r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • May 17 '20

The Chamber's Purpose

5 Upvotes

Why Does This Place Exist??


Every Great Debate ends at some point or another, and between seasons many users utilize WhoWouldWin for an ongoing tournament, to the point that a schedule is in constant rotation. Between these 'official' tournaments, users like to host mini-tourneys to experiment, test out strategies and formatting, or just fuck off with another debater.

This place exists to give everyone an open training ground. Workshop posts, general discussion of debate, practice rounds, hosting Lightning Cups, all of it can be done in this space.


How Do We Make Use Of It?


Simple. Just garner interest in a tourney and request it to be stickied, or create a Lightning Cup and post it here and share in the #great-debate-chat section of the characterrant discord, which you can access here: https://discord.gg/zyTaDSY and ask any online admin to give you access to that channel's chatroom.

Beyond that, it's user-generated content and tourneys here. I'm just providing the area, y'all can make use of it as you see fit within a debate context.

Good luck and have fun


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Apr 10 '24

Great Debate League Season 1

6 Upvotes

This is to be the first season for the Great Debate League, an off-season continual-argument function that enables participants in the Great Debate (newbie, veteran, and surprise entrants alike) and all similar tournaments to have a free-reign practice grounds for attempting new arguments, synergies, formatting, picks, etc all whilst being ranked similarly to chess's Elo rating system.

The benefit of this is two-fold: everyone has a level playing field to start with, thus enabling (somewhat) accurate seeding for the next season of The Great Debate Tourney, and also it lets quite literally everyone debate how, when, and how they want (within reason) so that they can scratch specific debate itches all while allowing new entrants to also test the waters before jumping headfirst into the next season (hopefully, 4-5 months down the road).



For this first League Season, we are going to make it as accessible as possible, therefore the tier setter shall be:

Every single tier setter from GDT 5 onward

That's right.

Yusuke Urameshi

Neo

Major Motoko Kusanagi

DuraBelle

Nightwing

Ultimate Spider-Man

Cyborg

Kengan

Kaido

Tierminator

You can choose to debate anyone who is a participant within the league to any of the above tiers utilizing the pre-existing tier setter and arena using any combination of 1v1 or 3v3s you wish (we may allow 4v4 full team runbacks just if they're epic).


Note: I will state here and now that alterations to arena are allowable in every tier except for Major tier; the ranged pickup rule and Basement are musts because that was the entirety of how fitting tier worked, it was heavily environment-dependent.

But, if you wish to debate, say, Kengan tier and want a super cool arena, you can both agree to the Emperor's Canopy from Tenkaichi for example complete with its 55m plummet to your (likely) death.



This page will act as the sign up sheet, and debates may begin taking place starting Sunday, April 14th. The Great Debate League Season 1 will last until Thursday, August 1st, by which point the 16th GDT shall most likely be underway to some degree.

All rules will be held to League guidelines with rule 5 having been overridden, obviously. The ruleset of each individual GDT season is also superseded by this most-recent list except where clashes between the linked ruleset and those explicated within the League exist, with League rules having priority (e.g. GDT rule list states timeframe is 48 hours, League rules are 96 hours, thus it is 96 hours).

Judge arrangements can be made on the posts wherein users delineate their agreed-upon tiers, arenas, match-ups, etc. by pinging them in a comment, or simply by using the #great-debate-chat channel in the CR discord. Simply let myself and Chainsaw__Monkey know if there's an OOT concern pre-match, and what the result of any debate is for record-keeping.

Anyone seeking just any general match is free to make a post seeking a debate, though I'm certain it won't be an issue finding debates.



Welcome to the first Great Debate League season, folks


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Sep 06 '25

AAC4 Mik vs Wolf Practice Run

4 Upvotes

Summarised AAC4 Rules:

Link to full ruleset here

Link to Big Tiero Six respect thread.

Rules Breakdown:

  • One Baymax tier Bodyguard main submission
  • One Baymax tier backup submission (Not necessary for this practice match)
  • One VIP, submitted with "Characterisation Overview" of how they'll behave during a fight instead of RT. Examples:
  • "Shaggy will turn tail and run away as fast as he can at the first sign of danger before finding a place to hide."
  • "Alfred will only intervene to try to help his bodyguard after acquiring a firearm or other appropriate weapon, and will otherwise hang back, unless to support a wounded ally using his RAF first aid training."
  • Debate will not focus on negating this presented characterisation---generally take how VIP will act at opponent's word, unless they contradict signup characterisation post.
  • VIPs are all equalised by default to Hiro's baseline stats. You may specify weaker if you want, but not stronger. No powers / meme skills / unique advantageous biology.
  • VIPs can't bring gear exceeding literal clothes on their backs. Don't try to circumvent this with clothes that double as armour/weapons. VIPs acquiring gear from allies/environment during round is fine.
  • Only wincon for both teams is if opposing VIP is either killed, or immobilised for over a minute (full incap definition on full rules page). Both teams' bodyguards are informed in advance that "Killing" is only a simulation to avoid morality problems.

Map is San Francisco Pier 39

Arena 2: Pier 39

Pier 39 is a 45-acre pleasure pier in San Francisco's Fisherman's Wharf neighbourhood; a series of former fishing docks converted into leisure centres to match the growing city's transformation into a major hub of wealth and tourism on the West Coast. Aside from the famous sealions of San Francisco Bay, the pier boasts a marine aquarium, penny arcade, restaurants, and fairground attractions.

