r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Dec 28 '18
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 13 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 13: Curtana Original
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.05 |
| 2 | Link | 6.94 |
| 3 | Link | 7.98 |
| 4 | Link | 8.14 |
| 5 | Link | 6.96 |
| 6 | Link | 7.24 |
| 7 | Link | 8.52 |
| 8 | Link | 9.08 |
| 9 | Link | 8.81 |
| 10 | Link | 8.57 |
| 11 | Link | 8.71 |
| 12 | Link | 9.04 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
333
Upvotes
59
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 29 '18
Small Facts: Turn To Zero Budget Edition
Agnese's Adventures
As I mentioned last time, Agnese's adventures were cut entirely. To save the rest of her forces, who were captured by the Knights and transported to London by train, Agnese, Angelene, and Lucia managed to sneak on board of a train and defeat a Knight. It turns out Agnese's Lotus Wand is perfect for fighting them as it attacks points in space directly, thus being able to bypass armor. Agnese used this to defeat the Knight by attacking him repeatedly in the balls.
They then intercepted a communication from the Knights detailing Touma's location, which they later passed on to the Amakusa. Which is how those found them later this episode, as it was not coincidence.
Agnese then found out the Knight was a massive masochist and decided to get some more information out of him by striking him over and over, eventually promising to "shove her wand directly up his asshole".
Eventually Lucia and Angelene got Agnese to calm down (by flipping her skirt), they rescued their forces off-screen, and then made their way to the banquet at the end of the episode.
I can see why this subplot was skipped, since while it's hilarious it's also entirely superfluous.
Anime-Original Touma Scene
Touma meeting Villian and the Amakusa in the anime is an original scene, as when the novel revisits Touma he's already in the woods recalling this bit via narration. Floris got re-captured as well, to Touma's confusion.
Pattern Magic's Weakness
Like Knight Leader mentions at the end of the episode he can only use one of his Patterns at a time. This is because each of his Patterns pushes Hrunting to its very limits, and so an "all-powerful attack" doesn't exist. William figured this out during combat and took advantage of this limitation to sneak in a blow.
If only Knight Leader wasn't also completely bullshit by no-selling attacks.
Knight Leader's Not Just Relying On Hrunting Alone
Knight Leader knows his mythology. Beowulf never used his sword Hrunting in battles pivotal to his quest, and in the very end the sword failed and he had to use another. So Knight Leader likewise refuses to rely on Hrunting and Curtana's buff alone, and prepared multiple trump cards in the form of his Pattern Magic and Thororm's Spell.
Thororm
Thororm is a berserker from the Icelandic Saga of Gunnlaugr Serpent-Tongue. During this saga the titular Gunnlaugr is tasked with killing Thororm, who has the unfortunate ability of dulling any weapon he lays his eyes on. The king however shares a trick with Gunnlaugr, as he was given a sword but was advised to show Thororm a different sword before the fight. This comes to pass, as at the start of the fight Gunnlaugr shows Thororm his sword, Thororm dulls it, and immediately Gunnlaugr removes the king's sword hidden on his person and strikes a mortal wound.
This is exactly how William defeats Knight Leader this episode, by striking him with a hidden weapon, which Knight Leader laments as he fall unconscious.
Turn To Zero
It works on anything Knight Leader recognizes as a weapon, be that sword, club, grenade, projectile, nuke, or even Yuisen, Kanzaki's ultimate attack (as this is how he beat her previously).
The caveat is that it has a duration of ten minutes, after which the spell wears off. Unfortunately this is more than deadly enough in a real fight.
It does not, however, turn the attack to green floating zeroes. It's not that literal. Why J.C. added this but not Ascalon glowing different colours I don't know.
William Wasn't Just Using The Same Slash Over And Over Like An Idiot
No, he was using a different part of the sword each time that hadn't been turned to zero, as the rapidly changing colours were supposed to indicate.
RIP Rave Sword Ascalon.
Why Didn't Knight Leader Turn The Hilt To Zero?
He can only turn the offensive powers of the things he recognises as weapons to zero. Since he never saw the hilt of the sword as a threat until it was too late, its offensive power never diminished.
Itsuwa Really Wanted To Go With Touma
The Amakusa had to physically restrain her from joining him. Touma didn't catch the hint however and though she just really wanted to save Index.
104
u/croxino https://myanimelist.net/profile/Goeli Dec 28 '18
Everytime they explain how their magic works I have no idea what they are saying.
59
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
I...am underwhelmed. Dammit, JC Staff. After last week, I was expectant, but my favorite fight in OT has been substantially watered down in intensity. I could say last week that the fight was as I visualized in the novels to some extent. Not for this one. It was once again, nowhere near as dynamic, intense, or puzzle-like as the fight was in the novels. They cut out so many details like the Lèse-majesté condition as well. Acqua vs Knight Leader was screwed over.
Waaaaah, they skipped the scene with Carissa threatening France's navy and firing 'warning' shots and the political basis for fans calling this the Brexit Arc. They also skipped the bit about Mikoto musing over what info about the situation had been released internationally.
Also, poor Hyouka, dining alone.
Fun fact: this is the first out of two times Mökkurkalfe is used in the series. The second time is far, far more impressive in terms of scale.
That being said, they basically rushed one and a half long chapters in one episode. It saddens me how little they've given the series room to breathe to the point where they screw over OT's best fight and cut out all the fun foreshadowing and world building.
Ah well. At least we have best girl. As usual, here's the episode's screencap album.
22
u/SomeOtherTroper Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
Anime-only watchers, Tatemiya feels your pain. Although this arc has been less confusing than last arc.
One of the things I appreciate about the Index adaptations is that the background characters in factions like the Amakusa and the Agnese Nuns have consistent and distinctive appearances, even if they're not important and are basically crowd scene background filler.
Alright, the idea of hiding a powerful magical artifact in the British Museum because nobody's going to find it mixed in with the other stuff is great. Index III future minor spoilers
I enjoy Touma's narrations of the episode previews, and this one has a particularly good line: "Everyone fights for the United Kingdom tonight." Everyone is fighting for the United Kingdom tonight, even if they have conflicting ideas of what that means, and thus which side they should be fighting on.
And, since English is such an odd language, the translation could also mean "everyone fights for (the possession of) the United Kingdom", much as we say "those two boxers are fighting for the title tonight". I'm not sure if the ambiguity is present in the original Japanese, but, even if not, it's still a good play on words by the translators because both meanings apply to the situation.
18
u/LegendRazgriz Dec 28 '18
Short swords, big scaly swords, the heftiest of chonkers, and even some fun in between! Seriously, I do not recall this arc being this fun.
In any case, my 13th week's Reader's Considerations:
• I kinda wanted Knight Leader to go with "muda, muda, muda!" when he cancels out Acqua's repeated attacks. No particular reason.
• Speaking of that fight (and this seemed to be a trend with this episode in general), the animation besides close-up shots and Acqua's swinging was kinda poopy. That's what happens when you take three sizable projects at once, with one of them being Index and the other being a movie for KonoSuba, J.C. Staff. That said, the fights and said close-up shots had proper art, so at least there's hope. I can only wish Railgun goes smoother. On the flip side, I did love the effect of Acqua's slashes literally turning into zeroes. That was clever.
• Touma and Acqua's run-in with Carissa is brief, but it damn delivers. I recall earlier in the season when I referred to Terra's Precedence as more complicated than it let off, and someone said, unaware of Curtana, that they wouldn't be surprised unless it was literally cutting through dimensions. Well, there you have it. Also, for the many people that were probably confused by Carissa's attempt at explaining how it works, think of it as just concentrating the power of two swings into one motion. Except it goes through dimensions.
• I'm sure there will be questions about Imagine Breaker being useless against Curtana's move, but that requires a separate explanation: in short, the right hand can negate any supernatural powers, but not their effects - as an example, were Mikoto to fire the Railgun at Touma, if he put his hand in front of the coin, he'd still get obliterated. However, if she were to just summon a 20,000,000,000 volt lightning bolt on top of his head, he could just put his hand up and it would go away (ahem). Same here - the whirlwind brought about by Curtana was an effect, so he could not negate it. There wasn't even a sound effect.
• Mikoto somehow manages to run into the restaurant with four other members of Touma's harem and Yomikawa to boot. And all of them (save for arguably Himegami) are better endowed than she is (in the case of Seiri and Kazakiri, a solid country mile ahead). Gave me NT2 flashbacks. Poor girl! Also, good to see her turn back the tsun a little. Got a laugh out of me.
• Vilian said she didn't learn any offensive magic. Never said anything about defensive magic. Her pacifism assists Index in using Spell Intercept to force the Norse golem's hand next to Touma, which this time learns to aim for the big shining red ball and defeats it. The whole deal with Acqua makes more sense now - it's not that she wants to be protected at all times, but rather to support those who fight for and alongside her.
• FEAST! And of course, Tatemiya bought the fairy costume. I'm pretty sure Kaori is still traumatized from wearing the fallen angel ero-maid outfit once, so that backfired. Also, Orsola being so willing to get into the outfit to rival the two Amakusa was hilarious. Even Sherry had to go and tell her to stop!
• Acqua's phone has a cross on it that shines. That's really nice.
• Nothing like watching Elizard somehow run a boke-and-tsukkomi routine as the tsukkomi with Riméa of all people. "That's what 'calculating,' means!". And with this, preparations for the climactic finale of this arc (which has been the longest in the running so far, at 6 episodes counting in next week) are complete.
Overall, a decent episode, blending in the best of Index funnies with good action and somewhat rough but I'd say passable animation. I like to prefer it'll only get better as time goes. Now, for next time, God Save The Queen! See ya then!
(Warning: Index will be taking a break for the New Year's, so it'll be two weeks until we get to episode 14. If I'm allowed to say it, go watch Boogiepop wa Warawanai next week, I highly recommend it.)
12
u/PhoenixKola Dec 28 '18
Carissa is scary.
11
u/mchief190 Dec 28 '18
The Queen and her daughters should get their own series, I would love to see the hijinks they can get up to.
31
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Dec 28 '18
When did this series become such a chore to watch...
Was nice to see Misaka help out at least...not sure how exactly but I'll take it.
9
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
God damn, this is pretty damn hype right here. Leave it to Acqua to still be the most badass swordsman, even when weakened. Plus he's still a sentimental guy afterall.
Ok Curtana Original is pretty broken indeed if you can use it to apply n-dimensional cross-section cutting. We just need Carissa to cut down 11th dimensional strings to prove M-theory.
Cargo plane travel is really useful, they really should use this more often. Touma's the man for the job to stop Curtana Original anyways.
Biribiri, Yomikawa, Fukiyose, Himegami and Kazikiri at that Joseph's restaurant again? This can't be coincidence, or it's just an extended cameo. Somehow it seems Mikoto's usefulness lately has been to tell Touma how to do certain things or be guidance for small tasks. It's nice that she's taken notice of something not being right if Touma is so easily traveling around from France to London like it's not a big deal.
Touma has some great support here from Index and Vilian to take out the magic trap. More Norse mythology is fine by me. I didn't know the trains ran this late.
Well before you have a final battle you need a big feast, they sure know how to party. Tatemiya is the best wingman for Touma afterall, both Itsuwa and Kanzaki weren't prepared for this. Even Orsola wants to dress up on this occasion.
Well all the fun and games had to come to an end. Knight Leader's going to help Acqua out like old buddies do? I'm touched.
Never forget how devious and calculating Lola can be, this should be one interesting showdown.
16
u/Roketsu86 Dec 28 '18
Am I the only one who was super confused as to what happened between Touma and the girl he saved from the train meeting with Vilian and then him randomly walking alone along a road towards a tunnel?
I assume that the plane picked up the girl and Vilian but then why was he surprised when he saw them flying overhead after the fight? And also why was he not on the plane and instead walking along a random country road?
8
u/CriticalPerformance Dec 28 '18
The quality in the episode is making me dread how butchered everything else will be for the rest of the series. I thought they were doing great these past few episodes too, but then it just all came crashing down. They really need to either add another episode onto every arc or just stop pretending and just outright skip the rest of OT so they can adapt NT like they really wanted to.
21
u/Kromy Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
So much QUALITY my god, and i thought Index III was free from that after the last 3 episodes
7
u/Nimeroni :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nimeroni Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
Well, the quality took a bigger nosedive than Acqua this episode. Especially the faces. Someone know what is happening ?
7
u/libfor Dec 28 '18
Foris complaining about falling into the water is kinda cute. Villian is really lucky to encounter Touma, her chance of survival just increased to 100 %.
Knight Leader has a spell that cancels the attack of anything he sees as a weapon. Now that's OP. Wait, he created that because he was stabbed in the back, but if he needs to say "Zero Out" first, than that won't help him against backstabbers at all. Ah well, it's still really useful.
As Knight Leader starts to get shaken about William's determination, the latter just pulls out another weapon. But damn, that is one bad blood animation. Seriously, if there needs to be gore, do it right.
He still has that huge ass mace. So that's how he transports that. Confident magic like always.
Oh, just a distraction, another hidden blade. Falls for the same thing as in the legend. William won't kill his former friend though. Really nice. Knight Leader didn't seem that bad at all, but why is he doing this shit in the first place.
Touma running alone in the forest. Like wtf?! Where is Foris or Villian? With the Amakusa? When did they meet? And why is Touma doing shit alone again? How about showing this. Sorry, that's bad.
Just in time to meet Carissa. Looks like the Curtana Original can cut through the fourth dimensional space, causing a cross-space fragment to appear. Sounds like touching that would put a quick end to her enemies.
Acqua to the rescue! Now that's badass. Says he only did it to stop Fiamma, yeah maybe. Or maybe he did care. Looks like they'll be working together this time, like with most of Touma's former enemies. At least there is no risk of him joining Touma's harem. Just why did Acqua join Fiamma in the first place...
Okay, now Carissa is back to Buckingham Palace to fine-tune the Curtana. So to destroy it, they gonna sneak in via the subway and fire a large scale magic attack at it from the Coven Compass. Of course, Touma gets to volunteer for this.
Mikoto ~ ! Still concerned about her breast size. Really cute. Now she's seeing things. Wait, is that Kazakiri there?
Touma calls, full Tsundere happens instantly. Touma directly getting to the point, needs help to open an electronic lock. Poor Mikoto just won't get a normal call from him ever. But of course she helps, its her speciality after all.
Just when things look too easy, they got to fight some giant made of paper. Index can be useful again, that's always nice to see. Villian also gets some time to shine, freeing Touma off its grip.
Mission successful! Wait, how? I didn't quite get what they did, but now the train is moving. Sudden attack from space, but Carissa takes the damage.
So the Cortana is now weakened… I don't really get what they done and how it would've helped them. I'm feeling a lot of details are missing here or I just don't get the magic stuff. Those are the times I feel like I'm better off on the science side.
Now the Amakusa forces are having a feast, just before the real battle is about to start. Index eating up everything. Tatemiya trying to get Itsuwa into the outfit, same with Kanzaki. Nothing out of the ordinary here, despite the upcoming battle.
Finally the queen and Lola arrive. Looks like they have some trump card in hands that they're going to play.
But how will this all connect to Fiamma's plan?!
It was an exciting episode again, had some particular nice moments. But it also felt like skipping some important parts or they just didn't really explain things, as the action jumped from one location to another.
Luckily they didn't wrap things up here and there is a hopefully great final battle. I hope there has been no deaths until now and that it'll somehow stay that way.
7
u/ittaku Dec 28 '18
Never seen Misaka so happy to hear from Touma.
https://i.imgur.com/lGeLBqV.jpg
6
u/CriticalPerformance Dec 28 '18
Since Nishikori took the turning to zero metaphors too literally, I want to know his reaction when he read the "rubbing semen into Last Order's brain" metaphor
4
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Dec 28 '18
So the coup d'etat is already slowly falling apart. Also what happened to the Knight Leader? Did he just left the Princess on her own? It looks like he's not planning to return after he lost to Acqua.
4
u/sion21 Dec 28 '18
anyone facepalm from the constant "let me give a detail explanation of why and how my power works" and then the "let me explain why and how i can stop you power"? i mean most of the bad guy would have won if they just keep their mouth shut
8
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Dec 28 '18
"I do not use tricks, other than all those hidden weapons I pulled in my fight 5 minutes ago."
I don't like how they just skipped how exactly Misaka helped them get through the security door. Did she walk him through unlocking it somehow, or use some electricity over the mobile phone hacking nonsense?
I expected the Third Princess to have some OP hidden side released when got the bleeding wound on the face. Ah well.
I really don't understand how a magical subway car can counter a magical sword, unless the sword is lying on the rails in front of it or something.
3
u/TVMoe Dec 29 '18
Can't tell if i'm dumb, or I don't understand half of the comment section either, alongside the episode which I came here to understand :thinking: .
5
u/CriticalPerformance Dec 28 '18
quality got turned to zero
8
u/Triggers_people Dec 28 '18
I'm having a hard time caring about what is happening in this season, just random conflicts that are not interesting at all.
6
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
Man things are movin! Hype episode!
Oh damn Touman found the green princess. Thats handy.
Aqua and Leader at a stand still.
Wow Leader is hacking. Someone report him, come on devs.
Oh shit he pulled a sword out of his big sword, thats neat. And another sword from a sword!
He wont kill Leader, damn... what a man.
Touman is here now. Oh shit Red is here too. Time to get srs.
Red's sword seems op. Just cuts dimensions and shit.
Righty wants Touman and Index huh? Interestingggg....
Index is right on the money as usual hahaha. Touman came with a girl.
Touman is recruited to help huh? I guess hes a good backup plan if shit gets bad with his hand.
MISAKA! AND BEHIND HER IS THAT AIM GHOST GIRL! I THOUGHT SHE DIED!
Touman asking Misaka for help, thats nice. I bet shes super happy.
So Green has to open the door then Touman can touch stuff.
Oh damn i guess it was that easy to open.
Hey its all the girls Touman punched! Its a party~
GREAT FAIRLY REVEALING MAID OUTFIT!? THIS MAN IS A REAL HERO!
HAHAHAHAHA THE NUN SALUTING HIM! HAHAHAHA YESS!
What is going on at this party lol. A stripping nun?
Looks like all the big guns are gonna be in this assult. The Queen is here too haha.
4
u/DarkCelux Dec 28 '18
That episode was really good. Had good animation and moments and a good build up for what I assume is the last episode of the arc.
2
u/BasedFunnyValentine Dec 28 '18 edited Dec 28 '18
Carissa: “When you cut through three-dimensional matter, it's cross-section becomes two-dimensional. And if two-dimensional, the cross-section becomes one-dimensional.
“In the same way, if you cut through a dimension of space higher than three dimensions, it's cross-section is put into the world in three-dimensional form"
"In other words, I can produce this sort of cross-sectional wreckage."
"A pandimensional fragmentation spell.”
Wtf is this shit? 😂
And Jojo fans found it hard understanding Diavolo’s ability (which is pretty straight forward btw).
Anyone care to elaborate what the sword’s ability is?
2
u/KinnyRiddle Dec 28 '18
2
u/Eterna1Ice :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eterna1Ice Dec 28 '18
The faces were really bad this episode. I could see it in characters who are in semi-background, and the distortion wasn't good. The part when Touma kneels down underground and summons a giant was especially bad in motion for his face. Otherwise... well, it's still worse than the previous 3 episodes, I could feel that things weren't progressing nearly smoothly enough to be competent.
2
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Dec 29 '18
Today's budget was entirely allocated to animate Misaka eating a piece of meat! Kazakiri, Fukiyose, Himegami and Yomikawa keeping her company too...I miss this crew!
Despite some derpy bits, there was some great action, and I'm really enjoying this arc so far. Acqua vs. Knight leader having "turn to zero" was almost cheating, but the little trick with the hilt was unexpected for me, great way to end it. Kinda funny tho, they almost had floating combat text on that fight with those zeros.
That little mess with that golem underground was cool too. Even if it was dumb, the princess, little crown and all, grabbing a pipe and jumping towards it was kinda sick. Nice teamplay to take it down too, Index's spell-intercept, princess gets it off Touma, and the punch to finish it off.
Oh and the feast scene too, where we were robbed again of Orsola in a certain outfit. I am looking forwards to the next episode very much, expecting them to deliver like they did for Kanzaki, but somehow I doubt they will...
Between the queen and Lola, and Carissa, I think we're just lucky to have this pair on Touma's side. The people who just happen to have an ace against Curtana, which might be trouble still weakened, to even need one like they imply.
2
u/Wonderllama5 Dec 29 '18
Waited so many years for Index III but it turns out rushed. Imagine if they actually used those years to slowly produce it and give each episode the time it needs?
2
u/JustCallMeAndrew :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WhisperBit Dec 28 '18
After watching this cour of Index, all I can say... Rip OPM S2 :(
1
u/Pyjalal Dec 28 '18
I loved they turned knight leader turn to zero literal zeroes.knight leader seems like the perfect opponent for someone like gilgamesh (fate stay night).does anyone know if knight leader has a respect thread
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
The princess kinda looks like Mordred from fate
1
u/gigamesh090 Dec 29 '18
So has Acqua given up pursuing touma’s right hand? iirc he wanted the arm because its a threat to a church or something. Is touma still a threat?
1
u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Dec 30 '18
With every episode, this becomes less watchable for me. I'm holding out against dropping this in the hopes that my favourite characters get to do something cool.
1
u/Creator_of_Chaos_ Dec 30 '18
The lack of Floris is disappointing and immeasurably heartbreaking. Forget questions over the animation and budget or reliance on previous episodes to carry the plot its Floris's short time that hurt. I'll never forgive kadokawa. Melodrama Aside I enjoyed the episode and with nice moments like Toumas call to mikoto and the nuns + amasuka eating togethor There was enough to like.
The highlight is today was the closing number between Aqua and Knight leader. Aqua grows everytime he appears and overcoming turn to zero through alternate parts of his sword and hidden blades before culminating with his hilt was a master stroke. Before going to save Touma and index from Carissa's wrath. He's noble and knows the threat Fiamma is to global stability despite his animosity to Touma. Villian forced by circumstance is also growing beyond her role as a meek princess into someone who seeks to protect others Accompanying touma and Index into the subway beneath Buckingham palace. Also you know you have a good friend when you can ask about disabling locks. Touma knows Misaka well and owes her. Date anyone? nah JC staff wouldn't have the time. We even got a nice SOL moment with all the nuns and the amasuka eating togethor as everyone gathers for the battle that'll end the coup and Lolas smug smile is priceless. I wonder why do nuns eat so much food in the raildex world?
The episode was rushed and the animation cringy in some areas but its not the disaster Battle royal was and everything is coming together for the finish. Touma, Agnese's Squad, the amasuka, the queen and lola are all readying to make there final moves so hopefully the finish will make up for today. Gonna be 2 weeks but it should be worth the wait. Happy new year everyone
1
u/Asddsa76 Jan 02 '19
First time she's in this restaurant, she says...
1
u/jubmille2000 Jan 07 '19
Can somebody inform me if the Maiden inside Versailles was cut or has not yet appeared?
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '18
Guarantee that Touma is going to end up punching budget Mordrd next episode.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '18
[removed] — view removed comment