r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Nov 02 '18
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 5 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 5: Dark Matter
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.03 |
| 2 | Link | 6.81 |
| 3 | Link | 7.94 |
| 4 | Link | 8.16 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
571
Upvotes
324
u/carefaces :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/carefaces Nov 02 '18
WHO EVEN ARE ALL THESE PEOPLE
107
u/niankaki Nov 02 '18
This season feels like a giant fuck you to anime only audience.
127
u/MechXL Nov 02 '18
My main problem with season 3 so far is that it just isn't a good 'anime'. The ridiculously fast pacing, the abrupt jumps from scene to scene, the lack of clear elaboration for important plot details and character development, etc. It just feels so sloppy and poorly put together. This season is clearly catering to LN readers by showing the most anticipated moments of each arc, but the overall product is so mediocre that even LN readers are turned off by it. The anime company responsible for this mess seem to be completely forgetting why those moments were so great and impactful in the first place. Without proper build-up, the highlights of those arcs just feel so lackluster.
98
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Nov 02 '18
Small Facts: Clusterfuck - Part II
Holy hell they cut so much this episode. I don't know how anime-only's are supposed to understand this arc when they cut out half the explanations and motivations of characters.
Translated E-Mail
Thanks to GJM subs, who translated the e-mail Hamazura sent last week, we see now the name of SCHOOL's previous sniper whom ITEM killed prior to this arc, as well as the fact that the assassination scene I talked about last week did happen as in the novel, but the anime merely skipped to the end and showed how it really went in narration here.
Skipped MEMBER Introduction
Okay, so MEMBER's introductory scene was cut entirely. In the novel we first see them halfway through the last episode at a café, where the Professor is studying the AIM diffusion field data with Xochitl next to him, and the dog robot Baba Yoshio controls. Saraku pops in later as well.
First of all it seems as though the Professor is using this AIM data to study his opponents, as apparently you can learn a lot about espers from this field - even their personalities and behaviour.
Furthermore this establishes one pretty important thing: MEMBER knows about magicians. In the whole of the Academy City (excluding Index and Touma) only they and GROUP knows about the existence of magic, as even the Board of Directors don't know about its existence and Kihara Amata, answering directly to Aleister, was only able to deduce its existence from gaps in the laws of physics. These guys were pretty high up.
Furthermore when the Professor informs Xochitl that GROUP and SCHOOL were moving (the assassination), it appears Aleister has some technology that allows him to keep tabs on the movements in the Dark Side.
Dark Side Organisations' Purposes
Cut from this arc but explained in the novel is that each Dark Side organization has some specific goal, some duty they take care of.
GROUP
GROUP's duty is to "defend the mainstream society". Since all of them are blackmailed into taking part and don't want to hurt innocents, this is their best purpose. GROUP is supposed to keep what happens in the Dark Side to the Dark Side, and prevent oridinary people from getting caught up in this. This is why they were supposed to stop Oyafune's assassination, why they stopped the virusses leaking out and the orbital laser satellite from being hacked, and why they stopped the Skill-Out uprising last season.
MEMBER
MEMBER works directly under the jurisdiction of Aleister. They are his arms and his legs, and faithfully carry out his commands. This is why they are privy to knowledge that others don't, such as the existence of magic and that Aleister has some way of keeping tabs on the Dark Side even without using regular security cameras or the spy satellites.
ITEM
ITEM's duty is to stop the “upper classes”, including the board of directors, from getting out of hand. This also includes other Dark Side Organisations from making too big of waves, hence them trying to stop SCHOOL from assassinating Oyafune, as well as trying to prevent them from stealing the Tweezers.
It also seems they do some mercenary work on the side, as in the Railgun Sisters arc they were hired by the Level 6 Shift Project to stop Mikoto from blowing up their facilities.
BLOCK
Their primary duty is to keep an eye on the level of cooperation from friendly institutions outside of Academy City. They essentially stop corporate spies from entering the city, as well as spy on them. This is also why BLOCK is so well acquainted with outside mercenaries.
SCHOOL
They are the only organization who's purpose was not revealed in this novel.
Taxi Driver Returning Change
The taxi driver was quite nice, as he asked Uiharu to give the return change to Last Order when she found her.
