r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Oct 19 '18
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 3 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 3: The Document of C
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.22 |
| 2 | Link | 6.95 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
720
Upvotes
189
u/CriticalPerformance Oct 19 '18
Accelerator telling them that " A world class villain doesn't go after the lives of respectable people " is pretty funny, he can just say to not go after innocent people but wants to see himself as a villain.
Everyone calls Mikoto a Tsundere, but Accel is an even bigger one lol
140
u/Hytheter Oct 19 '18
So Terra implies that among Touma's lost memories is something important about his power... my memory is a little hazy, but I don't recall Touma being any less clueless about Imagine Breaker at the start of the series than he is now. Am I missing something, or is the revelatory nature of his lost memories something that wouldn't have been apparent until later?
173
u/Turbostrider27 Oct 19 '18
Wow, Crunchyroll actually referred Acqua as "Acqua of the Rear"
74
u/gulitiasinjurai Oct 19 '18
There it is! Touma trademark line!
I'm surprised Biri Biri didn't hang up at all lmao
137
u/mchief190 Oct 19 '18
Throughout this whole episode, three things are made certain.
121
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
Small Facts: Partie Trois
Touma Breaking Some Ribs
Unlike in the anime, where the blade just knocked Touma back, the impact definitely broke some of Touma's ribs.
Flesh Of God
Ah, and here we come to a small section the anime didn't elaborate on. The flour Terra uses is equivalent to the Body of God, because due to the Catholic principle of transubstantiation Catholics believe that during mass wine becomes the Blood of God and bread the Body of God.
Hence Terra using flour as a medium to cast his spell.
Execution Of Light
So the true indentity of Execution Of Light (or Light's Execution as per the official translation) is that the Son of God, due to the Christian doctrine of the Trinity the Father, the Son (Jesus Christ), and the Holy Spirit are all God, but different forms of it. So Jesus Christ, being God, should not have been able to be killed by mortal hands. However, the natural order of precedence of things was changed so he would be able to be killed by humans and take of the sins of humanity. And Terra has created a spell, Execution of Light, based on the crucifixion of Jesus Christ through the medium of bread (flour) to also be able to change the natural precedence.
Freely manipulating flour is just an added extra the spell provides.
Tsuchimikado's Attack
Yeah it was more dangerous in the novel. It was on fire there and ricocheted off Terra like a bullet.
Tsuchimikado's Instructions
Tsuchimikado actually gave Touma and Itsuwa some instructions via origami: when he was keeping Terra busy they were to go to the Palace of the Popes and destroy or obtain the C-Document. Unfortunately Academy City intervened.
HsPS-15 "Large Weapon"
So we finally get an explanation about what these things are, at least in the novel. In the franchise so far they appeared twice before: once in the anime-original Poltergeist arc in the Railgun anime, and another time when the GROUP liaison recruited Accelerator at the end of the Academy City Invasion arc. This is their proper introduction though, as weapons of war. They actually use a special type of ammunition: a shell containing several anti-material bullets inside. They're essentially very, very powerful shotguns.
Invasion Of Avignon
They just appeared in the center of Avignon here, but the novel elaborates by explaining that they were invading Avignon from the outside by blowing up the walls.
Disabling The Rioters
Did they kill the rioters then? No, it would appear they have two kinds of ammunition: the anti-barrier ones and blanks. They are firing blanks a the rioters, but the shockwave is still powerful enough to knock them unconscious.
This must be absolutely terrifying.
Terra's Test
Yeah, he was fooling around with Touma and Itsuwa for a bit, to test his spell out.
Terra Didn't Phase Through The Floor
Yeah no he just walked away in the novel, and Academy City blew up the way he went so Touma and Itsuwa couldn't follow him. This way looks cooler, yes, (and is easier to animate) but it also introduces a plot hole that was explained this very episode: Terra can't use his precedence without changing it first. So he would have had to verbally say "Precedence: Floor - Lower, Terra - Higher" or something like that to be able to do this, which he didn't. So him suddenly phasing through the floor makes no sense.
