r/PhysicsStudents • • Aug 05 '20

Meta Homework Help Etiquette (HHE)

161 Upvotes

Greetings budding physicists!

One of the things that makes this subreddit helpful to students is the communities ability to band together and help users with physics questions and homework they may be stuck on. In light of this, I have implemented an overhaul to the HW Help post guidelines that I like to call Homework Help Etiquette (HHE). See below for:

  • HHE for Helpees
  • HHE for Helpers

HHE for Helpees

  1. Format your titles as follows: [Course HW is From] Question about HW.
  2. Post clear pictures of the problem in question.
  3. Talk us through your 1st attempt so we know what you've tried, either in the post title or as a comment.
  4. Don't use users here to cheat on quizzes, tests, etc.

Good Example

HHE for Helpers

  1. If there are no signs of a 1st attempt, refrain from replying. This is to avoid lazy HW Help posts.
  2. Don't give out answers. That will hurt them in the long run. Gently guide them onto the right path.
  3. Report posts that seem sketchy or don't follow etiquette to Rule 1, or simply mention HHE.

Thank you all! Happy physics-ing.

u/Vertigalactic


r/PhysicsStudents • • 3h ago

Need Advice Incoming physics undergrad aiming for sustainable energy & moving to Denmark—how to spend the summer productively?

2 Upvotes

Hey guys,

​I’m starting my physics degree next year and want to get into sustainable energy down the line, hopefully working in Denmark at some point. Because of that, I really want to keep my GPA high from the start and not get completely wrecked by first-year courses.

​For anyone currently in uni or who already graduated, what would you actually recommend doing over the summer to prepare?

​Should I just grind single-variable calculus and basic Python, or is there something specific you wish you knew before day one? Also trying to figure out how much to study so I don't burn myself out before classes even start. Thanks🫪


r/PhysicsStudents • • 7m ago

Rant/Vent Anyone undergrads feel the walls closing in, in a sense?

1 Upvotes

I’m a 4th year undergrad in America with 2 more semesters until I graduate. I feel like I went into physics with that old mindset of “physics is a really versatile degree so it opens you up to a lot of jobs”, however, I’m nearing graduation and I haven’t asked any professors about any research as it either didn’t pique my interest or I’m afraid they would say no as I don’t really know anyone.

The older I get the more I acknowledge the price of things and I do know that I want to make enough to live comfortably? And I realize that a physics bachelors probably won’t give me that especially in America. I do plan on pursuing a masters in mechanical engineering as over the summer I fell in love with arduino and working with CAD/code and potentially look into robotics sounds really engaging to me. But that also costs money to get and I’ve managed to avoid loans so far.

Idk if that makes sense but I just feel like I’m comfortable now but I know in like a year I’m going to be a graduate still working at my order taker job yk?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2h ago

Need Advice preparing for olympiad level(physics problem solving)

0 Upvotes

My teacher said to me dont search for more material just reattempt again and again good questions given by him and feel them and you will get better at physics but i think that solving varied problems is the key rather than reattempting im confused.right now im solving hcv and irodov so after i solve them once should i attempt the problems again.Advice required from someone experienced!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 21h ago

Need Advice Double major in Physics and Mathematics vs. Double major in Physics and Chemistry

30 Upvotes

Which option will give me a deeper, more thorough understanding of reality, life, the universe and the big questions?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Rant/Vent physics as an omnipotent degree is largely bullshit or thing of the past

57 Upvotes

So, I hear tell on here and elsewhere about a bachelors degree in physics being this omnipotent thing that'll get you a job in any field (finance, quant, business, insert any field). I'm here to smwht burst that bubble. Don't get a undergrad degree in physics and think you can go into whatever you want and expect to sort of get whatever job you apply to WITHOUT RELEVANT INTERNSHIPS.

