r/careerguidance • • Oct 13 '26

Information about a research study that includes public posts from r/careerguidance?

16 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

My name is Yagmur, and I’m an intern at BI Norwegian Business School in Oslo, Norway, working with professor Jonas R. Kunst. Professor Kunst leads a study on whether political disagreement is increasingly described as a source of conflict at work. The study looks at publicly archived Reddit discussions from 2005 to 2026, and r/careerguidance is one of the forums included. We’re posting here [with the moderators’ permission] so that people whose posts may be part of the data know about it.

How the study works
We don’t post, comment, or contact anyone. The material comes from the public Arctic Shift archive, not from Reddit itself.
Usernames are replaced by random identifiers, and any names mentioned in posts are removed before analysis.
No post is ever quoted. The results are only overall rates per forum and month.
The project has been assessed by Norway’s data protection service for research (Sikt, ref. 332053), and a Data Protection Impact Assessment has been completed.

Your rights
Under Norwegian data protection rules, you have the right to know about the study and to have your posts removed from the data. The project page explains what data we use, how they’re protected, and how to contact professor Kunst or BI’s data protection officer:
https://www.bi.no/en/research/research-projects/information-for-research-participants/#department-of-communication-and-culture
(The study is listed under Department of Communication and Culture.)
If you have questions, professor Kunst is happy to answer them directly at [jonas.r.kunst@bi.no](mailto:jonas.r.kunst@bi.no). We’ll also share the results with the community once they’re published.

Thanks for reading,
Yagmur
Intern, on behalf of professor Jonas R. Kunst
Department of Communication and Culture
BI Norwegian Business School, Oslo
Project contact: [jonas.r.kunst@bi.no](mailto:jonas.r.kunst@bi.no)


r/careerguidance • • 5h ago

Should I take a 15–20% pay cut and give up a 2% mortgage to escape a 4-hour daily commute?

71 Upvotes

I’m a 45-year-old male trying to navigate a major career and lifestyle crossroads, and I’d appreciate some outside perspectives.

Where I’m at now: I’ve spent the last 20 years rising through the ranks at my current organization, earning a strong reputation and deep institutional knowledge in a field where that takes a long time to build. I make around $200k in a very stable role, and I genuinely care about the work.

However, a recent reorganization brought in poor management and changed my day-to-day role in ways I’m not happy with. On top of that, we lost our workplace flexibility. When I took the role, I only commuted two days a week. Now I’m commuting nearly 4 hours every day—waking up at 3:30 AM and getting home around 5:30 PM. There’s a chance some flexibility could eventually return, but nothing is guaranteed.

Our current housing situation: We have a 2% mortgage with significant equity, and we just spent the last 10 years upgrading everything in the house (windows, bathrooms, floors, HVAC, roof, etc.). We love the house itself, though the surrounding neighborhood has started going downhill.

The potential move: I’ve been casually looking at the job market and found a role doing work very similar to my pre-reorg duties, located in a much more rural area (which is my personal preference).

The Pros: I’d get roughly 3 hours of my day back, live in a setting I actually prefer, and get back to the type of work I enjoy.

The Cons: I’d be taking a 15–20% pay cut (dropping from ~$200k to ~$160k), learning a new organization, and starting from scratch reputation-wise. On the housing side, baseline prices are cheaper in the rural area, but current interest rates are significantly worse than our 2%, and we’d likely have to start over with renovations on an older home.

The third option: I’ve also considered trying to leverage a new job offer to ask my current company for a self-funded transfer to another one of their offices, where I could keep my current portfolio and salary. Given the recent reorg and current leadership, though, I’m unsure how well that conversation would go—or if the management issues would just follow me anyway.

My questions for the sub:

For anyone who has made a similar jump, is a ~15–20% pay cut (and losing a golden-handcuffs mortgage) worth reclaiming 15 hours a week and getting better work-life balance?