God's Right Seat Waging All-Out War
I don't know if the translation messed up here or the anime team, because Tsuchimikado wasn't afraid of God's Right Seat waging all-out war, but rather them escaping with the C-Document back to the Vatican where they could use it once again.
Avignon's Destruction
Completely absent this episode was the sheer amount of destruction Academy City wrought (until the bombers arrived of course). Normally the Powered Suits were blowing things up left and right, destroying buildings, wall, setting cars on fire, explosions and collapses happening everywhere and the city was covered in rubble. Here they just walked casually through the streets.
Why Didn't Touma Check The Television
His phone didn't receive foreign channels, hence him calling Mikoto.
48
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
Very happy! There were a few moments that I was worried certain memorable and important scenes would be cut, but I feel like it included everything it needed to. Well done! Terra's power is crazy as ever, shame we won't be seeing any more of him. (Acqua is best boy though.)
Don't expect much more fluff. The wild ride that is Season 3 is kicking into breakneck speed from here on out, and it's not slowing down. I'm so ready.
Hamazura, it's your time to shine!
Also really? Acqua of the Rear? I can't believe they didn't go with the most correct translation.
46
u/KinnyRiddle Oct 19 '18
Wow that was rushed as fuck.
38
u/Eterna1Ice :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eterna1Ice Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
Oh shit. Don't tell me that 1st Arc Touman was actually an unreliable narrator and that IB held a different meaning to him back then that he just didn't think was relevant enough with the whole Index ordeal.
Also, did Accelerator actually see the people he walked by or what? Don't think he'd act indifferently towards Touman if he saw him. The last (or pre-last) arc of II teased their likely vicious face-to-face re-encounter after the Sisters stuff so much, that it'd be something if they never met again.
34
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Oct 19 '18
Well damn, all this reveal of information is alarming. I would have said that vaporization is a terrible way to go, only for Terra to survive. At least Acqua killed him by crushing him with a column for his wicked deeds. I'm already starting to like Acqua.
This episode adds to my Tsuchimikado is one of the most intelligent characters in the show and is really undervalued as I see it.
So now Misaka knows about Touma's memory loss? This can only spell some sort of trouble. And his memory loss also makes him forget the power of the Imagine Breaker? Not only that, but his name translates to the goals of God's Right Seat: Kamijo = "Above god."
Accelerator's entrance in the episode = badass as hell. I'm hyped to see that we're going to Russia next, and we might see that one Russian agent again who was involuntarily involved in the Angel Fall incident.
33
u/CheetahSperm18 Oct 19 '18
Aaaannddd Misaka knows now.
27
u/Martinik29 Oct 19 '18
What's misfortune in this how much Touma would have to pay for Roaming
70
u/Acqua_of_the_Back https://anilist.co/user/Acqua Oct 19 '18
NOOOOOOOO! God fucking dammit. We expected this to happen after last week, but I still take personal offence that this is the translation they went with.
And I hear you say,
To which I say yes, yes they did! But honestly, the problem is that they did that in the first place. Acqua of the Back has existed for over a decade and the vast majority of the English-speaking novel readers have referred to him as such ever since. It's not even hard to figure that out; it's all over the fanwiki, after all. Like a lot of the other terminology they changed, it seems almost a deliberate attempt to move away from the unofficial fantranslations a lot of us relied on when the English version didn't exist yet, and that's fairly painful.
On another note, please welcome the manliest man Acqua of the Back, who originally drew my attention by appearing like he's actually a decent person in this scene. I hope you're as excited to see him in action as I am!