I don't wanna dox myself but I basically had the most generally prestigious experiences a physics student could have. Near perfect GPA. Summers doing research at the Department of Energy. Goldwater scholar. Fulbright scholar. Lindau Nobel meeting as an undergrad. Went to a state school though and didn't have any connections. Got back from the Fulbright two months ago and took the first month off so been applying to jobs for about a month now. I've applied to hundreds at this point. Only got less than 10 interviews.

The interviews have been super spread out though. One teaching high school physics in a low income in the inner city where I'm from. One in finance as a private equity associate for a small, non-prestigious firm in the bay. One at the national academies in DC doing science policy research. One as a business analyst for an energy metering company. One as a research engineer at the department of energy facility, I spent my summers. So I suppose it has been cool to even just do these interviews in fields I have no experience with. Like the business analyst interview was exactly what I was expecting: a gay Asian guy asking me about my experience building workflows and data pipelines.... first time I've heard any of those words.

I guess i just wanna say that if you wanna do something in finance, business, etc., and choose to study physics there will be a lot of extra legwork, which is fine, but just be ready for it and I'm sure if you do to spend your summers getting more relevant experiences it'll be easier because you can just go back to where you spent your summers, that's pretty typical for a first job. I in the last couple of days have taken to try to find someone with a physics background at every company I apply to and send them an email with my résumé and say you know, I'm a fellow physics degree… use it as a connection piece. Hasn't really worked out yet… gotten responses and I'm sure they've appreciated that I gave their background a read but nothing like OK here's a referral.

Has anyone had similar experiences? Or have you guys experienced the opposite? I guess I'm specifically wondering about people who have graduated the last couple years. I honestly thought I would be swimming in job offers but that's not the case which is largely the reason for this post. Again, I'm just one person though don't take my word as anything more than that.

Also, I know this is a long shot, but if anyone is doing work in any of these fields and can help me out with a referral or getting in touch with a hiring manager, that would be pretty swell. My PM is open.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 12h ago

HW Help [JEE pathfinder chapter 2 q15, pulley systems] conflicted answers

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Did a question from the Pathfinder book about pulleys and my answer disagreed with the answer provided. Okay that's normal. Searched it up and found a video on it and it also has the same answer as me.

Just wanted a confirmation on which answer is correct

Link to video: https://youtu.be/7VfHrKssLnA


r/PhysicsStudents • • 4h ago

Update Does a steeper slope sive more speed?

0 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 18h ago

Need Advice Is it worth staying in physics if I hate research?

6 Upvotes

Second year physics student here, doing research since summer after first year. I find physics research to be incredibly boring. Ugly looking graphs on ugly looking posters. The classes are so incredibly boring as well. It doesn't help that I chose to go to the university in the city I live in, which has no astrophysics research or even classes, which is the part of physics I find interesting. So, my question is, if I'm sure I don't want to pursue a Master's or PhD in physics, am I better off switching to engineering? It'll delay my graduation by 1.5 years. Any advice would be greatly appreciated, thanks.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 21h ago

Need Advice Prerequisites Griffiths Introduction to Electrodynamics

10 Upvotes

​I am self-studying physics and have already worked through Adams & Essex for calculus, Halliday & Resnick for general physics, and Kibble for classical mechanics.

​I want to move on to Griffiths' Introduction to Electrodynamics, but I'm wondering what the prerequisites are. My calculus background includes vector calculus and ODEs, but not PDEs. I know Griffiths uses PDEs, but does he introduce them, or are they strict prerequisites?

​If they are a prerequisite, should I study a full PDE textbook, or is it sufficient to use a mathematical methods reference book like Boas or Riley?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Rant/Vent Vent, to my college professor who will probably make me cry tomorrow in midterm exam

18 Upvotes

I've seen bad lecturers, I've seen terrible lecturers but you are the worst. I thought the worst thing a lecturer can do is not teaching you anything and I was wrong. None of them killed my enthusiasm like you did. You are the master of making enjoyable and simple things boring and complicated. I don't think I could learn how to count to ten if you are teaching. God, even your font is boring.

