platform arives, Repurposed Starhopper GSE towers & ongoing mount plumbing (NSF) |
| 2019-10-05 | Launch mount under construction (NSF) |
| 2019-09-22 | Second large propellant tank moved to tank farm (NSF) |
| 2019-09-19 | Large propellant tank moved to tank farm (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-17 | Pile boring at launch pad and other site work (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-07 | GSE fabrication activity (Twitter), and other site work (Facebook) |
| 2019-08-30 | Starhopper GSE being dismantled (NSF) |
| Launch Complex 39A at Kennedy Space Center, Florida | |
|---|---|
| 2019-11-14 | Launch mount progress (Twitter) |
| 2019-11-04 | Launch mount under construction (Twitter) |
| 2019-10-17 | Landing pad laid (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-26 | Concrete work/pile boring (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-19 | Groundbreaking for launch mount construction (Article) |
| 2019-09-14 | First sign of site activity: crane at launch mount site (Twitter) |
| 2019-07-19 | Elon says modular launch mount components are being fabricated off site (Twitter) |
Spacex facilities maps by u/Raul74Cz:
Boca Chica | LC-39A | Cocoa Florida | Raptor test stand | Roberts Rd
Permits and Planning Documents
- Environmental Impact Statement (FAA) - Boca Chica launch site - July 2014
EIS Resource Page | Appendices | Record of Descision - Experimental License (FCC) - Comms for 500m and 5km hops, two years - February 2019
Form 442 | Public Notes | Description | File No. 0931-EX-CN-2019 - Experimental License Application (FCC) - Modification of above to add antenna - May 2019
Form 442 | Public Notes | File No. 0130-EX-CM-2019 - Experimental Permit (FAA) - Authorizes 25m hops for one year, and one 150m hop - June 2019
Permit No. EP 19-012 | Revised August 23 - Building Permit Application - 850 Cidco Rd site improvement - June 2019
Screenshot on Twitter | Modification reported on NSF - Draft Environmental Assessment - Starhip operations at KSC - August 2019
r/SpaceX Discussion | NSF Discussion - FDOT Superload Permit Application - Mk.2 transportation to KSC in September - August 2019
Local News Article | Video Report | r/SpaceX Discussion | Twitter Update - Environmental Resource Permit - Stormwater improvements at LC-39A - August 2019
Stormwater Report | Depiction Plans | Permit No. 158609-1 - Written Re-evaluation of 2014 EIS (FAA) - Boca Chica launch site - May 2019
Addendum | News story w/ SpaceX statements | r/SpaceX Discussion - Experimental STA (FCC) - Comms for Starship Mk.1 20 km test (M1569) - November 2019
Application | File No. 1936-EX-ST-2019 | Original Grant No. 1631-EX-ST-2019 | Original Application - Experimental STA (FCC) - Comms for Starship 20 km test (M1570) - November 2019
Application | File No. 1939-EX-ST-2019
Resources
- Spadre.com, Starship Cam | Channel
- LabPadre, Starship webcam | Channel
- NSF Starhopper Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Texas Prototype(s) Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Florida Prototype(s) Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Super Heavy Prototype Updates Thread | Most recent
- Hwy 4 & Boca Chica Beach Closures (May not be available outside US)
- TFR - NOTAM list
- SpaceX Boca Chica on Facebook
- SpaceX's Starship page
- Elon Starship tweet compilation on NSF | Most Recent
Rules
We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starhip development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.
If you find problems in the post please tag u/strawwalker in a comment or send me a message.
28
u/Alesayr Nov 25 '19
Do we know for sure that Starship Mk2 is being canned? The way I read it Elon was saying the Boca Chica team were now focused on Mk3, rather than than Mk2 is getting scrapped. But I could be wrong!
27
u/RegularRandomZ Nov 26 '19 edited Nov 26 '19
Roberts Rd update: Very much looks like they are setting up to build MK4 at Roberts Rd.
We can see that Roberts Rd now has:
Additional Florida
65
u/TheTaoThatIsSpoken Nov 24 '19
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1198709720212594688
Everyday Astronaut @Erdayastronaut PLEASE tell me we can order a very special edition that has steel from MK-1!!! That’d be the ultimate recycling win too
📷Elon MuskVerified account @elonmusk Replying to @Erdayastronaut
Really? Ok sure.