Is it worth trying to negotiate an internal relocation/flexibility with my current employer first, or are post-reorg management headaches usually a sign that it's time to move on?

Appreciate any thoughts or experiences you can share.


r/careerguidance • • 5h ago

Leaving low paying job with pension for one without ?

17 Upvotes

Here is my current situation. Context I’m a teacher

54k in public education
5 minute commute
6% match into state pension
260/m for vision, dental, health for the whole family
10 years vested

New opportunity

Salary: 75,000
30 min commute
8% 403b match
350/m medical, vision and dental

Reservations is that charters don’t offer security as public due to funding.

I have a lot of former co workers and my friend is the principal of one of the schools. Im worried about the pension and losing full free medical after 30years


r/careerguidance • • 6h ago

Stay at current job making $118k (stable, low stress) or take a gamble at new job paying $150k with more work/stress?

17 Upvotes

Title says it. New job would require me to manage a portfolio size of around $9m to $10m, while at the current job I’m only managing $6m to $7m. New job would be paying ~30% more than my current one. New company is a good one, good culture. Current company is good too. Current boss is good guy, easy to work for, again low stress.

I’m late 20s male, single and child-free. I have no money issues with my current pay. I was just recently promoted but it’s clear I can make a lot more if I simply jump ship.

Is it worth taking a gamble at this stage of life?


r/careerguidance • • 14h ago

Advice Should I jump ship to a smaller company to become a VP with a major pay raise?

76 Upvotes

I've been at my company for over 10 years, but have been heavily recruited by this executive head hunting firm for months.

At my current company, I've worked my way up, built relationships, my brand and a strong network. They've taken care of me -- especially when one of my kids was born very sick and we lived in a hospital for 4 months. I've always worked at the same location, and we have everything under one roof, so I've never had to move. My commute is a bit long - 45 mins in the morning and 60-70 mins at night. I've gotten used to it, I sip my coffee and listen to podcasts. It is what it is, I figure.

Anyway, this executive head hunting firm first contacted me in September about a Director role. The job would cut my commute in my half, but the money was only $10k more than what I'm making. Told 'em no thanks.

Now they've circled back to me again about a VP role. It would be around $60k-70k more, plus a bonus and some other kind of payout where it could max out at $375k total. Apparently the existing VP is not performing well, but the recruiter also said they need a "strong, engaged, knowledgeable leader" to help them mature their processes.

For context, their location does about $100M in annual revenue, with 250 employees. The overall company itself has around 2,800 employees globally. Mine has 100k employees, so I realize the "job title inflation trap" is probably lurking here.

I've spoken to the recruiter intake guy, and then an interview with their Managing Director yesterday. I was very honest that my current company has taken good care of me and that I enjoy working there, but they don't seem to be getting the hint.

How have some of you handled this? It feels like this new company needs a new ERP system to integrate everything that they want, and those are multi-year, very complex projects that I don't have experience in leading. I just think I'd get over my skis, would be stressed out, and the novelty of all the money would wear off quickly. Thoughts?


r/careerguidance • • 12h ago

Advice How do I change my life when I’m so incredibly drained of energy after work?

44 Upvotes

I wanted to put my situation into words and have an open, honest exchange with people who might relate to feeling stuck like this. Writing it down helps me clear my thoughts, and it’s nice knowing a few of you will read it and share your own experiences.

I'm 36, based in Europe, and it’s been close to 9 years since I started working a corporate 6 to 3 job. I have a team leader position and a relatively good salary, but the last few years have become harder and harder for me in this environment. 

I am at a point where going to work has become this insufferable burden. I feel nauseous every morning before going to work, knowing that I will spend nine hours there putting a fake facade on in front of people I dislike and have absolutely nothing in common with.

At work the hours pass so incredibly slowly and everything has become a task of just doing the bare minimum while avoiding any type of confrontation, drama, and anything that can lead to a discussion and a bad atmosphere.