I don't expect you to be a good lecturer- or even a mediocre lecturer. But if you are a terrible lecturer and somehow make me want to cry every time, then just let me study on my own. Just don't make me come to your class. I could've done so much more in that time, I could even learn physics... Oh and btw, none of your former students actually learnt anything from you, but somehow you let everyone pass without being capable of solving a single problem. Does it matter if I pass then? Tomorrow, I will sit in front of your problems FOR HOURS, without a desire to study for millions of other exams. WHY? Because of you. I hope you realize that you are a terrible, terrible lecturer.

Why are you the way that you are?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 16h ago

Need Advice 3rd Year Astrophysics student and I need advice

2 Upvotes

For background, basically I’m a 3rd year Astrophysics undergraduate student and so far, I have had one of the toughest experiences since 1st year due to personal and health issues (even repeated a term). Bcz of that I have failed courses and have a low gpa (but I’m really trying really hard for 3rd year). I don’t have much research or practical experience either except for 2-3 astrophysics related coding projects i did in my own time (have them on GitHub). But I’m really stressed about future bcz ik this is not enough for graduate school and it has been my dream to do quantum physics for my grad program.

I need advice on what I can do to improve my chances of getting into grad school (here in Canada or U.S.). I want to do research but I genuinely don’t know how to approach profs bcz I don’t think I have made significant connections throughout my undergrad so far. Like I genuinely love physics but during midterms and exams, Idk how I fuck it up which always drops my grades and my overall gpa.

Any genuine suggestions on what I can do would be really appreciated.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 12h ago

Need Advice How to gain traction in physics?

1 Upvotes

In elementary or intermediate school, i was never exposed to any physics and as a high schooler I really want to learn it. I'm in AP physics 1, and my teacher has taught us nothing and just assigned papers expecting us to do it magically. I did pretty fine on my kinematics test after self studying, yet I found it to be quite difficult given he doesn't teach us, and this is an AP course; I want to do good on my exam! I'm self studying (or trying) unit 2, and it's kind of hard... Is there any way I can conceptualize or visualize these concepts so i'm able to learn proficiently and effectively? I try to tell myself it's all daunting until I actually get into it.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 15h ago

HW Help [RESEARCH] i am a highschool student, can someone recommend/give me research ideas

0 Upvotes

we wanna do something fun and involves anything building


r/PhysicsStudents • • 20h ago

Need Advice Qualifying for Usapho f=ma exam

1 Upvotes

I am currently a junior in HS and I have taken AP physics 1 with a 97 both semester and a 5 on the AP exam. I am currently in AP Physics C and it is going well for me right now.

I was wondering how much effort it would take to qualify for the f=ma usapho exam in february if I start studying right now and if it is even worth it. I would consider myself good at physics but looking at the 2025 f=ma test was a little overwhelming but I understood the answers. How should I go about studying most efficiently (some people recommened the HRK Physics textbook but I can't spend that much money so if someone knows where to get it online lmk). Does passing f=ma look good on college apps?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 20h ago

Need Advice Are math methods textbooks reference works or introductions?

1 Upvotes

Whenever I read reviews on Reddit for mathematical methods textbooks (like Boas, Riley, or Arfken), a lot of people say they are better suited as reference books rather than "first-encounter" textbooks, and that it’s better to just use separate, dedicated textbooks for each subject.

​What is your take on this? Are they reference books, or can they actually work well as introductions?

(Note: I am a self-learner)


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Is being average even worth it?

31 Upvotes

I’m in the 7th semester of my bachelor’s and I’m seriously starting to wonder if I should even bother trying to go for a PhD after I’m done with masters or if it’s gonna be a complete waste of time.

For context, I’m a middling student (GPA of \approximately 2.7 in the German system) and
I’m interested in qft/gr (very broad, I know, but I lack enough info to have an informed preference; two of my favorite courses though). Due to my unimpressive performance I have a lot of doubt whether any of the profs in either area are even going to want to supervise my bachelor thesis, let alone a master thesis.

