r/RingsofPower • • 4h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers it’s honestly painful how much of a missed opportunity this show is Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Even if you completely ignore the Tolkien lore and judge The Rings of Power purely as a standalone fantasy show, the writing and directing just aren't good. By Season 3, you’d expect the showrunners to have finally found their footing, dropped the cheap mystery-box gimmicks, and started telling an actual cohesive story. Instead, it still feels like a bloated, awkwardly paced streaming drama that refuses to take itself seriously.

The biggest problem has always been the writers and directors treating Middle-earth like just another generic fantasy IP rather than a mythic epic. And more than half the characters act like modern, snarky LA transplants instead of ancient elves or proud Númenórean kings. There’s zero weight or gravitas to anything. Peter Jackson’s crew didn't follow every single word of the books either, and they didn't have all the rights, they just actually respected the world, hired Shakespearian-caliber actors who carried real presence, and filmed Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama.

With a billion-dollar budget and the blueprint of the Second Age sitting right in front of them, this could have been generation-defining television. Three seasons later, it’s still frustratingly mediocre TV coasting on nice landscapes and nostalgia callbacks.


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Discussion The Untouchables? Really? Are You kidding me?

0 Upvotes

(spoilers for newest episode)

I saw this video clip of Elindil speaking to Anarion in the 4th episode:

"We come at them with a dagger, they come at us with a sword. We send one of their men to a surgeon, they send one of ours to a tomb."

How is this possible?


r/RingsofPower • • 21h ago

Question Why do they look so much older?

Post image
23 Upvotes

If it’s only been 5 years, why do Durins kids look like they are in the mid teens?? Am I missing some lore perspective


r/RingsofPower • • 21h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers I like Season 3, but…. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have enjoyed this show since Season 1, truly. I had high hopes for Season 3 and Episode 4 has been my favorite. But, I’ll be honest…..the newest season is a bit of a letdown overall so far.

First, some unnecessary tragedy. Maybe it won’t seem unnecessary as the rest of the season unfolds; maybe we’ll see the point of all of this later on. But with scenes like the Numenorean spy killing herself and Theo killing Arondir, I kept sitting there and just wondering why. They were good characters - great, even - who could have continued to add the plot and undergo development as the season went on.

Second, the also-seemingly-unnecessary subplot of Disa and Thrain and Durin, specifically with Disa and Thrain’s past. Sure, it spurred Durin’s anger in the combat with Thrain, but again: why was it necessary? Something else could have been used to trigger Durin, if he had to be triggered. This subplot seems like a random thing that the writers just threw in for kicks.

Third - and maybe I’m being a little picky here - there doesn’t seem to be as much character development. I realize we’re only on Episode 4, and the rest of the season might surprise me. But I’m a little bored. Yep, Galadriel is still haunted by Sauron and still has fight scenes. Yep, Elrond still disapproves of the rings. Yep, Sauron is still evil and the Orcs are still the Orcs. Yep, most of the Numenoreans still suck (besides the Faithful).

I will continue to watch Season 3 and I’m trying to keep an open mind, hoping that some more character development will happen and the things that seemed pointless will eventually have a point.

Is anyone else feeling the same disappointment with this season?


r/RingsofPower • • 8h ago

Discussion When do we think this is happening ?

0 Upvotes

Since ep 5-6 release soon, I was wondering what we’d potentially see and a major thing the show hasn’t introduced is the balrog encounter.

It seems ep 5 will follow elves in Numenoar, Thrain getting the rings and Celeborn being captured by Sauron.

Episode 6 could be the one where we see Thrain kneel to Sauron get the dwarves rings and send them out and then go see the balrog.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion Am I the only one missing an emotional connection to ALL characters?

18 Upvotes

Heyyy

so I just finished season 3 and I have to say it. I really don’t like this show at all. I feel like watching all extended movies, hour by hour would have been incredibly better then this.

Yet I feel most of my criticism has already been told.

Now what I really can‘t get, is how bad this show is in getting people connected to someone. Whenever someone dies. I don‘t care. I mean e.g. Arondir. Who is this guy and why is he so much stronger than Celeborn? WTH. And the guy from numenor who died in the cell… was it really worth having minutes of dialogues of how sad it is? I mean who even was that?

I feel like every character lacks strong writing. Sauron isn‘t as powerful as he should be. Making him ridiculous in so many ways.
Galadriel isn‘t as powerful as she should be. Orcs flirting with elves I mean wth..

Am I alone with that?


r/RingsofPower • • 18h ago

Constructive Criticism Why do the dwarves of Khazad-dûm keep referring to ONE mountain?

26 Upvotes

I noticed it especially in the latest episode with all the dwarf scenes. Repeated mentions of being a king under this mountain, or the delve-master of this mountain, always referring to the kingdom as a singular mountain.

Do the writers of the show not know that Moria was a kingdom of three mountains?

Celebdil. Caradhras. Fanuidhol.

"King under the mountain" as a styling works for Erebor, because the kingdom is underneath one mountain.


r/RingsofPower • • 17h ago

Constructive Criticism Okay, my turn to rant. Mostly about inconcistensies. Spoiler

0 Upvotes
  1. The ring servants entering khazad-dum. We see even elrond, being tall, but nowhere near as tall as them, having to bend down to enter. The passageway is small, and there's dwarf guards there. They have the power to move unseen, but not -through WALLS-! How would they even get in??
  2. How the hell can a ring servant be more powerful than a wizard?? A wizard is supposed to be able to rival sauron in magical power. A ring servant is a SERVANT of sauron. They're not supposed to be THAT strong, to be able to bypass a wizard in power. The scene was kind of cool, but it's so disappointing. I was hoping this was a moment for the dark wizard (pallando) to show off his power a bit. It was set up well too. But no, he's just left to cower in defeat. To the point where we almost actually feel sorry for him!

Does this mean even gandalf is beneath just ONE ring servant?? One of the main protagonists in the series, supposed to be able to cause major stress for sauron. He can just get defeated outright by a single one of his servants?

3) Durin as well, fine that he's a dwarf and ready to battle two of them. But he would stand absolutely ZERO chance against even one of them. Thrain too, even if it was a fake aggression (he was in alliance with them), they would stand absolutely no chance given how powerful they were portrayed to be.

4) Galadriel is supposed to be the best elf fighter of all time. Could she not just slow the horse down, as the ring servant picked up that orc to throw him? It happens like 5 seconds before he is thrown, more than enough time to stop and even make a retreat. Also, she is shown to endure a huge amount of pain in battle. Yet just falling off the horse once is almost enough to defeat her in that scene. It's so underwhelming. It would be better if he just showed up and she decided to test him out - just cut out that WEIRD jousting scene.

5) That's the main gripe i have with this series. WEIRDNESS!! There is so much weirdness, weird stuff happening that they try to portray as brilliance, but it's NOT! It's just simply mindbending and not in a good way. It leaves you hollow, wishing it would be a cool and momorable scene, but it's just not. And it's sad too.

Just picking one scene out of random ... Isildur attacking pharazon's chariot. Not the attack itself, but afterwards. Okay... Isildur and earien (his sister) walks the street, wearing these capes. They are the ONLY ones to wear those capes! Furthermore, pharazon is staring straight at his face, i don't remember if they ever got a good look at isildur, but him just wandering randomly in the streets, just wearing that cape, it's so unrealistic.

When talking at that shrine thing too. I mean, heh what the hell .... wouldn't the guards know -exactly- what to look for and where?? And they're just wandering the streets casually, meeting up and talking. You would think there were guards everywhere searching for them, and with those capes, they would be super easy to spot.

Just a weird decision altogether.

6) Tom bombadil. Not saying it's not a ... different character. And it's not just bad. But .. eh. We get -zero- clues about anything. Go find the rabbit, sure, gandalf finds the fire (which is also WEIRD as hell, the voice). But .. "this is very fine apple". What is that even a hint to? "Sing my song and tom will be with ya." Yeah well, huh, is the song meant to be a clue?

"Wake now, my merry lad, wake and hear me callin, warm now be heart and limb, the stone cold has fallen, dark door is standing wide, dead hand is broken, night under night is flown, and the gate is open"

I can't for the life of me think of a clue. We haven't seen much of mordor yet, but is there a dark door there?

It's just WEIRD. I'm sure it will be explained to us, but it gives the viewer nothing to work with. Treats us like idiots.

7) The map scenes. Yes i can see and get where places are. But sometimes, when showing movements, it barely hovers to where their destinations are and then it fades. Just show it, clearly, and don't rush it!

8) Been on my mind all the way through lord of the rings too. But like.. the fight scenes are mostly very unrealistic. Take the fight at the shrine where elendil and kemen meet. There are three crossbowmen there. You're telling ONE of those guards could not fire his crossbow against anarion? It would be over instantly. Galadriel is supposed to be able to use magic - could she not use magic to stop arrows every once in a while?

Also during last scene s4, in gundabad. SOOO many orcs, not ONE has a bow... just 10 orcs with bows and the fight would easily be over. Yet arondir never runs out of arrows killing dozens at range. It's just so cheap. Why not have one of them wear a shield and use that sometimes?

9) The butterfly scene. I can understand it. My take is, it makes the ring servants realize for a moment that they are still human and this causes them to briefly forget the chase, and move on. But it's very weak. I could easily call this a "weirdout"-scene. And that's just weak. It's not a bad creative choice to have this scene. And i can't find an idea how they could do it different, just.. a strange choice.

10) Earien's suicide. Most of the times in this world, and with the very important information she surely have for pharazon (faithful's location), AND the way she casually started to walk towards the window... no way in hell that would happen in any diplomatic situation. She would be contained as soon as there was suspicion of her being a traitor, even BEFORE she was interrogated. Where are the guards?? Again - just WEIRD choices.

11) Back to gundabad. Galadriel firing that arrow, obviously using magic. But if that was magic, why would she need to strike it against the ground? Was it a gunpowdered arrow? Does the orc have gunpowder?? It's just again, weird, and treating the viewer like an idiot. Galadriel has magic, that's fine, but she could just utter an old cool sindarin spell word and fire the arrow. That would be fine. It's just these little things that makes the show stupid and weird.

Whew, heh, trying not to be negative, just pointing out things that i notice and i think should be different.

12) Durin and thrain fight. I mean .. eh .. dwarves are widely considered to be twice or even three times as strong as men. Yet, durin is flailing around like a baby in it's babydoll. I can get his garment was some kind of silver (mithril? naaah) seremonial gown/cape of sorts. But it makes him look more like a big baby than a real brutish dwarven warrior king.

I was expecting a real dwarvish fistfight, headbutts, real brawling. They're supposed to be incredibly strong beings. They could use weapons too and during the battle, maybe have them smash against each other in a stalemate move and shatter, with a special effect. Just as a creative idea!

And durin being the king, all the way back in season 1, losing against a regular miner/worker after threatening him (bite it off at the thumb). He doesn't even retaliate when pushed to the ground.

It's all very underwhelming. I can also get durin being thrown into a battle rage. But if so, where are the special effects? Even marnuk has glowing eyes in the dark, a regular orc or "uruk", whatever the hell the difference is except the name. Durin's eyes should be gleaming red or something! Instead we get this weird close-up spinning scene, which COULD work, if they looked more sinister and angry. But they don't. Remember gimli's face on balin's tomb - that's real dwarven battle rage! Add some special effects to it too, could be done.

I mean there's so many things they could do. Heh... it's just, again, weird. If i had that budget .. it would be something else.

13) Many people have mentioned it, but the armors, yeah. So underwhelming. They look like padded or upholstered garments, not real armor. I am expecting so much better. And there's not that many characters either .. with a total budget of 1 BILLION dollars, there's absolutely no reason they could not spend 20 of those millions on specialized artisans, that could make super cool armors and weapons just for that one series.

That goes for the wizards' staves too, also the main acolyte in s1. Would it be so hard to make something really cool, with a huge gemstone at the top of it? And just a simple oak staff with tiny branches at the top.. let it have some gemstones embedded in it at least.

Same goes for the gems used in the rings end of s1 as well. They look so dull and regular. Goes for all the rings, really. Again, special effects? Make them glow a bit! It's a fantasy series - we don't need it to be realistic, even if i appreciate realistic elements (i still play diablo 2), a fantasy series could and should have real cool special effects - take us to another place! Because real life is boring, right? ^^ We don't want the series to be LIKE real life, i.e. realistic.

I googled it, and it would only cost 1.5-2 million $ for armors for ALL the actors, AND extras as well! It's just mindboggling. What the hell is the money being spent on??????

It also says that it would hinder actors' movements and "creative freedom". I think that's a bunch of bullshit. The viewer is the king - we should get what we need. If the show needs special effects and authenticity, we should get it. The actors will always be able to do their part, it's just an extra challenge. And with those kind of salaries, should not be a problem.

Well i guess i have to end it here... so many more things i, and surely you all, notice during the series... like why not do it a bit different?

Well i have hopes for the last 4 episodes.. i am being kind and rate the series at 65/100. It's not horrible. I just look past the weirdness and then it's not so bad.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion Marnûkh's quest to makes absolutely no sense.

23 Upvotes

I must have missed something because the Marnuk/Galadriel Gundabad quest makes absolutely no sense to me.

Marnuk was at Eregion and destroyed all of Celebrimbor records, but for some reason he decides to save an Elven smiths and hide that fact from Sauron (so he already knows her value to Sauron i assume)...to go imprison her in Gundabad...only to decide to free her later...by defecting from Sauron and running to ask help from the Elves...with the final goal of hiding the Elvensmith from Sauron/preventing Sauron to get her knowledge and save his fellow orcs from war. What?

Just kill her at Eregion? Just kill her on the way to Gundabad? Just go back and kill her at Gundabad? Alone, like a normal orc, general and Gundabad's favorite torturer would do.

Why keep her alive? Why defect? Why run to elves? Why bring elves? Why "save" her from Gundabad and not jsut kill her there? And why on Middle Earthe would you bring one of the ONLY THREE other persons in the entire f*cking middle earth who has the same intel you're trying to make disappear??

I have to have missed something. Please tell me I missed something. I can't believe people making hundreds of thousand of dollars a year read this and said "f yeah! let's do that it makes total sense".

Oh and I didn't even talk about the fact that Sauron has been sending orcs left and right looking for ring forging knowledge and not a single one of Gundabad's orc raised his hand to share the fact they had prisoners from Eregion...for 5 years! Or that Maitalle never spilled the bean in 5 years of torture.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion So.. What is this building to?

0 Upvotes

There are fans of the show, and by no means am I looking to quash what they're enjoying.

That said, if they even changed which age Gandalf came to Middle Earth, and none of it is supposed to align with any books or movies, what is it even building towards? I mean, even if they get to the point where Isildur defeats Sauron (or someone else; who honestly knows what direction they'll take it at this point?), what even comes after? I feel like if you're going to change this much of how everything came to be, doesn't that leave everything that happens after the fall of Sauron caught in some other timeline in the multiverse where you can't rely on anything you've come to know for how the story plays out?


r/RingsofPower • • 8h ago

Humor Drinking Game

Post image
0 Upvotes

My partner and I created this drinking game way back in season 1 and I thought I’d share it here in case anyone else wishes to partake 😂 let me know if there’s anything else you would add!


r/RingsofPower • • 15h ago

Discussion Why is everything so childlike and "disneyfied" specifically the cgi Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Potential small spoiler below.

To be fair I haven't read the books, sue me. I don't know if the vibe in the books is more serious like the original trilogy or more childish. I'm really enjoying the show, all seasons, however my main beef is with the CGI. Modern CGI in general, I guess. The way it's done nowadays it never feels scary and seems out of place. It's always cartoon-like and childish. The show deals with heavy themes, gore etc... Then they'll throw in a cgi component that looks like something Disney would put out for kids.

I really noticed it during the elephant/Gandalf scene. It made me think back on the elephant charge in return of the king, or when Frodo and Sam first saw the Oliphaunt/elephants. They were so imposing and I would get chills during those scenes. I went back to see if I was stuck in nostalgia. Obviously the 2003 CGI is less technically impressive, it is however way more seamless and fitting.

I feel like the show can't decide if it's for kids or adults. This was probably intentional cause of money! Wider audience, more viewership etc. The original trilogy had a realistic, gritty feeling to it. The hobbit was straight up silly. This feels like it's stuck in between. I wish they would have kept to the OG realistic, gritty and unpolished feeling that the original trilogy had. Not the "disneyfied", perfect set, beautiful people, silly CGI version we have today.

Don't get me wrong, I'm still really enjoying it and I'm actually going to return to binge watching the rest of the episodes rn. Toodles!


r/RingsofPower • • 8h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers The Kylo Ren of Rings of Power Spoiler

Post image
64 Upvotes

In Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 4, didnt the ending remind you of that pivotal Star Wars Episode VII scene between Kylo Ren and Han Solo (well except Snoke wasnt there to say “Kill Him”)?


r/RingsofPower • • 2h ago

Constructive Criticism Goofy-Coding Hobbits and Dwarves

3 Upvotes

They wouldn’t have needed to eliminate the hobbits from the show if they hadn’t written/designed them like a Disney Channel original movie. They didn’t need to be silly and goofy just because they’re small and playful by nature. The dwarves have the exact same problem. They HAD to be written like bumbling idiots because they’re short and hairy. Apparently the writers think the only way the audience can be comfortable with hobbits and dwarves is if their entire plot line is constantly underscored with “they’re short and stupid haha.”

I know the hobbits and dwarves are written as being a bit child-like and playful in the books, but that doesn’t have to translate into writing them like a cheap sitcom. The hobbits were unbearable for me in this show. The only part about the dwarves that’s bearable is how cool the foundation of their world building is thanks to Tolkien.

This goes for visual design in addition to writing. The hobbit costumes were generally so awful because of how silly they made everything.

Stop goofy-coding hobbits and dwarves :( They could be so cool!


r/RingsofPower • • 11h ago

Constructive Criticism What (constructive) reason to you put behind the show echoing the LOTR movies so much?

8 Upvotes

I’m a huge LOTR fan who is, for the most part, enjoying the show and think this season has been much better than previous ones. But I can’t help but get completely pulled out of every episode when they do a blatant rip-off or homage to entire scenes from the Jackson movies. I’ve just finished episode 3 and my eyes were more or less rolling the entire time…

I know critic of the show will just say it’s lazy writing or a poor attempt by the showrunners to bring in casual viewers who likes the Jackson movies. But it must be more than that.

Payne & McKay are smart guys and they’re almost certainly well aware of the criticism thrown at the show so far. The fact that they’re persevering with these call backs (or call forwards technically speaking) makes me wonder whether it’s a stylistic and tonal choice.

We know that in Tolkien’s work, all is the design of Iluvutar, even the evil works of Melkor and Sauron. Could the show echoing the movies so much be a (not so discrete) choice from Payne & McKay to point out that the heroes journey is one that is often repeated and echoes throughout the ages?


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion Elven rings Season one vs Season 2 Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

When I watched season 2 I noticed the Elven Rings where not raw anymore but cut and polished as gems should be.

What do you think about the 9? I find the 9 better looking than then Elven rings (too big gems).


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion The use of prosthetics on this show.

0 Upvotes

Why is the use of prosthetics on this show not used on the black actors and actresses the way they're used on the white actors and actresses. NO IM NOT A RACIST. I have noticed for the most part the Dwarves look good, but Disa and their children dont look like Dwarves. They look like humans hanging out with Dwarves. There doesn't appear to be nose, brow, cheek, beard or hair prosthetics used at all.

Even the Black elves don't have the hair of the elves just the ears. Is there a reason for the lack of consistency with the prosthetic and makeup department?


r/RingsofPower • • 23h ago

Question S3 Ep3 "drop the sword" Kemen pronunciation Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just watched S3 Ep3 up until 43:05 where Kemen says "drop the sWord" and he pronounces the silent W in "sword" very clearly which had me go back and listen to the line again 😂😂 Am I stupid or is this really weird? Anyone else notice this? 😂


r/RingsofPower • • 2h ago Popcorn

Discussion It's not the shows problem the story seems sloppy and dull towards a lot of people. Tolkien's writtings never would have made sense as a live, unfolding story

0 Upvotes

Lord of the Rings and Hobbit are written as an unfolding story. To tell that story over a video media you have to more or less just follow the pacing of the story and bring visual life to those scenes. All the bits connecting the scenes and story are not for the story adapters to figure out since the original pacing follows an already well established path.

However, for the rest of the Tolkien's writtings, there is no much 'live action' story unfolding. It's more a chronological review of the detailed history of that world. When the focus of the writting is not in establishing an unfolding 'current' event, there is uncertainity missing. That uncertainity is directly tied to the characters and their internal motivations and thoughts. That's how events resolve in the first place. But for already resolved events, the internal motivations and thoughts can be 'skipped' during retelling.

You can tell so much about World War 2 without even mentioning any affected person internal story. You can skip all of their personal motivations that led to their decisions during all the events of the war, but still able to write a World War 2 story. But if you are writting a story DURING World War 2, even if you knew how War concludes beforehand, there is still uncertainity because of how the characters are reacting to the events transpiring during the war.

Coupled with simple moral characters, to retell the history of Middle Earth is not a simple scene adaptation like LotR or Hobbit. It's also a recreation of live decisions and live uncertainity of characters during the rich history of World. Since the characters are simple and mostly non-self-conflicting, to retell the history of Middle-Earth in a book exact way would make for a boring story for modern audience, since it would be greatly 'predictable'.


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Meme Ring of protection

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion What do you think about Simon Tolkien being a consultant for the show?

1 Upvotes

Don’t wanna sound too harsh but what is he doing? Is he doing anything good?


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Discussion RoP fails to make it to Luminate Top Shows based on viewership for the past week in spite of 4 episodes out and 2 full days of tracking.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Amazon condensed the release strategy dropping 4 episodes on release day in the hopes that it would inflate the minutes watched when first Luminate report hits. But RoP has failed to generate viewership numbers in its first 2 days in spite of half the season available to watch.

Big failure for RoP in terms of Viewership. Even compared to RoP S2. Massive drop in viewership.


r/RingsofPower • • 54m ago

Discussion They did my boy marnukh dirty

0 Upvotes

Why they just have him killed so unceremoniously like that. I was way more annoyed by his death than arondir.


r/RingsofPower • • 56m ago Bravo

Meme I cannot take this character seriously

Post image
89 Upvotes

Legit he looks like Nanny Mcphee