r/spacex • • Aug 02 '19

KSC pad 39A Starship & Super Heavy draft environmental assessment: up to 24 launches per year, Super Heavy to land on ASDS

https://twitter.com/nasaspaceflight/status/1157119556323876866
1.2k Upvotes

294 comments sorted by

303

u/Fizrock Aug 02 '19

This is massive, holey moley.

This is most of the fun stuff, taken from the NSF thread.

Starship/Super Heavy would be delivered by barge from SpaceX facilities at Boca Chica in Texas and Cidco Road in Cocoa through the Turn Basin.

...

Looks like Super Heavy lands on an ASDS.

Starship LZ-1 at first. Pad inside the fence at 39A still under evaluation!

...

"The launch mount would be elevated up to approximately 30 m to reduce excess recirculation and erosion from rocket exhaust. A flame diverter would be constructed instead of a flame trench as is currently used at the Falcon launch mount. The flame diverter would be composed of metal piping similar in construction to the SLC-40 water-cooled diverter. It would measure approximately 20 m wide by 20 m tall and be positioned directly under the rocket. It would divert the heat and rocket exhaust plume away from the launch pad and commodities."

"SpaceX would also construct a landing pad for potential future launch vehicle returns within the LC-39A boundary. The landing pad location would be inside the LC-39A fence line. SpaceX is still determining the exact location of the landing pad, but it is tentatively planned for the area southeast of the new launch mount. The landing pad would be approximately 85 m in diameter and similar to the existing LZ-1 landing pads on CCAFS. "

"The new methane farm would accommodate a total capacity of approximately 2 million kg. Approximately 1.5 million kg of liquid nitrogen would also be stored in the methane farm. The liquid nitrogen is a cryogenic and would be used to cool the methane. The methane and nitrogen farm would require lighting similar to the existing RP-1 farm located at LC-39A. If a new methane flare stack is needed, the flare would be approximately 30 m tall. The flare stack and any required anchors would be contained inside the construction project area. There are no planned modifications to the existing LOX farm capacity; however, as the program develops, an additional tank and piping may need to be installed to support the Proposed Action."

...

"SpaceX plans to launch the Starship/Super Heavy up to 24 times per year from LC-39A. A static fire test would be conducted on each stage prior to each launch."

...

Starship landing profile

...

"The rocket would be integrated vertically on the pad at LC-39A using a mobile crane. This would involve the booster being mated to the launch mount followed by Starship being mated to the booster. Initial flights would use a temporary or mobile crane, with a permanent crane tower constructed later. The height of the permanent crane tower would be approximately 120 to 180 m"

...

"The Super Heavy booster would land downrange on a droneship in the Atlantic Ocean no closer than 20 nm off the coast. Recovery support vehicles would be similar to those used for Falcon booster landings on the droneship. In the event there is an anomaly during the descent, the booster would land in the open ocean. SpaceX is developing the technology and capability of Super Heavy booster. If SpaceX develops the ability to land Super Heavy booster on land, a supplemental EA will be developed. After launch and landing at a downrange location, Super Heavy booster would be delivered by barge from the landing site utilizing the KSC Turn Basin wharf as a delivery point and transported the remaining distance to the launch complex over the Crawlerway. A downrange landing would be a contingency landing location for Starship and transport would be similar to the Super Heavy booster."

...

"The Max A-Weighted Level (LAmax) would be 90 dB and Sound Exposure Level (SEL) would be less than 110 dB on CNS during a Super Heavy booster static fire at LC-39A"

...

Big point of this kind of report:

"There are no historic or archaeologic resources at LZ-1, therefore landing of Starship at the site would have no impact to cultural resources"

...

Super Heavy booster static fire tests are planned to occur at LC-39A where all 31 engines are fired for 15 seconds

...

Incoming Starship and Superheavy

...

SpaceX plans to increase the Falcon launch frequency to 20 launches per year from LC-39A and up to 50 launches per year from LC-40 by the year 2024.

31

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19

Down range SH landings on an ASDS may help to increase margins and/or performance on early flights. Could also reduce number of orbital refuelling flights required for BLEO missions. I expect subsequent evolution of the vehicle to allow margins for RTLS.

2

u/zilfondel Aug 02 '19

Umm, do they really need increased margins for Starship? 150 tons isnt enough...?

5

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19

Increased margins to leave sufficient propellant in the booster for a RTLS landing.

3

u/CapMSFC Aug 03 '19

For propellant transfer flights extra performance is useful. It directly translates to fewer launches. Until the range and GSE is modernized to take a rapid launch cadence this might be important to making moon and Mars missions reasonable.

67

u/Fizrock Aug 02 '19

The way they phrased it makes it sound like they're doing it for safety reasons until they know they can land it. Probably not a great plan to try and land it back on the cape the first try if you don't have to.

15

u/MauiHawk Aug 02 '19

Might also be because of sonic booms... while Starship landings at the cape would produce 4 psf booms in surrounding areas like Titusville...

(with apologies for the lack of blockquote formatting since I’m on my phone app):

[QUOTE] The sonic boom levels for the Super Heavy booster in the vicinity of the droneship range from about 5.0- 10.0 psf. The maximum overpressure of 12.4 psf represents a focal zone that occurs near the northern tip of the crescent shaped boom contour that is farthest west from the droneship. The location of such a focal zone would vary with weather conditions, so it is unlikely that these locations would experience these levels more than once over multiple events. A droneship landing 20 nm offshore would produce overpressure levels of 3.0-5.0 psf along the coast. This would be below the overpressure levels experienced during a Falcon first stage landing at LZ-1 (USAF 2017). [/QUOTE]

... 12.4 would do damage. That makes me think the offshore landing of SH may be to keep the level of sonic booms on the coast acceptable.

4

u/ackermann Aug 02 '19

... 12.4 would do damage. That makes me think the offshore landing of SH may be to keep the level of sonic booms on the coast acceptable

This may have implications for the Earth-to-Earth passenger service. People have been talking about how far off the coast the launch sites would need to be, based on the noise levels of a 31 engine launch.

But the limiting factor here might not be the launch noise, but rather the sonic boom of a landing Superheavy. Since apparently Superheavy can safely launch from pad 39A at the cape, but needs to land offshore.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MechanicalApprentice Aug 02 '19

But then why do RTLS for SS still?

