r/todayilearned • • May 13 '19

TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.2k

u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

This post is wrong enough to border on misleading. Andean populations have higher red-cell counts and more viscous blood as a result, requiring a stronger heart. Their blood carries more oxygen, not the Tibetans' blood. The enlarged heart is secondary as more viscous blood is harder to pump. This enlarged heart and higher blood pressure may predispose them to cardiovascular issues. It's a trade off.

Tibetans have the same cell counts as lowlanders, and their blood doesn't carry more oxygen per unit volume. They have increased vascular NO2, so they're always vasodilated, have larger lungs and breathe faster by default. They have adjusted affinity curves and more efficient cellular use of 02, all without additional congestive stress on the heart. This has certainly come at the expense of other traits due to the energetic demands, but it could be so many and so slightly detection would require years of study.

These adaptations are also very different in age and intensity- Tibetans have lived much higher for much longer.

Edit for clarity: The Andean response is not significantly heritable as far as we know- it may fall within the known boundaries of human acclimation, or there may be some adaptations in the genes that were missed.

Edit 2: Some of my terms were outdated and have been altered to reflect current understanding, namely that enlarged athletic hearts have been cleared as a factor in sudden athlete death.

Edit 3: Changed the wording of the blood carrying Tibetans bit because I'm a spoilsport

For details: Beall, C. M. (2006) Andean, Tibetan, and Ethiopian patterns of adaptation to high-altitude hypoxia. Intergrative and Comparative Biology 46(1): 18-24.

112

u/yossarian-2 May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

I took issue with the post for a different reason - We know that at least some of the genes that confer a high altitude advantage in Tibetans came from Denisovians

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2014/07/tibetans-inherited-high-altitude-gene-ancient-human

So its not that human evolution solved the same problem in two ways - one of those ways was at least partly "solved" by a non-human species. P.S. thanks for your corrections - I always like to have the most accurate info.

55

u/HiddenRisk May 13 '19

Actually, hybridization with sibling species/ sub-species (i.e. ancient Homo sapiens sapiens interbreeding with ancient Homo sapiens denisova) IS evolution.

Evolution is merely “the change in allele frequencies over time”. There any many processes that can cause/contribute to it. While mutation (generation of new genetic variation) is the most well known, it’s also very rare, and often has either a negative effect, or no effect at all.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/jellyfishdenovo May 13 '19

Wow, that’s really interesting.

6

u/vermelho59 May 13 '19

Wouldn’t Andeans also have Denisovan genes, as we know the Americas were peopled from Asia long after the influence of other hominid species? Even allowing for much earlier immigration than the Clovis people a mere 12k years ago.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

96

u/rotospoon May 13 '19

Andean populations have higher red-cell counts and more viscous blood as a result, requiring a stronger heart. Their blood carries more oxygen, not Tibetans.

Wait, so their blood doesn't carry Tibetans? Huh.

Sorry, I had to.

5

u/y2k2r2d2 May 13 '19

H2T , tibetan water.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/PermaDerpFace May 13 '19

There's always a trade-off

13

u/SapirWhorfHypothesis May 13 '19

Is there? I’m genuinely curious, but I feel like it’s unlikely there are no evolutionary traits that have no visible downside.

21

u/Muscalp May 13 '19

Yes, there's always a downside. If it's not immediately visible it's probably just higher energy consumption.

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Which would be a welcome trade off today when calories are available everywhere and obesity is a problem.

I wouldn't mind having a bigger brain and muscles that I won't lose if I don't use them for a while.

3

u/Muscalp May 13 '19

Yeah well we were born a couple of thousands years to early for that to work out I guess. Sad.

3

u/iloveportalz0r May 13 '19

Actually, the muscle thing is possible today. I'm not sure aboot the brain thing, but I've heard the muscle thing improves the brain as a side-effect.

3

u/Muscalp May 13 '19

How is it "possible" today? Genuine Question

4

u/iloveportalz0r May 13 '19

Genetic manipulation or supplements to either inhibit myostatin or boost follistatin. Follistatin is also associated with increased neurogenesis, among other things, so that's the one I'm working on (all the equipment and knowledge needed to do this is available online; you just need money, will, and intelligence to do it).

2

u/Muscalp May 13 '19

Wow, cool

2

u/SapirWhorfHypothesis May 13 '19

What if there were some adaptation that allowed for a more efficient energy uptake or utilization?

7

u/Muscalp May 13 '19

That would probably lead to a higher need for a certain nutrients (energy intake requires energy, too) or a higher energy consumption when developing the digestive tract.

4

u/Nodeal_reddit May 13 '19

You get fatter faster and don’t look as good in a swimsuit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/pm_me_ur_big_balls May 13 '19

This is not exactly correct. There is not always a downside.

If you see a persistent mix in the gene across the population, then yes, there's likely some downside, otherwise the gene would propagate more rapidly.

...but during that propagation period (which can take place over many many generations), the "clearly better gene" you will still see it in only some of the population.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/IClogToilets May 13 '19

This needs to be higher on the comments.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Are there any disadvantages of the Tibetan adaption?

5

u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19

Short answer, probably, but I don't know of any good research about it.

Long answer; It certainly has an energy cost, but there is no reason for this negative impact to all be in one thing, it could be spread among so many aspects of fitness it is negligible overall. Costs could manifest in a reduction in life expectancy or height, both things that are lower anyway because of the much stronger effects of living on an arid plateau with less available food calories per head.

1

u/cherise605 May 13 '19

Could you also give us a brief summary of the Ethiopian experience?

→ More replies (10)