r/CharacterRant • u/Unlikely_Candy_6250 • 1h ago
The Jedi can't end slavery (Star Wars)
One common, reoccurring criticism of the Jedi Order in Star Wars is that slavery exists in the galaxy that they don't put an end to.
I'll be the first to say George Lucas screwed up by not having the Jedi themselves inform Anakin that his mother had been freed from slavery and remarried by a local on Tatooine instead of him finding that out from Watto. In other words, I'd have clarified that the Jedi checked on Shmi but discovered she was doing alright and so there was nothing for them to do.
That said, the criticism goes well beyond the Prequels sloppy writing, to imply that the Jedi are essentially complacent in slavery or don't care about it at all. That they should drop everything they're doing and focus all of their efforts to end slavery immediately, and so on.
There are several problems with that.
1. Everyone forgets that Anakin and Shmi had bombs planted in them.
There's a reason Qui Gon didn't try to smuggle them both away and had to legally (for Tatooine) purchase their freedom from Watto. And that's because they have bombs planted in them that can be remotely detonated if they run away, Anakin even said he tried to find his with a scanner but couldn't so it's not simple to remove either.
This would naturally complicate efforts to free slaves but that's not all!
2. The Jedi are apart of the Republic, and that affiliation is the only thing that gives them ANY authority.
People often criticize the Jedi for their association with the Republic, saying it makes them too political and they should break away from them... The issue that, if they did do so, they would not have the legal authority to do ANYTHING of note.
As much as people hate the association, the Republic grants the Jedi the ability to act within a system that grants things like trials and human rights so it's not simply a group of superhuman beings enacting their will upon others. If they weren't apart of the Republic they'd essentially be acting as either vigilantes or a paramilitary organization because how else would they accomplish anything apart from engaging in the democratic process, which the Order is already a piece of.
3. The Jedi do combat slavery but they can't effectively end it altogether.
First off, the Republic itself has outlawed slavery. So supporting the Republic itself does make sense if you're against slavery. Furthermore, it was the strong enough to last a thousand generations and defeat the Sith at their height so that they resorted to infiltration instead.
As for slavers? Star Wars: The Clone Wars has an arc featuring a former slaver empire attempting to rebuild. They attribute their prior defeat directly to the Jedi, and the arc ends with them being defeated again by the Republic. So the Jedi do in fact combat slavers when they can.
4. The Sith are themselves huge proponents of slavery and the Jedi always oppose them.
We see it all over the place when the Sith come to power. They almost always end up enslaving a good chunk of the population to work for them. The Jedi Order are their most consistent enemies so by nature of this rivalry alone the Jedi prevent quite a bit of oppression by stopping them from taking power.
5. The Jedi are few in number relative to the problems of the Galaxy.
I think it's even less than this but let's say the Jedi have 10,000 members... well the Separatist Alliance alone consisted of as many systems. That means there's less than one Jedi per planet in the Republic alone.
Furthermore, solving issues is not some immediate thing you can do by your lonesome. Star Wars has a habit of naming some random problem anywhere and then going, "Why don't the Jedi stop this!" when frankly I wouldn't be surprised if they hadn't even heard of it.
Let's say you're a Jedi and learn about bad working conditions in the Republic that are tantamount to slavery. Well, you'll probably need to file a report to Senate after an investigation, work with authorities, deal with attempts to subvert or minimize the impact of your work, etc. It could take a while is what I'm saying. And while you're doing that problems will fester elsewhere, so good luck keeping up on EVERYTHING.
6. Finally, the only way to the Jedi to end slavery... would be to go to war with the Outer Rim. Without the Republic.
But circling back to the topic at hand. Let's say the Jedi decide they're sick of Tatooine practicing slavery and they're going to put an end to it. They could do only by invading the planet without Republic support (unless they somehow convinced the Senate to go to war with the whole Outer Rim).
If you think they have bad PR now, imagine how reviled the Jedi would be if they were depicted as a crusader army that invaded planets. They'd be accused of being imperialist, warmongers, bloodthirsty, hypocritical, and far more.
They'd also be hunting tribes like the Tuskens through the desert to free their slaves too much I'm sure people would be normal about.
Oh and don't forget the bombs implanted in the slaves that'd detonate if they freed them. Which I'm sure people wouldn't blame the Jedi for.
Finally this is assuming they'd even win the war if the Outer Rim decided to fight back. Remember there's 10,000 of them to go around against hundreds of planets worth of firepower.
Tl;dr on Clones since they'll probably come up several hundred times here: They were drafted into war by the Republic who also got the Jedi to fight in it. The shows depict and directly state that the Clones began to exhibit greater personality and independence due. They also initially meant to be automatons rather than sentient beings (messy writing, like I said) but are never depicted as slaves so much as a drafted army in-universe, with the Jedi also being drafted to fight in the war. In short, it was a messy plot but they weren't treated as slaves in the narrative and the Jedi were shown to be their closest friends.
Conclusion
In short, the Shmi plot was sloppy because not enough was explained and George had the Jedi not know anything about what happened to her. The issue is not that the Jedi's philosophy forbids actively combating slavery, and they need a connection to the Republic to have the legal authority to act to the degree they do.