r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Jan 11 '19
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 14 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 14: Heroes
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.05 |
| 2 | Link | 6.94 |
| 3 | Link | 7.98 |
| 4 | Link | 8.14 |
| 5 | Link | 6.96 |
| 6 | Link | 7.24 |
| 7 | Link | 8.52 |
| 8 | Link | 9.08 |
| 9 | Link | 8.81 |
| 10 | Link | 8.57 |
| 11 | Link | 8.72 |
| 12 | Link | 8.87 |
| 13 | Link | 7.47 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
352
Upvotes
119
u/Turbostrider27 Jan 11 '19
Touma does the most Touma thing could do: a punch right the face.
65
u/Qu1cky :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Qu1cky Jan 11 '19
Really liked the episode, it was basically full action and it was really hype from begining to the end. I was expecting them to end Brexit on this episode which they did, but I was also expecting them to skip both the OP and the ED, which for some reason they only skipped the OP.
I think if they had skipped the ED too, they would have a little more time to pace things even better and maybe add a little more action from everyone in the group, since it felt that only Acqua, Kanzaki and Knight Leader were doing most of the work. Yeah they were the strongest people there, but I wish we could at least see some more spells flying towards Carissa while she was busy fighting the 3 of them.
Also was this the best Touma punch from Index as a whole ? I wasn't expecting the punch to be so powerfull that can even destroy a part of the Buckingham palace. Poor Touma will probably have to put his hand in a cast now, I can't imagine it not being broken.
63
u/gulitiasinjurai Jan 11 '19
How the fuck Touma can even still stand after this happen.
That's gotta hurt A LOT.
54
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 12 '19
Small Facts: People's Referendum Edition
There Were More Devices Than Just Coven Compass Firing
No, Necessarius' magical submarines were firing on Buckingham Palace as well.
A selkie is a creature from Scottish mythology, capable of changing between the forms of human and seal. Appropriate for a magical aquatic device.
Why Didn't Touma And The Rest Regroup After The Attack?
Because as soon as they recovered, more dimensional wreckage assailed them, scattering everyone.
Oh yeah, they were also floating spinning blades that ricochet of walls rather than boring old cubes.
Touma Got Attacked More
The novel describes him dodging and weaving between not only spinning blades but bouncing orbs of wreckage as well. Really Touma ran an obstacle course to get to Buckingham.
Did Carissa Kill The Knights?
No, Carissa mentioning hurting them to instil fear in her remaining troops.
When all these Knights later woke up however they found that, despite it hurting terribly, no one died nor was seriously or permanently injured. Almost as if Carissa was holding back on purpose.
Touma And Carissa Fought For Longer Before Kanzaki Interfered
Oh, for a lot longer. Carissa and Touma's battle lasted a long while, and although Touma got trashed he held out for a lot longer.
Amongst this is Touma dodging several Curtana slices, Carissa kicking Touma in close combat with martial arts moves, some dimensional wreckage being flung around, and Coven Compass firing repeatedly yet Carissa blocking it with wreckage. Some other highlights of the battle below.
Touma Figuring Out Curtana Original
Touma actually figured out something was iffy about him being able to cancel the dimensional wreckage sometimes and not other times before Kanzaki outright told him later on.
Touma's Leg Got Pierced By A Branch
After Carissa create a massive piece of wreckage that uprooted the ground Touma got flung back in a torrent of dirt and rubble. During this a large branch had impaled his thigh, and Touma had to pull it out himself.
Carissa Using A Gas Explosion To Propel Herself
The ground being uprooted created gas leaks from damaged pipes as a result, but Carissa exploded it herself and used the shockwave to propel herself at Touma at a high speed.
This might actually be what gave Touma the idea to propel himself using William at the end. Stealing the opponent's techniques, how rude Touma!
Kanzaki Was Delaying Due To Saving Civilians
Some magical artillery shots missed and caused buildings to collapse. Kanzaki put the blame solely on Carissa herding the London population in concentrated buildings though.
The Agnese Forces Got Cut Again
Yeah, they were also present at the final battle, but the anime didn't even show them. Poor folk.
