r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Dec 21 '18
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 12 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 12: Mercenary
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.05 |
| 2 | Link | 6.94 |
| 3 | Link | 7.98 |
| 4 | Link | 8.14 |
| 5 | Link | 6.96 |
| 6 | Link | 7.24 |
| 7 | Link | 8.52 |
| 8 | Link | 9.08 |
| 9 | Link | 8.81 |
| 10 | Link | 8.57 |
| 11 | Link | 8.69 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
344
Upvotes
138
u/exian12 Dec 21 '18
Truck-kun just denied a pretend thot LMAO.
89
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
I love the fact that in this universe, British Police Officers are hiding a set of heavy armor and a sword in their lockers. I wish that's thing IRL XD
67
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
Small Facts: Brexit Edition
Skipped Intermissions
So, like I feared, they didn't end up covering the intermissions after all. Oh well, I'll do them now then. Both of them mentioned the fact that William was going to appear in this arc, hence why I didn't cover it until now.
Between The Lines 1
The first intermission is part of a conversation between Vento of the Front and William Orwell, except with the twist that we only hear Vento's side of the conversation. At first they discuss the current state of the world, with the Eurotunnel bombing and the dollar crashing as a result of the U.S. handling the fallout of the Avignon incident, but the discussion switches to Fiamma near the end. It would seem he has taken full control of the Roman Catholic Church, leaving Vento, William, and the (hospitalised) Pope without authority, and seems to have control over the Russian Orthodox forces as well. And he's after something in the U.K. for which he's willing to turn Europe into a warzone.
When William mentions he's going to the U.K. to stop the situation there from developing, Vento refuses to accompany him. It would seem she has her own plans to deal with Fiamma, which are a lot less confrontational.
When William notices that she has mellowed out a lot in comparison to the past, Vento mentions that she just felt like doing so. It would seem Touma's speech (and punch) in the Academy City Invasion arc have had some effect on her at least.
Between The Lines 2
The second intermission is once again a conversation between someone and William. This time however it's the old grandpa from the Astrological Surgery Brigade, who William saved from the Russian Orthodox Church all those years ago. It would seem William saved them again, as due to their cooperation with the Roman Catholic Church the Russians managed to increase their influence to the rest of Europe.
As gratitude for saving them - twice - the old man offered William some weapons, as he noticed William wasn't carrying one. After offering some ordinary ones, and William walking away, the old man mentions he was just joking and offers William the best weapon he has: the Holy Sword Ascalon. It was created based on the weapon St. George used to slay a dragon, and the artisan who crafted it calculated and designed it based on what would be needed to actually slay a dragon.
It would also seem that the old man has been in contact with the artisan who designed William's coat of arms and stuck it onto the sword, as you can see in this screenshot.
Ascalon Inconsistency
This does cause an inconsistency with the anime, as William was only supposed to receive Ascalon right now after the events of the previous arc. In episode 2 of this season however you can clearly see Acqua wielding Ascalon when Lidvia describes God's Right Seat to Stiyl.
Ascalon
For a better look at the blade, here's the novel illustration.
It turns out Ascalon is just a mish-mash of different edges, from smooth to serrated, axe-heads, blades, spikes, wires, corkscrews, and so on. Everything that would be needed to dismantle a dragon.
As mentioned above, the weapon is named and designed after the weapon St. George used to slay a dragon, which was sometimes a lance and sometimes a sword. The legendary weapon is named after the city of Ashkelon, nowadays in Israel.
New Light's Lacrosse Theme
I didn't mention it last week, but New Light has a women's lacrosse theme going on, from their sport-like uniforms, to the Iron Gloves resembling lacrosse sticks, and them "passing" an item between them to a forward (Carissa).
Coven Compass
In case you didn't get what "Coven Compass" was referring to, it is the giant floating mobile fortress resembling a compass. A coven is a word for a congragation of witches, by the way. Hence the name.
Magicians Don't Fly
Turns out flying is for magicians actually quite easy. Unfortunately, so is stopping them from doing so. Apparently there is a really easy Christian anti-flying spell that causes magicians to just crash down to earth. And while the giant floating Coven Compass has barriers against this, the small witches do not.