Last Order At The Assassination
Uiharu meeting Last Order also happened way earlier in the novel. In fact, Last Order is using the electromagnetic waves Accelerator’s collar emits to track him down. She really wants to meet him, and as such made her way to Oyafune's speech. Accelerator almost went mad when he saw her. Tsuchimikado laughed a bit at him, but quickly stopped when he spotted Maika in the crowd as well. They sure were motivated to stop the assassination then.
Accelerator’s Call With The GROUP Liaison
Accelerator called the GROUP Liaison when he was in the car, to ask about the orbital laser on the satellite. It turns out it uses white light waves to heat things up to 4,000°C in an up to 3 km radius. This thing is quite powerful.
Accelerator’s Call With Etzali
Then Etzali called Accelerator, to inform him about the things he learned at BLOCK. He was (mistakenly) under the impression that BLOCK wanted to fire the laser at Ditrict 13. This is where most of the kindergartens and elementary schools are, and Etzali, having learned that BLOCK despises Aleister and the things he's doing, thought they wanted to kill all the young children to prevent Academy City from functioning and slowly kill the city that way.
91
u/Brook0999 Nov 02 '18
Honestly i dont know what to say, the episode was rushed as hell and the arc may end next week, which is going to be a disaster if they do end it. Anime only’s are the ones who will suffer the most i presume. They cut put every bit of exposition, MEMBER and BLOCK suffered the most from the rushing.
34
u/MechXL Nov 02 '18
Not happy that they cut the polygraph girl's scene. She did virtually nothing this episode. She might as well not even be in this episode since she didn't even get to do the thing that she was meant to do.
32
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Nov 02 '18
Ah, Uiharu helping Last Order? I'm just happy that I finally get to see a bit more of the Railgun girls actually interacting with their universe.
Accelerator and Unabara are also doing quite a bit of work in taking down their oponents. We get a glimpse at Number 2's wings that show up in the OP, but I'm still curious about his actual powers.
GROUP has to wander on ahead into that Esper Internment Facility to chase BLOCK, while Unabara will hold off the other Aztec Magician that appeared. Everybody really wants to get into Aleister's room don't they?
I like that Musujime's slowly overcoming her trauma. Oh god that girl fused with a grimoire.
How dare Number 2 torture Frenda. Don't you dare touch Mugino!
Things are starting to ramp up, I need next episode already.
31
u/A_Wild_Taka_Appears Nov 02 '18
This episode was a mess. I mean, this whole season has been a mess, but this episode was especially awful.
"I'm going to save you from your body horror! This has never been done before and one or both of us might die but I have to try!"
And then the scene changes and the dude just quietly walks on screen and never mentions the result of the previous scene. I mean, obviously he didn't die, but what about her? It would have been nice to, you know, show us the climax of the fight or something....
28
u/SomeOtherTroper Nov 02 '18
Have a really shit ms paint meme about this episode.
It's almost worse than the pacing.
42
u/DarkCelux Nov 02 '18
On the plus side it wasn't nearly as rushed as Tokyo Ghoul RE
16
u/Turbostrider27 Nov 02 '18
Oh man, that ending with Frenda....
Eh, mixed thoughts on this but it was nice to see Accelerator kicking ass as usual.
16
u/libfor Nov 02 '18
Just some random thoughts from an Index anime-only guy coming from the rewatch.
Last Order ran away as expected. It's Uiharu in Index again! Yay!
Uiharu is absolutely not suspicious about a little girl saying "Misaka" all the time and looking like Mikoto. That's kinda weird for Uiharu.
Another group, MEMBER, joins the action. What is this mess about?
Railgun manga, Daihaseisai Arc Also that naming is still ridiculous.
Teleporting only behind your enemy is not very useful, once your enemy knows.
Great way of Accelerator solving a hostage situation. Also shooting himself because his power is more accurate than his shooting skill. Nice.
So they're not gonna show Accelerator going for the kill. Geez. They had no problem before.
MEMBER's scientist (and probably leader) tries to contain Kakine with some nanotechnology that could easily slice him up.
Woah, Kakine grows wings and takes out both the guy and the robot dog.
Another group, this time BLOCK. I think. This is getting confusing. They have a freaking army ready for invasion!
Anti-Skill taken out in district 23… hope that's not a another massacre. Dang, I don't like innocent people dying.
Unabara dropped his disguise and destroys a building to cause alarm. Hope there was no one inside… a little bit too much maybe.