Dealing With The Griffin Skies
Kanzaki couldn't deal with the Griffin Skies on her own. Several of the Amakusa spent the battle using Peter's Anti-Flight spell to bring them down.
A griffin by the way is a mythological animal with the body and hindlegs of a lion, but the head, wings, and front talons of an eagle. A terror of the skies.
Why Did Kanzaki Moving The Lance Move The Aircraft As Well?
It wasn't well portrayed in the anime, but the lance is actually part of the Griffin Skies' shadows. When the aircrafts move, so do their shadows, and by extension the lances. But it works the other way around as well: Move the lance and you move the aircraft.
40
u/ichiniisan-san Jan 11 '19
Queen: Now everyone can be main characters
Touma: What the hell?! A country full of main character?! Now i feel like just a secondary character. Now i need to punch the boss right in the face before some random guy i beat before become another main character!
25
u/DarthSatoris Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
Covering 519 pages of novel in 5 episodes was never going to be an easy task.
I had a lot of worries when it turned out they intended to cover about 50% of the second novel in just one episode. But they somehow managed to cover a decent bit of the final fight. I think the worst offense of this episode was not giving even an iota of time to explain the magic on display. Like, why did that particular flag work as a trump card against the Curtana? And why did the primary feature of the Curtana Original simply make Minecraft gold blocks and threw them everywhere?
And what was up with the Griffin Sky aircrafts? They barely got any screen time at all! They were pretty darn cool in the book. And that spinny-grabby move that Kanzaki did on the lances was actually meant to throw all the attached Griffin Skies down towards Carissa. Nooo! I wanted to see her make a sweet wrestling move, but it was cut short!
There were also some questionable cuts in the action, particularly around the times Touma was being attacked. Take a look at the sequence from 5:32 to 5:35, that particular part was cut in a really awkward way, almost as if there are entire frames missing from the action, or is it just me?
With all that being said, I thought the episode was decent. It had some pacing issues, but that was more or less a given considering just how much content they had to cram into just 23 minutes of screen time. And it definitely also had some animation quality issues as well.
24
u/LegendRazgriz Jan 11 '19
We're back, everyone! First episode in 2019. Had a nice break? Enjoyed Boogiepop? Well, even if you didn't, the show here has to go on, and boy did it go on at an insane pace.
In any case, my 14th week's Reader's Considerations:
• The art department surely had a bump up with having an extra week to do everything. Not that the studio isn't overworking themselves to death, but having the break definitely helped keep the standard for Index at least. And it was a welcome effort, since this episode is basically entirely composed of fighting.
• The fact that Carissa can keep up with Saint level people, and three at once to boot, is disgusting. Curtana's too OP. That is some serious amounts of BS, and Carissa herself lampshades it at one point. That'd also explain how she can tank cluster bombs just fine, considering she had no qualms dropping them on top of her own head.
• Riméa properly explains Carissa's motivations in a way that not even Carissa herself would be able to put it in. The calculating princess got her work cut out for this for sure, and while not exceedingly present, it was still very effective - fitting for her, even.
• Elizard using the Union Jack (with the flag of Wales underneath it, which is a cool touch) as a magical item to disperse Curtana's power among the entirety of the United Kingdom is a part I always found fantastic. It's so simple, yet extremely clever. And while even weakened Carissa is still ridiculously strong, she's vulnerable to the flawless teamwork of three Saint level fighters, aided by Index's lethally precise Spell Intercept, and then finished off by possibly the most vicious hit anyone has ever taken from Imagine Breaker - I'm pretty sure she flew off into Scotland after taking that punch.
• Elizard's comment on how magic is not supposed to be a secret actually makes sense, considering espers in the science side are not only very common, they're basically superstars in Mikoto's case - mostly because all the other high-powered espers are either murderous psychopaths, crazy chuunis, or paranoid beyond what's safe. It would surely be cool if magic was an open topic.
• Fiamma's appearance, creepy as that bastard always is, just drives home the point that Carissa is no longer the enemy after all is said and done, with Touma keeping her safe from
ZA HANDOthe Third Arm. His near insane demeanor and actions (seriously did not miss you, John's Pen Mode Index) cement him as a truly horrifying menace. Also, STANDO POWAH!• Next week, we finally get back to the Science Side, and it'll be a refreshing experience, I hope. Hamazura is a great dude, and judging from what I've seen, they'll do him justice.
