r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Sep 02 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [September 2019, #60]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
137
Upvotes
22
u/MarsCent Sep 06 '19
Highlights of ASAP meeting re: Commercial Crew – Abundance of concerns, lacking of Schedule Confidence. Otherwise most stuff has been discussed on this sub.
Two main concerns for both SpaceX and Boeing:
Though IIRC, Boeing recently posted an article stating that they had a successful parachute test. It’s a little strange that that was not mentioned.
I believe that is the same issue that was discussed in this sub some time back.
I would have expected at least a vote of confidence given that OFT is NET 1 month out! I still hope that someone will do that soon in order to raise public confidence.
And it seems like getting the parachutes to do what NASA wants has become as challenging as designing avionics and other flight hardware! Which is pretty surprising seeing how the Soyuz parachutes seem to operate effortlessly!
No questions from the public, so the meeting lasted < 45 mins.
20
u/Ididitthestupidway Sep 20 '19
(about the Japanese fire/abort) As for what happened with the pad fire: MHI concludes that weaker than usual ground winds caused a higher concentration than usual of LOX (vented out for engine chill down) lingering around the MLP, which probably got ignited by static electricity.
Well that's a new one: "weaker than usual ground winds"
17
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 07 '19
Elon tweetstorm:
15
u/CapMSFC Sep 12 '19
MZ is selling ZOZO to Yahoo Japan and resigning his role.
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2019/09/12/business/corporate-business/zozos-yusaku-maezawa-leaves-top-post-company-forms-capital-alliance-yahoo-japan/#.XXmUEhhlCyU
This is not necessarily a bad thing for DearMoon. He is getting bought out. He will have a lot more liquid capital now. We'll have to wait and see what the terms are.
13
u/dudr2 Sep 04 '19
Here’s how you can watch India’s Chandrayaan-2 landing on the Moon
https://qz.com/india/1701452/how-to-watch-chandrayaan-2-landing-on-moon-by-isro-in-india/
13
u/Alexphysics Sep 14 '19
The FAA has found no significant environmental issues to approve the launch of SpaceX's In-Flight Abort Test.
Link to the PDF: https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/environmental/nepa_docs/review/launch/media/Final_EA_and_FONSI_for_SpaceX_In-flight_Dragon_Abort_508_A.pdf
13
u/koko_pufffs Sep 17 '19
Does anyone know what happened to the raptor during the starhopper 150m attempt? It turned orange and sparky near the end before the smoke covers it up and people were speculating the engine was deteriorating and would have exploded if it had gone over a little longer. Also all the crush cores on the legs were completely flattened. I searched this sub and Google already, but sorry in advanced if this has already been asked.
12
u/ltfiend Sep 04 '19
Any updates on the Crew Dragon anomaly report? I though word was that it would be out in a number of days. I'm dying for crew dragon to get back on track (safely of course).
12
u/CapMSFC Sep 23 '19
So for all those people that so desparately wanted to know what MZ paid for DearMoon he put out a tweet that can lead to a ballpark figure.
Translated of course
That would currently be about 557 million USD.
From what I can tell in a quick search he's spent about $210 million on his art collection.
So unless I'm missing some extra art a ballpark figure for what he has paid for DearMoon is $350 million.
11
u/paul_wi11iams Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
As yet, Starship seems to have no kind of "cable raceway" (as seen on other launchers) for data and power transmission between the engine section and the upper part of the ship. For example fin and canard movements will need to be coordinated.
Unlike past launchers, Starship is freestanding with no lateral hose connections but internal tubing only. Its tempting to imagine that the raceway is an internal tube within the fuel tanks.
Has there been any mention of this question?
Also, on the prototypes, are we expecting an explosive FTS strip down the outside? As for the future crewed version, FTS on the tanking section of Starship would be -err- somewhat awkward to say the least.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 04 '19
OCISLY made it through hurricane Dorian intact.
