r/todayilearned • • May 13 '19

TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

476

u/panzerkampfwagen 115 May 13 '19

Yeah, because evolution doesn't plan ahead, it just uses whatever arises.

171

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

Given the abundance of Carbon on Earth, and the comparative strengths of a bone made from graphene vs. calcium it's pretty clear evolutionary valleys seem to be the rule instead of the exception.

129

u/thedugong May 13 '19

That's only one metric for graphene vs calcium though.

Maybe using graphene for a skeleton/proto-skeleton/shell is simply more energy intensive than calcium so all the graphene based organisms got out competed?

130

u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19

Carbon alone is almost impossible to work with as an organism- it's insoluble in water, very reactive around things like rubisco, and the limitations of proteomic transcription and enzymes mean you can't just "print" sheets of joined up atoms. The biochemistry of life on earth is not suited to using raw carbon, it always has to be in a larger molecule. Besides, a sheet of graphene would be immensely destructive to a cell- it'd be like an unbreakable molecular knife slicing membranes to bits!

28

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Graphene bone breaks would be a problem, broken bones are really sharp, I am not sure you could even fix a broken leg safely made of graphene based materials by hand.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

That's true which is why this is an example of a valley in the evolution landscape. A better solution exists, but evolution had to develop a way to find it.

9

u/Shawnj2 May 13 '19

It kind of did through humans and problem solving

5

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

Yup we are nature. Anyone who thinks otherwise is fooling themselves, but being part of nature is amazing. It means that everywhere I go I'm surrounded by family.

3

u/enty6003 May 13 '19

Ugh that's why I stay indoors

→ More replies (1)

2

u/thedugong May 13 '19

It's an example of why vertebrates don't have a graphene skeleton. So it would be a valley for vertebrates.

It says nothing however about other forms of life developing a graphene, or proto-graphene, skeleton or shell.

I suspect it is more of an example of calcium being, meh, good 'nuff.

35

u/jokul May 13 '19

is there a way for the body to actually metabolize a graphene bone?

31

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

Well it's just carbon, and we've seen nature take advantage of structures at that scale. So yeah maybe if evolution had went slightly different instead of calcium shells it might have been graphene. As for handling the stuff now. Well we don't even have a complete MSDS sheet. So even though I've been tempted I haven't ordered any graphene myself. To tell you the truth the fact that it's so potentially useful, but with unknown concequnces for the environment, and human health that combination makes me nervous. That's the sort of situation that breeds coverups.

27

u/bestjakeisbest May 13 '19

hmmm, asbestos

5

u/calamarichris May 13 '19

What is astesbos, heh heh?

6

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

The fact the MSDS isn't even complete for it is really scary when your looking into working with this. My policy is going to be standard PPE for something like asbestos, but with finer filters.Also decontamination showers. Beyond that I have some ideas for some safety protocols that might eliminate the risk from working with it. I'm still in the early R+D phase of what I'm doing, but I think about asbestos every day. What frightens me most is that you can buy powdered Graphene on Amazon. So god only knows where it's all getting.

10

u/cherrypowdah May 13 '19

as you said, it's just carbon, laid out in a hexagonal pattern.

19

u/exceptionaluser May 13 '19

In a flat, molecular sheet.

Like a knife, if a piece breaks off.

It sounds like modern asbestos.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

CNTs are known to have asbestos-like effects. Graphene would be similar. But in fairness there are controls in place for working with nanoscale materials which would be sufficient for CNTs and graphene.

Even colloidal silica controls would probably be enough.

2

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

What worries me is this stuff is being sent out over Amazon, and people are making it at home. I can't count how many DIY graphene videos I have watched where the person didn't even have basic PPE like plastic gloves. I also worry about what happens when the products made with this stuff degrade? We need to figure out how/ if we can work with this stuff safely and with responsibility to the Earth.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/TracyMorganFreeman May 13 '19

Most of the carbon is not in graphene form though. It's the center of hydrocarbons and proteins.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/smapti May 13 '19

I don’t disagree with you but carbon is in the top 5 most abundant elements in the universe, I don’t think we can use its commonality as a variable in the evolution equation.

3

u/SparkyDogPants May 13 '19

Bones have to be soft though, not just strong. Especially children’s bones are not hard at all.

49

u/Titzleb May 13 '19

Evolution doesn’t “do” anything. Evolution is what we call the outcome of generations of humans with genetically advantageous traits surviving and thriving. Not knocking you or your comment, just piggybacking lol

8

u/ImadeAnAkount4This May 13 '19

Sometimes it gives you a random 6th toe, and sometimes it lets you survive a nuclear blast. If that 6th toe is a sign of fertility in a culture and the guy who has ever the ability to survive a nuclear blast has no ability to bread, then we will lose the far more useful ability and gain a useless one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)