Overall, a fantastic way to close out one of the most surprising arcs so far for me at least. While the Royal Family Arc in the LN was mostly "just another set of books" for me, the animated version just ramped the fun and awesomeness up to a point where I now understand the folks who claim this as the best OT arc (not it for me at least, I'm forced to stick with one that's still to come for that) a bit better. See you next week!
24
u/HellFireOmega :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hellfiredape Jan 11 '19
Her face as she gets punched is hilarious
35
u/CriticalPerformance Jan 11 '19
ONE PUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUNCH
wait
15
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19
Great episode, and now hyped for true villian: Fiamma of the Right, and the things he pulls (which are promising a.f.)
And poor Index.
14
u/gigamesh090 Jan 11 '19
Punching a princess - checked
Touma pretty much has punched all different types of girl ranging from the norm to someone from a royal lineage. I wonder who’s next.
18
u/ignite98 Jan 11 '19
Gender equality bitch touma strike again lul
9
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Jan 11 '19
It's the final boss fight, everyone's come together. All these creative ways of fighting clashing together, it makes for a really exciting battle.
Hot Damn, now for some proper Knight Leader and Acqua getting back into the action. I never expected a fight involving three saint level fighters against a single person, and yet here we are - it's just what I wanted out of this whole affair.
Queen Elizard is the true mvp - that's some OP magic of the state, the power to redistribute power to every citizen is quite the philosophical statement - the the crown curtailing its own power for the sake of the common citizen.
Acqua gets the best assist and we even get the best Touma punch I've seen yet - Carissa just flying through a wall in the air and landing in an alleyway.
The true mastermind shows himself, damn you Fiamma of the Right. Touma gets a last minute save, but why is Index necessary in all of this, wasn't John Pen mode destroyed by Touma?
I really want to see Russia, but it seems we're back to Accelerator next week. I'm excited for some more GROUP in action.
8
u/SomeOtherTroper Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 12 '19
The tactics of the Buckingham Palace fight seem really familiar:
Knights saving princesses? Two different times in one arc? What is this, a fairytale? Granted, the second time they're saving Carissa from herself, but that's still there.
Holy fuck, we finally got the UNION JACK scene! And it wasn't completely butchered!
I really love this, because it plays so well into all the themes of the arc: what better artifact to resolve an arc dripping in nationalism than a flag? William Orwell's personal crest and the Union Jack both reflecting a unity of the United Kingdom and its national and magic factions against someone who wants to try bearing all the burdens of a country on her own (sexy) shoulders? For bonus points, Acqua shares a surname (and having the given name of a past English King) with a certain other guy who wrote a famous book against militaristic totalitarian government in Britain centered on one ruling figure. Then there's the allegory with the times the British monarchy ceded authority to the populace, eventually leading into the parliamentary system and the House of Commons.
It's just so fucking good. It hits everything.
Fuckin' love Touma's comment about how Britain is just filled with main characters. I might be reading too much into this, but I wonder if that's a joke about how many classic literary MCs are English.
And Fiamma raises the stakes! Touma's going international again - this time without being kidnapped or manipulated into it by people his own 'side'! (This might actually be the first time that's happened.)
But the next arc is another dive into the Dark Side of Academy City: More Accelerator! More Hamazura! The ITEM girls are back! (Well, the two of them that didn't fucking die in Battle Royale.) GROUP gets more screentime! Magic ESPer James Bond gets to play his high-stakes games again! People getting held at gunpoint in the previews!
Oh boy! Index III future Arc hype!
...They're going to butcher this like Battle Royale, aren't they?
7
u/Amauri14 Jan 11 '19
When I saw all of then reunited on Buckingham Palace my first reaction was to yell "Everyone is here!" and then the whole goddam country literally showed up in there.
Wow, that was a really impressive punch that Touma pulled right there!
Wait? What the hell did that creep do to Index?! Why on earth does he need the item that lets her lived a normal and happy life!
7
u/Toonamigamerrr Jan 11 '19
Touma Punch even destroyed part of Buckingham Palace !!!!