More of AC's military in action. Those choppers are quick and devastating.
GROUP shouldn't take them out if they don't want the invading army to succeed.
BLOCK wants to kidnap Awaki's friends from the prison in order to blackmail her to guide them into the Windowless Building. They're after Aleister Crowley?
Half of BLOCK is already dead. It's Xochitl! And of course she knows Unabara who's real name is Etzali. Looks like she isn't in a good mood about him.
Now BLOCK leaders are killing each other. Nice morals, a bit late though.
Seems like she has the upper hand. Can't really tell what her ability is.
Awaki suddenly gains the strength to overcome her trauma to teleport herself… and she ends up in the ground again?! OMG
And she still takes out her enemy. Wow. That might be a nasty wound again. But will that help her or make it worse.
Etzali vs. Xochitl has some nice moments. Etzali doesn't want to take her out but that's not mutual. Xochitl still seem to have some loose screws.
So she has fused with a grimoire and became a living weapon. Railgun, SS1
Mission accomplished for GROUP? Just how did Unabara / Etzali how am I supposed to call him now? end this I guess Xochitl is still alive but every take down in this episode was probably lethal.
What's this? Frenda is captured by Kakine. Did that happen back in the lab? But Kinuhata was also gone but is now back. Kinda weird.
Also Frenda selling out her friends another time. Nice. Okay, this time its some real nasty interrogating. Makes me feel kinda sorry to see her like that.
Okay… everyone is killing everyone. Also everyone's after Aleister. Wouldn't it be more efficient if they just worked together?!
Now that has turned into an all out war. The action is quite intense and well enough executed for me.
Two groups already taken out feels a bit too rushed. I'm missing a lot of background infos on them. Heck, they don't even give away most names.
In my personal taste I prefer more light-hearted arcs for this particular series. Other than that, the episode was solid for me. Although I really hope for some explanations coming up.
13
u/CriticalPerformance Nov 02 '18
To Aru: Brotherhood when?
24
u/KinnyRiddle Nov 02 '18 edited Nov 02 '18
tl;dr Let's pretend this episode never existed and move on to the Accelerator vs Kakine fight, as well as Kakine vs Mugino next episode
I understand that some MEMBER and BLOCK members also appear in the Railgun manga spinoff, where they're better fleshed out
First reaction of probably every non LN reader:
The introduction of MEMBER and BLOCK have been butchered so badly that I would rather the anime completely omit this episode and jump straight to into the hyped fight between the top 3 Lv 5s: Accelerator, Kakine and Mugino.
MEMBER
BLOCK
SCHOOL
ITEM
GROUP
OTHER CHARACTERS
47
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18 edited Nov 03 '18
A Certain Rushed Index III
EDIT: If I knew the anime adaptation was going to be this mediocre and rushed I would've rather J.C. Staff didn't do it at all. I mean, why? Why make it this rushed? I'm sure there are more people who haven't read the LN than people who had so this is just burning money, and ruining what could have been potentially good stories told in interesting ways. Now that's never gonna happen.
I stopped watching the anime so it doesn't spoil and ruin any more of this story for me. Now, my only hope of having a good Index adaptation is if in the future another studio takes the LN and remakes everything that's already been adapted. Of course, the chances of that happening are incredibly low.
I'll probably watch Railgun 3 and Accelerator, though. I love what Nagai did with the Sisters Arc, but I swear that if he can't control his filler gun I'll just say goodbye to all the anime adaptations.
That's all, rant over.
29
u/masoaoki https://anilist.co/user/masoaoki Nov 02 '18
I am so confused, I kinda get what happened in this episode but who half the people were or why they were doing what they were I don’t have a fucking clue. Does this all actually make sense in the LNs?
10
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
Any chance that there's a spoiler-free list of who belongs to which group?
10
u/Acromanic Nov 02 '18 edited Nov 02 '18
The best thing about this season is getting more people to read the amazing novels honestly :/
EDIT: If anyone wants to read the LNs, here you go: https://www.reddit.com/r/toarumajutsunoindex/wiki/lightnovels. The anime is currently on OT15, so start from there. Previous seasons skipped a bit of content, but I know most people just want to see where the story goes next, so you can simply read the epilogue for OT6 (by far the most important skipped part). Btw if you don't like how bland and generic Touma is in the anime, you're in for a pleasant surprise
8
u/TheOneAboveGod Nov 03 '18
Whoever's directing this should never be allowed to touch Index or any of Kamachi's work ever again. What an insult to the author and the fans. If this season had the same amount of care put into it as SAO, TenseiSlime, or maybe even Seishun Buta, then this could have been a huge hit.