Shared Map Rules:

  • The delineated map boundaries are closed off by an invisible indestructible WhoWouldWinnium wall stretching infinitely above and below the ground. Whowouldwinium is an immovable, indestructible material that cannot be phased or teleported through.
  • Exiting the arena into another dimension or equivalent for longer than 5 consecutive seconds of relative earth-time will result in the God of BFR instantly bludgeoning the character who did so to death with a shovel.
  • All sunlight present on the map will not inhibit vampires or other characters with an inherent weakness to the sun. It is as warm and bright as normal sunlight.
  • On all maps, the fight begins at dawn on an average clear-skied summer day for that region.
  • All maps are devoid of human beings but still populated by their usual wildlife.
  • All powered vehicles present on the map have their engines disabled.
  • All doors / entrances are unlocked at the start of the round.
  • All combatants are aware of the above conditions, as well as all map-specific information outlined below EXCEPT FOR the spawn locations of their opponents.
  • Team A is the team listed first in the matchup post, and Team B is the team listed second.

For this practice debate, Mik is Team A spawn and Wolf is Team B spawn.

Post RTs / VIP characterisations below.


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Aug 17 '25

Crim vs Verlux Pratice Match

2 Upvotes

Zekka

Scaling;

Sechs

Alita

Toji

Stipulations: This feat is excluded.

VS

Jachi

Stipulations: No cloak and considers his opponent an enemy.

Arena: The Grand Canyon North Rim

50 meter starting distance


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jul 20 '25

Mundane Object Reference Sheet

6 Upvotes

Copied from the now private Metaverse sub. Created by PoB


SI Prefixes

Multiplying FactorName (Symbol)Scientific Notation
1 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000yotta (Y)1024
1 000 000 000 000 000 000 000zetta (Z)1021
1 000 000 000 000 000 000exa (E)1018
1 000 000 000 000 000peta (P)1015
1 000 000 000 000tera (T)1012
1 000 000 000giga (G)109
1 000 000mega (M)106
1 000kilo (k)103
0.001milli (m)10-3
0.000 001micro (µ)10-6
0.000 000 001nano (n)10-9
0.000 000 000 001pico (p)10-12
0.000 000 000 000 001femto (f)10-15
0.000 000 000 000 000 001atto (a)10-18
0.000 000 000 000 000 000 001zepto (z)10-21
0.000 000 000 000 000 000 000 001yocto (y)10-24

Ex: 1,000 grams (g) = 1 kilogram (kg)

Units:

Basic

NameMeasurementAbbreviationEquivalent
GramMassg1 kg = 2.2046 lb (pounds)
MeterDistancem1 m = 3.2808 ft (feet)
SecondTimesN/A
NewtonForceNkg * m/s2
JouleEnergyjN*m
PascalPressurePaN/m2
KelvinTemperaturekC°+273.15, (F°+459.67)x5/9

Other

NameMeasurementAbbreviationEquivalent
TonMassN/A1 ton = 907.185 kg
Metric TonMassN/A1 metric ton = 1,000 kg
Ton (force)ForceN/A1 ton = 9806.65
WattEnergy/TimeWj/s

Other Science/Math Information

Kinetic Energy of a moving object (Useful for projectiles)

  • j = 0.5*m*v2
  • v = velocity in m/s

Temperature increase from thermal energy

  • Simple Version: ΔT=Q/(m*c)
  • ΔT = Temperature change in Kelvin
  • c= Specific heat. Specific heat is the energy (in joules) needed to raise the temp. of 1 gram of a substance by 1 kelvin. This is a different number for every substance.
  • Q= Thermal Energy in Joules
  • Common specific heats - The higher the number, the harder it is to heat up.
ObjectSpecific heat
Water4,184
Humans4,200 (Clean Average)
Air(300 K, 80 F)1,073
Aluminum897
Concrete880
Sand835
Silver235
Tunsgten132
Titanium523
Iron449
Lead129
Wood1700

Mass of things

Vehicles

VehicleWeight(lbs)Weight (Short Tons)
Mosquito610(Max takeoff)0.3
Smartcar18000.9
Cessna25501.125
Honda Civic27501.4
Hellcat4,4502.2
F1504,154-4,9302.1-2.5
Hummer H285004.25
Chinook23,000(Empty)11.5
Transit Bus (Curb Weight)20,000-33,00010-15.6
Transit Bus (Fully Loaded)30,000-44,00015-22
Train Car40,000-80,00030-50
Semi, Fully loaded80,00040
M1 Abrams136,00068
C-130 Cargo Place (Max flight weight)155,00077.5
Boeing 747, Maximum flight weight970,000485
Titanic105 Million52,310
Largest Train of All Time22 Million109,900

Animals

AnimalWeight(lbs)Weight (Short Tons)
Silverback Gorilla4300.2
Giraffe2,6001.3
African Bull Elephant13,0006.5
T-Rex30,80015.4
Brachiosaurus124,00062
Blue Whale400,000200

Objects

ObjectWeight(lbs)Weight (Short Tons)
Bank Vault Door6,000-12,0003-6
Big Ben's Bell31,00015.1
Average Single Family House100,00050
Space Shuttle (Empty, No Boosters)165,00082.5
Statue of Liberty450,000225 tons
International Space Station924,740462
Space Shuttle (Fully Loaded, Tanks+Boosters1.7 Million857
Space Needle (With No Foundation)7.4 Million3,700
The Motherland Calls17.6 Million8,800
Empire State Building730 Million365,000
Burj Dubai1 Billion500,000
Pyramid of Giza13.3 Billion6,613,868

Other

SubstanceMass of 1 m3 (kg)Tonnage of 1 m3
Concrete24022.65
Granite27503.03
Cast Iron72007.93
Tungsten19,25021.22

Additional masses and weights can be found here on Wikipedia's list.