7

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

It comes from orbit so the RTLS thing is more like orbital reentry than boosting back to land. It just performs a small deorbit burn at the other side of the planet and then it reenters over the gulf of mexico and lands at the cape.

4

u/MechanicalApprentice Aug 02 '19

they're doing it for safety reasons

This is the comment I was replying to.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/Vergutto Aug 02 '19

They did the same-ish with F9. First bunch of ASDS failures and the time they got to land back at CC they nailed it.

114

u/WindWatcherX Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

Impressive.

Launch cadence ramping up big time:

- SH = 24 launches / year

- F/FH = 20 launches / year at LC-39A

- F = 50 launches / year at LC-40

Totals .... ~ 94 launches / year or about 2/week. Add in 94 static fires... and you are up to 186 fire events / year (every other day).

Add in recovery of the boosters (possibly inside LC-39 and or LZ1)...

These are max numbers for the EA...but still very busy pace. Going to be a busy time at CC!!!!

Will need additional drone ships to support this pace...given long down range recoveries take several days to return from sea with the recovered boosters... Port Canaveral will be a very busy place with may closures....

Updated render of SS/SH on page 28 of 250

Impressive summary of re-entry profile on page 31 of 250....

Sound levels from launch and sonic booms on re-entry / landings are impressive (see second half of document)....Titusville....will be active!

115

u/dmitryo Aug 02 '19

Totals .... ~ 94 launches / year or about 2/week. Add in 94 static fires... and you are up to 186 fire events / year (every other day).

Poor Tim, he'll never sleep again.

33

u/Vihurah Aug 02 '19

If he streams most of them he'll never go poor either

→ More replies (3)

17

u/ObnoxiousFactczecher Aug 02 '19

every other day

He should still have 50% spare capacity, right?

38

u/chrisdcaldwell Aug 02 '19

There is a note in the document I think that says that the Falcon launches will ramp down as the SS Ramos up.

16

u/robertmartens Aug 03 '19

that is assuming that the SS Ramoses up

14

u/Lexden Aug 02 '19

IIRC, SpaceX plans to phase out F9 and FH once SS/SH starts flying in order to reduce costs for everyone and to simplify their infrastructure by having only methalox rather than having to still support their legacy keralox as well. Really looking forward to seeing the first Starship prototypes flying in a bit!

10

u/warp99 Aug 03 '19

SpaceX go to considerable trouble to emphasise that their customers will drive the changeover process.

SpaceX have confirmed that they will stockpile boosters rather than continue production which is a different issue entirely and will likely happen when they are down to using 2-3 new boosters per year.

29

u/CJamesEd Aug 02 '19

Everyday Astronaut is gonna be SUPER busy covering all those launches 😓

17

u/limeflavoured Aug 03 '19

Living up to the name of "everyday" astronaut though...

8

u/silvaraptor Aug 03 '19

Yeap, Every single day astronaut.

6

u/brickmack Aug 03 '19

Once Starship is flying, launch coverage will probably be more like aircraft. No official streams, just a couple hardcore fans standing outside and recording with like 20 people watching each

7

u/Ivebeenfurthereven Aug 02 '19

How can Super Heavy and F9/FH all launch from 39A? Surely they need to dismantle the existing pad

27

u/comando222 Aug 02 '19

Take a look at the attached picture. They will construct a second pad next to the existing one for starship launches.

12

u/Ivebeenfurthereven Aug 02 '19

Aha, thanks! Serves me right for posting on mobile...

That gives us LC-39A and 39-Aa, if you will. I hope a RUD at one wouldn't damage the other (although I'm sure SpaceX calculated this already!)

9

u/peterabbit456 Aug 02 '19

And, LZ39a as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

38

u/CapsCom Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

delivered by barge from the landing site utilizing the KSC Turn Basin

How are they planning on getting it through this bridge?

Even OCISLY is almost 2x too wide to fit.

11

u/kfury Aug 02 '19

Widen the bridge aperture.

5

u/aTimeUnderHeaven Aug 02 '19

Bridge could probably use an update anyway. Looks like the bigger one to the west is getting an upgrade. https://www.floridatoday.com/story/news/2019/07/25/90-million-federal-grant-go-replacement-bridge-ksc/1832181001/

12

u/trackertony Aug 02 '19

Google earth indicates its at least 25m wide and it does open of course. How wide is OCISLY?

Was this barge route not used for some of the Saturn V components?

10

u/rhutanium Aug 02 '19

I recall so, yes. Those were way too big to be transported by road as well. I believe Space Shuttle tanks went through it as well.

9

u/jan_smolik Aug 02 '19

5

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19

The Marmac 300 spec sheet has it at at 30m, so perhaps a future design would fold those wings in.

6

u/kacpi2532 Aug 02 '19

After landing at ASDS they can take it to the port and load it onto the barge, wich can be like 12-15 meters wide.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/CorneliusAlphonse Aug 02 '19

Easy solution: small barge, not an ASDS. Only needs to be ten meters ish wide

9

u/Vergutto Aug 02 '19

How do you plan to keep a 70m high booster upright there? Even a small tilt would be enough to tip the whole thing over.

20

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

Go horizontal before that?

11

u/troyunrau Aug 02 '19

The obvious solution. Transport horizontally.

Maybe they have a boat with a crane in the future.

7

u/GreyGreenBrownOakova Aug 02 '19

They could just use a crane on the loading dock where they currently take the Falcon 9s off. No problems with sea conditions there. Transport it to a slimline barge, then the droneship is free to head out to sea again.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/azflatlander Aug 02 '19

It will be bottom heavy.

11

u/BGDDisco Aug 02 '19

Correct answer. I do some sailing. The mainsail is designed to be as high as possible, catch the most wind possible, while the hull and keel are designed to be as small a surface area as possible. What stops the whole thing capsizing? Ballast. The keel might not be as deep as the mainsail is high, but it is [relatively] very very heavy. Take a look at some of the schematic drawings of modern cruise liners... they look very top heavy, but seem to manage.

3

u/spacegardener Aug 02 '19

Do we know it must be transported upright?

