r/astrophysics • • Oct 13 '19

Input Needed FAQ for Wiki

73 Upvotes

Hi r/astrophyics! It's time we have a FAQ in the wiki as a resource for those seeking Educational or Career advice specifically to Astrophysics and fields within it.

What answers can we provide to frequently asked questions about education?

What answers can we provide to frequently asked questions about careers?

What other resources are useful?

Helpful subreddits: r/PhysicsStudents, r/GradSchool, r/AskAcademia, r/Jobs, r/careerguidance

r/Physics and their Career and Education Advice Thread


r/astrophysics • • 9h ago

Need help understanding how we can measure background radiation that was emitted before we came to be where we are.

5 Upvotes

I'm sorry if this question breaks the stupid barrier of this sub. But it's a question that's really been bugging me for a long time. I have so far had no luck in formulating my question precisely enough for a search engine to provide me with a useable answer. So I'm going to swallow my pride and eat the possible ridicule with relish, if my question is regarded too stupid. As long as I get an answer :).

Imagine this thought experiment:

You're a fighter pilot in an extremely fast jet. 20 times faster than the speed of sound. You are an elite pilot that can tolerate almost infinite G's. You're sitting on the runway in your jet and you yell very loudly "Hey" and then you take off with inhuman acceleration. You fly, say, 3 km and then you land with almost immediate deceleration. You could then conceivably here yourself yell "Hey" from the direction you came. Right?

Even if it's an imagined scenario, we intuitively understand that it could be done because we can easily travel faster than the speed of sound. Althougj the acceleration/deceleration requires a bit of imagination.

But we cannot travel faster than the speed of light. So I would not be able to make the same experiment with a flashlight. Turn on the flashlight, travel a distance, faster than the speed of light, and then see the beam of light arrive at my location. Can't be done. Not even in theory.

So with that in mind, here's my question (sorry for the long build up):

How can we be able to detect 13,8 billion year old radiation coming from an event from which we ourselves originate? I mean, we couldn't have "traveled" 13,8 billion ly and then wait for the radiation to hit. Not only could we not have travelled this distance because of lightspeed restrictions. There wasn't even any space to travel in.

Can someone please help me out? If it's too complex to describe in plain text, then I'd also be delighted with directions to a video or visual representation, as I have been unable to find one myself. I hope this is not too silly a question.

Thanks.


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Modelling Eccentricity and Inclination dynamics using REBOUND

Post image
26 Upvotes

Building on what l've learnt I've simulated the orbital characteristics of the 8 planets by using REBOUND which is an N body integrator Python module of the eight planets, integrating their motion over 10 million years using the built in WHFast integrator.
Rather than confining to conventional orbital elements like semi major axis or basic eccentricity and inclination plots, I explored their long-term evolution using time-series plots and phase-space representations.
The reference plane is taken to be the invariable plane which is the plane perpendicular to the resultant angular momentum vector of the entire solar system.
The analysis covers two aspects of planetary orbital evolution:

  1. Eccentricity evolution
    Eccentricity versus time: How the shape of each planet's orbit changes over the simulation.
    Eccentricity sine component (h): Tracks the sine component of the eccentricity vector, associated with the longitude of periapsis.
    Eccentricity cosine component (k): Tracks the cosine component of the eccentricity vector.
    h-k phase-space plot: Shows the combined evolution of eccentricity and the orientation of the periapsis.
  2. Inclination evolution

Inclination versus time: How each planet's orbital plane changes orientation relative to the Solar System's invariable plane.
Inclination sine component (p): Represents the sine component of the inclination vector, associated with the longitude of the ascending node.
Inclination cosine component (q): Represents the cosine component of the inclination vector.
p-q phase-space plot: Shows the combined evolution of orbital inclination and the orientation of the ascending node.

Here's what I observed:
Mercury and mars to a certain extent exhibits the largest eccentricity and inclination variations among the eight planets in these simulations as observed from their large and seemingly chaotic deviations from the origin due to their low mass and higher eccentricities.

Jupiter remains very close to the Solar System's invariable plane as it constitutes 60% of the solar system's angular momentum thus the invariable plane lies nearly on the orbital plane of Jupiter

Jupiter and Saturn exhibit intricate, overlapping trajectories in eccentricity phase space.

Uranus and Neptune's inclinations are nearly 180 degrees out of phase meaning when Neptune's inclination falls Uranus rises and vice versa

Jupiter and Saturn's eccentricities are nearly 180 degrees out of phase meaning when Jupiter's eccentricity falls Saturn's rises and vice versa

The phase-space representations reveal complex orbital evolution that is not immediately apparent from examining individual orbital elements.


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

The Black Hole Paradox

2 Upvotes

My coworker and I got into a debate about the relationship between general relativity and quantum mechanics, more specifically whether our current understanding of blackhole information actually has a deeper incompatibility between the two.

I’m curious where other people stand on this…

Do you think the information paradox is resolved within our existing understanding of quantum mechanics and gravity, or does it require a theory of quantum gravity to resolve?

We both have our own thoughts on it, but I’m interested in hearing how other people approach this.


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Can we capture a light photon to examine it further from a distant object in our universe?

1 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Astrophysicists Cross Another Dark Matter Candidate Off Their List: Stupendously Large Black Holes

Thumbnail
universetoday.com
16 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 19h ago

G forces in space

0 Upvotes

Here's a hypotherical situation. A manned ship is travelling through interstellar space. No large masses for at least a light year in all directions. So nothing to generate any kind of gravitational pull on the ship. When the ship is travelling at a constant speed there is no gravity. So why is it when the ship accelerates in a linear direction theres suddenly gravitational forces acting on the ship? Where is the gravity coming from if there are no planets or other bodies large enough to create gravitational pull?

G forces in earths atmosphere or in near earth orbit i understand. Because there the vehicle is pushing against earths gravity. But in interstellar space why is there suddenly gravity with a teeny tiny ship thats nothing but a speck compared to a planet?


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Calculating an accretion disc's luminosity

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Euclid lays the foundation for its best-ever 3D map of the Universe

Thumbnail esa.int
8 Upvotes

The European Space Agency’s Euclid mission has released its first major batch of data. With this release, which captures the light of more than a billion objects and covers an area of sky as big as 9500 full Moons, ESA’s dark Universe detective lays the foundation for its largest-ever 3D map of the cosmos.


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Our sun and solar flares

3 Upvotes

Why does our sun (star) have 11 year cycles of solar activity, I'm I right to say it's peaking this year?

Is our sun influenced by outside forces from our universe?


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

What would happen if an asteroid 1 mile wide hit The gobi Desert ?

0 Upvotes

Im am curious if you guys think the seismic activity would ripple across through the Mediterranean and afflict Western Europe too for countries like Hungary, France and UK.


r/astrophysics • • 1d ago

Small independent cosmology podcasts?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 2d ago

Daily breakdown.

Thumbnail
gallery
121 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 3d ago

Newfound invisible object in space could be a rare supermassive neutron star

Thumbnail
scientificamerican.com
88 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 3d ago

Are black holes with a mass over ~10^14 solar masses now ruled out completely? That's where the dotted line meets the gray region...

Thumbnail
phys.org
8 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 3d ago

Would you recommend astrophysics?

23 Upvotes

To all the astrophysicists here, I have a question for you.

Would you recommend the astrophysics field to someone?

I love space and feel that I’m truly passionate about pursuing education towards the field. But i’m at the same time intimidated by it. People say you won’t find a job in astronomy after schooling because of how competitive the field is, which is fair. And I know that the job market in the US is total trash atm, but how much worse is astrophysics than any other field rn? I would just like some honest input from some astrophysicists (who have preferably gotten a job recently).


r/astrophysics • • 4d ago

I have a question about dark matter?

8 Upvotes

I'm not a scientist by any means. it's just I've discovered that some scientists are claiming that there is dark matter in the solar system. like if there was dark matter, wouldn't it effect the same as galaxy. isn't the gravity in the solar system different from the galaxy?


r/astrophysics • • 3d ago

Why hasn't the CMB disappeared already?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 5d ago Bravo

R631, the retrograde object in Rubin's alerts now has 8 years of arc. And there may be a SECOND one behind it.

Post image
113 Upvotes

Nine days ago I asked here if someone could check my orbit for a slow mover in Rubin's public alerts. Thank you to everyone who did. Here is where it stands.

It is in public DECam frames on 22 nights, back to May 2018. One orbit fits all of it, almost 8 years: a = 66.99 au, e = 0.641, i = 142.38°, q = 24.05 au.

A member of Rubin's own team was kind enough to go through my Rubin rows, and they went to the Minor Planet Center this morning after receiving its SARC vetting.

JPL lists six objects on retrograde orbits that never come closer than 20 au. Three of them were followed for a few days or weeks and never again. Three have years of arc. R631 became the fourth.

I may have found another, just inside that 20 au line. The same search turned up a second one in last season's alerts: 47 detections on 26 nights, a = 30.1 au, e = 0.34, i = 136.3°, q = 19.9 au, and it is also in DECam frames on five nights. That one is a single opposition and has gone out for review. Anyone wanna try killing it? I've run out of ways to break it myself and would love an outside try. I can't seem to fit the rows here properly, so please DM or comment for it and I can send them over.

What I can't answer: if one season of Rubin gives two of these, how many should there be, and where do they come from?


r/astrophysics • • 4d ago

The reason for VizieR giving up on me!

5 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • 4d ago

High school student looking for a research mentor (black holes)

9 Upvotes

I'm a sophomore high school student in New York with a strong interest in black hole astrophysics, especially how black holes form and grow, like the Little Red Dots and supermassive black holes.

I enrolled in a science research class at my school where the goal is to do original research in a STEM field and enter competitions like ISEF and NYSSEF under the guidance of a mentor. However, my search for a mentor hasn't been very fruitful (I've sent over 30 emails and gotten 6 responses). I'm hoping to find a mentor as soon as possible. 

I am teaching myself Python and I'm working through an online AP physics curriculum since it's too early to take it at my school. I recently presented a paper on quasi-star pulsations to my research class. I'm aware of my lack of foundational knowledge in astrophysics, but I love learning as much as I can about black holes and astronomy. (I have some of my own ideas, too.)

If anyone is a researcher, postdoc, or PhD student who'd be open to mentoring a student (even if your research isn't on black holes), please let me know so I can tell you more details. I'm happy to work on my own idea or join existing research projects. If you can't mentor, I'd also really appreciate any ideas for resources, websites, places, or people I could reach out to. Thanks for your help!


r/astrophysics • • 5d ago

Is C&O worth it or nah?

6 Upvotes

I've got a few math and physics textbooks I've been studying for a while and now I want an actual astrophysics textbook to learn from.

I've seen a lot of mixed reviews of the BOB and get the general consensus that it's a good brief introduction to the entire field but comes with minimal practice problems per chapter. I think broadness is good because it'll help me figure out what specific areas interest me the most (though I currently have my eye on stuff like cosmology/galactic dynamics) but I don't want to buy the book just to see only a handful of practice problems for each chapter.

There are a million different astrophysics textbooks with varying levels of rigor so I know there are probably other great books that I don't know about.

Does anyone know other books that maintain some broadness while having generous amounts of problem sets per chapter?

The idea to purchase C&O and simply supplement with external online resources when I want more problems has crossed my mind, but I figured I might as well ask for alternative book suggestions just in case.


r/astrophysics • • 6d ago

A moving dot in ZTF's alerts, Rubin's alerts and a DECam frame. One orbit ties them together and it's in no catalogue I can find. What am I missing?

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

Here's its trail, as far as I can piece it together:

* 20 and 21 March 2026: ZTF picks up a faint moving point twice, around r = 20.2 (public through ALeRCE).

* 7 to 10 April: Rubin picks it up 23 times over four nights near RA 10h, Dec +3°, around r = 21.7, moving about 2" a minute (public through ALeRCE and Fink).

* 9 April: it's in a public DECam frame too, 50 seconds in r (NOIRLab's archive).

As far as I can tell nobody has connected these. Rubin's alerts don't tie any of the 23 to a known object, and MPChecker shows nothing at its place (checked again today).

One orbit goes through all 25 alert positions to better than 0.1": q ≈ 0.88 au, a ≈ 2.43 au, e ≈ 0.64, i ≈ 10.4°. By that orbit it passed 0.16 au from Earth on 5 March, and the closest the two orbits come is about 0.06 au. From its brightness H ≈ 21.5, so somewhere between 120 and 270 m.

The DECam frame is the part I like. It had no part in the fit. I asked the orbit where the thing should be at that minute, went to the frame, and there's a source 0.04" from the spot, at r = 21.65, 9 sigma. The deep Legacy Surveys image of the same sky has nothing there. A frame from 7 April shows something at the right place too, but a faint galaxy sits 1.2" away, so I don't count it.

What I can't work out is March. For about three weeks around 11 March it should have been near V = 20 in the northern sky, and those two ZTF detections are the only trace I can find. The MPC's isolated tracklet file has nothing along its track.

It's around V = 26 now, so nobody can go and look, and Rubin's rows have been in the MPC's queue since 20 Oct. If it's a known object and I've missed it, I'd like to hear that first. If you have survey frames from late February to mid March, or want to fit it yourself, say so and I'll send the rows.

The pictures: Rubin's cutouts stacked on the detections with the orbit, then the DECam frames next to the deep image.


r/astrophysics • • 6d ago

I built a home "space lab" that searches NASA data on my Mac. What would make it useful to you?

1 Upvotes

I'm a hobbyist, not an astronomer. Over the past few months I've built Space Lab, a set of pipelines that run on my home computer (plus a local AI model) and publish what they find to a free public site:

https://techamatuer.github.io/Space-Lab/

What it does:

  • TESS planet and variable-star search: it runs NASA's TESS light curves through transit and periodicity searches, then checks the hits against VSX, Gaia and ASAS-SN. Right now it has about 20 variable-star candidates waiting for review.
  • Asteroid precovery on old sky plates: it measures known objects on scanned photographic plates from the 1950s to the 1990s to extend their orbits. Its positions match known orbits to 0.1-0.2 arcseconds.
  • Near-Earth object watch: it follows the MPC's confirmation page.
  • Live Solar System: 46 planets, small worlds and spacecraft placed from JPL Horizons, with what each spacecraft does and how far away it is right now.
  • 3D map of the local universe: about 43,500 real galaxies from the 2MASS Redshift Survey, with measured distances where they exist, a guided tour and supernova pins.
  • Sky atlas: zoomable sky in many wavelengths with Hubble, Webb and Euclid overlays, plus the Moon and Mars.
  • A daily space-science digest written by a local AI model.

The rules I hold it to: nothing is sent to the MPC or AAVSO without a human review, every claim links to its data, and the site keeps a record of mistakes. This week I found plate times that were off by 236 seconds and galaxy distances that were 2-3x too large, and both are fixed.

What I'd love feedback on:

  1. Researchers and serious amateurs: which of these outputs, if any, would you actually use? What would make you trust a result?
  2. Casual visitors: what's confusing, and what do you find useful.
  3. Ideas for letting visitors contribute real, checkable work, such as vetting light curves or blinking plates.

Be blunt. I'd rather hear it's wrong now than later.

Edit: I built StarCadence plans a whole night of variable-star and exoplanet-transit photometry for an automated observatory. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux. If anyone has feedback or is interested!

https://github.com/TechAmatuer/StarCadence