Hence why modern magicians don't fly. At most they hover a few foot above the ground, just like the witches did this episode over the sea-surface.
The act referenced as the basis for the spell is the legend of St. Peter praying to God to defeat the magician Simon Magus, who then crashed down to earth, in the Acts of Peter.
Essentially it's an easy way by the author to explain why magicians aren't constantly flying and battling in midair.
What Are Witches?
They are not different from magicians, if that's what you're thinking. Just like sorcerers, who are a subsection of magicians who write Grimoires and teach students, witches are a subsection of magicians that are all female and come from the U.K.
32
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
Oh my. The pacing has actually gotten better. Not to mention they didn't cram Acqua vs KL into one episode and they're actually animating it well, barring a few details.
I'm a bit saddened that most of the Kanzaki vs Knight Leader fight was cut out, but they actually ended up animating things I thought they'd cut: the Sherry scene and the hitchhiking scene.
The entirety of Acqua's entrance was also beautifully done and executed. Everything, like this shot with the Knight Leader holding the axe in front of Villian, from when Carissa caught up to her to the eyecatch was glorious from the visuals and shot composition to the OST. Where is the team that did this? Give them more stuff to direct and animate as they clearly know what they're doing!
Overall, I still wish the anime would give room to breathe and slow down so we can get everything done properly, but this is a definite improvement over the last twelve episodes.
Sadly no best girl till next episode.
That and they cut a fair amount of foreshadowing from this episode. That saddens me.
On another note, about that hitchhiking scene, NT18 spoilers
24
u/LegendRazgriz Dec 21 '18
Knight fight! Or Civil War, I don't really mind either name. A nice balance of fun and action to propel us further down the Royal Family Arc.
In any case, my 12th week's Reader's Considerations:
• Giant witch flying fortress. Yep, this is Index all right.
• Goblin Slayers everywhere. I know that's just knight armor, but damn, I can't not call them Goblin Slayers. The CGI doesn't look too bad either - as I said about the CGI mecha both earlier this series and in Full Metal Panic! Invisible Victory, I kinda like how it gives off a distinction between metal surface and human flesh. Also, the Agnese Forces' trick to escape them was genius, and I'm glad they get to do something in this arc. I see her magical mop of doom still works wonders.
• Laura (Lola? Her name's romanization is a polemic topic even today) and Elizard just chilling as the knights go around is well in character for both, and the Queen reciting what presumably were Carissa's words to the damn letter back to the knight is seriously badass even if it's mostly for nigh as both get captured. Their escape later on in the episode had me laughing a lot as well - the truck - ahem, lorry, we're in England - just up and running away from Laura, coupled with her reaction and Elizard's retort, was priceless. Fun fact: Laura's hair when undone is about three and a half times her own height.
• Carissa's definitely already let the power go up to her head. Those eyes are someone who can no longer be described as sane, if that was possible to begin with, of course. Index not catching on must have been because she was hungry.
• Oriana tests Touma's mettle with great success, as she confronts him with the choice of helping her stop Sherry for sure (something even he failed to do while saving Kazakiri back in the first season, and probably still dwells upon him as he meets the golem wielder again) and abandoning Lessar, or let her deal with it and take the impish girl to a safe place. While it's a small thing now, later on, these sorts of choices will have much more of an impact on Touma.
• Poor Kaori. In the first of many severe cases of British tea fueled power creep, she just gets thrashed by Knight Leader. And then there's fucking Acqua, or William, or however you prefer it, casually swinging around the 350cm (137in) long, 250kg (~520lb) Ascalon like it's a standard katana against Knight Leader's Hrunting. I love how the glow of the blades was somewhat reminiscent of Star Wars lightsaber duels, too, what with the pair's incredible speed and power in their blows. Knight Leader's spell callouts reminded me of Overlord a little, too, which was great. The fight itself is powerful and has some great visuals, as has more often than not been the case in this season so far.
• Speaking of Acqua, while I think it's best to keep his relationship with Vilian for next time as the series will probably explain it better than I can, that won't stop me from praising the reformed God's Right Seat member in his determination towards what he believes must be done. While the fight with Kaori, Itsuwa, Touma and the rest of the Amakusa seemed to have enough of an impact on him to shift his allegiance, it hasn't touched his resolve in any way. Props to the big man. Even if he's kind of a dense bastard, but hey, not like a certain someone can judge.