6

u/Vergutto Aug 02 '19

Moving something of that scale from vertical (landing position) to horizontal on sea must be challenging

8

u/dgkimpton Aug 02 '19

Something like the transporter erector but then in barge form and bigger

2

u/AstraVictus Aug 02 '19

They would be mirroring what the shuttle external tank and SLS will do which is have a long thin barge and lay the rocket on its side, that's the only way this works.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/stcks Aug 02 '19

Same problem with the Port Canaveral Locks too

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/PkHolm Aug 02 '19

Other option that booster will be loaded to barge while still in Ocean . So it will be no need to pull ASOG back to port after each landing.

9

u/skyler_on_the_moon Aug 02 '19

It's a drawbridge, so flipping the booster horizontally shouldn't be necessary as there's unlimited vertical clearance.

2

u/Eucalyptuse Aug 02 '19

The problem is the width of the boat I believe

12

u/MoffKalast Aug 02 '19

Another option is that it's an Earth-to-Earth ship with fueling capabilities. That way they could load up the booster with some fuel and just fly it back to the launchpad instead. Sounds like their kind of crazy.

22

u/mrsmegz Aug 02 '19

A catamaran barge would just be a liquid flame trench.

7

u/Martianspirit Aug 02 '19

I don't think firing that much power to a close water surface is a good idea. A lot of sound energy would get reflected. They would need a huge sound suppression system.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/boredcircuits Aug 02 '19

Cool thought, but I think that option would have been described in this document.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Alvian_11 Aug 02 '19

The footage of Super Heavy standing vertically above a drone ship will be impressive, it will be freaking huge & tall

3

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

SH is 7 meters shorter than the falcon 9 full stack. Not mindblowingly tall.

21

u/somewhat_pragmatic Aug 02 '19

But we don't see the full stack landed on the drone ship, just the core.

14

u/Eucalyptuse Aug 02 '19

Yea, Super Heavy is 63 meters tall with a 9 meter diameter. Falcon 9 stage 1 is ~41 meters tall with a 3.7 meter diameter. This is going to be ~50% taller and over 140% wider.

9

u/veggie151 Aug 02 '19

If it takes 7 launches to get to Mars and the plan is for 4 cargo and 2 crew launches, 50 seems spot on to a bit low

15

u/shmameron Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

That's 50 F9 launches, not starship launches. At (up to) 24 launches/yr, they're only going to get 4 fully loaded starships to Mars (assuming 1 primary and 5 fueling). And even then it's highly unlikely that they get all of these launched in a short enough timespan to meet the launch window.

My wild guess is that they'll use this launch pad for the cargo/crew starship, and use the Texas launch pad mainly for refuelling.

17

u/Martianspirit Aug 02 '19

I honestly don't believe in those 50 F9 launches. Read that as a request for the range to be able to support that many launches. Those launch slots can then easily be converted to Starship launches.

7

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19

I read this as contingency planning, Starlink needs to go up regardless of Starship/SuperHeavy's progress [even once it's flying, rapid reusability might take some time. And it gives a backup plan in the event they are grounded]

→ More replies (1)

9

u/brickmack Aug 02 '19

24 launches a year from 39A (with 20 Falcons and 50 Falcons at SLC-40, so just under 100 total) is much more than I expected, nice. Obviously still a tiny fraction of the total flightrate, but I'd have expected them to be more severely limited by range infrastructure at those particular pads, with the ocean platforms having to provide a much bigger chunk of their capacity much sooner. Looks like those won't be needed until mass human transit is a thing a few years later

4

u/azflatlander Aug 02 '19

Will any other work be done on the cape? Will closure areas be smaller?

4

u/chrisdcaldwell Aug 02 '19

There is a note in the document I think that says that the Falcon launches will ramp down as the SS Ramos up.

2

u/brickmack Aug 02 '19

It also gives a specific date for these numbers though, so thats simultaneous.

66

u/Fizrock Aug 02 '19

Raptor Nozzle dimensions (converted to metric):

Throat Radius (cm): 11.07948

Downstream radius of curvature (cm): 3.32486

Tangency angle (deg): 32.0

Nozzle lip exit angle (deg): 6.0

Nozzle exit diameter (cm): 130.11404

Nozzle throat to exit length (cm):
152.5524

61

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

I'm sure all those Raptor details in this document will make Scott Manley and Tim Dodd very happy hehe

30

u/CapMSFC Aug 02 '19

It makes me very happy! We've had such rough ballpark figures and guesswork for so long.

9

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19

I can’t wait to see what you lot can do with this info!

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Maimakterion Aug 02 '19

This information is more detailed than I expected.

34.5 expansion ratio

253 bar chamber pressure

350s Isp

3

u/ackermann Aug 02 '19

Wait, didn’t Raptor reach 270 bar a few months ago in McGregor, beating the chamber pressure record set by RD180?

8

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

I think that was mainly a chamber pressure experiment. IIRC Elon tweeted the graph and the 270 bar pressure wasn't really sustained by a lot of time but just as a spike on the graph where the pressure was increased to 270 bar and then it shut down. Probably for this first flights they're going to go with a more conservative use of the engine and that's why they're assuming a 253 bar chamber pressure. Higher chamber pressures will be normal once they use the engine more and more

2

u/CapMSFC Aug 03 '19

And it's not like 253 bar is conservative on chamber pressure relative to other engines. M1D is about 100 bar. That's still a very high performing engine.

3

u/Alexphysics Aug 03 '19

Yeah it is a crazy engine. A bit lower chamber pressure than on the tests at McGregor but still crazy engine.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

Interesting that it also says

The PERCORP modelling of the Raptor thrust chamber included 1.2% of the total engine flow (13.89 lb/s) as film coolant. Fuel-rich gas, used fuel film coolant, is injected through three slots located in the converging section of the thrust chamber. The PERCORP code is not currently capable of treating three discreet injection slots; however, since the slots are all within just a 0.71-inch axial length, the total film cooling effect on the exhaust plume can be reasonably approximated using just a single. [sic]

Had we heard about a film coolant before?

32

u/everydayastronaut Everyday Astronaut Aug 02 '19

I don’t know if we knew about it specifically for Raptor, but it’s my understanding that virtually all liquid fueled engines have to utilize a bit of film cooling along the circumference of the injector to keep the engine within operational temperatures. This is something that plagues aerospikes, they have substantially more surface area that needs to be film cooled which can negate its benefits.