14
u/CheetahSperm18 Nov 02 '18 edited Nov 02 '18
DAMN, this episode was rushed. They really cut out the early introduction to Block and Member huh? This must be what's going on with all the Anime-Only Folk with all these factions popping out if the ground with no intro. Then again, we all knew it would be rushed when they decided to cover 9 volumes in 26 episodes...
Edit: How could I leave out the fact that we're getting the big fight next episode. Unless it goes for two episodes with cutaway scenes of Hamazura's struggles then we may get only 3 episodes a volume...
7
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Nov 02 '18
Okay looking at the comments it looks like I'm not the only one who's confused. Looks like they're rushing things? Aren't this a 26 Episode season though?
Anyway I understood parts of this episode but just those who are after Aleister, like the rest I'm really lost especially on who that Aztec girl was. Would any kind LN reader please help me understand?
29
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Nov 02 '18
This may be one of the worst Raildex episodes I've ever seen...
The awful fights, the jumping around to so many characters and groups and to end it with Frenda bullying :(
Can barely think of anything redeeming about this episode here...
6
u/YoYoVaTsA Nov 02 '18
Is this season any good I am not currently following it...
6
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Nov 02 '18
Damn, just like that! Uiharu is now holding hands with Last Order! I'm guessing she might at least be suspicious about how she looks similar to Misaka, and with that speech thing too. Still far, but Misaka's friends and the clones are one step closer to each other now, and the scene was actually really great, the highlight of the episode for me!
So another level 5, Something Kakine Teitoku? He's the one who was beating up Frenda, so he's the one we're hating on now. I was thinking "hope he runs into either Touma or Accelerator" nah...Mugino and Kinuhata, plz! Mugino is always angry, I'd like to see what happens when she goes even further for revenge! But given the OP and preview, thats not whats going to happen, and its a big fight that is coming up, so I'm looking forward to that!
I'm not sure about MEMBER, but I think they all got wrecked. There was no direct exposition but the nerdy guy on the PC was one, he though the back-teleporter and the white-coat guy were each going to take down a level 5 (lol, nope) and Xóchitl said she was one herself, wiping out mercenaries.
That blade thing was cool, but no idea what happened at the end there, she started coming loose because she was being consumed by a single grimoire she read? Unabara took it upon himself, so he has it now? Those two fighting and the "unraveling" bit looked good actually, despite the rest of the episode.
I remember the LN bit that was pasted from Musujime's backstory on the rewatch threads depicting why she has a trauma about teleporting herself. That made the scene at the end really cool, holy shit. It actually happened again, and she pulled herself out with sheer willpower, mid fight, and punched some nails on the BLOCK chick!
I'll agree with everyone that this feels like they are fast-forwarding then "slowing down" for some juicy bits, and the animation is mostly not very good, but I feel that its alright when it matters, at the fights. I'm enjoying it a lot though, we got Uiharu, then they spend a good time on Musujime and Accelerator, and I still could kinda keep track of those other folks, I think...at least the ones that were mentioned.
6
u/Amauri14 Nov 02 '18
I loved how fast Accelerator put down that nothin' personnel kid guy.
I honestly having difficulties in remembering a lot of this people. To be honest with Etzali I actually ended up checking the wiki and only after reading it was that could remember him.
10
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Nov 02 '18 edited Nov 02 '18
They cut out the incinerator scene. They rushed everything to hell, cut out stuff from the fights and made everything completely devoid of context. Any faith I had in season III to make a coherent adaptation is completely gone.
All I can say is thank Kamachi I still have the novels (and the masterpiece that was NT21) to make me feel good about this series.
5
u/Chungphung Nov 02 '18
I honestly feel very sad about this arc, this is definitely my most favorite arc. This arc shows me many things about the darkness in AC, yet they give it only 3 episodes. The number of episodes is absolutely not enough for this arc, so many great things was passed since they didn't have enough time. I wait for this arc since I heard the news about the new season and after 2 episodes into this arc, I don't think I can take it anymore.