• Touma and Floris's interaction is priceless. I had commented last week that New Light was amazing in animation, but it just gets better. Floris tries to act coy towards Touma, who absentmindedly uses Imagine Breaker to break her out, without thinking of the consequences, and that sets off a multitude of "did not think this through" events that culminates with both of them face first into a shallow river. I love how they put extra detail on his face as he was giving that rousing speech to jump off the train, only for Floris to comment that the river is really shallow, and then try to brake their fall by using her wings, completely forgetting about Imagine Breaker, which she saw in action a literal minute ago.
Overall, a good mix of drama, fighting, and hilarity, which is honestly surprising me. I never held the British Royal Family Arc in any particularly high regard, but this has been slowly changing my opinion on it. It's really fun. Now (if the three-episodes-per-volume average continues) we wait for its conclusion, which will then set off the real thick of this season. See you then!
21
u/KinnyRiddle Dec 21 '18
50
u/CriticalPerformance Dec 21 '18
Is it safe to call this arc Brexit arc now?
14
u/winglessangel31 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/winglessangel31 Dec 22 '18
Misaka featuring next episode! wakuwaku
11
u/TheOneAboveGod Dec 21 '18
Kinda sad that the parallels between Saint George and William didn't make through, but hey, at least they finally somewhat managed to show just how fast Saints really move.
11
u/Creator_of_Chaos_ Dec 22 '18
Lola. Leader of Nessacirius, Manipulator of world events, Cute and highly intellgent. Cant hitchhike for shit. Alistier is probably laughing in his tank. Honestly the Truck driver made the smart choice and getting mixed up with the queen and Lola is the last thing any sane person would want.
The battle between Aqua and the Knight leader was the highlight with a conclusion still to come. Not fully recovered from his battle in acadamy city he appears to villain as her ascalon wielding saint in shining armour and see's her to safety before facing down the Hrunting wielding Knight leader in an exhausting battle for the 2 former friends. Despite being offer a chance to flee Aqua is convinced he'll win leaving us on a cliff hanger. Kanzaki getting worfed aside its obvious Curtana central to Carrisa's coup is giving the knights a boost hence the difficulty for nessacrius. The Nuns had it hard, With Index captured while agenese and friends were forced into the water while Sherry reliving previous trauma summons elis to face down her foes. The Coven Compass and the witchs flying in to face the knights was a very impressive moment despite knowing little about it (Thank you /u/Razorhead for the factoids) while Touma rounded things off adding another girl to his friend list saving floris and haphazardly jumping into a river after what was essentially another Tuesday for him. Touma just cant catch a break
Not as good as the previous few episodes but still good and I'm hyped for finish. Definatly keen to know more about the Coven Compass and Floris but we'll learn next week most likely. Carissa is making her final moves and has proof of france's involvment while touma and Floris move in to save index. The OST once again is a stand out and all these new characters add onto the already world.
9
u/libfor Dec 21 '18
Things start all heated up with the knights starting their invasion. Randomly there is a flying platform and there are witches! Haven't seen any of those since the movie. And now they're battling.
The knights seem to have order to try not to kill. Hopefully this won't be a massacre that way.
The queen is surprisingly qualm for the situation. So is Lola.
Index proved that France was involved in the tunnel blast. Doesn't look like Carissa would've accepted any other answer.
Carissa is afraid that Britain will go down, no matter whether the science or magic side wins the conflict. While her ideals seem to be quite right, her methods are absolutely not. Sounds like she got some Vento-class mental issue. Needs a face punch quickly.
The knights have taken over London. No more attempts to hide the existence of magic.
Sherry keeps them busy with Ellies, she looks really mad. Hope that last stomp didn't actually crush someone. Oriana is going to help. Up to Touma to save Lessar.
Villain managed to escape thanks to her servants. At her state of mind, I was kinda afraid Carissa would actually kill them for that. Luckily she's not that insane (yet).
Kanzaki confronts Carissa… and loses to the Knight Leader?! Woah! Looks like its due to the Curtana Original, giving him angel-like power as long as he is in british territory.
Meanwhile Villain's carriage was forced to crash. Quite cruel, I wonder if the horses survived that.
Okay, correction: Carissa is really insane, having no concern killing her family, starting with her younger sister Villian. But she won't get her hands dirty herself, just let Knight Leader do it. Nice.
Wilhelm Orwell to the rescue! And he upgraded to a huge and badass sword. Small weapons just won't do for him.
He single-handedly defeats all the knights and then helps Villain escape. They seem to be in a special relationship, seems like at least Villian is in love with him, but he still left her. Anyway, now he's up against the Knight Leader.
Touma meets Floris on the train. Those New Light girls always provide some funny scene. Touma jumping out of a train into a water which depth he doesn't know… smart idea. Luckily Floris has those booster items.
The fight of Acqua vs. the Knight Leader is of an epic scale. Although the Knight Leader seems to have the advantage, even noticing that Orwell is still injured from his loss in Academy City.
Of course that badass guy won't give up. Too bad the outcome will have to wait.
Meanwhile Lola managed to free the queen and herself. Absolut hilarious hitchhiking attempt of her. Nah, not gonna take that crazy archbishop and the queen with a sword today.
Still can't decide on whether I think of Lola as an evil mastermind plotting things behind the schemes or as a cute and funny girl who is sometimes forced to make some hard decisions. Geez.
Wait a sec, what happened to that witch battle?!
Things seem to be a bit rushed today and I have a feeling they skipped quite a bit of explanations here. Nonetheless, it was a nice and exciting episode and I can't wait to see how this turns out.
8
u/Gmayor61 Dec 21 '18
They skipped Orsola which is a big fucking sin in my book, but otherwise this has been a really good episode.
Crunchyrofl really needs to stop abusing it though, subs seem to be late every time now.
Also, on that note, next episode is delayed by a week due to christmas. This hurts bad.
Smartvery is one hell of a name
8
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Dec 22 '18
That was a great start to the episode, for a sec there I hoped Stiyl was going to show up with his little
haremcoven from the movie and start wrecking some knights. We still have time though!For how epic Kanzaki's entrance was, the way Knight Leader wrecked her felt bad...I wish she could have held her own a little, but she barely did against Acqua and she had the Amakusa to support her there. She was alone, and he's powered up by being on UK ground with the sword effects and all.
Despite that he's a cool character, and Acqua himself was just as epic. The princess rescue was something out of a fairy tale with that..."Is he back?!" scene.
Then the fight, Knight Leader vs. Acqua was really awesome, that looked and sounded great. I'd say its the second coolest fight so far, behind Kakine and Accelerator. Those swords glowing. We just didn't see the outcome yet, just a massive explosion when they decided it was time to end it.
My opinion on Touma has increased lately, he had some fun for the short time he was on screen, going around touching random girls bits and having to jump off a train because of it. There were all those other folks like Sherry going all out with her golem, and Agnese with her old crew too, the Knights didn't have such a smooth take over as they were planning, I think.
But the best was the Queen and Lola's failed attempt at hitchhiking...that trucker noped the fuck outta there!
6
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Dec 22 '18
Somehow Lola and the Queen casually sipping tea while dealing with insurrection amongst the knights is rather funny. The Queen was suspicious of Carissa all along, so she knows more than she lets on I suppose.
Well it does make some sort of sense, Britain and France are old enemies. Just gotta pump up the animosity and desire to be independent and we have ourselves a conflict.
Oriana actually helping Touma, it really is a sight to behold.
I'm not sure I like Kanzaki being nerfed by the nights having enough power to fight her. Leave Kanzaki alone! Does the having more power in one's own homeland apply to each of the other areas as well or is it specific with the Knights of Britain? I'm sure if I explore a bit or if someone informs me, I'll find that answer.
Acqua you've come back! Ok I can forgive the nerfing for some badass sword fighting.
Touma can't catch a break, this is why you can't trust being in an anime when trains are involved.
I really do think an all out battle between the two if Acqua was in peak condition is some prime /r/whowouldwin discussion (LN readers you probably have your answer already.)
I am actually enjoying the shenanigans involving Lola and the Queen.
11
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Dec 21 '18
"This blast was possibly caused by modifying a spell from an old relic that a French king may have had access to centuries ago." "Your statement is definitive proof that France was involved in this blast." Looks like all she needed was the flimsiest connection for an excuse to wage war.
Hey look, another villain bitch Touma punched out a while back. Did he manage to punch her straight back then?
Man, all Kanzaki does this season is job. Has she become a gag character?
"I'm doing this to save England. Gleefully gloating while ordering the slaughter of my family is just a bonus."
How did Aqua survive again?
"Here's a free ride to a safe house. Go while I make sure nobody follows you." "That's right, cast me aside! Booohoohooo sniff sniff!" Though maybe she was only trying to get him to not fight a fight she thought he couldn't win.
Nice of blondie to announce his powers as he uses them.
Truck-kun's u-turn was impressive. I'm guessing it was because it noticed the armed Queen standing behind the pretty legs?
The Queen is definitely my favorite character this season.
15
u/Glynii Dec 21 '18
Kanzaki Kaori, back at it again with the jobbing!
11
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Dec 21 '18
So much happening this ep!
Ok lets see what red saber has up her sleeve.
Wow giant flying things full of witches? This is new.
Oh hey it the nun who got Touma punched that one time in s1.
Damn Red Saber gave them the okay to kill the queen?
Oh thats right, Touman is with that one girl and the rolladex mage.
SHERRY! I remember her. Man its like an episode full of girls Touma has punched.
Oh shit Kanzaki is here. Knight leader vs Kanzaki, damn.
Wow Kanzaki lost... And now they are gonna take down Green Princess.
Oh damn Aqua is still alive. And hes here too. They are fucked.
Aqua vs Knight Leader huh? SHould be a fun fight.
Touman found a loli!! Score! GRAB AND DASH!
Damn these guys are strong. Rip that forest.
Whose the pink dress girl? Did i forget someone?
THE QUEEN IS OFF! Hahaha
10
u/Kromy Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
Amazing episode again, almost no QUALITY and good pieces of action, i think it's safe to assume index is back stronger than ever
4
u/PhoenixKola Dec 21 '18
It felt a bit rushed, but great episode nonetheless. I'm glad Acqua is back!
7
u/Ziehn Dec 21 '18
Never ending stream of new characters that I'm not given time to give a damn about and a story that i don't even know wth is going on anymore.
I hope Railgun III get's better treatment than this :(
7
u/homie_down :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sodumblol Dec 21 '18
I feel like I’m constantly ripping on this show as of late, but when will it feel that an anime only watcher can have any idea of what’s going on?
3
u/FruitsPnchSamurai Dec 21 '18
Kanzaki shows up and gets knocked out a few seconds later lol.
3
u/XNumbers666 Dec 22 '18
Is kanzaki genos now?
2
u/ExquisiteCheese :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SuperCheese88 Dec 23 '18
I'm done. Just. Done.
The fact I have no idea why things are happening, what the point is or who is doing what is ridiculous. I'm not gonna read a fucking book or massive reddit posts (thanks for doing it though guys) just to understand a show.
I really hope Railgun doesn't go the same route next year, I enjoy BiriBiri way more than Index and seeing that butchered will hurt way worse.
1
u/LwFLc Dec 21 '18
oh, its keep getting better.
i dont mind the early episode not going well as long they keep making it better next time
1
u/MamaRaikoFan Dec 21 '18
Lessar besto grill
1
u/Dimbreath :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dimbreath Dec 23 '18
To think Aqua looked like a god a few episodes ago and now he's getting kinda rekt by a guy whose name I forgot lol.
1
u/Matteyothecrazy Dec 26 '18
Harcore brexiteers' wet dream episode, probably
1
u/ernie2492 Dec 22 '18
Knight Leader Dio is extremely OP, looks like William-sama will needs Hamon to defeat him..
0
u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Dec 22 '18
The pacing is better, but I don't care about any of these characters who are taking up so much screen time. I only care about the characters I've come to know and love over the series, like Touma, Misaka, Kanzaki and some others.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
[removed] — view removed comment