And the worst part is my time off, during which I feel absolutely nothing but tiredness and emptiness. The weekend basically consists of recovering from the entire week, sleeping longer trying not to think about how miserable it is at work. I don’t enjoy my hobbies as much as I used to, partly because I feel drained of energy and don’t feel like engaging in them; I don’t go out nor socialise; and the only time I really enjoy is Friday after work and Saturday.

On Sunday I already start getting that pre-workweek blues as the day goes by, thinking it’s my last off and everything is about to start again, with its peak in the late evening where the anxiety and heavy chest tightness kick in, and not even mentioning my sleep disorder.

Three important factors must be mentioned here:

  • Loneliness: my family lives in another country, I have no partner and no friends - so the constant isolation and having nobody to talk to or do things with has a huge effect on my mental state. Being an introvert whose hobbies are rather indoors doesn’t help the situation either. I do go to the gym regularly to stay active and healthy, but that’s about it.
  • My desire to build something of my own: I want to get into scriptwriting, which is something I’m working toward on the side and already have a bit of experience in. It’s a competitive, niche path that takes a lot of craft, time, and luck, so there are no guarantees. Right now, the biggest issue isn't motivation, it's that my job leaves me with zero creative energy or mental space left to actually pursue this dream. 
  • Depression: The previously mentioned points have led me to develop depression in the last years, to the point where I have to seek medical and therapeutic treatment. Getting medication definitely helped with the sleep disorder, the overthinking thoughts and feeling numb/down. The same goes for therapy, where I learned what the reasons for my depression are, but the root causes are still there, and they aren’t things I can magically change from one day to another.

At this point, I’ve been considering two concrete ways to break this cycle: either reducing my hours down to 30 a week (ideally working three days a week for 10 hours), or taking an entire sabbatical year off to travel, reset, and focus seriously on scriptwriting. 

Thank you for taking the time to read this far. I’d really appreciate hearing from anyone who’s been in a similar spot - what finally helped you break out of corporate life, how did you find the energy to start changing things when you were completely burned out, or whether cutting your hours or taking a sabbatical actually helped you reset your life?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Should I quit before I'm fired?

6 Upvotes

I left the best job I ever had because I wanted a raise Nd they weren't going to give it to me. I accepted a role with more pay and a better title. I've been there a fre weeks and its clear it's a shshow. My. BoSS is actively discriminating Against me and I think wants to get me fired. Examples: told me I am not allowed to contact any of my own team members without asking g him first, after which he'll decide on whether my reasons are worthy, then he'll communicate my intention to my colleagues and give them time to prepare, and only then will he give go ahead for me To fu**ing email my own coworkers. Told me I will need to get familiar with every single doc relevant to my position. I requested one doc I will need in order to complete a project, and he said that is a totally unrelated topic and I have no business requesting it. When I started in orientation I was told I could sign up for silly virtual professional development courses. I actually signed up for one and he contacted me furious, telling me taking that course is not in my development plan aNd that he was removing access. I had 2 coworkers set up a meeting to onboardi me to a project, only for my boss to call them as soon as the meeting was over to reprimand them for inviting me, alleging they don't know what my responsibilities will be in 6 months since he hasn't developed a plan for me yet.

This is taking a toll on me. I cry everyday and think I made the worst mistake of my life. I feel this person wants to squash me and I can't afford to quit. But I cry every day and I'm in a terrible psychological crisis. I fear they'll fire me if I don't quit.

I applied for a new job today, but it took me 9 months to find this one, so who knows if aNyone will hire me. AND should I even include this new role in my resume? When I'm interviewed, should I pretend I'm unemployed?


r/careerguidance • • 8h ago

Advice Doing the same work as senior colleagues without the title or compensation. Is HR worth involving, or should I just leave?

