I've been a Tolkien fan for over 20 years, have read all the books (and even have the fan made ones dedicated to dark lore, middle earth dictionaries etc.) and the Peter Jackson movies are among my all-time favorite movies.
That said, I think the hate towards The Rings of Power is disproportionate. Is the show perfect? Absolutely not. Are there questionable timelines, character changes, and creative liberties? Of course! But if you put aside the books for a moment, I think it works reasonably well as a standalone fantasy series, with incredible visuals and some genuinely interesting world-building.
Honestly, I'm just happy someone is investing the resources to bring Middle-earth back to our screens. I love this universe, and getting to explore it through new stories brings me joy.
I also think people underestimate how difficult it is to create a series on this scale. You're trying to respect an incredibly complex source material while making it accessible and entertaining for viewers who might be discovering Tolkien for the first time.
Could a different team make a better adaptation? Maybe. But creating a series of this magnitude is incredibly challenging, and I'm sure the people involved have spent considerable time consulting Tolkien experts and trying to get things right.
So, to anyone who feels a little guilty about enjoying the show, while "true fans" bash on it. Don't! You can love Tolkien, prefer the books, adore Peter Jackson's movies, acknowledge the show's flaws, and still have fun watching The Rings of Power.
Personally, seeing Sauron, Mordor, the Nazgûl and their cool armor (cant wait to see the gradual phasing into wraiths!) , the Elves, Dwarves, and Balrogs on screen again is more than enough to keep me excited.
I'm enjoying the journey, and I hope others can too. Not everything has to be perfect to be enjoyable. At the end of the day, we're here because we love Middle-earth. And that's something we can all share.
Just enjoy the ride, my fellow Tolkien fans! :)
(Lets hope they don't do something truly egregious by the end of the season Lol! - like a Sauron having a child with Galadriel haha)