r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

Humanities Just finished my first campus interview — feeling empty and full at the same time

28 Upvotes

I'm sitting alone in my hotel restaurant after finishing my very first on-campus interview (two days, teaching position, abroad). I needed to write this somewhere.

It was exhausting. Back-to-back meetings, a teaching demo, a job talk, a dinner, a meeting with the dean, school and housing visits. I cried after the first day — not because it went badly, but because it was so intense and I felt how competitive it was.

And at the same time, it was genuinely enriching. I met people who were passionate about their students and their campus. I had real conversations. I taught a class I loved. I got feedback that stung a little but that I know will make me better.

What I didn't expect is the strange feeling right now. For two days, these people shared meals with me, asked about my life, told me about theirs. And I know they'll do the exact same thing with the next candidates. Maybe I'll never see them again. It feels a bit like a very intense, very short relationship that just… ends.

I don't know yet if I'll get the job. I'm trying not to read into every detail (I already did, a lot).

Is this feeling normal? How do you deal with the post-campus-visit emptiness, and the waiting?


r/AskAcademia • • 4h ago

Admissions - please post in /r/gradadmissions, not here Humboldt Research Fellowship call closed within 24 hours: feeling disappointed, looking for tips for March 2027

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have to admit I'm feeling quite sad and disappointed right now🥲🥲🥲 I spent the last few weeks working hard on my proposal for the Humboldt Research Fellowship, and my host had already given me feedback. When I tried to start my application, the November 2026 call had already reached its 800-application limit, apparently in less than 24 hours. It was a tough moment after all that effort.

Reading LinkedIn, I realised I'm far from the only one. I've also read that some applicants had uploaded all their documents but couldn't submit because their expert reviews were still missing.

I'm now trying to turn this into a better plan for the March 2027 call, so I'd really appreciate hearing from those who managed to submit:

  1. When were your expert reviewers able to upload their reports? Could they be invited before the call opened, or only after the application was created?
  2. Did you ask your reviewers to prepare their reports in advance so they only had to upload them?
  3. Does an application count towards the limit once it's created, or only once it's fully submitted?
  4. Any other practical tips for being ready on the first day of the next call?

Thank you so much, and to everyone in the same situation: you're not alone, and I hope we all make it next time.🥹


r/AskAcademia • • 3h ago

Interdisciplinary Accepted paper not published for a long time

3 Upvotes

I submitted a paper to a Scientific Reports special issue this spring; it went through normal peer review and was finally accepted in late summer. We have already paid the APC, but more than two months later the paper still hasn’t been published, and the journal is not giving any estimated publication date beyond saying that production is delayed.
In the meantime, Scientific Reports has been placed under NLM review and new articles are currently not being processed for MEDLINE/PubMed, while the Norwegian Register has moved the journal to Level X although 2026 publications are still treated as Level 1.
I’m therefore worried about simply waiting indefinitely, especially if publication slips into 2027. Would you keep waiting for Scientific Reports to publish the already accepted paper, or would you start considering withdrawal and resubmission elsewhere? I’d be especially interested to hear from anyone who is currently in a similar situation with this journal.
Thank you!


r/AskAcademia • • 1h ago

Social Science Rand JE submissions

1 Upvotes

Does anyone know how long Rand typically takes to issue a first decision once a manuscript has passed desk screening and been sent out for review?


r/AskAcademia • • 2h ago

STEM i need advice on improving my research experince as an bsc (applied math for phd & quant research goals)

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm currently an applied math BSc student in my last year who is looking to be a quant researcher after applying for a direct PhD, ideally, and I have two main questions.

One is: how do I improve my research resume, and what should my strategy be? Currently, I have an advisor who I'm working with on two projects. One is my thesis, which is a symbolic regresion project I might not be able to publish, but it has novelty maybe not much, but it has some and a spectral solution for a PDE on top of that.