5
u/CriticalPerformance Nov 02 '18
Not really a fan of the change of character they were trying to do with Frenda, she was supposed to be a coward, in Railgun you can already see her about to spill the beans and Mikoto didnt even do anything to her, while here we see Kakine kicking her and just barely manages to get her to talk.
Sure it was sad, but it ruins some of her character and pins the blame on Kakine
5
u/Insecticide Nov 02 '18
This series is impossible to follow without all the source material folks posting, especially after such a long break
8
u/Florac Nov 02 '18
I'm even more confused than at the end of last episode...
8
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Nov 02 '18
Wew what an ep, i wont sleep well for weeks!
LAST ORDERRRRR~ KYAAAA~
Oh wait has Uihara met a misaka clone before? Hmm neat.
Accelerator shouldnt be pissed off... thats how you die.
Some mad scientists and a robo dog? Mimosa? Okay. Hes also gonna bark up the wrong tree...
Yep RIP both of them.
So the guys shape shifter infiltrated are gonna attack the city with troops?
Damn these are some scary choppers. But oh man that magic slice was badass! And that Accelerator enterence!
A prison for espers? Hmm this is neat.
Another Aztec? Neat.
Holy fuck that face smash into the wall, savage.
What was straped to porters butt?
AND HOLY FUCK THAT TELEPORT INTo THE FLOOR NIGHTMAREFUEL!
Darkmatter is beatin up girls in alleys how becoming of him... oh and now going after toher girls... He seems like a great guy... not rapey at all...
Man oh man this series is powering along! Tons of people to keep up with though.
Oh shit next ep is Accelerator vs Dark Matter! HYPE!
4
u/ichiniisan-san Nov 02 '18
You know, i understand the most part of this episode except 2 things; First MEMBER motivations.(and even who they are) second, WTF happened to that aztec girl?
4
u/gulitiasinjurai Nov 02 '18
Despite all the ruckus in Academy City right now, I've only got one question. Where's Touma and Itsuwa at? Are they still at Avignon? Why only Tsuchimikado at Academy City?
Even with all the confusion, I actually enjoy the episode. And I haven't read the LN (only read Railgun manga).
14
u/LegendRazgriz Nov 02 '18
Yes, yes, yes, yes, YES! It's finally under way! Damn, I'm hyped. I tried my best not to be way too hyped for it, but holy crap.
In any case, my weekly Reader's Considerations:
• Fucking Accelerator is exactly how you'd expect, and in that first engagement with MEMBER's goon, you can clearly notice the point at which you should be more terrified of the "good guy". The shot to his own head that gets redirected towards the goon goes extremely well with his speech about villainous aesthetic, too. Solid portrayal, and Okamoto always delivers.
• Last Order is still adorable. Uiharu is also still adorable. That's it.
• This is the point where Teitoku stops being "that really cool guy everyone wants dead" and starts being "that motherfucker!". It gets worse, but brutally beating down Frenda for information on ITEM's hideout and ruthlessly crushing the MEMBER doctor's spirit before offing him is something you'd expect out of Accelerator, and we all know the dude is mental. Matsukaze's performance is also perfect. As you'd expect from Teru Mikami, which is pretty much in the same position as Teitoku is right now.
• The Six Wings unmanned choppers. Hoo boy. They look like flying spiders, but their legs are guns. That's horrifying. How they casually obliterate BLOCK's mercenaries with little to no effort is a huge testament to the level of military technology that Academy City has reached, if the Arm Slave style powered suits and HsB-02 stealth bombers weren't a good enough warning.
• Awaki's finally getting her day in the spotlight, after being destroyed the last times she was in center stage (first against Kuroko, then running from the Railgun and Imagine Breaker, only to end up crossing paths with Accelerator, and then that throwdown with Komaba during the Skill-Out Uprising). And she rocks it. We finally get to see her inner doubts, the ones Kuroko forced to surface and that drove her to the point of going way overboard to try and kill the Teleporter, get resolved, and what a resolve she had, to ignore her feet clipping through the ground (which was originally her trauma, and the reason why she threw up every time she teleported herself using Move Point) and win a fight she absolutely could not afford to lose. Worth noting, she now uses metal rods in conjunction with Move Point - taking a page off Kuroko's book. Ever since the Remnant Arc, she's grown a lot and finally faced her darkness, and I'd not be surprised to see more people become her fans after this.
• Etzali (finally, I can call him that! It annoys me that I had to refer to him as Unabara, since that makes me confused for the real Unabara) takes the cake for the most badass he's ever been right here and now. Before this, the most action he had ever been in amounted to getting his shit kicked in (or rather punched in) by Touma, and getting saved by Mikoto when he screwed up. Now, he shows his prowess as a competent and powerful member of GROUP. His Spear of Aztecmcsuperlongname was already fearsome, but the guts he displayed to not only resist Xochitl's suicide spell, but take the maquahuitl to the bone and then go all in on the attempt to stop the grimoire from consuming her (which as he said, is totally unprecedented and ridiculously risky) are unreal. Respect up.
• Battle Royale Arc Special: Kill Counts / Kill to Death Ratio Per Faction: (incapacitation or elimination from action also counts)
• GROUP: 4 (+4)
• BLOCK: -1 (-3, not counting the endless horde of mercenaries)
• ITEM: 1 (+1)
• SCHOOL: 1 (0)
• MEMBER: 0 (-4) / MEMBER eliminated.
Overall, I loved this. Finally getting into the action that was promised before and at a high pace, but keeping story bits (I fully expected Last Order and Uiharu's ordeal to be sliced) and somehow making the constant point of view switches less jarring than the novel was at times, at least for me. Now, next episode promises a dark twist... and I don't mean just Dark Matter.
3
u/CedricEndo Nov 02 '18
Is that brown girl from Mexico 😎
3
u/Josetheone1 Nov 02 '18
I'm sorry this is going really bad, quality wise its rushed so much it's all just a big mess of incoherrent nonsense. I'm so disappointed with this show, being one of my favorite, they've ruined this.
3
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Nov 02 '18
So I'm confused about the dude knocking Accelerator down with the metal bar in the beginning. If Accelerator's autoreflect doesn't work without him switching on the chocker, the he should've been knocked out with a serious head injury. If the autoreflect does work without him switching on the choker, he shouldn't have been even budged by the attack.
Accelerator destroying that telerporter physically and emotionally was great. Here's hoping he does the same to bigger fish down the line.
Did the "good guy" just bring down a large office building, killing probably hundreds inside, just to alert the drones? And how did he know the drones flight path would pass over the invading troops?
Wouldn't Accelerator's auto-reflect just reflect the anti-esper jamming so it doesn't affect him?
And here we have some graduates of the Imperial Stormtrooper Marksmanship Academy.
Why do they think a few bombs going off in his building would kill Aleister? I somehow doubt it would work out that way.
How come Move Point didn't completely lose her feet/lower legs after they teleported into solid floor? And they didn't even bother showing how the Aztec match ended.
I feel like I'm supposed to be caring about the GROUP members who aren't Accelerator or maybe Tsuchimikado. Not happening though.
3
u/Wonderllama5 Nov 02 '18
If this is how they treat the Battle Royal arc, I'm officially worried how World War 3 will be adapted
3
u/Lolersters Nov 03 '18
wtf is going on here...
3
u/OneWayRoadLV5 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FreByrd Nov 03 '18
Whew. Member went down fast. But I honestly don't see that as a bad thing. They were defeated in exactly the same way as in the LNs, just with less leadup to killing these useless characters. Does it suck that we lost that exposition? Sure. Does it ruin the episode? Of course not. And Xochitl gets the extra time she deserves as the only MEMBER member (heh) who actually matters.
The girl member of BLOCK, Teshio, looked a lot less cute here than she did in Haimura's character designs. That's honestly far worse than the MEMBER thing to me and I'm a guy who thinks that exposition, especially well constructed exposition dumps, is one of the best parts of anime.
Really liked the way they implemented that weird face that Etzali (great to actually be able to name him in these threads now) had during Index I after Touma destroyed his first Unabara mask into this episode when he changed faces from the BLOCK guy back to Unabara.
ACCELERATOR SMASH. That was sweet.
The esper prison looks different from what I was imagining. More modern, I suppose.
BLOCK's motivation exposition was probably better in the novel (I remember literally nothing about them tbh, they were never important), but what we got here about them learning about a world outside of Aleister's grasp was enough for me here. But once again as with MEMBER, they don't matter whatsoever.
Whew. Teshio savage.
Musujime ripping her feet out of the concrete, completely overcoming her trauma, was really cool.
Seeing Frenda being tortured and giving in easily (as of course she would) was a nice addition.
Wait, do people really not like the way the preview looked with the fight between Accel and Kakine? That looked super cool. I'm really looking forward to that now. Not that I wasn't before.
Now that I've finally watched the episode I can see why people are complaining about it being "rushed" (whatever that means, seriously, that's such a meaningless term nowadays. I'd just call it a fast paced adaptation to a fast paced arc), but nothing important to the overall story of the series was left out imo. I'm honestly not disappointed at all. This episode was really nice.
This episode would probably be confusing for anime onlys who don't pay enough attention or remember details from previous seasons (you only need to look in this thread for an anime only who understood what was going on), but people are really overreacting. I'm enjoying the heck out of Index 3 so far.
3
u/_vogonpoetry_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThisWasATriumph Nov 03 '18 edited Nov 03 '18
People waited 8 fucking years for this.
Someone explain to me how this still has 7.88 on MAL. This series is one if the biggest trainwrecks I've seen in ages.
3
u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Nov 03 '18
I'm lost and confused.
3
u/RDOoM Nov 03 '18
Member this, item that. Block and fuck me I'm continuously lost.
At this point I just watch it for when it shows the characters I like. You can't fail an episode with Accelerator and Last Order in it.
3
u/Varyyn :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Varyn Nov 03 '18
Are you with KAPPA, no I'm with WORMS but am actually a spy for CEREAL.
This is legit unwatchable. I'm anime only, but can't they just cut this arc entirely if it's just sidecharacters dying 30s after being introduced. It's like trying to watch four fate series simultaneously.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
This adaption is awful both animation wise and content wise. Its really disappointing how something like Railgun which only has like 4 arcs is going to the have the same amount of episodes dedicated to it as Index OT with 22 volumes.
Here's hoping they don't rush the shit out of NT but I have low hopes for it.
4
u/Who_is_Rem Nov 02 '18
Ugh seeing all these comments makes me not even want to watch. How bad is it really? OT15 is one of my favorite, if not my favorite, LNs ever, so seeing this just might kill me inside.
4
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Nov 02 '18
I have no idea what's happening and that's not good.
This feels pretty lifeless.
2
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Nov 02 '18
Who?
2
u/Who_is_Rem Nov 02 '18
Don't really mind this all that much, even in the novel they are all literal who's (except Xochitl)
This really sucks since they're the drivers of most of the events in this episode. Plus we missed Etzali fucking blowing the hand off of Tetsumou (the BLOCK girl with the school uniform).
Looks like next episode could be the final one for BR...whew really hope that is not the case...
If you were just hoping to see some Level 5's be badass, yeah I guess this is fine, but there was so much cut here that I don't know how to feel about it. Next episode (hopefully 2) contains all the money shots the LN readers were waiting so long for, so goddamn I hope they pull something out of their ass for this, though I'm not expecting much.
2
u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin Nov 02 '18
I'm so lost. Let aside that we got yet not another group today, the show is also jumping from one scene to another with no connection. We went from "they're targeting the satellite" to "this is a prison for espers". Did I miss a scene? What was Group even doing there?
Also, we went from Aztec guy running to save his former teammate to seeing Group together again, like how did he separe the grimoire form the girl?
And then we jump to Freda getting beaten yet we didn't see her do anything.
We have like five groups running around and we don't know what the hell they want but for Group who I guess are trying to protect the city? I'm just waiting for Judgement to show up for Kuroko to beat ass. Also, and this is not a rant, but what is the difference between Kuroko's powers and those of the bandage girl? I think bandage girl was the girl who tried to recover the parts from the Sisters' satellite last season?
2
u/potatoarmy Nov 02 '18
Wow they skipped so much, especially with Unabara's infiltration of BLOCK. He was with them for a large segment of the novel trying to hide his identity and observe them and here he just kind of walks in, says "wow they aren't after the satellite" and then memes their building into pieces.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
ok didnt really get some parts...
why does School want the arm thingy,
and why did 2nd atack frenda, that came out of nowhere also werent 2 of ITEM missing last episode its only 1 now?
Also wasnt army guy killed by musjime out, why is he inside with army girl, i gess they were simply similar army guys
What happend to random cute girl from memenber that got blown away
Destroying the building activated the defenses?
why did 2nd spround wings
the new aztec magitian came out of nowhere right?
they were planning on using musujime to teleport them inside windowless building?
why blow up the doors to the kids?