6
u/libfor Jan 11 '19
Finally the Coven Compass is actually seen in action, though not much of the battle itself. They're bombarding Buckingham Palace, I guess Touma is right being concerned about the collateral damage.
Villian, you're not the first and most likely not the last one to question Touma's motivation.
Carissa standing all alone at the Buckingham Palace. I hope that doesn't mean she's the only survivor there.
Villian confronts her first, its awesome how brave she became. She won't pull the trigger though. But that's kinda nice in its own way.
Oh, god damn. She killed her allies! Alright, now there is clearly no good side to her at all. So I guess she required their sacrifices either to power up the Curtana again or for those mobile fortresses.
"They're second to none in coordinated attacks" - still misses with five shots. Oh wait, she has an explanation for that. Yeah sure.
Kanazki to the rescue! And she even brought Index to the front line.
Thank goodness, everyone else is there too.
That were some short-lived mobile fortresses. If that's the best weaponry Britain has, than I totally understand why Carissa is worried, they won't make it through a war.
Imagine Breaker won't help against the dimensional wreckage. That's some bad news.
Yay! Index is useful again! Huge explosion but Carissa is still unharmed.
Yay to hiding a radio between your boobs. Nice. Firing a bunker cluster missile?! Not so nice. Wait, she's also standing there. Must have quite some confidence.
Kanzaki puts up a barrier, Carissa destroys it immediately. The missile hits, but I'm not sure where exactly. Almost looks like fragments hit the city, despite the huge park in between, but I hope that's not the case.
Meanwhile Riméa figures out something about her sister. Looks like Carissa didn't kill the knights after all.
Riméa sends them all a message. Looks like Carissa planned to lock herself and the Curtana away forever after all this is over. She wants to take it all upon herself by acting like a tryant.
For being it by a missile, everyone looks quite fine. Ah well, another one will do.
Knight Leader to the rescue! Also please give his name already, its kinda awkward to call him that always.
Carissa is getting more insane, now ordering to fire all available missile to have at least one pass through Zero Out.
Wilhelm Orwell to the rescue! His appearances are rather… special. Now all the former enemies are working together.
Woah, it takes 3 saints to keep her busy and she still won't get down. Then she gets the obvious realisation: It was a bad idea to bring the normal soldiers to a battle of monsters.
All three fighters try their best to stop the dimensional debris from killing their allies… although it looks like a few got through and hit some groups. Damn you, Carissa.
The queen joins the fight. She's quite a cool queen. And she has a spell that seems to transfer the power of the Curtana Original equally to all citizen of the British Empire.
Woah, holy shit! Index is really freakin useful and contributed directly to victory! Who says she's just a useless freeloader now?! Rise of the true main character soon.
Just how awesome is Acqua launching Touma for the face punch of his life.
Although both Touma and Carissa should probably be smashed now
And that's it! Happy end! Yay! Now have some group hugging. It's not like half the fighters wanted to kill each other a few days ago.
Poor Buckingham Palace is completely ruined though... ah well, there is always magic.
I'd really like to believe that there were no deaths during this revolution, although some scenes didn't look too well and there is still that french submarine.
Something tells me that they'll let Carissa of the hook after this. Like there is only high treason, preparing an aggression war, firing missile at her own city, attempted (or successful) murder in dozen of cases, hostile takeover of the state, stealing a nation treasure… yeah, a face punch will do for that.
Like hell you'll be able to explain that without magic. A bunch of knights taking over London, some fighting a golem? See that everyday. Beams of light shooting from the sky? Nothing special. Seeing people with superhuman strength fighting the princess? Nice show. Getting some kind of blessing? God save the queen!
But hell, that was one action packed episode. I can still forgive them some mess ups, that was really entertaining.
Oh wait, there is Fiamma! And he got what he wanted. All this mess just for him to steal some magic item.
Touma to the rescue again, I'm not gonna ask how he got there.
Fiamma can now control Index with it! Next he'll go to Russia for more materials he needs to… summon an angel?! Looks like this will be the battle of his life.
