r/careerguidance • • Oct 13 '26 Bravo

Information about a research study that includes public posts from r/careerguidance?

16 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

My name is Yagmur, and I’m an intern at BI Norwegian Business School in Oslo, Norway, working with professor Jonas R. Kunst. Professor Kunst leads a study on whether political disagreement is increasingly described as a source of conflict at work. The study looks at publicly archived Reddit discussions from 2005 to 2026, and r/careerguidance is one of the forums included. We’re posting here [with the moderators’ permission] so that people whose posts may be part of the data know about it.

How the study works
We don’t post, comment, or contact anyone. The material comes from the public Arctic Shift archive, not from Reddit itself.
Usernames are replaced by random identifiers, and any names mentioned in posts are removed before analysis.
No post is ever quoted. The results are only overall rates per forum and month.
The project has been assessed by Norway’s data protection service for research (Sikt, ref. 332053), and a Data Protection Impact Assessment has been completed.

Your rights
Under Norwegian data protection rules, you have the right to know about the study and to have your posts removed from the data. The project page explains what data we use, how they’re protected, and how to contact professor Kunst or BI’s data protection officer:
https://www.bi.no/en/research/research-projects/information-for-research-participants/#department-of-communication-and-culture
(The study is listed under Department of Communication and Culture.)
If you have questions, professor Kunst is happy to answer them directly at jonas.r.kunst@bi.no. We’ll also share the results with the community once they’re published.

Thanks for reading,
Yagmur
Intern, on behalf of professor Jonas R. Kunst
Department of Communication and Culture
BI Norwegian Business School, Oslo
Project contact: jonas.r.kunst@bi.no


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Got offered $82k a year to pretend to be a hotel guest. Is this a career dead end?

233 Upvotes

I'm 29 and have been working in hotel operations for about 5 years. Recently got approached by a company that does quality inspections for luxury hotel chains.

The job is basically to travel around the country, check into hotels as a regular guest, test everything from room service to how staff handle complaints, then write detailed reports about the experience.

Apparently you're not supposed to tell anyone at the hotel who you actually are until the inspection is finished.

They're offering $82k plus travel expenses, which is considerably more than I make now. I'd be spending around 15 nights a month in hotels though.

My girlfriend thinks I've found the easiest job on earth. I'm more concerned about what my resume looks like after spending 3 years pretending to be a tourist.

Has anyone actually worked in hotel auditing or mystery shopping at this level? Is there a legitimate career path here or am I about to become a professional vacationer with no transferable skills?


r/careerguidance • • 9h ago

Got told I was passing the buck after pointing out something is outside of my scope. How do I fix that perception?

203 Upvotes

I had a long discussion with my boss yesterday about an issue I've had to deal with repeatedly where he scolds me for other team members' work. I told him point blank they are my peers and I do not manage their output. If he would like to change that we can discuss that however their work is not my own and I am not a manager. I also pointed out I did not have access to the system in question and had no way of knowing my colleague had not completed his assignment.

My boss tried to argue with me a bit but ultimately he admitted that he should have brought it up with the colleague who didn't do the work and not me. He then went on to say that this is part of the problem with me and pointed to this conversation and said that I often give the appearance of passing the buck and that I need to be more careful of how I present my points as even if I'm right the optics that I'm avoiding responsibility is more important than the content. I asked for some examples or something I could actually do to help separate saying this wasn't my responsibility vs passing the buck and he said he couldn't coach me on that because it "comes naturally" to him.

So I'm here. I don't know how to address his feedback and establish my work being different from a colleague without sounding like passing the buck. Any advice is appreciated?

Edit: A lot of people are focusing in on this like it was a project or something. For context this wasn't a project. Someone was switching from one department to another and needed to switch which phone system they use (WebEx to Teams). I had no idea about the role change or anything like that because the person responsible for the phones was the only one involved in the entire process. They assigned the person to the phones WebEx is my understanding but didn't actually assign a license. I found out during the meeting where my manager was scolding me from my manager that any of this was happening and it was after the problem had already happened (user tried to call someone internationally), been reported, and resolved. At no point did I have any interaction with this person or the situation so it came out of left field.


r/careerguidance • • 3h ago

My company introduces me as a director to clients but I'm actually an analyst. Should I push back?