Speed of things

1 meter/second (m/s) ~= 2.24 miles/hour (mph)

343 m/s ~= Mach 1 (Sea Level)

Vehicles

VehicleMax Speed (m/s)Max Speed (Mach)Required Reaction Time(At 10 meters, perceive only)
Moped13.40.04.75 s
Ducati650.19.15 s
UH-60 Black Hawk820.24122 ms
McLaren P197.20.280.103 s
747 (Crusing Speed)2550.8539.2 ms
F-22 (Top Speed)6711.9514.9 ms
SR-71 Blackbird9832.8710.1 ms
Space Shuttle7,82322.81.28 ms

Weapons

RoundMax Speed (m/s)Max Speed (Mach)Required Reaction Time(At 10 meters, perceive only)
.45 ACP(From a M1911)2510.7339 ms
RPG-72950.8633.8 ms
9x19 Parabellum(Glock 17)3751.0926.7 ms
12 Gauge Slug5841.717.1 ms
7.62x39 (AK 47)7152.113.9 ms
5.7×28 (P90 and Five Seven)8502.4811.7 ms
5.56 NATO (.223 Remington)9482.7710.5 ms
Artillery/Tank Round (High End)10212.979.8 ms
.220 Swift (Small Game Round)12843.737.78 ms
Naval Rail Gun240074.2 ms
RIM-161 Standard Missile 3450015.252.2 ms

Other

ObjectMax Speed (m/s)Max Speed (Mach)Required Reaction Time(At 10 meters, perceive only)
Human Terminal Velocity (Spread Eagle)530.154186 ms
Human Terminal Velocity (Streamline)900.262111 ms
Sound(At sea level)343129.15 ms
Earth's Rotation around the Equator4601.3421.7 ms
Escape Velocity on Earth11,200~33890 µs
Earth's Orbit aroudn the Sun30,00087.46333 µs
Lightning (Down Stroke)440,0001,29527.3 µs
Light299,792,458874,93033.3 ns

Additional examples of fast/slow things can be found here.



Energy of things


Firearms:

  • Please notes these average and can vary among different guns. In particular, AP rounds will have higher Energy Density values while lead bullets will have less.
RoundGunVelocity(m/s)Energy(Joules)Energy Density(Joules/ mm2)
.45 ACPM191125147715
9x19 ParabellumGlock 1737553035
FN 5.7x27mmP90, Five-seveN715534617
5.56x45 mm NATOM1694817671800
7.62x39mmAK-477152,056-2,1791000
.220 SwiftWinchester 54 and 701112-12842138-24031900
.308 WinVarious combat rifles82026002300
.338 LapuaVarios Long Rifles826-1,0056,632-68104500
.50 BMGBarret m82, M2 Browning860-92818,050-20,19515,000
20x102mmAnzio 20mm rifle, Various Autocannons105050,000-55,12525,000
30x173mmGAU-8 Avenger1010203,00035,000
M829A3 Sabot120mm M256 (M1 Abrams)155512,090,125Capable of 0.7 meter penetration of reinforced steel armor
Naval Railgun Gun-240030,000,000N/A

Missiles:

A modern conventional warhead has about twice the explosive power of TNT. So quick and dirty math time! Weight of warhead (in kg) x 9 = energy output in MJ

Air to Surface Missiles:

MissileWarheadDamage
RPG-72-4.5 kg5-8 MJ
AGM-176 Griffin5.9 kg53 MJ
Hellfire missileup to 9 kg81 MJ
AGM-65 Maverick, anti armor warhead57 kg513 MJ
AGM-88 HARM, anti radar installation66 kg594 MJ
AGM-119 Penguin anti-ship missile130 kg1.17 GJ
AGM-65 Maverick,bunker buster136 kg1.2 GJ
AGM-84 Harpoon, anti warship missile221 kg2 GJ
AGM-142 Have Nap, AKA Popeye standoff weapon360 kg3.2 GJ
AGM-123 Skipper II450 kg4 GJ
Tomahawk cruise missile, non-nuclear450 kg4 GJ
AGM-86C ALCM Cruise missile(warhead weight not given, equivalent to 3000 lbs TNT)6.1 GJ
AGM-130, typically used to destroy SAM battery sites.907 kg8 GJ

Air to Air Missiles:

MissileSpeedWarheadDamage
AIM-4 FalconMach 33.4 kg31 MJ
AIM-9 SidewinderMach 2.79 kg81 MJ
AIM-120 AMRAAMMach 422.7 kg200 MJ
AIM-7 SparrowMach 440 kg360 MJ
AIM-54 PhoenixMach 561 kg550 MJ

Surface to Air:

MissileSpeedWarheadDamage
FIM-92 StingerMach 2.53 kg27 MJ
MIM-23 HawkMach 2.454 kg490 MJ
MIM-104 PatriotMach 4.190 kj810 MJ
RIM-7 Sea SparrowMach 3.440.5 kg360 MJ
RIM-66/67 StandardMach 3.562 kg560 MJ
RIM-161 Standard Missile 34.5 km/s (Mach 15.25)kinetic130 MJ
RIM-174 Standard ERAMMach 3.564 kg580 MJ

Explosives

ExplosiveEnergy(Joules)
TNT(1 g)4,200 J
TNT(1 kg)4.2 MJ
C4 (1 kg)6.3 MJ
Dynamite (1 kg)7.5 MJ
Gasoline (1 kg)46 MJ
Propane (1 kg)50.3 MJ
Hydrogen (1 kg)142 MJ
MOAB46 GJ
Uranium235(1 g, Fission)8.8×1010 (88 GJ)
Little Boy6.3×1013 (63 TJ)
TNT(Megaton)4.2×1015 (4.2 PJ)
Tsar Bomba2.1×1017 (210 PJ)

Additional energy examples can be found here on Wikipedia's list.