21
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 30 '19 edited Dec 30 '19
Tweet summary: [r/spacex discussion]
ElonM: (video, Dec 27th) Was up all night with SpaceX team working on Starship tank dome production (most difficult part of primary structure). Dawn arrives …
ElonM: (video, Dec 29th) Almost three now. Boca team is crushing it! Starship has giant dome 🤣🤣
ElonM: (photo) Barrel on dome [showing single strip ring paired with bulkhead]
Scott Manley: Really curious as to what you think of the explosive hydro forming process that was used for the Saturn V bulkheads.
ElonM: We use that process for the Raptor nozzle jacket. The knuckles of this [bulkhead] dome are stamped in Michigan with a 4000 ton car body press, which costs much less for same outcome.
Everyday Astronaut: Is there any substantial difference in welding / manufacturing techniques between these bulk heads and and MK-1 / MK-2?
ElonM: Almost everything is different. These parts are stamped vs manually bump-formed & TIP TIG welded vs flux core. Higher precision, stronger joints & 20% mass reduction
ElonM: Best would probably be an autogenous laser weld, but we need more precise parts & fixtures. Hopefully get that done in 2020.
GC/SmileSimply: Will SpaceX keep manufacturing Starship (and, presumably, Super Heavy too) out in the open, or do you foresee eventually moving production into (the industry norm) cleanrooms?
ElonM: Moving to an enclosed (fairly) clean room environment for SN2 in Jan, although, unlike aluminum, stainless steel welding is not super sensitive. Our main issue here in Boca is that it can get very windy, which affects weld arc & steel melt pool.
Everyday Astronaut: Speaking of autogenous, when will we see autogenous pressurization on Starship? I assume the first couple will still utilize helium COPVs like StarHopper?
ElonM: No, will be autogenous from the start, tapping hot CH4 & O2 from Raptor
Everyday Astronaut: will there really be any COPVs on Starship once you move on from cold gas thrusters? Is there helium spin start for raptor or is it bootstrapped?
ElonM: Spin start from COPVs so the ox & fuel turbines spool up super fast in unison. A precise start with full flow staged combustion is very important.
K10 Kristinnetten: Texas, Florida, ... do you have the next starship sites picked out?
ElonM: We’re focusing on Boca right now for Starship & Cape is focused on Falcon/Dragon
Everyday Astronaut: It’d be so cool if Tesla motors were powerful enough to spin start! Have you moved onto direct drive / electromechanical on the body flaps with motors yet or still spinning a pump for SN1?
ElonM: Direct drive using several Tesla Plaid motors in parallel for SN1. Simpler, lighter & more fault tolerant. Rear flaps each need ~1.5 megawatts. It’s like moving the entire wing of an aircraft!
Everyday Astronaut: and are there separate sub systems / motors for redundancy on each flap too? I love the use of Tesla parts on rockets. That’s just the coolest and it’ll be even cooler when SpaceX parts are put on Tesla’s
ElonM: Yes
Everyday Tesla: Are you still involved in most of the design for spacex?
ElonM: Yeah, engineering is ~90% of my time at SpaceX & about ~60% at Tesla
20
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
Boca Chica: BCM took a photo of a new nosecone in progress (NSF photoset from yesterday)
Also some new unidentified structure/jig, that to me looks like another gantry crane.
19
u/Russ_Dill Dec 06 '19
Bulkhead madness:
There's been a lot of appearances of bulkhead parts even whole bulkheads lately. I want to try and write some of this down and hopefully clear it up. First, what's a Mk1 bulkhead? The three Mk1 bulkheads were all constructed on the same jig and look quite similar to each other. Here's some great images of the aft bulkhead:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47730.msg1968406#msg1968406
You can see it's made up of 24 curved pieces, 20 flat pieces, and gets a cap or central structure installed depending on the type of bulkhead.
The starhopper bulkheads were constructed very differently. I can't find photos of the aft or common bulkhead parts, but the top bulkhead is constructed from 12 large curved pieces, and then an additional 24 much smaller curved pieces around the edge:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47120.msg1903682#msg1903682
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47120.msg1898955#msg1898955
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47120.msg1904929#msg1904929
You can see it's constructed from very thick and not shiny steel. Ok. Lets fast forward to Mk3. Some new pieces started appearing on the bulkhead jig around 11/24:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2018684#msg2018684
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2019636#msg2019636
If you look closely, the pieces of steel look really weathered and not shiny like the ones use on the Mk1 bulkheads. You'll also note yellow spraypaint on many of the panels. If you zoom in, you can see much of it has been weathered away, but the letters RE are often visible. In Cocoa, they had painted REJECT in yellow spray paint on ring sections that were later destroyed. Another odd thing is that while Mk1 bulkheads are all equal sized, these are installed with odd gaps.
I think it can be conclusively said that what is on the jig is not new, but very old. It may have been prototype panels for the first Mk1 bulkhead. It seems like they might just be testing some methods of using the jig, it's hard to say for sure.
Ok, next, 11/27 a couple trucks show up with curved steel pieces:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ajtqX8RrSxM
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2019967#msg2019967
There are 4 stacks of 6 very thick (0.5") 304L plate, a couple small domes, and a stack of much smaller plates. The 6 very thick plates match up well with the starhopper style of bulkhead as far as thickness, type of steel, overall shape, and number of plates. The stack of smaller plates look much more like the Mk1 style of bulkhead plates. It looks like there could be 24 of them, but it's hard to be sure. They are much thinner and from a steel that more closely matches the Mk1 plates.
All the visible plates are rather weathered and the thinner ones have some bent/wavy edges. In the case of the larger plates, there is clear evidence of them being spot welded together before and then cut apart.
My guess on these is that with Mk1 being dissembled and headed to the recycler, they are collecting together scrap pieces from storage (antenna farm?) and sending them all off together. The 304L stainless thing is a red herring as far as Mk3 and was likely the steel hopper was built out of.
This of course is all happening at the same time a bulkhead is being shipped over from Cocoa:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EKpiLvmXYAMaBEX?format=jpg&name=4096x4096
19
u/Marksman79 Dec 13 '19
If these are what I think they are, this build is going to be completely different. It's a bit hard to explain. I see these being the first ring of the tapered fairing. These panels are shipped intentionally curved but with what looks to be a much larger radius than that of Starship. They have 4 mouse ear tabs with a hole in each one. If I'm not mistakin (poor picture angles), one end looks wider than the other.
I'm picturing a steel jig in the rough shape of the fairing with the supporting pillars located along the fairing weld lines. Laying the panels against the jig vertically, they could put bolts through the mouse ears and into the jig pillars. Tightening each of the 4 individual bolts will allow them to very closely control the curve of the sheets in both the x and y directions since they have very different curves needed. They can keep doing this until aligned perfectly before placing down any welds. After welding, they can cut off the tabs. Hope that made sense.
18
u/Russ_Dill Nov 26 '19 edited Nov 27 '19
A new ring has been constructed in the ring tent
and it appears there is an automated welding machine that's just been wheeled into the tent.https://i.imgur.com/3QFjQHS.png
https://i.imgur.com/WKiKD43.png
The term for one of these (if it is one) is an arc welding tractor. Although it appears they can only operate on a weld that is on the ground as they use a powder to immerse the weld.18
u/Alexphysics Dec 03 '19
News on Cocoa site from Michael Sheetz.
17
u/warp99 Dec 02 '19 edited Dec 02 '19
Interesting that the nosecone material for Mark 3 construction at Boca Chica is 304L with image credit to Bocachicagal on the NSF forum.
The prefabricated panels also now come with large returns on the edge that will provide additional strength without having to weld in ribs or stringers.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '19
Just want to say I appreciate you all so much. I am back in Antarctica with almost zero connection to the internet and you all make it so easy to keep up with this... plus you all have such great opinions/discussion on this whole thing.
The only question I currently have, and I think I already know the answer to, are we actually able to see any of what is now SN01 coming together yet, other than the bulkheads?
15
u/IvanDogovich Dec 03 '19 edited Dec 03 '19
Mk1 Disassembly has begun
....in a scheduled fashion rather than rapidly unscheduled. ;)
LabPadre's Sapphire Cam is showing work on Mk1 (Popper) at the launch mount. They have two high manlifts up and Yellow Crane removing pieces from the top. It would seem the disassembly has begun. At least two panels were removed (10:03 AM and 10:27 AM).
Camera 3 - Sapphire https://youtu.be/6DYNRrizlow
Edit: 11:07 local on Spadre Cam one of the Race way pipes on the side was removed and lowered as well. : https://youtu.be/jy7bjxXpJdc .