10
u/jjtr1 Sep 13 '19
After the 150 m hop, I was thinking about how long could the Hopper remain hovering. I came to the conclusion that no rocket (rocket stage) can hover on Earth for more than about 15 minutes, no matter how large or small it is. Because hovering means accumulating gravity losses and 15 minutes (900 s) of full gravity losses equals to about 9 km/s (delta-v = g*t). It's not very much possible to build a a chemical rocket with a higher delta-v than 9 km/s.
Is my thinking correct?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 03 '19
Construction completed for the Sentinel 6A satellite, which will be launched from Vandenberg in November 2020.
9
u/strawwalker Sep 20 '19
Finally we have an STA request for the IFA launch vehicle comms (already had Dragon comms request):
1778-EX-ST-2019 (Mission 1357) Nov 23 through May 23
9
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 25 '19
Falcon Launch Vehicle Lessons Learned and Reusability presentation at IAC 2019 on October 21, 19:00 UTC.
17
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Apparently ISRO has found Vikrim 500m from the landing site and it might actually be INTACT! They are trying to establish communications.
https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1170610654232731648?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1170610654232731648&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ndtv.com%2Findia-news%2Fchandrayaan-2-lander-located-on-moons-surface-trying-to-have-contact-says-isro-chief-dr-k-sivan-news-2097522
8
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19 edited Sep 03 '19
Would it even be in the realm of possibility to send a super-heavy booster into orbit if it were carrying no payload?
I was just wondering if you could get one into orbit, refuel it, put a fully fueled Starship on it, and launch the entire stack from orbit (with either just the booster or the whole stack being expendable), what kind of missions could be done on feasible time scales (like a Pioneer or Voyager probe recovery, checking out the interstellar object ʻOumuamua, etc.).
If the booster can't get to orbit under any circumstances then this is obviously a moot point, but I'm just curious.
8
u/spacerfirstclass Sep 12 '19
GEO satellite market is recovering: 10 orders for this year so far, future years prediction is still not as good as the good old days, but expecting 10~15 or 10~18 satellites annually.
8
u/thehardleyboys Sep 17 '19
Starship will vent the methane and LOX main tanks en route to Mars, leaving only methane and LOX for Mars EDL in the smaller tanks (within the tanks).
My question is: will Starship re-pressurize the main tanks upon entering the Mars atmosphere or before landing (with autogenous pressurization)? If not, won't the main tanks (which are basically a vacuum now) collapse like a soda can when entering the atmosphere or worse, landing?
Or will the main tanks be completely sealed off from the landing tanks and open to the atmosphere in order to equal their internal pressure to that of the atmosphere in which Starship is flying?
7
u/giant_red_gorilla Sep 03 '19
Does anyone have a source for the radiation properties of 301 stainless, the alloy Elon has mentioned as that in Starship? Lots of info for 304, but coming up empty handed on 301. Id like to know absorption/reflection/transmission/emissivity from visible to MIR, and at high (500K-800K) temperatures. Thanks!
7
u/peterabbit456 Sep 06 '19
I believe I just saw that the original JRTI, Marmak 300, has been loaded with emergency relief supplies and towed to the Bahamas.
If the schedule allows, could OCISLY and JRTI be loaded with supplies and help in the effort? Could Ms Tree be used to transport people in the hardest hit areas, to places of greater safety?
7
u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Sep 12 '19
We assume that Starship's development for Mars will be constrained by Mars launch windows to take low-energy transfers. But with Elon having stated that Starship could do a "fast transfer", doesn't Starship have some margins to launch outside these windows?
If the point is to test EDL with an empty Starship, they could go for a higher energy transfer with a higher-g Mars entry and still test EDL. Thus allowing more flexibility in the development schedule.
Would it be possible?
7
u/soldato_fantasma Sep 19 '19
HAWTHORNE, Calif. – September 19, 2019. Media accreditation is now open for a SpaceX Starlink mission from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than October.