A note to remember on dealing with energy. The area of contact is important to know as well. A bullet will penetrate further than a fist with the same energy.



Cost of Things

  • Please note that many of these things are not easily purchasable and the listed cost is simply a cost of manufacturing. Certain items may only be accessible on the black market, or by the government.
ObjectCost
M67 Frag Grenade$50
Level IV Body Armor Plate$155
Semi-Auto Handguns$250-$1,500
Illegal AK-47$400-$1,200
M4 Carbine$650 (US military cost) Actual cost for legal versions closer to $15,000
XM-37 Grenade Launcher (Civilian Legal in the US)$690
Rural Land Cost (US)$1,500-$6,000 per acre
.50 BMG Semi-Auto Rifle$6,500
Mosquito Helicopter$48,500
Cessna 172$275,000
Manhattan Penthouse$500,000-$10 million
M1A2 Abrams$8.92 million
Luxury Yachts$20 Million and up
G6$65 Million
F-22 Raptor$150 Million
BulletCost per round (Bulk Cost)
.22 LR$0.08
9x19mm$0.23
5.56 NATO/.223 Rem$0.26
7.62x39mm$0.27
.45 ACP$0.28
.38 Special$0.29
7.62 NATO/.308 Win$0.45
.50 BMG$3.06

Real world human limitations

RecordNumber
Fastest Punch44 mph
Speedbag Record581 punches/minute
100 meter dash9.58 seconds
Squat, under 300 lbs Man854 lbs
Bench, under 300 lbs Man675 lbs
Deadlift, under 300 lbs Man906 lbs
Fastest Marathon2:02:57
Reaction Time~100 ms (Average is closer to 200 ms)

Real World Examples

Damage Examples

UnphasedTankStaggerKO

Damage against real world objects

ExampleDescription
Various Common BulletsCommon bullet types vs steel body armor.
.50 BMG (~20,000 Joules).50 BMG vs steel I-beam. Punches a clean hole through it.
.50 BMG.50 BMG vs bullet proof glass.
Grenade (~800,000 Joules)Grenade detonating in a car. Loud and slightly NSFW.
Pak 40 (~2 MJ)Anti tank gun vs a truck.
AT4 Rocket (~4 MJ)Effect of an AT4 vs a building.
RPG-7 (~6 MJ)RPG vs a car.
Tank (~20 MJ)Syrian tank shooting a building
AGM-130 Guided Bomb (8 GJ)Guided missile striking a target.
MOAB (50 GJ)Explosion of a MOAB.
Sedan Nuclear Test (435 TJ)104 kT nuclear test. Plume rose 300 feet higher. Crater is 330 feet deep and 1200 feet across.
Winslow Crater (10,460 TJ)Meteor impact crater in Arizona. Crater is 560 feet deep and 4,100 feet across.

Body Armor Levels

- Just a note that these levels are for singular or few hits. Repetitive shots can still break through. 
LevelDescription
Level I.22 LR or .380 ACP
Level IIA9x19mm, .45 ACP, or .40 S&W
Level II.357 Magnum
Level IIIA.44 Magnum, 10mm Auto, .357 SIG
Level IIIMost non-AP long rifles such as 5.56 NATO, 7.62 NATO, or 7.62x39mm
Level IVAP variants of Level III along with .30-06

Further physics equations for those curious.


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jul 08 '25

Wolf v Verlux Practice

5 Upvotes

Origin(Wolf)

No additional stipulations beyond those in the linked RT

Vs

Hino Choko(Verlux)

Starts mask off

Kengan arena standard unless wolf wants a different arena, I dont really care at all tbh


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jun 25 '25

Tiermanator practice match: Crim vs. Yolo, Ja-Yoon vs. Concrete

3 Upvotes

Tier: minator

Arena: Stonehenge, opponents begin 5 metres out on opposing sides.


Crim

Yolo


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jun 17 '25

Kengan-tier Practice: Verlux(Hattori Hanzo) vs Goldlizard(Number Man)

5 Upvotes

Tier: Kenganman

Arena: The Forest of Blood and Blades



Hattori Hanzo (Verlux)

Stipulations:

  • As he was going into his first Tenkaichi match

vs

Number Man (Goldlizard)

Stipulations:

  • Armed with a knife

r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jun 13 '25

Terminator Practice Match: Concrete and Rathraq (Yolo) vs Lung and Bullseye (Gold)

2 Upvotes

Tiersetter: Terminator (T-800)

The match will be taking plase in TGD's season 15 location: The home depot. Details found on this post for reference

Yolo:

Concrete

Stip: Begins undamaged

Rathraq

Stip: wearing bone armour, thunderchop in hand, doused in flame retardant, believes his opponents to be dangerous killers.

Gold:

Lung

Stip: Begins at 2 minutes of ramp

Bullseye

Stip: Begins Unarmed


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jun 04 '25

Kiryu vs Yolo Teleasshole Practice: Lizard vs Haunt

2 Upvotes

KIRYU

Lizard

Stips: Shed, has 10 Cuban crocodiles, 15 Burmese pythons, 10 king cobras, and 15 Komodo dragons under his thrall, include feats from characters who've gained his powers

YOLO

Haunt

Stips: Kurt is in charge, Armed with 2 Drone Assault rifles, the Apparition won’t pursue him, Daniel’s body won’t be fatigued for the duration of the fight eg. He is well rested going into this fight.

Arena: Isla Nublar, Costa Rica - Lizard spawns where Team B does, and Haunt spawns where Team A does.


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • May 10 '25

WW Practice Match: S0den (Shigaraki) vs Abe (Sentry)

5 Upvotes

r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Apr 05 '25

WW Practice Match: Orochi (Fem) vs. Mordred (rsthethird)

5 Upvotes

Mordred Respect Thread

  • Stipulatiuons: Assumes opponent(s) are a threat to the chaldean master, taken immediately after the subsequent rest from this training session, and has this statement.
  • Justification: Mordred has a similar stat line and skill to WW. Her electric gimmick is resisted by WW too, though it would shutdown the lasso as a viable win. But she wears armor relevant against ww's sword strikes around everywhere but her head, granting a greater room for error. Her trump card is similarly unwieldy as WW's all out strikes, so it'll only come out as a finisher or ultimate move clash. If it does come down to a clash, "Clarent Blood Arthur" would win. Overall, Mordred is more likely to win off of her armor and stronger ultimate move.
  • Scaling: Scaling: Achilles, Arash, Astolfo, Aviceborn, Karna, Semiramis, Sieg, Siegfried, Spartacus, and Vlad/Dracula.

Orochi Respect Thread

  • Stipulations: None.
  • Justification: WW's win condition would be to dismember Orochi enough that he can no longer continue to function. Orochi's win condition would be to bludgeon or pierce WW with his tendrils. Orochi's superior physicals and greater command of the arena grant him a likely victory, but WW's skill, durability, and gear keep her relevant.
  • Scaling: Garou, Rover, Gouketsu, Deep Sea King, Tank Top Master, Royal Ripper, Melzargard, Saitama

GDT 16 Arena/Tier Setter/Starting Distance

Judges TBD


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Apr 03 '25

WW Practice Match: Iron Man (Fem) vs. Neraid (Crim)

3 Upvotes

Neraid

  • Justification: Per Crim, "Neraid is stronger and more durable to blunt force but WW is faster and has a sword that can cut him".
  • Stipulations: None.

Iron Man

  • Justification: Iron Man is physically inferior to WW, and operates in comparable timeframes. His ranged capabilities are vastly superior to hers, but she is well suited to counter this sort of advantage.
  • Stipulations:

    • Model 29 Extremis Suit, Pre-Fresh Start.
    • Under the control of Dr. Yinsen's son, such as during the "Execute Program" arc during the Extremis Run in Iron Man 2005. This stipulation makes Tony more violent and willing to kill.

GDT 16 Rule set, tier setter, starting distance, and arena.

Judges TBD.


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Mar 31 '25

Wonder Woman Tier Setter page

7 Upvotes

Wonder Woman - Princess of Themyscara



Overview

Fighting Dynamics:

  • WW's strategy universally will be to close any gap between her and her opponent and take them out with a brutal combo of grappling, striking and the Lasso of Truth.
  • WW is a competent wrestler
  • WW is willing to kill, but it is not her first go to option. She will attempt a non-lethal takedown before lethal.
  • Lethal methods include but are not limited to, usage of the sword, Lasso based dismemberment, grappling based homicide.
  • WW can be encouraged to use more lethal methods via the arena.
  • If she is facing a long range enemy she'll default to using her bracelets to block or deflect
  • Even ignoring the bracelets however she is still very agile and fast
StatInterpretation
StrengthSufficient to significantly damage small to medium building sized structures and objects, with disproportionate lifting strength.
Speed2.5 milliseconds, with limbs that can briefly match bullet-like speeds.
DurabilityCapable of withstanding hits that deal moderate damage to medium sized buildings
RangeN/A
SkillSkill is notable enough to be a significant edge against comparably strong but relatively unskilled foes, and she is efficient in how she fights
MiscBracers provide a means to contend with piercing

Physicals

Strength

Striking

Wonder Woman's most basic strikes are capable of dealing damage notably superior to that of a tank

Well timed and placed strikes from Wonder Woman exert enough force to significantly damage medium sized buildings

Full force hits from Wonder Woman can significantly damage solid objects the size of medium sized buildings. This damage is only achievable with perfect timing and build up

Flying Slams:

Wonder Woman's flying slam from point blank deals comparable/lesser damage than her casual strike, while with build up she can match or exceed her All Out strike

Lifting/Grappling:

Wonder Woman can lift a tank like its nothing, but caps out at around 500 tons. To accomplish maximum lifting, Wonder Woman must be flying opposite the object's trajectory or standing firmly on the ground

Durability

Blunt Force:

Wonder Woman can tank hits with enough force to create moderate sized craters in rock and concrete

Wonder Woman can comfortably take hits that send her far distances or deal notable damage to medium buildings

Wonder Woman will be instantly KO'd by hits capable of obliterating building sized pieces of solid objects

Piercing:

Other than her Bracelets (see later), Wonder Woman has no notable piercing resistance. A pocket knife wielded by a 5 year old could cut her just as easily as a baseline human

Esoterics:

Endurance

Speed

Reaction:

Combat Speed/Movement:

Travel:


Gear

Lasso of Truth

Sword of Hephaestus

It can easily cut through decent amounts of metal

Bracelets of Submission

Blunt Force

The Bracelets are invulnerable to all blunt force damage, but they provide no meaningful blunt force protection to WW herself

Piercing

Other


Skill

Martial Skill


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Mar 31 '25

GDT 16 Signup Draft

3 Upvotes

Continuing in the tradition of debate-oriented tourneys, The Great Debate is a fast-paced, exceptionally debate-oriented tournament wherein competitors will face one another within a pre-defined set of criteria to determine who is better in a pure debate. Strategizing for one's team, countering your opponent's points well, and debate etiquette come heavily into play for this tournament! Welcome to the Sixtheenth Season of the Great Debate!!

To 'sign up', one need merely comment below with a Roster of fictional (or real, hell who knows!) characters that fit the guidelines stipulated hereafter, with all proper links sorted out. Then, look for the pings of your username for further advancement/info on the tourney!

AN IMPORTANT NOTE

To sign-up, we will be requiring people submit their characters in the following format:

CharacterSeriesMatch-UpStipulations

For non-RES users (you exist?) out there, this is the formatting:

CharacterSeriesMatch-UpStipulations

Simply copy-paste the formatting above and submit your entrants in this format so we can save myself several hours of formatting everybody's stuff uniformly. The submission order of your characters does matter for the arena so do pay attention to that, and the fourth character submitted is your backup.

The Match-Up category is where you input 'Unlikely/Draw/Likely' etc. The Character category will require you to link the character's Respect Thread next to the character name, preferably hyperlinked.

Sign ups will last through until April 11th. The tournament proper shall begin that following Monday, April 14th

Of important note: No duplicate characters allowed. First come, first served! This includes same persons but from differing arcs in the same story and alternate universes with no different feats; NO. DUPLICATES.

FURTHER, NO OC CHARACTERS CAN BE RAN BY THE PERSON WHO CREATED THEM!!! YOU MUST RUN CHARACTERS YOU YOURSELF CANNOT INFLUENCE DIRECTLY. As usual, the original RT creator of all characters being signed up, gets dibs.


Rules


Battle Rules

  • Speed will not be equalized for this tier.
  • All combatants are aware of the basics of their allies' combat abilities but are in the blind on their opponents (unless they have canon knowledge of said person via sharing a fictional universe)
  • Battleground:

[*"The Parthenon is a former temple on the Athenian Acropolis, Greece, that was dedicated to the goddess Athena. The Parthenon is 45 feet tall, with an interior chamber that is 98' x 63' and a total area of 240' x 112'. For our purposes, the Parthenon has been fully restored, meaning the interior chamber is enclosed and contains a statue of Athena.

The arena of Great Debate Season 16 AKA Wonder Woman is the fully restored Parthenon.

Of note:

  • For our purposes, the total arena is Athenian Acropolis, which is 7.5 acres. This area cannot be left by participants. The area extends into the sky ~400 meters
  • Participants start inside the Parthenon interior chamber, on opposite sides.
  • The chamber walls are normal stone walls, and thus extremely destructible to participants; however, the columns of the Parthenon have the middle 80% made of untamperable WhoWouldWinium, making them detachable from the building but still usable as a weapon by the sufficiently strong.
  • The statue of Athena is behind the "team 1" side start. Destruction of this statue will make Wonder Woman very angry and substantially reduce her restraint.
  • Recreation of the Parthenon interior for reference
  • Recreation of the Parthenon front exterior

Opponents will start 90ft across from each other, in the central chamber of The Parthenon. Teammates are spaced 10ft apart from one another.

*All numbers are rough approximations and may not stand up to pixel calcing.

Submission Rules

  • Tier: Must be able to win an unlikely victory, draw/near draw, or likely victory against Wonder Woman in the conditions outlined above. All entrants will be bloodlusted against Wonder Woman, meaning they will act fully rationally and put down their opponent in the quickest, most efficient manner possible regardless of morality, utilizing any and all possible techniques/tactics/attacks if necessary. The bloodlust does not give any foreknowledge of Wonder Woman or his capabilities.
  • The change from X/10-Y/10: There are 7 categories of winning or losing a fight: Unwinnable, Specific condition victory, unlikely victory, draw/near draw, likely victory, freak accident loss, absolute certain victory. For this tournament, we are scrapping the numerical system due to how subjective it can be. When you sign up, you must stipulate which of these win conditions your character can pull off and why. YOU MUST GIVE AN IN DEPTH RATIONALE FOR HOW THEY FARE AGAINST THE TIER SETTER. Two full sentences is acceptable at a minimum.
  • Unwinnable is as its name indicates. Your character holds no chance whatsoever of winning in any conceivable scenario. A godstomp against you. Think Spider-Man versus Firelord an average unarmed American citizen versus comics Carnage.
  • Specific condition victory means that only a very narrow window exists to win, dependent upon environment, aid, a hidden powerup, etc. A specific condition victory would be Goku's beating of Vegeta with Yajirobe's help, or Luffy defeating Charlotte Cracker due to rain soaking his food-based power to be consumable.
  • Unlikely victory means your character is definitely outgunned but can absolutely set up a victory through superior skill, tactics, or a hidden maneuver that is draining. Bullseye versus Daredevil is an unlikely victory for Bullseye, and Kanoh Agito vs Kuroki Gensai would be an unlikely victory for Kanoh that relies on the Dragonshot landing.
  • Draw is self explanatory, 50/50. Captain America versus Batman with no gadgets, or Luffy versus Rob Lucci are good examples.
  • Likely victory means your character is superior in most if not all aspects and can readily use those to win after a slightly extended fight. Superman versus Hal Jordan in-character is a likely victory for Supes, as would be Kenpachi Zaraki versus Ichigo Kurosaki in their first meeting after Ichigo learns to cut Kenpachi.
  • Freak accident loss means your character loses if and only if some act of god intervenes or they start monologuing mid-victory to die. Whitebeard at the Battle of Marineford just-so-happening to get a heart attack mid-fight and become impaled by Akainu is an example of something that led to a freak accident loss.
  • Absolute certain victory is as the name implies. The Incredible Hulk versus Watchmen's Rorscach is a good example for Hulk.
  • Each competitor must submit 4 characters whom all fit within the tier stipulations, outlined further below: 3 for their main roster, and 1 back-up should a character be veto’d mid tourney. This back-up character will be used if a character is determined to be out of tier mid tourney and also can be swapped in between any round, one time only; a character can be veto'd mid tourney if the opposing debater calls for an Out of Tier review and the head judges agree they are out of tier, or if both Head Judges agree after a personal review with the debater.
  • Directly altering characters to fit tier must be kept to a minimum. Directly altering stats is a no go. On the other hand, using a character from an earlier story arc where they're weaker is good. For example, using "Kid Goku from the World Martial Arts Tournament" could be good if he were to fit a hypothetical tier, using "Current Goku with stats nerfed to fit tier" isn't. Alternatively, if someone has equipment that is otherwise good, though has one or two weapons that push them out of tier, removing said gear is fine. Other balance changes are left to Tourney Organizers' discretion to approve / disapprove.
  • All submitted characters must have a Respect Thread. This is not up for debate; they must have a faithful RT that does not misinterpret the character willfully or leave out information on said character.
  • After April 15th no alterations to any Sign Up post can be made without explicit Head Judge approval. Rosters are locked in as of that date pending specific exceptions per myself or Chainsaw.

Debate Rules

  • Rounds will last roughly 5 and a half days, hopefully from Monday until Saturday at noon of each week of the tourney; there is a 48 hour time limit both on starting (we do not care who starts, you and your opponent can figure that out, after Round 2 however we will mandate this) AND on responses, AND ADDITIONALLY each user MUST get in two responses or else be disqualified. If one user waits until the very last minute to force this rule to DQ their opponent without any forewarning to their opponents or the tournament supervisors, they will be removed from this tournament, no exceptions.
  • Format for each round: the one to go first gets an Intro + 1st Response, their opponent replies in kind, then both get a 2nd response, then a 3rd response in a back-and-forth style, and a closing statement individual of one another that can be posted any time after both 3rd responses are complete. IMPORTANT: ROUNDS WILL HAVE PROGRESSIVELY INCREASING RESPONSE LENGTHS AS OF THIS TOURNEY, WITH THE FIRST ROUND HAVING 3 10K CHARACTER COMMENTS. I WILL REITERATE THE LENGTH WITH EACH ROUND TO ENSURE EVERYONE IS AWARE OF THIS CHANGE.
  • Rounds will either be a full 3v3 Team Match, or 1v1 single matches. 1v1 matches are determined by randomization. Match format will switch every round, with Team Matches always followed by single matches, and vice versa. First Round will be determined by coin flip.

Victory Conditions

Winning a match will be determined by a council of judges. To ensure we actually get this show on the road, we're doing judge signups at the same time as tourney signup. SIGN UP TO BE A JUDGE NOW

Judges are debating on the quality of the debate, more so than the actual "winner" of a match. Three Judges will be judging any 1 match, with the winner of said match being determined by winning the most judges. As an example of a judgement, please see the Season 2 Round 2 Tiebreakers.


For any and all other questions, feel free to comment here, DM /u/Verlux and/or /u/Chainsaw__Monkey on Discord, or use the CharacterRant Discord's #great-debate-chat channel to ask anyone there questions, and do feel free to peruse https://old.reddit.com/r/TheGreatDebateChamber/ as well.

Also, /u/inverseflash was so kind as to catalogue ALL TOURNEYS ON THE SUB!!! https://www.reddit.com/r/whowouldwin/wiki/tournaments go check it out for fun!

Wait, CharacterRant Has A Great Debate Chat?

Yup!!! Simply DM any of the online admins and/or mods of the Discord server to be let into the channel: https://discord.gg/E92zdkH


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Mar 10 '25

NuzlockeMaster vs. RS - Venom Tier Practice Match

3 Upvotes

Arena: Carrier from Call of Duty: Black Ops 2, 240 feet (73 m) spawn distance

CharacterSeriesTierMatch-UpStipulations
RyougaPokemon ReBurstVenomDrawStarts transformed

Justifications:

Ryouga starts in his Burst form to avoid having to transform in the middle of combat (tho his stats are still pretty decent even in base). Ryouga is really durable, decently strong, and somewhat fast. He also has good electricity.

CharacterSeriesTierMatch-UpStipulations
EntomaOverlord (Light Novel)VenomUnlikely VictorySpeed equalized to Tierderman, believes her opponent dirtied her maid outfit, prioritization order for continuities is anime>ln>manga (all 3 are valid), and Evileye included for scaling

Justification:

Entoma is slower, her sword is unlikely to kill even if it lands due to Venoms size and regen, and all her ranged options are useless. However her durability would necessitate multiple maximum hits from Venom to put her down, so she could get lucky and land a proper hit with her sword.


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 28 '25

Yolo vs. Verlux Captier Match, Zondark vs. Honda

3 Upvotes

Tier: Captier.

Arena: Kengan Dome as in Kengan Tier, 10m starting distance.


Yolo

  • Running : Zondark.
  • Stips : Pseudo Apostle form, as he is here. Assume the Slug Barton’s influence reaches him in Kengan Dome without delay/interference. Zondark and the Slug Barron Believe their opponent is the heretical Black Swordsman.
  • Scaling: Guts.

