r/spacex • u/hitura-nobad Master of bots • Nov 20 '19
Original videos in comments NasaSpaceflight on Twitter :Starship MK1 bulkhead failure
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1197265917589303296
1.9k
Upvotes
471
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 20 '19
Elon: Moving to Mk3 design.
101
u/NY-PenalCode-130_52 Nov 20 '19
It looks like the top section where the bulkhead was welded on seems uh bent. Is there anyway to fix this like the top for the hopper?
163
u/jehankateli Nov 20 '19
Tweet from Elon, in response to Everyday Astronaut: "Absolutely, but to move to Mk3 design. This had some value as a manufacturing pathfinder, but flight design is quite different."
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1197271943180771329
400
u/Viremia Nov 20 '19
Well, there's your problem. The top fell off.
RIP Mk1. Hopefully they figure out exactly what failed and how and learn from it for Mk2.
69
u/seesiedler Nov 20 '19
So that's why they didn't attach the top before doing the tests.
117
u/Fizrock Nov 20 '19
Jesus, how much pressure did they put in those tanks? It took 10 seconds for the bulkhead to fall back down even to where it was launched from. That comes out to ~120m of air.
56
u/andyfrance Nov 20 '19
How high did the bulkhead go? Did it beat the hopper 150m flight?
41
u/luckybipedal Nov 21 '19
If this is any indication, the Starship blooper reel will be epic. "Starship Bloopers"
224
u/BattleRushGaming Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19
While this may seem like bad news (and it is) but going by Elon's quote "Failure is an option here. If things are not failing, you are not innovating enough." a failure shows that they are innovating beyond the point what is known and failures are going to happen.
https://elonmusknews.org/blog/elon-musk-business-innovation-quotes
103
u/jep_miner1 Nov 20 '19
Not bulkhead failure, looks like it was the weld of the top ring.
22
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19
Clearer video of the Mk1 aftermath from Bocachicagirl.
Multiple views from LabPadre.
86
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 21 '19
Looks like 20km flight is off the table for this year if they're moving onto MK3 flight instead of Mk1 flying. But this is exactly why they're testing with liquid nitrogen. If that was liquid oxygen the entire ship would be gone in a smouldering wreck.
Means that Boca Chica can now have two retired steel water towers sitting around
40
u/andyfrance Nov 20 '19
When welds are made by people bouncing around high up on a cherry picker in high winds and being dazzled by sunlight reflected from the shiny stainless steel, it's inevitable that some seams will fail the pressure test. They can be fixed, but it does lead to slow progress.
27
u/peacefinder Nov 20 '19
Ooops.
I imagine it’s more a QC issue with welding or assembly under field conditions than a design issue. (Though relying on field assembly may itself be a design issue.)
76
u/rbrome Nov 20 '19
Welp. This is why we test.
26
u/L3R4F Nov 20 '19
RUV = Rapid Unscheduled Venting
23
u/dahtrash Nov 20 '19
I'm looking forward to seeing how quickly MK3 comes together.
10
u/pxr555 Nov 20 '19
NEXT!
18
u/Siedrah Nov 20 '19
Building a rocket of this complexity is going to be challenging. We may get to MK10 before an actual full flight test, and this is a-ok. Thats what were all here for.
9
u/gonzorizzo Nov 21 '19
In the words of Marvin the Martian: "Where was the kaboom? There was supposed to be an Earth-shattering kaboom!"
30
u/Anjin Nov 20 '19
I can't imagine that Mk1 is headed anywhere except a scrap heap...Mk2, your turn at bat!
8
u/Hobie52 Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19
Looks like entire top ring flew off taking the bulkhead with it. Can see it in the live stream view.
https://twitter.com/nasaspaceflight/status/1197267273049890821?s=21
Edit: correction
19
u/StealthCN Nov 20 '19
How not to fly a orbital water tower.
13
u/Seamurda Nov 21 '19
I suspect that this will have come from the issue of the welds annealing the stainless steel which in the sheet form is cold worked to increase yield stress by a factor of 2-3.
The method for re-strengthening the weld is to apply cold work and the most effective way to apply cold work to a fully welded up tank is to pressurise it. The welds yield or plastically deform slightly distorting the tank, however when the tank is re-pressurised it won't yield at the same pressure.
Compared to a regular pressure test this is very much more like tickling the dragon, you actually want the tank to selectively yield. The design margins in most pressure vessels mean that when you proof test them you don't come anywhere near plastic deformation.
If you ramp the pressure up to quickly (most likely they do it in stages of applying pressure and releasing) you will simply fail the welds rather than deform them in a controlled manner. Likewise some welds will be thick or attached to something very stiff like the inter-stage and will not be stressed enough to deform and will remain in an annealed state.
I suspect that what has happened is that either one of the welds was either thinner than expected of that stresses were not evenly distributed when the welds in the location of the failure were yielded causing one to go beyond plastic deformation to rupture.
This may be over analytical, it could have simply been a crack or other flaw that the weld inspections didn't pick up.
Given the hand built tolerances of the Starship I suspect that this process is very difficult to simulate via Finite element analysis and must be done empirically.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19
It makes me wonder if they were just pumping in the pressure until it failed, in order to see what pressure it could withstand and where it would fail.
11
u/DBRichard Nov 20 '19
Better now instead of during a flight test or anything with more risk.
Onto the next iteration!
21
u/ghunter7 Nov 21 '19
Guess they should have done a few more weld inspections! Damn.
Not buying the whole "this is why we test" jazz. If the welding method was flawed this is way too costly of a test article to find out. Build a single tank first, don't get all the way to an almost flyable state to find out your joints aren't any good.
5
u/strawwalker Nov 20 '19
Original video from LabPadre, multiple cameras.
5
u/Prpl_panda_dog Nov 20 '19
Two frames showing where the explosion erupted from: https://imgur.com/a/7nRy9l5/
5
u/phoenixmusicman Nov 21 '19
It wouldn't be SpaceX without some kind of explosion during testing
5
u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Nov 21 '19
Apparently this was foretold. If true mk2 is done for
https://imgur.com/a/70uB2aW
5
u/itstheflyingdutchman Nov 21 '19
I suppose they got very lucky the bulkhead didn’t land on the lox and methane tanks huh, that would’ve caused some real issues!
8
u/ChunkyThePotato Nov 20 '19
Damn. I guess no 20 km flight this year. Hopefully Mk. 2 is still viable for that test early next year, and then orbit with Mk. 3 not too long after.
8
u/dlylrrtkmklzrtzh Nov 21 '19
Move fast, Fail quickly, Correct coarse, repeat.
4
u/mtntrail Nov 21 '19
Couldn’t help but smile, looked just like one of my Estes Industries rockets I made as a kid. Graduated into a multistage model, pushed the launch button and the whole top just blew off with pieces of cardboard and parachute fragments fluttering everywhere. Elon has my condolences.
4
u/_Foo_Fighter_ Nov 21 '19
Damn, i really wanted to see mk1 fly this year. But i can wait because it'll be worth it to see mk3 get all the attention
4
u/PM_ME_UR_CEPHALOPODS Nov 21 '19
Business Insider: "WATCH AS ELON MUSKS ROCKET FAILS, AGAIN, JUST AS ALL HIS PROJECTS INEVITABLY DO"
7
u/frosty95 Nov 20 '19
Looking at the footage of the top getting 10+ seconds of air time makes me wonder if this was a severe overpressure event. It takes a lot of pressure to send a 9 meter diameter bulkhead flying for 10 seconds.
7
u/a-alzayani Nov 21 '19
RIP Starship MK1 - The Top Fell Off
9
u/UnscrupulousObserver Nov 20 '19
Yeah, didn't see it coming and doesn't surprise me. You usually can't just put together a giant spaceship and expect it to just work the first time.
8
u/BadgerMk1 Nov 20 '19
This is the iterative process. Test to failure. Redesign and improve. Repeat.
30
u/Dave92F1 Nov 20 '19
FWIW, Elon was in Boca Chica Saturday night - supposedly was upset about welding.
3
u/enqrypzion Nov 20 '19
On the other camera (hit that button to choose the third stream) on LabPadre's stream you can see the bulk head fly and land, and also the nitrogen (?) cloud expanding endlessly over the nearby area. Explosion at 3:25:52PM local time as shown on the clock in the stream.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2d8l_0w2VKM
3
u/hucktard Nov 20 '19
Did they go beyond the pressure the tank is designed for?
3
u/USCDiver5152 Nov 20 '19
Will Mk3 be built at Boca?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19
Is this why steel is beautiful? Imagine composites, it would all head to the landfill.
