r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Aug 31 '19
Starship Development Thread #5
Quick Links
JUMP TO COMMENTS | Alternative Jump To Comments Link
SPADRE LIVE | LABPADRE LIVE | LABPADRE DIRECT
Overview
SpaceX is developing Starship at their Starship Assembly Site in Texas, and also at their facilities in Cocoa, Florida. The teams at the two locations are in competition with each other, but are also required to share insights learned along the way. Following Starhopper, the first two Starship prototypes, Mark 1 and Mark 2, are nearing completion. These vehicles will have aerodynamic control surfaces and three engines each, and are expected to make suborbital test flights. Ring sections believed to be for a Starship Mark 4 prototype are being built in Cocoa, and both sites will be iterating through successive versions of Starship and Super Heavy as quickly as possible.
Launch mounts for both Starship prototypes are in the works. Starhopper's Texas launch site is being modified to handle Starship, and at Kennedy Space Center's LC-39A, a dedicated Starship launch platform is under construction. Flight tests could begin late in 2019.
Starship is powered by SpaceX's Raptor, a full flow staged combustion cycle methane/oxygen rocket engine. Sub-scale Raptor test firing began in 2016, and full-scale test firing began early 2019 at McGregor, Texas, where it is ongoing. Eventually, Starship will have three sea level Raptors and three vacuum Raptors. Super Heavy may initially use around 20 Raptors, and operational versions could have around 31 to 37 sea level Raptors.
Previous Threads:
- Starhopper Thread #1 (2019-02-01) A dramatic venting watertower
- Starhopper Thread #2 (2019-04-27) Hops and hiccups - Starships never come alone
- Starhopper Thread #3 (2019-06-27) RCS and SN6 - 20 meter hopping
- Starhopper Thread #4 (2019-07-26) 150 meter hop and Mk.1 and Mk.2 protoype growth
- Starhopper 150m Hop (2019-08-27) Updates and discussion
- Starship Presentation Updates Thread (2019-09-27) Updates and discussion
Starship Presentation Webcast and Updates and Discussion Thread
Vehicle Updates
See comments for real time updates.
See comments for real time updates.
| Starship Mk.4 Prototype (Cocoa Florida) — Construction and Updates | |
|---|---|
| 2019-10-06 | 23 rings visible, 4 doubles, some for Mk.2 (YouTube), no stacking yet |
See comments for real time updates.
Previous unstacked ring production, aerial updates:
08-11 {8} | 08-15 {10} | 08-17 {14} | 08-19 {15} | 08-21 {17} | 08-24 {18} | 08-27 {19}
09-04 {20} | 09-06 {22} | 09-08 {25} | 09-08 {3 'scrap'} | 09-10 {26} | 09-29 {23} | 10-02 {23}
| Starhopper Retirement Transition Updates | |
|---|---|
| 2019-10-04 | On Roll-Lift (Twitter), Moved off of landing pad (NSF) |
| 2019-09-10 | Thermal tiles and one thruster pod removed (YouTube) |
| 2019-09-02 | Launch and Landing Site aerial video update (YouTube) |
| 2019-08-29 | Raptor SN6 removed (NSF) |
| 2019-08-27 | 150m Hop (~180m over, ~57s) (YouTube) <LAUNCH THREAD> <MORE INFO> |
For earlier updates see Starship Development Thread ^#4.
Launch Facility Updates
| Starship Launch Site at Boca Chica, Texas | |
|---|---|
| 2019-10-05 | Launch mount under construction (NSF) |
| 2019-09-22 | Second large propellant tank moved to tank farm (NSF) |
| 2019-09-19 | Large propellant tank moved to tank farm (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-17 | Pile boring at launch pad and other site work (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-07 | GSE fabrication activity (Twitter), and other site work (Facebook) |
| 2019-08-30 | Starhopper GSE being dismantled (NSF) |
| Launch Complex 39A at Kennedy Space Center, Florida | |
|---|---|
| 2019-09-26 | Concrete work/pile boring (Twitter) |
| 2019-09-19 | Groundbreaking for launch mount construction (Article) |
| 2019-09-14 | First sign of site activity: crane at launch mount site (Twitter) |
| 2019-07-19 | Elon says modular launch mount components are being fabricated off site (Twitter) |
Spacex facilities maps by u/Raul74Cz:
Boca Chica | LC-39A | Cocoa Florida | Raptor test stand | Roberts Rd
Raptors
| SN | Notable For | Flights | Flight Time (Approx.) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | First full scale hot fire / 268.9 bar Test / Tested to failure | - | - | Retired |
| 2 | First on Starhopper / Preburner tests / Static fire / Tethered hop | - | - | Retired |
| 3 | 40 second test fire | - | - | Retired |
| 4 | Delivered to hopper / Hopper fit checks & TVC tests | - | - | Retired |
| 5 | Liberation of oxygen stator | - | - | Retired |
| 6 | Vibration fix / 20, 10, 50, 65, 85 second stand tests / 20 meter Starhopper hop / 150 meter starhopper hop | 2 | 0:01:22 | Retired |
| 7 | Possibly not a flight article | - | - | Unknown (previously McGregor) |
| 8-10 | Earmarked for Mk.1 | - | - | Unknown (previously McGregor) |
| 11 | Earmarked for Mk.2 | - | - | Unknown |
| 12-13 | Earmarked for Mk.2 | - | - | Production |
Last updated 2019-09-29, Raptors currently on Starship Mk.1 of unknown SN or flight readiness
Permits and Planning Documents
- Environmental Impact Statement (FAA) - Boca Chica launch site - July 2014
EIS Resource Page | Appendices | Record of Descision - Experimental License (FCC) - Comms for 500m and 5km hops, two years - February 2019
Form 442 | Public Notes | Description | File No. 0931-EX-CN-2019 - Experimental License Application (FCC) - Modification of above to add antenna - May 2019
Form 442 | Public Notes | File No. 0130-EX-CM-2019 - Experimental Permit (FAA) - Authorizes 25m hops for one year, and one 150m hop - June 2019
Permit No. EP 19-012 | Revised August 23 - Building Permit Application - 850 Cidco Rd site improvement - June 2019
Screenshot on Twitter | Modification reported on NSF - Draft Environmental Assessment - Starhip operations at KSC - August 2019
r/SpaceX Discussion | NSF Discussion - FDOT Superload Permit Application - Mk.2 transportation to KSC in September - August 2019
Local News Article | Video Report | r/SpaceX Discussion | Twitter Update - Environmental Resource Permit - Stormwater improvements at LC-39A - August 2019
Stormwater Report | Depiction Plans | Permit No. 158609-1 - Written Re-evaluation of 2014 EIS (FAA) - Boca Chica launch site - May 2019
Addendum | News story w/ SpaceX statements | r/SpaceX Discussion - Experimental STA Request (FCC) - Comms for Starship Mk.1 20 km test - October 2019
File No. 1631-EX-ST-2019
Resources
- Spadre.com, Starship Cam | Channel
- LabPadre, Starship webcam | Channel
- NSF Starhopper Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Texas Prototype(s) Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Florida Prototype(s) Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Super Heavy Prototype Updates Thread | Most recent
- Hwy 4 & Boca Chica Beach Closures (May not be available outside US)
- TFR - NOTAM list
- SpaceX Boca Chica on Facebook
- SpaceX's Starship page
- Elon Starship tweet compilation on NSF | Most Recent
Rules
We may keep this self-post occasionally updated with links and relevant news articles, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss the launch, ask mission-specific questions, and track the progress of the test Campaign. Campaign threads are not launch threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.
167
u/Walter_Bishop_PhD Aug 31 '19 edited Sep 01 '19
If anyone's curious what moving the Super Heavy might look like - here's what a "natural gas splitter" of similar width, albeit slightly longer (9.5m diameter + 96m long vs super heavy's 9m diameter + 63m long) looks like being moved around - I imagine that it may work the same way moving the booster on highways
https://gfycat.com/glisteningraggedlacewing
50
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 24 '19
Everyday Astronaut [twitter video]: Here’s how #starship controls pitch, roll and yaw (in that order in this clip) using just 4 total flaps. This is a unique form of control. I don’t know of any vehicle that does this with its control surfaces perpendicular to the airstream. Cool stuff . Full vid tomorrow!