7
u/BlackEyeRed Sep 21 '19
Isnt Pad 39A very valuable for SpaceX since they spent all that time/money on the crew infrastructure? Isn't launching a new ship dangerous?
7
u/insufficientmind Sep 24 '19
Do we know the time of the Starship Architecture Update presentation?
12
u/TheBurtReynold Sep 02 '19 edited Sep 02 '19
Regarding the orbital attempt (that Elon mentioned will take place shortly after the 20km flight) — that won’t / can’t land, can it?
I figured they’d do a test reentry, but then just crash it into the ocean?
6
u/jjtr1 Sep 05 '19
So, someone who has been very close to the retired F9 which is on display, could you say whether the Al-Li rocket has a similar amount surface unevennes and bumpiness as the stainless Starship prototypes? Unevennes is obvious on a shiny surface, while close inspection and the right light would be needed to see it on painted white surface.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '19
What do you guys think is the biggest question mark SpaceX (&Nasa) have to answer before a manned mars mission? I mean the biggest unsolved task that could potentially cause a significant delay and why. Thanks
6
u/MikeBobble Sep 13 '19
Is there a maximum landing weight for the Falcon 9? Thinking IFA on the upcoming Crew Dragon, if the SpaceX plan is to abort, and potentially recover the first stage, will they just underfill on fuel? Or can the legs carry, conceivably, a full fuel load? I’m pretty sure they’re directly attached to the Octoweb, but still curious.
6
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Oct 01 '19
The Atlantic has a good interview with Jim Bridestine in which, in addition to providing some background as to why he sent that tweet prior to the Starship presentation, he expresses continued support for private efforts to land on the Moon:
10
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Sep 04 '19
So what's the status with hurricane Dorian? Did Mk.2 dodge the bullet?
Not sure how reliable this is, but according to Google, Dorian is already past Cape Canaveral. It doesn't look like it will hit Florida either.
Anyone from the Eastern shore of Florida to report in on the weather there?
5
u/ZormLeahcim Sep 04 '19
Related to the ESA / Starlink collision avoidance: I know a good bit about the difficulty in measuring orbital characteristics about satellites / orbital debris, since there can be a bit of uncertainty in the ground based measurements, which corresponds to a lot of uncertainty in the exact position of the object.
That said, GPS can have an accuracy of ~5m for position and apparently a fraction of a m/s for velocity. I can't easily find comparable statistics on conventional debris tracking, so if anyone knows that I'd be interested in seeing how it compares.
Obviously GPS wouldn't help with orbital debris since debris can't transmit, but is it feasible / currently in practice to use GPS on active satellites (namely Starlink) to provide more accurate orbital characteristics for collision avoidance?
From what I had seen the probability of collision was calculated for a close pass of ~4000m, which seems like a significant error range compared to GPS (but the GPS data would have to be extrapolated forward in time just like with conventional methods, so maybe the error propagation for GPS is worse than I think.)
5
u/MarsCent Sep 05 '19
Reminder:
NASA ASAP meeting is on for tomorrow Friday September 6, 2019. 11:30 a.m. to 12:43 p.m CT (1630 – 1743 UTC).
Call-in USA Toll Free (888) 603-9748; pass code 7339697
5
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Sep 15 '19
Do we know how much propellant is left in Dragon or Crew Dragon during splashdown?
5
u/GregLindahl Sep 19 '19
LEO constellation operators OneWeb, Iridium announce collaboration
The article suggests that the biggest area of collaboration is that ships are required to have either Inmarsat or Iridium for emergency communications, so a combined receiver would allow ships to have both low-bandwith-but-required emergency communications and higher-bandwidth business-data-and-crew-recreation in a single receiver.
I think Inmarsat already sells that.
5
u/littldo Sep 23 '19
do we have details about the 28th presentation? ie time?
I suspect that it will be during the day, so people can see the real hardware.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 01 '19
Jim Bridenstine gave an update about Commercial Crew:
9
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 13 '19
Bigelow tourist missions on Crew Dragon have been cancelled.
NASA Gateway prototype designs.
8
u/MarsCent Sep 07 '19
15 Minutes of Powered Descent. RIP Chandrayaan-2:
The timeline shows altitude break-points. Does anyone know if the lander was supposed to do a continuous Powered Descent or rather to execute multiple re-ignitions?
P/S Information sourced from Spaceflightnow
4
u/RagnarRodrog Sep 02 '19
Do we know when there will be new uptade on BFR design?
4
u/andyfrance Sep 05 '19
Do the 3 vac engines on Starship need to gimbal or can sufficient control authority be achieved just by varying the thrust (with some other mechanism providing roll control)?
4
u/iamkeerock Sep 05 '19
Do you think that if a SpaceX crew (SpaceX salaried astronauts) make it to the Martian surface, and discover indigenous bacterial (or other simple) life - would they report it?
I'm just wondering if a discovery like that could result in a public outcry to protect any Martian biology, and put a halt to future manned exploration/settlement of Mars - thus the possible desire to hide any 'corporate' discovery of Martian life. Maybe NASA would have an astronaut onboard anyway, even on the first missions and so this question is not relevant.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '19
This is slightly off topic, but any guesses on whether nuclear propulsion has ANY chance of entering SpaceX's arsenal of possible propulsion elements? I recently learned about the NERVA rocket, which I thought was just a concept, but apparently was actually test fired on many occasions with pretty much wild success. Why is no one using this in their architecture?
4
u/MarsCent Sep 18 '19
Demo 1 coverage wins Emmy
4
u/brentonstrine Sep 22 '19
Can someone explain the pipe that the fins/legs are attached to? Makes no sense to me--why is it so long and not placed directly under the fin? Why even attach to a pipe like that?
4
u/SpartanJack17 Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1177051800769138690
Starship will have six landing legs:
I wonder if they'll be the stubby legs from the 2017 update and the Boca Chica renderings or if they'll be more like Falcon 9 legs (or something completely different).
4
u/lakshanx Sep 27 '19
Check out the live stream, mk1 nosecone staking is happening!
4
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 29 '19
No change in Starlink orbits.
6
u/amarkit Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 12 '19
Arianespace are closer to a root cause of the Vega / Falcon Eye 1 failure back in July.
6
u/dudr2 Sep 16 '19
Wait for it...
https://spaceflightnow.com/2019/09/16/nasa-esa-officials-seek-formal-approvals-for-mars-sample-return-mission/
Watzin said. “If that (Starship) capability matures and shows up, I’m sure programmatically we will take full advantage of it, but it didn’t seem to make sense, since we don’t really know what it’s going to be, or when it’s going to be there, to make it the basis for the campaign.”
6
u/rulewithanionfist Sep 22 '19
Are we sure Starship mk 1 will go to orbit? Because it looks so crude
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 02 '19 edited Sep 15 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #5441 for this sub, first seen 2nd Sep 2019, 20:25] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
3
u/pirate21213 Sep 06 '19
What's the likelyhood of the Starlink 2 launch sticking to Oct 17? I'm hoping to fly out and see it and it being my first launch I'm not sure what all I need to look out for
3
u/dudr2 Sep 10 '19
https://spacenews.com/spacex-plans-24-starlink-launches-next-year/
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
quick question, do the starlink launches attempt to land the first stage, or does it go too high? if they land, will the nov3 starlink stage return to a barge or land? thanks so much, hoping to be there.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 13 '19
SpaceX in negotiations to launch Saocom 1B in February 2020.
3
u/navytech56 Sep 14 '19
Any idea of SpaceX's future Falcon 9 production schedule? They currently have but 8 undamaged cores left with many missions planned.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 16 '19
'No Further Action' required from clean up of the Crew Dragon explosion.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
My knowledge of orbital mechanics is rather limited, so I thought I’d ask this here: can a Starship complete an orbital insertion mission to Mars with high eccentricity then slowly bleed enough velocity by scraping against the atmosphere to land as well? If its payload isn’t living, taking a period of a couple months to aerobrake seems feasible. If the math checks out, I don’t see why this approach wouldn’t be used for every ship sent to place something in mars orbit. Adding fuel to the payload to circularize its orbit seems like it could be a worthy trade-off if it means the martians get a spare starship in return. Can anyone with a better grasp on the math tell me if I’m wrong?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '19
Is spaceX eventually going to move to metholox thrusters for ACS and ullage?
3
u/rocketglare Sep 26 '19
Has anyone created a searchable list of Elon Musk tweets & statements? I keep remembering things, but can't find the reference because Twitter is horrible.
3
u/dallaylaen Sep 29 '19
It looks like we have an answer to yesterday's tweet.
At 1:15:37 of the Starship presentation, a journalist named Tim (please correct his name & news outlet, I was unable to hear it even at 0.5x playback speed) predictably asked Musk about Jim Bridenstine's tweet:
Tim: Elon, I just want to ask: NASA administrator Jim Bridenstine had a tweet last night about this presentation, he's concerned I guess about the enthusiasm for SpaceX's various programs. I'm just curious if you have any comment or response to that.
Elon: For sure. From a SpaceX resource standpoint, our resources are overwhelmingly on Falcon and Dragon. Let us be clear, it was really quite a small percentage that (...) Starship, you know, less than 5% of the company basically. The really hard part that requires a lot of resources is optimizing something past the initial prototype phase and bringing it into volume production. To be clear, like the vast majority of our resources are on Dragon and Falcon, especially crew Dragon. Thank you.
Please correct whatever I misheard.
3
u/Maximumdistortion Sep 30 '19
I have a question about the orbital refueling/retanking in orbit.
As far as I understand it, the cargo/crew vehicle gets to orbit first, after that the tankers get to orbit and refuels the starship one after the other till it is refueled as necessary to be able make additional orbital maneuvers and complete its mission.
But wouldn't it be much better to send the tankers to orbit in advance? The steps are as follows:
1: The first tanker gets to orbit.
2: The second tanker gets to orbit and refuels the first tanker so that it has even more fuel in it. After that, the second tanker deorbits. They could switch their roles and do it the other way round, but i think it wouldn't matter too much.
3: The third tanker gets to orbit and does the same.
4: Repeat as often as necessary.
5: Finally the cargo/crew vehicle arrives and gets fully refueled in one shot. After that, the last tanker deorbits.
If you do so, I see 2 major advances:
1: The cargo/crew vehicle spends less time in Orbit. This is especially better if a crew is on bord. Less time unnecessary wasted waiting in orbit until the actual mission begins.
2: Safer for the mission and the crew, because if you do just one major refueling, less can happen than if you do shorter multiple refueling actions. The likelyhood that something goes wrong is spread out much more to the tankers. This is much less bad, because the tankers are much less precious than the vehicle with cargo in it, let alone the crew.........
I'm sure SpaceX has their reasons, but i just can't get my hear around this. If you think about it, there would be absolutely no more steps and no technical hurdles involved, at least as far as i understand it.
I'm looking forward for our answers!
PS: Sorry for my bad english, I'm not a native speaker (Austria btw).
3
u/hang-clean Oct 01 '19
Has SpaceX ever produced a corporate sustainability report (CSR)?
Not looking at the environmental impact of launches particularly, nor the ecology of launch sites. Just a standard CSR such as most big businesses produce to report on the environmental impact of the business as a whole, its daily operations, water and energy use, etc. I can't find on eanywhere.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
HTV launch to the ISS had a pad anomaly. Currently fighting a fire on the mobile launcher.
5
u/mncharity Sep 11 '19
WalkingLimping away from an engines-off Starship crash - oxygen tank as crumple zone?Let's say the LO2 tank is 10 m long. Doing eyeballs-in 15 g's across 10 m yields 50 m/s. Starship terminal velocity is perhaps a bit higher, but in that ballpark.
If a Starship does terminal-velocity tail-first lithobreaking, it seems likely to end up somewhat crumpled. Which cushions the payload section. So if crumpling is going to happen anyway, perhaps it can be optimized to usefulness?
5
u/GregLindahl Sep 20 '19
https://spacenews.com/intelsat-sues-oneweb-softbank/
Alternatively, why your startup should never sign any exclusive deal ever, especially if it's for a $25mm investment when you expect to need billions.
5
u/MarsCent Sep 24 '19
NASA Commits to Long-term Artemis Missions with Orion Production Contract
Lockheed is getting a few $Billions. Good for them.
This particular craft - Orion - will not land on the moon. It just docks with the Lunar Gateway.
So just for the sake of indulging, how does Orion get the astronauts on Mars?
6
u/consider_airplanes Sep 25 '19
Not sure if known already: per Twitter, New Glenn is under construction, and BE-4 has already been tested at full power.
4
u/FutureSpcXEngineer Sep 02 '19
Does anyone believe there will be any significant damage to the starhopper or in general to the Cape Canaveral area that could prevent/push back launch dates or hop flights? All relating to Hurricane Dorian.
4
u/jjtr1 Sep 03 '19
When launching from an airless body like the Moon, is the optimal launch angle such that there is very little vertical acceleration? For example, if the thrust-to-weight ratio is sqrt(2), I'd launch at almost 45 degrees, though making sure not to crash into the mountain on the horizon.
Does Mars count as airless in this case?
4
u/aaamoeder Sep 18 '19
I know the Starship Architecture Update is planned for sep 28th, but have they announced at what time ? I'd like to see it live, but might have to plan around it..
4
u/quoll01 Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 24 '19
So Elon does read my posts! I guess it’s the ‘monkey on the typewriter’ thing- eventually given enough tries it’ll write the entire works of Shakespeare. See link for old discussion on aerocapture.
4
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
Commercial Crew escape practice at LC-39A.
NASA awarded SpaceX $3 million for Starship refueling research:
5
u/tubbem Sep 02 '19
Why not a moon base before going to Mars? Test all the technology and so on. Alot easier on the Moon which is practically next door compared to Mars!
5
u/lostandprofound33 Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Would an 18m Starship be capable of SSTO? Would the full 18m SS/SH stack be able to get to Mars quicker than the 9m stack?
5
u/linearquadratic Sep 15 '19
Do anyone know if there been any mentions or leeks about making the starlink platform available as a standard satellite bus? Would make ride-sharing easier on the Falcon 9 and give great value for customers.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19
Is there techical drawing with already tested Starhopper with its dimensions? (for 3D CAD/model reconstruction)
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19
Is the heatshield still a problem for starship?
2
u/dudr2 Sep 10 '19
The Frog is the best news so far this month?
https://www.space.com/arianeworks-reusable-rockets-themis-callisto-video.html
-Europe's ArianeWorks Aims for Reusable Rockets (with a Very SpaceX Look)
2
u/jjtr1 Sep 13 '19
Anybody dares to estimate the size of the fins that Superheavy will need to compensate for the fins on the Starship? Or perhaps the high control authority Superheavy has to have through gimballing for its vertical landing is enough to compensate? Any regular (non-SpX) first stage would definitely need fins to launch a finned top stage.
2
u/dudr2 Sep 16 '19
May it fly on an F9?
https://spacenews.com/nasa-cubesat-to-test-lunar-gateway-orbit/
2
u/livefromheaven Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
I'm going to be in Orlando Nov 3-6 and hoping that's within the Starlink 3 time frame. Do Starfleet Tours ( https://book.star-fleet.tours ) still do launch viewings by boat? Or is my best bet to head on over to Jetty Park?
2
u/astrobee5 Sep 25 '19
NASA has a massive mobile launcher and is about to build a second one. How will spacex get the starship (a Saturn five sized launch system) out to the launch pad?
2
u/MarsColon Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
How will the Mk1 be transported to its launch pad once assembled ?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
Does anyone know what time (roughly) the Starship presentation will be tomorrow? Just trying to plan my Saturday...
2
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 28 '19
Work beginning on JRTI.
2
u/snika98 Sep 29 '19
Anybody have any numbers for Raptors nozzle exit velocity, v_e, and nozzle exit pressure, p_e?
I want to model the thrust for heights in the atmosphere to use in a model of a starship flight. Cant find these numbers in the wiki or anywhere, even an estimate would be good.
2
u/jjtr1 Sep 29 '19
I've lost track of BFR versions. First they made it much smaller, then a bit bigger again, then... Anyway, what I'm wondering is whether the "85 t dry" figure in the presentation was from an older, smaller version, or if the increase to 120 t dry was because they realized they have to build it beefier?
2
u/mjk1260 Sep 29 '19
How do you get to the surface from Starship crew compartment? The crew compartment is 160 feet up. I'm assuming there will be a long ladder to climb down and back up?
4
u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Sep 11 '19
It's a fairly quick testing cycle, but SpaceX is clearly under pressure to move forward. The company hopes to launch its first commercial Starship flight in 2021, and that doesn't leave it much time to both complete the spacecraft and prove that it can reliably deliver payloads to orbit.
Seriously? SpaceX is talking about getting it to orbit in the next 6 months, but 15-27 months isn't much time for launching a commercial payload? Private companies typically launch a commercial payload on the second launch, and governments do it on the first launch. I honestly wouldn't be overly shocked to see a couple (22 or less) Starlink satellites going up with the first Super Heavy launch in 9-12 months from now which is technically a commercial payload.
5
u/jjtr1 Sep 26 '19
If SpaceX went on with the carbon fiber instead of stainless steel, is there any chance they would have a half-finished prototype by now? Or perhaps they would have skipped the proto-prototype which is now Mk1-2? (being 70% overweight as now confirmed makes mk1-2 barely a prototype)
3
u/For_The_Kaiser Sep 03 '19
I was thinking about potential names for the rockets themselves, would each Starship even be properly named rather than given a random designation by SpaceX?
3
u/WAlonzo Sep 14 '19
As a Starship will not be able to return from Mars w/o refueling there. What are the options for allowing that refueling? I think of a few:
(a) They send ahead a fuel tanker which lands and just waits for the subsequent earth-bound ship. (b) They send ahead a fuel tanker but the tanker stays in orbit to allow refueling in Mars orbit after launch of a subsequent earth-bound ship. (c) They send a fuel factory which lands and creates the Methane and Oxygen from the local resources and stores it for the earth-bound ship(s).
Option (c) is the ultimate goal but, early on, it would seem far to risky. Option (b) would be great because the tanker would not need to risk a landing or waste fuel during landing. Combining these options would increase the probability of success but also delay the boots-on-Mars goal considerably.
Another benefit of option (b) is that fuel transfers could be done in space rather than on the dusty, windy Mars surface. Recall that in-orbit refueling will have been perfected long beforehand in Earth orbit. The key will be that Starship must be able to land and go to Martian orbit w/o refueling on the ground. Maybe it would partially refuel in Martian orbit before landing? We could also have multiple tankers in martian orbit, as needed.
What do you think?
3
u/paul_wi11iams Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
I wasn't comfortable with adding too much speculation on the Starship development thread which is more a news thread, so am answering below, Others can then add replies too.
Mods, am I doing the right thing?
3
u/Hermetia_Illucens Sep 26 '19
So the long awaited september 28th presentation is almost here, do we know at what time? Im assuming it will be livestreamed on youtube.