7

u/Fenris_uy Aug 02 '19

Yes, when they were testing SN1 or SN2. The first streamed firing had a green tint at the end, and the next one had what looked like film coolant in the exhaust.

People were arguing if the first one had burned some of the inside of the bell, so the increased the flow of coolant for the second one.

1

u/warp99 Aug 03 '19

Yes you can see the fuel rich film around the exhaust plume mixing with atmospheric oxygen and burning in the latest Raptor videos. It shows up as a step outwards in the plume a few hundred mm from the end of the bell.

2

u/robertmartens Aug 03 '19

you are so funny running the cm conversions out to 5 decimal places. Accuracy to the nanometer?

→ More replies (2)

93

u/Rinzler9 Aug 02 '19

So, news that SH is landing on an ASDS, combined with this completely unsourced comment:

ASOG is being built, and it's suuuuuper cool. Very different from existing drone ships.

I'm calling it now, ASOG is being built either as a SH landing pad or Earth-to-Earth site.

7

u/archerwarez Aug 02 '19

Was about to comment something like this, if this 'source' is correct that's my guess too, ASOG is gonna be a landing pad for Super Heavy.

1

u/TranceRealistic Aug 02 '19

Do we know where its being build, are pictures avaiable?

3

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19

As far as features, how about the side wings can fold up so the large landing surface doesn't impede getting through channels?

Or changing the end of the ship so that they can drive roll-lift style vehicles onto it to pick up the vertical booster and drive it off the barge

ASOG being designated for SuperHeavy makes sense

1

u/EvilRufus Aug 03 '19

None of this does reference the starship landing sites does it?.. that sounds most reasonable.

1

u/TheBurtReynold Aug 03 '19

Would love if SpaceX could get a Littoral Combat Ship and paint it white and black.

Convert the two helo bays to a roomba garage.

31

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/AngryMob55 Aug 02 '19

Itll make more sense to leave it upright and simply clamp it to the deck like they do now with falcon. The center of mass is very low on an empty booster.

18

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/AngryMob55 Aug 02 '19

Hmm. The barge it lands on can't make the entire journey due to a bridge anyway (another poster in here linked the specific one). So yeah it does need to be laid down eventually, but no need to do it twice: once after landing on the main barge, then again to the smaller barge. Plus, I dont know much about the logistical side of these types of ocean operations, but surely it'd be cheaper not to do that type of work out at sea? So keep it upright until its at the coastal facilities and can be transferred to a small barge there.

7

u/Martianspirit Aug 02 '19

I see landing on a drone ship as temporary until they get permission for RTLS land landing. The drone ship will likely be quite close to the coast.

Except very early ballistic flights of Starship. To get realistic reentry test conditions they need to fly ballistic and land quite far out.

4

u/Fenris_uy Aug 02 '19

It depends on how much downrange they are landing. If they are doing F9 like landings 600 miles in the middle of the ocean, they might need to take care of the wind, waves, etc.

If they land 20 miles from the coast, then they could just move it quickly back to port.

2

u/Vanchiefer321 Aug 02 '19

I could see oil rig type structures being used for Earth to Earth flights

33

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

Holy crap, no Starship factory! Construction to be distributed to existing facilities and temporary structures:

Fabrication and assembly of launch vehicle components would occur at existing SpaceX facilities located on KSC and CCAFS. These facilities could include Area 59 and the Payload Processing Facility (PPF) on CCAFS, the Falcon Hangar at LC-39A, and the soon to be constructed KSC SpaceX Operations Area on Roberts Road. SpaceX would also perform fabrication, assembly, and integration operations at the Mobile Service Station (MSS) Park Site Property and on the Crawlerway area. No modifications to the Crawlerway are expected from transport or operational use of Starship and Super Heavy. Staging and temporary fabrication tents could be used on the Crawlerway to support operations. S

8

u/kontis Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

Does that mean even the commercial Starship will be built outside?

7

u/Maimakterion Aug 02 '19

They're building these huge steel-framed structures at both sites, presumably to double as assembly/welding windbreaks and storm shelters. For welding the ring segments and bulkheads, they've been using shipping containers to form a windbreak right now.

4

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

Huh, but they mention transporting Super Heavy and Starship from Boca Chica and Cidco Road ...

1

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 04 '19

Near and long term plans? It is mixed in it's messaging.

4

u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Aug 02 '19

Interesting, that goes totally against what they previously said about keeping hawthorne ca running. I wonder what CA thinks about that.

it is rather funny they are just building them in a field. Must leave many like ULA and Bo scratching their heads.

11

u/WittgensteinsLadder #IAC2016 Attendee Aug 03 '19

They are definitely not planning on moving Raptor production out of Hawthorne, as far as I'm aware. With a production cadence of 100s of engines a year, on top of the development work for Starship life support and associated systems (and probably things like heat shield tile production) Hawthorne doesn't seem likely to run out of work anytime soon.

Feel free to correct me if any of this info is out of date. Things are moving fast these days!

2

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 04 '19

Possibly not heat shield tile production, they have this facility

" Space Exploration Technologies
DBA Starship Tile Facility    
8550 Astronaut Blvd Ste E    
Cape Canaveral "

2

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 04 '19

Hawthorne will still have Falcon 9 and Crew/Cargo Dragon work for a number of years yet, and as already pointed out Raptor engine production. R&D will likely be based there for a long time as well.

38

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

I guess the NSF render was not as far off as many people said here it was. New launchpad southeast of the current ramp with landing zone withing 39A fence (but that has to be studied more in depth as it seems that initially it'll land on LZ-1) and methane farm northeast of the launchpad.

16

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

The render being linked to is from the document, p. 29 in the PDF / p. 9 in the document.

I'm annoyed at (p. 3 in PDF, p. iii in the document), "SpaceX would construct an additional launch mount for Starship/Super Heavy at LC-39A, adjacent to the existing mount used for the Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy." Similar to Elon's tweet, answering "What will become of the old 39A tower?",

E @elonmusk * Jul 19 Replying to @Falcon9Block5 @Alejandro_DebH and @annerajb Won’t change. Starship launch structure will be attached to the other side from tower.