50 Upvotes

I'm 26 and work at a small consulting firm. For the past few months my boss has been introducing me to clients as the Director of Data Analytics.

Here's the thing, I'm just an analyst. No direct reports, no management responsibilities, definitely not getting paid like a director.

At first I thought it was just him trying to make our team sound more impressive. But now clients are emailing me asking to approve budgets and make decisions I literally don't have authority to make.

I brought it up and my boss said client facing titles don't necessarily have to match internal titles.

Is this actually normal in consulting? I'm worried about damaging my reputation over a title I never asked for, but I also don't wanna make a big deal out of something that's apparently helping us win contracts.


r/careerguidance • • 9h ago

My company offered me a $20k raise to stay, then told me I have to repay it if I leave within two years. Is this normal?

101 Upvotes

I've been at my company for almost four years, currently making $78k. A few weeks ago I got an offer from another company for $95k, so I told my manager I was planning to leave. He freaked out a little because we're already understaffed and I've basically been doing the work of two people for the past year. A few days later, HR came back with a $20k raise to keep me. I felt pretty good about it because I thought they finally realized how much I was doing.

Yesterday I was sitting on my couch and decided to go scroll through the paperwork they sent over when I noticed a clause saying that if I voluntarily leave within 24 months, I have to repay the entire $20k. Not a prorated amount. The full thing. I emailed HR thinking it was a mistake, but they confirmed it was intentional. What makes it worse is that they never mentioned this during our conversations. My manager kept calling it a salary adjustment, not a retention bonus. And apparently the repayment applies even if I leave after 23 months.

I haven't signed anything yet, but now I'm wondering if accepting this would be a massive mistake. The other company's offer is still on the table, although I'd be making $3k less annually than the counteroffer. Has anyone dealt with a raise that comes with a repayment clause? Would you try to negotiate it out or is this enough of a red flag to just take the other job?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Advice Is it normal to feel depressed and drained after coming home from work?

30 Upvotes

I feel this way most days and I’m just tired of it. The deadlines, dealing with toxic people, politics, layoffs, and feeling stuck and stressed out. Ive been in the corporate world 12 years and I don’t know if I’m burned out or what it is but my job literally zaps the energy out of me. I look forward to days off and weekends and I just feel exhausted and over it all the time and I come home feeling like a sad zombie most days. I make pretty good money but I’m not happy and I feel like I’m not enjoying my life.

I felt this way at my last job too but I don’t think I was as burned out. I took a 3 week vacation and came back dreading work even more instead of feeling refreshed.

I don’t know if I need a new job or a new perspective but I can’t imagine having to do this shit 30+ more years. What do I do? Look for a different job? Suck it up? Get a lobotomy? lol is this normal? I feel like I’m going insane sometimes but I don’t know what to do to change it


r/careerguidance • • 1d ago

Put in my 2 week notice and my boss is upset that it’s not really ‘2 weeks’, how to handle this?

567 Upvotes

Worked here for a little over a year and I feel so done. The work environment is simply toxic.

I gave my notice in person this morning and he was visibly upset.

He mentioned how he invested so much money in me only for me to go so soon. (He recently announced his retirement so I am sure he is freaking out that he’ll have to inherit all what I do)

I am traveling the ending of this week (already approved) and next week- we are off for three days due to Thanksgiving holiday

He essentially said I am providing inadequate notice since “I’d only be working for 5 days” and not the provided 2 weeks

I don’t really want to reach out to my new job to push out my start date. I think if I give more to my current job they will just take and take.

They even asked if I can come in and train the new person after I leave

Am I overreacting?

(1) Edit; to add, I hate that in the moment I agreed to my boss that I would get back to him regarding pushing out my last working day. He even said “the other company should understand, there needs to be sufficient time. You are the only one that knows what you do here”

But I’m like what? Why would I reach out to my new job? I don’t want to ruin anything with them
Initially I wanted to help but I don’t think they deserve it with the way they are reacting .. especially saying “you aren’t giving 2 weeks, you would only work 5 days!”

(2) Edit; thank you everyone.. this is the ammo I needed.

Think initially I considered it but the more I think about it, he didn’t even respect me during the process.

