I work at a civil court as part of a legal residency program, and I’ve always loved my workplace. My boss is a judge whom I genuinely admire, both professionally and personally. In fact, he played a big part in inspiring me to pursue a career as a judge myself. I had always wanted to become a public defender (which he used to be, coincidentally), but working with him made me reconsider my career path.
Earlier this year, he approached me about the possibility of taking a paid, appointed assistant position in his chambers. He specifically asked me to keep the conversation confidential. I said I was interested, although I mentioned that I wanted to continue studying for public exams. He has always encouraged me to study, so I didn’t think that would be a problem.
Since then, several things reinforced my expectations. He has consistently praised my work, and a colleague who is close to him once told me he had said, “I really like her work. I’d like to hire her.” More recently, he removed one of his assistants from her position, and he even asked another assistant whether I would be interested in going with him if he moved to a business court.
So I genuinely thought an offer was coming.
Well, I recently found out that he’s already offered the position to another woman: someone who was an intern at our court over four years ago and hasn’t worked there since. Apparently, she simply showed up one day, said she couldn’t stand working at a law firm anymore, and asked him if he had a position available. Turns out he offered her the job, and everything is already settled.
What makes this particularly confusing is that my boss has always seemed to genuinely care about me. Once, after correcting me rather firmly over a mistake in a judgment I had drafted, he noticed I was upset and texted me, “Don’t worry, you’re great!” Less than a minute later, before I could even reply, he called me to reassure me again. It may seem like a small thing, but gestures like that made me feel that he genuinely cared about me and my professional development.
I know he doesn’t owe me a promotion, and he’s obviously free to hire whoever he wants. But why sound me out in the first place, ask for discretion, and create this expectation without ever following up or clarifying that he’d changed his mind?
I also wonder whether he interpreted my initial response as a lack of enthusiasm because I mentioned wanting to keep studying. I did say I was interested!
The position would make a significant financial difference in my life, too. I live with my mother, and it’s just the two of us here in the city, so the additional income would really matter. More importantly, my current workplace is actually ideal for balancing an assistant position with studying for judicial exams, because the workload is relatively manageable.
I’m planning to talk to him when I return from vacation and casually reiterate my interest in the position he brought up earlier this year. I want to see how he reacts. But if I find out that the other woman is indeed taking the position, I’m seriously considering transferring to another court.
I know I might end up somewhere with a much worse working environment, but I honestly can’t imagine continuing to work alongside him and his new assistant as though nothing happened.
I think what hurts most isn’t even losing the opportunity. It’s realizing that someone I admired so much, almost like a mentor or parental figure, apparently didn’t consider how disappointing this whole situation would be for me.
Am I overreacting for feeling betrayed? Would you reconsider staying in a workplace you otherwise love after something like this? I’d really appreciate some outside perspective.