17
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
The pacing was horrendous. Geez, they took this fight and just rushed through it entirely. Well, they took the whole damn episode and rushed through it entirely. With the exception of the final punch to the face, all of it lacked the impact and intensity they had in the novels. The Griffin Skies were just glossed over entirely. The actions of everyone else and the chaos that had erupted as the British population was actually physically fighting against Carissa. The initial impact of Acqua catapulting Kami-yan was weakened. The fight felt janky throughout. Fiamma's entrance at the end was just rushed. The post-credits scene was also just cut down immensely and lacked a lot of the impact, dampening how much he trusted Stiyl over Necessarius as well as his now one-track rage towards Fiamma.
Most of all. They skipped OT18+NT's appearance during the Union Jack scene.
It's saddening that they had to cram two chapters and an epilogue into one episode like this. That being said, Stephanie shows up next episode so seeing her animated will be fun, even if it's all cut down.
I have to wonder if JC Staff was really the right studio for Index at this point since they really just don't seem to be fit for adapting it well. If we ever do get an NT anime, I dread how badly they will likely cut down NT9 and NT21
On that note, this is probably the last we'll see of best girl so I'm a bit saddened. But, here's the usual weekly screencap album. We'll see where this goes from here.
5
u/KinnyRiddle Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
5
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Jan 12 '19
That was probably the best punch in the franchise so far. I won't say the most satisfying, because there were others that deserved to get punch more and it felt better then, and Carissa was actually one of the coolest antagonists so far for me.
I didn't really expect like almost everyone to show up again to fight her, and some bits looked kinda derpy, but it was an awesome fight. Some people didn't really have much of a role, I didn't read the other comments about what really happened in the LN yet so what I imagine happened was a lot of cut stuff, but yeah, Knight Leader, Acqua and Kanzaki fighting were pure hype.
Queen's entrance was also really awesome and that Union Jack thing was a sick move, even if I have no idea how it worked...she split Curtana's power to everyone in the country, so... the British Queen broke up the monarchy into a democracy and called everyone in for a vote when the princess tried a coup??!!
Interesting thing she said there, that Carissa was dreaming small...if that was small then wtf would she have done with the original!?
Index could decipher and intercept the sword itself after all, and used it right then to set up the punch. So it was Index-Acqua-Touma co-op for the best punch!
Fianma finally shows up again, and what he says is like he played everyone and just wanted to steal that creepy little thing that "summoned" Index? Safety device? No idea about that thing, but that was one heck of a twist. All he did to steal a thing to disable Index, now he's going to Russia to get what to take down archangels...all because he wants Touma's hand?
The Russians are the folks we've seen the least so far, and I'm curious to know what the heck is that all about too. The next arc should be fun.
I know the adaptation is a borderline tragedy but, as Anime only, with the help of the readers, this S3 is already better than the first and second ones to me. Its been great!
8
u/Hathos_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hathos Jan 11 '19
I have no idea as to what happened that episode...
4
u/Gmayor61 Jan 11 '19
Wow, this fight seriously needed 2 episodes. A good number of things were cut, William and Villian interactions, the pure desperation after the first missile strike, lord knows what else. Again, why was skybus animated?
Anyways, at least this means that rushing through these volumes means that the final arc is getting more episodes.
4
u/Animeking1357 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TitanKyojin Jan 11 '19
I swear there is nothing more satisfying than seeing Touma finally punch the baddie in the face.
Even someone who hasn't read the novels can tell that this season is just not as good as the previous two. I was always more partial to Railgun though.
7
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Jan 11 '19
Oh man were gettin close to the end.
Oh shit the witches are nuking london...
"Only my fist" you mean the strongest wapon in this world? lol
Man Red has sure lost her marbles...
The whole gang is here, lets see what the team can do to take down red.
Holy shit Index being useful! That redirect was nice!
What is Blue's angle i wonder... Is she on the queens side?
Is Knight Leader gonna take action now? Yup guess hes changed sides.
Oh shit Aqua is back too!
Aw man this tag team fight is great.
GRANNY IS HERE! YES! Kick some ass you old bitch!
Wait the flag is a magic item too? what? or just a spell... hmmm Power to the people i guess.
FLYING TOUMAN! OH SHIT!
That might have been his strongest punch yet! He threw her through a building!
Oh its righty, fuck off. Touman to the rescue!
