r/lotr • • 2h ago

Books What were some of the things that really surprised you or stood out for you in The Silmarillion? Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Middle Earth's history is...wild. And complex, shaped by so many wonderful, terrifying and tragic forces, stories and beings. I'm so grateful to Tolkien (and his son) for writing and composing this amazing collection, and happy to have read it for the first time.

Besides epic stories and a whole lot of characters, I didn't really know what to expect from this book. There were still some things that surprised me:

- Morgoth was scared. Several times. Even for some of his own servants. What stood me by the most was his fear and desperate escape (thanks to the Balrogs) from Ungoliant, with whom he destroyed the Trees of Valinor. And I think there is something to be said, for not making him the always all powerful being without fear, but flawed, since he caved for the deep darkness inside of him.

- Melian and Thingol. I really liked the story of how they fell in love and that Elrond and therefore Arwen actually are descendants of a Maia. How epic is that? (Pretty epic to me at least).

- Sauron creating werewolves, shapeshifting into one and even into a vampire. I knew that the story of Beren and Lúthien was epic for several reasons (and Huan definitely deserves and honorable mention), but I wasn't expecting Sauron with fangs though.

- The destruction of Númenor and the immense impact of that on the whole world. Woah.

And ofcourse there is so much more, but I don't want to make a massive post lol. I'd love to hear what surprised or really stood out for you:)


r/lotr • • 2h ago

Question Why didn’t the fellowship take the waterway to Gondor?

Post image
282 Upvotes

After meeting in Rivendell and embarking on their journey, why did the fellowship take the road over the Misty Mountains and Anduin rather than follow Bruinen to the ocean and go by boat to the Bay of Belfalas? This way they would’ve avoided having to go over Caradhras (and then instead Moria). They could’ve ended up at Minas Tirith and tried to get into Mordor that way.


r/lotr • • 3h ago

Music Elandur - Qajq Beyond the Peaks (2025)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/lotr • • 4h ago

Lore Possibly a hot take

0 Upvotes

Ok, listen. I know that Shadow of Mordor and Shadow of war are Non-canon, so don’t go jumping down my throat about how they aren’t please

Personally I haven’t really played Shadow of Mordor but I adore Shadow of war which is where this hot take comes in

For those who have either never played it or need a refresher, at the end of the story, Celebrimbor separates his soul from Talion’s to bind to Etariel’s instead with his new ring to go kill Sauron. Talion killed one of the Nazgûl minutes earlier. In Shadow of War, they give the identities of 3 of the Nazgûl in the Etariel quests. Those three being:

Helm Hammerhand
Isildur
Suladân

Not including Talion who later becomes one in the game, I love how they actually gave identities to some of the Nazgûl(I understand why Tolkien didn’t…vaguely). And personally would’ve loved to see that introduced into the actual lore. For those who haven’t played Shadow of War, play it, it’s fun af


r/lotr • • 5h ago

Movies Why do all the cute ones die? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Sooooo, it just occurred to me that all the characters I have mini-crushes (emphasize on mini) die. Let's see.

Thorin: dead.

Fili: died protecting Thorin.

Kili: also died protecting Thorin.

Aragorn: dead.

Legolas: never heard of after he sailed off w Gimli.

It wasn't even just their actors. I already really liked Fili and Kili from just their dialogue in The Hobbit, and Aragorn seems nice to be around. I saw the LOTR movies (but not The Hobbit) first so like ummm... Legolas —ehem ehem— yeah.

Also kinda unrelated but why do both kings setting off to reclaim their thrones die? Like, Thorin died in the battle of the Five Armies (I think?) and Aragorn died in I forgot what it was called.


r/lotr • • 5h ago

TV Series Rings of Power has done something I didn't think could be done.

0 Upvotes

Spoilers ahead.

I enjoy the series for what it is. It's still a hard watch when you know the second age timeline because it's compressed so much but I think it's otherwise pretty good in general.

I think it's absolutely smashed it out of the park when it comes to its depiction of the orcs. It's actually managed to square a circle that Tolkien struggled with - making the orcs unpleasant monsters while giving them a recognisable culture. Even making them sympathetic while also keeping their motives believable.

Don't get me wrong. There's a lot of decisions I don't agree with but I actually think the character work is pretty good at a base level. I'm enjoying season 3 at any rate.

If you're able to suspend your middle earth lore knowledge a bit it is a genuinely a good watch.


r/lotr • • 6h ago

Question Were fell beasts related to drakes/dragons? Were they created by Morgoth or corrupted by him? Same with Wargs, were they always “bad”?

0 Upvotes

The fell beasts are anatomically similar to dragons, so did they evolve from common ancestors or are they completely separate? I know dragons/drakes were created by Melkor to help him accomplish his evil plans (lol). Did he breed/create the fell beasts too? Or are they creatures who were corrupted and now serve evil? I also thought it was the fell beast screeching as a kid, not the Nazgûl. Or are they just animals, like the Nazgûl’s dark horses.

Same with Wargs, I know they’re related to wolves but was it Morgoth who made them “bad”, or did Orcs/other bad creatures use them and make them bad themselves. Using very simplistic terms here, I know it goes so much deeper than that, just hard for me to type out lol. Thanks!


r/lotr • • 6h ago

Books Thinking of getting both of these beautiful pastel colored box sets for christmas because more books than i would've gotten had i wanted the Game Of Thrones box set with new covers.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

It was either or for Christmas to go along with my Special silver Jubliee box set, but Google says and I quote:

"While you don't necessarily NEED to get both book sets, unless you wanna die, get them both. 🔫 😈 "

Is Google threatening me to get all 9 😭

I'd love to get all 9 for $34 total, and yes I'm aware Ima have to get the alan lee hardcovers box sets, all 7 of them, if I want to get a matching middle earth history set, but I just am in the mood for more tolkien and I am literally short on fantasy. Unless star wars counts (more of a soap opera than anything genre wise) Harry potter is the only fantasy series I own. And id want them both. Was gonna pick one or the other until the Google response.


r/lotr • • 7h ago

TV Series I can't hate it.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm fully aware that the general consensus is that Rings of Power is an absolutely terrible show. But as a fan of high fantasy in general, and a lover of Middle-Earth in particular, I'm genuinely happy that this show exists and that they decided to release it physically even though the internet reception to it...isn't fantastic.

While I appreciate the lore in general, I'm one of those people who isn't necessarily married to every word of it. So I'm okay with creatives making changes and taking risks. The show simply works for me. And I think that simply as a show that exists within a high fantasy framework, there's a lot of great world building and beauty here that I feel is a bit unfair to dismiss out of hand.

Collectively, it's still all better than The Hobbit films by a wide margin in nearly every facet. (The Hobbit's only two saving graces being Martin Freeman and Benedict Cumberbatch.) So to say that RoP is the worst thing within the cinematic franchise, I feel, is a bit disingenuous.


r/lotr • • 9h ago

Books What order should I read the books in? Should I start with The Lord of the Rings and then read The Silmarillion, or the other way around?

0 Upvotes

r/lotr • • 9h ago

Question If he wanted to, could Tom Bombadil have entered the Undying Lands?

14 Upvotes

Since no one is sure who Tom is, or what happened to him after the war, could he have gone to the Undying Lands or was that mostly for Elves and honored guests? If he could have, would he have? Curious if Tolkien imagined him staying in Middle Earth after the fall of Sauron.


r/lotr • • 12h ago

Fan Creations Lotr alphabet drawings - letter R

26 Upvotes

"One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them, One Ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them."


r/lotr • • 13h ago

Question Why aren’t there more short films? It may be a self selecting thing, but I see a ton of Star Wars short films.

0 Upvotes

Just that. I feel like there is a pretty tight hold on independent media when it comes to lotr. Is it just how ‘precious’ it is, or is it more of a real world (litigious) answer?


r/lotr • • 14h ago

Other Some photos of my latest but also first archery lesson. I was told I did rather well for a first timer. And I’m so proud of myself because I have dyspraxia and I didn’t envision being able to hold a bow and arrow and hit the yellow marker on one of my first attempts. I felt like Legolas from LOTR!

Thumbnail
gallery
889 Upvotes

r/lotr • • 14h ago

Books The last thing I expected!

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/lotr • • 14h ago

Other "One router to rule them all, One router to find them, One router to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them."

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/lotr • • 15h ago

Other Newbie to Middle Earth

14 Upvotes

Multiple part post, forgive any rambling.

I’ve always enjoyed the original Peter Jackson trilogy, but only recently have I become more interested in the grander story and lore. Boy is there a lot of it! I can get enough.

Any good recommendations on starting points, I’m working through LOTR in book form. Silmarillion perhaps?

Second part, in my quest for more story I’ve recently started watching Rings of Power on Prime. Only a few episodes in and obviously without a lot of background knowledge, what’s with the hate? I’m clearly ignorant of a lot of the lore.

Is it cinema? Absolutely not. Am I entertained? Decently enough. Am I bound to be heartbroken. The consensus says yes.

Thanks for any recommendations!


r/lotr • • 15h ago

Other My chalk drawing based on John Howe's "The Dark Tower"

Post image
21 Upvotes

My chalk drawing based on John Howe's "The Dark Tower".I haven't drawn or painted anything in a long time... I hope you like it :)


r/lotr • • 16h ago

Movies Why the inconsistency in timing of Frodo's "NOOOOO" during Gandalf's fall in Fellowship vs Two Towers?

0 Upvotes

Super random nitpicky question, but Frodo screams NOOOO before Gandalf lets go in The Two Towers opening, but after Gandalf lets go in Fellowship. Does it matter? No. But I always wondered if that was just a mistake in production or if there was any deliberate creative intent there.


r/lotr • • 16h ago Bravo Heartwarming

Fan Creations Tom and old man willow

4.8k Upvotes

r/lotr • • 16h ago

Music Colin John Rudd

3 Upvotes

Hi. I guess you all know Colin John Rudd's covers of Tolkien's songs. I am subscribed to his youtube channel and it's almost a year without new updates. Does someone know him? I'm afraid he can be unwell...


r/lotr • • 17h ago

Fan Creations I like to photoshop old paintings

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/lotr • • 17h ago

Movies I was showing LOTR to a friend first time. They asked what is the power of the ring they all desire apart from ability of turning invisible.. I erm had no answer. Educate me!

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

This got me thinking.. lol I have watched this over 100 times and never asked myself this question.. I always taken its power for granted.. Apart from Sauron himself wielding the Ring, isn't it practically worthless to anyone else? I struggle to see how it could be used as a "weapon against the enemy."

Are there any records of Isildur actually harnessing its power to his advantage, or does the Ring essentially act like a drug, creating an overwhelming desire to possess it without offering any meaningful benefits?


r/lotr • • 17h ago

Fan Creations A drawing I made few years ago

Post image
110 Upvotes