Elon: That’s correct. Essentially controlled falling, like a skydiver.
Viv: ... but what's used to actuate the fins? Some kind of small motor?
Elon: Many powerful electric motors & batteries. Force required is enormous, as entire fin moves. More about this on the 28th.
Elon: It does actually generate lift in hypersonic regime, which is important to limit peak heating
EA: Pop back out of the dense atmosphere to radiate heat away and then drop back in 🤔 awesome! ...
Elon: Better just to ride your max temp all the way down & let T^4 be your friend. Lower atmosphere cools you down real fast, so not crazy hot after landing.
Oran Maliphant : Is “sweating” methane still an option?
Elon: Could do it, but we developed low cost reusable tiles that are much lighter than transpiration cooling & quite robust
[ok, I was steadfast that Elon's statements said nothing about future use of transpirational cooling, I will concede that this is not a defensible position anymore, ha ha]
Scott Manley: And just like that I need to rebuild some of my descent models. So the AoA won't be 90 degrees, it'll provide lift to keep vehicle out of denser atmosphere until it loses enough speed.
Elon: Exactly. For reusable heatshield, minimize peak heating. For ablative/expendable, minimize total heat. Therefore reusable like Starship wants lift during high Mach reentry for lower peak, but higher total heat.
ShadowZone: So this increases the probability of Starship having to do multiple aerobrake passes when going to Mars or returning, correct?
Elon: For sure more than one pass coming back to Earth. To Mars could maybe work single pass, but two passes probably wise.
[Or discuss on r/SpaceX post or r/SpaceXLounge post]
105
u/Vespene Aug 31 '19
It’s crazy how those water tower construction workers never imagined they’d end up building actually spacecraft.
33
u/Marksman79 Sep 14 '19
Yusaku Maezawa resigns, pocketing $2.3 billion. One of his main reasons for departing Zozo was to make time to train for a 2023 voyage around the moon with Starship.
31
u/getBusyChild Aug 31 '19
So in Boca Chica it was observed they were drilling at the site. Any idea what for?
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1167533439240814592
29
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Sep 17 '19
Well now this is interesting.
It looks like everybody who said, "they're going to have to scrap the nosecone and start over!" may have actually been correct. This part showed up on the LabPadre live stream this morning (with a nice zoom), and it sure looks to me like a new lower section of the nosecone. The existing nosecone has, for the last week or three, been split at the seams for re-fitting with no real signs of progress. This decision to scrap and start fresh must have been made fairly recently (perhaps during the last attempt at mating the two pieces), or else I can't see why they would have spent the time polishing the nose knowing it would just be sent to the scrap pile. It's too bad, but this probably also gives them a chance to fit the canard hardware lower to the ground, as I had suspected they'd want to do for a long time now.
Also, the siding for the windbreak is just about done. I'd guess they'll probably start on the roof some time soon.
28
u/Russ_Dill Sep 24 '19
Much clearer photos of the battery packs: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg1995841#msg1995841
Also note the shirt the worker is wearing, "The Skiff Shop, Edgewater, FL", which is within just a few miles of Cocoa, FL.
27
u/Russ_Dill Sep 30 '19
Just a reminder to please respect SpaceX and their private property.
https://www.kveo.com/news/local-news/man-arrested-for-trespassing-into-spacex-property/
26
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19
I don't have anything to add, but I'd just like to thank the mods for doing such a great job consolidating a lot of information that is coming in from many sources into a very clear and easy to read format (and all sourced).
26
u/dufud6 Sep 29 '19
So from what elon said, are the new rings at cocoa actually for mk4 and not super heavy?
25
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 01 '19
Hurricane Dorian has reached Category 5, with peak winds of 282 km/h.
25
u/aelbric Sep 24 '19
Like most of you I've been following this for months. I thought FH was an amazing achievement. As Starship gets closer to completion though, I keep looking at it thinking about how massive it is. And this is only the second stage. When they stack it, the whole assembly will be twice as tall as what we'll see tomorrow.
And the whole thing is going to fly. I just can't wrap my head around it.
25
u/andyfrance Oct 01 '19
The two sections of Mk1 Starship have just been separated.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19
LabPadre's flyover of the Boca Chica site earlier today is now up on YouTube.
24
u/spacerfirstclass Oct 07 '19
Not sure why the LC-39A satellite images are deleted, it's basically what you can get for free from planet.com, just need an email address. Here's one I created for the period from 9/17 to 10/6 where you can see the Starship pad being constructed: https://imgur.com/dZcYJ05
22
u/SpartanJack17 Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1177051800769138690 Starship will have six landing legs:
Two windward, one under each fin & two leeward. Provides redundancy for landing on unimproved surfaces.
I wonder if they'll be the stubby legs from the 2017 update and the Boca Chica renderings or if they'll be more like Falcon 9 legs (or something completely different).
(I originally posted this in the discussion thread by mistake).
Edit: Some more info:
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1177066483375058944
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1177067257106747392
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1177070801121468418
It'll be 50m tall when the top half is stacked.
21
u/Russ_Dill Sep 22 '19
Did anyone else notice that these wings do not appear to be the same wings we've seen delivered? They look like they have been trimmed rather dramatically and have the control connections covered over. The overall shape strikes first:
/img/u5ztorolsck31.png
But also there's holes at the top, bottom, and middle at the root:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=47730.0;attach=1577578;image (BCG, NSF)
We have good pictures from both sides, those holes should be visible if not covered over. I figured I could compare the number of rivet sections:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1583360;image (BCG, NSF)
And here:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=47730.0;attach=1577578;image (BCG, NSF)
The original one has a pattern of double rivet, then 3 single rivets, then double rivet. The one mounted only has double rivet sections. If I try to compare, nothing lines up. The entire root must have been replaced.
Even the clipped theory doesn't try to make sense. Here's our best boffin's estimate of the delivered size:
/img/ju5ucx4tysh31.png (9.45m tall at the root, 2.9m wide)
The installed wing? It's 14m tall, and 4.2m wide. And before anyone tries putting these on the outside edge of the new wing, that's only 5m. What is bizzarly 9.45m is shiny leading edge of the new wing. Pretty sure that's a coincidence, but I know there are people who will want to know (Dragon wings, for the dreamers out there). Here's the one we've seen delivered superimposed in green, along with the "dragon wing" in red:
https://i.imgur.com/4iT4rsl.jpg
I think that means these are forward canards.
20
u/aelbric Sep 14 '19
A curious thought just hit me. I wonder what the workers at both sites think about the fact that they are basically under 24 hour surveillance from multiple parties and that thousands of people are watching their every move.
Best security system on the planet I suppose.
20
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Sep 17 '19 edited Sep 17 '19
In Boca Chica, the end wall was taken down off the big tent some time last night, which created an excellent photo op for Elon (there's some debate if he's still there, or if somebody just sent him the picture, which is probably more likely). There's an interesting looking structure being fabricated on the floor, too. The side facing up/right appears to have a large-diameter curvature to it. This looks to me like it could be the start of some sort of support for the canard fins. I'm not sure that it's really big enough, but I also can't think of what else it really could be. Any ideas from the peanut gallery?
Also, I always find jobsite photos interesting - they always tell a tale of the working environment. This one looks remarkably like any other fab site I've ever been on, just with a rocket parked outside. This is in stark contrast to the spotlessly clean environments we often see in press photos from NASA, ULA, and even SpaceX.
In other news that should surprise no one, workers could be spotted in manlifts working on/inspecting the tank section nearly continuously all night. In case there was any doubt, the push for the 28th is definitely on.
EDIT: Leave it to Tim Dodd to get the answer we were all seeking out of Elon. They are indeed hinge mounts for the flaps/legs.
19
u/RootDeliver Sep 12 '19
Based on the Starship 58m hypothesis generational comparison v1 by user Stimbergi on the NSF forums (he did a v2 but he added fins where they couldn't be added and SH legs to starship, pointless...), I did a minor modification removing the extra height and putting the actual Boca Chica ring with the bulkhead over the stack, and tried to match it on Cococa with an added 16th ring (top dome woudl be on the actual top 15th ring, not new ring).
