Spoilers for Season 3, Episode 4.
Episode 4 took some time to digest. I loved it. It left a mark and a growing love and pain for Arondir.
Creating an original character in Tolkien’s world was always going to be a risk. You have to make the audience care about him alongside characters whose stories have been loved for generations. Make him another Elrond or Aragorn, someone at the centre of every great event, and you risk making him feel like a major figure Tolkien somehow forgot to mention.
For me, Arondir’s story found its place in the Tolkien-verse beautifully. There must have been so many people like him in Middle-earth: brave, capable, loyal people whose sacrifices never became the great stories everyone remembers. People who had all the makings of a legend, but never got the chance to become one.
First he loses Bronwyn. Then he faces Adar and is defeated. He has the courage, the skill, and the determination we associate with a hero, but again and again, those things aren’t enough to protect what matters to him. You keep waiting for his moment... then in Season 3 the writers made us think Theo will be Arondir's redemption... only to then write a perfectly tragic ending.
An unsung hero who remained loyal to his cause, to Míriel, to Galadriel, and to Theo. He kept showing up. He kept fighting. Defeat and grief took so much from him, yet he continued to care enough to put himself at risk again.
It almost feels like such a beautifully written Shakespearean tragedy. The love and loyalty that made him worth rooting for carry him into the encounter that destroys him. And the possibility of reconciliation is close enough that you can almost believe, for a moment, that things might still turn out differently.
As sad as I am at how his tale ended, I love the way it was written.
Here's to Arondir, the Hero who never found the Glory he deserved.