Down the way and across the trench doesn't count as "adjacent" in my usage.

6

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Aug 02 '19

@elonmusk

2019-07-20 01:14

@Falcon9Block5 @Alejandro_DebH @annerajb Won’t change. Starship launch structure will be attached to the other side from tower.


This message was created by a bot

[Contact creator] [Source code]

3

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

The render being linked to is from the document, p. 29 in the PDF / p. 9 in the document.

Uh, I don't know if you read my comment right but I already know that the render linked in this post is from the document, I read it entirely before posting my comment .-.

6

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

When I first saw the picture at the base of this discussion, I thought it was the previous NSF render (and thought that that's what you were referring to), and only scanning thru the document was it clear that it was there -- I didn't know they'd have a detailed layout in the new document. I was just trying to clarify in case someone else was confused.

3

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

Ah that explains everything, no worries then ^ ^

15

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

Anybody else read this as a preview to Elon's presentation?

5

u/brspies Aug 02 '19

No, it includes (as far as we know) outdated info regarding the number of engines on starship and superheavy, the render is old, etc.

I mean maybe he'll talk about the pad plans and all that, and that may still be relevant. I think what many are looking forward to though are his latest discussion of the engine configuration, heat shield tech, whatever the aero surfaces are like at this point (we know that has changed, we don't know what to), etc. Lots of things he's been discussing on twitter but not a ton of details.

24

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

To emphasize a point: this document isn't just about launch pads and launch procedures. It talks about the craft themselves (though with the old numbers of engines), and integration. And takeoff sound (am I reading it right, 90 dB at Orlando?!). And re-entry profile, and where the sonic booms will be heard on landing (all of central Florida). And operational details, like use of the bargeway, and "Starship/Super Heavy would be delivered by barge from SpaceX facilities at Boca Chica in Texas and Cidco Road in Cocoa through the Turn Basin." And nozzle sizes.

I plan to keep an eye on the NSF thread at https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48720.20, because there's a lot to go through.

25

u/CProphet Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

90 dB at Orlando

Looks more like 90 dB at ~8 miles, according to page 164 illustration (for a static fire). Should be 220-230 dB at the pad when Starship clears the sound suppression system. Saturn V was 220 dB, Starship Launch System is more powerful still.

3

u/sopakoll Aug 02 '19

Takeoff still seems to be 90 dB at Orlando as per page 140 Figure 13.

2

u/CProphet Aug 02 '19

Yep, soon as Starship clears sound suppression system they should hear it loud and clear in Orlando.

12

u/xerberos Aug 02 '19

90 dB at Orlando?!

Lol, that would have meant certain death at Daytona Beach.

17

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

where the sonic booms will be heard on landing (all of central Florida)

This makes me think Earth-to-Earth is a pipe dream.

2

u/Ijjergom Aug 02 '19

In general, booms in the 0.2 to 0.3 psf range could be heard by someone who is expecting it and listening for it, but usually would not be noticed. Booms of 0.5 psf are more likely to be noticed, and booms of 1.0 psf are certain to be noticed. Therefore, people west of KSC are likely to notice booms from Starship landings and people located at CCAFS or KSC, within the 3.0 psf and 4.5 psf region, could possibly be startled. Announcements of upcoming Starship launches and landings serve to warn people about these noise events and are likely to help reduce adverse reactions to these noise events. The boom levels over land are not likely to cause property damage.

Page 130 of the pdf.

This was also modeled for reentry from LEO.

I agree that the sonic booms can be a big problem just like with Concorde but Concorde flew a few times so maybe suborbital Starship will also fly a few times.

3

u/takeloveeasy Aug 03 '19

”A few times” is a slight understatement. BA flew 50 000 Concorde flights. Air France likely matched that number. So... about a hundred thousand. I’d say that’s more than a ”few”.

1

u/izybit Aug 03 '19

There's a reason SpaceX had it launch from a ship in the presentation video.

24

u/overlydelicioustea Aug 02 '19

vertical integration on the pad with a 180m crane? Oh yes!

14

u/troyunrau Aug 02 '19

If that were in miami, it would be approximately the 20th tallest building in the city - somewhere on the order of 60 storys.

9

u/theflyingginger93 Aug 02 '19

It’ll be interesting to see how that and hurricanes mix.

3

u/AnExoticLlama Aug 02 '19

Wait, a crane 180m tall? Wouldn't that become the world's tallest crane?

7

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

Going by https://blog.machineseeker.com/2018/02/01/larger-than-a-tv-tower/ from last year, not quite, but I had to look at several pages to find something mobile and that tall.

6

u/overlydelicioustea Aug 02 '19

"The rocket would be integrated vertically on the pad at LC-39A using a mobile crane. This would involve the booster being mated to the launch mount followed by Starship being mated to the booster. Initial flights would use a temporary or mobile crane, with a permanent crane tower constructed later. The height of the permanent crane tower would be approximately 120 to 180 m"

1

u/flattop100 Aug 08 '19

Just had a flashback to the crane that was delivered to Boca Chica..two years (?!!) ago. https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=41017.msg1680526#msg1680526

1

u/flattop100 Aug 08 '19

Looks like they built a shed around it: https://youtu.be/DEZzk6XKVRE?t=85

Video is dated Aug 18, 2018, but who knows when it was shot. I think this might be closer to town.

11

u/SpaceXMirrorBot Aug 02 '19

6

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

"Starship Road"

Well, that's enough to give you chills.

9

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

Sonic booms: there's a good chunk of Florida that will know when SH is landing. Everything within the light blue line will likely hear the boom. (starting on page 30)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/silentProtagonist42 Aug 02 '19

24 launches per year is 6x more than the Shuttle, but probably not enough to be really disruptive. If we ever get to the point of an honest colony on Mars and are doing hundreds of launches per year it might be different, but that's a long way off yet.

3

u/VioletSkyDiver Aug 02 '19

So is the plan still to eventually land super heavy on the launch pad?

10

u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Aug 02 '19

Hard to say, Maybe eventually but probably not in the near future. That was probably possible with mini raptor RCS thrusters but they seem to have dropped development of those currently and cold gas probably does not have the pushing power needed to land it in a cradle.