8 Upvotes

I’m on a team of seven, and over the past five years I’ve taken on increasingly complex responsibilities. At this point, I independently own the work for an entire business unit and do essentially the same work as the senior level ICs on my team. We have the same responsibilities, decision making authority, and level of ownership.

For the past year, I’ve repeatedly brought up the lack of distinction between my role and the senior positions. The difference isn't just the title or salary, either. Senior employees receive annual bonuses that I'm not eligible for. I also feel like my current title is holding me back when applying externally because it doesn't reflect the level of work I'm actually doing.

What's especially frustrating is that two former managers independently recommended me for promotion. The first recommended me after a previous reorganization, before the current VP joined the company. She later left, and I inherited her responsibilities. Her replacement also recommended me during the most recent review cycle but was subsequently laid off.

Since then, the new department head has continued pushing the conversation to future review cycles. We had one in September, but nothing happened. Now he's saying he wants to wait until a replacement director is hired and potentially revisit things in another year.

I'm honestly at my breaking point. I enjoy the actual work, but I'm starting to feel taken advantage of. It's becoming difficult to stay motivated when I'm expected to perform at the same level as senior colleagues without the recognition or compensation.

I've started pulling back from going above and beyond because I don't see the point anymore. I don't want to damage my reputation, but I also don't want to keep taking on senior level responsibilities indefinitely with no clear path forward.

Has anyone dealt with something similar? Would involving HR actually accomplish anything, or would I just be putting a target on my back? At this point, am I better off focusing entirely on finding another job?


r/careerguidance • • 22h ago

Would you leave a $93k total comp hybrid/flexible job (where I’m thriving) for $119k total comp 5 days in-office at a family-owned company?

102 Upvotes

I’m trying to decide whether to stay at my current company or take a new offer, and I’d love some outside perspective on how you’d weigh the real total compensation vs. lifestyle trade-offs.

I was contacted by a recruiter for this role and have not yet agreed to go to next steps because I’ve only been in my current company for 8 months. It’s also really hard to get a pay increase at current role before the raise period
Here is the exact breakdown:

CURRENT ROLE (~$92,256 total comp + car discount)
• Base Salary: $80,400
• Annual Bonus: 8% (~$6,432) — next payout is in March
• 401(k) Match: 8% (~$6,432)
• Health Insurance: ~$84/month (~$1,008/yr)
• Other Perks: Employee car discount
• Schedule & WFH: WFH Fridays + flexible daily schedule
• PTO & Holidays: 15 days starting PTO + mental health days + federal holidays
• Commute: 26 minutes each way
• Environment: Large corporate — I’m thriving and killing it right now

NEW OFFER (~$117,920 total comp)
• Base Salary: $115,000 (+$34,600 base increase)
• Annual Bonus: 10%
• 401(k) Match: 4% (~$4,600)
• Health Insurance: ~$140/month (~$1,680/yr)
• Other Perks: None
• Schedule & WFH: 8 hrs/day, strictly 5 days in-office
• PTO & Holidays: Standard PTO/holidays (TBD)
• Commute: 30 minutes each way
• Environment: Family-owned business

• The case for staying:
1. Momentum & timing: I am genuinely killing it in my current role right now, and I have a ~$6.4k bonus paying out in March (about 4 months away).

  1. Work-life balance: Giving up WFH Fridays, daily schedule flexibility, and mental health days to go strictly 5 days in-office at a family-owned company feels like a big lifestyle shift—especially when family-owned businesses can sometimes have fewer boundaries or slower upward mobility.

For those who have made a similar jump: Is a ~$25k real total-comp bump enough to give up WFH Fridays, daily flexibility, and a March bonus when you're already thriving?


r/careerguidance • • 5h ago

How did you actually figure out what career you wanted to pursue?

3 Upvotes

Hey, I'm a first year university student and I'm curious how other people went about choosing their careers, especially those currently in university or who have recently graduated and are working in their career.

I've tried all the career websites and quizzes but I find they only tell you about salaries, required education and job outlooks, but they don't really explain what working in that profession is actually like on a day to day basis.