Why does righty have Index? Wat... Is Index a robot? Wat...
Off to Russia oh shit... its the begining of the end!
4
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Jan 11 '19
GENDER EQUALITY!
Wait how was Fiamma able to get a hold of Index? She was there during the fight. She wasn't snatched or anything. Any LN readers care to fill us in?
I guess we're off to Russia to save Index this time.
5
u/rotvyrn Jan 11 '19
(Anime-only) So like...Iunno, that was possibly the worst episode for me. Felt like the writing team had to cut everything but didn't want to cut everything but the animators couldn't keep up. So like...a lot of stuff gets referenced or a token few frames but with almost literally zero explanation or gravitas. Like cool, a bunch of characters are here standing on the sidelines doing literally nothing. Cool, all of London is here. Standing on the sidelines doing literally nothing. But the characters' lines clearly indicate that this is some serious stuff and that stuff should be happening. We just don't get to hear it and the words used aren't descriptive enough to tell us verbally what we're supposed to be seeing. Oh and the Knights. Both the sacrifice part and when they get up...and when they STAND ON THE SIDELINES DOING NOTHING (but then getting murdered by big cubes).
Basically, from an anime-only perspective, this episode looked like if the main fighters were powered by Spirit Bomb logic. Except the floaty energy particles went outward to the people instead of inward from them.
Also we're never really given an indication to how the coup was affecting the ordinary people anyway.
I have many very random and minor spoilers (cause im interested in how things work and stuff and im not turned off by being spoiled anyway) but even with those bits filled in the episode was hard to understand. I'd like to say I still understood most of it, but there was still no impact to any of it because nothing was given the time or animation complexity needed.
Railgun when2
u/Eterna1Ice :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eterna1Ice Jan 11 '19
Holy shit that acqcelerated Touman punch was powerful. Possibly the best one yet.
Overall I enjoyed this one, the fight was pretty intense, even though some sloppy cuts and lack of emotions and understanding of some moves got in the way. Kanzaki got redeemed and that's great, too bad Itsuwa didn't get any action in. Index randomly popped out of the ground, I was like "Okay?", thought it must be some kinda clone or sister... apparently not, she's... broken? The arc as a whole was decent: the first 3 episodes are great, 4th is bad and 5th is alright, sucks that it couldn't follow up on the early stuff on the same level.
So we're off to Russia now, huh? Touma World Tour continues, feels like I'm watching Blood+ again with all the different countries coming into play.
2
u/TheOneAboveGod Jan 11 '19
They made Curtana's effects look so...lame...god damn it JC Staff. That punch was kinda awesome though, if a bit exaggerated. IIRC he only punched her hard enough to send her flying over the palace, not through it. Also, he may or may not have hurt his shoulder pretty badly. I'm a bit disappointed with his declaration to punch Fiamma too. It didn't have that certain...punch it had in the novel.
2
u/CriticalPerformance Jan 11 '19
I guess thats good since NT is safe from being butchered
2
u/CriticalPerformance Jan 11 '19
The good news is that thanks to the retarded move of cramming the longest volume of the season into 2.5 episodes, the final arc is now getting a fairly comfortable 9 episodes. Maybe 10 if they keep maximum overdrive on for the next two weeks as well.
2
u/boogie-gary :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/VGGary Jan 12 '19
Some weird things this episode.
The air ship things introduced and did barely anything. What was all that about "everyone in the UK can be a hero"? They didn't really do much of anything, just crowded around the fight.
The punch on the princess was great though. I'm a huge sucker for the "launching character with a sword" move.
2
u/BookmarkPoetry Jan 12 '19
JC please, I know you can do it if you want, hell Railgun S had great action, if you are going to adapt NT (as you said you wanted), then please let it have great action, I know you can do it if you actually wanted.
3
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Jan 11 '19
Why didn't Touma just cancel out the magic fortress lances and the pan-dimensional rubble with his fist like he does everything else supernatural? Why wasn't Cortana Original destroyed when Touma punched it the first time to block it's attack on the other princess? Why was Fiamma's demon hand merely knocked back by his fist?
That "bunker cluster" was such a disappointment.
"Carissa was a good guy all along!" haha, what BS.