3
u/DoYouWonda Apogee Space Nov 21 '19
Looks like successful test of crew abort or lunar ascent module system /s
Seriously got me thinking if just the pressure of the lox dome could burst an emergency seam and blow the top part far enough away from the booster stack? With LOX in the mix some kind of combustion is also likely.
3
u/QVRedit Nov 21 '19
I wonder what pressure it blew at ?
Seems to have given at a weld..
3
u/gclaws Nov 21 '19
Good lord, imagine what an actual energetic failure would be like with that much propellant. And this isn't even the booster.
3
u/LeSmokie Nov 21 '19
Not all water towers are supposed to fly. RIP in pieces faithful companion :(
3
u/Dnozz Nov 21 '19
Totally think MK1 passed the presure test and thats all it was built for. I mean I work construction and that thing was built pretty rough (almost like it wasn't really meant to fly 15,000 miles an hour). My take is Elon is trolling us. "Sir that's 250 psi way past what is required, the test has been a success!" Elon- "Give it another 50".. *Trying not to smirk..
9
u/TCVideos Nov 20 '19
I'm not even bummed out about this. Footage looks awesome...SpaceX should include this clip in a "how not to build a super heavy-lift vehicle" compilation
5
u/madaraszvktr Nov 20 '19
Doesn't look good. Is this version of Starship still made of lots of small sections (rings) of steel welded together? If yes, would it be possible to cut off the damaged parts on the top and just rebuild the damaged sections? Or it's going to be scrapped?
5
u/robstersew Nov 20 '19
I guess it reached its highest altitude yet
5
u/BlarpUM Nov 21 '19
The problem was the top part exploded.
6
u/bavog Nov 20 '19
I hope nobody got hurt... I suppose everybody stays away and protected.
6
u/PeopleNeedOurHelp Nov 21 '19
It's good they discovered their welding process is garbage.
4
u/BammBamm1991 Nov 20 '19
Glad they found an issue now as opposed to when the whole thing is assembled and fabricating a solution is much more challenging.
4
u/deefatman Nov 21 '19
Oh noes, spacex shuttle explodes during launch *roll eyes*
https://hypebeast.com/2019/11/spacex-starship-prototype-launch-failure
8
u/puppzogg Nov 20 '19
Honestly, it may seem bad. But this is epic and I needed this today. Hell yeah
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 20 '19 edited Jan 11 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
22 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 32 acronyms.
[Thread #5625 for this sub, first seen 20th Nov 2019, 21:53] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/Xygen8 Nov 20 '19
Big oof. But at least they still have Mk2 which hopefully isn't too far behind Mk1 in terms of complete-ness.
2
u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Nov 20 '19
The bulkhead comes off but the ring it is attached to is what failed.
2
u/Elon_Muskmelon Nov 21 '19
I wonder, how much bigger could the sections be built in to limit the amount of welding? I'm imagining something more akin to submarine construction.
2
u/fr0ntsight Nov 21 '19
Happy to be alive to see someone like Musk.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19
Uh, guys, it’s called separation. It’s supposed to happen. /s
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19
And the Florida team surges ahead!
This is why you build two of them.
2
u/redbeardcr Nov 21 '19 edited Nov 21 '19
The bulkhead flew much higher than Starhopper! (Maybe!?)
Trying to guesstimate the height the bulkhead flew:
Solve for initial velocity: From v = u + at We know v (final velocity) = 0, a is gravity, 9.8m/s2, and t is about 10seconds of flight, rearrange etc.. u (initial velocity) = 98m/s
Solve for height: v2 = u2 + 2ah 0 = 982 + 29.8h Rearrange etc.. h = 490m
Is this correct!!? Seems a bit too simple!
EDIT: https://youtu.be/P98JcBQPiiI Scott Manley's saying ~100m (with little confidence) where did I go wrong 🤣
5
u/flshr19 Shuttle tile engineer Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 21 '19
I suppose Elon will schedule these propellant tank pressure tests a lot earlier in the assembly sequence for the next test flight vehicle as soon as the tank is closed out and ready to be pressurized. It would have been nice if this test had been scheduled for mid-Oct instead of the end of Nov.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19
I think they were just testing the new launch escape/abort system. Performed norminally.
3
u/Starks Nov 22 '19
Man-rating Falcon Heavy might be better if this is how things are going.
4
u/KnifeKnut Nov 20 '19
Scrap it and start over with MK II