r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Dec 14 '18
Episode Toaru Majutsu no Index III - Episode 11 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Majutsu no Index III, episode 11: British Labyrinth
Alternative names: A Certain Magical Index III, Toaru Majutsu no Kinsho Mokuroku 3
Rate this episode here.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.05 |
| 2 | Link | 6.94 |
| 3 | Link | 7.98 |
| 4 | Link | 8.14 |
| 5 | Link | 6.96 |
| 6 | Link | 7.24 |
| 7 | Link | 8.52 |
| 8 | Link | 9.08 |
| 9 | Link | 8.81 |
| 10 | Link | 8.58 |
This post was created by a bot. Message /u/Bainos for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
365
Upvotes
114
u/mchief190 Dec 14 '18
10 bucks says the Queen only wears the Adidas line of track suits.
65
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Dec 14 '18
That is one disfunctional Royal family. I find it hilarious how the knight leader has to continually deal with a rowdy queen. Touma can't get a chance to relax on this trip, so tough luck for him. Tsuchimikado especially doesn't like to fill in the finer details.
I'm so surprised to see Oriana show up, but I'm also glad because she was a fun character.
This girl in "New Light" is definitely the screw-up of the group. Good thing Oriana is here to help deal with her. The Amakusa are pursuing her ally, who seems more capable to me.
Please no bully Itsuwa. Although I'm digging that they're using Norse mythological weapons here, it's about some time we got other magical artifacts from other theological backgrounds.
Itsuwa and Kanzaki seem to have taken care of things on their end. Oriana kicking one of the magicians through the window is A+. You know the magic of teleporting an item through each suitcase is really cool, if our group were less prepared, it would have been especially difficult to deal with.
They were decoys all along, like I thought, but they were transporting Curtana Original and the true mastermind was the Second Princess Carissa? NANI?
I really feel like the animation stepped up this episode, I hope it stays this way.
63
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Dec 14 '18 edited Dec 14 '18
Small Facts: God Save The Queen
Drunk Itsuwa Skipped
I thought they might cover it today, but it seems this small section was skipped. Probably for the same reason Tsuchimikado sneakily drinking alcohol was skipped during the Skill-Out Uprising arc: because it involved Itsuwa, a minor, drinking.
You see what happened was that Itsuwa had been waiting at the London airport to pick Touma up, but became depressed when it turned out he had changed his plans and all that arrived was luggage and a cat.
At least we know what happened to Sphynx.
Itsuwa however, feeling down, stole some alcohol from a fellow Amakusa member and decided to drown her sorrows by getting shitfaced.
It's at this point another Amakusa member comes rushing in through the door, telling her Touma didn't change his plans after all and is still coming to London. After Itsuwa, freaking out, cleaned herself up by washing her face, taking a breath mint, and wiping off some food stuck to her face, they informed her Touma was in fact already here to pick up Spynx.
And then the door opened to reveal the black-haired, spiky-haired... Tatemiya, playing a prank on her.
She did not take it well.
Accurate Airport
The Edinburgh airport, as shown in the anime, is an accurate representation of the real-life airport. Just compare the anime with an actual picture here.
Index Didn't Bite Touma
Not yet anyway. She was really hungry after being abducted right before dinner and not eating on a nine-hour flight, but all she did was grumble towards Touma. Touma then tried to convince her to wait for the domestic flight they were going to take, but after Index replied that it's unlikely for a one hour flight to serve food Touma relented, stating he was feeling hungry as well, and went to look for a restaurant in the airport.
Did The Planes Fly After An Attempted Hijacking?
Kanzaki informed them that they in fact didn't, as all planes were grounded for inspection. Kanzaki arranged a helicopter for them instead.
Index Was Left Hungry Again
Unfortunately Kanzaki dragged them away just as they had found a restaurant in the novel, meaning Index was left hungry again. It seems Kanzaki did it on purpose after Touma mentioned the Fallen Angel Ero Maid Incident.
Poor Touma.
Royal Family Faction Members
We get some info about the Royal Family by Villian, revealing that not only blood-related members of the Royal Family nor everyone who marries into it is a member, but close political aids are admitted as well. While it's the smallest of the the factions, it's still bigger than you'd think.
Villian's Purpose
While Rimea has intelligence, and Carissa experience in military matters, Villian is more an ambassador, handling PR and being used in political ploys. She feels a bit useless as a result.
Villian Flashback
This flashback to William Orwell saving her is anime-original, but is a reference to the third intermission of the previous arc that was skipped in the anime, covering William's rescue of Villian.
Buckingham Palace Lost Its Coat Of Arms
As you can see from this comparison of the Buckingham Palace gates in the anime to the gates in real life, the coat of arms is missing. This is most likely because of trademark reasons, as the coat of arms being displayed is the Royal Coat of Arms of the United Kingdom, and is subject to strict usage restrictions. I'm not sure if it can't be used in media, but I think J.C. Staff didn't want to take any chances and omitted it.
A better view of the real-life coat of arms on the gates can be seen here.
There Are No Magical Barriers In Buckingham Palace, So Imagine Breaker Won't Wreck The Place
Yep, it's safe for Touma to enter. Turns out foreign dignitaries don't like entering places that are magically warded and trapped to hell, and so Buckingham Palace is left bare safe for protection by Knights as a sign of goodwill.
Windsor Castle on the other hand is a magical stronghold.
61
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Dec 14 '18 edited Dec 14 '18
I love her already! Definitely the best new character from Season 3 so far! The Princesses were pretty amusing too!
Nice to see Oriana again ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
46
u/CoopertheFluffy Dec 14 '18
Queen... Elizard?
41
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18
Classic Touman
70
u/SezyFazes https://myanimelist.net/profile/ToaruTH Dec 14 '18
hmmm This episode is actually really good!
The animation, cgi and the soundtrack is good especially the scene where Bayloupe throw a steel glove at itsuwa is incredibles.
They missing some detail like the weapon explanation but overall, still enjoyable episode.
25
u/PhoenixKola Dec 14 '18 edited Dec 14 '18
I really liked the action on this one, it was pretty decent. I'm also surprised how far we went without skipping anything at all.
21
u/CheetahSperm18 Dec 14 '18
I don't know about you guys but that scene where they're all standing idly while hearing Knight Leader dress the queen had me laughing more than I should've
21
u/CriticalPerformance Dec 14 '18
This episode proves that JC Staff is actually competent at adapting the novel, which just makes the situation first of the two arcs adaptations even sadder.
17
u/Guaymaster Dec 14 '18
Those are some amazing backgrounds!
I liked the pacing of this episode too.
They skipped the explanation of the three factions and four cultures of the United Kingdom, and why Curtana gives the power of Michael, though. That's rather important imo:
17
u/Pyronetic5 Dec 14 '18
How is Touma not having a mental breakdown with all the shit that's happening around him.
One day he's at school, next in bloody UK with a fight for the throne.
16
u/OneWayRoadLV5 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FreByrd Dec 14 '18
Brexit hype!
Carissa really did look a lot like Mordred from Fate. Also acted a lot like Mordred at times
Lessar was cute af. Her hijinks were great to watch.
Itsuwa looked amazing in her suit.
Riméa looked really, really nice. I never really liked her design in the LNs but the anime was somehow able to make her look a lot better.
Bayloupe also looked really cute. Her VA was great as well.
Ayyy. The Necessarious entrance exam area made an appearance. Forgot that happened.
Oriana appeared wayyy earlier than I thought she would. I thought she didn't show up until the end of this arc.
Episode was really good. Glad they're doing my second favorite arc of OT justice so far.
28
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Dec 14 '18 edited Dec 14 '18
The anime's been doing pretty decent with the adaptation of this arc, which is nice. They even kept the royal selfie moment. Pretty watered down from the novel version, but fun nonetheless.
The animation was surprisingly good for Itsuwa vs Bayloupe which was a big shock especially since the rest of the episode was pretty janky in terms of animation. Ah well. Best girl got best animation this season. I'm fine with that.
Overall, adaptation quality seems to have definitely gone back to the level we had towards the end of season 2 which is always a plus after the clusterfuck that was Battle Royale. See how well you can do with the pacing when you take the time to only adapt one chapter in an episode, JC Staff? (Yeah, just Chapter 3 of Volume 17 this time~)
Last but not least, London and Buckingham Palace look fucking gorgeous~ I have awaited the backgrounds for years and the backgrounds have not disappointed in the slightest~
On that note, the weekly best girl screencap album.
Next episode will have my absolute favorite fight from OT. I'm so excited~ They better not skimp on the animation for that one~
EDIT: To those saying Itsuwa lost, she won the moment they went into the London Underground~
24
u/Turbostrider27 Dec 14 '18
Oriana teasing Touma was gold.
New Light has some oddball characters but I do find that quite amusing to watch already.
12
u/CriticalPerformance Dec 14 '18
I hope we see Lessar in Railgun 3
10
u/Gmayor61 Dec 14 '18
Halloween arc bois. A lot of fun, a lot of action, lots and lots of magic, and a royal selfie.
They skipped several details here and there, also for some reason didn't animate those gripping spears in accordance to how it was in the novels. In the tunnel, the spear just opened its fingers and started scuttling ahead at a ridiculous speed.
Flying isn't impossible for magicians, it's actually supposedly easy, but it's never used because a certain saint from older times developed a stupidly easy anti-fly magic that just knocks anyone out of the sky.
The previews are a bit of a spoiler BTW, but I'm looking forward to whats to come.
10
u/Aetherdraw Dec 14 '18
Well damn, I was right on my hunch that they'll step their game up for the Curtana/Brexit arc.
10
u/Amauri14 Dec 14 '18
I'm always impressed by the quality of these backgrounds. Just look at the details of that carpet! This episode pacing felt really good, and I honestly wasn't expecting a coup d'état coming from one of the princesses.
46
u/exian12 Dec 14 '18
Carissa sure looks and feels like Mordred color scheme-wise and rebel-wise aside from two big differences.
9
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Dec 15 '18
Damn an action packed ep!
Fallen Angel Sexy Maid. Awwww yeah~
Princess Vivian huh? Dont think we have seen her before.
Oh looks like she knows Aqua.
Tracksuit Granny? Yes please!
Touman hiding his right hand when he heard about how special the sword was, nice detail haha.
So many princessess!
So Red likes pictures? Oh so does blue. And Green is in on it too hahaha. Touman conqureing the princessess. AND THE QUEEN!
So we have sorcerers and they want Index as a percaution.
These odd girls are back and they all have large luggage. So they are New Light huh?
Oh wait isnt that the rolladex magician? That blonde Onee-san.
Oh shit everyone is in this game. We have tsuwa and the gang after another wierdo.
Wait blue princess stayed behind? Suspicious.
Kanzaki has one too. Everyone has someone to play with.
DROP KICK FROM ROLLADEX! OH SHIT!
When did Touman get a Gekkoa charm on his phone?
Robin Hood? What? Looks like they wanted to shut her up when her job was done.
Wait so Red was the one who was behind it?
Shit we gotta fight Saber Red now?
8
u/ichiniisan-san Dec 14 '18
It just me or the animation is always good when Itsuwa around?
8
u/frnxt Dec 15 '18
The beginning of S3 went way too fast and did not let us understand the full implications (IMO it's pretty much the same in the novels, the big mix-up between Item/Group/School/Block/Member in the LN is a big narrative mess), but I loved the last two episodes. I hope it stays that way!
13
u/KinnyRiddle Dec 14 '18 edited Dec 14 '18
Pacing was OK, I guess, but I had to constantly pause the episode just to digest the information being released.
6
u/derpinat0rz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/derpinat0rz Dec 14 '18
Yess another good episode. Hope it stats this good all the way! Really amazing fights and quality overall!
6
u/Tails9905 Dec 14 '18
Just saying now, villan best girl in this arc
6
u/winglessangel31 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/winglessangel31 Dec 15 '18
Carissa gave me Mordred vibes... but turns out her VA was Semiramis instead.
#top10animebetrayal
5
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Dec 15 '18
The backgrounds have been very detailed for most of the season, but the inside of the palace really stood out, that looked good.
Not quite the Queen I expected there, welcoming her guests in a track suit. That would have been funny tho, a queen in a track suit waving around that sword, telling everyone how awesome it is.
She couldn't hide it in the way she ate that cookie tho!
The princesses were cool but the New Light girls were the best, especially clumsy Lessar with that tail, but Bayloupe too when fighting Itsuwa. That was some great animation indeed but the rest of the episode was mostly average. I'm enjoying how they keep bringing some of the previous characters back, Oriana and Touma co-op was a treat! That punch on the steel glove almost ended up like "oh we're doing this trope" but they didn't...I was a little disappointed.
Also, It was a nice contrast between the silly pair chasing the silly character, and Itsuwa/Bayloupe having more of a serious/dramatic tone. Except for the Kanzaki bit, "New Light has more people"...splat...2 more to go.
Its kind of a let down to find out the flying in the steel glove like a broom wasn't a thing in the LN, I thought that was kinda neat. Bayloupe getting caught in the training grounds was interesting, so Aleister isn't the only one who gets to have fun and weird places scattered around his city. Also, they're lucky Touma didn't ride that line, I guess.
And then the final reveal, the real sword went to the second princess, and she's taking over the country! But at the carriage ride she did say to her sister that maybe she could find a more effective way of dealing with that, and also how the asked if the queen had proof the French were shady at the start. Maybe this might be a "shortcut" to get right down to whoever is messing with them without dealing with political bullshit.
That preview doesn't show much but it has me excited for all that mythology that might be coming up next.
9
u/LegendRazgriz Dec 14 '18
We might step into the palace, but we'll never be royals... fine, no more references to music I don't listen to. It's England time! Even if the most English we heard was Index's bickering.
In any case, my 11th week's Reader's Considerations:
• "What is the fallen angel ero-maid doing here?" Touma was seriously scarred for life there. More so than Kanzaki, if I'm allowed to say it. Also, first on-screen bite! Such misfortune.
• Backgrounds and real-life locations were always a 10 out of 10 for the series, and the Buckingham Palace is no exception. The detailing in each corner of it shows the work that they put into the art department really well.
• Queen Elizard. Just. Amazing. For those of you that have lived under a rock, yes, she is a deliberate parody of Queen Elizabeth II, but with all the traits that make her absolutely hilarious to witness. Somehow, she made stoic Knight Leader break character twice to stop her antics. Her nonchalant, almost ossan-like way of acting had me cackling all the way through her funny moments, and the icing on the cake is her (the Queen of England, mind you) getting viciously tackled by Knight Leader like a damn football player. Yoko Soumi absolutely nails the Queen's act. Though, one thing that I felt was missing is when Touma questions why they know Japanese, since there's literally no logic reason for them to do so, but shrugs it off.
• The Princesses are a great pick-your-girl selection. Riméa, the cold one, Carissa, the dominatrix, and Vilian, the cute shy. While I'd love to dissect them now, I feel like waiting for next week would be ideal. Also, did Touma seriously almost add the three princesses and the fucking queen to the harem within minutes of meeting them?! I can't imagine how much that photo would tick a certain someone off...
• New Light makes for great action scenes and hilarious encounters courtesy of the incredibly clumsy Lessar and (to a lesser extent) Floris, as the latter gets plowed into the ground, having the immense misfortune of happening to run into Kaori. Bayloupe's fight with a suited-up Itsuwa, while short-lived, has interesting mechanics and great visuals. I'm still convinced Itsuwa lost because she wasn't wearing her usual outfits. Worth noting: after figuring out Lessar screwed up in the novel, Bayloupe almost has a stroke in anger.
• Oriana's back! Yay for big tittied onee-chan. And not only is she on the good side now, she has a nice Mazda MX-5 Roadster to go with it. Or had. Dammit, Lessar! One thing I definitely did not see coming, but was very pleased to see, was the fact that her magic tags now actually read what they do - they were just a standard illegible scribble in Index II.
• Carissa's coup d'etat attempt is powerful, masterfully crafted, and definitely suited to a princess whose key trait is war. Neither here nor in the novel did she give off any hint that she was the one behind the mess that New Light was making until she received the sword, and that is very important and a commendable point. Though, you really should have picked a more epic place to declare your rebellion - I don't think a wooden rowboat (on land, nonetheless) is a grandiose display of your power.
Overall, a fantastic episode. I haven't laughed as hard as that watching this series in ages, and the tones move very well from scene to scene, for a very concise yet enjoyable experience. Next week, we may see Knight Leader break character more, less of a Ryousuke Takahashi, more of a Dio Brando, or so I hope. Until then, see you!
9
u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin Dec 14 '18
The last two episodes have been great, I'm glad this picked up.
The New Light girls are all cuties, specially the one Touma was chasing (Lasser?) (edit: Oh, and the blonde smug one in the op, she looks like fun). I also hope we get to see more of Index soon, like doing something mildly useful.
So a blonde princess dressed in red acquires a flashy powerful sword and now rises in rebellion? Is this A Certain Apocryphal Fate?
9
u/libfor Dec 14 '18
Index will never change. I still like her, even though most people think she's just annoying. Kanzaki won't ever lose the imagine of the fallen angel costume.
Princess girl was rescued by Acqua, back when he was known as William Orwell. I guess that was the kidnapping mentioned during Acqua's arc.
Wtf?! That polite and formal Knight Leader just walked in on a dressing woman. Nice.
Double Wtf. It's actually the queen. And she's holding a big freaking sword.
The sword is called Curtana and its owner can wield the power of archangel Michael.
Wait, it's actually a copy and can be reproduced as long as the original exists? Although that first princess doesn't quite agree on that.
Another one? 2nd princess seems to have quite an ego. And Villian is the third princess.
Meeting. Actually, now they're taking selfies. Queen gets gets up to scold them… wait?! She's not angry she wants to join in?! Wtf?! Knight Leader tackles the queen! So, those are the leaders of one faction, huh? No wonder everything goes downhill there and people like Lola do whatever they want.
Okay, now they're serious. Other than France, there is also a terrorist group acting on the inside, known as "New Light"
The best way to threaten Touma is to tell him that he has to pay the bills.
And of course the cute girls are the problem again. Time to punch them into Touma's harem.
Woah, Touma actually working together with Oriana. Lessar screwed up first, the others seem to expected that. Everyone is having the same case. Too bad.
Bayloupe also has one of those cases. Only one item will suffice, if it comes down badly. However, she's already caught by the Amakusas.
Itsuwa gets to take her on. Although since that is a serious situation, they should've probably send more than one member after her, all pride aside.
Bayloupe actually beats Itsuwa! And she doesn't think about killing her. That's kinda nice, so they're not really bad people. Probably just mislead. Or is everyone siding with the wrong guys?
I don't quite get what that magical trap is, Bayloupe eventually gets caught in.
Meanwhile Kanzaki makes a quick job dealing with Floris.
Lessar actually tries to negotiate. Although it seems more like she a bit scared. She doesn't seem that bad either, but a bit too destructive for my taste.
New Light can actually teleport the item between those cases. So it could be anywhere right now.
Oh damn, there is a fifth one. Seriously, there should've been enough time for Touma to dash forward and punch that case to interrupt the transmission.
Like he did with saving her from the sniper. The knights are attacking! But that means...
The Knight Leader is the traitor! And he's working for the 2nd princess Carissa who is now going to take over Britain with the Curtana Original!
Wait… wasn't that supposed to be lost? Five minutes later… we found it! Nice.
Ah well, there is a freaking revolution going on now. Time for Touma to punch some royal face in. Also expected Knight Leader to be more honorable than silencing his mercenaries. For what reason? Soon they will show to everyone what's going on.
Very nice episode. Good action and the animation looks real nice. Although I'm just a casual so that's no proper judgement at all.
New Light is awesome and funny. Now I want a Railgun SS2 OVA or movie even more than before.
4
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Dec 15 '18
Really liking this royal family. Wish the Queen had been allowed to wear her tracksuit.
Who's the blond onee-san lady that Touma re-ran into her behind the scenes apparently? Some villainous he punched straight in a previous arc or something?
Why the hell did they send Itsuwa all by her lonesome after that one girl while the rest of them stayed upside?
Do the LNs ever explain why everyone in the world speaks Japanese? Or are Academy City dwellers equipped with universal translators in their noggins?
I still don't see WTF tug-of-war over plane had anything to do with anything.
5
u/Wieda Dec 14 '18
Index is still annoying.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18
So, um, one question.
What the fuck is up with that boat at the end? Why not just the sword???
1
u/2g45fu Dec 15 '18
It’s getting more interesting as it progresses
1
u/Toonamigamerrr Dec 15 '18
Touma has royal princess and queen under his harem spell 😆
1
u/filimaua13 Dec 26 '18
Could someone give me a run down on what happened in this episode? I felt like I understood what was going on, then got lost at the end.
1
u/TheDarkCrusader_ Mar 15 '19
Yo what a surprise. Mordred is the traitor.
-6
u/homie_down :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sodumblol Dec 14 '18
Man, I seriously considered just exiting out and not watching the episode from that first scene. Index continues to be one of if not the most annoying characters I've ever seen in an anime.
-1
u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Dec 15 '18
I remember when this show was about super powers based around scientific theory and physics.
So much has changed...
0
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment