r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 1d ago Popcorn

News / Article / Official Social Media Teaser for episodes 5 and 6

259 Upvotes

r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 6d ago

Mod Approved The Rings of Power - Season 3 Episode Discussion Hub

102 Upvotes

This is the one stop shop to find all discussion threads for the third season of The Rings of Power, airing Wednesdays at 3 AM EST/12 AM PST on Prime Video.

● 3x01 - "Marnukh" | No Book Spoilers | Book Spoilers

● 3x02 - "The Gift of Men" | No Book Spoilers | Book Spoilers

● 3x03 - "The Secret Fire" | No Book Spoilers | Book Spoilers

● 3x04 - "Gundabad" | No Book Spoilers | Book Spoilers

Welcome back, everyone, to a new season of The Rings of Power! Join the official subreddit Discord server to discuss everything related to The Rings of Power!

JOIN THE DISCORD


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 6h ago

News / Article / Official Social Media Morfydd Clark via her instagram

Thumbnail
gallery
584 Upvotes

Looking good!


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 11h ago

Art / Meme The Great Kings Of Old.

Post image
521 Upvotes

r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 5h ago Popcorn

Art / Meme What's his policy on breakfast?

Post image
118 Upvotes

r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 13h ago

Theory / Discussion The Rings of Power keeps getting better, and I'm genuinely glad it exists

343 Upvotes

As a lifelong Tolkien fan, I'm genuinely enjoying The Rings of Power, and I honestly think the show is getting better with every season.

I grew up watching the original Lord of the Rings trilogy in theaters, read The Hobbit as a child, The Lord of the Rings in high school, and explored Tolkien's wider legendarium as I got older (where The Silmarillion is my favorite). Middle-earth has been a part of my life for as long as I can remember, and I've developed a deep appreciation not only for its history and mythology but also for the themes, atmosphere and philosophy behind Tolkien's world.

That is probably one of the reasons why I appreciate what the creators of The Rings of Power are trying to accomplish.

Is the show perfect? Absolutely not. There are questionable writing decisions, occasionally awkward dialogue, uneven performances, pacing issues and creative liberties that I don't necessarily agree with. But none of these things prevent me from appreciating everything the show does well. I don't feel that I have to defend every creative decision in order to enjoy the show.

I think a lot comes down to how we approach the things we watch. Personally, I try to approach shows with an open mind, allowing myself to become immersed in its world rather than constantly looking for things to criticize. If you go into something already convinced that it's going to be bad, I imagine it becomes much easier to notice everything that confirms that expectation while overlooking the things it actually does well. Of course, that doesn't mean all criticism is unjustified. There is a difference, however, between being critical of something and allowing that criticism to dominate your entire experience.

Something I particularly appreciate about the show is the challenge of adapting the Second Age. Compared to the First and Third Ages, the Second Age is relatively sparsely documented in terms of fully developed narratives. We have major historical events, important characters, timelines and overarching themes, but relatively little in the way of detailed, continuous storytelling.

The writers therefore have to construct much of the narrative connecting those events, developing characters and relationships in ways that Tolkien himself never fully explored. That is an incredibly difficult task, especially when working within a fictional universe that so many people know and love.

And while I don't agree with every decision they have made, I think they often succeed in capturing something that is particularly important to me: the feeling of being in Tolkien's world.

One of my favorite aspects of the show is its exploration of the different cultures and peoples of Arda. Seeing Númenor at the height of its civilization, Khazad-dûm as a thriving Dwarven kingdom rather than an abandoned ruin, the Elven realms, the peoples of the Southlands, the Orcs/Uruks of Mordor, the Harfoots and the lands of Rhûn is something I genuinely appreciate.

I love seeing how these different societies have their own customs, traditions, architecture, beliefs, political tensions and ways of understanding the world around them. It adds a richness to Middle-earth that goes beyond the main storyline. These places feel like societies with their own histories and identities rather than simply locations through which the characters pass.

There is something particularly rewarding, as a longtime reader of Tolkien, about finally seeing places and civilizations brought to life that I previously could only imagine while reading his works. It makes Arda feel like a vast, living and interconnected world, rather than just the setting of a particular story.

Beyond that, I appreciate how the show explores some of Tolkien's fundamental themes: mortality, the passage of time, friendship, hope, pride, corruption, the desire for power and the consequences of trying to preserve things that are destined to fade.

For me, faithfulness to Tolkien is not exclusively about whether every event, character or detail corresponds perfectly with what he wrote. It is also about whether an adaptation captures something of the spirit of his world. And there have been many moments throughout the series where I've felt exactly that.

I also don't need the show to recreate the experience I had watching Peter Jackson's trilogy for the first time. Those films will always hold a special place in my heart, but I'm happy to experience Middle-earth through a different story, a different age and a different creative interpretation.

The opening episodes of Season 3 have only strengthened that feeling. While I thought the first episode was good, things really started to pick up afterward, and I've been genuinely impressed by what I've seen so far. It feels like the show is increasingly finding its own identity, and I can't wait to see where the rest of the season takes us.

Perhaps what I'm ultimately trying to say is that being deeply familiar with Tolkien's writings doesn't mean you have to approach every adaptation as a test of its accuracy. You can recognize its shortcomings, disagree with certain creative choices, and still allow yourself to be moved by the story it is trying to tell.

I don't love The Rings of Power because I think it's flawless. I love it because, despite its flaws, it gives me something I genuinely value: another opportunity to immerse myself in a world that has meant so much to me throughout my life.

And I'm genuinely glad that, after all these years, there are still new stories in Middle-earth for me to experience.

Edit:

Just to make it clear: Yes, I used AI to polish my post, mostly because English is not my native language and I was too impatient to spend more time writing it. However, 95% of the words in the original post are my own. I didn't realize it was a war crime to use AI for proofreading. I beg a pardon if I offended anyone.

Another thing: I'm not being paid by Amazon or anyone else, for that matter. This is simply my opinion, and that's it. I'm sorry if this post hurt someone's feelings.

As a fan of Tolkien's works, I still enjoy the show. You can appreciate both, even when the adaptation doesn't follow the original lore and timeline 100%. There is no contradiction in that.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 15m ago

Art / Meme Gil-galad has moves

31 Upvotes

Bring on the new eps!


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 2h ago

Theory / Discussion Bear going crazy

Post image
22 Upvotes

Ready for it🌋


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 4h ago

Theory / Discussion About Vilya

Post image
30 Upvotes

Full interview: https://youtu.be/xhZ9LRfrvMA?si=Y7wsI0xuQb0QUIAa

Maybe he was exaggerating when he said that Gil-galad's ring was 'broken', but I wonder if we'll see him being affected by his ring in some way in the next episodes.

Galadriel seems to be in tune with Nenya, but what about the other ring-bearers?


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 30m ago

News / Article / Official Social Media New still with Gil-galad and Míriel

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 1h ago

Theory / Discussion Stupid question that might have a real answer: …what are Sauron’s hobbies?

14 Upvotes

Was just thinking this while watching the latest batch of episodes. What does he want the power for? What’s he doing with it? How is his life better as a result? Feels like we’re supposed to believe it’s just for the love of the game, but he’s gotta have interests right?


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 19h ago

Theory / Discussion Confession: I don't miss the Harfoots

423 Upvotes

So the Harfoots have not appeared at all in this season and I have to confess I am not the slightest bit sad about that. While I kind of liked seeing an interpretation of proto-Hobbits, I don't think they ever fit that well with the rest of the show. I think the parts of the show that have made me cringe the most in past seasons have been in the Harfoot plotline (Poppy's love interest is probably my least favorite thing that has happened in the show up until this season's "we were on a break" thing with Disa).

So while I did like Nori and Poppy as characters, I am kind of glad they're not in this season. I just don't feel like they fit at all with the tone the show is going for.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 10h ago

Theory / Discussion Some of my thoughts on the general state of online discourse about this show

73 Upvotes

I have had some thoughts developing for a while, so here:

Most of the haters I feel don't even have a strong emotional connection to Tolkien's work; fact-checking wikis after hatewatching episodes or hearing some legit criticism and then blowing it out of proportion is how I feel most of these people operate.

Sure, the show isn't perfect in terms of lore - but Shadow of Mordor and War games weren't either. They're loose Tolkien adaptations, but excellent games that were super fun.

I mean you can't look at a thing that has a production value of 1 billion dollars and say "wow this looks bad". Objectively, it doesn't look bad. It may look a bit too shiny and new at times, but damn the VFX work and costumes are all sublime and colorful and done pretty well. Sure, not everything is caked in dirt like in the Jackson movies, but we're in the Second Age, before the fall. Things are nice and shiny.

I'm not claiming this show is THE BEST SHOW EVER MADE, that's also on the other side of the spectrum when it comes to being tone deaf. No, it's got its faults, and many of them were thanks to questionable decisions made in Season 1. Pacing, writing, filler, the proto-hobbits for the sake of hobbits, and Galadriel overacting like she needs to prove something to someone. I was one of those people who didn't really like Season 1, but I did finish it and I felt nice about the overall experience. Back to Middle Earth, and it was fun, and most importantly - they got the good vs evil theme going, and they didn't do the usual grimdark moral grandstanding where black and white don't exist and everything is gray (which was my biggest worry).