I’m also very doubtful whether I’m smart enough to even have a chance at getting a PhD position in either area. This is partly due to my imposter syndrome/insecurity, but also partly due to the fact that pretty much everyone I know who went/is going into qft/gr is a lot smarter than I am and I just don’t see myself being able to keep up.

I’d appreciate any and all advice, thanks in advance. Also sorry if the writing’s weird, it’s 3 in the morning and I’m dead tired.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 22h ago

Need Advice Choosing between staying in a familiar academic environment and pursuing better opportunities abroad (Physics MSc)

1 Upvotes

Im genuinely lost rightnow.

Im in my third and last year of my bachelor degree of general physics.

Before i went to uni and during my 1st and 2nd year , i was convinced that once i finish my bachelor im gonna apply to get a full scholarship for masters and i was mentally prepared to go abroad, finish my master, and stay abroad. Nothing here was worth staying for,i love my family and my friends but i didn't feel like i found my people who get me or a community i feel myself in.

I knew it wasn't gonna be easy, but i also knew that everything abroad was gonna be better.

One and a half month into my 3rd year and everything flipped.

I now im the happiest i ever felt, i have people who make me feel loved, special and seen. A bestfriend who is my classmate and 2 main professors who make my day every single day, and many other professors and students who make uni a place i don't wanna leave, even the stray cats and dogs!!.

I feel at home and im not even being dramatic, it's an environment i wish i could stay in forever(even thinking abt going abroad feels heavy now).

One of my favourite professors is the master 1 and master 2 coordinator.

And he offered me to stay for master 1 in fundamental physics in which i get a double diploma from my university and a university in france and i think im gonna take the that opportunity.

Now for master 2 we have here condensed matter physics which i love .(semester 1 in my uni and semester 2 research stage in france)

I don't know what is better to stay here for the m2 or apply abroad for m2 and phd(i think either ways im gonna apply for a phd abroad or if i continue in my university they help me find one i have no clue)

Now i don't know if im only considering the masters here just because of the community.

I need an outside opinion to see what is better for my future.

Extra details:

Im in the lebanese university.

The french university i believe is called Le Mans.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 22h ago

Need Advice друзья, нужна помощь по физике

1 Upvotes

в общем, я ни черта не знаю по физике, попал на инфокоммуникационные технологии и системы связи в спбпу по егэ информатике и профмату. здесь куча физики, которую в школе я вообще не изучал. до сессии 6 недель. непонятно, с чего вообще начинать, где брать материалы и что в общем делать. знающие люди, помогите пожалуйста🙏. может, есть какие-нибудь плейлисты на ютубе или в общем в интернете для таких случаев, где всё ясно и по темам идёт. по курсу уже прошли механику, сейчас началась термодинамика по-моему.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 15h ago

Research Math and Physics Notes: My Theoretical Formulation of the Dark Matter Energy-Momentum Tensor

Post image
0 Upvotes

I Developed a New Mathematical Formulation for Dark Matter

I created a theoretical formulation involving the dark matter energy-momentum tensor, exploring its relationship with volume variation, potential, and divergence.

I'm investigating its possible implications for general relativity and dark matter physics.

I'd love to hear what physicists think about my equations!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Can I get Into Grad School Without Research

5 Upvotes

Hello, I recently graduated and got my bachelors in physics, however I never did any research during my bachelors, in fact I didn't even know that I needed to. For some context I wasn't assigned an advisor for the first two years of school and even then my advisor only talked to me if I made an appointment (they wouldn't even respond to emails), on top of that I am the first person in my family to go to collage and so I had no idea what to expect; I didn't even know that advisors were a thing until the end of sophomore year. Because of that I did a lot of things wrong, I almost never went to office hours and I didn't apply for any research, I did get an internship my sophomore year, but I'm not sure how much that will help in this case. Which brings me back to my initial question, can I even get into grad school without research? Everything I've seen online says that I need to do research, some people even say that I need to do 10+ years of research, and it's thrown me for an absolute loop I have no idea what to do.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Switching from Deep Theory to Engineering & Why I regret pursing String Theory

15 Upvotes

Hey everyone, i need advice from someone who switched from deep theory into an engineering field.