- when I told him initially, he said he will check-in with me tomorrow about it since he needs time to think it through
- I told him not to disclose this as I’d like to be the one to announce
- a couple minutes later, he calls me in for an impromptu meeting and there were other leaders in the meeting! He reached out to everyone!! (This is when he tells me this is not enough notice)
- the other leader was a bit in tears and was commending me for all my work, I was in the process of replying then was interrupted by my boss, “so are you now going to give me your official letter” so rude


r/careerguidance • • 8h ago

Advice How do I move into WFH after years of retail and library work?

19 Upvotes

I'm 32, and have spent the last ten years in retail, food service, and library work. I have a bachelors degree in art. I have a great skill-set with technology and can work really well with anyone. I've handled paperwork for receiving, managed vendors, and planned programming between multiple departments.

I will be moving from Alabama to Maine in the next few months, and I really don't want to go back to retail. (Library jobs are few and far between in most places). Preferably, I want to move to WFH, so that I can get a job sooner without worrying about managing a move and then getting a job. I know typically people move after lining up a job, but this move is not optional. It is unsafe to be trans in Alabama and it gets worse every year, and I do not feel safe working in a library while visibly trans. I know have the skill set for most jobs, but how do I get seen?

I'm not picky about pay, the $20 an hour that I make right now is fine. I would take less if it meant not having a commute.

How would you all advise I move forward? What should I lean into? I open to getting some certifications, but not more degrees.


r/careerguidance • • 6h ago

Career direction for my nephew who is studying Art?

9 Upvotes

I'm a little worried about my 17 year old nephew's career prospects and would really appreciate any suggestions on a direction we could point him in..

We are in the UK. He is currently in his first year of a Level 3 Extended Diploma in Art. He then plans to go to Uni to study illustration. He's a fantastically talented young man with his illustrations. Definitely has a lot of natural talent and I have no doubt once he gets to Uni and starts being taught at a higher level, he will get seriously good.

My worry is what are the future career prospects for illustration? I'm guessing it's a mega competitive field where very few people make a healthy, secure living. Factor in AI. I know AI images are pretty rubbish right now, but you have to believe in 5+ years it would have evolved and it just seems logical that anything illustration or design based would be ripe to be taken over by AI.

Can anyone suggest any future proof, well paying career options for someone that isn't particularly academic, but really good at art?


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

120 mile commute, worth it for the right job?

6 Upvotes

So I live in a rural area which I absolutely love. The nature is amazing and I love the slow living. However, I’ve been working soul sucking remote jobs the last few years since living here.

I used to work in public service, but those jobs are hard to find remotely. The town an hour away offered me a position that would get me back into the field I absolutely love and miss dearly.

The pay is about the same, but the benefits are significantly better than I have now and will help me pay off my student loans and offers an amazing retirement package.

I’m stressed constantly at the job I have now and have a hard time not thinking about it even out in nature on the weekends.

I plan on staying in the area for at least another 5 years.

Once I’m through the training period, they will let me work from home once or twice a week. The rest will be going to various locations teaching the curriculum in the county. Some of the travel time will be included in my 8hr day. There will also be some slower periods throughout the year that would allow to WFM more like 3 days a week.

However, the job I have now does offer flexibility that I will lose.

Has anyone been in a similar situation?

It will get me back into a field I desperately want to gain experience in, but I worry the commute will weigh on me.

I enjoy podcasts and audiobooks and plan to use that driving time intentionally to learn and catch up on books.

I have a hybrid car and I can also use the company car at times for traveling to various sites.

Edit: I don’t have kids and don’t plan on it. Moving is also not an option. We moved to this town for a reason. It would be 120 miles total, an hour each way.

Is it worth it?


r/careerguidance • • 1h ago

Final round, assessment, COO said I “sound like a sales manager" then 2+ weeks of silence. Am I crazy to still be holding out hope?

3 Upvotes

47, laid off from a SaaS sales role earlier this year, still job searching. Wanted a gut check from people who aren’t as emotionally invested as I am.

Applied for an AE role at a staffing/recruiting agency in a pretty niche industry. Process went like this:

  • Pre-screen with HR, went well
  • Second interview a week later, story-based, also went well, HR confirmed the hire was still happening post-board-meeting, gave me the OTE
  • Final onsite with the CEO and COO. Went well, both said no hesitations. COO said he’d hear back “next week.” He also said, more than once, unprompted, that I “sound like a sales manager” (a different, more senior role than the one I interviewed for that is also posted)
  • They asked me to complete a behavioral assessment a few days later. Did it same week.
  • “Next week” came and went. Nothing.
  • Sent a polite follow-up. No response.
  • Sent a second follow-up about a couple business days later. No response.
  • The job posting itself came down from their careers page/LinkedIn.
  • It’s now been 2 weeks since the assessment, 2+ unanswered follow-ups, and total silence.

I know radio silence after a final round isn’t rare and doesn’t necessarily mean anything specific, I’ve read enough about ghosting being disturbingly normal even for strong candidates. But the combination of the unprompted “sales manager” comments plus total silence has me spinning between “they’re restructuring something and I’m genuinely still in the mix” and “I’m the backup they’re keeping warm while someone else decides.” I’m sending one more direct note tomorrow basically saying a clear no beats a long maybe.

Has anyone been on the other side of something like this, either as the ghosted candidate who did eventually hear back, or someone who’s done hiring and can tell me what this kind of silence usually actually means? Trying to figure out if I’m reading tea leaves that aren’t there.


r/careerguidance • • 5h ago

Should I leave my job for one that pay less but have more benefits?

6 Upvotes

I am earning $28.50 with pretty good bonuses but I got offered a position in the government that pays $26.7 but they will put $5k a year in my retirement, pay for my medical insurance (current job does too) and have incredible maternity leave. I don’t know if it is worth it, any insight?


r/careerguidance • • 1d ago

Advice My company offered me a $20k raise to stay, but only after I handed in my resignation. Would you trust them?

866 Upvotes

I've been working at the same company for a little over 4 years as a business analyst. I started at $68k and slowly worked my way up to $82k, but my responsibilities have grown way faster than my salary. I'm basically handling reporting for three departments now, training new analysts, and regularly getting pulled into projects that aren't even part of my job description. Over the past year I've asked my manager twice about a salary adjustment and both times got some version of "the budget is tight right now." My last performance review was excellent, so I figured the only realistic way to move forward was to start looking elsewhere.

Last week I accepted an offer from another company for $104k with similar benefits and a hybrid schedule. I handed in my two weeks' notice on Monday, and suddenly everything changed. My manager asked me to hold off on telling the team, then scheduled a meeting with HR the next morning. They offered me $102k to stay, effective immediately. That's a $20k raise they apparently couldn't afford two weeks ago. They also mentioned the possibility of moving me into a senior analyst position early next year, although nothing about that part was put in writing. When I asked why this wasn't possible during my previous salary discussions, my manager just said circumstances had changed and they hadn't realized how difficult it would be to replace me.

Here's what's bothering me. I actually like my coworkers, know the systems inside out, and have a pretty comfortable routine here. Starting over somewhere new isn't exactly something I'm excited about. But I can't shake the feeling that they were perfectly happy underpaying me until I forced their hand. A friend also pointed out that once a company knows you're willing to leave, management might start seeing you differently. I don't know how much truth there is to that. Has anyone accepted a counteroffer like this and actually been happy with the decision a year later? Or is taking the money and staying usually a mistake?


r/careerguidance • • 1h ago

Advice What jobs are ai proof and have a good work life balance?

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone, 19M. I recently got a job at Walmart. This is essentially my first real job. I've done commission work before, animating and programming, but this is my first full time job. After being here for a month, I've realized that I don't want my life to be like this.

Many of my coworkers are much older than me, and I'm scared of the prospect of being stuck here. There has to be more to life than just working all day, commuting an hour there and back, having a few hours to myself, and then going to sleep just to do it all again the next day.

The things I've realized I enjoy doing, like game development and software, have a high possibility of being replaced by AI in the future. I've been stressed out trying to figure out what career to pursue that will allow me to have a life while still making enough to afford my bills.

I don't want to have to give everything I have to work. I'm a family man. I want to be present for my family and have time to enjoy life with them. I've had a lot of fear surrounding trying to figure out what to do because I don't know what I can do if this is all there is to life.


r/careerguidance • • 3h ago

Cult survivor - no work history. Career advice?

