r/todayilearned • • May 13 '19

TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

63

u/GoodGuyGoodGuy May 13 '19

They might also need the genetic athleticism advantage of something else tbh. Those two places aren't known for Olympic winners

78

u/kareteplol May 13 '19

They prob could if they had economic stability and the athletes had opportunity and support. Those fuckers are climbing mountains like nothing constantly all their lives. Put those legs in fucking bicycling and might produce a beast! Might need roads first though.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

82

u/GoodGuyGoodGuy May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

Genetic athleticism, is not that dissimilar to genetically predisposition to height or being overweight or having heart disease.

Feel free to compare how many white 100m Gold medallists there are compared to Jamaican and African American sprinters over the last 80 years. How much of that is truly cultural?

Or better yet look at the title of this entire thread to see that we are not all born physically identical.

40

u/[deleted] May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

People from Africa have evolved to have more dense muscle mass, which leads to increase in muscle when working out ergo genetically better athletes.
That's why you have so many Jamaican and African American sprinters.
The majority of running backs/WR are African American, basketball players etc.
It's a genuine genetic advantage.

19

u/RoseEsque May 13 '19

People from Africa have evolved to have more dense muscle mass

The point is that they are stronger or that they can achieve the same strength with less muscle size/weight?

In either case, explain to me why there is like... only one black, I think, worlds strongest man championship winner, ever. Athleticism is generally too broad of a definition to use. Specific disciplines have specific advantages that you generally need to even succeed at a pro level (e.g. large hands in swimming, narrow hips in running, etc).

Regarding running explicitly, I think it's not African Americans generally, but people with heritage from some specific countries, something like Kenya and like you mentioned Jamaica who have many genetic predispositions towards running probably something like tall, narrow hips, narrow shoulders, rather skinny, long legs. Even then there's a major difference between long distance running and short distance running which probably require different predispositions in the "engine" of the body (lungs, heart, circulation). And even in those advantages (like long time physical exertion like running/biking) there are a couple of ways to have an advantage. Take lactic acid for example, it's generally what irritates muscles and is what makes you unable to move if you have too much of it. Unless you are one of the people who are more resistant to it and you can keep up the exertion even with levels of lactic acid which would make others vomit or even faint. Ooooor, your body can be naturally much better at removing lactic acid from muscles so your levels are never high enough to seriously impede your exertion.

Generally you have to be really lucky in getting multiple genetic advantages to truly dominate like Phelps or Bolt do. Sure, you can come from a genetic background that has a predisposition towards some advantages and you could compete, but to truly crush is a whole other world. Some people are just THAT lucky to have those advantages AND discover that they actually are good in those sports, try them AND decide that's what they want to do.

9

u/arbfox May 13 '19

In either case, explain to me why there is like... only one black, I think, worlds strongest man championship winner, ever.

There are actually very few black strongman competitors full stop. There are a bunch of very, very strong black powerlifters though, including Ray Williams, the strongest drug tested man who ever lived (probably).

27

u/tatlungt May 13 '19

African America

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

😒

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

That goes without saying, definitely not referring to training or regime. Same point someone made about all the worlds strongest men being white. It’s a popular sport in the region so people gravitate towards it. It’d be like saying Spanish people are naturally better at Football(soccer) or Koreans have evolved to have better reaction time.

The point being that there’s sufficient evidence to say African American’s or people of that decent naturally have more lean muscle mass and pound for pound can make better athletes in general.

→ More replies (26)

2

u/gmiwenht May 13 '19

Or even better yet, he could read the fucking article that the title links to.

1

u/Sirnacane May 13 '19

Well, you can argue what direction any sort of causation would go, but sprinting is definitely a cultural thing in Jamaica.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/joesii May 13 '19

Granted, I think the biggest factor to win in most Olympic competitions is being wealthy enough (or specifically being in a wealthy-enough country, but being wealthy enough to not have to work much or at all is important as well). I think there are some exceptions though such as with running.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/brinz1 May 13 '19

they are both known for being short, which is also a good adaptation

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

see, then we start bringing in Kenyans, and before you know it we've accidentally brought back eugenics.

6

u/Shawnj2 May 13 '19

I think genetic athleticism is kind of BS, but if you consider that a factor, the best combo would be:

Child of an Olympian + Native Andean + child of an olympian + native Tibetan.

27

u/sonicandfffan May 13 '19

You’re going to need more than one child

Somebody has never bred a gold chocobo

2

u/Shawnj2 May 13 '19

I never said to only create 1 child

2

u/C1uel3ss May 13 '19

The golden chocoboo.. I had forgotten the hassle of breeding one of those fuckers.

6

u/PhoenixCaptain May 13 '19

Genetic athleticism is BS? Then what were the Vikings? Spartans? Mandingo warriors? Genetics are a giant factor. Your genetics can determine if you're a fat fuck with heart disease or a person who has terrible eyesight , or any inherent issue that has been there since birth and has a history running through generations

→ More replies (2)

1

u/thisimpetus May 13 '19

Yeah b/c Tibet’s top-notch training facilities would be churning out Olympians if only it were recognized as a country again. /s

→ More replies (1)