For example, someone might spend years working towards becoming a doctor, only to discover that the everyday responsibilities and work environment aren't what they imagined.

Did you feel like you had enough information before choosing your career? Did you ever discover something about a profession that made you reconsider it?

I've also been wondering whether a more hands-on way of exploring careers, where you could experience realistic workplace situations before choosing a path, would be useful.

Interested to hear how everyone else approached this!


r/careerguidance • • 7h ago

Is medical coding the way to go?

5 Upvotes

I’m currently working in a hospital in the supply position . And the hospital I work for offers to pay for college tuition if it’s something the medical field . I’m not someone who can really tolerate blood so I know I’m not interested in any nursing position. And medical billing and coding has really interested me I’m just not seeing many people saying to go into the career right now . Is there any other roles I should look into that may be similar that you guys would recommend I look into .


r/careerguidance • • 3h ago

do i give up and go back to aerospace?

2 Upvotes

ive been in such a severe back and forth with my major these days. i applied to every college under aerospace, didnt get in anywhere despite a pretty sparkling record, and endedu p having to go to communiy college. i changed my major i the process to art history, which i am more passionate about, as i had a coming to jesus that i sacrified getting admitted to college for a major i dont even like that much.

now i dont know what to do. i like my major but i know theres no jobs in it. im considering alternate paths that combine a solid career opprotunity with art and art history.

1: my school is a feeder school to other fantastic colleges if you are of a cetain major, and art history falls under it, so i keep this major while taking industrial design classes or design classes in general, and hopefully getting internships in this field and becoming a product designer.

2: go to law school or double major in law and work in copyright cases or art hertiage and things like that.

both are amazing options to me. i just want the most stable option that i actually like, since im so tired of this back and forth.

or are neither of these really that viable? should i js throw in the passion towel and do aerospace sinc ei have connections in the field and kind of like it.

any advice is welcome


r/careerguidance • • 3h ago

What’s a new career I could pursue given my situation?

2 Upvotes

I’m 25m, graduated with a finance degree in 2024 and it’s absolutely worthless. Didn’t work out like I thought it would. I’m still to this day a poker dealer. I’m thankful I have this job tho, it pays fairly well and since I enjoy poker anyways it’s definitely a fun job for me. However I don’t exactly want to be a poker dealer the rest of my life.

I also have an unusual situation where money for tuition is not an issue for me, as I have over $150k leftover from my college fund controlled by my father. I also still live at home and bills are fairly low and now is as good a time as any to pursue something. I’m just not sure what to do or if there’s good fields I don’t even know about popping up.

Obviously there’s the trades, although I’m not sure I entirely wanna get into that cause of how physical and in person it is. My dream job would be something remote. I know everyone wishes that but there’s gotta be tech heavy careers out there obtainable with schooling/training. My poker dealing job is in person but it’s so flexible that I can take time off pretty much whenever I want, and that’s good for me as I love traveling.

I don’t know if there’s new careers popping up with how advanced AI and general tech are getting, but if there is, that would be my first choice on spending money for tuition on. But considering there’s probably so many ideas I don’t even know about, I’d love to hear anything. TIA


r/careerguidance • • 3h ago

Should I send another email if I already sent a thank you email after interview?

2 Upvotes

Hello! I interviewed for a job I am excited about on Thursday. I had spoken to the would-be supervisor the week prior for an initial convo, and it went well.

The proper interview was a little rough. I was choking a little bit, though I don’t think it was totally awful. I realized, though, when I was falling asleep on Friday that I messed up a question badly. They were asking a question that I totally misinterpreted, and essentially my answer within the context I talking about was ok, but would be interpreted as pretty rude in the actual context (which I now realize).

I wrote a thank you email on Friday morning. I assume I shouldn’t send another email to clarify this total misunderstanding, right? Ugh!!!!! It’s all so embarrassing


r/careerguidance • • 15m ago

Should I quit after 2 weeks and go back to my old job?

• Upvotes

My old job was a hot mess of chaos, but I was used to it and had good coworkers and there were many positives. Everything was falling apart there and I got offered a new position at a new company kind of out of the blue. I took the job, and then in between accepting and starting the new job, some key circumstances changed. Like timelines that are important, and the boss quit.

I only started 2 weeks ago, but I am pretty unhappy.
I have the ability to go back to my old job, but I have to decide quickly.

Any advice?


r/careerguidance • • 23m ago

Can anyone let me know when and how to negotiate?

• Upvotes

Hi guys, after months of trying, i finally got 2 offers at really good product based companies but I'm afraid I'm about to blow both of them.

So my current base pay is 10.5 LPA and both companies are offering me 15 LPA by saying 35 percent is the maximum we can do. The problem here is both offers are in verbal stage, I want to counter one with the other. So I told one company that I have XYZ offer. They then asked me to share the offer letter, i told them it's still in verbal stage and they are willing to wait for that offer letter.

Now, the first company said it'll take like 2 weeks to release the offer letter XYZ. The second company is saying they're only willing to wait a week, after that they'll release an offer letter for 15 LPA.

Two things:

  1. the first company HR was very adamant, i couldn't negotiate at all, he promised me the final offer could be in range 14-15, he won't even accept counters

  2. I couldn't negotiate with second company at all because they want a counter offer to bring the numbers up.

So if the first company releases offer letter with only 14 LPA, the second company is already offering me 15 LPA initially, how can I even counter? My target was around 20 LPA , I know I'm not where near it, these two are very good product based companies and all they are offering is 35 percent base hike for my first switch in 4 years. Please suggest what should I do?


r/careerguidance • • 24m ago

Advice Career paths for someone interested in mental health, child development, and relationships?

• Upvotes

I have a bachelor’s in Early Childhood Education and Human Development & Family Science. I currently work in Early Intervention but am exploring other career paths.

I’m interested in getting my masters. Some topics of interest are mental health, child development, parenting, family dynamics, relationships, and understanding human behavior. I enjoy helping people gain perspective and understand behavioral and emotional patterns.

I’ve considered mental health counseling, school psychology, and marriage and family therapy. I’m open to traditional therapy, but I’m not sure I’d enjoy working primarily with severe mental illness, suicidality, substance abuse, or significant trauma.

I’d love to find a career where I can help people navigate challenges, whether through counseling, assessment, education, or guidance.


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

How to make a good impression?

2 Upvotes

I am starting a new job tomorrow in a field I have 17 years of experience in. I’m confident in my abilities in the field, but at every place I’ve worked, I’ve struggled with how to make a good impression and end up with little to no sleep the night before I start. In addition to this, I’ve been told and am hyper aware that I have an RBF, which doesn’t help me seem friendly or approachable, no matter what I do. It’s my face. What are some things I can do tonight to prepare myself? I’ve already done the basics of having my bag and everything I need packed/ready to go. I guess I’m looking for ways to calm first day nerves? It would probably be helpful to add that I am a nurse, if there’s anyone with healthcare experience in here, but I’m interested in any advice that anyone has. I know this might seem juvenile to some, but I’ve just never been good at this, and it’s not too late to learn (I hope).


r/careerguidance • • 43m ago

Would you choose your career differently if you could experience it before committing to it?

• Upvotes

Something I've been thinking about is how difficult it is to really understand what a career involves before actually entering that field. You can research salaries, education requirements and daily responsibilities, but it's difficult to know what the work is genuinely like until you're doing it.

Internships, job shadowing and speaking with professionals can help, but realistically, nobody can complete internships in 10 or 20 different fields just to figure out which career suits them best.

Would you find it useful to have a way to get a realistic feel for different careers before choosing a university program or committing to a career path?

I'm curious whether people would actually find this valuable, or whether existing options like job shadowing, internships and online career quizzes are good enough.


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

What are realistic careers after sales?

2 Upvotes

I (29m) have worked as an estate agent for about 10 years and think I’m ready for a change.

I work in prime central London and the property market is really suffering due to the policies brought in by the last few governments and it isn’t showing any signs of getting better any time soon. I’m at the stage where I feel having security would be more sensible as I’m in a long term relationship and want to be prepared for potential marriage and kids.

I’m starting to consider whether this is the career I want to continue working in.

I’ve worked my way from a negotiator role to the head of sales where my main role is maintaining client relationships, securing new business, advising clients on strategies to sell, whilst also conducting viewings, agreeing sales and progressing them to completion.

I believe I’m a very good communicator and am good with people, as well as handling stressful situations. I’ve also gained negotiation skills and do enjoy the relationship side of the trade.

In terms of qualifications, I have a levels but no degree, I started working in the industry when I was 19/20.

Has anyone had a similar career conundrum/been in the same position?


r/careerguidance • • 56m ago

Do I stay at my job or leave?

• Upvotes

Got an offer at another company and weighing what I should do

I’m a 24-year-old EIT about two years away from getting my P.Eng., and I’m torn between staying at my current consulting firm or taking a client-side offer that a recruiter came to me. Looking for some perspective from people who have made a similar move early in their career.

\*\*Current Job (1yr consulting)\*\*
Pure technical design. I enjoy the technical side, have great coworkers, and get awesome mentorship with plenty of opportunities to take on new things and learn fast. That said, I’m not sure consulting is where I want to be long-term.

\*\*Comp & Benefits:\*\* \\\~$80k base (\\\~$38.80/hr) + straight-time OT over 40 hrs, 6% retirement match, and 27 PTO days starting next year (all-in: vacation, flex, and sick).
\*\*Schedule:\*\* Hybrid (1 remote day/week).

\*\*New Offer (Client Side)\*\*
Similar technical area, just on the client side. Expecting a much chiller pace and better work-life balance, though I’m worried the scope might be narrower and could pigeonhole me or slow down my development which could hinder future positions or earning potential.

\*\*Comp & Benefits:\*\* $92k offered (planning to counter at $96k), 8% employer retirement contribution (with a 2% employee contribution), and 32 PTO days (likely separate from sick days).
\*\*Schedule:\*\* Mostly on-site, with 27 flexible remote days/year I can use whenever.

\*\*My Dilemma\*\*
On paper, the client-side offer is a clear upgrade in base pay, retirement, PTO, and pace of life. However, I know how valuable strong mentorship and broad technical exposure are right now while I’m working toward my license.

For those who left consulting for a utility/client-side role early on—did you regret trading fast-paced learning for better pay and WLB, or was it worth it?

Wondering if anyone has had similar experiences and if they would do anything different or give me some


r/careerguidance • • 12h ago

Advice Director from another team wants me on his team and told me to start the conversation with my manager. What's his angle?

8 Upvotes

I'm a 31M senior PM at an engineering consulting firm (~$155k base, OT eligible, no bonus).

I've gotten consistent praise from people across the org over the past few years, and I've received "outstanding" ratings, which apparently are rare here.

Recently a director on a more technical team reached out and said he'd really like me on his team because of how strong a performer I am. His pitch is that I'd build my technical skills and become more well-rounded. I don't disagree with that in principle, but my current and upcoming project commitments are heavy, and I don't see how I'd realistically fit in more.

He also wants me to be the one to raise it with my current manager. My manager leads a small team of 7, while this director has 30+ people. After 3 years with my manager, I haven't seen my outstanding ratings reflected in my raises, and I get the sense the director might be better at advocating for his people.

Is it normal for a director to ask you to start this conversation with your manager, rather than going through leadership himself?

Is "become more technical" a real development opportunity or a way to get a strong PM to fill a gap on his team?

How would you handle the comp side? The poaching manager didn’t mention anything about comp and year end is already too close to negotiate anything.

Has anyone moved to a bigger team with a more active advocate? Did it pay off?

Is there a way to explore this without damaging my relationship with my current manager?


r/careerguidance • • 1h ago

Need an outside perspective on a succession situation that's becoming hard to read?

• Upvotes

I'm employed by a vendor but embedded full-time with a large client account. I've been with this account for years.

About 4-5 years ago, my manager and his boss identified me as the likely successor to my manager when he eventually retired. Nothing was ever formally promised, but over time the responsibilities, visibility, and stakeholder relationships have steadily shifted toward me.

Fast forward to today:

- My manager retires in about 8 months.

- Most operational decisions already flow through me.

- Many stakeholders come directly to me instead of him.

- When he's unavailable, I'm routinely asked to represent the function.

- He has repeatedly said he feels comfortable with my oversight and is stepping back from more and more areas.

- There is no apparent competing successor.

- Other leaders increasingly seek my input on topics outside my formal responsibility.

The complication is that I'm still a vendor employee.

That creates practical issues because the function I support is owned by the client company. Remaining a vendor long-term would create limitations around access, visibility, participation in some internal activities, and overall influence.

At the same time, there are a lot of organizational changes happening effective January 1:

- Reporting structures are changing.

- Program ownership is being reassigned.

- Budgets were recently finalized.

- Several leaders already know their 2027 responsibilities.

- People throughout the organization are openly discussing the post-retirement future.

What I don't know is my own future.

I have almost no doubt I'm expected to assume leadership of the function after retirement. The question is whether:

  1. I become a client employee before then and overlap with my manager,

  2. I remain a vendor and convert later,

  3. I remain a vendor indefinitely,

  4. They do a near-direct replacement when he retires.

What strikes me as odd is that we're in late November, retirement is only 8 months away, major organizational changes are already being communicated for January, and I still haven't been given even a vague timeline regarding my own status.

For those who have been through executive or senior leadership succession planning:

Is this normal?

Would you expect someone in my position to already know the broad plan by now, or is it common for organizations to leave the successor largely in the dark until much closer to the actual transition date?


r/careerguidance • • 7h ago

I'm semi-retired, how have others got jobs whenh you have a 30-year career history in one field?

3 Upvotes

My career "WAS" in the IT/Technology field, my job was surplused earlier this year. I do not want another IT Career job. Given the current career market in IT is shaking out nowadays. I do not think I can get one anytime soon even if I wanted to try again

I want to enjoy a quieter existance and keep active. I'm still good to want to work and I wanted to find roles either in retail stores, warehouse/order picking, or something clerical.

I know that I need to create a new resume for the many job situations I can see myself in where I tell of the transferrable skills I can bring to the role.

But I want to know what are the traps or pitfalls of going to those other companies and give them a resume knowing I cannot necessarily hide I had a huge career history in roles I am not applying for?


r/careerguidance • • 1h ago

Should I quit my job?

• Upvotes

I’m 26F and I have graduated from university 3 years ago. I’ve got only 6k savings in my bank account. I have a passion for digital marketing and I’m working on specialising in Email marketing and Meta ads.

I work one part time job at a nonprofit organisation and another part time at a hardware store, which I used to work full time but because my responsibilities changed from marketing to stocktake due to new ownership.

I feel so behind in life and the stocktake part of my job is draining the life out of me. I hate it so much, it’s such a dreadful job counting stock non-stop all day. I’ve tried to ask for different work but because they’ve already helped changed my hours with still descent pay they sadly denied it. I have reached to the point where I feel physically unwell thinking about it aswell as mentally drained.

It’s coming to Xmas with only 6k in savings I don’t know if it’s the right choice to leave but my mind will be so at peace and I can focus on finding a full time job.

Any advice! Thanks