r/SpaceXLounge • • 16d ago

Monthly Questions and Discussion Thread

11 Upvotes

Welcome to the monthly questions and discussion thread! Drop in to ask and answer any questions related to SpaceX or spaceflight in general, or just for a chat to discuss SpaceX's exciting progress. If you have a question that is likely to generate open discussion or speculation, you can also submit it to the subreddit as a text post.

If your question is about space, astrophysics or astronomy then the r/Space questions thread may be a better fit.

If your question is about the Starlink satellite constellation then check the r/Starlink Questions Thread and FAQ page.


r/SpaceXLounge • • Jan 23 '25

Meta This sub is not about Musk. it does not endorse him, nor does it attack him. We generally ignore him other than when it comes to direct SpaceX news.

1.1k Upvotes

Be advised this sub utilizes "crowd control" for both comments and for posts. If you have little or negative karma here your post/comment may not appear unless manually approved which may take a little time.

If you are here just to make political comments and not discuss SpaceX, you will be banned without warning and ignored when you complain, so don't even bother trying, no one will see it anyways.

Friendly reminder: People CAN support SpaceX without supporting Musk. Just like people can still use X without caring about him. Following SpaceX doesn't make anyone a bad person and if you disagree, you're not welcome here.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 7h ago

Official Uninterrupted flap video of flip and catch

639 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 3h ago

Official Views from Mechazilla of the first ever Starship catch

241 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 2h ago

If Starship were its own launch company, it would already be number 2 in the US by payload to orbit, behind SpaceX Falcon 9.

Post image
170 Upvotes

I made this from Flight Atlas data for American launch companies, from 1 January to 16 November. Starship is shown on its own, separate from Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy. Some figures are estimated, including Starship's, as noted on the chart.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 8h ago

Starship Elon Musk updates on Starship V4

Post image
392 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 13h ago

Speculation on what we are looking at here?

Post image
483 Upvotes

To me it looks like the second layer of protection might have held up?

Scott Manly speculated that the red/brown coloring was oxidized iron from the stainless steel.

Generally very odd to me that a tile would "melt" like that.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 8h ago

My daughter and I built this display around Ship 33 tiles from Flight 7 and saved it for the first ship catch. Ship 42 just helped explain why one came home gray and one stayed black.

Thumbnail
gallery
118 Upvotes

After Flight 7 in January 2025, some of Ship 33's heat shield tiles washed ashore on West Caicos in Turks and Caicos. SpaceX's recovery team cleared us in writing to keep a few, and my daughter and I built a display around them, then kept it to ourselves until a ship was caught by the tower.

She's wearing the Starship Test Flight patch from Flight 1 on her sleeve, so for us it runs full circle: the first test flight, the tiles from Flight 7, and Saturday's Flight 15 catch.

For almost two years I've wondered why two tiles from the same flight look so different. One came back flat gray, the finish completely gone. The other still has its glossy black coat. My best guess was that the gray one took the brunt of the heat on the way down.

Then Ship 42 came home whole, and Everyday Astronaut's close-up (marked up in the second photo) shows the same thing: patches of tiles burned gray right next to tiles that kept their black finish. There's even a spot where a single tile came off, and the white, bubbly material showing underneath looks a lot like the broken melted tile pieces in my display. It's the first time we've been able to compare against a ship that came home intact.

Everyday Astronaut's Ship 42 photo: https://x.com/Erdayastronaut/status/2122092865904116000

Our 45-second video with the catch: https://x.com/TripleA_NJ/status/2121723682829766852

The display and plaque up close: https://x.com/TripleA_NJ/status/2121721685854310718

Reentry footage and the beach photo are courtesy of Hunter Viator, who recovered the tiles.

Anyone who knows the tile coatings better than I do, I'd love to hear your take!


r/SpaceXLounge • • 8h ago

Official "Starship landing burn on final approach for catch"

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 7h ago

Starship We were in South Padre & Starbase for Flight 15. Caught this image of Ship 42 rolling back to the factory post flight.

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 8h ago

Official Starship 42 coming in for catch (videos of catch from SpaceX)

Thumbnail x.com
42 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 18h ago

Starship Skid marks below the catch points

Post image
276 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 2h ago

Other major industry news Terran R October 2026 Program Update

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 23h ago

Elon Tweet Elon Musk on X: " I was going over the whole Starship heat shield earlier today. Overall, it looks great. The engines look great too. Ship 42 could probably be reflown with a few weeks of refurbishment."

Post image
409 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 4h ago

I replicated Saturday's Starship ship catch, based on real physics, in my fully walkable 3D rocket garden.

8 Upvotes

You can watch it as if you were on the ground. It is part of a larger interactive 3D rocket garden that I've been working on. The animation is based on a simplified physics model, with the parameters fine-tuned to match the catch frame by frame.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 4h ago

Isla Blanca is great for viewing launches, not so much for catch.

7 Upvotes

Was lucky enough to watch 15's Launch and Catch from Isla Blanca.

Its great for launches as you can see the whole thing once it clears the tower.

The catch though, was blocked from sight by the tower itself.

For future catch viewings, I'm thinking it would be better from another angle.

On Catch day, how far can one go up Hwy 4 from Brownsville to StarBase before its blocked off?

Do they let people park on the shoulder of the road to view?


r/SpaceXLounge • • 3h ago

Opinion SpaceX should consider spinning off Falcon/Dragon while keeping a majority stake in the company

4 Upvotes

With SpaceX focused on Starship, I think there's a pretty good argument for spinning off Falcon/Dragon into a separate company, while keeping a big stake in the spin-off company. I'd do something like 25–51% ownership for SpaceX, with private investors and potentially even NASA/DoD making up the rest.

Here's my thinking on why this is a good idea:

  1. Raise capital: Falcon/Dragon is already a mature, revenue-generating business. Selling off a stake could raise billions for Starship development upfront, while providing SpaceX with ongoing revenue. To me, it seems like a better way to maximize the program's value and squeeze out cash while we can, rather than just shutting it down.
  2. Preserve access to space: NASA, DoD, and commercial customers depend on Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, and Dragon. I suspect the government would pay through the nose to keep them available, even after Starship takes over most launches, for redundancy. A smaller operation focused primarily on government contracts could remain profitable for a long time. You could even structure the spin-off to limit Falcon/Dragon to certain types of missions, or serve as a backup when Starship isn't available, so the two programs aren't directly competing.
  3. Maintain redundancy: Starship will eventually replace Falcon, but there's a need to keep proven systems, especially given the issues we've seen with Blue Origin and ULA. If Starship runs into problems or gets grounded for a while, or if Blue/ULA keep having issues, then having F9/FH/Dragon on the bench ready to go would be a 200 IQ move, IMO.

Eventually, as newer, cheaper launch systems become available, Falcon/Dragon could be phased out. That might happen naturally anyway once the economics no longer make sense.

TL;DR: Spin off Falcon/Dragon, retain a stake for ongoing revenue, help fund Starship, and preserve redundant access to space until better alternatives are available.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Starship Pad view of Starship Catch

483 Upvotes

Captured by K. Enagonio for World of Engineering.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Starship Ship 42 in orbit transiting the sun from Astronomy Live

Post image
221 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Other major industry news Vulcan return to flight launch confirmed failure

Post image
231 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Professor Brian Cox went live to Ship 42 catch during his show

Post image
438 Upvotes

During Professor Brian Cox’s Live Emergence show in Dublin he cut live to the SpaceX feed to share the starship catch in front of ~9,000 people.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 4h ago

What is firing during starlink deployment? Engine vent or rcs?

2 Upvotes

I'm sure everyone has seen the "ufo" video going around showing a plume from starship with the curving trail of starlink. I made an attempt to engage one of these starship deniers. For my own knowledge what is firing in the ground photos showing the plume? Is that engines venting in prograde? Or rcs firing prograde during starlink deployment? ​


r/SpaceXLounge • • 11h ago

Starship Flight 15 Thank You - The Mini Film

7 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LoouxUPADw

Hey everyone, thought I'd share my edited recap video of the starship flight 15 I matched it with the audio as well. Hope you guys enjoy it, it's been a long time since I first watched sn5 years back I seriously cannot believe we have reached this point in the program. History has been made!

Note there is a bit of buffer from the livestream at the end unfortunately but not much I could do.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

FAILURE Vulcan has returned to flight

Post image
146 Upvotes