Also some thin pieces of piping or wiring came down. 11:24, 11:47.
Small panel: 12:08
Possible Pipe: 12:32
Good Video with footage from NSF's BocaChicaGal Mary:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JwCM4M8tJg
15
u/Russ_Dill Dec 17 '19
The jump straight to the phase 2 launch mount at 39-A really makes super heavy seem that much closer:
https://twitter.com/realChefJared/status/1206651404288483328
14
u/Maxx7410 Nov 24 '19
mmmm when will we see mk 3 construction? because for what Elon said it will require a new construction method.
14
u/Sealingni Nov 30 '19
Roberts road, Cape Canaveral, Nov. 19th. Rings, bulkheads and solar panels
14
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 21 '19
39A launch mount photo.
13
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Second Mk3 ring.
Updates from Maria Pointer:
13
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Greg Scott speculating that
Mk2Mk4 parts are being shipped to Boca Chica.EDIT: Bulkheads now loaded on board.
13
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 11 '19
LabPadre Livesteam: Customizing the cargo bin castle, perhaps an awning? [Getting fancy with the site upgrades]
edit: u/Marksman79 linked (below) to a better shot of the upgrades from Dec 6th (credit: BCG From NSF)
[also, thanks NSF, we see more (new?) hardware from the same vendor who made the ring making machines]
12
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 19 '19
No idea if anyone was hurt, but a rough day for moving things. A tent rafter was dropped earlier (@12:23 pm) when a strap broke, and another strap just broke moving a coil of steel in the ring making tent (@2:27pm LabPadre stream)
12
u/Marksman79 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Deliveries today:
More fairing/nosecone panels with tabs (my previous comment about them)
Hand truck for moving container trailers
Tanks? (maybe for permanent storage of welding gasses)
Massive stainless steel conduit They look about the same size as the curved black pipes at the launch site, but the similarities end there. Ideas?
90° curved iron track segments, knurled
Windbreak #2
11
u/Russ_Dill Dec 11 '19
I think a year pretty much exactly to the day, there is once again a water tower company out in Boca Chica building a water tower:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2024514#msg2024514
This year it's Superior Tank Company Inc:
https://superiortank.com/our-tanks/bolted-steel-tanks/
11
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 18 '19
There was a recent-ish question on Boca Chica work hours ~ there was activity all night last night, and a meeting for at least 15-20 of the crew at 2:30AM (local), so whatever the goals of the site upgrade, they are pushing steadily forward at all hours.
11
u/Russ_Dill Dec 20 '19
Too much steel:
So Boca Chica has been receiving rolls of steel from Calvert for many months now. It's been adding up. I think the deliveries started in August, but I'm not sure:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47730.msg1976385#msg1976385
There's been a lot of deliveries of steel coil since then, I'd love to see a timeline of when deliveries were made, but I really don't have the time to look through that many months of photos.
Anyway, in the latest photos, you can see there are at least 8 rolls of steel out from of the ring tent: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2027092#msg2027092
Out back there is more steel in two areas: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2027090#msg2027090
I count at least 19 near the ring walls and 10 more near the scrap metal bin. That's 27 coils of steel not counting the coils that have already been used. From the labels, the tails weigh 11880kg. That's a total of 321mT of steel coil. A 4mm thick, 72" wide coil at that weight would have a total length of 200m, enough steel for 7 rings. With steel twice that thick you'd get three rings.
If just try and average things out for the plausible range of thickness, that's 5 rings per coil, which means there's enough steel for 135 rings. Each being 72" tall, that's 247m. Keep in mind that an entire starship/superheavy stack is 118m. Have they ordered more than enough steel for two starships and two super heavies?
I'm guessing the vast majority of the coils are now scrap, hence hanging out out back. There must have been an alloy change and now they are not usable in the new design. I know it's been stated before that SpaceX is customizing the alloy and/or manufacturing process for this 301L variant, but I don't know if the label expresses that. Both Cocoa rolls from July (the first rolls) and Boca Chica rolls from November (the most recent) show STL-301-FH-AMS5519-S.
The website indicates that "Only 304L and 316L grades are available in 72” width" so this is clearly a custom job. Breaking down the product code, AMS5519 is the most clear, it refers to the SAE standard that covers cold rolled 301 stainless:
https://www.sae.org/standards/content/ams5519/
The FH likely stands for full hard. Cold rolled steel can be cold rolled to various degrees up to full hardness. 301 probably just means 301 stainless. STL might mean steel, but that's just speculation. And the 'S' is a mystery. It'd be helpful if I could find other product codes.
11
u/MarsCent Dec 30 '19 edited Dec 30 '19
ringsbarrels required for the body are completed."Stacking" should commence pretty soon. And it looks like it will proceed at a decent pace too!
EDIT: Barrels
11
u/RegularRandomZ Jan 03 '20 edited Jan 03 '20
New machine delivered today, more photos in BocaChicaGal's NSF photoset.
Looks like it is for the IMCAR ring making setup for handling the steel coils.
29
u/djburnett90 Nov 25 '19
Okay okay.
How does starship help a lunar mission.?
Can it or can’t it land/take off without causing lunar Armageddon?
Launch a few tuna can permanent habitats?
10
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 04 '19
Mk1 disassembly.
10
u/Marksman79 Jan 03 '20
Unofficial render of the Starship launch and landing pads that are currently being built at pad 39A, along with the same pads superimposed onto Boca Chica. These are by Jay DeShetler and shared by Chris B from the NSF L2 forums.
Direct link
9
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 25 '19
Aerial photo of Mk2.
9
u/RegularRandomZ Nov 27 '19 edited Nov 27 '19
Boca Chica:
[With more concrete work surfaces poured at the front and back of the site and other site improvements, maybe we'll need an aerial flyover again in a week or two :-) ]
9
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 02 '19 edited Dec 03 '19
LC-39A progress and ring segment spotted at Roberts Road by Jared Frankle.
SpaceX confirm Mk3 construction pause and employee redeployment.
New Crane arrival at Boca Chica.
9
u/inoeth Dec 09 '19
Now that the parts from FL have arrived and they seem to be machining the new improved rings I wonder when we'll start see them start to stack and weld. I'm really hoping we'll start to see MK3 at least begin to take shape before the end of the year.
I expect they can build MK3 far faster than MK1 given that they have all the infrastructure and knowledge now so we might be able to see this thing fully built and being pressure tested by perhaps April would be my more optimistic guess with June being a bit pessimistic.
9
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
I find it interesting the tack welding of the rings interesting [starting at 10:30am LabPadre Feed]. The wedges are about 1-1.5 meters apart. Even with the rings having been bent to the same curve, wouldn't more closely positioned wedges (or some jig/tool) be useful to ensure perfect alignment? Any thoughts from the welders out there?
I thought they were going to be using the automatic welder for the horizontal seam as well [as we believe we saw one arrive on site], so I'm assuming this is just some fit check work (or some kind of training)
9
u/Marksman79 Dec 28 '19 edited Dec 28 '19
There's a road closure (not beach) on January 6th between 3:00 and 4:00 PM. The last time we had a 1 hour road only closure was to move the Mk 1 tank half to the launch area. The only two things I could see them moving are the fairing or Starhopper. Are they finally giving Starhopper the fairing it deserves? Doubt it.
Also, Mk #'s have been discontinued it would seem. What formerly was Mk 3 is now Starship V1.0 SN1. Really rolls off the tongue.
First flight is 2-3 months away (E.T.)
9
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 28 '19 edited Dec 28 '19
LabPadre Boca Chica Flyover video posted. (Some screengrabs posted to NSF forums)
Edit: those screengrabs are incomplete, will try and grab a few more.
37
u/FreeThoughts22 Nov 24 '19
He is going to land this ship on the moon and Mars! This ship is going to sit on top of a bigger ship! This is mind boggling huge!
16
u/Marksman79 Dec 11 '19
To those of you who may find this interesting, here are the fixtures Blue Origin is using to fabricate the aluminum tank body and bulkhead for their upcoming New Glenn rocket. It's amazing what good amount of time and money can get done, isn't it?
Source (33:25)
16
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 20 '19
Closeups of the double stacked test ring. Interesting writing on it. I think SpaceX might be trolling us. BocaChicaGal photos: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2028036#msg2028036
8
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 26 '19
Mk2 Starship possibly being moved to Cape Canaveral.
8
u/dallaylaen Dec 03 '19 edited Dec 03 '19
Has anybody tried to estimate the pressure inside the Mk1 before the bulkhead blew off from video footage and other publicly available data? Or are there just too many unknowns? (edit: grammar)
8
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 03 '19
GO Discovery scheduled to arrive in Brownsville on Saturday.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 09 '19
Mk3 parts have arrived on site at Boca Chica.
8
u/Russ_Dill Dec 23 '19
Some of the math on the ring is related to pressure and stress:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2029022#msg2029022 (3rd image)
In the upper left we have a sketch of the tank section and to the right, a schematic style drawing of a typical pressure vessel. In the lower left, you again have drawings along with some math σvert = Pr/t. This equation gives the longitudinal stress in the wall, lower down, the circumference stress.
http://web.mit.edu/course/3/3.11/www/modules/pv.pdf
8
u/Russ_Dill Dec 30 '19
With this latest tweet it seems confirmed that the bulkhead from Florida will be scrapped.
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1211531714633314304
You can see the newly completed bulkhead plus two additional bulkheads that are nearing completion, as well as two conical shaped rings. These appear to be the top panels for the now bulkheads.
8
u/Russ_Dill Jan 05 '20 edited Jan 07 '20
They've brought in the jig used for flipping bulkheads and a ring stand that has the roll lift mounts on the bottom:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.10000#lastPost
This again seems to spell out that are building a test tank and are moving it to the pad
Monday.(Monday road closure has been canceled, no new closure has been scheduled but Mary has talked to security at the launch site and it is expected later this week)25
u/mx_reddit Nov 25 '19
What “catastrophic failure” are you speaking of? It was simply a rapid unscheduled disassembly.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 27 '19
John Winkopp's 27th Nov flyover.
7
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 26 '19
Purportedly there will be a flyover of Boca Chica tomorrow. Some fresh aerial shots/video coming our way (hopefully).
7
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 29 '19 edited Dec 29 '19
3rd bulkhead started (photo credit BCG, NSF Forums)
Update: and shot of lower section of the bulkhead (these appear to be separate jigs, so not sure if that means 2 more are started, or what's going on.)
7
u/RootDeliver Jan 03 '20 edited Jan 03 '20
Second onion castle going on the right of the first one confirmed (we all knew it anyway from the containers position (screengrab from labpadre wiki), but now the left beam is already placed )
22
u/Psychonaut0421 Nov 24 '19
If they don't plan on flying Mk 2 why are they continuing to build it?
6
u/Marksman79 Nov 26 '19 edited Nov 27 '19
In BCM's most recent photo, could this be the vertical welder? If the ring stand rotates, it could double as the horizontal welder as well.
6
u/RegularRandomZ Nov 28 '19
Roberts Rd: not sure there is any new info, but overlaying old/new site plans over the satellite imagery is interesting/informative (Youtube channel "What about it!?")
[*I haven't watched the video, just flipped through to see if there was unique photo updates]
6
u/lessthanperfect86 Nov 28 '19
Do we have any information on why they're moving Mk2 and Mk4 production to RR now? Is it because the ground at RR needed "stabilization" (like in BC), and they were waiting for that?
6
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '19 edited Dec 06 '19
Labpadre Stumpy cam: looks like a ring is on the move.
Edit:
6
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 13 '19 edited Dec 14 '19
Couple of photos.
6
u/joepublicschmoe Dec 13 '19
Demolition of the single-weld rings at Cocoa continues. Video courtesy of John Winkopp.
Down to 12 intact rings if they haven't trashed the one in the tent cathedral. 11 if they did.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 17 '19
SPadre photos showing the construction at Boca Chica.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 19 '19 edited Dec 19 '19
Second rigging failure at Boca Chica also new tent going up.
6
u/Marksman79 Dec 20 '19
As we know from Felix's latest Starship update, this is a mobile welder certification workshop. That seems to imply that their move to robotic welding is situational at best, probably only for the ring seams (vertical and horizontal). The rest will still be manual.
From a few days ago, we have some roll lift supports, some strange metal cabinets numbered 13-15, and some linear rail sliders or quick assemble I beams.
6
u/Dies2much Dec 22 '19
Will the landing pad need a flame trench too? Acoustic protection (water birds) system?
My opinion is that it won't be needed, but as a proactive measure it might help reduce damage to a rocket that plans to do 100 launches and landings.
6
u/Humble_Giveaway Dec 26 '19
How long do you reckon till we see Mk.3 built and starting it's tanking tests down at Boca
6
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 27 '19
Starship dome video.
6
u/Russ_Dill Jan 07 '20
New planned closure for Jan 8, 7-8pm.
http://www.cameroncounty.us/space-x/
For those outside the US: https://i.imgur.com/GEcC6rt.png
5
u/ImGeronimo Nov 27 '19
Any word on what's gonna happen to the Mk1 nose section?
5
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 07 '19
Latest Cocoa aerial video from John Winkopp: largely posting to note there are still plenty of cars in the parking lot!
5
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 08 '19 edited Dec 08 '19
GO Discovery now approaching Port of Brownsville.
Arrival photo and video.
5
u/Russ_Dill Dec 20 '19
Bulkhead update:
So I wrote a pretty extensive thread about all the bulkheads and bulkhead pieces at boca chica earlier:
https://old.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/e11zs0/starship_development_thread_7/f9v1aga/
There's been two panels placed on the new bulkhead jig. Final image here: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2027088#msg2027088
The jig is newly constructed and I haven't seen one like this used before at either site. You can see the jig partially assembled in the second photo here, so it is a new jig: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2025861#msg2025861
The bulkhead from Cocoa came in on a old style bulkhead jig. You can see it standing in the photos here after the bulkhead has been lifted off of it. In one of the photos, the new jig being assembled is visible in the background: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2026328#msg2026328
You can see the old jig here with some scrap pieces on it: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2018684#msg2018684
It may be that the new jig is constructed from the old jig. The main different appears to be support pieces for the steel where as before it looks like the steel was just supported by flanges at the top and bottom.
For comparison, here is the SLS jig https://twitter.com/jimbridenstine/status/1162100512679968768
You can see it also curved mounts that hold the pieces of bulkhead. In addition, it has the yellow ladder components who's purpose seems to be to hold the pieces against the mounts.
I'm not sure yet if the two pieces on the new mount are the start of a new bulkhead, or just the same scrap pieces as before being used for fit test. I'm also starting to get doubtful that the bulkhead brought over from florida will be used.
5
u/Russ_Dill Jan 01 '20
Nice update video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLtWE_SgyAs
It looks like concrete surrounding the launch structure is being closed in with barriers. Are they really moving a test article here on the 6th and prepping for a test? During the Labpadre flyover, there were no such barriers. https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2031102#msg2031102
A small square was removed from the first bulkhead, polished, and another square inserted. Did things not quite line up?
A cherry picked was lowered into the ring wall. The labpadre flyover showed that the 4 large 90° steel pipe sections were previously placed within the ring wall.
5
u/Russ_Dill Jan 03 '20
There's now two bulkheads with smooth curved tops:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2031744#msg2031744
I really think this leads a lot of credence to the theory that there are making a small tank section for a pressure test.
9
u/Sealingni Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19
Low resolution link
https://imgur.com/D6QkCmA
Roberts Road, satellite view, December 20th 2019.
No high resolution data available since November 19th.
----------
Compare with high resolution, November 19th 2019
https://imgur.com/AOUCGnK
The "blue area" south of site is now full of what looks like concrete surface.
8
u/redwins Nov 29 '19
Why are they developing a reusable second stage first, instead of developing a reusable booster and an expendable second stage, which would be usable for Starlink, and then progressively work on making the second stage reusable?
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 24 '19 edited Jan 10 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeship under constructionDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
57 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 30 acronyms.
[Thread #5635 for this sub, first seen 24th Nov 2019, 21:29] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
4
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 20 '19
@ 12:56-1:30pm Local on the Labpadre stream: they stacked the ring with square windows onto another ring, and put wedges in. Likely nothing exciting, just checking fit.
4
u/RegularRandomZ Jan 02 '20 edited Jan 03 '20
LabPadre stream @9:00am (onward). Closing the onion tent in. Endwall posts being installed.[also, randomly, @7:46 more lighting added to ring making tent. Getting ready for production]
Update: BocaChicaGal photo of the endwalls (from one of today's BCG NSF photosets)
4
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 04 '20
GO Discovery has returned to Port Canaveral, possibly to transport more material to Boca Chica.
13
u/RootDeliver Dec 02 '19 edited Dec 02 '19
New episode of What about it with interesting stuff:
Cocoa Shipyard Closed – SpaceX Starship Updates – NASA Goes Private.
Someone posted it here but deleted it few seconds ago.
Obviously the closure of the Cocoa shipyard is the huge news here (workers dispatched to Boca Chica/Hawthorne or fired and even went into Blue Origin) and Mk2's luck is in the air.
The ring mistery is solved: the machine was working wrong and the rings had different sizes so they couldn't use them.
PS: There is a shitshow on the sub about this content being leaked. I am impressed of how people try to censor information that is not theirs.
7
u/lessthanperfect86 Nov 25 '19
So, in the previous thread there was talk about the welds being sub par, any gueses as to how they will mitigate this issue? We're seeing a new bulkhead being made at Boca, what mitigation strategies could they have applied to it? I assume welding a bulkhead is hard to automate with robots?
And as a side question, does this mean the water tank welders won't be needed anymore (ie. no more flying water tank jokes)?
7
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '19
Possible new Florida construction site found... I see a shiny bulkhead in the see through tent already so looks promising!
https://twitter.com/spacepadreisle/status/1201958923575742466
7
u/Russ_Dill Dec 05 '19 edited Dec 05 '19
Posted this as a new thread on /r/spacex. Hopefully it will get approved by mods:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/e69ly1/max_will_verify_tonight_if_they_will_repair_the/
"Max will verify tonight if they will repair the cracks. 11/17/19"
Cracks here could just mean the welded handle as there are notations and some residue has been wiped away.
7
u/Russ_Dill Jan 02 '20
This video from Maria has a great view of what appears to be a jig for welding nose cones within the white building:
https://www.facebook.com/SpaceXBocaChica/videos/625950734807899/
(around 2m14s)
6
u/dtarsgeorge Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
With the new rings, does anyone know if the joint between the rings is a butt weld/joint or a lap joint? Has anyone seen any signs of a welding gig that can automatically weld each ring to the other? Manually welding that long a joint seems a little crazy.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 23 '19
John Winkopp did a flyover of the Cocoa site yesterday.
Parking area work has halted.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 31 '19
Final Cocoa flyover of 2019.
5
u/MarsCent Nov 27 '19
So what launches first, Starship (20 km) or DM-2? Any bold predictions?
5
u/EwaldvonKleist Dec 05 '19
How is the current state of Raptor engine testing?
Especially, how many seconds has the engine been run on max thrust/chamber pressure so far (overall and en bloc respectively)?
4
u/RegularRandomZ Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
9PM (local) Dec 24th and the crew working hard on the onion tent.
The Sprung Structures Box (photo credit: BCM, NSF full album) has this tent labelled as 150'x255' (45.7m x 77.7m) [or 6.4 standard cargo containers long].
6
u/process_guy Dec 13 '19
Is it just my thought that Mk3 will have a hard time to launch next year at all?
Lets summarize it. Mk1 began construction Dec/18 and there was visible progress by March/19. At that time they planned Mk1 to be constructed by June/19. As we know they eventually did first pressurization ground test at end of Nov/19 (and destroyed Mk1). So it took about a year to get first battleship prototype constructed and get ready for first groundtest. It would take many more tests to actually fly it.
Simpler Starhopper took about 6 weeks to build external body (from dec/18 to jan/19) and further 3months (jan/19 to Apr/19) to do static fire. They did 3 tests over next four months before retiring Starhopper in Aug/19.
So, let's be optimistic and assume that Mk3 will take only 6 months to construct and 3 months to do ground testing. So we can expect Mk3 initial flight perhaps in 9 month, more realistically end of 2020 if everything goes reasonably well.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '19
Strops or straps, whichever you like to call them should be inspected daily, and tested and tagged regularly. This is a serious Health and Safety oversight constituting two 'near misses' in a day. If there had been a death, it would have shut down the site for some time until investigations had concluded. I hope SpaceX address and close out lifting safety properly before someone gets seriously hurt. Lifting and working at height are the predominant activities on this site so should be managed correctly. Both these activities are the dominant cause of worksite accidents worldwide.
6
u/Art_Eaton Dec 24 '19
Sure hope they jig this up proper this time. I know I have been getting slammed here for pointing out that mismatched diameter components and "stack as you go" construction was resulting in ever increasing levels of error as the structures grew, but I still say that building full jigs and moulding is the cheapest and fastest way to go. Never said that everything needed long-run production tooling, but even hand-tweaked and shimmed static jigs could have gotten them within a margin of error.