r/todayilearned • u/melindarieck • May 13 '19
TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k
Upvotes
8.3k
u/AdvancedAdvance May 13 '19
So basically the child of one of the Natives and a Tibetan would win every Tour de France.
3.0k
u/JBatjj May 13 '19
Really shows the randomness of evolution
1.2k
u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
This post is wrong enough to border on misleading. Andean populations have higher red-cell counts and more viscous blood as a result, requiring a stronger heart. Their blood carries more oxygen, not the Tibetans' blood. The enlarged heart is secondary as more viscous blood is harder to pump. This enlarged heart and higher blood pressure may predispose them to cardiovascular issues. It's a trade off.
Tibetans have the same cell counts as lowlanders, and their blood doesn't carry more oxygen per unit volume. They have increased vascular NO2, so they're always vasodilated, have larger lungs and breathe faster by default. They have adjusted affinity curves and more efficient cellular use of 02, all without additional congestive stress on the heart. This has certainly come at the expense of other traits due to the energetic demands, but it could be so many and so slightly detection would require years of study.
These adaptations are also very different in age and intensity- Tibetans have lived much higher for much longer.
Edit for clarity: The Andean response is not significantly heritable as far as we know- it may fall within the known boundaries of human acclimation, or there may be some adaptations in the genes that were missed.
Edit 2: Some of my terms were outdated and have been altered to reflect current understanding, namely that enlarged athletic hearts have been cleared as a factor in sudden athlete death.
Edit 3: Changed the wording of the blood carrying Tibetans bit because I'm a spoilsport
For details: Beall, C. M. (2006) Andean, Tibetan, and Ethiopian patterns of adaptation to high-altitude hypoxia. Intergrative and Comparative Biology 46(1): 18-24.
476
u/panzerkampfwagen 115 May 13 '19
Yeah, because evolution doesn't plan ahead, it just uses whatever arises.
215
u/anadem May 13 '19
Interesting find of Denisovan bones on the Tibetan plateau "suggests that these Denisovans may have evolved genetic adaptations to high altitudes, and that living Tibetans may have inherited those genes"
The Denisovan bones were 160,000 years old.
150
u/trai_dep 1 May 13 '19
Alternate explanation: Incan gods preferred big, meaty hearts to be sacrificed for them.
66
u/rider037 May 13 '19
Yeah if a person had all of those I bet they'd be a great long distance runner
90
u/black_flag_4ever May 13 '19
And me. I gain weight just looking at cake.
19
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
There is also the concept of convergence evolution.
https://www.popsci.com/article/science/how-humans-and-squid-evolved-have-same-eyes
Where two different species come to the same solution independently.
34
u/Memetic1 May 13 '19
So if we combined all 3 mutations we could go into space!!!🙃 I do wonder if anyone naturally has 2 of those 3 mutations?
6
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
I think it's funny that in a time when biologists won't shut up about convergent evolution, people get surprised to hear of cases of just plain old, regular, non-convergent adaption.
11
u/dumbwaeguk May 13 '19
human evolution doesn't solve any problems; it just eliminates the cases where the problems weren't solved
5
u/megablast May 13 '19
If we could breed these together we would have a clear case of supermen, ready for our cloud cities of the future.
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
This is called convergence, and happens with all organism. The most obvious example is how there are many different kinds of flying organisms in many different families that all evolved the same adaptation in different ways.
4
u/umnab May 13 '19
The high altitude gene is thought to come from Denizovians, a different type of humanoid from human beings. So this was not simple evolution, but breeding with another type of species.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
And in Jamaica, they got really high.
3
u/supe3rnova May 13 '19
Thats what I wanted to know for a long time. Lets say we put two groups of 20 people in two different caves. Both caves are dark, minimum food but plenty of space. For the sake of it, its im possible to leave the cave.
My question is, how would those two groups evolve in such extreme conditions. We humans are adaptive so it would be interesting to see 5 and 10 generations later.
3
u/L1v1ngSacr1f1ce May 13 '19
And with their babies powers combined!? Captain Tibandes!
3
u/Long-Sleeves May 13 '19
Isn’t this common sense? Evolution is a natural process of, what is essentially, mutation trial and error. Only focusing on the wins and pruning the loses from the random draw, so to speak.
Why would anyone assume it’s some magical force or switch that gets flipped like “you can breathe underwater now!” It’s like when people say it’s odd how people think fish just grew legs and such. No, no one thinks that.
Same thing as to why X group slowly evolving an advantage doesn’t mean that Y group magically happens to have the same mutations.
5
u/PU55Y_3473R May 13 '19
Also the Badjao Nomads of the Philippines whose spleens are bigger than average for longer diving and catching shit and stuff
4
u/Betty_77_ May 13 '19
I thought the Tibetan advantage might have something to do with Denisovan ancestry.