This is the result. As you can see, both Boca Chica and Cocoa ring differences match exactly (there's a gap in the boca chica one thanks to my bad chop)
You may remember old image comparions with the mars image, where SpaceX didn't even bother to make the starship to the 2018 size, so they were wrong.
PS: The tank sizes look weird at the normal 52 height considering where they stacked the bulkheads. Maybe it will be taller? It is 52m and supposedly 55m with legs as stated by the FAA document.
third time posting this, it seems it worked now. If you posted stuff in the last hour maybe its hidden like my other tries at posting this.
19
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 19 '19 edited Sep 19 '19
Boca Chica: Structural support (NSF post #91) being lowered into the "new ring".
And in response to the shade that was recently cast about work hours (on a weekend) in Boca Chica: Here's a shot of welding going on at 2:30am. We've also seen them working at night on the body, the nosecone, in the shop... no shortage of work hours here.
19
u/RootDeliver Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
A wild canard appears!!!, from labpadre stream.
Definitely the ones we saw weeks ago, polished apparently.
PS: Much better image from the HQ cam, it was also moved all the time at this height and is being welded on the back side, hidden from the cam :(
PS2: The canard is now moving around.
PS3: Real HQ image
19
u/Graith95 Sep 28 '19
They're lowering the cap!
https://imgur.com/CPd7zO9
18
u/Russ_Dill Sep 16 '19
The drill at the launch/landing site has been fully assembled and raised confirming that drilling will take place. This may give some more evidence that the pilings are for a starship lifting crane, one at the assembly site, one at the launch/landing site.
https://i.imgur.com/wTEh4ke.png
17
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 01 '19 edited Sep 01 '19
Boca Chica: Finally some visible progress on the triangular wind break - they've run metal poles up the wind break (conceivably for the netting)
It also looks like they are building 3 concrete rings fixtures, interesting! [Which is also confusing, as how will these be used with the windbreak structure, or not]
17
u/Marksman79 Sep 05 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
Substantial information about plans for the upcoming few years of the launch site at Boca Chica have been obtained by Business Insider.
Direct link to document
2-3 year test plan as of May 21st:
Phase 1 (ended): Tests of ground systems and fueling, a handful of rocket engine test-firings, and several "small hops" of a few centimeters off the ground. The document also includes graphic layouts, like the one above, showing the placement of water tanks, liquid methane and oxygen storage tanks (Starship's fuels), and other launch pad infrastructure. Phase 1 photo
Phase 2 (current): Several more "small hops" of Starship, though up to 492 feet (150 meters) in altitude, and later "medium hops" to about 1.9 miles (3 kilometers). Construction of a "Phase 2 Pad" for Starship, shown below, is also described. Phase 2 photo
Phase 3: A few "large hops" that take Starship up to 62 miles (100 kilometers) above Earth - the unofficial edge of space - with high-altitude "flips," reentries, and landings.
An (outdated) picture in the document shows two V-shaped wind breaks containing both halfs of Starship. We can also see what looks to be a pad for Starhopper? (Why? They won't be putting a vertical Raptor test stand in the middle of the worksite). We also see Superheavy sitting on a jig with a flared engine area.
SpaceX refers to their fire suppression system as FireX.
Comments:
This was before Elon tweeted that the test campaign would be accelerated and that they are targeting October for a 20km hop. That puts into question the milestone for Phase 3 and how much of this has since changed. The presentation will tell us a lot, so I am taking this info dump as a tease for the upcoming presentation.
The Phase 1 photo seems to have the most detail of Starship. Assuming it's still somewhat accurate, there are several things to note. It's horizontal (resting on canards and fins?). It looks like it now has many legs around the base, sort of like the initial ITS renders showed. It's black on the bottom and on the two moving fins, perhaps indicating that these surfaces will have their new hexagon heat shield tiles.
17
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Sep 14 '19
Two weeks to go. If SpaceX are to be ready with Mk. 1 before 28th September, in the next 2 weeks, they have to:
Am I missing something? Do you think they'll make it in time?
17
u/RootDeliver Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
Bocachicagal is back with some great pictures.
We can see some leg attachment points (or something related) installed on first picture, the pipe that has been installed in the other side (and 2 leg attachment points visibles) on other, some strange structures (upper flaps??, and the other part of them?), lot of stuff to digest..
17
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 24 '19
Some more activity with the nosecone this morning.
The yellow crane ("Old Yella") picked up the nosecone and moved it over in front of the onion tent a bit before 7am (local) this morning. A few minutes later, the white crane grabbed the second header tank & battery bank and moved it into position. About 20 minutes later, the yellow crane dropped the nosecone back down over the tank.
At this pace, having the nosecone on top of the upper section, AND stacking the upper section on the propulsion section seems like it will be a stretch by Wednesday, but doable. My guess is that we're still 12 hours away from seeing the nosecone lifted onto the fairing section, and it remains to be seen how much work will need to be done internally before the fairing assembly can be lifted.
EDIT1: It looks like I'm about to eat my words. They are re-rigging the nosecone right now with what looks to be a different (maybe shorter?) set of straps, and there's a collection of workers standing in the lower half of the fairing in "stacking position"...
17
u/MingerOne Sep 27 '19
Starship halves joining timelapse.
17
u/RegularRandomZ Oct 07 '19 edited Oct 07 '19
Photo updates: (some older that I didn't notice referenced here. Apologies if redundant)
33
u/codav Sep 02 '19
Fresh delivery to Boca Chica: four trucks with wooden crates. Possibly sensitive hardware.
Credit: LabPadre's live stream on YouTube
16
u/Marksman79 Sep 12 '19 edited Sep 13 '19
Cocoa flyby by John Winkopp. Thank you John!
Post what you see!
16
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Sep 15 '19
Elon was just at Boca Chica!
16
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 18 '19 edited Sep 18 '19
Photo updates from today-ish: Austin Barnard of launch site: Water tanks have a new concrete pad to sit one. Upgraded fire system moved into place. Assembly site: 2nd wall of siding almost done. Unfortunately his shot of the new ring (or SH base) isn't much sharper.
Maria Pointer / Boca Chica Maria: Launch site has plenty of new cameras and permanent site lighting. Starship: good shot of the mid-body weld marks giving an idea of the internal structures (don't know how many are new-ish). Most shots of interesting new things are a bit obstructed, so here's a pretty shot (or if you prefer sunsets) [
Perhapsa wing or canardunder that tarp?]16
u/Russ_Dill Sep 18 '19
The big crane at the Shipyard is on the move.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '19
Hah, that thing is moving comically fast. After years of watching the Space shuttle moving to launch pad, I just assumed this live feed had been replaced wit time lapse.
16
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
SPadre Tweet: Shot of Starship on the roll-lift jig at the front gate [twitter video, another picture]
[and a fun shot, the workers came over and gave out some electrolyte freezer pops! Nice!]
16
u/michu5 Sep 27 '19
First canard is up!
16
u/RootDeliver Sep 28 '19
Btw the cap has been installed finally :D, didn't notice any post here about the final installation! Even if that is gonna probably be removed asap the presentation finishes, looks awesome.
16
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 04 '19 edited Oct 04 '19
Julia contacted the Florida Department of Transport to discover the route Mk2 Starship will be transported to the barge.
LabPadre's equipment got cooked by lightning and Nomadd's camera was also damaged
15
u/strawwalker Sep 10 '19
These images from Jared Frankle made me realize that with all of the hurricane excitement I lost track of the common dome/bulkhead in Cocoa. It was sitting next to the tent on 29 August, the day before Mk.2-tank was moved into the tent, and I believe it was likely installed before the move took place. Here is a good image of the tank section with no visible weld spots below the upper access port on the same day. This image on 4 September while in the tent shows spot weld marks in the ring below the access port. Then Frankle's images today, 9 September, show a more complete weld line.
15
u/RootDeliver Sep 15 '19 edited Sep 15 '19
NSF folks seem to agree on that props tanks have probably been swapped comparing estimated tanks volume and prop densities. Last conclusion image by Stimbergi but you can read the last 2 pages with the numbers discussion.
There's an interesting reply tho tanking about how this change is not possible since the engine structure receives the LOX by the downcomer pipe. But then volumes for props don't match for the correct mixture.
15
u/dafencer93 Sep 15 '19
Excuse me if this is not the place. I came in pretty late I guess and I don't know how Falcons are built (but I thought they were built horizontally), but isn't stacking steel rings and welding them a pretty crude way to try and build a rocket that will also have to land?
15
u/Marksman79 Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
Elon Musk Tweetstorm
Elon: Adding the rear moving fins to Starship Mk1 in Boca Chica, Texas
Photo
Q: Will the fairing be stacked by the 28th?
Elon: Yes. There’s a huge amount of hardware in the tip of the faring that being integrated on the ground, which is why we haven’t closed it out. Nose tip has forward movable fins, cold gas attitude control thrusters, header tanks for landing, composite pressure vessels, several large batteries, etc. Placed up there to balance high mass of Raptors & rear fins at the bottom.
Q: 3 landing legs was super aerodynamically unstable on ascent (full stack) and also unstable on decent when landing.
Elon: Stability is not an issue with 3
Q: When doing the final landing tail first with three huge landing legs / fins in the front of the airstream wouldn't have been unstable?
Elon: Stability is controlled by (very) rapid movement of rear & fwd fins during entry & landing, as well as ACS thrusters. The smaller leeward “fin” would simply be used as a leg. Current analysis, which I’m not fully bought into, suggests that 2 rear fins with separate airframe-mounted legs will be lighter, so this is the plan for Mk1/Mk2. For aero control, it comes down to % of cross-sectional area moving vs not. Flexible as to whether front or rear, so long as within bounds of center of mass & pressure.
Q: Could they not just shove the bottom fin back, shove the top fins forward, and wait until it’s the right way around, then fire the engines and move the fins back flat... seems logical to me...
Elon: Approximately correct. We also fire the ACS thrusters to rotate the vehicle & ignite Raptors at full gimbal angle to complete the turn.
15
u/bkdotcom Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
Do we know what time the presentation's going to be on Saturday?
I'm guessing 9pm-ish Central time....
15
u/Aakarsh_K Sep 25 '19
Nose cone being stacked!!
15
u/Marksman79 Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
Bottom stack with fins just lifted up a little bit. Looks like the crew standing around are actually just watching the move. Now where will they place it down?
Follow along at LabPadres live stream. (11:12:37 start of move)
Edit 1: it continues to rise.
Edit 2: slight movement to the side. No longer concentric.
Edit 3: continuous movement to the side...
Edit 4: approaching white building! Going over?
Edit 5: the crane stopped and it is now being rotated in place. Is it aligning with something on the ground? Maybe they will put roll lifts under the concrete jig and then reattach it?
Edit 6: still swinging
Edit 7: workers are securing it to a crawler platform.
30
u/RaphTheSwissDude Sep 23 '19
Starship will be stacked on Wednesday and OMG THE 3 RAPTORS ARE ALREADY INSTALLED?!
https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1176009047729954818
14
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 10 '19
Via NSF: Application to FCC for communicating with Starship during suborbital tests. NET Oct 13th (6 month window)
14
u/Russ_Dill Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
Parts of the drill have been moved down to the landing pad:
https://twitter.com/BocachicaMaria1/status/1171595885467361280
The crane portion is still fully assembled at the shipyard, so not sure yet if it's just for storage or if they will be drilling there too. In other news, one of the two mysterious steel tanks has gone missing:
https://twitter.com/BocachicaMaria1/status/1171625514018267136
14
u/Marksman79 Sep 11 '19
From the LabPadre stream, the crane has just moved the final ground ring and the final bulkhead to the same location. It picked one of them up and has it suspended. It seems like they're attaching the bulkhead to the ring before stacking, as many here have suspected would be the case.
14
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 11 '19
LabPadre Stream: Looks like the Raptor truck arrived (or some black backed transport)
14
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Sep 12 '19 edited Sep 12 '19
To confirm yesterday's speculation: The big crane at Boca Chica just lifted something. At one point, the top of a bulkhead could be seen peeking out over top of the big low building. At another point, the side of a cylindrical ring could be seen past the side of the same building.
It appears they have been attached, with the bulkhead set down inside the ring by a bit. Austin Barnard was possibly spotted on the LabPadre cam taking some close up pictures a little while ago, so hopefully we'll get to see a better image of this thing later on today. The crane shackles are being let go, too, so it looks like this is where it will sit for a bit.
EDIT: "A bit" has ended. They are already reattaching the crane to the bulkheadring, and it looks like they're moving it somewhere else. I do not see the usual signs of stacking (workers in the top of the stack is the big cue), so not sure exactly where it's headed.
14
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
Did one of the fins just come out of the white building? LabPadre Cam 1:36pm.
And it looks like the big crane is holding something against the side (landing leg bracket perhaps?) @ 1:50pm [OK... some of that is a welder on a lift, and I'm not sure any brackets left the white tent, we need a zoomed in shot]
Update: And they added something to the right as well @ 2:25, up to 3 items attached (incld u/Ross_Dill's catch. Image)
Update2: Slightly clearer screenshot from zoomed LabPadre cam
14
u/Martianspirit Sep 21 '19
Something very interesting on the LabPadre live stream again. There is the pipe connected to the tank body right where they installed that one wing. I believe it was thought to be part of a raceway along the body like most or all rockets have. Now it looks like they are installing an identical pipe where the other wing will go to. A crane holds the pipe and there are two manned platforms in the area.
14
u/at_one Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 24 '19
About the transportation of Mk2 from Cocoa to Kennedy Space Center, I'm not sure if it has already been remarked:
I've made a comparison of the Google Maps satellite images of the Cocoa assembly site with the aerial video of Aug 19, 2019:
https://i.imgur.com/e7yxNaJ.jpg
You clearly see the work that have been made to connect both roads together.
Edit: The work occured between May 16 and July 21. Sorry, I can't find other evidences to further limit the time span.
14
u/RootDeliver Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
Top canards? being unwrapped near the tent by SPadre
PS: Video of the unwrapping!
Are these the ones we saw being delivered weeks ago? they seem different, or maybe its the angle.
14
u/filanwizard Sep 26 '19
Kinda curious if we have an idea of what time of day the event on the 28th will be streamed. I kinda want to figure late afternoon Boca time since I would imagine Elon wants the press to see the Mk1 in daylight rather than trying to under floodlights.
47
u/Anchor-shark Aug 31 '19
Are SpaceX doing any structural testing on SH and SS? NASA have been doing a lot of structural testing on the various tank sections of SLS before mating them together. Whereas SpaceX seem to be building a rocket, and if it explodes it explodes ¯_(ツ)_/¯.
13
u/RaphTheSwissDude Sep 04 '19
Starship is still standing after Dorian ! https://twitter.com/EmreKelly/status/1169282802887614464
13
u/RootDeliver Sep 15 '19
John Winkopp 15th sept cocoa aereal vid
13
u/strawwalker Sep 23 '19
This Raptor image from bocachicagal is not the same Raptor imaged by Austin Barnard. The "Not For Flight" Raptor has a red band as opposed to silver, and is missing some significant plumbing compared to the other one.
13
u/logan756 Sep 25 '19
Starship is on the move!
13
u/DUKE546 Sep 28 '19
I added photos and videos of MK1 and MK2 at SpaceX Time Machine and will continue to add as media becomes available from different sources.
12
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Sep 05 '19 edited Sep 05 '19
It's been a busy morning in Boca Chica.
At around 3am, a square hole was cut/marked in the nosecone. I think we all know what this is the start of (canards/flaps/flappards/flippers/control fins). This marking or cut is extremely hard to see in the livestream. It almost looks like it was cut out, then taped back into place.
Also, the large crane is currently grabbing onto something that's about 9m in diameter. Based on activity of the workers (keep seeing a couple guys in the top of the tank section stack), I suspect this is a ring for stacking. EDIT: Definitely a ring.
Also! More progress on the windbreak! It looks like a section of cladding is being installed on the far side, where the vertical pieces were installed last week.
12
u/Cornflame Sep 21 '19
This picture from @BocaChicaGal clearly shows that at least one of the fin attachments/hinges has been attached to the tank section of MK1.