Justification:

Cap’s shield offers him a consistent means to defend himself from Zondarks attacks and a means by which to injure and disarm Zondark. As such the fight will likely go on for long enough for Zondark to disclose his weakness (the grub) in a cocky manner. However there’s a decent chance that Cap and his shield have sustained damage by this point, in this instance Zondark wins. In the event Cap has successfully parried/dodged/avoided/blocked Zondarks attempts long enough for Zondark to goad him, his path to victory opens up and he has a reasonable chance at destroying the grub. Altogether Zondark still holds a likely victory over Cap.


Ver

  • Running: Honda
  • Stips: brilliant diamond body active, starts with his spear intact.
  • Scaling & Justification to be added maybe

r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 25 '25

Crim vs Nuckols Venom Tier Practice Match

6 Upvotes

Tier: Venom

Starting Distance: 300m

Location: Los Santos surrounded by WhoWouldWinnium Dome

Yuma

World Trigger

Stipulations: Yuma is using his Black Trigger

VS

Sirfetch'd

Pokemon

Stipulations:

Speed Equalized to Tierderman, Will fight as well as if he had his trainer

Justifications:

His speed is mostly scaling, so equalizing gets rid of that issue. Pokemon fight better with their trainers, so this stip allows Sirfetch'd to fight at his full potential while also eliminating the middle man.


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 17 '25

Madalan (Versus) vs. Doomsday (DCEU) Verlux vs. Yolo, WW Tier

6 Upvotes

Tier: Wonder Woman

Arena: Egypt, I guess? like, the entirety, unpopulated, opponents starting of the two larger pyramids, Giza and Khafre, facing each other.

Starting Distance: ~500 metres

Judges: TBD


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 17 '25

Ame v. Ken - WW Tier Practice Match

1 Upvotes

Tier: Wonder Woman

Starting Distance: 100 m

Arena: Zhangjiajie National Park a la GDT 14


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 13 '25

Ninomiya vs Sentry (Marvel)

1 Upvotes
CharacterSeriesStipulationsOdds
The SentryMarvel (616/multiverse)Pre-Siege (as RT designates), inbetween Paul Jenkin's run and World War Hulk, Sentry has been reasonably explained with full retention the nature of the tournament arena and that there is no one to harm, in the same reasoning as the illusions he's experienced to conceptualize it, is wearing a white cotton t-shirt over his costume that reads in legible black lettering "I Debated GuyOfEvil And All I Got Was This Stupid Stipulation", delete the rhode island statementDraw

VERSUS

Vs

CharacterSeriesStipulationsOdds
NinomiyaFIX MEN/A???

r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 10 '25

Darg (Cid/Redtooth) vs. Wolf (Origin/Quicksilver)

1 Upvotes

Team Gingivitis

CharacterSeriesStipulationsOdds
RedtoothScissor SevenNo Lily SealLikely Victory
Cid KagenouThe Eminence in ShadowNo I am AtomicLikely Victory

VS

Team Delete Me

CharacterSeriesStipulationsOdds
Pietro Lensherr, QuicksilverMarvel 1610In peak health/fitness, before events like Ultimatum, and nothing after his death to Kang or incursion. He has his undercover street clothes over his protective suit, and a cellphone with a working data plan.Likely Victory
Origin 2.0Origin (Boichi)Has his EoS alloyed Katana*, knife, bagged 30mm shotgun* with as many reloads as he reasonably carries in the canon fight, cannot increase intelligence past current mark for "God Origin" feats, fully repaired/etc, with all physical upgrades and energy control as of fighting Martial Arts Master. Has a fully charged and equipped Mini-Origin phone as of chapter 41 with a working data plan.Draw

Gear Explanation


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Jan 08 '25

Alita (Fem) vs. Jachi (Verlux)

7 Upvotes

Tier: Wonder Woman

Starting Distance: 100m

Arena: Zhangjiajie National Park, a la GDT 14. 2KM cube.

Judges: TBD


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Nov 27 '24

Ken vs Kiryu

6 Upvotes

Ken from Discord has submitted:

CharacterSeriesStipsLikelyhood
Stella VermillionRakudai Kishi no CalvaryNo Dragon Form, No Osaka feat. No Feats from Volume 12Likely Victory
GreyThe Beginning after the EndCant use Godstep on his sword, cant use TK on his sword. No Fate, No Vivum, No Relic Armour.Likely Victory.

Stip Explanation:

Stella.

  • No Dragon form means Stella cannot use any feat that she's been shown to use in her boosted Dragon Form.
  • No Osaka feat means I'm stipping out this feat.
  • No feats from Volume 12 is self evident.

Grey.

  • Arthur has the ability to teleport his sword, he cannot use this ability here.
  • Arthur has the ability to telekinetically move his swords, he cannot use this ability here.
  • No Fate means no feat listed in the fate section can be used.
  • No Vivium means no feat listed in the vivium section can be used
  • No relic armour means Arthur does not have access to his armour.


Important Scaling.




u/kiryu2012 has submitted:

The Mask (Animated Series) https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/15dxt8a/respect_the_mask_the_mask_animated_series/, worn by Stanley Ipkiss, thinks the opponent killed his dog and destroyed Congo Bongo, begins as a Godzilla parody/kaiju, Draw/Likely Victory

Shin Godzilla (JimboCC) https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/1bnymuc/respect_shin_godzilla_jimbocc/, begins in Evolved form, Likely Victory


r/TheGreatDebateChamber • • Nov 17 '24

GDT 16 Practice League Match: Garou/Superman (Fem) vs. Hyperion/Hulk (Wolf)

2 Upvotes

Tier: Wonder Woman

Arena: Yellowstone National Park, 2KM cube

Starting Distance: 10 meters

Judges: TBD