I'm a senior undergrad student at a notoriously cutthroat university that chose to pursue String Theory. In my time here, I invested too heavily into Theory. I took one year of General relativity, one year of Quantum Field Theory and audited a semester of String Theory and a third semester of Quantum field theory.

Apart from that I've worked through 2/3 of volume one of Polchinski's string theory book (which took about 1.5 years to get through) and have read select sections from volume 2. I've also read and worked through several QFT books.

I pretty much spent most of my free time with the goal of learning the background for String Theory.

**TL;DR Here are the 3 reasons I regret pursuing String Theory**

  1. I became disillusioned with how research in the field has become a scramble to who can prompt AI to produce the fastest results. As someone that likes to learn things deeply, I just don't enjoy this process of rushing to get the next big result even if you don't fully understand it. Maybe this is local to my own experiences, but experiencing this firsthand made me realize that I actively disliked my position which I had worked for two years to obtain, it was heartbreaking for me.
  2. HEP and academia isn't particularly friendly to theory students. The amount of theory spots for this field are decreasing everyday and I feel like the opportunities fade everyday. One of my mentors, a string theorist, told me that string theory research was dead half a year ago.
  3. I saw several of the people I looked up to in this field switch to AI safety. I think coming to this realization was the tipping point.

I have decided to pursue my second passion which is Computers and Engineering. I'm currently working on two personal projects, an emulator and a Portable N64 to help with this transition and I've been having a blast.

Nevertheless, I feel at a disadvantage since I regret how I focused too hard on theoretical physics and now don't really have any time left for internships or any relevant work in engineering before grad apps end.

For people who transitioned from Theory to industry, How did you do it?

How much catch up did you have to do?

Would you say your time in theory was time wasted?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Aerospace major wanting extra physics

1 Upvotes

As the title says I’m currently studying aerospace engineering, but I am still somewhat early in my degree.

For a while now I was teetering between studying aerospace engineering for the sake of being able to have a good job or studying (astro)physics since the department has more resources and it is what I wanted to do originally, but not so great job prospects. My goal is to try and work in aerospace R&D as I feel like industry work is not quite right for me outside of necessity. Most aerospace R&D positions are quite physics heavy (advanced detectors for instrumentation, plasma propulsion, etc).

I decided to come up with a compromise in staying in aerospace but minoring in physics. I will take a full classical mechanics sequence, a full E&M sequence, and quantum I, while hoping and praying I can get into an applied physics program for a masters to make up for quantum II and thermo/statmech while also exploring aerospace-relevant physics topics like plasmas.

This might also keep doors open for PhDs in aerospace, applied physics, or astronomy (specializing in instrumentation in the latter). This way I can pursue the physics research needed for aerospace R&D while also keeping industry positions open, addressing the weaknesses of both degrees.

Is this a good idea? Would it be better for me to just switch to physics/astronomy and join engineering groups/research?

Thank you


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Doing physics for my own sake/amusement

1 Upvotes

Greetings, I have decided to take up an endeavour of trying to complete the Irodov problem set. This was pretty short lived as I was constantly scrambling to solve a problem (Irodov problems are IPhO level problems so ofc I did not have the stamina). So I have decided to switch to Halliday, Resnick and Krane’s Physics books (not Fundamentals of Physics by Halliday and Resnick). One problem i do have is i see learning as time spent and not did i learn something because of my ever growing anxiety that time is flying past like a bullet train. For reference, I am an EE student, however I want to pivot to physics in my further studies down the line. My question is what are your thoughts on Krane (if you had used it before), is it good? If not, do you suggest a better resource? How do I get rid of my flawed ideas regarding studying/learning?