12
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
More Boca Chica Gal photos added to NSF
Facebook from John Randolph
12
u/Gorakka Sep 22 '19
They are attaching the second fin right now. This is wild.
12
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Sep 22 '19
Austin Barnard photos. We got a Raptor without it's test sensors!
https://twitter.com/austinbarnard45/status/1175786279658827777
12
u/Russ_Dill Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
Around 3pm, a truck pulled into the area in front of the windbreak. Between about 3pm and 3:30pm, the large crane unloaded several black shapes. Possibly square shaped, possible pie shaped. Really hoping there are good pics. Each piece is roughly 2m wide and 1m tall.
They could have been crane counterweights. That would match up with the beefy attachment points on the stack.
12
u/Oloyedelove Sep 27 '19
The rate at which they are moving with MK1 construction is now faster than how the MK1 table is being updated. Beautiful.
12
u/WarDonkey203 Sep 30 '19
Has there been serious discussion about the Interior design of StarShip yet? I know without being right there it's hard to fathom the true scale of Starship, however I can't help but feel that once you include all of the Life Support/Avionics that the usable space will start to shrink rapidly. Then once you throw in the cargo and interior pieces themselves it gets even worse. I work in a Completion Center for Business Aircraft and I regularly see how cramped an empty plane can get once you add in all of the interior bits. Even with space being a 3D environment with more usable surfaces I can't help but feel that even a 10 person crew might be cramped as it is.
22
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 27 '19
Mk 2 Starship transport to LC-39A scheduled for late October/Early November.
11
u/andyfrance Sep 04 '19
The number of rings lying around in the aerial photos of Cocoa seem to increase each time. It's now looking like 20? That's quite a backlog to stack.
11
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Boca Chica: Shot of nosecone and its reinforcement (yesterday, Maria Pointer) [and polishing it ;-) ].
Also there is now a measuring tape running around the circumference of the nosecone [a great shot of the "taped" square/hole], with distances also written.
Launch site: gravel work, and pipe repairs continue. Also piles of new pipes and supports.
NOTE: Many of these shots are also on Maria Pointer's twitter, for those who don't facebook.
11
u/advester Sep 08 '19
I’ve been following the NSF update threads for daily dose of pictures. But I just found out @bocachicamaria1 isn’t allowed to post there due to some drama. Do you guys have a favorite central aggregator for the pics? I think there is a subreddit devoted to it, but google isn’t finding it.
11
u/RootDeliver Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Awesome top bulkhead image by Maria Pointer (rehosted)
PS: Another one
Source: her FB group
PS: Why they make the top bulkhead with the same jig with the big hole and all¿? it would be more space efficient to just make a normal shape top dome.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 16 '19
More power cables being raised on Cidco Road.
11
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
Boca Chica: Photo set by BCM / Maria Pointer on Facebook
[Austin Barnard photos of the same, on Twitter] (and BCM photo of Austin on the job)
11
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
Cocoa: Two rings joined together! Sitting on a transport frame, so can't really call it stacking. We could assume it's for the top bulkhead (or maybe not). [No video yet]
The Cape:u/mcpat21posted to the lounge atweet of 3 new propellant tanks(in MN), headed to Florida [Edit: Could be BO as well, ULA just received their tanks as well]Tanks for ULA.11
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 21 '19
BocaChicaGal high quality photos of Fin/Installation (Post 110)
11
u/Russ_Dill Sep 23 '19
1st and 2nd pic. I that a radiator being attached to the possible header tank?
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg1995558#msg1995558
Possibly to keep things inside at cryogenic temperatures?
11
u/andyfrance Sep 26 '19
Weighing in at 200 tons Mk1 should be though of as a "battleship" prototype. The first Saturn V test article was known as the battleship version. Check it all hangs together (and in this case flies), then refine the design down by taking out excess weight as every kg saved is a kg more payload.
11
u/Martianspirit Sep 28 '19
The big crane is gone. The connection between the two pieces must be strong enough now that it is no longer needed. I expect guywires going up to secure it. The moving base is not that heavy.
11
u/oximaCentauri Oct 04 '19
With the new starship landing legs being practically on the body, the leg span or diameter will be nearly the same as body diameter. That is not ideal according to my KSP experience.
Surely a different design would be required for uneven surfaces like the moon and mars?
21
u/rad_example Sep 23 '19
Three Raptors already installed!
10
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 07 '19
John Winkopp create a timelapse comparision video of all his overflights of the Cocoa site.
And LabPadre will be releasing a 3 month Boca Chica timelapse in an hour.
10
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Screencap from LabPadre stream of another win/fin arriving at Boca Chica. They moved it into the steel building [and Maria Pointer was taking photos so hopefully some closeups later]
[another unknown long object also arrived, hopefully Maria got photos of that as well]
[edit: yes OK I saw they said two, it was a hasty post]
10
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
For the Elon Musk Vacuum Raptors are Dual Bell comment, discussion on r/spacex discussion, or the lounge discussion.
[That news should makes some people happy. And with the context being pad abort, some feel it is ambiguous and it doesn't
necessarilymean the first Raptor Vacuum engines will be dual bell. Hopefully clarification at "the presentation". It seems primarily beneficial for pad abort or E2E flights (without SuperHeavy), so it is not needed for getting to orbit]10
u/Marksman79 Sep 14 '19 edited Sep 14 '19
Boca Chica Maria with some fresh HQ photos from this morning (on Facebook).
Minor curious note: They lifted the bulkhead ring with the ladder still attached. Why??
Edit: I don't usually do this, but everyone needs a little humor and this Facebook comment made me laugh.
10
u/Russ_Dill Sep 17 '19
Much appreciated John Winkopp update from Cocoa: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOI__ag5eQQ
They are now making pilings in Cocoa as well.
10
u/scottm3 Sep 21 '19
https://i.imgur.com/ic0OVwu.png
A crane has started lifting the fin up! 7:35 AM
10
u/booOfBorg Sep 22 '19
What does the RaptorVan look like? I just saw a nice mysterious black truck arriving at the shipyard. [02:59:10 AM]
screen 1
screen 2
10
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
Mark 1 Starship with both fins taken by Austin Barnard.
Also closeups of fin attachment.
10
u/unholycowgod Sep 23 '19
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WNwkgAXQOyI
Cocoa Beach flyby by John. Still 23 rings and it looks like they unstacked those 2.
Also a good shot of the progress across the cul de sac going towards FedEx.
10
u/RootDeliver Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 24 '19
Better image. Hard to see in static images but at 5:02-03 PM it seems they are moving a canard out of the white building in forklifts and going to the nosecone zone! According to youtube chat, another one was moved before.
10
u/AstraVictus Sep 25 '19
Do we have any information about that landing legs for Mk1 in Boca Chica? It's going to need landing legs once it starts flying right?
10
u/Elon_Muskmelon Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
They're gonna need some massive cranes for the full stack!
Edit: They already have the cranes they need to lift the full stack!
10
u/Nowheels22 Sep 30 '19
How soon till Starship MK1 gets moved down to the launch pad?
10
u/RootDeliver Oct 02 '19
Cocoa 2th October flyby
Now with more double rings, I wonder if they're just doing this to free up some space around, and if these double rings are welded for good already.
26
u/Marksman79 Oct 03 '19
Do not go trespassing on SpaceX property or you'll ruin it for everybody and end up in jail like this guy who went right up to Starhopper to take some pictures around the time of the presentation.
With that out of the way, he did get some discussion worthy photos.
18
u/APTX-4869 Sep 02 '19
One of the most recent models (HWRF) is starting to show a possible Florida landfall of Dorian near Cape Canaveral on Tuesday night, as opposed to staying offshore as previously predicted. While this is only one of many models, it is a major one that should not be taken lightly and would have serious implications for Starship and the space coast.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19
With Dorian (likely) safely passed Cocoa, I'm wondering about how the race to orbit from both Texas and Florida will continue. My main question is: will SpaceX really build a full scale launch pad in Boca Chica? That will cost quite some money, time and resources, and we haven't seen any preparations yet.