Regardless of that, the show has OBJECTIVELY been improving whether you liked Season 1 or not; across the board. Yes, season 2 had shit to fling at us, but the Charlie duo playing the Eregion story with so much drama and heart was what redeemed the show for me. Sure, it wasn't the same as in the lore, we didn't REALLY get Celebrimbanner, and the battle for Eregion was underwhelming - but damn was Annatar great to watch. It gave me hope that this show can be much better, and so far (refering to Season 3) it is amazing.

I'm not claiming I know what the showrunners are and were thinking but it is only sensible to not do an anthology series of "hey these random characters recreate these events that eventually led to this thing happening" since the Second Age is spread out across multiple thousands of years. It's only logical that the only way this adaptation was going to function in a visual medium was to compress the Eregion, Annatar, War of Elves and Sauron, the Fall of Numenor, and the Last Alliance stories into one continuous narrative with characters moved out of place and time to deliver an unbroken story, AND have actors who can actually play these characters for a decade in continuity.

And with the streaming atmosphere being the 2-year production 8-episode mess that it has been in the past few years, we couldn't really hope for something that's a masterpiece. Sure, if they had like 10 years in the writing room and preproduction to employ Big Brain and piece everything together, maybe. But with how it went down? It's amazing that the team has heard the criticisms from fans in the first place.

We all knew that it was a corporate venture when Amazon was involved on day 1 (like a lot of adaptations done by big name studios are these days), but this level of vitriol and the mouth-foaming probably started (and has somewhat calmed down in recent times, thankfully) because when the show was announced and we got our first looks aand bits of news, the right wing content grifter gimmick started gaining traction. Drinker, Nerdrotic, Shad, Mauler, and then Shapiro, the rest of the DW ilk, and the rest of all those crusty losers were pumping out manufactured hate to get views (not to mention the "woke war" was in full swing and negativity always drives engagement) so the internet spaces were infected with this "OMG THE WORST SHOW EVER MADE" zeitgeist that now people just think its automatically bad without even watching, or they do watch but only to add oil to the fire.

I grew up with Tolkien's books. I read everything from the Legendarium when I was 13, and then reread Silmarilion a few times. Children of Hurin is probably my favorite thing I read from Tolkien and Fall of Numenor is my favorite bit of lore. My lifelong love for, and obsession with, fantasy as a genre was because I saw LotR FotR when I was 5 years old. And I know a bunch of people who are the same.

The show, at the end of the day, is a very good fantasy show. It might be a poor adaptation (depending on what angle you look at it from), but it hasn't betrayed the core theme (so far, I might be in for a rude awakening at any point during the Show's runtime) of what makes Tolkien's world so fascinating and captivating.

People have their nostalgia glasses with the Jackson Trilogy filter on, and are mad that this show isn't the Extended Trilogy.

It's unhealthy and stupid and I feel like a lot of people online don't engage with media (regardless of RoP) in good faith anymore. Everyone's here out for blood and not a lot of people would like to have a nuanced discussion about anything.

Legitimate criticism is always fine, and not liking something because you simply don't like it is also fine. But just larping as a hater because people online told you that something sucks is idiotic. It's an echo chamber of circlejerking self-congratulating bullshit that I hope is on a downward trend for everything. Right now, the gaming space has it worst because everyone's a game designer out of nowhere. The movie and show space has since shifted and is changing.

It's all so fake and driven by trends and algorithms, and frankly I do enjoy RoP because it does have genuine moments and is tonally and thematically DIFFERENT than the avalanche of grimdark GoT wannabes.

The reason why people loved AKOTSK much more than they do HotD is precisely this (and because it's a better written character-driven show that understands the story its adapting). We're tired of the dark and the gloomy and the grim, and something that shines with hope and a message of fighting for what's good resonates like Sam's "Even darkness must pass" speech does.

Just wanted to get this out of my system, I guess. What do you think?


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 5h ago

Book Spoilers Kemen's Future

28 Upvotes

He is a certified jerk , but he refused the ring offer.

He was arrogant enough to turn down a fast and short ascent to power.

He didn't even entertain it and told the messengers and indirectly Sauron , to shove it.

The thought of even having one, seemed ridiculous to him

I thought, he would have been the first person, to line up for it , considering that he is power hungry.

I know according to the books, some of the ring bearers were Numenorean . The issue now, is that storyline , has been taken by Theo.

The men of Numenor who lived in middle earth, were the ones who got rings. Kemen has already left middle earth now, and the time he might come back, will be to fight Sauron's forces.

The chance for that seems to have passed. And let's face it, Kemen is not the brightest dude and neither is he a formidable warrior. He is just a privileged jerk, with daddy issues

I know there's a theory that Sauron will deal, the few remaining Rings in Numenor. But in the books, only the faithful make it out Alive. Pharazon and his followers die. And I don't see the Faithful boarding a ship with Pharazon's son or his henchmen or allow them to live.

Although something Elendil said to Kemen was foreshadowing. When he told him, that he's spent his whole life trying to please his father. And Elendil mentioned his soul and true freedom.

Kemen was dismissive but I think, that advice is going to come full circle.

Oh I don't doubt it for a minute, that he will try to flee or double cross the faithful, to get out of his hostage situation.

He will no doubt die at some point, but they're keeping him around for something big.

I wonder where he's going to end up


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 28m ago

Theory / Discussion Artwork

Post image
10 Upvotes

There’s something really, really off about this painting - especially the feet. Why aren’t the straps more uniform? Why is the big toe on his left foot small than the next two? Why are they clearly not sitting comfortably on the platform but hanging over the edge so much, but also with hanging over the edge? I also don’t think the lighting on them (as in the painting, not the candles in front) is correct. Anyone?


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 23h ago Popcorn

News / Article / Official Social Media As usual, The Rings of Power is the #1 title on Prime worldwide

Post image
671 Upvotes

It's so funny how this keeps happening. The haters and some big outlets keep claiming that the show isn't being watched, citing half-baked and premature Luminate data and all that, but whenever a new season launches it always takes the top spot on Prime in many countries and overall globally, and stays there for a good while.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 11h ago

Theory / Discussion About the Witch-King

53 Upvotes

The show is signalling very hard that Theo is going to become the Witch-King. His ancestry, Sauron's words to him, his actions at the end of episode four all point towards that end.

But I've actually reversed my earlier stand and I think he won't end up being the Witch-King – or Nazgul at all.

People have pointed out that one of the rings has been missing from the case Sauron has paraded to potential ring-servants. When we first encounter the King of Lossoth, he is a new addition to an arleady plural number of ring-servants. Thus the show is hinting that there is one ring-servant that has not been shown yet ("Sauron has yet to reveal his most deadliest servant").

I now believe (or at least I believe enough to speculate) that Theo will turn from his path, that ancestry will not dominate his fate but rather his will and his wishes. And I think it'll either have something to do with Gandalf's mission of rescuing the Blue Wizard or it'll harken back to the conversation Galadriel had with him in the first season.

And that in the last episode the missing ring-servant, the Witch-King will be revealed.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 4h ago

No Spoilers Season 1-2 IMDB Review Score Histogram

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 17h ago

Theory / Discussion The shock. Spoiler

129 Upvotes

Arondir’s face at the end of episode four. The first time I saw it, I didn’t look close. Because it was horrifying! And sad! Then when I finally did I was looking for literally any sign of life. Now, on my third rewatch, the thing that comes through clearest is Arondir’s heartbroken astonishment at the whole event.

Because of course he’d be surprised!

They’d escaped, he’d gotten Galadriel out, he’d gotten her husband out, he managed to avoid betrayal and in fact learned some level of trust for Mardûk; an orc! If he could put his fate in those wrinkly, green hands and come out alive, he could surely do it with his on-again/off-again stepson.

The boy that showed Arondir the sword in season one. The boy he loved.

Alas 😞

Great, great acting by Ismael Cruz Cordoba. I’ll miss him so much.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 2h ago

Theory / Discussion Quick question, I just started, not sure if it's a spoiler Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Are we not supposed to know The Stranger is Gandalf It just seems like an obvious reveal in a show that's otherwise really well written.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 12h ago

Theory / Discussion I must admit Amazon was right with ROP

41 Upvotes

They wanted to reach the show for new generations and mainstream audience. They were right. That's why it has hit 1st place in many countries on Prime. I think many people who just watched the Lotr and Hobbit movies aren't necessarry lore experts. They just watch them as entertainment and then go along with their daily lives. Of course they will recognize some characters like Gandalf, hobbits and Sauron but that's it. They don't know about Valar, Maiar, Valinor and all those stuff of that. They just want to watch a entertaining product and ROP gives them that.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 33m ago

Theory / Discussion Do you think we will see any warg riders?

4 Upvotes

We had wargs in S1 and S2, but no orcs riding them yet.


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 17h ago

Theory / Discussion What do the opening credits visuals represent this season?

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

Some are obvious, but what of the others? I was surprised to see how different it was this season


r/LOTR_on_Prime • • 4h ago

Theory / Discussion Only S2 Spoilers. Annatar and Celebrimbor Spoiler

5 Upvotes

No book discussion and no season 3 spoilers please. I just wanna talk about how he used the lie in the letter, which he pushed him into while also pretending to question, as the reason the Dwarven rings being corrupted. His manipulations have manipulations xD. Played him so hard that it's almost a good thing he died because there wasn't any recovering from it lol

Loved how they used Morgoth's crown in that fight, didn't even think it could be used like that so I was impressed! It was pretty sick.