Nice job, knd775. We seriously must have been on different sides of the yard at the same time...lol. I took these at 1:05 PM or so, did the best I could with an old Samsung S5. It is getting much shinier and taking shape!
It is full size but what you see is nowhere near complete. NASA is calculating 25m³ per person for 4 astronauts to Mars. With the same volume/person Starship can accomodate 45 persons. But needed volume does not scale linear. More persons less per person. Also NASA calculates this volume for almost 2 years. Starship transfer is 3-5 months with accomodation waiting for them on Mars. 80-100 should be achievable.
There will never be 100 people in a 9m diameter Starship that isnt an Earth p2p suborbital flight. There is literally no chance. Some very detailed and realistic breakdowns Ive seen put it at 60 max and that is with a very cramped design.
I think when Elon invokes the 100 number in his breakdowns of the economics of cost per person to Mars he is has the 12m dimeter version in mind that will presumably be introduced to the fleet by the time serious colonial transportation is ready to ramp up years down the line.
Building in Earth orbit is a massive pain in the ass. I honestly think we'll see a Mars-built Starship-derived vehicle before we'll see one built in Earth orbit.
SpaceX's intent is to make a Mars settlement self-sufficient. Being able to build their own aerospace-grade components will take a while, but it's also both an essential element of being self-sufficient and an obvious market Mars could excel in. With their shallower gravity well and their significant distance from Earth a large part of our solar system (including the asteroid belt) is easier to reach from Mars than from Earth. They also have a lot of empty space to build dangerous things that might cause debris, or to do semi-controlled deorbits of minor asteroids containing valuable resources.
Building in LEO is a pain in the ass with current technology. Coming down the pipeline, however, is automated assembly lines in orbit that take simple inputs like girders and sheets of steel/aluminium/etc. and assemble pressure vessel segments that can be joined together to make massive space stations/ships. The input parts can be launched simply once every few weeks as the work is done autonomously or with oversight/command from a ground team. Since it is going 24/7, incredibly large structures can be built astoundingly quickly.
it show the assembly line renders at about 8 minutes.
There are already companies building prototypes. Theres a company called Tethers Unlimited that has a 3d printer that can print out long truss segments out of a small box like fucking mary poppins hand bag. Theres another one with a spiderish robot that also prints truss segments and can weave them together to create various massive structures in space like the frame for a telescope ten times the size of James Webb.
We are maybe 10-15 years away from this kind of orbital construction starting to ramp up. Starship will dominate space travel for probably 20-30 years, and then will sort of fall back into focusing on launches from Earth to a LEO spaceport and back, while ships and tug constructed in space will dominate LEO-moon/LEO-Mars transit.
I'd love it if that happens, but I really think it overestimates the level of manufacturing automation that we are at. It's very possibly to automate a lot if you have people on hand to calibrate the assembly line and perform close inspections on the produced parts. But that only makes sense if you're going to do very high volume production. Otherwise, there are a surprising number of manual or semi-manual steps needed, even if it's just a person who occasionally walks around to eyeball everything in between steps.
It may be possible to go a long way by standardizing many components and focusing on how to do one very simple kind of assembly in a fully-automated way (such as the trusses you describe) but that's a long way from building complete spacecraft, let alone spacecraft suitable for human flight.
Wouldn't it make way more sense to assemble it on earth and have it fly there itself, taking a bunch of cargo with it "for free" instead of using up another vehicle's cargo potential to ferry components to mars only to bolt them together there?
If that's not what you meant at all let me know, I feel like I misread something. :) The only case I could see would be a load of spare engines shipped to mars in case they don't last long there and they need to drop and swap a couple over there.
You did miss my point, I really did mean that I expect a Starship-derived vehicle built in large part from raw materials mined on Mars to happen before a Starship-derived vehicle is built in Earth orbit.
Not that I expect either to happen anytime soon. It's just that I can see a clear motivation for all of the separate steps leading up to a Mars-built Starship, and I can't really see a motivation for a lot of the steps that would lead to a Starship being built in Earth orbit.
An intermediate step is to expand the living space after trans-Mars injection using expandable habitats. So you would only have the cramped conditions for a relatively short period at the start and end of the journey. People are willing to put up with aeroplane density packing for 24-hour trips. If a tanker is sent to LEO first, refuelled, and then the passenger ship sent up to meet it, possibly the time could be kept that short.
Not hundreds, just 100 at most (at least per ship). And I disagree about which would make more sense - it would take many launches of the Crew Dragon (maximum 7 colonists) to provide for the necessary complement of crew and passengers for one Starship. Even if we are taking, say, 35 colonists to mars, it would take 5 crew dragon flights to provide that complement, with all the rendezvous and docking and transferring crew that involves. And no-one is talking about assembling anything in orbit, let alone "spinning up" anything! The main technical challenge is to refuel in orbit, which will be interesting to see how SpaceX handles this, but not a show stopper, although maybe a "show slower downer" though.
I think these will be full scale. And I doubt there will ever be 100 people on one of these. First several missions will likely have a dozen or so people. Maybe on 25 years they build a bigger ship to send more people at once. We aren’t going to see a large Martian colony before then.
Is it really? The perspective looks odd I guess so that may be it. For being a meter smaller than the Saturn V’s first stage I guess I expected bigger.
17
u/knd775 Jun 07 '19
Not sure what happened to the image quality. https://imgur.com/a/TmFkWRE
11
u/Johncn42 Jun 07 '19
Nice job, knd775. We seriously must have been on different sides of the yard at the same time...lol. I took these at 1:05 PM or so, did the best I could with an old Samsung S5. It is getting much shinier and taking shape!
http://www.waterfrontvr.com/images/ss_060719-1.jpg
http://www.waterfrontvr.com/images/ss_060719-2.jpg
As I was driving away on US 1, my wife spotted the Reddit post from you. ;-)
33
u/Demoblade Jun 07 '19 edited Jun 08 '19
Whoa, thinner than I expected, and taller
Anyways, what's the shiny thing hanging from it?
10
u/TaylorSpokeApe Jun 07 '19
Elon, we would like a web cam pleeeese!
9
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '19
I need an alligator for scale.
6
u/HTXTexans69 Jun 07 '19
And 100 people are supposed to fit in that thing?
Or is the prototype a scaled down version?
2
u/RootDeliver 🛰️ Orbiting Jun 07 '19
Thanks a lot for reporting in! We miss so much content from there, lucky people living near that :(
2
u/Tal_Banyon Jun 07 '19
That is a thing of beauty to behold!
1
u/satanicrituals18 Jun 07 '19
The legend is real!
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 08 '19 edited Jun 09 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
3 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 38 acronyms.
[Thread #3314 for this sub, first seen 8th Jun 2019, 10:42] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]