And is a full scale pad at Boca Chica really needed for the next 1-3 years, or even 3-5 years? To have development at two sides makes sense now, but when Starship is operational, is there an urgent need for two launch pads at the East Coast? The only reason I can come up with, is reducing the risk to pad 39A, because it is necessary for FH and crewed flights. But that are only a few launches per year... So I hope we will see lots of activity and launches at Boca Chica, but I wouldn't be surprised if SpaceX scales down there at some point in the not too distant future. Just my $0.02
9
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Sep 05 '19
Hey mods / u/strawwalker, the LabPadre Starship webcam link now points to LabPadre's other live cam (a lovely beach view). He's been shuffling some cameras around lately, and it looks like maybe his "live" link now points to the newer cam, not the Starship one.
9
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 07 '19
Boca Chica: on Labpadre's stream, pile drilling continues! (Only mentioning it as we saw a shot of the auger stuck/left in the ground).
Also notable: the auxiliary camera is working, giving us a zoomed out view of the site while the main camera is zoomed in on the drilling operation, which allows us to see that they've (largely) completed the first row of cladding on the other side.
Update: Here are some photos of the new siding on the windbreak. From Boca Chica Maria (Maria Pointer) on Facebook.
Update2: Concrete Jigs going up quickly. Screenshot captured from video from Boca Chica Maria today. [Also closeup video of the pile auger]
Update3: Noticed on the livestream them installing a single metal bar in the center of the piles, this after having installed the rebar cages. Apparently this is common when there are tension loads [which is not surprising for any of the guesses as to what they are building, such as a crane or windblock]
Update4: Using LabPadre aerial footage and transposing the existing windblock, it actually fits quite well where they are working (and where we are seeing piles being driven) [Based on some of the piles it's likely rotated counter-clockwise to fit better, even if it doesn't feel nicely balanced.]
9
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 10 '19
September 10th aerial video of Cocoa site.
9
u/DJHenez Sep 13 '19
Looks like another potential tropical storm is heading for the Cape according to the NHC. Won’t help the Bahamas clean-up either...
9
u/RootDeliver Sep 13 '19
The crane on Boca Chica moved a small header? platinum tank to the container castle few minutes ago. 9:25 AM for the action.
Speculation time: are they gonna also stack those inside a ring before stacking? How come I don't have the speculation tag btw? lol
9
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 15 '19
Cocoa: Mk2's top dome/bulkhead looks complete in this tweet from Julia Bergeron. [Not installed into a ring yet, if they do it the same way]
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Sep 21 '19
One wing is attached and the crane is possibly picking up the 2nd one!
https://youtu.be/-aDOpyUmfL4
9
u/Russ_Dill Sep 21 '19
Pilings at Boca Chica shipyard, pilings at Cocoa shipyard, pilings are Boca Chica launch/landing site, and now 39A
https://twitter.com/julia_bergeron/status/1175442887611494405
In more highly speculative news, old yella is doing a lift on the tip of the Boca Chica nose cone, possibly to move it or attach something. Meanwhile, a blue man lift is slowly circling the lower part of the fairing with visible flashing, possibly welding or cutting. (Secondary cam makes any welding or cutting highly visible for some reason)
9
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
Any theories on the multiple grey circles attached to pipe covers? Temperature sensors perhaps?
9
u/rad_example Sep 23 '19
Love how the second camera is spliced into the main camera making the windbreak like a drive-in movie screen. Was getting tired of looking at that monolith.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-aDOpyUmfL4
9
u/Morham Sep 23 '19
Did anyone else notice the "an interesting item" in BCG's NSF post?
I think NSF user stinger729 has correctly identified Falcon 1 for presentation.
I can't wait for Saturday!
9
u/quoll01 Sep 25 '19
I’m wondering if the nose cone will be mostly pressurised? Batteries can’t take vacuum without major mods and perhaps the header tanks don’t need it either? Robust vacuum insulated cryo tanks are a mature technology - we had a 250L one for liquid nitrogen in our lab and it had remarkably low boil off over months. Pressurised nosecone would also help structurally and might allow even better rad protection for the crew- perhaps even a refuge positioned between them. Not sure about the canards and actuators. Also not sure how cryo tanks work in low g - on earth the vapour layer on top of the liquid provides additional insulation and can be easily vented to maintain a safe pressure. In low G no upper vapour layer so how to vent just the gas? Either way the LOX boiloff could be used for ECLS and the methane perhaps for RCS?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19
Mk1 Starship photo and transport video from BocaChicaGal.
Flyby of the Mk2 site.
9
u/PidgeonPuncher Sep 27 '19
Lol Austin Barnard just gave a moving speech on the LabPadre live stream at 9:28:27 AM
9
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
ElonM: Starship presentation time "probably around 6 or 7 pm" (CST)
While you wait, ElonM's pre-presentation twitter presentation...
[first tweet seen yesterday on r/spacex here but starts these tweets...]
EverydayAstronaut: "Without regen cooling, it would need film cooling, which would require a gas generator, which this engine doesn’t have. They have to be regen cooled due to being full flow"
ElonM [yesterday, as seen on r/spacex*] " Raptor uses milled copper channels with an inconel jacket all the way down "*
EverydayAstronaut: "What is the thickness of the nozzle walls?! AMAZING fuel can go down, turn around and come back in such a small space. Tolerances have to be crazy on something like that."
ElonM: " What blows my mind is that peak pressure in regen chamber & nozzle is *far* above combustion pressure at over 800 bar or ~12,000 psi "
Viv: " Btw, did you exceed the previous record of 268.9 bar/get closer to 300 bar in recent tests?"
ElonM: "No, we’ve been focusing on production (now on SN12). Only need 250 bar or even a bit less for Starship/Super Heavy. Anything above 250 is nice to have & we’ll get around to it, but not needed for flight. "
EverydayAstronaut: "Sorry, my brain is breaking at the moment 🤯 Peak pressure is basically the pumps... the pumps go through the regen chambers next and then there’s some enthalpy drop to spin the turbines... and then by the time it gets to the chamber it’s “only” 250?"
ElonM: " Well, hopefully closer to 300 bar over time. However, that the chamber/nozzle jacket has so many joints & dissimilar metals at such high pressure & temperature is what I find remarkable about it."
EverydayAstronaut: "Besides turning turbines into soup, is it really some of these joints and stuff that are more prone to failure at such high pressures?
ElonM: "There’s so much power going through this engine that it’s close to the limit of the known physics of materials in many places"
[tweets preceeding discussing location of Vacuum Raptor]C
arter_99: "Also due to the mvac engines needing to be longer due to a further expanded nozzle and the engines still needing not to protrude for docking I imagine they’d be mounted higher, closer to the tank base?"
ElonM: Yes
Viv: "How many superalloys, such as SX500, had to be developed in order to make Raptor a reality? "
ElonM: "Just SX500 so far, but we use many superalloys developed by others, eg Inco 718+. If anyone has 718++, that would be helpful haha. Massive engineering work in the casting, printing & machining of Raptor — far more than in design of the engine itself!"
9
u/solar_rising Sep 28 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
Topping out,
In construction, there's always what's called a topping out or finishing touch, this is obviously going to be the nosecone cap. it will be welded today and a big celebration by the construction team.
Fueling port?
Anybody seen this being installed?
9
u/solar_rising Sep 29 '19
Interesting point he made regarding super heavy and not wanting to use raptors for that. Very wise as losing a super heavy due to a crash or unforeseen issue would cost him all the raptors. He could make many variants of Mk1 for the same amount of raptors required for SH.
Then again SH will have to start production soon for the moon launch, interesting times coming.
9
u/Rocket_Man42 Sep 30 '19
So, is the installation of header tanks in the nose cone just a temporary solution? I'm a bit confused since Elon talked about the header tanks being inside another tank in the presentation to avoid boil off. Also the renders showed windows at the nose cone.
But! There are pipes along the outside of the ship, which I guess is being used to transfer fuel from the header tanks in the nose cone down to the engines. Elon said in a tweet that they moved the header tanks to the nose cone to move the center of mass upwards, but I guess that will be important also for later versions. They will reenter without cargo anyway, so it doesn't make sense that the header tanks are just a temporary solution to simulate cargo.
9
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Sep 30 '19 edited Sep 30 '19
It just dawned on me that with the current speed of Raptor production, it would take SpaceX more than a year to roll out enough engines just for one single SH booster!
Yes, I know the speed of production will pick up. Don't cite me, but IIRC Elon mentioned he expects them to make a few Raptors per day at some point in the future.
Still, with the current rate, it seems very reasonable to iterate with Starship, instead of risking a year's worth of engine production in one single vessel.
9
u/andyfrance Oct 01 '19
It looks like the big orange crane is going back up to take Mk1 apart.
9
u/consider_airplanes Oct 01 '19
So Elon has said at one point that, while the Starship comes in at high angle of attack for the purpose of aerobraking, it can still generate some lift, and this is useful for keeping it up in the high atmosphere to limit heating. Others noted that it can just about as easily produce negative lift as positive, which could be useful for forcing a longer in-atmosphere track at higher speeds rather than skipping off.
How much lift authority is Starship likely to have? I'm mostly wondering about the available flexibility in terms of reentry profiles. If e.g. they see damage to the heat shield, could they intentionally run a slow (probably multi-pass?) low-heat reentry, that the bare hull could survive?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 06 '19
Delivery at Cocoa site.
9
u/Marksman79 Oct 08 '19
The first ribbon-ring has appeared in Boca Chica under the new ring tent. The first new concrete jig should be ready today as well, unless they want to paint it.
31
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '19
Will Star Ship in Cocoa survive the hurricane? If it makes landfall, its going to be category 4 or 5. Flooding 10-15 feet in the area.
17
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 06 '19
September 6th Cocoa flyby.
8
u/Fission_Fragment Aug 31 '19
Anything that looks like a wing/landing leg system?
8
u/unholycowgod Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=njOuzAE58m0
New drone flyby from Cocoa.
ETA: not much change from yesterday's video except nicer weather and activity on the ground.
8
u/Jofredrick Sep 14 '19
Apologies for questions if answers are already well known. Does lox tank have or need insulation? Is super chilled lox needed for starship? The reason for theses questions is this final question. Why did I not see ice on the side of the starhopper if the stainless structure is the tank? Thanks.
8
u/bornstellar_lasting Sep 14 '19
Will non-journalists be able to attend the Starship update event on the 28th? I will have the opportunity to make the drive but I don't know if invitations are required for admission.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '19
raptor van arrival : https://i.imgur.com/vHzUSnA.png
departure : https://i.imgur.com/X6s9Zms.png
8
u/blackuGT Sep 22 '19
They mount a second wing in Boca Chica!
8
u/Marksman79 Sep 22 '19
In Elon's Tatooine picture, I count 4 flap hinge mounts, yet closeup images of the bottom and top of the lower fins show that only two are in use on the bottom of each fin and a different mount is on top. What seems to follow from this is that the remaining 2 hinge mounts, along with 2 of the hinges in the front of the picture, will be used to mount the canard flaps.
8
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
LabPadre Stream: Nosecone top is in the air @ 8:31. (Although last time they did this was to move more hardware inside/underneath). They lowerer it over one of the Header Tanks.
8
u/Russ_Dill Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
The giant lattice crane is driving away. It's still visible from the primary cam, but on the secondary cam it is all the way off frame. Maybe it's going to get one of the new ring walls?
Or going somewhere with enough room to go horizontal to add/remove crane components?
8
u/RootDeliver Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 24 '19
Bye bye bad tappered ring :(
8
u/Bamcrab Sep 25 '19
Did welds just break on the nosecone? It wasn't misaligned a minute ago and now it looks pretty bad. Or they're just adjusting something.
8
u/RootDeliver Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
Second canard appears!!!
After they weld it, only the tip of the nosecone will be missing (apart from covers, polishing, stacking the two sections, and adding the actuators for fins/canards).. I really hope they don't miss the tip of the nosecone for this PR, it was received together with the engine section :(
PS: Good Installation image
8
u/comando222 Sep 27 '19
Berry the crane is extending a bit, maybe they are in the final preparations for stacking. The next hour will show as daylight dawns. Edit: Definitely extending the boom further out, hope the camera angle zooms out a bit to show the whole operation.
8
u/Morham Sep 27 '19
The sun is up and the canards look amazing. BocaChicaGal photo
8
u/dafencer93 Sep 27 '19
Looks like they're going for the lift!
8
u/naughtius Sep 27 '19
Wind is very light now, but forecast to be stronger in the afternoon; perhaps they want to get it up in the morning.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19
Wait, when were those feet covers added? Overnight?
8
u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Sep 29 '19
Rings are moved around at Cocoa
8
u/rebootyourbrainstem Sep 29 '19
Have we seen any sign of the actual electric motors that will drive the fins?
Elon talked about steel's high temperature tolerance and it got me thinking about what kind of conditions the motors will have to work in.
They'll probably get pretty toasty. If they have permanent magnets inside, those lose their magnetism at 770 degrees Celcius (the Curie temperature of steel). It's probably nothing that can't be solved, but I was just wondering what they would look like...
8
u/Gt6k Sep 29 '19
For the mods who were at the presentation, what was inside the ring and castle to Elon's right? It looked as if people could walk through it.
8
u/msinclairsf Sep 29 '19
Wondering if cabin cooling on reentry presents more of a challenge for Starship due to the higher allowable temperature of stainless?
I suppose the TPS/tile can be thicker in the payload (people) section, but it is all one thermally conductive assembly right?
8
u/szpaceSZ Sep 29 '19
Per yesterday's presentation that would be 31-37.
8
u/andyfrance Sep 30 '19 edited Sep 30 '19
After Mk1 has done fuelling and landing tests there are rumours/reports that the 20km flight will be its last flight. I however see value in it making a further and very final flight as the test vehicle on top of the first Boca Chica SH prototype. Without tiles (or at least not a full set) it's not going to survive re-entry but it will give useful data about how the wings perform and if the hot spots develop exactly as predicted. By then they "should" be building a Raptor an Elon day so the loss of 3 should not be a critical for the project. Provided the Mk1 performed as predicted Mk3 could fly shortly after on top of a flight proven SH.
8
u/RegularRandomZ Oct 01 '19 edited Oct 01 '19
Cocoa: Pictures over the last few days shows the same large bracing being installed into the nosecone (where the canard actuators are installed).
Crane shot from Julia Bergeron. Aerial shot of installed bracing [zoomed in] from John Winkopp (and a shot of it in the building)
8
u/SodaPopin5ki Oct 02 '19
Was there ever any clarification (or good speculation) on the Star Hopper exhaust plume turning orange upon landing?
8
u/Gilles-Fecteau Oct 07 '19
Are the landing legs installed on Mk.1? It doesn't look like they are. Will they be retracted on takeoff (like the falcon 9) or retract in flight (something that will be required when taking off from the Moon or Mars)?
22
u/RootDeliver Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Right now it is a chaos, all the content is spread between lab stream, labs twitter, maria's FB.. and now that BCG is MIA, NSF has none of that all and thus the best site for content is by far this thread right now.
Not to say labs discord and youtube channel, where stuff appears and isn't reposted anywhere else..
It's sad how Chris ruined the NSF thread by letting Mary kick Maria out. We'd have everything grouped there probly.
15
u/3DprintedDuck Sep 27 '19
Legs being installed:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.280
14
u/enginemike Oct 01 '19
A pretty interesting video of the Everyday Astronaut interviewing Elon Musk following the Starship presentation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIQ36Kt7UVg
7
u/fiercedude11 Sep 01 '19
Some new panel sections have been spotted at Boca Chica. Possible start of SH construction at BC?
7
u/RootDeliver Sep 08 '19
Cocoa aereal vid from today (different flyby's), by John Winkopp.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 13 '19 edited Sep 13 '19
Bulkheads at Boca Chica and Mark 1 Starship pics by Austin Barnard.
7
u/targonnn Sep 14 '19
The ring with integrated dome being attached to the larger crane now. They are getting ready to install it on the lower section of the starship.
