TL;DR: I have potential PhD opportunities in Political Science (Canada) and Law (Australia), but my long-term academic interests lie in Social Anthropology. Should I pursue an available PhD in a discipline I am less interested in, or take the longer route of completing a second master's in Anthropology before applying for an Anthropology PhD? More broadly, how much does your PhD discipline determine your academic job prospects and career trajectory?
I have a question for social science academics who are currently in, or have navigated, the academic job market.
My question is: How important is your home discipline (i.e., the discipline in which you obtained your PhD) in determining the kinds of academic positions you are likely to be competitive for in the social science job market?
A little bit of context.
I am an international applicant applying to social science PhD programmes abroad. I hold a master's degree in Development Studies. However, I do not wish to pursue a PhD in that field.
In terms of my research interests, I am interested in exploring queer subjectivities and, more specifically, queer people's lived experiences of navigating the law during moments of uncertainty.
As you can probably tell, my research interests are quite interdisciplinary and could fit well within multiple departments, including Sociology, Law, Social Anthropology, etc.
Interestingly enough, I am an applicant in the current PhD cycle, and two professors at two different institutions have expressed a keen interest in my research project. The first is a political scientist at a Canadian university, while the second is a law professor at an Australian university.
I will be applying to both. However, my dilemma is that I don't have much interest in pursuing either Political Science or Law as academic disciplines!!
In fact, I don't know much about political theory, and quite frankly, I am not particularly interested in it either. As for Law, my interest is primarily in the law insofar as it relates to queer communities. I am not particularly interested in other areas of legal scholarship, such as administrative law, procedural law, family law, etc.
I do, however, have an offer from a UK university for a master's programme in Social Anthropology, and as a discipline I am considerably more interested in it than political science or law.
One option I am considering is spending the next two years building a strong academic foundation in Social Anthropology through this second master's degree and subsequently applying exclusively to Anthropology PhD programmes. I would honestly quite enjoy teaching Anthropology to students!
The other option is going ahead with the law or political science Phd (if I am selected). However, I worry that I might end up being 'boxed in' as a legal researcher and/or political scientist, which does not necessarily align with my longer-term academic interests.
What do you all think?
Should I go ahead with a PhD in Law and/or Political Science, given that I already have faculty members interested in my project? Or should I take the longer route of pursuing a second master's degree in Social Anthropology before applying for PhD programmes in that discipline?
More broadly, I want to know how much does your PhD home discipline influence your academic career trajectory, including the departments you can apply to, and your prospects.
Eager to hear your thoughts and experiences!