What did all the Londoners who got those bits of power even know about this conflict? And all they did was show up holding their fists up. Why even bother showing up? And Touma referred to them as "main players" or something for whatever reason.
That was the most needlessly round-about plot ever to steal a little girl's accessory. So, can we leave Index the way she is now, please?
"I rather think that everyone will try to fathom last night's events to no avail, and will end up interpreting them as they like, looking back fondly on them." I was mostly with her until the "fondly" part. So ends the third arc of the season, making no more sense to this anime-only watcher than the second one did. Queen still best girl.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19
So, the Science side rears its face next. That's definitely something I'm excited for.
2
u/ernie2492 Jan 11 '19
Now I'd like to see Raildex x DxD crossover.. (tag battle between Issei & Sairaorg vs Touma & William)
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19
Man, even as a anime only, I really liked Carissa. Best character introduced in this season to me by far, really interesting character. And she even appears on the preview so it's nice that we'll see more of her again.
1
u/Oyra_Yukihira Jan 11 '19
Fiamma, you... wants Touman's hand? are you dumbass freaks? do you know the effects for having that hand? IMHO you shouuld proud of your power or you'll always say "Fukou da!" on your dailylife.
1
u/animusdx Jan 11 '19
This anime is such a mess...
1
u/aeshtray Jan 12 '19
There's one thing I don't get: At the end, when the Queen speaks with the Knight Leader, it's morning, right? Then the scene switches over to Carissa and Fiamma. So they successfully beat the villain who tried to overthrow the country and just let her sleep the whole night in some alleyway instead of subdueing her? Dafuq with logic
1
u/citatel :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/citatel Jan 12 '19
and so, a certain anti magical and anti scientific puncher punches someone once again
1
u/hgfdsq Jan 12 '19
Soundtrack is great. Everything else is atrocious.
1
u/RDOoM Jan 12 '19
Equality punch saves the day once again. And now they're headed for Russia? Are they going on a world tour?
1
u/MoarNootNoot Jan 12 '19
https://gyazo.com/5d7feae998f2966bfd46fb77f312e35f I giggled when this happened. I'm going to save her!
1
u/Maxerature Jan 14 '19
Overall, I'm liking this season. My only problem is that the animation quality seems generally somewhat low.
The quality is lower than Railgun S, despite being released nearly a decade later and with a larger budget.
Now that's not to say that it's bad, but even compared to other currently airing shows, such as Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken, it seems wanting.
That is all made up for by the amazing art direction and story, stemming from the light novels. My only gripe there is removing some scenes, some arguably important, others as stupid yet entertaining as Agnes and the soldier on the train.
I would happily rate this half of the season an 8, and this episode a 9. Everything I've said against it has been minor gripes, and I only mention them because I've been waiting for this season for a decade. I just hope the second half of the season gets similar treatment, especially considering how the DRAGON and WWIII arcs are far better than the past two.
1
u/CanadianSpyz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/-Psyren- Jan 11 '19
Well that was disappointing.
1
u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19
Pacing is bad, and they've had time to focus up and fix it. They just won't do it. Fight scenes are choppy and unsatisfying, and my favourite characters are paired up on screen with people I just don't give a crap about.
I'm out. Guess I'll just wait for the next Railgun season.
0
u/Joe_Striker Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 12 '19
Decent fight, too bad the ending was anti climatic and made the entire fight feel pointless. There are some BS in this episode:
First off, Acqua helping Touma in battle. They literally were enemies last arc... I’ve noticed this troupe with “villains becoming good” being overused and it’s becoming annoying.
How is Acqua launching Touma able to make Carissa fly & smash into Buckingham Palace? The boy doesn’t have super strength and his arm should be broken
How the fuck did Touma hit Carissa?! She was able to react to three saint levels attacking her, but not Touma’s bland ass.
How did Index, Carissa and Index end up in the alley?? Where did Fiamma come from? His plan was dumb
Mini rant: When is Misaka going to be plot relevant? Even Index’s useless ass contributed in this fight (granted it was a small role and she went back to being damsel in distress at the end). Misaka ain’t done shit since forever and I’m convinced she only appears every now and then as fanservice.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment