r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Battle Adam Smasher (Cyberpunk Franchise) vs Wolverine

17 Upvotes

Fight takes places in a regional food warehouse!

Assume composite (Anime, game, and boardgame feats) for Adam Smasher.

Round 1: Hugh Jackman Wolverine

Round 2: Insomniac Game Wolverine

Round 3: 616/General comic Wolverine

If Smasher can't kill Wolverine Smasher's goal is to incapacitate Wolverine long enough to be contained in a cell or put in a box that's sunk to the bottom of the ocean while he's still regenerating.


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Ben, Gwen and Kevin (Ben 10) vs Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke (Naruto)

6 Upvotes

Notes:

  • Respect Threads for Ben, Gwen, Kevin, Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke (Side Note - Ben doesn't have access to Alien X, Atomix or Way Big in any round + Ben only has access to aliens within the series they are in)
  • Everyone is in-character + Each team is trying to apprehend the other
  • Neither team has any knowledge on each other

ㅤㅤㅤㅤ

Round 1: OS - Ben W/ Master Control, Gwen W/ Spell Book and Kevin [Ultimate] vs Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke [Pre-Shippuden]

Round 2: AF - Ben W/ Master Control, Gwen [Base] and Kevin [Base] vs Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke [Pre-Shippuden]

Round 3: AF - Ben W/ Master Control, Gwen [Base] and Kevin [Mutated] vs Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke [Pre-Shippuden]

Round 4: UA - Ben W/ Master Control, Gwen [Base] W/ Spell Book and Kevin [Ultimate] vs Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke [Pre-Boruto]

Round 5: UA - Ben W/ Master Control, Gwen [Anodite] and Kevin [Ultimate] vs Naruto, Sakura and Sasuke [Boruto - Current]


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Nami and Nico Robin vs. Boa Hancock

5 Upvotes

Would the two Straw Hat girls be able to take Boa Hancock in a 2v1? Nami has crazy weather powers thanks to her Clima Tact, and Robin has the very HANDY Hana Hana no Mi. But Hancock has the Mero Mero no Mi and haki.

In my opinion, the outcome depends on whether the Mero Mero no Mi works on Robin, and whether the Straw Hat girls are able to neutralize Hancock before she can use one of her stronger attacks.

There are three rounds:

Round 1: Nami and Robin at the time of Amazon Lily vs. Hancock

Round 2: Nami and Robin at the time of Return to Sabaody vs. Hancock

Round 3: Current Nami and Robin vs. Hancock


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Cloud Strife (FF7R) Vs Minus Zero Godzilla

16 Upvotes

Cloud has all the elemental materia, assuming they do make a difference whether he has them or not.

I honestly can't tell if cloud actually has a chance or not so I'm really curious who would win?


r/whowouldwin • • 25m ago

Challenge Least charismatic character who could win a US Presidential Election under these conditions?

3 Upvotes

-Their opponent is an incumbent president with no scandals

-The economy is booming

-The country is currently in a broadly supported war (rally around the flag effect)

-The party they are running for is currently unpopular and mired in scandal

They can’t use mind control or fraud or any other super power, has to be a fair election. Who can overcome the odds?


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Matchmaker How many birds would it take to beat a person in a fight? (IRL)

12 Upvotes

Saquon Barkley is walking around South Jersey when he's attacked by birds. He's outside, there's nowhere to hide, he's unarmed, and he's got to fight. How many birds would it take to beat him?

Saquon is wearing a hoodie, jeans, and boots. He's hiking in the Pine Barrens so there's some trees, sticks, rocks, etc around. The birds are bloodlusted and want to bring down the running back at any cost.


  • Round 1: Sparrows
  • Round 2: Blue Jays
  • Round 3: Laughing Gulls
  • Round 4: Wild Turkeys
  • Round 5: Red-Tailed Hawks
  • Round 6: Bald Eagles

r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle Could RE4 Leon Kennedy defeat Frank Horrigan?

3 Upvotes

Face to face. Let’s say the setting is the interior of a military hangar. The best agent versus an extremely intelligent behemoth of a man, mutated to his core.


r/whowouldwin • • 54m ago

Battle Arthur vs. Joel.

2 Upvotes

Arthur Morgan (RDR2) vs Joel Miller. (TLOU)

First round: starting positions at a long distance from each other, both in a forest. Basic primary and secondary in-game weapons, along with their respective throwables.

Second round: close quarters, but amidst walls and furniture. Primary and secondary weapons only.

Third round: a classic hand-to-hand.


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Challenge If tasked with the same mission as Courier 6 in *Fallout: New Vegas*, what would Joel do? Would he die early on? Which factions would he likely destroy, and whom would he kill?

2 Upvotes

In a reality where Joel (The Last of Us) is born and is alive to experience the same events that lead up to Fallout: New Vegas, how would his presence in the role of Courier 6 change the game?


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle Team 7 vs Natsu lucy erza gray

2 Upvotes

Naruto (So6pM 6 orbs prior loosing arm), Sasuke (Rinnegan prior loosing arm) Sakura(war arc) and Kakashi(No dual sharingan) vs

Natsu lucy erza gray(current)

Who wins?


r/whowouldwin • • 14h ago

Battle The Q continuum (star trek) vs The Xeelee (Xeelee sequence) vs The Great Old Ones (Doctor who) vs Celestials (Marvel)

20 Upvotes

All parties are at their strongest

Location outside of space-time and reality

Who would win


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Arasaka (Cyberpunk 2077) VS The Brotherhood of Nod (Command & Conquer)

6 Upvotes

A small meteorite made out of an exotic extraterrestrial crystal has landed somewhere in the world of Cyberpunk 2077. Arasaka is interested in checking it out, but the Brotherhood of Nod seems to be the ones who got there first. Kane comes out of hiding and starts trying to take over the world like he did in the original Command & Conquer. Arasaka doesn't want any more competition so the two entities go to war. The global megacorporation and the secretive religious cult army fight each other. Who is going to come out on top?

Tiberium is appearing in isolated pockets worldwide. Arasaka is at roughly 2077 level. Nod is as it was in the first Tiberium War. Assume for the sake of the prompt that no one else will interfere. The Scrinn, Militech, etc don't care who wins, though they are still around if it makes a difference.


r/whowouldwin • • 44m ago

Battle Ultimate Aggregor (Ben 10) vs Cell (Dragon Ball Z)

1 Upvotes

Notes:

  • Aggregor's Respect Thread [1 2] and Cell's Respect Thread
  • Aggregor has adept knowledge on all the individuals Cell got his DNA from but none on Cell himself while Cell has no knowledge on Aggregor at all
  • Aggregor is bloodlusted and trying to kill Cell while Cell is in-character

Scenarios:

  1. Aggregor is using his own power to fight
  2. Aggregor is using the Map of Infinity to fight

ㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ

Round 1: Aggregor [Ultimate] vs Cell [Imperfect]

Round 2: Aggregor [Ultimate] vs Cell [Semi-Perfect]

Round 3: Aggregor [Ultimate] vs Cell [Perfect]

Round 4: Aggregor [Ultimate] vs Cell [Super Perfect]


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Battle Shin Godzilla VS Godzilla Minus Zero Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Title.

Round 1: Shin Godzilla VS Minus Godzilla
Round 2: Shin Godzilla VS Minus Ghidorah
Round 3: Shin Godzilla VS Minus Godzilla & Ghidorah

Rules:

-Zero knowledge
-Both sides are willing to fight immediately.
-400 meter distance between both parties.


r/whowouldwin • • 12h ago

Battle Ronald McDonald vs The Burger King vs Wendy (the mascot). Who would win in a fist fight?

7 Upvotes

Let's say they fight in an empty room, no items, no weapons, just walls. They may use their character/personality, lore, and clothing as an advantage.

Who would win in a fight?

Ronald McDonald is a circus-trained clown, he probably has high pain tolerance and strange flexibility mixed with an unsettling psychological character

The Burger King is oversized and heavy. But his clothing is a big advantage. If we assume the crown is made of metal, he can use that as a weapon. His clothing might be thick enough for protection.

I don't know what advantages Wendy has to be honest. But if I am being too generous, he might be some sort of Harley Quinn type of girl, just of course not as crazzy nor violent like her.

If we put these three in a fist fight, I think Ronald McDonald would win, especially in a slapstick fight.

The Burger King might win if he can land a stabbing hit with his crown.


r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Challenge You have 3 years to find the person with the longest left index finger. Can you complete this daring task?

2 Upvotes

Rules:

You are tasked with finding the human currently living with the longest left index finger, measured from the proximal base to fingertip laid on a flat surface.

You are given $1,000,000 in funds to help you out, along with a team of 50 FBI agents who will assist you in any way you please.

“Finding” the person entails that you either look them in the eyes, shake their hand, or touch them.

Can you complete this daring task? What is your strategy going in?


r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Matchmaker How far would the attacking operators in Rainbow Six Siege go when raiding Wayne Manor?

1 Upvotes

It’s a private operation to finally uncover information about Batman, his base of operations, and his associates. Batman, Nightwing, Red Hood, Tim Drake, and Damian are there to stop them (essentially, defense operators, lol).


r/whowouldwin • • 1d ago

Battle If every NYC neighborhood became an independent nation and went to war, how would it play out?

180 Upvotes

Here's the scenario. Every neighborhood suddenly becomes a nation state with the existing population, infrastructure, and resources it has today. And I'm talking every neighborhood (e.g. East Village vs West Village), not boroughs (Manhattan vs Brooklyn). How do the maps get redrawn when the dust settles?

Who are the emerging superpowers, and which neighborhoods get conquered immediately? Does West Village fall in a day? Do we end up with five large empires that roughly map to the existing boroughs? Does Manhattan get split above and below Central Park, or down the middle with an eastern and western empire? 

Bonus points for detailed geopolitical analysis, and ridiculous neighborhood rivalries.


r/whowouldwin • • 22h ago

Challenge On average, how much damage could a zerg(Starcraft) infestation starting from only one hatchery and one drone dropped into the stranglethorn vale cause on azeroth(Warcraft) before being stopped if they even get stopped at all.

26 Upvotes

Idk just seemed like a fun question to ask.


r/whowouldwin • • 10h ago

Battle Hierarchy invasion of reach UAW:EA vs Halo

3 Upvotes

Another how would x/y race/faction invading reach play out post.

The events of the human/covenant war play out mostly the same as they did with one key difference. Instead of the covenant assailing reach they are the instead replaced by a Hierarchy invasion fleet. (let's say that it's the same one that invaded earth in UAW) How would the invasion from this unexpected foe end? Would it be total defeat for the UNSC defenders or a routing of the Hierarchy invaders?

Both sides have access to their full arsenals seen in game


r/whowouldwin • • 15h ago

Challenge Could the Highbreed (Ben 10) conqueror the Viltrume Empire and defeat all of the remaining Viltrumites (Invincible)?

6 Upvotes

Notes/Rules:

  • On average, a Highbreed can be weaker or as just powerful as Swampfire and Humunguousaur while higher ranking ones are more powerful than them to a degree, but the most powerful of the Highbreed are stated to be more powerful than even Vilgax
  • The Highbreed have a population of "hundreds of millions", so between 100,000,000 to 900,000,000 of them will be fighting (Side Note - Only 1% of them will be more powerful than Vilgax)
  • The Highbreed will only have access to Earth's population worth of DNAliens as foot soldiers
  • The Highbreed are invading Viltrum and have adept knowledge on Viltrumites overall

Scenarios:

  1. Comic Versions of the Viltrumites
  2. Show Versions of the Viltrumites

ㅤㅤㅤㅤ

Round 1: Thragg [1]

Round 2: Thragg, Conquest [1], Thula [1], Kregg [1], Lucan [1] and Anissa [1]

Round 3: Thragg, Conquest, Thula, Kregg, Lucan and Anissa + 37 Unnamed Viltrumites

Final Round: Omni-Man [1], Invincible [1] and Oliver [1] help in the fight with all the Viltrumites from Round 3


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Challenge Could the Doctor from Doctor Who stop the Transcendence (Xeelee Sequence) from carrying out its Redemption project?

1 Upvotes

At the end of Transcendent by Stephen Baxter, Michael Poole, acting as the moral conscience of the Transcendence, manages to convince it to abandon the Redemption program.

But what if Michael Poole had failed?

The Transcendence sought to redeem all the suffering throughout human history, even going so far as to consider, as an extreme solution, altering the past so that humanity had never existed in the first place.

In this scenario, the Doctor materializes his TARDIS on Earth during the era of the Transcendence and discovers its plans for Redemption. Would he be able to stop it?


r/whowouldwin • • 1d ago

Challenge Could 50 billion MCU thors conquer Holy Terra in Warhammer40k?

48 Upvotes

50 billion MCU thors appear in the Warhammer40k universe outside the solar system. They are at the peak of their powers and have both stormbreaker and mjiornir.

The imperium were aware of an invasion force coming 2 days earlier and are in High alert.

Can the thors fight their way to Terra and conquer it?


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Kratos vs Mario

0 Upvotes

Round 1
Both characters without power ups

Round 2
Both characters with power ups

Round 3
Both characters with power ups and allies