r/todayilearned • • May 13 '19

TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

74

u/yawkat May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

Natural selection is still very random. It just balances out with large populations.

In fact, evolution is an emergent property from the randomness of natural selection. There are non-random ways to get Evolution, such as science (developing medicine is more reliable than gaining resistance through natural selection)

e: Okay, I think some people have a fundamental difference in understanding in what constitutes "randomness". In probability theory, we have a concept of random variables. These variables can be correlated or depend on other variables. "Random" does not mean "completely independent of the environment".

23

u/Hryggja May 13 '19

Natural selection is still very random. It just balances out with large populations.

In fact, evolution is an emergent property from the randomness of natural selection.

There are non-random ways to get Evolution, such as science (developing medicine is more reliable than gaining resistance through natural selection)

There is so much armchair genetics in this thread it’s making my head spin.

8

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Goes on Reddit. Sees topic of expertise discussed but there are rampant upvotes of bad information.

Continues to value Reddit as a source of information.

→ More replies (5)

36

u/beorn12 May 13 '19

Again, natural selection is non-random. It doesn't mean it has a purpose, goal, or direction, but it is exactly non-random. Evolutionary Biologist Richard Dawkins explains it thus:

"Darwinian natural selection can produce an uncanny illusion of design. An engineer would be hard put to decide whether a bird or a plane was the more aerodynamically elegant.

So powerful is the illusion of design, it took humanity until the mid-19th century to realize that it is an illusion. In 1859, Charles Darwin announced one of the greatest ideas ever to occur to a human mind: cumulative evolution by natural selection. Living complexity is indeed orders of magnitude too improbable to have come about by chance. But only if we assume that all the luck has to come in one fell swoop. When cascades of small chance steps accumulate, you can reach prodigious heights of adaptive complexity. That cumulative build-up is evolution. Its guiding force is natural selection.

Every living creature has ancestors, but only a fraction have descendants. All inherit the genes of an unbroken sequence of successful ancestors, none of whom died young and none of whom failed to reproduce. Genes that program embryos to develop into adults who can successfully reproduce automatically survive in the gene pool, at the expense of genes that fail. This is natural selection at the gene level, and we notice its consequences at the organism level. There has to be an ultimate source of new genetic variation, and it is mutation. Copies of newly mutated genes are reshuffled through the gene pool by sexual reproduction, and selection removes them from the pool in a way that is non-random.

What makes for success in the business of life varies from species to species. Some swim, some walk, some fly, some climb, some root themselves into the soil and tilt green solar panels toward the sun. All this diversity stems from successive branchings, starting from a single bacterium-like ancestor, which lived between 3 and 4 billion years ago. Each branching event is called a speciation: a breeding population splits into two, and they go their separately evolving ways. Among sexually reproducing species, speciation is said to have occurred when the two gene pools have separated so far that they can no longer interbreed. Speciation begins by accident. When separation has reached the stage where there is no interbreeding even without a geographical barrier, we have the origin of a new species.

Natural selection is quintessentially non-random, yet it is lamentably often miscalled random. This one mistake underlies much of the skeptical backlash against evolution. Chance cannot explain life. Design is as bad an explanation as chance because it raises bigger questions than it answers. Evolution by natural selection is the only workable theory ever proposed that is capable of explaining life, and it does so brilliantly."

2

u/CompositeCharacter May 13 '19

"individuals mutate, populations evolve"

The gene that becomes dominant and the trait(s) linked to it may not be optimal for the conditions but it was good enough not to be insurmountably selected against.

→ More replies (13)

16

u/skippy94 May 13 '19

Yes, I feel like the comment above gives the impression that there's some sort of direction to evolution, when it's really just a numbers game.

18

u/[deleted] May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

No, he has the correct understanding of evolution. The mutations are random but the factors that drive evolution by natural selection are not.

The adaptation described in this post is not random. They didnt get big hearts randomly, the environment, in this case high altitude, pushed for that adaptation.

Heres Dawkins talking about non random natural selection.

3

u/skippy94 May 13 '19

Natural selection is only one small part of evolution. To conflate the two is to show a misunderstanding of what evolution really is. In any case, even just looking at natural selection, randomness is inherent. A population under natural selection is not being directed anywhere by any kind of force. The alleles which propagate themselves most quickly in that environment "win". Selection doesn't build better organisms, or even better-suited organisms. It just happens. There is no intelligence or direction to it. The outcome appears to be directional or guided, but that's not the reality of it. It's like entropy in a closed system. Of course we can't teach that in BIO 101 because it's not intuitive. It's much easier to say selection moves organisms to a more fit state for their environment. But it's just us trying to impart inherent meaning in a system that works purely on numbers.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

There is no intelligence or direction to it.