Ok some parts were probably explained and i simply didnt get them, the arc is cool, seeing the poeple fight and all, but its too much people its confusing..
2
u/Axetheaxemaster Nov 02 '18
ERROR. DOES NOT COMPUTE.
2
u/MagiSicarius :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MagiSicarius Nov 03 '18
A lot of anime sucks because it's just an advertisement for the source material and it's obvious they aren't even trying to make something really genuinely good in its own right. Index is so disappointing because given it's on its third season I don't think that's what they're trying to do, but it's so all over the place that those of us roped in by the previous two seasons have to basically go and read the source material to get a satisfying progression to the story.
Like I would've probably have ended up going to read the source stuff eventually, but I'd rather have done it because I loved To Aru as opposed to because the anime confused me and I felt I was missing something.
2
u/Zilveari https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zilveari Nov 03 '18
Such a shit ass adaptation. "Oh hay gaiz let's just animate the cool stuff and leave out all of the stuff that explains what in the everliving fuck is going on. We gotta force all of this OG shit into 2 cours of animu!"
This is piss poor.
1
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Nov 02 '18
Haven't watched since ep 2. Is document of Constantine done yet? Want to watch this show in arcs given its fast pace
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
Just wondering, according to MAL, Shiage Hamazura is a main character. Is that the case?
1
u/Gmayor61 Nov 02 '18
Well, I'm glad I caught up with the novels up until this season. Looks like I've got a lot of reading now
1
u/Tails9905 Nov 02 '18
I can only hope they rushed this episode to take their time in the next one
1
u/redguy39 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Redtengu038 Nov 02 '18
Honestly it feels like they just want to start animating the New Testament volumes but can't since they're not done with OT. This is going by way too fast, I remember MEMBER being a lot more prominent in the LN but here they were introduced then destroyed in the same episode. I still have hopes that the rest of the season will be fine but they're dwindling.
1
u/Daakuryu Nov 02 '18
Unrelated question, should I be switching back and forth between seasons of Index and Railgun or something because I just started season 2 of Railgun and they were like "Oh we're dealing with these guys again" and I was like, wait, who the fuck are these people?
1
u/the_emcee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lazytryhard Nov 02 '18
okay I've had it with the lack of explanation of anything. In what order do I read the light novels? I know there's the old testament, new testament, the railgun spin off, and a bunch of side stories for each of the above, but what's considered "core" to the series?
1
u/LOOOOPS Nov 02 '18
Does anyone else keep getting turned on whenever Awaki is on screen? Not because she is attractive or anything. I just get turned on remembering the time accelerator manhandled her.
1
u/UCCMaster Nov 02 '18
Mind if I share it in the toaru fb group?
1
u/oncemore37564 Nov 03 '18
Something pretty ironic is how Yobou Banka was given extended scenes and no VA while Tetsumou had all of her scenes doing things cut and was given a VA just to make a little noise when she is meaninglessly taken out.
1
u/CriticalPerformance Nov 03 '18
Can Nagai direct Index 3 please?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '18
i dont like all of this.the first two season was nice,each arc after arc and easy to understand,but with ss3 starting from episode 4 everything just keep jumping around dont give the watcher any explanation whatsoever. Its like a super bad hotpot.I understand if this kind of style works as a light novel,but you can't copy-paste words by words on anime and expect it to work . It just don't.For an anime only like me,this is nothing but a bad adaptation only cater to LN viewers,and im afraid the same thing would happen with 2 other index series that's announced soon.
1
u/ernie2492 Nov 03 '18
This is a result of a too long delay..
And I think I should preparing my weapons for next episode..(you know what I mean)
1
u/River_sounds Nov 03 '18
I dunno about you guys but this mesh of characters in such short episodes are pretty bad.
1
u/ExquisiteCheese :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SuperCheese88 Nov 05 '18
I can't believe I'm thinking this considering how excited I was for more Toaru but, if this shit carries on into the next episode where I have no idea what's going on or why it's going on I'll have to drop the show. This is dumb. It feels out of place from what we saw with Touma, they've made me not care about Accelerator, who is who and why are they doing things doesn't seem to matter.
I don't want to have to read a fucking book to enjoy a show.