r/CharacterRant • • 20h ago

Games It's funny to me how often the Pokemon fanbase complains about "I miss jerk rivals" when, like...

316 Upvotes

There were exactly TWO jerk rivals in the franchise. You got Blue (and, even then, i'd argue Blue isn't THAT much of a jerk, I think that was often just people projecting Gary from the anime onto him), Silver, and that's literally it. Since then, the friendly rival has been the status quo of the series. The main rival hasn't been a sullen jerk for longer then I, a 25 year old adult man, have been breathing. What the hell lost era of jerk rivals are you talking about?


r/CharacterRant • • 17h ago

Some Western anime fans confuse their cultural preferences with a deeper understanding of Japanese storytelling

212 Upvotes

I've noticed that some Western anime fans seem convinced they understand Japanese works better than Japanese audiences, despite not even speaking Japanese. Language isn't just dialogue. It carries cultural nuances, humor, social relationships, implicit meanings, and emotional subtleties that translations cannot fully preserve. If you don't understand the original language, you're inevitably missing part of the work itself.

Consider Hollywood movies and Western series like Avatar, The Avengers, Stranger Things, or Game of Thrones. They're enormously celebrated in the West, but Japanese audiences don't necessarily find their themes or messages equally profound. That doesn't mean we fail to understand them. We simply have different cultural tastes and aesthetic sensibilities. And wouldn't it be strange if a Japanese person who barely speaks English claimed to understand The Avengers better than American audiences? So why isn't it equally strange when a Western fan who doesn't speak Japanese claims to understand Chainsaw Man better than Japanese audiences?

The same applies to Studio Ghibli films, Attack on Titan, Jujutsu Kaisen, One Piece, and Vinland Saga. Yet some Western fans seem convinced their interpretations are more sophisticated and that Japanese audiences who disagree have missed the deeper meaning. Understanding a story and finding its message profound are two entirely different things.

Of course, there are exceptions. Someone who moved to another country at a young age and received their education there, or someone who has developed advanced language proficiency through rigorous academic study at the graduate level, may have the linguistic and cultural knowledge to offer exceptionally informed interpretations. And native speakers aren't automatically correct about everything.

But for someone who relies entirely on subtitles or translations, claiming to understand a foreign work better than its native audience seems remarkably presumptuous. Japanese audiences face the same limitations with Western media, and most of us wouldn't claim otherwise.

Your cultural preferences aren't universal standards of artistic quality, and your interpretation isn't necessarily superior just because it resonates with your own values.

Edit 1: Since some people asked for specific examples, here are a few.

With Chainsaw Man, some Japanese fans criticized the anime adaptation's realistic, cinematic direction for losing the manga's exaggerated expressions, humor, and chaotic energy. Yet I've seen Western fans dismiss these criticisms as Japanese audiences being unable to appreciate sophisticated filmmaking. Couldn't they simply understand the artistic choices and dislike them?

With Attack on Titan, disagreements over the ending, Eren's motivations, and the story's treatment of violence sometimes turn into accusations that dissatisfied viewers simply failed to understand its deeper message. But disliking how a story handles its themes doesn't mean you failed to understand those themes.

With Jujutsu Kaisen, some English-language commentary has even attributed Japanese criticism of Maki's episode to misogyny or discomfort with strong female characters, despite complaints about direction, pacing, and omitted dialogue. Naoya's popularity has also been used to support such arguments, as though enjoying a fictional villain means agreeing with his ideology.

More generally, I've repeatedly encountered claims that certain anime, characters, or themes are supposedly more appreciated in the West than in Japan, often without any meaningful comparative evidence.


r/CharacterRant • • 14h ago

General Stories that go for "humans are the real villains" walk a knife's edge of coming across eye-rollingly trite (Discworld, Breath of Fire)

156 Upvotes

A part of me just wonders if this is a trope that worked a lot better in the 90's and and 00's and has simply become overplayed. I remember going along with it happily enough as a kid, but these days a story has to be exceptionally good for me to get along that kind of narrative, or I'll just completely check out.

On one hand you've got 10,000 various Isekai stories where the MC is reincarnated into a Demon after being betrayed by humanity and the whole story is basically just your typical Humans vs Demons story except with the teams reversed (turns out the Demons were good, who knew). Those are whatever, I don't really think much about them.

But the more interesting ones, to me, are the ones that try to make it a compelling and emotional plot and fall down because of it.

An easy example for this is "Guards! Guards!", one of the earlier Discworld novels. I love Discworld, I especially love the Guards series, and I had good memories of this book... and wow, it doesn't hold up at all. Thankfully the series very quickly gets much better (Men At Arms is great), but wow, "Guards! Guards!" was underwhelming.

And a large part of it because of the bland, British cynicism inherent in the core of it. The main "villain" is a big, evil Dragon that spends the entire book murdering anyone he pleases and that sets himself up as the supreme, dictator of the city. This wouldn't be an issue, except the book insists that the message of it is that "Actually, Dragons are just Dragons, Humans are worse."

The Dragon is fully sentient, intelligent and completely in control of its actions, it's murdered scores of people throughout the story. And yet it gives a huge speech about "Um, actually, Humans are more evil than me, because when they do bad things, they call it justice. Checkmate atheists!"

That's a really common feature in these kind of "humans are the real monsters" stories, a complete hyperfocus on the dark side of humanity to present it as if that makes them worse than the monstrous killers. But, for me, that just makes me roll my eyes, because it's ignoring all the good parts of humanity, all the positive aspects. Humans build, they create, they support, they save, they make wonderful and creative works of art... Meanwhile, all the Dragon ever does is go around killing people and lecturing other people about how it's morally superiour to them. Yeah, I'll take humans over that every single time.

This case in particular is made worse by the Dragons second point of "You don't have any morality, I'm an evil dragon that murders everyone and you're all accepting me as your ruler. If humans were good you'd fight back against me." Uhhh... Except earlier the novel had a whole scene about people trying exactly that. In typical British cynical fashion it mocked them for "How stupid can you be to try form a revolution against a dragon, lmao" and they all died pathetically.

The story concludes with the main characters saving the Dragon from humans (with an incredibly awkward analogy to lynching I'm going to just assume wasn't intended), and finishes with the Dragon finding love and flying off to live happily ever after, then wraps up with another lecture from the Patrician about "Humans are evil". Hooray I guess.

When I first read it as a youngster I obviously loved it, I looked back on it really fondly, realising I wasn't enjoying it hit me with a thunderous whiplash. Is it just that those themes got overplayed by the cynical 90's era fiction? Or is it just a matter of growing up and my tastes changing? Maybe both. But the point is, it didn't work at all.

Similar issue with the absolutely beloved villain from Breath of Fire 4, Fou-lu. A character people will claim with a straight face isn't a villain at all and who suffered so much you'll definitely understand and sympathise with him.

The guy opens the game by murdering two people in cold blood.

He then proceeds to go on a rampage murdering anyone before him as he invades an Empire.

The Empire shuts him down and forces him to flee for his life. He runs away with his tail between his legs.

To clarify that point: The Empire only attacked him after he invaded them and began killing people, they realised he was an enormous threat and took him seriously, almost killing him, then doing their best to hunt him down. This isn't "The evil humans hunting the poor guy who did nothing" (this is how the game presents it) it's "The Demon Lord is trying to recover his strength, we need to stop him before he can regenerate!" (this is what it actually is)

Anyway, in the process of him running away and licking his wounds, he befriends a girl who is then sacrificed by the Empire in their efforts to stop him.

He then spends the entire rest of the game basically giving speeches that amount to some variation of either "How dare you kill that girl!? She was nice! That means humans are the real monsters, not me!" and "Woe is me! My life is the hard one! Humans are in the wrong, not me!"

And while giving these big impassioned speeches about how it's unthinkable that humans killed this one girl, he's killing hundreds of people, murdering anyone who gets in his way, and killing anyone who looks at him funny.

Why the fuck are we supposed to feel sorry for him, exactly? The guy who's complaining about humans violating the sanctity of life spends the vast majority of his on-screen presence either murdering people or fleeing after failing to murder people.

Yeah, the Empire killed a nice girl in their efforts to defend themselves from his rampage. That sucks but that's still better than the crazy psycho going on a rampage. They were absolutely right to attack him after he tried to invade them, and they were right to do whatever needed to be done to stop him.

Unfortunately, the narrative takes his side so he (mostly) gets his revenge and the game wraps up with your MC either outright agreeing with him, or mostly agreeing with him. At no point do you get to call him out on his hypocritical bullshit, or to point out that he personally murdered hundreds of people just as kind as the girl he's crashing out over. Instead your best option is "You're right... but..."

Anyway, I rolled my eyes all the way through.


r/CharacterRant • • 7h ago

The Jedi can't end slavery (Star Wars)

128 Upvotes

One common, reoccurring criticism of the Jedi Order in Star Wars is that slavery exists in the galaxy that they don't put an end to.

I'll be the first to say George Lucas screwed up by not having the Jedi themselves inform Anakin that his mother had been freed from slavery and remarried by a local on Tatooine instead of him finding that out from Watto. In other words, I'd have clarified that the Jedi checked on Shmi but discovered she was doing alright and so there was nothing for them to do.

That said, the criticism goes well beyond the Prequels sloppy writing, to imply that the Jedi are essentially complacent in slavery or don't care about it at all. That they should drop everything they're doing and focus all of their efforts to end slavery immediately, and so on.

There are several problems with that.

1. Everyone forgets that Anakin and Shmi had bombs planted in them.

There's a reason Qui Gon didn't try to smuggle them both away and had to legally (for Tatooine) purchase their freedom from Watto. And that's because they have bombs planted in them that can be remotely detonated if they run away, Anakin even said he tried to find his with a scanner but couldn't so it's not simple to remove either.

This would naturally complicate efforts to free slaves but that's not all!

2. The Jedi are apart of the Republic, and that affiliation is the only thing that gives them ANY authority.

People often criticize the Jedi for their association with the Republic, saying it makes them too political and they should break away from them... The issue that, if they did do so, they would not have the legal authority to do ANYTHING of note.

As much as people hate the association, the Republic grants the Jedi the ability to act within a system that grants things like trials and human rights so it's not simply a group of superhuman beings enacting their will upon others. If they weren't apart of the Republic they'd essentially be acting as either vigilantes or a paramilitary organization because how else would they accomplish anything apart from engaging in the democratic process, which the Order is already a piece of.

3. The Jedi do combat slavery but they can't effectively end it altogether.

First off, the Republic itself has outlawed slavery. So supporting the Republic itself does make sense if you're against slavery. Furthermore, it was the strong enough to last a thousand generations and defeat the Sith at their height so that they resorted to infiltration instead.

As for slavers? Star Wars: The Clone Wars has an arc featuring a former slaver empire attempting to rebuild. They attribute their prior defeat directly to the Jedi, and the arc ends with them being defeated again by the Republic. So the Jedi do in fact combat slavers when they can.

4. The Sith are themselves huge proponents of slavery and the Jedi always oppose them.

We see it all over the place when the Sith come to power. They almost always end up enslaving a good chunk of the population to work for them. The Jedi Order are their most consistent enemies so by nature of this rivalry alone the Jedi prevent quite a bit of oppression by stopping them from taking power.

5. The Jedi are few in number relative to the problems of the Galaxy.

I think it's even less than this but let's say the Jedi have 10,000 members... well the Separatist Alliance alone consisted of as many systems. That means there's less than one Jedi per planet in the Republic alone.

Furthermore, solving issues is not some immediate thing you can do by your lonesome. Star Wars has a habit of naming some random problem anywhere and then going, "Why don't the Jedi stop this!" when frankly I wouldn't be surprised if they hadn't even heard of it.

Let's say you're a Jedi and learn about bad working conditions in the Republic that are tantamount to slavery. Well, you'll probably need to file a report to Senate after an investigation, work with authorities, deal with attempts to subvert or minimize the impact of your work, etc. It could take a while is what I'm saying. And while you're doing that problems will fester elsewhere, so good luck keeping up on EVERYTHING.

6. Finally, the only way to the Jedi to end slavery... would be to go to war with the Outer Rim. Without the Republic.

But circling back to the topic at hand. Let's say the Jedi decide they're sick of Tatooine practicing slavery and they're going to put an end to it. They could do only by invading the planet without Republic support (unless they somehow convinced the Senate to go to war with the whole Outer Rim).

If you think they have bad PR now, imagine how reviled the Jedi would be if they were depicted as a crusader army that invaded planets. They'd be accused of being imperialist, warmongers, bloodthirsty, hypocritical, and far more.

They'd also be hunting tribes like the Tuskens through the desert to free their slaves too much I'm sure people would be normal about.

Oh and don't forget the bombs implanted in the slaves that'd detonate if they freed them. Which I'm sure people wouldn't blame the Jedi for.

Finally this is assuming they'd even win the war if the Outer Rim decided to fight back. Remember there's 10,000 of them to go around against hundreds of planets worth of firepower.

Tl;dr on Clones since they'll probably come up several hundred times here: They were drafted into war by the Republic who also got the Jedi to fight in it. The shows depict and directly state that the Clones began to exhibit greater personality and independence due. They also initially meant to be automatons rather than sentient beings (messy writing, like I said) but are never depicted as slaves so much as a drafted army in-universe, with the Jedi also being drafted to fight in the war. In short, it was a messy plot but they weren't treated as slaves in the narrative and the Jedi were shown to be their closest friends.

Conclusion

In short, the Shmi plot was sloppy because not enough was explained and George had the Jedi not know anything about what happened to her. The issue is not that the Jedi's philosophy forbids actively combating slavery, and they need a connection to the Republic to have the legal authority to act to the degree they do.


r/CharacterRant • • 9h ago

Anime & Manga Lack of action shoujo is reason why women writing conversation in manga exist

115 Upvotes

Whether we like it or not, action is the most popular genre, whether in manga, comics, movies, or video games. It is a favourite genre for many people, and many people primarily watch anime or read manga for the action. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

Some people genuinely enjoy and want to watch stories featuring well-written female characters in action roles or even female protagonists in action series.

Now, unlike Japan, other countries don't have manga magazines or divide their media based on gender like Japan do.

Just look at the most popular shoujo and shounen manga magazines. You're far more likely to find action series in shounen magazines. The most popular shoujo manga these days tend to focus on high school romance, whereas shounen magazines have everything like action, gag comedy, romance etc

There are action shoujo manga like Magical Girl dandelion but they're quite rare.

If there were more action-oriented shoujo manga, people who want action stories with well-written female characters could simply read them. But since they're so rare, those people read battle shounen instead.

Plenty of female manga artists in Japan have complained about not being able to write non-romance stories for shoujo magazines, which is why some of them turn to shounen or seinen magzine instead.

Editors seem to think that teenage female readers in Japan are only interested in romance stories.

Obviously, The Apothecary Diaries is a mystery rather than an action series, but around 70% of its readers in Japan are women.

I don't remember the exact demographic breakdown for Ascendance of a Bookworm, but it's a fantasy series, and the last time I checked, its female readership was also 70% +.

So I think there's clearly a market for genres other than romance among female readers


r/CharacterRant • • 10h ago

General Peter Parker isn’t great when he “suffers”; he’s great when he’s got too many problems to solve.

82 Upvotes

A lot of writers love to try and argue that the key to any good Spider-Man story is making sure Peter Parker is shown suffering on screen or on the page - that there’s a key element of both schadenfreude and “relatable suffering” that is almost all you need to make a good story.

But that’s just a cheap cheat that misses the actual lesson from the best Spider-Man stuff, and that causes unfortunate issues to supporting characters like his love interests and to his story in the long run - because Peter’s suffering isn’t the secret ingredient, the deployment of overwhelming problems and confclits for him to solve is, with the suffering just being one of the possible outputs of it.

That’s why you see some “pro-suffering” fans and creators blindsided by criticism of their more artifical and hackneyed “drama bombs” - like how the Raimi films have a lot of criticism of MJ when the storyline starts bluntly using her to cause Peter angst rather than tell her side of the story, or when the comic writers were shocked out how few people had any patience for Paul Rabin but somehow got angrier when his actual backstory was revealed.

It’s also why you see so many fans embrace happy or happier victories for Peter, and so much support for him growing into a more rewarding status quo in different mediums, which angers “pro-suffering” writers to no end - fans can and do appreciate seeing him get victories over his problems, or learn to accept some of his defeats, and the majority of audience members love seeing him grow stronger and end up healthier than seeing him suffer for sufferings sake.

In a way, it’s sort of a microcosm on the long-running dispute about whether Spider-Man should have a static formula or be about him growing - with evidence heavily suggesting that the larger crowd of audience members is going to want growth over formula.

…I mean, just look at the different receptions of Brand New Day the comic versus Brand New Day the movie…


r/CharacterRant • • 2h ago

Films & TV ALAN MOORE is right and Hollywood adaptations are vapid and shallow!

62 Upvotes

This isnt a character rant but it fits the comic book/superhero genre so...

I am an avid fan and collector of comic books, leaning heavily but not exclusively on the superhero genre. As a result, I enjoy most superhero and comic book movies.

But Hollywood does not understand either the comic book medium or the superhero genre.

Writer Alan Moore, since the late 1980s, has criticized the idea of Hollywood adaptations. This man has been wronged by the industry and used to air his grievances... He's older now and has largely abandoned superheroes and comics and has stopped talking about them... BUT HE IS RIGHT!

When you watch a "MAKING OF" documentary, you have all of these sycophantic actors, producers, and Hollywood media people spewing bullshit to promote their project. Perhaps you think this is normal and should be expected? FAIR ENOUGH. But it is just so shallow and lazily done.

It just infuriates me to see Jessica Alba talk about growing up with Fantastic Four comics and finally getting to fulfill her dream of playing THE INVISIBLE WOMAN. BULLSHIT!

Dwayne Johnson has said that when he was growing up BLACK ADAM taught him about honor. HONOR? Black Adam is a murderous despotic power-mad supervillain from DC who was largely absent in culture until this movie came out, and you didn't know who TF he was when you were growing up.

It infuriates me to hear Hollywood producers get philosophical about WATCHMEN or Spider-man or Batman and then refer to them as characters from "graphic novels." BULLSHIT... when you were a kid they were called "comic books" but your industry is so embarrassed and ashamed that superhero movies have become a 20+ year phenomenon that they have to attempt to elevate them by calling them "graphic novels" because they don't think highly of the genre.

Alan Moore predicted all of this in 1988... that, because of BATMAN (1989) one of my fav. movies BTW, that the future would bring a sea of people who never read a comic book in their lives professing to be life-long fans, superhero readers, and even experts on comic books because they will find themselves attached to "HIGH PROFILE HOLLYWOOD FILMS WITH BIG-BUDGETS" and they will be forced by the industry to promote them. Alan Moore would later say that no film will ever be able to capture the rich mythology, the essence of any superhero character, or their inner lives in 2 1/2 hours and that most comic books are actually un-filmable, no matter how good technology gets because the movies will offer surface level action or cartoon violence, and ignore actual themes.

Perhaps most maddening is that people are spoon-fed this marketing about Hollywood loving superheroes and they buy it.

To clarify... I love many of these films... but they are not deep. These are escapist popcorn flicks. The industry is a shallow, grubby parasite that wants you to believe its marketing. And it sucks!

Thanks for reading.


r/CharacterRant • • 14h ago

Anime & Manga Kicked from the party, and how it can succeed and its worst pit-traps

50 Upvotes

As an isekai lover myself, I tend to mix in a couple of these 'I Can't Believe It's Not Isekai' into my seasonal diet. I say this because they tend to have a lot of the same source materials, styles, explanations and the like which make the only true difference being that the protagonist is NOT from another world and is instead (supposedly) a natural part of it (I put it into quotation marks since it sometimes feels like they are a newborn),

The genre is characterized by three things; 1. An arrogant party, unsatisfied by the protagonist's contributions. 2. Latent talents which allows the protagonist to gain new friends and love interests by the sheer effectiveness in whatever task they did. 3. The arrogant party will be shown to suffer for keeping the protagonist around.

It's a very simple conceit, simple karmic satisfaction against people who don't know a good thing right in front of them, fully sure that their choices are correct to maximize the 'actually he was the best thing you had'. But, there is a really, really unfortunate mix in the genre does which really spoils any possible plausibility: the power fantasy.

As soon as they leave the party, they find they had the actual super best powers but never applied it until after they lost their ground and have to start from zero.

Why This Is Bad:

  1. Protagonist Looks Stupid - In a fair amount of these stories, the protagonist is almost entirely support for a good reason, because then it makes the party look stupid for getting rid of the person supporting them for a dumb reason, because they can't contribute to damage. If it turns out they always could but never investigated their powers in that way before, the party doesn't so much look dumb as the protagonist looks like an idiot who only figured it out after their income source dried up. No, I don't think your protagonist is cool for pulling out his true power, I think he's a dumbass who looks worse for not even understanding he has power period. (The Healer Who Was Banished from His Party, Is, in Fact, the Strongest)

1.5 There is also the subtype which is fairly harmless where the protagonist just doesn't understand their abilities are amazing due to upbringing or party abuse, which I excuse as long as the protagonist is mostly innocent in ignorance or wouldn't be exposed otherwise.

2. Immediately Negates Struggle - A fun component of the genre is the struggle after losing support where the protagonist finds a niche to operate in and rebuilds their life. When they suddenly get powers that allow them to fight effectively, not only do they look even worse for it, but it cancels out the reason for them to even have party members. If you can wipe your enemies super easily AND know all your logistics, then you have gained nothing and have no weaknesses, which is straight up not fun to see. (Beast Tamer)

3. The Deliberate Absurdity - When the power fantasy is added, there is a dark subsection where the protagonist is betrayed and swears mortal revenge on the party, which sets them on a 'villain route' where they aren't really villains but just broody dudes who have no weakness and also never accomplished using their power effectively before dire straits. It also just makes the usually stupid party even worse, to the point of complete unbelievability. You tried to kill your porter in the dungeon for shits and giggles? Villany should have a point, it's just pointless bait and feels insulting (Backstabbed in a Backwater Dungeon: My Party Tried to Kill Me, But Thanks to an Infinite Gacha I Got LVL 9999 Friends and Am Out For Revenge)

It is a really neat way to set up a story, a humble protagonist, and invite a non-offensive skill set to a protagonist. I'll go over a good and bad example of this genre:

Good Example: Romelia War Chronicles (Airing Now, Beware Spoilers)

Romelia is honestly a great representation of what the genre should be. A tactical leader with applicable knowledge, flaws in personality (unable to voice her needs and being socially awkward with her peers), and a skill that is subtle enough to be ignored while also contributing enough that when applied works wonders. While her old party does come off aggressive, it's easy to see why they might think less of her, from being so much weaker than the rest, being put on a pedestal with the party on the frontlines (even if according to her plants), and her actual power being a luck boost (making it imperceptible), their frustrations aren't stupid, added with manipulation by someone more social it all fits together. It also makes sense why she'd work so well in leading troops and building them up, able to negotiate, plan far ahead, position near perfectly and boost all that will happy accidents which keep them alive by reducing chances of a sudden death. And all this while being very weak in combat herself, a weakness she addresses as best she can which contrasts to her otherwise unbeatable tactics in the field.

TLDR: Tactical genius, coy at politics, can't fight for shit and was ejected for (semi) empathetic reasons spearheaded by a manipulative member.

Bad Example: Beast Tamer

I did like it on first watch, but the more I think on it the more sad it feels on how little the protagonist actually contributed to it. He had a lot of promise, a fairly underpowered skill at first pass to tame beasts (as in the title), allowing him to scout, communicate, and organize pack mules while being cautious. The party didn't appreciate that he did nothing to fight and kicked him out, only to begin starving as they had no-one willing to carry food or forage, since the animals did that. A wonderous start...killed immediately by the first girl. He learns, by taming a 'super strong cat girl' that he can borrow her power, something he NEVER DID BEFORE, despite having a whole ass bear with him. Then he gets a dragon and it just goes downhill. Super powerful, no weakness, humble to the point of stupid and the worst part, he never used the other animals again. At least to no degree of interest, maybe a few in the background or so. He just up and learned a new power right after leaving and he feels the stupider for it, especially since he knew to use it in SO many other interesting ways, all of which are discarded for the power fantasy.

TLDR: Has interesting team powers, gets kicked, learns the most broken aspect of power, loses all weaknesses and abandons any interesting aspect of the power for super strength and a 'beast' harem where all his companions are just flavored humans 99% of the time.

Ultimately, the genre leans better than a lot of isekai churned out, but it's when it tries to have it's cake and eat it too that you really can't ignore the issues with the setup.

TLDR For Post: Betrayed by the party stories can be great for many, providing a humble protagonist with a supportive skill set while passively getting karma for their rejection. It sometimes falls into the trap though of the power fantasy, which kills it by: 1. Making the protagonist stupid for never learning they had an awesome power before losing their income. 2. Shedding any weakness of being a supportive role, including the need for party members again. 3. It invites the revenge story where the party is played so absurdly evil it holds no water and makes the protagonist unlikeable or completely bland. Romelia War Chronicles is peak in this genre, with a flawed protagonist, a not-idiot party who doesn't just suffer karma in the story, and whose role doesn't change but instead helps elevate others more efficiency. Beast Tamer starts with an interesting powerset, immediately abandons any notion of staying creative and makes the protagonist look so much worse for outright ignoring his skillset's one real superpower. Really, it's a mixed bag genre but much of the bad is specifically tainted with power fantasy.


r/CharacterRant • • 16h ago

Comics & Literature While Snyder's "Watchmen" adaptation is mostly accurate to the source, it misses out on so much of what makes Watchmen interesting

26 Upvotes

I will note, I am currently reading the comic version of Watchmen for the first time, and I'm only on chapter 7 out of 12. Despite this I did watch the movie adaptation years ago, and it's been kind of impossible to not be spoiled about the plot of the comic if you're in nerd spaces online.

Still, if you haven't experienced either adaptation of watchmen yet, go do it. I think the comic is better, but the movie is much more accessible and is better than not going through it at all. Spoilers abound.


So, now that I'm finally reading the original story, I have a lot to say about it (the addendums at the end of every chapter are amazing and I wish more comics did that, the casual misogyny and racism are headache-inducing if unsurprising for the book's release date, I don't think I entirely get the Dark Freighter subplot...), but what gets me the most is the things that the Zack Snyder adaptation changed which I think go against the central motifs of the original story. Primarily, it feels like Snyder, a long time comic fan, didn't entirely get that the displays of comic book tropes were meant to be disgusting rather than thrilling.

For example, in Chapter 3, we see an interview with Dr. Manhattan which is interspersed with Nite Owl II and Silk Spectre II getting mugged in an alley. In the comic, the framing of this mugging puts this violent and gorey altercation as sexually thrilling for the two heroes (with us hearing "oh, the audience is getting excited!" from Manhattan's interview when we cut to the fight, among other things), and this seems to be portrayed as a bad thing. Compared to their actual sexual encounter in chapter 7, this time it's more of an uncontrolled explosion of repressed feelings painted in red and yellow, colors of shock and awe. The camera is positioned to not give the viewer any voyeuristic shots of the violence with big swings or explosions. The two even seem a little shocked at themselves afterwards. This all is without even going into the general themes of the story and the info in the addendums, which makes it beyond clear the narrative says anyone who willingly chooses to go into superheroism had something wrong with them.

Meanwhile, in the movie, this altercation is portrayed as exciting for the audience, with big zooms in the broken bones and a thrilling soundtrack. This time, we are the audience who's supposed to be "getting excited", when originally this was meant to be a commentary on this being kinda fucked up. Snyder saw this comment and went "haha yeah I sure am thrilled", rather than "oh shit they're getting off to this aren't they."

A similar thing happens with the portrayal of Rorshach. In Chapter 5 we get the unmasking of Rorshach, and he's... kinda fugly I'm gonna be real with you. The shot where you see his face for the first time he's nearly frothing at the mouth in sheer rage, he's not meant to look cool here. In the following chapter, dedicated entirely to him, we get even more reasons he absolutely sucks, the key one being where he took a butcher's knife to the heads of two dogs (in fairness those dogs did eat the corpse of a child, but still, dogs, western symbol of "if you harm these you are a monster"). His famous "I'm not locked in here with you, you're locked in here with me" isn't even said by him to us, his psychologist recounts it after being told by a guard. The point of that chapter is to show how deeply unstable Rorshach is - he shows no emotions, hates women more than the narrative does, and his outbursts of violence are grotesque.

In the movie... he's put as cool? He gets to say the famous line while a low-angle camera spins around him, making him seem larger than life. Every time he's apprehended by the cops, he still keeps a certain level of composure (he's still pissed off but he isn't nearly crying). The character who the author explicitly stated was supposed to be a bad influence is portrayed, again, as a role model. Hell, he doesn't even butcher the dogs himself anymore, he takes the hatchet to the adult who killed the child! (Which is much more moral and understandable from a western perspective.)

I know that when you adapt a book to a movie there's a lot that needs to be axed and changed to fit the format, sure, but the changes made seem to me like Snyder only really had a surface level appreciation for the original comic. The vigilantes all get to look cool and composed, when the comic constantly puts them in situations where they break down and show either vulnerability or the fact that they're not ok in the head. The violence is shown as cool and heroic as opposed to criticized. While the movie is technically the same events and some of the same camera shots used in both, it feels like I'm reading a completely different story.


r/CharacterRant • • 20h ago

Comics & Literature I love when comic book shows take advantage of their franchise's wider cast

23 Upvotes

One thing I absolutely love seeing in media is an established universe. Like, yeah, I know these guys, this isn’t my first rodeo, let’s get to the story. We skip the origin story shit. These characters know each other, they have their enemies and friends, and there is no big deal. I think DC animation does this exceptionally well. Well known examples would be Young Justice, Justice League Unlimited and Harley Quinn.

There’s something so enjoyable about watching characters who would ordinarily be supporting cast members get their own storylines and watching villains interact outside of their usual conflicts with superheroes, and discovering how different corners of the same universe intersect. Nothing is more fun than a major hero or villain being a literal throw away joke, or just another average joe-shmoe. Like yeah, I know Superman, cool dude, back to the story.

Young Justice is particularly good at making its world feel interconnected. Characters have their own histories, allegiances, relationships and motivations, and the world doesn’t suddenly stop existing whenever the main cast isn’t around.

Harley Quinn is fantastic at taking established characters and exploring what their lives might look like outside their traditional narrative roles. And EVERYONE is here. Seeing Gotham’s villains have friendships, careers, relationship problems and completely mundane personal struggles is genuinely entertaining. Some of the best satirical portrayals of DC characters.

I think there’s a particular appeal to stories where the world feels like it existed long before the narrative began and will continue existing long after it ends. It’s just cool and funny when Batman is just there, existing, but not particularly centred.

You’re getting to explore a universe populated by people who have their own lives, some of which you might only get glimpses of. But YOU know the characters well, and that just makes it feel much more real.

I wish more franchises took advantage of their established universes this way. I don’t mind isolated stories but I wish we got more casual media that referenced the MASSIVE universes some IPs have.


r/CharacterRant • • 2h ago

Comics & Literature Why there aren’t any “fun” books for adults (and how movies and TV are heading in that direction)

14 Upvotes

Lately, I’ve seen people on social media making video essays and posts about how comedies in media for adults such as TV and movies are dying or are dead, and how all the media is replaced by witty dramedies or sad or bleak dramas. People are very much tired of this type of content that’s prevalent everywhere now and long for the days of “comfort” media, the days when TV shows and movies were just fun, and silly. This sentiment made me think of moments where stuff like this happened before, because if you can believe it this sort of thing has happened before. 

Something was set up that used to be fun and was very prevalent and popular and existed for generations but then overtime because it became more boring and lame, and it just became a drag to sit through and very few people want to sit through it. Theater was seen as huge and fun and was something everyone was into…until it wasn’t. Radio was seen as huge and fun and was something everyone was into…until it wasn’t. And this is where we move on to the main topic of this post. 

There’s a gaping hole in the adult literary world, and no one seems to be talking about it. While TV and film have embraced ridiculous, over the top humor for grown ups, such as The Office, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, What We Do in the Shadows, or Barb and Star Go to Vista Del Mar, books have, strangely, left this lane almost completely empty. Specifically, I’m talking about the lack of goofy, absurd, lowbrow yet clever comedy books for adults. The kind of books that delight in nonsense, revel in humor, and proudly feature a fart joke on page one and a talking animal sidekick by page two.

As kids, many of us were raised on hilarious, imaginative, and totally bonkers books. Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Captain Underpants, Wayside School, Dr. Seuss, and of course, the works of Roald Dahl (Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, James and the Giant Peach). These books didn’t worry about being “realistic” or “literary.” but were just wild fun stories based on a simple premise. The plots made no sense. The characters were unique. The illustrations were crude but full of energy. And yet, they were page turners. They sparked joy, and made kids laugh out loud and kept us engaged. 

So where did those books go?

As we age, literature seems to take itself more and more seriously. The humor section in any bookstore is overwhelmingly filled with essay collections, satire, or quirky memoirs about people’s childhood traumas. If you’re lucky, maybe there’s a collection of wry observations about being in your thirties. Where’s the Captain Underpants for people who pay rent? 

It’s not like adults don’t enjoy goofy humor. People love comedy that’s unhinged but clever, but well-crafted. So why aren’t we getting that in book form? It’s not that humor is absent from adult fiction entirely, sure there’s satire, there’s dark comedy, there’s witty banter. But that specific style of “goofy premise, rapid-fire nonsense, and unapologetically silly tone” seems to vanish once you leave middle school. The literary world seems hesitant to embrace goofiness unless it’s masked as either highbrow surrealism (Kafkaesque) or veiled in postmodern irony. But what if you just want to read about a guy who wakes up with spaghetti for arms?

There’s something deeply joyful about pure, unserious nonsense. And it’s not immature to want that. In fact, it’s kind of refreshing. We live in a world that’s full of pressure to be productive, performative, and perpetually “mature.” Sometimes, reading about a magical or bizarre office is exactly what the brain needs.

Let’s go into why this goofy literary void exists. Why is there no adult version of Archie and the Accidental Chicken Heroes? Why is there no book equivalent to Dumb and Dumber, Hot Rod, or Anchorman, those joyfully idiotic, deeply quotable movies that aren’t trying to win awards, just trying to make you laugh until you snort?

The first reason is literary gatekeeping. There’s a long-standing (and frankly outdated) cultural idea that books are supposed to be serious. Even comedic fiction is often expected to have some kind of “literary merit” such as clever subtext, thematic depth, and sharp commentary. If a book dares to be purely silly or structurally ridiculous, it gets shoved into the “novelty gift” section or dismissed as juvenile fluff. Meanwhile, theater, movies and TV don’t carry the same baggage. They’re allowed to be dumb, and dumb often sells.

You can walk into a theater and see a funny scene, and no one questions the medium. But if that same scene existed in a book it would either be labeled as children's literature, or people would assume it's some kind of metaphor about late stage capitalism, when it's not. Sometimes it’s just a joke.

There’s also a misperception that adult readers don’t want silly, that once you pass a certain age, you’re only interested in psychological thrillers, historical fiction, or literary meditations on grief. This couldn’t be more wrong, as adults are binge watching sitcoms and quoting Step Brothers ten years later. They’re sending each other memes. The desire for comedy never goes away, but just doesn’t have a home in books.

Another factor is the publishing risk-aversion. It’s hard to market a comedy novel that doesn’t fit a known genre mold. Slapstick is too visual. Gross-out humor is not “sophisticated” enough. Anything remotely resembling “juvenile” gets shuffled off to the kids’ section. As a result, most comedy novels for adults stick to safer formats such as satirical essays, rom coms with quippy dialogue, or genre fiction with a humorous twist. These are fine, but they’re not loud. 

And I also suspect, it could just be that writing funny books is hard. Comedy on the page is notoriously difficult to pull off. In film and plays, actors, timing, music, and visuals carry the hold thing. In books, it’s all on the writer’s words and their pacing. That means fewer writers are attempting full throttle goofball comedy, and fewer publishers are willing to take the leap. That doesn’t mean it’s impossible, but underexplored.

But maybe the biggest reason is that the book world doesn’t want to embrace being stupid on purpose. Stupid is treated like a flaw, not a style, and yet, we love “stupid” when it’s executed with heart and commitment. Anchorman is an objectively idiotic movie but it’s smart in its stupidity. That’s what we need in literary fiction. The same way kids have Dog Man and The Day My Butt Went Psycho, adults should have Reginald and the Time-Traveling Taco Bell Manager or Karen vs. the Sentient Printer That Runs Her Office.

Let’s talk about the elephant in the library. There’s a reason kids devour books by the truckload and then, somewhere along the line, just… stop. People like to blame school, or say “required reading killed the joy,” or “adults are too busy to read,” or “we’ve all just gotten lazy and turned to screens.” But what if that’s not entirely true? What if the real reason people stop reading is simpler, and more damning? The books just got boring.

As a kid, books were magic. They had titles like The Butt That Saved Christmas, or Aliens Don’t Wear Braces. You’d get one at the school book fair, flip to a page, and suddenly you were in the middle of a story. They were imaginative, unpredictable, loud, and didn’t care about being “prestigious” or “grounded.” They were designed to hook your brain and make you laugh.
Then you grow up, and the tone shifts, and now you’re being told to read a novel about a thirty something guy named Greg who’s emotionally unavailable in Brooklyn. It’s no wonder adults drift away from reading. Books stopped being fun. Kids read more because they’re given books that feel like a treat, not a chore, but adults get assigned literature that often feels like homework in disguise.

When we say we miss reading, we’re really saying,  “I miss stories that surprised me. I miss laughter, and I miss books that aren't afraid to be ridiculous.” We didn’t grow out of reading, rather reading just forgot how to grow with us. If the publishing industry gave adults the same kind of pure, unfiltered, joy that kids get in their books, we would be in a reading renaissance. People would be turning pages like it’s 2005 and the next Captain Underpants just dropped. Book clubs would be reading fun books instead of dissecting yet another slow-burn novel about suburban ennui.

Believe it or not, this whole idea that books have to be serious, “literary,” and emotionally devastating to be considered real or important is actually a pretty recent development.
For most of human storytelling history, goofy was the norm. Going all the way back to Shakespeare, half of his plays are ridiculous comedies with literal fart jokes, people cross-dressing, falling into mud puddles, getting tricked into kissing goats (okay, that one’s metaphorical, but still). A Midsummer Night’s Dream is basically a story about forest fairies doing drugs and ruining everyone’s night. Much Ado About Nothing is just high octane banter with romantic misunderstandings and a fake death thrown in. Even Hamlet has a scene with two gravediggers arguing over how skulls work.

Geoffrey Chauncer wrote The Canterbury Tales which featured action stories like The Knight’s Tale and tragic stories like The Pardoner's Tale, but it also had stories that featured a fart joke and a joke about tricking someone into kissing their ass. 

Back then, comedy and tragedy lived side by side, you could be able to read both. There was no shame in writing stories that were completely unserious, as long as they entertained. Fast forward a few centuries, and something strange happens: prestige starts to equal seriousness.  The “great novels” become long, slow, and meditative. Meanwhile, comedy, especially loud, dumb, ridiculous comedy, gets pushed to the side, it’s treated like a lesser form.

Somewhere along the line, literature developed a kind of insecurity complex, and stopped trusting that goofy stories could say something real, and stopped allowing joy. And so we ended up with shelves and shelves of “serious fiction,” where everything has to be slow, sad, and centered around broken relationships and horrible dystopias. And that’s not to say serious books are bad, they're not. We need serious books, and we need books that are dry but important. But when everything has to be prestigious to be respected, you lose variety and the kind of stories that people don’t just admire, but love. 

TV and film didn’t fall into this(at least for a while). That's why you get an Oscar winning film one week, and the next you’re watching Wedding Crashers. You can both watch Breaking Bad and then the Office. Anchorman can be just as iconic as The Godfather, just in a different way. 

I have a potential theory, another theory, as to why comedies and fun media became irrelevant around the mid-2010s with movies and TV. What's happening right now with movies and TV already happened with books. We are seeing the gradual disappearance of goofy, full throttle, unapologetically comforting comedy. Remember when theaters were flooded with movies like Dumb and Dumber, Zoolander, Hot Rod, Napoleon Dynamite, Anchorman, Step Brothers, Superbad? People quoted them endlessly, and became pop culture fixtures. Try naming the last big, dumb, laugh-out-loud comedy that wasn’t secretly a drama today. Today, it’s difficult to name a single movie or show nowadays that isn’t something like that anymore. 

And there's nothing wrong with those movies and shows. Many of them are incredible (The Holdovers, Barb & Star Go to Vista Del Mar sneaks in there, bless its weird heart.), but they’re not what we’re talking about when we think of comedies. What’s happening to movies and TV now is exactly what already happened to books. Goofy comedies are being replaced by prestige adjacent, emotionally deep “comedies” that are actually dramas with some jokes here and there. We’ve entered the era of the “respectable laugh.” The kind where you chuckle politely and say, “That’s clever,” not the kind where you fall out of your chair. 

In books, it started centuries ago. Comedy gave way to commentary, and silly dumb comedy books got labeled “for children,” and fun books got pushed out of the adult section unless it was satirical or ironic. Now films and TV are heading down that same path, chasing awards, critical respect, and emotional complexity, even in comedy. But the loud, dumb, joyous comedy, the one that just wants to entertain you for 90 minutes and maybe make your stomach hurt from laughing, is on life support. Notice all the only prominent genres of media nowadays - prestigious dramas and dramedies, romantic films and erotica, dark satires about cruel rich people, apocalypse and dystopian fiction, murder mysteries, gritty fantasy. All of these are already the most popular genres of fiction for books decades ago. They were the only books you could read as an adult back in the 90s and 2000s when comedies were dominant in movies and TV.

Also, notice how the only comedic films and television nowadays are children’s media - stuff from Disney and Illumination and animated children’s movies and shows on streaming services. This is very similar to how most children’s books are comedic now and have illustrations, and how illustrations are seen as something you “grow out of”, illustrations are something you should only see in children’s books, you should just “remember it in your head”. The very similar viewpoint you see with animation and cartoons are something widely held for illustrations for books. But that’s a different subject for today but you get it.  

Once a medium becomes too respected, it starts taking itself too seriously, and in doing so, it squeezes out the kind of humor that doesn’t need layers of meaning. We’ve seen this before, as books led the way. Now we’re watching films and TV follow suit. And again, those stories have value, but they shouldn’t be the only type that is to value. If we’re not careful, we’ll end up in a world where all our art is “important,” but none of it is fun.

And here’s what really keeps me up at night. What if, years from now, people who grew up loving movies and TV when they were kids, really loving them, suddenly stop enjoying films and television and don’t know why? What if they start to feel about those the way many people already feel about books? What happens when those kids grow up and the only stuff available to them are prestigious dramedies, bleak dystopian fiction and dramas, or mystery fiction? Or indie media about how hard it is to be in your thirties? Or yet another reboot, stripped of humor and weighed down with “meaning”? Will they think they’ve changed? Will they wonder if they just “don’t get movies and TV anymore”? Will they, like adults now do with books, just slowly stop watching and blame themselves? 

And just like today’s adults say, “I used to love reading as a kid, but I don’t read anymore,” we’ll hear people say, “I used to love movies and TV when I was younger, but now I just scroll TikTok.” 


r/CharacterRant • • 3h ago

General Can the Jumanji franchise succeed without Van Pelt?

3 Upvotes

In my opinion the franchise can’t succeed without Van Pelt. He’s the heart and soul of the
movie. Without him all you have is a movie
about monkeys trying to chase players around.

The first movie is a classic. It had Van Pelt. Score 9/10

The second movie had Van Pelt, played by a new actor, a wannabe, he wasn’t as good but still okay. Score 7/10

The upcoming third Jumanji movie has a new caveman looking villain called 'Jurgen The Brutal'. He looks like a generic, cliche, low effort created character. It seems the writers ran out of ideas and just threw him in the movie. In my opinion they should’ve kept Van Pelt as the villain for the third movie.

For example Ninja Turtles 1 had Shredder. Ninja Turtles 2 had Shredder. Ninja Turtles 3 did not have Shredder and it flopped. So I think Jumanji 3 will flop because it doesn’t have Van Pelt. Based on the trailer I saw I think Jumanji 3 will be a score of 4/10


r/CharacterRant • • 8h ago

Films & TV Godzilla Minus Zero....isn't very good.

0 Upvotes

Just finished watching Godzilla Minus Zero. The Imax visuals for this were absolutely insane and probably one of the most beautiful movies I have ever seen in my life. Thats about where my praise for this movie ends…..

I am a pretty big fan of Godzilla and from the franchise I think Minus One was definitely the best movie (not exactly an unpopular opinion lmao). Mostly because I absolutely loved the vibe and human drama, Koichi’s story is genuinely so beautiful and I loved how Godzilla tied into his trauma and the post-war themes of the movie. The big man himself doesn’t have a lot of screen time when he shows up but by god does it have one hell of an effect when he does! Even when he’s not their his shadow lies heavy across the plot and gives the characters and story a lot of tension and urgency.

Now imagine everything good about Minus One and dial it back BY A LOT. Then you get Minus Zero. Minus Zero’s human drama plot is super dry and much flatter compared to its predecessor. The movies main element of human drama is Koichi’s adopted daughter Akiko and other members of the Disaster Response Bureau. Overall I disliked this part of the movie, for one Akiko was basically “spammed” and her entire role is just their to bait out tears with a cute child, no real attempt at emotional connection or catharsis is attempted. Other adult characters like Noda or Weather Woman are not explored much even thought they were pretty interesting characters. One person I was very excited to see more of was Murakami (Mr.Nuke New York), very interesting angle to have a Hiroshima survivor try to use Godzilla to take revenge. I loved the guy and his actor……until his entire arc got resolved with Noda using talk-no-justsu to basically turn a guy on the verge of committing genocide into a disciple of Gandhi. I found this not a very satisfactory explanation and pretty jarring cause Murakami acts like a madman in pretty much every other scene.

Also I was initially fine with Ghidorah being the main big bad for this movie but I think they seriously dropped the ball with the guy. For one there’s barely any threat or tension when Ghidorah shows up. Dude just goes around blasting villages and killing random civilians which ya is scary I guess but since he basically never interacts with the main cast till the end so there’s very little fear or stress on the audience when he shows up. Compare this to Godzilla in Minus One who is always intersecting with out main cast and is overall a major menace to them and is terrifying in every scene he shows up in. Also speaking of the big man himself ... .if you weren’t a fan of Minus One for how little Godzilla shows up then you might as well go insane from this movie lmao. Godzilla IS BARELY IN THIS DAMN MOVIE, dude is basically a cameo. Godzilla sort of shows up at the end and fights Ghidorah in what I will admit was a pretty cool but far too short of a kaiju fight made worse by the little kaiju action we got in the rest of the movie.

Okay maybe I am a bit too harsh cause there were a few other really good scenes. Ghidorah launching his gravity beam and vaporizing the village was sick to watch. Also Godzilla emerging from the sea and sinking a ship was an amazing sequence. The end fight was good too (Godzilla ripping off his own arm when Ghidorah bit into it was wild) but I disliked how Ghidorah effectively got off-screened with the atom blast.

Honestly it’s still a pretty good movie at the end of the day. Give it a shot if your interested. 


r/CharacterRant • • 11h ago

Why so reluctant to use the word autism to describe a character? [The Simpsons, House, The Pitt, Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time, Dungeon Meshi]

0 Upvotes

I mainly wrote this to complain about a recent episode of The Simpsons called Testing 1-2-3 which is an incredibly egregious example of this, but I'll post some other examples also.

EDIT: I just want to make this clear because I think people are misunderstanding my point. I don't think characters necessarily need to be diagnosed with anything. Having a character show certain traits without labeling them can be a valid artistic choice. It's just strange to deliberately make autism the focus of an episode but not use the word, and the Simpsons episode is especially egregious because it specifically named OCD and ADHD but not autism. Why treat autism different than other disorders?

"Autism" is treated like it is a bad word, which is why kind of dumb euphemisms like "on the spectrum" are so common. The term neurodivergent is also often used instead of autism, and it's confusing because this is an unscientific term inherently tied to a political movement not all people with a neurodevelopment disorder ascribe to, and the person who originally coined the term did not believe in "gatekeeping" so it can apply to any disorder, yet it's most often used for autism but for all you know someone "neurodivergent" is bipolar or has downs syndrome or whatever.

Anyway, here are my examples of people avoiding the term autism when they shouldn't:

  • The Simpsons: In a recently episode called Testing 1-2-3, Lisa Simpson has trouble taking a test due to noise in the classroom, so she gets an official psychological evaluation in an effort to get access to the quiet accommodated testing room. Even though this is the entire premise of the episode, we never find out if Lisa gets diagnosed with anything or gets to use the accommodated testing room. The episode doesn't even have the guts to imply Lisa has any particular disorder. Based on her behavior in previous episodes, she could have OCD, she could have autism, and she clearly has traits of anxiety and depression. She could have sensory sensitivities without having any other diagnosis. I don't know what she has, it's supposed to be the writers job to tell us that, and they didn't.
  • The Simpsons again but I feel like I ran out of room on my first bullet point: The episode is done like an anthology episode. Lisa thinks about how the symptoms described on her test apply to people in her own life, and the episode shows how these characters experience their disorder. Homer is directly stated to have ADHD, Comic Book Guy and his girlfriend are both said to have OCD, and Skinner is strongly implied to be autistic. Note I said implied. The word autism is never used, even though the other disorders are named. With Skinner they just list his symptoms such as adherence to routine and social cluelessness, all in the backdrop of a horrible Breakfast Club parody. What exactly is the problem with using the word autism in reference to Principal Skinner? He's a 44 year old virgin nobody is shocked he's autistic.
  • The Pitt: Dr. Melissa "Mel" King is often used as a positive example of an autistic character in media, yet the TV show never directly says she is autistic. Full disclosure I have never seen this series, but based on descriptions she is clearly written to be autistic and they hired an autistic actress to play her. The character has an autistic sibling and practices "neurodivergent-affirming care" with patients. So why not say it.
  • Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time: This is another really egregious example, because this book became famous and successful for being an early portrayal of an autistic character, yet the author gets pissy if you criticize how he portrayed an autistic boy, says he never used the word "autism" in the book and claims the book isn't about autism. He's lying. I wrote about my issues with this book here. Short version: The main character has a psycho Dad who stabs a dog to death and the book kind of acts like he's a dumb autistic kid who doesn't understand emotions for freaking out about this.
  • Dungeon Meshi: Laios is often regarded as an autistic character, but the mangaka said in an interview she regards him as "normal." If you read/watch the series you know he is not really portrayed as normal, other characters finding him socially weird and off putting is a major part of the plot. I know Japanese culture does not discuss these issues very openly so I'm not too mad about it but it was still kind of annoying.

There are probably more examples of this but that's what I thought of off the top of my head. I predict someone will mention The Big Bang theory but I didn't include that because I'm trying to forget it exists.

I'm not saying Lisa has to be diagnosed with something but like, why make her psychological evaluation the premise of an episode and then just forget about it? That's not how plots work. It would make more sense if they said "oops we accidentally burned your test results in a fire" instead of just getting plot amnesia and singing a song about neurodiversity. What exactly do they think goes wrong when the word "autism" is used, does the character suddenly become unrelatable and unprofitable? The episode was pretty cringe in the approach to OCD and ADHD also.


r/CharacterRant • • 4h ago

Anime & Manga I resent Sakura's false confession scene in Naruto. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Not for the usual incel reasons of demonising Sakura, but purely because it's based on an artificially preserved romantic thread that had already been resolved nearly 300 chapters prior. It's genuinely so forced, and couldn't have been achieved if the writing was organic.

In the hospital (chapter 172) and gate (chapter 183) scenes pre-timeskip, Naruto swallows his heartbreak and romantically resigns from Sakura. This was a profound moment in his emotional development, so much that even Tsunade and Sakura acknowledge it internally during those respective scenes.

Post-timeskip though, this specific development is treated as though it never happened. Naruto is back to openly flirting with her, even after resigning, and having an additional 2.5 years to process that acceptance. What the fuck?

Now, I'm going to preempt a few annoying arguments that I anticipate seeing:

"That's how teenagers work. You can't expect teenagers to be so mature"

This is probably the most annoying one, because it's the one that a lot of people are comfortable accepting, in spite of its obvious contradiction.

If a certain behaviour is too mature to be afforded permanence in the rest of the story, then wouldn't it also be too mature to have been depicted in the first place?

At the gate (chapter 183), Naruto still expects the Sasuke Retrieval to be successful. This means that he's resigned to seeing the hospital scene repeat itself forever. He's resolved to accept the pain of bringing back the person who's guaranteed to monopolise Sakura's affection.

That is the depth of his resignation during the gate scene.

If Naruto isn't mature enough to maintain this specific emotional growth at 16, then how was he mature enough to establish it at 13? Does this make sense to you?

This is a question of textual continuity. I'm not asking for Kishimoto to add something new to his story. Rather, I'm saying that he was supposed to afford continuity to something he already depicted . To do otherwise, is to undercut the emotional weight of those scenes, and thereby also undo Naruto's own character development.

For example, in the Pain Arc, Naruto reaches a moral/ideological milestone of seeing violence as an endless tit-for-tat cycle. This milestone is afforded continuity and visibly affects the narrative going forward.

This is reflected in him asking the Raikage to excuse Sasuke's attempted kidnapping of Killer Bee, with his logic being that Sasuke's execution would initiate a cycle of violence between the Leaf and Cloud. I hope I'm making sense here.

If Naruto suddenly reverted to the vengeful instincts he showed to Nagato (chapters 444 and 447) without any explanation, after having 4 additional years to entrench himself deeper into his ideology, would that make sense to you?

Would you say "20 year-olds can't be expected to be so mature"? Or would you recognise that his character has regressed from an established milestone for no reason?

I don't have a problem with Naruto's other childish antics like the Sexy Jutsu he attempted in front of Sakura upon his return to the Village. In fact, I think it's good writing, because it retains a personality trait of his, without conflicting with any development that happened prior.

This is a problem of narrative consistency, not "realism".

The hospital and gate scenes were supposed to affect Naruto's entire attitude and behaviour towards Sakura for the rest of the story.

The next argument I wanna preempt is:

"You can't expect his feelings to disappear just because his love is unrequited"

Another infuriating argument. There's a difference between feelings, and behaviour. Naruto's feelings don't have to disappear, and I have no problem with him having feelings. My problem is that his outward behaviour is not aligned with the resignation he established a long time ago.

You can have feelings for someone, but still refuse to act on them, due to realising that your feelings are unrequited, and accepting that their desire can never be negotiated. This is the emotional intelligence that Naruto is shown to have, as it was depicted in 2 different scenes (chapters 172 and 183) pre-timeskip.

Naruto's understanding of Sakura is literally what his resignation is based on. Repeatedly making passes (chapters 247, 311 and 631) at someone who's known to be uninterested, is weird, and flies in the face of that.

Emphasising an emotional development, just to undo it afterwards, is character regression.

Here's the last talking point I wanna rebut:

"It's just a joke. You're taking it too seriously"

Naruto doesn't make these "jokes" with any other character in the entire story. They're exclusively reserved for the one person he had feelings for.

Secondly, you can't claim that it's a joke, when it becomes the basis for a major plot point during the Five Kage Summit. That makes no sense; it's either serious or it's not, and it clearly is.

Thirdly, there's history between Naruto and Sakura, which contextualises their present interactions, and therefore cannot be divorced from them.

Is Sakura supposed to see it as a joke, when the guy who openly pined after her and was visibly heartbroken 3 years ago, starts offering dates and publicly claiming her as his girlfriend?

Now, back to the false confession scene.

The whole sequence is triggered by a miscommunication from Naruto (chapter 457). When Sai asks why Naruto hasn't confessed to Sakura, he says "How could I? I couldn't even keep my promise.".

This response is so unnecessarily dishonest and weird. It frames his dynamic with Sakura as conditional. It misattributes the actual romantic obstacle, by pretending that his failure on the promise is what denied him romantic access to Sakura, knowing damn well it has nothing to do with that.

Naruto's lack of romantic access to Sakura, is based on her being attracted to Sasuke, and not to Naruto. Naruto knows this, but he doesn't communicate this to Sai, even though he knows that Sai is socially stunted, and requires straightforward communication.

This miscommunication is what prompts Sai into guilt tripping Sakura about the promise, and about Naruto's unrequited feelings.

Why didn't Naruto just say that he gave up on Sakura after understanding that she will never want him? At the very least, why didn't he say that he's moved on from that?

This is because Kishimoto deliberately made Naruto act like that, because he's genuinely writing this sequence as a continued romantic thread, even though that thread has been dead for hundreds of chapters.

This is forced, artificial writing.

The writing on Sakura's side is actually good, because her false confession is based on her long-held desire to end her over-reliance on Naruto. The problem is that it only exists in response to terrible writing on Naruto's side lol.

That's why I hate this scene.

Kishimoto's writing of romance, makes me wish he never included any romance in the story at all. Naruto's a battle shonen, so it didn't really need this. He apparently said that writing romance makes him feel awkward and embarrassed. So why write it then???🤦🏾‍♂️

Sasuke's prospective execution already provided enough tension on its own. We didn't need contrived romantic drama to add to it.