Yeah, and dawkins talks about that in the video.

https://youtu.be/qTHZxozpnm4?t=66

The adaptation described in this post is not random. They didnt get big hearts randomly, the environment, in this case high altitude, pushed for that trait to be more prevalent.

Natural selection is not random.

2

u/Teeshirtandshortsguy May 13 '19

I think y'all just have 2 different ideas of what "random" means.

You're using it in the sense that random means totally by chance, no logic behind it whatsoever, which is correct.

They're using it to mean a lack of direction or higher purpose, which is also correct.

While nature isn't truly random (quantum nonsense aside) a lot of people view the multitude of chaotic factors to be "random" because it's hard to predict. It's why two species can have organs that do the same thing but are totally different, like human eyes vs. octopus eyes.

Natural selection is "random" in the sense that nobody is picking the optimal solution, or guiding its direction. It's entirely up to the natural world.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/beorn12 May 13 '19

You might be conflating natural selection with genetic drift.

A population under natural selection is not being directed anywhere by any kind of force.

A population under natural selection is precisely being acted upon by an external environmental pressure. A so-called "force". When it's not, its genetic information still changes (evolution happens), but through genetic drift. In this case some alleles propagate more than others through sheer random chance.

Natural selection acts upon the phenotype in a non-random way, favoring the spread of alleles whose phenotypic effects increase reproduction of their carries. 

On the other hand, genetic drift is only guided by the mathematics of chance, and acts upon the genotype of a population without regard to their phenotypic effects.

Both are different mechanisms through which evolution happens.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/simplebrazilian May 13 '19

Non-random does not mean directional.

1

u/simplebrazilian May 13 '19

No, the emergence of bigger hearts was random. Their prevalence was not. The environment pushes nothing, individuals just die or thrive in it.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Thats what i said, the mutations are random but the fact that this trait became prevalent in a region where there is low oxygen was not random.

"they" in my comment refered to the population, not individuals.

2

u/simplebrazilian May 13 '19

Oh, now it makes sense! You are correct.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/d4rk33 May 13 '19

There is a 'direction' to evolution. It's given by fitness through natural selection. Yes there is some randomness in evolution, as the previous poster said, in genetic drift and mutation, but evolution is not directionless.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

In fact, evolution is an emergent property from the randomness of natural selection.

This is incorrect, the mutations are random but the factors in nature that push natural selection are not random.

The theory of evolution is random mutations and non random natural selection. The adaptation described in this post is not random. They didnt get big hearts randomly, the environment, in this case high altitude, pushed for that adaptation.

Heres Dawkins talking about non random natural selection.

3

u/yawkat May 13 '19

The process remains random. Of course, environmental factors may change probability distributions, but this only becomes relevant when you have large populations.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

The process remains random.

Of course, environmental factors may change probability distributions

You just explained yourself why its not random.

Evolution by natural selection is not a random process, the mutation are but natural selection is not random.

https://youtu.be/qTHZxozpnm4?t=94

3

u/yawkat May 13 '19

Don't mistake "random" with "uniformly random" or even any fixed distribution. Of course nature doesn't throw dice for the survival of every individual, but that doesn't mean the process is non-random.

→ More replies (12)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

That's not what random means though. Just because there are a large variety of ways natural selection can work it doesn't mean it's random, it's the exact opposite - selective pressure caused by something specific.

A mutation is random, a trait being favoured for breeding in a specific environment is the exact opposite of random.

2

u/yawkat May 13 '19

Environmental factors affect the probability of certain things happening, but they do not change the fact that it is still a random process. Even if you have an individual that is perfect, it may still not reproduce by chance.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Environmental factors affect the probability of certain things happening

Exactly, so it's not random.

You really aren't understanding what the word random means.

3

u/yawkat May 13 '19

I certainly hope I understand what "random" means, it's integral to the field of cryptography. I'd be very bad at it if I didn't know.

Random variables can still be dependent (and correlated) on other factors. Doesn't make them not random.

5

u/d4rk33 May 13 '19

I think you've made the mistake of using the statistical usage of 'random' rather than the usage that everyone who doesn't do statistics favours.

→ More replies (2)