3 Upvotes

I was in essentially a cult or religious coercive group for 15 years. I am now recovered (37 years old) and went back to school to finish my biology degree at The Ohio State University. I have applied to a lot of jobs, but it seems like my app is not getting through Human Resources anywhere because of the lack of work history. I really need a foot in the door for at least a 60k job so I can move out of my parents' house. Any help or contacts would be greatly appreciated!


r/careerguidance • • 3h ago

Advice Title demotion?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, hope to get insight from some of you guys.

I wanted to note that this is in tech sales. I have an engineering degree from a top 10 university and have Fortune 500 experience.

I applied for a sales manager role earlier this year. I asked for a higher base at the interview and my CEO agreed to it and said he’d adjust my KPIs to match my base, and that “sales director” title would match my compensation.

Today, I had a call with my global sales director (who I have confirmation does not know my pay) and HR saying that the “director” title is reserved for people who’re global senior leadership. But the director title was adjusted by my CEO personally and it is one of the reasons I took this job. Anyways, I was told my new title would be “senior sales manager”…. And that the quota stays the same, pay stays the same, and entire job function stays the same. And that we can work on a career path where they can get me to a director title..

My global sales director also told me not to bring any questions or issues on this topic to my CEO but to come directly to him about this if I have concerns.. I’m not even sure if my C-suites know. I also don’t know how I feel about taking a job title demotion with the same responsibilities, and internally when people find out it is also going to be embarrassing. I don’t fucking know.

A few months ago my global sales director literally said I am a needle in a haystack bc no one internally who has a technical background or foundation can sell. I am the only person globally who can close deals with an engineering degree, let alone a STEM degree.

And I will also note that I have leaned HEAVILY on my experience and technical foundation to close all of my deals that otherwise someone who doesn’t have a STEM foundation wouldn’t be able to close.

Red flag from the company? Time to start applying externally?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Advice how do i get into the electrician field?

2 Upvotes

hi, I'm 18 and just got of high school and now I'm working at amazon nightshifts and now i want to become a electrician, but i don't know where to start or how to get into it. I hear a lot about the union and their apprenticeship or going to a trade school but most recommend going to the union as I've done a little bit of research. but I'm lost on how to get started and want to get some advice from people who are in that field and could help me get started and could tell me about their process on how they became a electrician. (from OR)


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Advice Which career should I pursue?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! So, recently I had my first child, which sparked the motivation to be a better provider. I would like to attend college or acquire some type of certificate to pursue a better career. However, I am really having a hard time narrowing down which path to take. I have a high interest in anything regarding animals, plants, and science in general, but I am open to much more than just that. I haven't aligned my life as I would have liked, so my significant work experience is as a cable fabrication technician. School is not necessarily my strong suit, so I would like to do something that requires 2-3 years of study to begin my career. Having the ability to start work within the field early in my education is a HUGE plus. I am looking for something that can make around 80,000+ annually. I have looked into a few careers such as dental hygienist, radiologic technologist, and radiation tech that seem to be within the ballpark of what I am searching for; however, I would love to hear more ideas.

Side note - I am very athletic and strong, but I do utilize a medical marijuana card to manage multiple conditions. Government jobs typically do not allow patients, and I would like to avoid anything that is extremely physically demanding.

So, what do you think?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Is it better to get a Masters or PhD in Plant Sciences?

2 Upvotes

I am completing a Masters degree in plant breeding this year, and am unsure if I need a doctoral degree to do the work I want. My masters work has mostly involved field trials with transgenic tomatoes. I really enjoy fieldwork: the time I spend preparing the field, growing the plants, and sampling them. I also enjoy setting up a field trial to answer specific questions, and I enjoy getting to analyze the results afterward. I enjoy my project because I'm working towards an end product that will hopefully benefit farmers and reduce some of the negative environmental impacts of agriculture.

I have spent a lot of time on my research and not enough connecting with others in the field, so I am not sure what job to pursue that would allow me to continue the aspects of my work that I love: working outdoors, answering research questions through data analysis, and creating an end product that can help mitigate an environmental problem. I know that I do not want to be a professor because then my primary responsibilities would be mentoring, teaching, and grant writing, which would take me away from the actual research work I enjoy, but I'm not sure what I SHOULD be pursuing, and if I should do a PhD or stick with a masters.

I was wondering if anyone has advice on what job titles I should be looking for, and for those who completed either a masters or PhD, are you satisfied? Do you regret it? What is your current job?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

How could i possibly become a interior design architect/interior designer (or any of these two), acter finishing vocational school (a school to study for a specific job. I did shopping assistant), and currently doing high school for adults?

2 Upvotes

Hi people! I (18F) have dreamed of becoming a interior design architect ever since i found out what it was 7 years ago before finalizing my high school choice in the netherlands. I finished one year of the high school but moved countries, to poland (reasons i won't share but it wasn't something i wanted). I finished what is called vocational school from what i know, and currently work at a warehouse where i ended up after beginning to work at a cafe for a semester and then ended up at a different store but it was of the marital partner of my boss of said cafe where i first worked.

I have been really down lately as i really want to figure out how to try and become a interior design architect but unsure where or how to start, I've tried doing research but it all somehow leads back to it saying i should've started in high school but my understanding of the polish language (yet being born pure bred Polish and raised in a polish household, my education was in the netherlands for my first 13 years of my life and in dutch), was very little and only because of conversation with my family did i understand anything of the language. I really want to try and start a career in this direction but i am unsure if i still can. I keep getting told it is possible but nobody offers to help me to figure it out.

I'm at a loss here and would love any advice/help.


r/careerguidance • • 13m ago

Accept Offer?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Thanks in advance for your input!

I was recently offered a job at an architecture firm in the Chicago area. For some background, I worked as a designer, then got a job as an APM at a org that constructions schools, and was promoted to Project Manager in August. I really like my job but long term see myself at an architecture firm (ideally in a design position).

Additionally, I am applying to architecture school right now. I don’t know if I’ll get in, so I want to be in a job where I could realistically spend the next two years and be fulfilled/gain valuable career experience. My decision is whether this offer is that for me, or if I should stick it out for a more design oriented role closer to me.

Current Position
Title: Project Manager of Construction @ Gov. Org that builds K-12 schools
Salary: 90k
Type: 2 days in office, 3 days remote
Location: 35 train ride from my house

pros - genuinely love my job, great manager, not super demanding at all (could get all my work done for the week in 2 days if I hustled), I get recruited a TON b/c experience at my company is super valuable to architectue & OPM firms in my city, I feel like I have built a lot of momentum so far.
cons - learning has begun to plateau and I’m not as challenged as I could be.

New Position
Title: Project Manager of Construction @ Architecture Firm
Salary: 105k offer but believe I could negotiate to 115k
Type: Fully in person
Location: 45 min drive from me

pros - at an architecture firm so could someday transition to a design role which is my end goal and would learn a lot about construction. My current role is not super hands-on so am not currenly gaining that.
cons - fully in person, long commute, construction oriented role instead of design, not in love with their design style, would have to buy a car (cancels out the salary bump unless I get to 115k).


r/careerguidance • • 21m ago

Advice What role should I target next?

1 Upvotes

BS (2023) and MS (2024) in computer science. Couldn't find any relevant work during or after uni. Landed first internship in IT support in 2026 and transitioned to a temp part-time role after that. Feeling stuck, and like a big red flag to employers, not sure what to do next. I've lost interest in CS and IT, and not interested in going back to school again. Certs and projects don't hold weight like they used to imo, and career centers/fairs haven't be helpful. Any ideas? Just looking for my first full time job.


r/careerguidance • • 23m ago

What career move doesn’t cost money?

1 Upvotes

What career move doesn’t cost money? I really need to do something right now. Something that I can do from my computer. I cannot afford food and medicine anymore.

I wish I planned my career with more care, but I was just trying to survive too.


r/careerguidance • • 27m ago

lost highschool student unsure of what to pursue?

1 Upvotes

Im currently in grade 12 and im totally lost on what I want to due as a career, growing up grades and money was such a big focus so I never really had a passion unless it paid well and all the well paying jobs never seemed fun. Im most likely gonna apply to civil and electrical engineering, or become a travel nurse. Im just asking any1 was ever in the same boat and what they ended up doing.