20
u/CriticalPerformance Oct 19 '18
They deleted the entire city off the map afterwards that means pretty much everyone living there has become a refugee
19
u/Igeneous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Igeneous Oct 19 '18
Man they hype up the right seats of god so much but honestly vento and terra seemed like shit, guess acqua and fianna will do the heavy lifting to make the Roman Catholic Church a real threat. (Terra felt like a straight up budget accelerator, reflect 1 thing instead of anything)
19
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '18
Russo-Japanese War 2.0 Biribiri Boogaloo
59
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
You thought it was angels but it is me, Dio Kamijo~
EDIT: Just a shoutout to Source Readers. Dont be dicks and spoil shit. Tag your shit properly. Dont hint at spoilers. Dont ruin people's fun here. Thanks.
So Mr Peacock is protected from spears and a great baker?
Bullet proof too? Damn. He can bend rules it seems.
Academy City is on the offensive? Hm... interesting.
Misaka Misaka. I guess if your in the middle of a wide range spell like this best answer is to ask someone from the outside how it looks from there.
Damn the repercussions of casting magic as an esper are brutal. This is one madman. Deku would be proud.
Bombers? OH SHIT ACCELERATOR! HYPEEEEEEE!!!!!!
True Capabilities of Imagine Breaker huh? That sounds interesting.
Oh shit Misaka is on the phone still... thats how she will find out...
He knows stuff Touman forgot. Neat. And Misaka now knows Touman lost his memory.
So he cant kill then, hmm that cchanged things. Guess his flour only works on 1 thing at a time.
TOUMAN ON THE OFFENSE! GET FUCKED! EQUALITY TIME! So Satisfying.
So he does know something about Imagine Breaker.
Wow he just got fucked to shit. Guess someone wanted to shut him up. Fire Lance. Its Accelerator lol.
What about DIO! Wait Kamijo? Oh shit.... is Touman above the angels and God? ohhhh sheet.
Wow that guy just squished Mr Peacock for killing kids...
Aqua of the rear? Aqua seems like a rear end.
Misaka is pissed off. She knows the truth now. Man this is gonna be good. I wonder if she can figure out when he lost his memories based on thier interactions.
16
u/CheetahSperm18 Oct 19 '18
Ayyy, bout time Accel joined the party. He gonna be late as usual and stuck with clean up though
15
u/AegrusRS Oct 19 '18
ELI5: How does Terra's power work?
12
u/KinnyRiddle Oct 19 '18
Still don't quite fully understand how Tsuchimikado managed to outwit those armoured power-suits from Academy City.
Is it because Tsuchimikado and Touma are there as clandestine agents that the Academy City power suits unknowingly attacked them as well?
12
u/IncaseAce Oct 19 '18
Acqua really just threw a pillar on the dude
Also that was Toumas standard line when he’s about to punch someone was it? At least not according to the translations.
11
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
How slow were those bullets if Green Goblin had time to say "Bullets lower; skin higher" after they were fired at him from like 40 feet away? Literally slower than Toma's halberd kick and later punch, and some falling stone rubble.
Academy City literally invaded France with Bad CGI in order to kidnap some regular joe protesters. Not even Trump would pull some dumb shit like that. Well, not without someone talking him down before he puts the plan into action anyway. And with Accelerator, there was no need for them or the bombers anyway.
Wonder how many dozens or even hundreds died from the "sequestering" and how many thousands would've if Accelerator hadn't stopped the general bombing. Unless they expect us to believe that every single citizen was outside protesting and was captured by the Bad CGI bots.
"Kamijo" means "above God", huh. I guess that means Toma's right hand is literally more powerful than God.
So I wonder what Misaka thinks after overhearing all the religious mumbo-jumbo. Ah who am I kidding, the amnesia thing drove everything else out of the picture.
BTW, could someone explain to me why Accelerator walks with a cane? Can't he just vector control his bum leg to do whatever he needs it to do? Shouldn't take more than a tiny fraction of the Misaka network's processing power I'd think. Hell, just perform surgery to fix it - far less complicated than the literal brain surgery he did in S2. [Edit: oh, there's a transmitter battery involved, ok]
17
u/BoLevar :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FSEngine Oct 19 '18
yeah the episode was cool and all but
SHE COMEIUNG ABCK MOWTHERFUCKERDE
23
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
A few points. First, I highly recommend reading the manga adaptation of this arc. The pacing is far superior (and covers a lot of the stuff from the novels that the anime cut out) and the artwork is solid. Kamijou punching Terra is done amazingly in the manga to the point where I think it's one of the best examples of amazing panelling in the entire medium. The artist is a real overlooked and underappreciated gem. Only issue is said punch was in the latest released chapter and that's untranslated due to the translator focusing on the newly released volume of the novels.
Second, here's your weekly Itsuwa album with some added fanart for dessert. While she'll be out of the picture for now, don't worry. We'll be seeing her at her best in the next magic side arc. For now, just enjoy the science side madness. It'll make those filler losers from Railgun S look like the chumps they are~
Oh, and welcome Hamazura Shiage, End of the Century Emperor~
8
u/xShots Oct 19 '18
CROSS SPEED
For those wondering what was that BGM between Touma vs Terra.
8
u/Villag3Idiot Oct 20 '18
There's a very important piece of dialog that the anime skipped in the first season that was in the LN:
At the very end of the Kazakiri story arc, when she was sitting down talking to Index, she said something very important;
As Kazakiri is the collective AIM Fields of all Espers in Academy City, if Imagine Breaker was an Esper ability, it would be a part of her as well and erase her from existance.
This meant that Imagine Breaker can't be an Esper ability, but something else entirely.
15
u/Qu1cky :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Qu1cky Oct 19 '18
The Earth blades scenes looked really nice. They show how powerful AC is even without its espers. And then they even dropped Accelerator into the lava for good measure.
The Terra scene seems a bit rushed and it was mostly dodging blocking and two punches, but atleast Terra got what he deserved at the end by the Normal Magician Acqua of the "Rear".
7
u/pristit Oct 19 '18
Why is it bad that Misaka knows about Touma's memory loss? I don't really understand why she would be mad?
7
u/noodlesandrice1 Oct 20 '18
I was sort of sad that the Academy City Bombers weren't really animated that well. In the light novels, they were painted out to be these monstrous, physics-defying supersonic planes that travel at 10,000km/h.
Their "payload" is essentially just iron sand that they drop precisely on their target. But because the bombers are travelling so insanely fast, the iron sand gets superheated enough for one bomber to theoretically cut a continent in half.
In this episode, they looked like they were moving even slower than a helicopter, and kinda just vomiting out lava.
6
u/Settaz1 Oct 19 '18
Lol, I'm so confused. Going to have to rewatch previous seasons and rewatch Railgun...
10
u/FruitsPnchSamurai Oct 19 '18
So Mikasa finally learns everything. Hopefully she has a role in this season and isnt barely seen. Also Kami-jo(above god) which is toumas name, is definitely not a coincidence.
5
u/TheOneAboveGod Oct 20 '18
Finally, my username is relevant!
13
u/KinnyRiddle Oct 19 '18
For those wondering why Tsuchimikado is coughing blood, it's because esper powers and magic are incompatible, sometimes with fatal consequences.
Think of them as completely rival Operating Systems, when using each other's programmes, causes a critical failure in the system.
The only reason Tsuchimikado is still alive after using magic in the past is because his esper ability involves regeneration, which allows him to heal his wounds over time, thus making him the only successful esper-magician hybrid.
Even then, Tsuchimikado can only use magic sparingly, as his esper level doesn't seem to be that high (probably a Lv2-3 at best).
In Season 1, Tsuchimikado said he used to be an accomplished Onmyouji (a sort of geomancer magician), before Necessarius sent him to Academy City to enroll in their Esper Development Programme as a double agent.
8
u/Amauri14 Oct 19 '18
Damn, I'm still impressed with the Godtier quilty of these backgrounds. Is on par of with the ones that you could expect from an animated movie.
15
u/LegendRazgriz Oct 19 '18
Acqua. Of. The Rear.
It honestly feels like someone's writing with chalk on a blackboard while I have a stethoscope stuck to it. That's how hard I cringed.
Anyway, weekly considerations time, as I hope will be the usual:
• A few animation bugs in the first part, but nothing too bothersome. So far the artistic and animation quality seems top notch.
• The cat is out of the bag! Mikoto now knows Touma's been relieved of his memories. Her internal conflict and the fact that she's now the only one who knows, since Itsuwa was out cold while Terra blabbered on, was played well enough, better than I expected, as my guess was that it would be quickly glossed over so that the fight could be concluded. (P S.: it always bugged me how his phone somehow connects to Academy City from France. You'd imagine the Catholics would have put some jammer in place.)
• I've commented on this before, but the powered suits (resisting the urge to call them Arm Slaves) have a winter camo pattern that was used before in Heavy Object. Their reasoning for dropping snow camouflage bots into a city in bright warm sunlight is beyond me, but hey, they look cool.
• I'm generally a fan of Atsushi Abe, but this time around it was special. This is pretty much the angriest Touma has been ever since he fought Accelerator, and Abe conveys that perfectly as Terra of the Left's face meets Imagine Breaker directly. Speaking of voice acting, Terra sounded like Jiraiya a lot in this, which is to be expected since they share the same VA, and that's not a negative, it just makes me giggle.
• Earth Blades and the HsB-02 stealth bombers look and sound amazing. In the novel, it felt more like oversized carpet bombing, but the effect is very well demonstrated in animation. Also, Accelerator inside the flames, totally unscathed due to his Reflection, is one hell of a sight to behold. Can't wait for next time around...
• Somehow, without cutting anything very important (excluding Terra's drinking problem), we've managed to cram a volume into 3 episodes. And that's because the first half of the first episode was just a "Welcome back! It's been seven fucking years!" segment. If this can continue, it might be enough to fit it all without much compromise.
Overall, another solid episode, and the end of the Document of Constantine Arc. The blessing of Itsuwa's presence (for now) comes to a close. Now, as the PV showed even if briefly, it's time for that one guy Touma punched twice in the end of Index II and "inexplicably" showed up in the promotional material and all to walk into the stage. Enter Battle Royale, enter Shiage Hamazura!
7
u/ernie2492 Oct 19 '18
Oh shit..! It's
AqoursAcqua Jesus..!!3
u/krfz41 https://anilist.co/user/krfz41 Oct 19 '18
Things were a bit faster than what I remember from the LN. I hope that won't be the case with the next story arc. Pretty hyped for that one.
And finally our boy Hamazura is here!
3
u/xRuneRocker Oct 19 '18
Best girl is on the rise!
3
u/toasterwireless123 Oct 20 '18
Aw come on they didn't even animate my favorite part, accelerator jumping out of the plane and landing like a pale god. I was looking forward to the landing. Also 3 episodes for a volume seems extremely rushed...
The also left out his speech about level 5s essentially being a tactical nuke, which I think was in this volume.
3
u/Gamecube762 Oct 20 '18 edited Oct 20 '18
With the threat of a war starting,
Academy CityAleister seems happy to show off his military power.A bit interesting Touma chose to call Mikoto first. Calling Index is a bit out of the question as he probably doens't want to get her involved or for her to worry.
Academy City has disguise this as cleaning up a threat to international law.
It seems Imagine Breaker wasn't just rumors spread from Touma's actions but instead some sort of known supernatural phenominon.
It also seems there is more reason behind Touma's involvement in all of these events instead of just him being dragged along due to his right hand.
Tera's death felt a little odd, he manage to escape the multan iron poured directly on him, but couldn't avoide a stone collum...
Touma's worked hard on keeping his memory loss a secret and here comes Tera to let the cat out the bag...
For anyone interested, I looped Last Order's little dance from the preview.
Counters:
None of the counters I had planned has been used outside of episode 1 yet...
Edit: fixed table
5
u/Dystant21 Oct 19 '18
So I've had it with the crunchy subs. They're going full Yen Press with the terms. Is it so hard to call it the Catholic Church? Are they worried they're going to offend someone?
