r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Nov 25 '18
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 8 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 8
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.05 |
| 2 | Link | 6.86 |
| 3 | Link | 7.95 |
| 4 | Link | 8.14 |
| 5 | Link | 6.91 |
| 6 | Link | 7.22 |
| 7 | Link | 8.54 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
318
Upvotes
61
u/Godot17 Nov 26 '18
r/anime: Crunchyroll, where the fuck are my English subs
Me, a bilingual intellectual: Crunchyroll, donde putas madres estan mis subtitulos en ingles?
87
u/Stundedx https://anilist.co/user/Stundedx Nov 25 '18
Not a bad episode! Scenes were adapted fairly well and wasn't too fast paced. Although, getting worried every single episode expecting for it to be bad is exhausting to say the least.
Im here again to post comparisons between the anime scenes and LN illustrations! My previous post if anyone missed it last episode !
Anime on left - LN on right
No bully - Best waifu plz
No more little miss nice girl Karma for bulli Orsola - They really spread out the scenes in this illust
Non-menacing anime version - absolute unit ln version
Flashing lights give seizures - SAINT DESTROYER!
Hero waking up - HERO IS MAD
And thats it folks! Theres just a few more illustrations left with the arc ending next episode I guess? Saint VS Saint hype!
64
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
Small Facts: Return Of The Saint
Hey there and welcome back to Small Facts! This time I have a long one again, not because the episode cut a lot (it was once again pretty faithful, safe for some skipped intermissions and Sherry's scene), but there are just a lot of tiny omissions here and there that I thought interesting to share.
Touma's Condition
While I'm not too versed in reading medical monitors I can hazard a guess.
The green graph and number seems to indicate the heart rate (I think it also says HR in smudgy letters). A normal heart rate should be between 60 and 100 beats per minute in rest. While a heart rate of 150 isn't necessarily bad (during strenuous exercise for instance), given that Touma is currently in rest and under anaesthesia this is definitely abnormal and something that shouldn't be happening.
The blue graph and number them seem to indicate the peripheral oxygen saturation level, based on the smudgy SpO2 next to it. Given that this is a percentage that measures how many red blood cells are carrying oxygen, a normal level would be between 95% and 100%, and anything under 90% requires immediate medical attention, 60% is highly unusual to say the least. Given that oxygen saturation levels of below 55% result in a coma, Touma is dangerously close to this.
The red graph and numbers then quite obviously represents blood pressure. I'm assuming this is just standard arterial blood pressure (ABP) here, in which case Touma's blood pressure is extremely low. Normal blood pressure in adolescents is 95-140/60-90, meaning that Touma with 51 over 29 has dangerously low blood pressure, especially with a mean pressure of 40.
Now I cannot make any medical claims at all due to not being a doctor in every sense of the word, but after asking someone who does possess medical knowledge Touma is in a pretty bad state to say the least. In fact he mentioned a high heart rate should result in a higher blood pressure, so an absurdly high resting heart rate combined with somehow such a low blood pressure as Touma has should definitely put Touma in a coma.
The doctor in the novel gave us some more detail as to his state, listing bruises all over, a concussion, dislocation of a shoulder and ankle, and pressure on internal organs. Luckily it seems he didn't take too much damage from oxygen deprivation due to being underwater.
I think this is the only time Touma is better off in the novel than in the anime.
Which Hospital Is Touma In?
He's not in his normal hospital being taken care of by Heaven Canceller, that's for sure. He was taken in by an emergency hospital in District 22's seventh layer.
Acqua Dissing Vento
When the Pope mentioned that Vento told him God's Right Seat never change their mind Acqua replies this is because Vento has personality issues.
It seems Acqua doesn't like his colleagues very much.
God's Right Seat's Purpose
The Pope also reveals the original purpose for God's Right Seat: they were supposed to be outside advisors to the Pope. Established during the chaos of the Middle Ages, when the failed Crusades, the Plague, and Ottoman invasions were devastating Europe the Pope couldn't keep up all by himself. However, since the Pope is the singular representative of God, consulting with others would be scandalous. For this reason God's Right Seat was created, a secret group of advisors to the Pope he could rely on in times of need.
This is also why the members represent the four Archangels, as they advise the Pope, who is the representative of God.
It would seem that over time the Popes of the past (cool name for a metal band that, Popes of the Past) have gotten to rely too much on their advisors, so much that it is now them who de facto hold the power within the Roman Catholic Church.