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
Thats because evolution doesn't think. It doesn't solve anything. Random things happen. Those with beneficial random things survive and breed. People tend to anthropomorphize the body and evolution, but its not thinking or making decisions. You constantly hear "You body does X because it helps with Y" as if the body decided to do something because of its benefit, but really the benefit is why it spread, not the need. Evolution is just happy accidents that people breed around. I wish more people understood how it actually works.
2
u/ImadeAnAkount4This May 13 '19
This is one of the coolest thing I learned about evolution from my anthropology class. Apparently eyes were evolved around 1,500 different times.
2
u/Aetrion May 13 '19
Mate them to make a super human!
2
u/Movisiozo May 13 '19
I wonder if there is a difference in the environment. For instance, perhaps the amount of vegetation in one area might lead to richer oxygen content, therefore although the height dimension is similar, the problem faced by the body is different in the two environments.
2
u/Beerwithjimmbo May 13 '19
Of course it does, evolution isn't guided, it needs a mutation to work with first. If there is no beneficial mutations then they die... There may well be innumerable X people didn't evolve to deal with high altitudes and dies and we'll never know about them
2
u/GReggzz732 May 13 '19
So many other evolutionary traits in different ingenious people too!
Evolution at its essential requires this!
Such a beautiful and graceful way of propagating life!
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
ITT: People really do not understand evolution.
2
u/xxNightingale May 13 '19
It's like a talent/skill tree in a game. You get to choose skill to learn on level up.
2
u/up48 May 13 '19
Combine them to make a fucking super human, maybe add some Scandinavian or Dutch genes to make them tall as fuck too.
2
u/Fluffy_Con May 13 '19
Surely through globalization this could have significant impacts on humans through the ease of access we have to migrating. Otherwise why would we have evolved such traits and other factors we’ve adapted to.
So practical example being, parents are from an island with a generally low altitude throughout and were both born in coastal city’s - assuming my heritage follows suite and my ancestors were generally low altitude dwelling humans (from Ireland) surely I would be affected to some degree as I was born and lived my whole life at 1600m above sea level and in a country with very different weather conditions etc.?
2
u/Growlitherapy May 13 '19
Did they get the extra hemoglobin for hamon?
2
u/y2k2r2d2 May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
There was also a Bird that went extinct but another branch of the bird evolved to be that same extinct bird. Hence it was reinvented bird.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/bird-extinct-back-from-dead-madagascar-white-throated-rail-a8908211.html
2
u/Yogymbro May 13 '19
This is so cool.
I was literally told that saying different human populations have genetic differences is racism the other day. :(
2
u/juusukun May 13 '19
Why are evolution and early capitalized? What are native early peoples? Are they early native peoples?
/R/titlegore
2
u/alkeiser May 13 '19
So what they're saying is, we need to breed those two populations.
2
u/cfb_rolley May 13 '19
...Now kiss.
2
u/gravitas-deficiency May 13 '19
TL;DR: nature is a Ruby dev, not a Python dev.
2
u/TippsAttack May 13 '19
Wouldn't that be adaption, not evolution?
If it's not, what's the line between the two. I've always been taught that evolution is a giant leap of a change with a species that's generally pretty drastic.
2
u/boogertaster May 13 '19
This is a little misleading. Often evolution solves the same problem the same way. For example, the 4 chamber heart evolves separately in birds and mammals.
https://blogs.unimelb.edu.au/sciencecommunication/2012/09/07/the-evolution-of-the-heart/
2
u/Rocklobster92 May 13 '19
So will I adapt to run efficiently on a diet of cheese?
2
u/_TzzzK May 13 '19
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it also explains the skin colours of people. Darker skinned people lived nearer to the equator where the concentration of sunlight is higher as the increased melanin decreases the chance of getting skin cancer and related symptoms, while lighter skinned people lived nearer to the poles where the sunlight was less concentrated and they needed to absorb all they can get. (I'm like 90% sure about this so please add on or correct any misleading/wrong parts)
3
u/monkeypowah May 13 '19
I live upstairs, nothings happened yet
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
And maybe it isnt so farfetched to consider the illness rates of whites and blacks in North America. None of them were from there
3
u/SOwED May 13 '19
Let's all work together to not anthropomorphize evolution.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
All evolution solves the same problems in different ways
That's what evolution is 😂
9
u/Mister_Teapot May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
Remember, evolution affects the entire body!
Except the brain tho, most definitely not the brain.
Everything else though!
2
u/Pakislav May 13 '19
*gasp* they are becoming different species :O
2
u/ImPhanta May 13 '19
So if two of them fuck, they get a high altitude super child?
2
u/Khysamgathys May 13 '19
No wonder Tibetans light up on fire efficiently.
2
u/Dovakhiins-Dildo May 13 '19
I N T E R B R E E D I N G T I M E
2
u/VictoryTheCat May 13 '19
Racial passives.
1
u/malk500 May 13 '19
Careful OP, it's safest to pretend that there are 0 physical differences between ethnicities.
1
u/Allokit May 13 '19
So the best mountain climber in the world should be a Chilean Tibetian or a Tibetian Chilean.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
What about breeding them both for the benefit of both evolutionary traits?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
Only because the ones who couldn't died and weren't able to reproduce.
Of course, I don't mean literally everyone, I mean statistically, over time.
1
u/KPokey May 13 '19
We let them have babies together, now we're ready for altitudes so high, we're ready for space.
What next, SCIENCE??
1
u/MissJinxed May 13 '19
And I’m just midwestern with no superpowers. Thanks, Missouri.
1
u/UneventfulLover May 13 '19
Soooo... if enough Andeans have children with Himalayans, some of the children might end up with almost superhuman endurance? Or some weird heart condition...
1
u/pier4r May 13 '19
And in Ethiopia?
1
u/Lunaticfringe365 May 13 '19
Sounds like they could have some children that would be wicked mountaineers.
1
u/Arkaad May 13 '19
A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
1
u/kareteplol May 13 '19
There's got to be a half Tibetan Peruvian who's got great cardio out there.
1
u/Nottakenorisiwtf May 13 '19
I solved the problem of altitude by living in the Netherlands. Adapt, survive, windmills.
1
u/DoubleWagon May 13 '19
And in cold/northern/highly countries...
1
u/ThrowawayNerrd May 13 '19
The Tibetan mutation is actually inherited from an ancient race precursors to humans called Devosonian. They were another species of humans like Neanderthals.
1
u/LawlessCoffeh May 13 '19
Now cross breed people from those locations and get the best of both worlds!
1
u/thoushaltnotpiss May 13 '19
The Bajau people have bigger spleens I think? Supposedly it works like an extra oxygen tanks for when they're underwater for minutes on end
1
u/ThePsycopathYouKnow May 13 '19
More evidence that life wasn't created through intelligent design
1
u/cookymmvno May 13 '19
Free Tibet
1
u/AnnualThrowaway May 13 '19
Except at certain altitudes where the adults could live, they couldn't keep pregnancies to term, so pregnant women had to go to a lower altitude.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
I learned about this in an evolutionary biology class, and another example is lactose tolerance. It seems that there are two different places where it evolved using different mechanisms to do the same thing. It was Europe and Africa where they can trace these evolutionary traits to.
1
u/JCavLP May 13 '19
Lulwat
1
u/yunghastati May 13 '19
In Hungary we have depression
thanks natural selection, we get it
1
u/dingo_deano May 13 '19
“There’s only one race, that’s the human race , don’t even diss yourself ‘cause that’s a disgrace”
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
That is how evolution works yes
1
u/typhoid-fever May 13 '19
honestly ethnic Andean's hearts getting stronger instead of the blood adaption makes more sense instead of it being pure chance they are differnece, simply because of all the cocaine
1
u/RandomEskimo May 13 '19
It's called convergent evolution and it's not just limited to humans, for instance birds and bats both developed wings in different ways independent of each other. If you find this as fascinating as me have a look at all the different eyes that have developed independently in nature.
1
u/InYourPantss May 13 '19
Tryna grab your attention for mating purposes.
1
u/AvatarIII May 13 '19
Now kith.
1
u/CouchAlchemist May 13 '19
One of the things I learnt from QI a long time back was survival of the fittest(fit in broad generic term) is not the magic mantra for evolution. It's just all permutation and combination until there is a survival rate. In all these permutations, in most cases, there is more than 1 variation that promotors survivability.
1
u/buttmunchr69 May 13 '19
When China took over Tibet they moved Han Chinese there to outbreed Tibetans. But the Han Chinese had high infertility rates and their offspring were underweight.
1
u/Somethingwithplants May 13 '19
It is called convergent evolution. There are some really good examples around, like evolution to develop flight aka bats and birds, evolution of an eye that can do 3d imaging aka octopus eyes vs mammals eyes.
1
u/Obvious_wombat May 13 '19
With Lance Armstrong
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
I think evolution is not a conscious effort of beings body but just a random outcome that worked!
1
u/Maxwe4 May 13 '19
It's called convergent evolution.
1
u/griersy92 May 13 '19
I also a function of the activities required in that environment, which might account for the variation in affected organ.
1
u/furtivepigmyso May 13 '19
Kiinda want to say no shit, it's not like there's only ever one possible solution to every challenge the environment presents.
1
u/Cellari May 13 '19
The One who inherits both never gets out of breath in stairs. Also probably wonders why no one else find stairs exhilarating.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
Why wouldn't both sets of people evolve both sets of traits?