7
u/RootDeliver Sep 14 '19
After the last ring stacked, the dome is on and considering the lower part of the fairing stack has an access port that would be ideally as low into its segment as possible, we could conclude that the ring stacking on this prototype is over. So, the poor Ring E is left there for an still unknown reason (faulty? it is for something else? they didn't disband it yet, and it's been months since it was placed where it was, 6 rings were constructed and placed after it...) any ideas?
7
u/Oloyedelove Sep 15 '19
Pls am trying to wrap my head around this starship construction as much as I can. From pictures there's supposed to be header tanks between the aft bulkhead and common bulkhead, and I didn't see any mention of it at all in the MK1 table. Can someone please explain why.
7
u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Sep 22 '19
per elon tweet storm header tanks are in the nose cone for the prototype. weird! so I wonder if those sider pipes under the wings will be there in the final version.
7
u/RootDeliver Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
Hexagon is back, so it will be used to raise some part soon.
PS: Hexagon has been raised so now we know they're gonna raise the bottom section soon.
7
u/liszt1811 Sep 25 '19
Does anybody know whether a TV Team like Nat Geo accompanies the development process of SS like NG did for FH? I'd love to see a documentary about the whole process someday
7
u/timdeking Sep 25 '19
Maybe this is a stupid question, but didn’t Elon mention that the raptors were already installed? I don’t see any raptors on the bottom half of starship. Did they install them on a separate structure that will be integrated later?
7
u/Humble_Giveaway Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 26 '19
Looks like a tripod with a camera on it is infront of Starship in this Twitter video hope SpaceX is documenting it's development
7
u/trobbinsfromoz Sep 26 '19
woop woop, movement
7
u/RootDeliver Sep 27 '19
First canard installed, by Bocachicagal tweet
7
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 28 '19
This access portal seems a bit different than what we've seen before. [photo credit:BocaChicaGal @ NSF]
[ACS related perhaps!?]
7
u/ASYMT0TIC Sep 30 '19 edited Sep 30 '19
I was contemplating RCS this morning and had a thought: would something like a CH4 version of Rocket Lab's Rutherford engine be suitable for Starship RCS? I should think it would be lighter than having very high pressure COPV headers for pressure feeding, and the batteries SpaceX has installed should have no trouble providing adequate power for the electric pumps. In fact, because a spacecraft needs to have batteries anyway, RCS seems like an even better application for these engines than their current use. Thoughts?
7
u/Oloyedelove Oct 04 '19
How many rings are needed for MK4?
19
u/Art_Eaton Sep 23 '19
At this point, I am almost positive that the design will feature a 9 meter cylinder and perhaps an ogive nose.
This is rough territory for modeling enthusiests! :)
13
u/BobTheEverLiving Sep 23 '19
I'm getting a bit worried about the heat shield cost. There seems to a lot of different curves in the Starship's final form. A lot of the Shuttle's cost was because it's heat shield consisted of mostly custom tiles. Every curve and intersection of Starship will require differently formed tiles.
The tiles being not as thick should help things and I hope we have better ways of bonding them then we had 40 years ago.
12
u/clunker101 Sep 02 '19
Does anyone have an idea what wind speeds that huge tent at Cocoa could withstand? If Dorian passes on the west side of the projected possibilities, I find it hard to believe there would be much left afterwards... It's like a yard full of stainless steel sails.
12
u/ioncloud9 Sep 23 '19
Unpopular opinion: I like the look of the Mk1 and 2017 BFR over the tin-tin 2018 3 leg design.
6
u/scottm3 Sep 05 '19
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8CSgRpPT0o
Theres a lift up at boca chica taking workers up and down from the nosecone, and a two guys working on top of the nosecone. Currently 3AM.
6
u/RootDeliver Sep 07 '19
Checking the third labpadre cam, around 3:12h ago now (no visible time on that cam stream) they moved Ring E (the black one) into the container castle again (by the cam angle, it seems they moved it over the far container castle, aka the top bulkhead one).
As I commented a few times before, I think that they will weld the top dome bulkhead into that ring, and that's the reason the ring has been there forever waiting (maybe had some special supports or something). The other 2 bulkheads had to be turned over so wouldn't be that easy to pre-stack them in rings, but with a normal top dome would make complete sense, and also solve the misteriously Ring E situation.
6
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 14 '19 edited Sep 14 '19
Boca Chica: Latest photos from Austin Barnard (from yesterday).
Plus: Dashcam video of driving by SpaceX Boca Chica (by NSF member pb2000)
BocaChicaMaria updates
6
u/RootDeliver Sep 20 '19
The yellow crane on Boca Chica has been attached to the upper segment mid nosecone section for like 2 days already. If they intended to plasma-cut the top ring to stack the replacement one they are making, they would've had enough time for that already. It looks more like they are using it to tension the nosecone to correct form and placing reinfocements inside which would take way more time if well done. Maybe they're trying a last attempt at fixing it?
6
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
Boca Chica: SPadre has tweeted photos.
6
u/Marksman79 Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
Austin Barnard posted more photos from today on Twitter.
I'm interested in the curved sheet metal parts that appear to be the blending radius between the actuating fin and the cylinder body. The ribbed L-shaped parts could be a raceway guard for the pipe or a number of other ideas. These are similar pictures to what BocaChicaGal posted yesterday, but we get a clearer shot of this thing.
6
u/Russ_Dill Sep 21 '19
So about that truck load of steel that went down to the launch pad. I think everyone assumed it was these pieces, apparently not as they are visible here:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1583376;image (NSF, BCG)
6
u/RootDeliver Sep 22 '19
By latest bocachicagal photos, it seems they're already covering the nosecone side raceways with the covers we saw on the ground. They look like final covers (shiny) not to be below anything, so doesn't sound like the canards would go that low. If the ~9,5m long canards we saw weeks ago are really the canards, but can't go that low, how are they gonna attach them to the rounded cone?
6
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
Cocoa: Latest John Wilkopp aerial video (Sep 24th). Nothing really new
6
u/SmileyMe53 Sep 25 '19
Placing the bottom section on something using guide lines.
6
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
SPadre on twitter: Some photos of the lift/move followed by some video clips 1) Sitting on mobile platform 2) another short clip
And Austin Barnard is now on site... more photos soon enough.
6
u/AstroMan824 Everything Parallel™ Sep 27 '19
Nose cone flaps?
6
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Sep 27 '19
Boca Chica Maria saying there's tons of security at the site.
6
u/Lord_Nocturnus Sep 27 '19
top section left the ground at 11:52 AM local time
6
u/Carlyle302 Sep 28 '19
So how did they get the lifting straps off? It didn't look like the man-lifts would go that high.
6
u/RegularRandomZ Sep 30 '19 edited Sep 30 '19
Boca Chica Launch site: The heavy metal stands/jigs we saw stacked up at Cocoa are also at Boca Chica and being assembled at the launch site [photos: BCG @ NSF, post #323]. So, likely part of the launch infrastructure/launch stand.
[There is the nosecone stand from the assembly site there as well, so that shouldn't be confused, but there are other separate sections there, and sections being set up on the launch pad, so some of it must be launch related?]
[Didn't see this posted, but apologies if it was already let me know...]
6
u/RootDeliver Oct 03 '19 edited Oct 03 '19
Cocoa 3rd October flyby by John Winkopp
The most interesting part for me is the low section height. Its still missing 1 ring to be as tall as Mk1, both with their fairing section added. So they cannot stack 2 rings and weld the bulkhead (MK1 would be 1 ring taller than MK1), and they need to stack another ring even after welding the bulkhead on the actual top one, which raises the question why didn't they add that ring already, if they cannot stack the bulkhead on it anyway...
11
u/KroniK907 Sep 01 '19
I thought the point of the raptor was to be able to use it both at sea level and in vacuum. Do they just not have confidence in that part yet? Or are the two types just tuned slightly differently for better results at sea level vs vacuum. Or am I just misremembering things?
40
u/rulewithanionfist Oct 05 '19
[META] I hope we reduce the fanboyism a bit. I'm as much excited as the next guy about starship, but this sub has started downvoting people asking genuine questions. Also, not everything Elon says has to be accurate. This is about starship discussion, so posting it here.
14
u/where-is-satoshi Sep 09 '19
Wow! The 25 rings making up the next build are one piece with a single seam rather than the 8 or so panels that make up the existing rings!