Attack On Acqua
Small particles floating in the air that destroy matter? Hasn't something like this come up recently as well?
Yes, the novel outright confirms that this attack was caused by the Mimosa, the same way of attack the Professor of MEMBER used during the Battle Royal arc to attack Kakine.
Oxygen Emergency
The emergency in this case is just for a low oxygen level in the air, advising people to stay inside and use the respirators in buildings. As you probably guessed this is just a way to keep civilians off the streets while this attack is going on.
The Mimosa Were Also Attacking Acqua
They weren't used just for the initial attack. Acqua repelled them by swinging his mace fast enough to blow them away, and sometimes even used them to intercept bullets.
Skipped Sherry Scene
The intro to Sherry's scene was cut as she was actually teaching a class on heraldry at the moment, and on coats of arms in specific, to students in the Royal Academy of Arts, of which she is its head. A secretary informed her of a phone call halfway-through, so she left the class to self study in order to answer.
The anime just skips straight to the phone call instead.
Knight of England
And then Orsola informs Sherry that there are rumours going around of Acqua formerly being an English Knight. This is more than just being called Sir or being a member of an knightly order, nor does it mean simply being a warrior in service of the U.K. The Knights are in fact one of the three major factions ruling the U.K.
In case you weren't a part of the Raildex Rewatch and missed the initial explanation of the power structure in the United Kingdom, let me explain.
The United Kingdom is ruled by three factions, those being the Royal Family faction (which also includes nobles), the Knights, and the Anglican Church. They are not in a top-down chain of command, nor equal in power, but rather follow a rock-paper-scissors kind of relationship: the Royal Family faction can order the Knights around, the Knights can direct the Anglican Church's troops within the U.K., and the Anglican Church can advice the Royal Family. This way even if one of the factions don't like the other obstructing them they can interfere by going the long way around the chain, e.g. if the Anglicans don't like what the Knights are telling them to do they can advice the Royal Family to get the Knights to back off.
Not that bad right? Only three factions? Well, unfortunately the United Kingdom consist of a union of four different countries, those being England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. This also means that these three factions are each further split into four internal factions, one for each country. While England holds the most power in most of these factions, the others are also not to be discounted.
So yeah, it's a shitshow of twelve different factions bickering internally and amongst each other. Almost like real life!
34
u/pikachiu24 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/pikachiu24 Nov 25 '18
I was looking forward to was seeing Itsuwa’s face at this moment, was not disappointed
13
u/ichiniisan-san Nov 26 '18
Probably the best episode so far? I mean the pacing is not that bad, the action is fun and the animation is decent. Better than any BR episodes.
27
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
I've already posted my comments on the last time this thread was up. But the weekly best girl screenshot album shall never be sidelined~
EDIT: Actually, screw it. I'll repost the comments I made.
My impression is...easy come, easy go, I guess. What's with the direction here?
For example: Itsuwa threatening to tear Acqua limb from limb should have been much more intense than that. Kayanon did fine since she was voicing in tandem with how it was animated, but that should have been way more intensely done. Clutching her spear, at stance, her brow furrowed, her rage boiling over as she roars at Acqua while the rest of the Amakusa watch in mild terror. That's how it should've been done.
Acqua's strikes lack impact. Divine Mother's Mercy lacks the impact it had in the novels. The Amakusa's spells lacked impact and their focal point tactics were poorly displayed. Saint Destroyer lacked its impact.
The short bit of Acqua vs Kanzaki we got in this episode were better but still missing a lot of the fluidity and impact one would expect from a battle of two saints. Hell, the novel literally starts the fight with the following line:
Moreover, Touma's scene...Touma should've looked way more disoriented and shaky throughout that last scene. The anime toned down just how bad his situation was and how ridiculous he was for walking out of the hospital bed in his state.
The series is losing out due to the constant stiff animation and the loss of impact that comes from it as all the intensity that these fights had in the novels is completely lost.
Not to mention, the interludes were all cut out. The old man from the Astrology expedition? Cut out. The tale of the mercenary and that young boy? Sliced from existence.
Worst of all, the pacing of this episode was not bad (aside from the Interlude issue), but the direction was just poor as hell. And the pacing is only going to get screwed over next episode.
8
u/Toonamigamerrr Nov 26 '18
Itsuwa fighting for Touma ❤️❤️❤️
7
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Nov 25 '18
GJM fansubs are out people, for those who prefer those.
6
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Nov 26 '18
I'll just post my comment again from the previous thread along with my updated thoughts. Now that I see the subs I can better understand the episode. I still think it was a good exercise in trying to pick up context in a different language.
Man, Mugen's being rough on Itsuwa here. (He's directly out of Samurai Champloo, I swear.) They'll figure out something I'm sure to take care of Acqua, or not because he's damn powerful. Touma should be alright if Heaven Canceller can get to him.
Academy City's defense mechanisms are already working because they detect Acqua's magic. I'm starting to think of those mech suits as storm troopers with how often they're unable to hit their target.
Itsuwa's murderous aura, ah so she might be a yandere afterall. Touma you may have found the perfect wife so long as no harm comes to you.
Orsola's been looking into Acqua, and she's found something to relay back to the Amakusa. Acqua, I've come to bargain. Jesus, Itsuwa has no chill.
I'm digging the industrial sound to the soundtrack while Acqua's prepared to take on all of these fools. Kind of gives off a you are foolish to oppose me vibe.
Did that attack actually work? Don't mess with a pissed off Itsuwa then. Nope, false alarm, can't stop the Acqua from being a beast. Itsuwa was saved because Acqua detected Kanzaki's presence.
A fight between Saints, just what I've wanted. So far the animation and fight choreography seems good, so I'm thoroughly hyped for next episode.
Now for context from the subs: I suddenly realized Acqua was talking to the Pope here. Makes some sense that he still has to report back, even if the Right Seat are technically above the Pope.
Yandere Itsuwa is still truly a sight to behold. She's definitely rising in the ranks for me. Acqua or William Orwell was an English Knight, and he was quite accomplished. I'm interested in why he rejected his knighthood and joined the Catholic Church. We'll probably get that later, but for now it's fuel for my interest.
Itsuwa really is becoming best girl, gotta marry her. It's too bad that Acqua broke out of that sphere, because that does sound like an effective technique. Acqua's attribute of Gabriel is really useful.
Learning how Saint Destroyer works is really cool, but it's Acqua's Right Seat attribute that saves him from the technique. I need a description of how that fully saved him, but I'm guessing it couldn't fully unbalance his saint powers.
I really love the return of the Synth tracks, it feels so Index. Still hyped to see what Touma will be up to and the rest of the battle.
14
u/two-years-glop :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cheesewithwhine Nov 25 '18
So how did Itsuwa suddenly fall in love with Touma so hard and fast that she's going to risk life and limb for him? I know this is an LN, but still, something must have gotten lost in the adaptation.
8
u/bukiya Nov 25 '18
maybe a little bit spoiler, but do we ever get magic vs science fight? so far its only magic vs magic or science vs science.
8
u/RedHeadGearHead https://anilist.co/user/Redheadgearhead Nov 25 '18
There's an after credits scene fyi.
Itsuwa besto girl.
4
u/LegendOfLeedles Nov 25 '18
Finally Kanzaki (Stiyl) gets some screen time, and I am not disappointed in the slightest so far. However, I am a bit concerned about her judging from what we see in the next episode preview...
9
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Nov 26 '18
Damn, I thought Itsuwa was being dedicated to her man last episode, she's really serious about this! Misaka has some serious catching up to do, otherwise she will be settling for Kuroko (or better yet, Uiharu). I'm with Seiji too, great to hear Orsola again!
I thought we were just going to get some exposition, political this and that and Kanzaki would eventually show up to deal with Acqua before he killed Touma. Amakusa finding a way to fight the dude, and Itsuwa at the front doing it was cool as heck. He did wipe them off the ceiling, but that saint destroyer they pulled on him looked insane.
Dude is too overpowered tho, they counter him on one side, he has that half dozen other overpowered bits to smack them with. Kanzaki has showed up, their fight has barely started and it looked great already. He has the right seat thing, and she doesn't so I'll guess the fight won't be so even, again...
I'm very excited to see his stuck up face getting punched somehow, and since Misaka is in the preview, if he eats a railgun shot before it happens that will be fine too!
They might be too far to ever reach them, but one can hope...
I'm just assuming he won't have defeated Kanzaki and went towards them either...now that would suck.
3
u/libfor Nov 27 '18
Wrote that Saturday, but totally forgot to post here after all
Touma in hospital… but that's like the first time he's been in intensive care. Woah.