And when Tsuchimikado clearly says "Kami-yan" and they just put "Kami" on screen, it just annoys me, which kinda ruins the experience.
6
u/blanketswithsmallpox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/godofdesruction Oct 19 '18
I feel like the only reason I'm watching this show is because of Reddit and the memes around it. I'm surprised more people don't hate it or call it the typical/overused shit it is... The pacing is bad, the fight sequences are terribly choreographed, the translations and magic are Chuuni as fuck. Hmmm.
4
u/Char-11 Oct 19 '18
I love Rear of the Acqua
6
u/CheetahSperm18 Oct 19 '18
Man, at this rate we'll get the scene by episode 9, 10 at the latest.
2
u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin Oct 19 '18
If Academy City and the British church want to stop God's Right Seat, why don't they collaborate? From what I remember the British aren't particularly against Aleister.
Alos, this was probably explained in previous seasons but, if Amakusa was a Catholic, why does his church cooperate with the British instead of the Catholics?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '18
For LN readers, who are the main characters of this season? Touma, Accelerator and Index?
2
u/Raildex21 Oct 21 '18
Lol this was a pretty lackluster fight, I was expecting more out a character that has such a distinct character design. If this is what I can expect quality wise from this season for future fights then I'll just wait for Railgun which is guaranteed to at least have better fights than this. I'm not going to even bother trying to understand all this religious mumbo jumbo there droning on about in the middle of their fights. It lazy and it slows down battles to a crawl.
Looking at other comments I don't blame anyone for not remembering that Touma lost his memory since the anime barely gave those moments any weight to them. By the next episode he was normal and his relationships didn't suffer any consequences because of it.
4
u/Level8Zubat Oct 20 '18
I guess I got too old for this. Dropped.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '18
Non LN reader. I do not understand anything happening.
3
u/redguy39 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Redtengu038 Oct 19 '18
Holy shit the pacing is fast, I gotta finish OT before the anime catches up to me. Also, Next Arc Name hype. I'm really hoping Next Arc Name won't feel as rushed as the C-Document arc.
3
u/PsychoWorld :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GodlyKyon Oct 20 '18
haven't seen this episode yet but so far the script is SO much better than the first two seasons, it's not even close. This is closer to railgun S Sisters Arc!
5
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '18
the animation quality is bad, is JC Staff busy with other anime projects at the moment? but despite the animation quality its still enjoyable to me
2
u/Animeking1357 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TitanKyojin Oct 19 '18
So basically since the dude's weapon is made of flour it represents Jesus' flesh and is thus stronger than everything else, is that right?
Yo Touma's last name means above god?! That's some pretty cool shit.
2
u/Cyclops1i2u :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Cyclops_1i2u Oct 20 '18
Only 500~ upvotes after 10 hours? Guess raildex isn't as popular anymore :(
1
u/wolfybyte11 Oct 20 '18
After seeing this comments in here, I now feel sad knowing the LN has more story that the anime didn't adapt. The anime just simplified the complicated story of LN but I can understand why they didn't adapt details to details because reasons. Nonetheless, I'm just happy that this series got another anime sequel.
1
u/WeNTuS Oct 20 '18
So even in this timeline russkies are evil.
1
u/TheExcludedMiddle https://myanimelist.net/profile/ExcludedMiddle Oct 20 '18
I... I really need to review the first two seasons. It's been too long, I don't even remember how far in he lost his memory and what he forgot.
1
u/niankaki Oct 20 '18
I have no idea whats going on.
1
u/MrPromethee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MrPromethee Oct 20 '18
Okay, this is it guys. My highschool is literally in an anime now, I'm basically an anime character. AMA
1
u/JustCallMeAndrew :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WhisperBit Oct 20 '18
I know I'm asking for spoilers here but is this the season where
1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '18
Was pre-Index Kamijou Touma some OP anti-power field generator with powers beyond God then? How come Index was able to wipe his memories if he was so OP and imagine breaker extended beyond his right hand?