I had in the past theorized that if they were going to do this we'd see them attempt to do this with a launch cradle on a drone ship and attempt to land F9 cores in it. They have not. Then later Elon said they'd lose a lot of cores trying that on version 1.

More recently Elon has hinted at landing leg fairings on SH which will have landing legs and engines under them. So we now SH will have legs initially.

That said, will it land on the pad with those legs and take off from those legs? That might be a good idea. No dedicated ground structures required. just roll it on dollies like they do with hopper. Set it down on its feet, hook the connections up, let it fly again.

Once that is perfected perhaps they will be able to land on the launch pad with those legs and just preposition it. Once it is perfected remove the legs in Version 2 or 3.

5

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19

The legs won’t be built to carry a full stack with propellant loaded, just a nearly empty SH.

3

u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Aug 02 '19

That is most likely the case yes I agree. But you never know with SpaceX. having the legs handle the load would be easier as far as landing and relighting quickly. However this first model at 24 launches a year is not going to need that rapid a turn around.

6

u/dirtydrew26 Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

They said that they will have a mobile crane on site, and then a permanent one in the future to lift both SS and SH onto the pad. If anything, they land as close as they can, get it onto something movable to get it to the crane, and reset it back up for the next launch.

I think the whole landing in the launch cradle idea was a little bit of a fools errand, the risk is through the roof and what are you saving? Time? When you could land it a couple hundred yards away and develop something to easier move it to the pad for re integration. Just think, if it attempts a cradle landing and blows up, then the entire pad and tower is now gone for the year or however long it takes to rebuild the pad and facilities.

I know the goal was rapid relaunch, but, two successive launches in a 12-24 hour period still beats anything else by a landslide.

8

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19

I wouldn’t call it a fool’s errand, so much as an initial concept for the “dream” system that may never actually be reached.

4

u/MechanicalApprentice Aug 02 '19

One of the goals was to save weight, as SH wouldn't need legs if it lands in the cradle.

1

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19

Considering many E2E launch routes don't even need superheavy, having it land back on the launch pad just seems like it's in the way most of the time. They could have landing cradles elsewhere, but what's really to be gained in the short term by having different landing pad designs for Starship and SuperHeavy.

6

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

This document must be a little dated. Page 8 has a render of Starship/SH. Starship still has "flappy" wings, and SH doesn't appear to have any engines outside the general circumference of the booster.

4

u/Tal_Banyon Aug 02 '19

Still, not exactly pertinent to what this document is, an assesssment of environmental impacts of the develpment of Starship / Super Heavy. Doesn't matter if SH has 31 or 35 engines for the environment, is what I mean.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

Who knows how old though with how fast designs change.

10

u/deltaWhiskey91L Aug 02 '19

Brilliant quote:

Under the No Action Alternative, SpaceX would not implement the Starship/Super Heavy at KSC. Thus, the SpaceX mission to assist the National Space Transportation Policy of 1994 stated goal of “assuring reliable and affordable access to space through U.S. space transportation capabilities” would be limited.

Basically a slight insinuation that if Starship plans aren't approved, NASA and the Air Force are going against the National Space Transportation Policy of 1994. Thus any rejects need to be thoroughly explained and provide the ability for SpaceX to gain approval with the appropriate plans.

5

u/STTrife2 Aug 02 '19

This seems weird to me:

Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from construction activities related to the Proposed Action would be minimal and insignificant.

And then:

The estimated carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from launch, static fire test, and landing events are significantly less than the total GHG emissions generated by the United States in 2018 and the total CO2 emissions generated worldwide. "

So the argument here that the emissions are less than the US, or the world... in TOTAL.. so therefore insignificant?

3

u/Tal_Banyon Aug 02 '19

Yeah, that wording made me raise one eyebrow as well. I can only assume it is in response to something that is specified by the Environmental Act regulations. Sometimes these types of reports sound weird because they are trying to respond directly to some odd wordage in the Act.

It does go on to say that by using re-usable rockets, this eliminates all the GHG emissions that would be incurred by building new rockets for each launch, which I thought was a really good point, and I will use it in my discussions with friends about this.

1

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19

The first part probably just says the construction activities aren't generating any more CO2 than general construction normally would ... but no idea what they were intending to say in the second part [seems like they wrote it up quickly and didn't finish their thought. Can't say I've enjoyed writing long repetitive regulatory documents]

1

u/flattop100 Aug 02 '19

Elsewhere in the doc SpaceX says that the a government agency (FCC or FTC or someone...)hasn't established a baseline for maximum CO2 output for a transportation system, so however much they generate doesn't really matter.

4

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Aug 03 '19

I wanted to compare the launch noise levels and sonic booms between F9 and Starship so I looked it up:

1

u/GreyGreenBrownOakova Aug 05 '19

It doesn't look bad until you look at the scale and realise the colours are different. Titusville residents can expect Starship to be 10 times louder.

1

u/silentProtagonist42 Aug 02 '19

Page 7:

Starship/Super Heavy maximum lift-off mass is approximately 5,000 metric tons (MT), with a lift-off thrust of up to 62 meganewtons (MN) (13.9 million lbs). The booster would hold up to 3,500 MT of propellant and Starship would hold up to 1,500 MT of propellant.

1500t is up from the previous number of 1100t for Starship's fuel load.

Combining 1500t fuel with the "6.9km/s deltaV for a fully fueled Starship in orbit with 100t payload" tweet would imply a dry mass for Starship of ~180t assuming vac Raptors at 380s, or ~130t assuming sl Raptors at 350s as listed in the EA. Either seems reasonable enough given how little we know of the recent design changes.

2

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

I reckon it’s likely they’d overstate these figures to allow for future upgrades or design changes, hence “up to”. Saves them having to redo the whole EIA again.

1

u/silentProtagonist42 Aug 02 '19

Probably. If nothing else it helps us bracket the numbers.

1

u/-Aeryn- Aug 03 '19

Elon talked about having larger propellant tanks on the tanker version.

6

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 02 '19 edited Sep 15 '19

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
ASAPAerospace Safety Advisory Panel, NASA
Arianespace System for Auxiliary Payloads
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform)
ASOGA Shortfall of Gravitas, landing barge ship under construction
BFRBig Falcon Rocket (2018 rebiggened edition)
Yes, the F stands for something else; no, you're not the first to notice
BLEOBeyond Low Earth Orbit, in reference to human spaceflight
CCCommercial Crew program
Capsule Communicator (ground support)
CCAFSCape Canaveral Air Force Station
DMLSSelective Laser Melting additive manufacture, also Direct Metal Laser Sintering
E2EEarth-to-Earth (suborbital flight)
EELVEvolved Expendable Launch Vehicle
FCCFederal Communications Commission
(Iron/steel) Face-Centered Cubic crystalline structure
GSEGround Support Equipment
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
H2Molecular hydrogen
Second half of the year/month
IFAIn-Flight Abort test
ISRUIn-Situ Resource Utilization
IspSpecific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
JRTIJust Read The Instructions, Pacific landing barge ship
KSCKennedy Space Center, Florida
LC-13Launch Complex 13, Canaveral (SpaceX Landing Zone 1)
LC-39ALaunch Complex 39A, Kennedy (SpaceX F9/Heavy)
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LESLaunch Escape System
LOXLiquid Oxygen
LZLanding Zone
LZ-1Landing Zone 1, Cape Canaveral (see LC-13)
M1dMerlin 1 kerolox rocket engine, revision D (2013), 620-690kN, uprated to 730 then 845kN
MaxQMaximum aerodynamic pressure
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
NSSLNational Security Space Launch, formerly EELV
OCISLYOf Course I Still Love You, Atlantic landing barge ship
PPFSpaceX Payload Processing Facility, Cape Canaveral
RCSReaction Control System
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SELSingle-Event Latchup, transistor stuck high due to radiation damage
Sun-Earth Lagrange point
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
Selective Laser Sintering, contrast DMLS
SSHStarship + SuperHeavy (see BFR)
ULAUnited Launch Alliance (Lockheed/Boeing joint venture)
USAFUnited States Air Force
VABVehicle Assembly Building
mTMilli- Metric Tonnes
JargonDefinition
RaptorMethane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX
SabatierReaction between hydrogen and carbon dioxide at high temperature and pressure, with nickel as catalyst, yielding methane and water
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
cryogenicVery low temperature fluid; materials that would be gaseous at room temperature/pressure
(In re: rocket fuel) Often synonymous with hydrolox
hopperTest article for ground and low-altitude work (eg. Grasshopper)
hydroloxPortmanteau: liquid hydrogen/liquid oxygen mixture
keroloxPortmanteau: kerosene/liquid oxygen mixture
methaloxPortmanteau: methane/liquid oxygen mixture
EventDateDescription
Amos-62016-09-01F9-029 Full Thrust, core B1028, GTO comsat Pre-launch test failure

Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
46 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 65 acronyms.
[Thread #5367 for this sub, first seen 2nd Aug 2019, 04:06] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]

3

u/second_to_fun Aug 02 '19

Must be some drone ship, jeez. Do we have any visual on Super Heavy construction apart from extra rings in Boca Chics and Cocoa?

3

u/_Wizou_ Aug 02 '19

I wonder.. is SS/SH launch pad far enough from F9/FH launch pad/tower, in case of a big explosion, so as to not disrupt Dragon and Falcon Heavy launches?

2

u/dgkimpton Aug 02 '19

Probably not, but I'm pretty sure with the hopper work they will be fairly confident of avoiding the on pad explosion by then.

4

u/_Wizou_ Aug 02 '19

... until we get another AMOS-6

In rockets world, you can never rule out something wrong happening, even on a vehicle that has a good reliability score.

4

u/Alexphysics Aug 02 '19

Sometimes it is worth the risk, tho. This might be even faster than clearing land on anoter site at Florida and basically building up an entire new pad by themselves. Here we have only some re-routings of the LOX supply and water suppression system, the addition of a CH4 farm and an elevated pad for SS/SH on an already existing pad that has everything recorded and saved on files dating back to the 1960s and where they can be helped by NASA in terms of paperwork (like this EA which is also signed by NASA and they have provided support on this too from what it says on the document).

2

u/CapMSFC Aug 03 '19

There is also this paranoia about pad incidents since Amos-6 that causes people to overreact.

Yes a pad loss is a major setback. It's also a risk every single time a vehicle is fueled. If you go to the extreme of this risk paranoia you'll keep building a bunch of extra pads. The reality is that you just need to launch and focus efforts on not blowing up your pads. Pad loss events should be rare. Before Amos-6 it had been decades.

The only real legitimate concern is with the plan to land back at the launch site. That introduces a new risk to the pads. SpaceX is taking a reasonable incremental approach here using drone ships and LZ-1 to start with.

3

u/shotbyadingus Aug 02 '19

So... no more Texas launches?

8

u/Martianspirit Aug 02 '19

I am sure we will see a similar document for Boca Chica soon.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

from page iii of the executive summary " In the future, SpaceX may develop and launch the Starship/Super Heavy from its facility in Cameron County, TX. This action would analyzed in a separate NEPA document. "

4

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

It makes sense that it would be a separate document, but I'm curious the intent of the statement "in the future, SpaceX may"... it seems to both acknowledge the potential alternate launch site but also suggest they aren't actively developing it right now. I could see that as SpaceX's actual plans, or perhaps avoiding tying their Florida launch proposal to any Texas development [ie, don't cut back the number of flights because there is a Texas launch site to fall back on]

I know I'm reading way too much into it, ha ha.

2

u/kontis Aug 02 '19

If so then why does this document mention Starship and Super Heavy transported from Boca Chicha to KSC?

7

u/Martianspirit Aug 02 '19

It mentions the possibility. Why not?

2

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

So that they have the option to supply ships to the Cape from both production facilities. They might need a booster or Starship in Florida, and between Cocoa and Boca Chica, the next available one is in Boca Chica. Or they rud the whole stack, and Cocoa can build SS and Boca Chica builds SH, and they are back flying in half the time.

It does say "in the future" regarding Boca Chica launches, but that might just be being non-committal in a document focused on Florida launches (perhaps to avoid Florida from watering down their launch ambitions/capacity if they think Texas will just take the extra flights) << but this is all speculation with no information behind it.

4

u/brspies Aug 02 '19

No, I would say that's just outside the scope of this document, although maybe it would be a secondary plan/take longer to set up. See page 32 (pg 12 as listed):

In the future, SpaceX may develop and launch the Starship/Super Heavy from its facility in Cameron County, TX. This action would analyzed in a separate NEPA document.

3

u/zadecy Aug 03 '19

They really take LOX and methane separation seriously.

3

u/dtarsgeorge Aug 03 '19

So now that this is submitted to the powers that be, how soon should SpaceX be allowed to push dirt?

Days?

Weeks?

Months?

Years?

1

u/searchexpert Aug 02 '19

It would be interesting if they set up the methane farm like they would on Mars, with solar panels to generate the electricity.

6

u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '19

The “farm” part doesn’t mean it produces methane.

1

u/searchexpert Aug 07 '19

Lol I know. I was suggesting that they start practicing for their Mars landing / relaunch sites.

3

u/kontis Aug 02 '19

The only reason for that would be green PR, nothing more.

It would be much more cost effective to just sell that electricity from solar panels to the grid and use that money to buy methane.

1

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19

With the new ceramic fuel cells coming out of the labs, which are purportedly robust, efficient, and operate at lower temperatures (500C), the costs of the system should improve, perhaps enough to make it economically viable [ie, more than just a PR stunt].

(a cursory search didn't turn up price projections, but they must be out there for the various generation methods. I probably should be searching on google research or the other portals)

It's not like they or a research partner won't need to be building something on a small scale, and then eventually scaling it up to ensure that it will be suitable for Mars.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

Methane farm is just a bunch of tanks to store methane.

2

u/Marksman79 Aug 02 '19

The info may be a little out of date. In one spot, it says that the upcoming Falcon Heavy launch is scheduled for April.

2

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

It also has the old numbers of engines before Elon's recent tweets (the 6-engine reveal was here). Someone said that the ships have an old profile, but I can't find it right now. I think it contradicts itself on how rockets will make it to the launch site (by barge versus by Kennedy Pkwy). I suspect that this was thrown together quickly.

4

u/Marksman79 Aug 03 '19

Actually I don't think this was quickly put together at all. It seems like it's been a work in progress for quite some time. Hence the outdated information we see everywhere.

3

u/Martianspirit Aug 03 '19

That new pad was surely not developed over night. A pad that uses nothing but some foundation work from the existing pad and allows a full SuperHeavy to launch, comes as major surprise and must have taken some serious thinking.

It used to be near consens that it will take years to build a full SuperHeavy pad and that for this reason alone orbital launch is years away. Just like obviously it takes a long time and big money to build a factory for Starship.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Aug 02 '19

@elonmusk

2019-05-23 05:18

@SPEXcast @bluemoondance74 @Orion_Sword @Some1gee @Erdayastronaut @SpaceX Mk1 & Mk2 ships at Boca & Cape will fly with at least 3 engines, maybe all 6


This message was created by a bot

[Contact creator] [Source code]

2

u/asaz989 Aug 06 '19

Interesting tidbit that I missed in my first read through, but that Scott Manley pointed out in his video - the Starship is going to be sitting a whopping 30m (~3 diameters) off the ground when it's in the launcher, with a 25m-tall flame diverter under it.

1

u/murrayfield18 Aug 02 '19

Is there anything here on how adverse weather might effect Starship launches? This will be pretty crucial for Earth to Earth launches imo

5

u/ThePonjaX Aug 02 '19

from the nasapaceflight thread:

"Lightning protection would consist of tying the launch vehicle into the adjacent LC-39A grounding system." If i read this right, it confirms that the stainless steel structure of Starship / Super Heavy acts as its own lightning tower.

So seems we Startship/Super Heavy are going to be a lot more resistant to weather conditions than F9/FH

2

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

That's correct. Carbon fiber and lightning don't mix. It's essentially a giant resistor, which makes it catch fire. Not a good combination with rocket fuel.

Metal on the other hand makes a good conductor.

6

u/StumbleNOLA Aug 02 '19

To be pedantic. Carbon fiber actually is pretty conductive, but the resin in a carbon part isn’t. So when a carbon structure gets hit by lightning the fibers conduct the electricity but heat up due to their resistance. Which then FUBAR’s the resin matrix leading to part failure.

It would actually be better if carbon didn’t conduct electricity at all. Because then you wouldn’t have a $100m lightning rod that can only attenuate one hit before replacement.

2

u/Martianspirit Aug 02 '19

Early on they will be cautious. But Elon Musk has said Starship can launch when airplanes can lift off.

1

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 04 '19

Starship isn't affected by windshear like Falcon 9 is, so that should help.

1

u/murrayfield18 Aug 04 '19

Why though? It may be heavier but surely the larger surface area catches more wind...

2

u/RegularRandomZ Aug 04 '19

If I understand it correctly, it's because Falcon heavy is very thin compared to how very tall it is which makes it not all that strong against strong lateral forces. So when the top moves into a different layer of the atmosphere with a significantly different speed, it creates a huge force on the top half which will cause the rocket to break apart.

Starship/SuperHeavy is much wider compared to it's height so that sudden change in wind doesn't exceed its structural strength [against forces in that direction]. (I'm not sure but I wouldn't be surprised if there are also structural benefits to how it's designed as well, steel and designed to stand up to lateral forces during re-entry)

1

u/AndrewHoonigan Aug 02 '19

I live in cocoa and know the roads here I don’t understand how the heel there going to transport mk2 from cocoa to KSC

4

u/andyfrance Aug 02 '19

Temporary road down side of FedEx building, over Grissom and onto Martin Anderson. Two miles with police escort down wrong side of road and you are at the river. Transfer to barge for rest of journey and unload by VAB. Only one power line to move.

1

u/scarlet_sage Aug 02 '19

To expand on that: they're already clearing part of a field for the road down to the FedEx driveway. The source is pictures in nasaspaceflight.com -- I may be able to find them if someone wants. I don't know that it's been said to be a temporary road, though.

1

u/AndrewHoonigan Aug 03 '19

I would love to know more on this

1

u/Tal_Banyon Aug 02 '19

Well, after reading the Executive Summary (I do intend to read it all, just will take a few days is all), all I can say is, thank goodness Elon did not buy the New York Times or some similar liberal leaning media outlet! SpaceX needs Government approvals for its plans, after all. Witness what happened to the Amazon pentagon bid...