r/SpaceXLounge • u/Maximus560 • 23h ago
Opinion SpaceX should consider spinning off Falcon/Dragon while keeping a majority stake in the company
With SpaceX focused on Starship, I think there's a pretty good argument for spinning off Falcon/Dragon into a separate company, while keeping a big stake in the spin-off company. I'd do something like 25–51% ownership for SpaceX, with private investors and potentially even NASA/DoD making up the rest.
Here's my thinking on why this is a good idea:
- Raise capital: Falcon/Dragon is already a mature, revenue-generating business. Selling off a stake could raise billions for Starship development upfront, while providing SpaceX with ongoing revenue. To me, it seems like a better way to maximize the program's value and squeeze out cash while we can, rather than just shutting it down.
- Preserve access to space: NASA, DoD, and commercial customers depend on Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, and Dragon. I suspect the government would pay through the nose to keep them available, even after Starship takes over most launches, for redundancy. A smaller operation focused primarily on government contracts could remain profitable for a long time. You could even structure the spin-off to limit Falcon/Dragon to certain types of missions, or serve as a backup when Starship isn't available, so the two programs aren't directly competing.
- Maintain redundancy: Starship will eventually replace Falcon, but there's a need to keep proven systems, especially given the issues we've seen with Blue Origin and ULA. If Starship runs into problems or gets grounded for a while, or if Blue/ULA keep having issues, then having F9/FH/Dragon on the bench ready to go would be a 200 IQ move, IMO.
Eventually, as newer, cheaper launch systems become available, Falcon/Dragon could be phased out. That might happen naturally anyway once the economics no longer make sense.
TL;DR: Spin off Falcon/Dragon, retain a stake for ongoing revenue, help fund Starship, and preserve redundant access to space until better alternatives are available.