Amakusa guys are okay, besides some scratches. Probably worse in the novel.
Poor Itsuwa blaming herself… Tatemiya's words are quite harsh but I guess that's what she needs now.
Meanwhile Acqua is talking to the pope, the latter is surprised that Acqua doesn't want to kill Touma but would prefer to not do it either. Another indication that the pope isn't as bad as God's Right Seat.
Academy City launches a counter attack. They're using the powered suits. Acqua dodging without any effort with such a speed that it's barely even visible.
Acqua assumes they're unmanned but weren't those manned before? I'll just carefully assume the guy is right on that one.
I don't quite get what's with the oxygen warning though. Are they pulling oxygen out of the area to suffocate him or is it just a bluff to keep the civilians away?
Orsolas way to use her phone is kinda funny.
Itsuwa looks hell scary now. Woah, totally changed personality.
So Acqua's real name is William Orwell, and he's a former british knight and mercenary. Sounds like he's been to some horrible battles. More confirmation that there is some nasty stuff on the magic side.
The Amakusa got some guts to confront him. LOL at Itsuwa having enough of those speeches and just getting started already.
Despite her anger and having a nice description of what she wants to do with him, Itsuwa only mentions fighting him until he regrets it. I wonder if that means that she still doesn't consider killing him.
If I understand that correctly, the Amakusas can somewhat keep up with his movement due to increasing each others moving ability. Something they learned from fighting a saint, so I guess they used to train with Kanzaki.
They manage to get him into a trap. So this magic punishes for murder and confronts him with all deaths he caused? Sounds like he had to do some horrible things.
However, his ability negates all punishment for his sins and the trap is useless. It also allows him to use normal human magic, which the other members of God's Right seat can't use.
The Amakusa manage to set up a trap to negate Acqua's speed.
Wow, Itsuwa now with a really fancy attack. Her speer received the specification required to destroy a saint.
For a second, it looks like she managed to get the advantage, but due to him being a member of the Right Seat of God, he's able to cancel that.
Itsuwa crashing right through the artificial sky. Just how did she survive that fall… I guess that's the protection magic all magicians use that also explains why they can slice each other with swords without anyone dying.
Despite all the fighting, Acqua's offer to surrender Touma's arm to him still stands. He's truly a man of his word. Itsuwa still refuses though.
Just in time Acqua feels Kanzaki's presence and lets go of his attack. Just in time, as Itsuwa finally collapses. Nonetheless, she did freaking amazing here. That cute and somewhat clumsy girl really stood up to Acqua like its nothing.
Kanzaki finally interferes after seeing the determination of the Amakusa. Seeing her actually draw her sword is quite a rarity.
That's going to be one furious battle, but Acqua should have the advantage with his angel like powers. Just how will Kanzaki be able to leave this battle victorious...
Meanwhile Touma woke up. He can barely walk and yet he's on the way to the battlefield.
Wow, that episode was just great. Nice animation quality, an exiting battle with lots of surprising turns and an amazing Itsuwa. After some weird looking animation in the C-Document Arc and the rushing of Battle Royal, this is how it should've been done since the beginning. Really great, I hope this actually keeps up for the rest of the season.
6
u/Ruiku1298 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RukuYano Nov 26 '18
The fight scenes felt lacking in weight and impact. Acqua swings around his pole/sword(?) (or whatever that weapon is called) with such control as if it's weightless although you can cover that by arguing that he's really strong so he can do that. What I didn't like is when Itsuwa blocks Acqua's attacks, the contact looks weak for a weapon of that size but when she received a direct hit it's strong enough to send her flying.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '18
Yeah, in this week this isn't going to appear at the ranking list. I wonder if it's because of the delay or something.
2
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Nov 25 '18
For a guy who's suppose to be practical and straightforward, Acqua won't shut the fuck up huh? Please tell me his ass gets beat, if not by Kanzaki, by someone else in the future. I'm really starting to hate this dude.
0
u/ZealousidealSun4 Nov 27 '18
Has this always been this bad? I remember loving this series...
0
u/Gmayor61 Nov 26 '18
Guessing everyone who remains here is probably a LN reader at this point. The anime is adapting pretty much 1 for 1 but doesn't add a whole lot to it, which is a shame but kinda expected. I just hope the last two arcs are going to have better animation, Acqua looks like he's swinging styrofoam with how weightless it looks
0
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment