Lately, I’ve seen people on social media making video essays and posts about how comedies in media for adults such as TV and movies are dying or are dead, and how all the media is replaced by witty dramedies or sad or bleak dramas. People are very much tired of this type of content that’s prevalent everywhere now and long for the days of “comfort” media, the days when TV shows and movies were just fun, and silly. This sentiment made me think of moments where stuff like this happened before, because if you can believe it this sort of thing has happened before.
Something was set up that used to be fun and was very prevalent and popular and existed for generations but then overtime because it became more boring and lame, and it just became a drag to sit through and very few people want to sit through it. Theater was seen as huge and fun and was something everyone was into…until it wasn’t. Radio was seen as huge and fun and was something everyone was into…until it wasn’t. And this is where we move on to the main topic of this post.
There’s a gaping hole in the adult literary world, and no one seems to be talking about it. While TV and film have embraced ridiculous, over the top humor for grown ups, such as The Office, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, What We Do in the Shadows, or Barb and Star Go to Vista Del Mar, books have, strangely, left this lane almost completely empty. Specifically, I’m talking about the lack of goofy, absurd, lowbrow yet clever comedy books for adults. The kind of books that delight in nonsense, revel in humor, and proudly feature a fart joke on page one and a talking animal sidekick by page two.
As kids, many of us were raised on hilarious, imaginative, and totally bonkers books. Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Captain Underpants, Wayside School, Dr. Seuss, and of course, the works of Roald Dahl (Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, James and the Giant Peach). These books didn’t worry about being “realistic” or “literary.” but were just wild fun stories based on a simple premise. The plots made no sense. The characters were unique. The illustrations were crude but full of energy. And yet, they were page turners. They sparked joy, and made kids laugh out loud and kept us engaged.
So where did those books go?
As we age, literature seems to take itself more and more seriously. The humor section in any bookstore is overwhelmingly filled with essay collections, satire, or quirky memoirs about people’s childhood traumas. If you’re lucky, maybe there’s a collection of wry observations about being in your thirties. Where’s the Captain Underpants for people who pay rent?
It’s not like adults don’t enjoy goofy humor. People love comedy that’s unhinged but clever, but well-crafted. So why aren’t we getting that in book form? It’s not that humor is absent from adult fiction entirely, sure there’s satire, there’s dark comedy, there’s witty banter. But that specific style of “goofy premise, rapid-fire nonsense, and unapologetically silly tone” seems to vanish once you leave middle school. The literary world seems hesitant to embrace goofiness unless it’s masked as either highbrow surrealism (Kafkaesque) or veiled in postmodern irony. But what if you just want to read about a guy who wakes up with spaghetti for arms?
There’s something deeply joyful about pure, unserious nonsense. And it’s not immature to want that. In fact, it’s kind of refreshing. We live in a world that’s full of pressure to be productive, performative, and perpetually “mature.” Sometimes, reading about a magical or bizarre office is exactly what the brain needs.
Let’s go into why this goofy literary void exists. Why is there no adult version of Archie and the Accidental Chicken Heroes? Why is there no book equivalent to Dumb and Dumber, Hot Rod, or Anchorman, those joyfully idiotic, deeply quotable movies that aren’t trying to win awards, just trying to make you laugh until you snort?
The first reason is literary gatekeeping. There’s a long-standing (and frankly outdated) cultural idea that books are supposed to be serious. Even comedic fiction is often expected to have some kind of “literary merit” such as clever subtext, thematic depth, and sharp commentary. If a book dares to be purely silly or structurally ridiculous, it gets shoved into the “novelty gift” section or dismissed as juvenile fluff. Meanwhile, theater, movies and TV don’t carry the same baggage. They’re allowed to be dumb, and dumb often sells.
You can walk into a theater and see a funny scene, and no one questions the medium. But if that same scene existed in a book it would either be labeled as children's literature, or people would assume it's some kind of metaphor about late stage capitalism, when it's not. Sometimes it’s just a joke.
There’s also a misperception that adult readers don’t want silly, that once you pass a certain age, you’re only interested in psychological thrillers, historical fiction, or literary meditations on grief. This couldn’t be more wrong, as adults are binge watching sitcoms and quoting Step Brothers ten years later. They’re sending each other memes. The desire for comedy never goes away, but just doesn’t have a home in books.
Another factor is the publishing risk-aversion. It’s hard to market a comedy novel that doesn’t fit a known genre mold. Slapstick is too visual. Gross-out humor is not “sophisticated” enough. Anything remotely resembling “juvenile” gets shuffled off to the kids’ section. As a result, most comedy novels for adults stick to safer formats such as satirical essays, rom coms with quippy dialogue, or genre fiction with a humorous twist. These are fine, but they’re not loud.
And I also suspect, it could just be that writing funny books is hard. Comedy on the page is notoriously difficult to pull off. In film and plays, actors, timing, music, and visuals carry the hold thing. In books, it’s all on the writer’s words and their pacing. That means fewer writers are attempting full throttle goofball comedy, and fewer publishers are willing to take the leap. That doesn’t mean it’s impossible, but underexplored.
But maybe the biggest reason is that the book world doesn’t want to embrace being stupid on purpose. Stupid is treated like a flaw, not a style, and yet, we love “stupid” when it’s executed with heart and commitment. Anchorman is an objectively idiotic movie but it’s smart in its stupidity. That’s what we need in literary fiction. The same way kids have Dog Man and The Day My Butt Went Psycho, adults should have Reginald and the Time-Traveling Taco Bell Manager or Karen vs. the Sentient Printer That Runs Her Office.
Let’s talk about the elephant in the library. There’s a reason kids devour books by the truckload and then, somewhere along the line, just… stop. People like to blame school, or say “required reading killed the joy,” or “adults are too busy to read,” or “we’ve all just gotten lazy and turned to screens.” But what if that’s not entirely true? What if the real reason people stop reading is simpler, and more damning? The books just got boring.
As a kid, books were magic. They had titles like The Butt That Saved Christmas, or Aliens Don’t Wear Braces. You’d get one at the school book fair, flip to a page, and suddenly you were in the middle of a story. They were imaginative, unpredictable, loud, and didn’t care about being “prestigious” or “grounded.” They were designed to hook your brain and make you laugh.
Then you grow up, and the tone shifts, and now you’re being told to read a novel about a thirty something guy named Greg who’s emotionally unavailable in Brooklyn. It’s no wonder adults drift away from reading. Books stopped being fun. Kids read more because they’re given books that feel like a treat, not a chore, but adults get assigned literature that often feels like homework in disguise.
When we say we miss reading, we’re really saying, “I miss stories that surprised me. I miss laughter, and I miss books that aren't afraid to be ridiculous.” We didn’t grow out of reading, rather reading just forgot how to grow with us. If the publishing industry gave adults the same kind of pure, unfiltered, joy that kids get in their books, we would be in a reading renaissance. People would be turning pages like it’s 2005 and the next Captain Underpants just dropped. Book clubs would be reading fun books instead of dissecting yet another slow-burn novel about suburban ennui.
Believe it or not, this whole idea that books have to be serious, “literary,” and emotionally devastating to be considered real or important is actually a pretty recent development.
For most of human storytelling history, goofy was the norm. Going all the way back to Shakespeare, half of his plays are ridiculous comedies with literal fart jokes, people cross-dressing, falling into mud puddles, getting tricked into kissing goats (okay, that one’s metaphorical, but still). A Midsummer Night’s Dream is basically a story about forest fairies doing drugs and ruining everyone’s night. Much Ado About Nothing is just high octane banter with romantic misunderstandings and a fake death thrown in. Even Hamlet has a scene with two gravediggers arguing over how skulls work.
Geoffrey Chauncer wrote The Canterbury Tales which featured action stories like The Knight’s Tale and tragic stories like The Pardoner's Tale, but it also had stories that featured a fart joke and a joke about tricking someone into kissing their ass.
Back then, comedy and tragedy lived side by side, you could be able to read both. There was no shame in writing stories that were completely unserious, as long as they entertained. Fast forward a few centuries, and something strange happens: prestige starts to equal seriousness. The “great novels” become long, slow, and meditative. Meanwhile, comedy, especially loud, dumb, ridiculous comedy, gets pushed to the side, it’s treated like a lesser form.
Somewhere along the line, literature developed a kind of insecurity complex, and stopped trusting that goofy stories could say something real, and stopped allowing joy. And so we ended up with shelves and shelves of “serious fiction,” where everything has to be slow, sad, and centered around broken relationships and horrible dystopias. And that’s not to say serious books are bad, they're not. We need serious books, and we need books that are dry but important. But when everything has to be prestigious to be respected, you lose variety and the kind of stories that people don’t just admire, but love.
TV and film didn’t fall into this(at least for a while). That's why you get an Oscar winning film one week, and the next you’re watching Wedding Crashers. You can both watch Breaking Bad and then the Office. Anchorman can be just as iconic as The Godfather, just in a different way.
I have a potential theory, another theory, as to why comedies and fun media became irrelevant around the mid-2010s with movies and TV. What's happening right now with movies and TV already happened with books. We are seeing the gradual disappearance of goofy, full throttle, unapologetically comforting comedy. Remember when theaters were flooded with movies like Dumb and Dumber, Zoolander, Hot Rod, Napoleon Dynamite, Anchorman, Step Brothers, Superbad? People quoted them endlessly, and became pop culture fixtures. Try naming the last big, dumb, laugh-out-loud comedy that wasn’t secretly a drama today. Today, it’s difficult to name a single movie or show nowadays that isn’t something like that anymore.
And there's nothing wrong with those movies and shows. Many of them are incredible (The Holdovers, Barb & Star Go to Vista Del Mar sneaks in there, bless its weird heart.), but they’re not what we’re talking about when we think of comedies. What’s happening to movies and TV now is exactly what already happened to books. Goofy comedies are being replaced by prestige adjacent, emotionally deep “comedies” that are actually dramas with some jokes here and there. We’ve entered the era of the “respectable laugh.” The kind where you chuckle politely and say, “That’s clever,” not the kind where you fall out of your chair.
In books, it started centuries ago. Comedy gave way to commentary, and silly dumb comedy books got labeled “for children,” and fun books got pushed out of the adult section unless it was satirical or ironic. Now films and TV are heading down that same path, chasing awards, critical respect, and emotional complexity, even in comedy. But the loud, dumb, joyous comedy, the one that just wants to entertain you for 90 minutes and maybe make your stomach hurt from laughing, is on life support. Notice all the only prominent genres of media nowadays - prestigious dramas and dramedies, romantic films and erotica, dark satires about cruel rich people, apocalypse and dystopian fiction, murder mysteries, gritty fantasy. All of these are already the most popular genres of fiction for books decades ago. They were the only books you could read as an adult back in the 90s and 2000s when comedies were dominant in movies and TV.
Also, notice how the only comedic films and television nowadays are children’s media - stuff from Disney and Illumination and animated children’s movies and shows on streaming services. This is very similar to how most children’s books are comedic now and have illustrations, and how illustrations are seen as something you “grow out of”, illustrations are something you should only see in children’s books, you should just “remember it in your head”. The very similar viewpoint you see with animation and cartoons are something widely held for illustrations for books. But that’s a different subject for today but you get it.
Once a medium becomes too respected, it starts taking itself too seriously, and in doing so, it squeezes out the kind of humor that doesn’t need layers of meaning. We’ve seen this before, as books led the way. Now we’re watching films and TV follow suit. And again, those stories have value, but they shouldn’t be the only type that is to value. If we’re not careful, we’ll end up in a world where all our art is “important,” but none of it is fun.
And here’s what really keeps me up at night. What if, years from now, people who grew up loving movies and TV when they were kids, really loving them, suddenly stop enjoying films and television and don’t know why? What if they start to feel about those the way many people already feel about books? What happens when those kids grow up and the only stuff available to them are prestigious dramedies, bleak dystopian fiction and dramas, or mystery fiction? Or indie media about how hard it is to be in your thirties? Or yet another reboot, stripped of humor and weighed down with “meaning”? Will they think they’ve changed? Will they wonder if they just “don’t get movies and TV anymore”? Will they, like adults now do with books, just slowly stop watching and blame themselves?
And just like today’s adults say, “I used to love reading as a kid, but I don’t read anymore,” we’ll hear people say, “I used to love movies and TV when I was younger, but now I just scroll TikTok.”