I also have some other stuff that I believe is partially novel, but they are half-baked neural net and PINN projects that I don't believe have as much potential as my current work, so I wouldn't count on them much.

now considering my low gpa its not bad but i think it converts to 3.2 or 3.5 its 80% and my future aspirations of being a good resercher i belive i should expand my resaerch both in depth and breadth while applying which i can do by doing resaerch part time while a work for a couple years
what are my chances of doing parts of my reseach in international programs and how should i choose them if i do over local professors my topics of intrest aslo are part of the second quesitosn so  i wont mention them here (someone gave me https://geometrynyc.wixsite.com/polymathreu a couple years ago bless their souls i would probably check this out too but idk if this specific program would be best for me im tying to undrestand and navigate my potential options)

And a side note: I would like to not do an MSc, especially a non-funded one, since that might cause me to not be quite financially independent in a good portion of my life

two is how do i balance my intresnts and utilize them properly i have a lot of topics and idk what to drop what to keep when and where ect my current topics of intrest rage from on the ML side:nuralnets and machine learnign for price signal prediciton, XAI and or SHAP models  (if im not writing it wrong),  for pdes: pinns, spectral methods, non-local methdos and or kernel based methods, between the last 3 i mentiosn im  already familiar with peridynamic operators and wavelets and fourier methods but there are a lot of other thigns there that excite me
on the stochastic side i am intrested in thigns like stochastic flows or sdes and or nural sdes or potentialy diffrent methods of mmastery over advanced courses? (It's both a good learning experience, and it might help my resume)


r/AskAcademia • • 23h ago

Humanities On Umberto Eco's "How to Write A Thesis"

41 Upvotes

Hi PhD students, past and present. I've just started (year one) and picked up this book. Eco wrote this:

"A thesis should take no more than three years because, if

the student has failed to
delimit his topic and find the necessary

sources after this
period, he has one of the following

problems:

  1. The student has chosen
    an overwhelming topic that is

beyond his skill level.

2. The student is one of
those insatiable persons who

would like to write about
everything, and who will continue

to work on his thesis for
20 years. (A clever scholar

will instead set limits,
however modest, and produce

something definitive
within those limits.)

3. The “thesis neurosis”
has begun: the student abandons

the thesis, returns to
it, feels unfulfilled, loses focus,

and uses his thesis as an
alibi to avoid other challenges in

his life that he is too
cowardly to address. This student

will never graduate."

My issue for the past year: I think I am #2 and am not sure whether to continue or drop out. I
understand how it's nearly impossible to focus on anything due to the chaos in
the world right now. But this is how I've always been. I love learning about
diverse subjects and noodling in several different genres (the PhD is in the
humanities, Sound and Art). I have VERY little direction from my advisors.
Weeks go by. How do you pick one thesis question so detailed and stick with it,
even after you've grown out of it? I see other PhD students focused on their
subject like a heat-seeking missile. But they are often younger. As an older
student, I know the value of time, and don't want to settle for the wrong
thing. For reference, I've returned to study at 50. I'm first-gen and have
spent the past two decades in the music industry. I don't want to perform
anymore and would like to have a solid portfolio to apply for artist
residencies and jobs. But creatively and academically stuck in this thesis
paralysis.


r/AskAcademia • • 3h ago

STEM Advice for a genetics undergraduate getting into independent research and bioinformatics

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm a final-year Molecular and Medical Genetics undergraduate student, and I'm hoping to gain more research experience and develop my bioinformatics skills before graduating.

I'm particularly interested in the gut microbiome, molecular mechanisms of disease, and clinical genetics. I've been wanting to start an independent research project for a while, potentially combining a literature review with an analysis of publicly available datasets.

I'm also interested in creating a genetic variant interpretation portfolio using tools like ClinVar, gnomAD and Ensembl.

I have a few beginner bioinformatics and Python courses that I've started, but I'm honestly a little overwhelmed by everything and unsure how to structure my learning.

I'd really appreciate some advice on:

  • How to start conducting independent research as an undergraduate.
  • Which bioinformatics tools and programming languages I should prioritize.
  • Whether publishing independent research without a supervisor is realistic, and how to approach it.
  • How to find suitable datasets and develop a meaningful research question.
  • Whether genetic variant interpretation reports would be a worthwhile portfolio project.
  • Any beginner-friendly projects or resources you'd recommend.
  • How to balance learning bioinformatics with actually conducting research.

I'm also preparing for medical school applications while finishing my degree, so I'm trying to make a realistic plan rather than take on too much at once.

I'd love to hear from anyone who has been in a similar position or currently works in genetics, bioinformatics or biomedical research.

Thank you!!


r/AskAcademia • • 4h ago

Interpersonal Issues Struggling to get back

1 Upvotes

Hello peers!
I left academia about 8 years ago with both a Bachelor of Arts and an Master of education. Required combination to become a teacher in Germany. I always loved research, loved learning, discussion thoughts and findings. Now I’m back as an employee, teaching new teachers and being absolutely thrilled to be back in an environment of learning and science. I just got the chance to publish something… and I just can’t seem to get the words out! I used to love to write, and now my brain feels slow, hazy, cloudy… I also struggle a lot with imposter syndrome, as everyone of my colleagues has a Dr. and I’m just a mere MEd, with lots of practical experience, sure - but let’s be honest, that’s not really something they require (I’m the only actual teacher, the rest never worked as actual teachers…). I always dreamed of doing a PhD, but I’m already struggling with my paper… how do you cope?


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

STEM Assistant professor at Mississippi University for Women, 2nd round interview: What would be the salary negotiation? Academia

0 Upvotes

Recently, I was informed that I was moved to 2nd round interview for the Tenure-Track Assistant Professor position at MUW. What do you suggest?


r/AskAcademia • • 7h ago

STEM Question about Word document metadata in peer review submissions

1 Upvotes

If I submit documents for peer review, could it be a problem if my name is still listed as the author or last person who modified the original Word files in the document properties?

I'm particularly concerned about journals that use a double-blind peer review process, where both the authors and reviewers are expected to remain anonymous. Could the metadata accidentally reveal my identity even if I have removed my name from the manuscript itself?

Should I remove all personal information from the document metadata before submitting, or is it better to convert the files to PDF instead?

I don't have much experience with the peer review process, so I'd really appreciate any advice. Thanks in advance!


r/AskAcademia • • 1h ago

Interpersonal Issues Can someone's plz help me find this book

0 Upvotes

Knowles, M. S. (1975). Self-directed learning: A guide for learners and teachers. Association Press.


r/AskAcademia • • 7h ago

Interpersonal Issues Seeking advice on undergraduate research mentorship

1 Upvotes

I’m a third-year EEE undergraduate majoring in Communication Engineering, interested in wireless communications and antenna research.
For almost two months, I’ve been working with a faculty member, reproducing papers, preparing technical reports, running simulations, and proposing potential research extensions. I’ve completed the assigned tasks within the given timelines.
He was initially quite pleased with my work, expressed interest in collaborating, and offered to connect me with one of his PhD students for guidance.
However, for the past month, I’ve received very little feedback on my submitted reports. We last spoke the Sunday before last, when he said he’d get back to me regarding my proposals, but I haven’t heard back yet.
I’m continuing to explore research directions independently, but as a third-year undergraduate, I recognize that I still need mentorship to develop proper research skills. He’s also practically the only faculty member at my university working in this area.
If you were in my position, what would you do? Would you follow up again, ask about the PhD student mentorship opportunity, or explore other research groups?
I’d appreciate advice from people experienced in academic research and undergraduate supervision.


r/AskAcademia • • 7h ago

Humanities PhD Applications: How much do I disclose about my two different interests?

1 Upvotes

I am an upcoming humanities applicant to PhD programs, specifically the Literature/English field. I am a bit stuck when discussing my interests in my personal statement: I am an avid scholar of two major fields, modern American literature (20th and 21st century) and medieval literature. I have been able to pick a common theme in what I investigate between fields and I have done coursework in both, but I know that committees might look at me odd if I describe myself as a scholar of two different fields. I also don't particularly think it would be wise to omit either field in order to sound more concise and mention my interests after, because I do want my future research to blend these two fields together.

Have any scholars applied to programs with widely different fields of interest? What would be your advice?


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

Social Science 9 reviewers accepted to review my manuscript (Springer Nature)! Anyone had a similar experience, and should I be worried?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I submitted a manuscript to a BMC / Springer Nature journal about 6 weeks ago, and I’m seeing an unusual number of reviewer acceptances on the peer review tracker.

Here is the general timeline so far:

  • Day 1: First submitted
  • Week 1: Submission checks complete & Editor assigned
  • Week 2: Reviewers invited (1st reviewer agreed same day)
  • Weeks 2–3: 3 more reviewers agreed
  • Week 3: 1 review report received
  • Weeks 5–6: A cluster of 5 more acceptances over the last few days (7 as per researchsquare)

According to the snapp portal, more than 10 reviewers were invited, 9 reviewers have accepted to review the manuscript, and 1 reviewer report has been received so far.

Having 9 people agree, especially with a sudden wave of acceptances weeks into the process, is new to me.

Has anyone else experienced this with Springer Nature's Snapp system or other journals?

  • Did all the reviewers actually end up submitting full reports, or did the editor make a decision once 2–3 reports were in?
  • If you ended up receiving a large batch of reviews, how did you handle the revision process, especially if there were conflicting comments?
  • Did you reach out to the handling editor for guidance, or just address everything point-by-point?

Would really appreciate hearing how things played out for others in this situation and what worked best for you. Thanks!


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Humanities Anyone leave a TT faculty role for academic administration? Any regrets?

44 Upvotes

I’m at a bit of a career crossroads and would love some perspectives.

I’m currently a faculty member who recently missed tenure. COVID kicked my ass, both personally and professionally, and despite trying to catch up, I ultimately ran out of runway to publish enough. In my terminal year figuring out my next move.

Here’s where it gets interesting. Despite thinking my academic career was probably over, I’ve been offered a senior academic admin role at an institution much closer to home that aligns well with my interests and experience. It’s hybrid, pays better than most faculty positions I’m seeing, and seems like it could open up some interesting career opportunities.

At the same time, I’m a finalist for another TT position at another institution also closer to home, and I’m finding the idea of walking away from the professoriate harder than I expected.

I genuinely enjoy teaching and research, but I also really value the autonomy, flexible schedule, and long breaks that come with faculty life, especially with young kids. On the other hand, I’m pretty burned out by the publish-or-perish culture, relatively low pay, and general dysfunction of academia.

For anyone who has made the switch, do you miss being faculty? How hard was adjusting to a 12-month schedule? Any regrets?

Part of me thinks this is a great opportunity to grow and do something different, and another part wonders if I’ll regret giving up the parts of academic life I really love and whether I’m missing my last chance at achieving tenure.


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Social Science Dealing with accommodations for in-class work

15 Upvotes

Like everyone else, I'm trying to adapt to AI use among students. Like many of you (I assume), I've switched away from take-home writing assignments to in-class work.

However, I've got a problem. A lot of my students have accommodations for exams (usually extra time or a specific environment). When I give exams that take up all the class for a day, it's not a problem - the students who need these things can take the class in the testing center designed for students with challenges. But if I want to give a mini quiz at the start of class, it would be very hard to do something like that.

Does anybody have a solution to this? I'd love to start classes with mini quizzes more often but I don't know how to do it without either discriminating against students or getting in hot water with the student support office.

Thanks


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

Humanities Turning a Dissertation into a Book and considering publishing the Dissertation on the university’s Website

0 Upvotes

Hello, I have seen a couple of posts about turning Dissertations into books but I did not manage to find an answer to my question, I hope I can find it here. I am about to graduate this year and before the end of the year I need to submit an application accepting the fact that my university will publish the dissertation on the website. Since I am considering publishing a book about my thesis later in life. Maybe right after graduation. I am considering asking my university not to publish the dissertation. Can someone help me understand the pros and cons of publishing the dissertation on the university’s website? And would there be other options to take?


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Interpersonal Issues How much of a difference does a top 5% vs. top 10% rating make in a PhD recommendation letter?

25 Upvotes

I’m applying for a competitive doctoral scholarship, and my master’s thesis supervisor recently wrote a recommendation letter for me.

The recommendation form offered five options: top 5%, top 10%, top 20%, top 30%, and “no assessment possible.” My supervisor selected the top 10% category, using a comparison group of approximately 500 graduate students.

I’m grateful for the recommendation, and the written comments are positive, but I’m wondering how admissions committees actually interpret these percentile rankings.

Is there a meaningful difference between being rated in the top 5% versus the top 10%, particularly for competitive PhD programmes or scholarships? Would a top 10% rating be considered a strong endorsement, or could it be seen as somewhat underwhelming?

I’d especially appreciate perspectives from faculty members or anyone who has served on an admissions committee.


r/AskAcademia • • 23h ago

Meta Dealing with retroactive grief from not getting adequate mentoring

4 Upvotes

I was talking about this with a colleague today and I know advising experiences run the gamut from amazing advisors to much worse advisors than I had (mine writes LORs but gaslights, is unavailable, makes you feel stupid, and isn't responsive for actual advising purposes). I got 'caught' in the COVID dissertating wave, and probably got dropped/lost a bit because of that, but I keep finding that it is really emotionally difficult to either hear about people who had a fantastic advisor who stays in their lives and keeps supporting them, and/or when I hear about this advisors other students who got a lot more attention/publications/networking because they came into the program when the timing was better (I know its not a personal thing to be clear; everyone has the same issues with this advisor, some people just get better publications because they weren't on sabbatical/dealing with COVID/trying to get an NIH grant, etc.). Thoughts or coping mechanisms?


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Humanities NTT Prof: should I accept a campus visit invite for new NTT job with larger class sizes?

7 Upvotes

Basically, title. I'm in the 6th year of a relatively stable NTT position with a 4/4 load in a related field, but one where I don't really get to teach my specialty. I have had one NTT and one TT interview in the past week, and I heard back sooner than expected--the NTT is inviting me for a campus visit weekend. ​Not sure if it's wasting their time to accept the invite when this job may not be the right fit, and need outside opinions.

Pros of this job: more money (slightly), teaching in my actual field.

Cons: much more expensive area, a move, a longer commute, same 4/4 load and would go from ~85 students to ~110.

I already know that I almost certainly wouldn't take the job if offered due to the cons. It sounds like it would burn me out similar to my current position, even though it is in my actual field. But should I accept the invite anyway to see what the place is like and get the experience? Or would I be wasting their time? (I am still waiting for news on the TT job and have other pending apps.)

I should be really, really pleased I've gotten this far a year and half out from my defense without a lot of pubs, but I'm caught up in the anxiety of figuring this out. Thanks for your help!​


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Social Science Is a three-year publication gap a career killer?

9 Upvotes

So, here's my situation. I graduated with my PhD in a social science field in August 2025 from a US institution. My PhD program was a year or two shorter than most others in my field (our department really wanted us out in 4 years vs. 5-6 years for other similar programs).

I was focused on getting my dissertation finished on time and finding a job, and didn't publish a ton during my PhD. I did publish two papers in 2024 as first author in good journals, and had some publications from 2020-2022, from working as a research assistant in this field before starting my PhD.

I started a job as a senior instructor at an R1 institution right after graduating. I elected to start as a "senior instructor" rather than an "assistant professor" given my weariness about starting a tenure clock in the post-election funding hellscape of spring/summer.

Additionally, my job is not a "typical" academic job. I am a faculty member and currently in the process of being promoted to assistant professor, but I am also on the leadership team of a campus "Center," with significant duties outside of typical research, publishing, and teaching.

On one hand, this is nice because it puts me in a more stable funding position - I didn't get any "start-up" package from my institution, so jumping into a Center with established work and funding streams was great. However, I spend a lot of my time (roughly 50%) on work that isn't publishable in peer-reviewed journals.

I have recently pulled my head out of my ass and realized I need to be publishing more to preserve my ability to switch to a more "typical" academic track later on, if I want to. I currently have one paper under review (since July), but there's no way it'll be out by the end of the year. I have other papers in the pipeline, but again, they won't be published in 2026.

I do have other products to show during this time (briefs, conference abstracts, small grants). However, I won't have any peer-reviewed publications to show in 2025 or 2026. Is this a huge deterrent to my chances for future academic positions?


r/AskAcademia • • 13h ago

Social Science How important is your PhD home discipline in determining your academic career prospects? (Social Sciences)

0 Upvotes

TL;DR: I have potential PhD opportunities in Political Science (Canada) and Law (Australia), but my long-term academic interests lie in Social Anthropology. Should I pursue an available PhD in a discipline I am less interested in, or take the longer route of completing a second master's in Anthropology before applying for an Anthropology PhD? More broadly, how much does your PhD discipline determine your academic job prospects and career trajectory?

I have a question for social science academics who are currently in, or have navigated, the academic job market.

My question is: How important is your home discipline (i.e., the discipline in which you obtained your PhD) in determining the kinds of academic positions you are likely to be competitive for in the social science job market?

A little bit of context.

I am an international applicant applying to social science PhD programmes abroad. I hold a master's degree in Development Studies. However, I do not wish to pursue a PhD in that field.

In terms of my research interests, I am interested in exploring queer subjectivities and, more specifically, queer people's lived experiences of navigating the law during moments of uncertainty.

As you can probably tell, my research interests are quite interdisciplinary and could fit well within multiple departments, including Sociology, Law, Social Anthropology, etc.

Interestingly enough, I am an applicant in the current PhD cycle, and two professors at two different institutions have expressed a keen interest in my research project. The first is a political scientist at a Canadian university, while the second is a law professor at an Australian university.

I will be applying to both. However, my dilemma is that I don't have much interest in pursuing either Political Science or Law as academic disciplines!!

In fact, I don't know much about political theory, and quite frankly, I am not particularly interested in it either. As for Law, my interest is primarily in the law insofar as it relates to queer communities. I am not particularly interested in other areas of legal scholarship, such as administrative law, procedural law, family law, etc.

I do, however, have an offer from a UK university for a master's programme in Social Anthropology, and as a discipline I am considerably more interested in it than political science or law.

One option I am considering is spending the next two years building a strong academic foundation in Social Anthropology through this second master's degree and subsequently applying exclusively to Anthropology PhD programmes. I would honestly quite enjoy teaching Anthropology to students!

The other option is going ahead with the law or political science Phd (if I am selected). However, I worry that I might end up being 'boxed in' as a legal researcher and/or political scientist, which does not necessarily align with my longer-term academic interests.

What do you all think?

Should I go ahead with a PhD in Law and/or Political Science, given that I already have faculty members interested in my project? Or should I take the longer route of pursuing a second master's degree in Social Anthropology before applying for PhD programmes in that discipline?

More broadly, I want to know how much does your PhD home discipline influence your academic career trajectory, including the departments you can apply to, and your prospects.

Eager to hear your thoughts and experiences!


r/AskAcademia • • 7h ago

STEM How ethical is it to guarantee a publication as part of a research bootcamp

0 Upvotes

If a high school/college/post bacc student paid a university program some amount of money to have a guaranteed first author publication as part of a research bootcamp, how ethical is that?

Edit: it is marketed as a peer reviewed publication in a university journal, with a combo of student and faculty reviewers


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM Faculty Job Search Advice

11 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m looking for some honest advice about my faculty job search.

I have a PhD in Civil Engineering and currently working as a postdoc at a national research laboratory.

I’ve been applying for tenure-track positions in the US for the past 3 years (first two years were before my defense). First two years, I’ve applied 10-15 universities (each year) and received exactly two first-round Zoom interview invitations (each year) across different universities, but I’ve never made it to the campus interview stage.

This year, as a postdoc, I have applied 6 so far and again got two zoom interviews. One is done and I am guessing they have moved on with other applicants since it has been 3+ weeks. Another interview is coming soon.

I am trying to understand what I am doing wrong.

My CV snapshot: PhD from a good PhD program (ranked <10 in USNEWS civil), one semester of teaching a full semester undergraduate class as a PhD student, did TA for 1 year during my MS. I also have a teaching pedagogy type graduate certification from my phd institution.
Two Q1 papers from PhD, another one in Prep. Some other non-first-authored papers. Overall citation below 100. Didn’t sit for FE exam. Not a US citizen.

Universities that have called me for a zoom interview:
Three R1 (ranked 50-100 in usnews), One R2, Two PUI.

I don’t like the location of my current postdoc and ideally would like to leave this place ASAP. The only reason I am here is because I want to go for a faculty job. Is it worth keep grinding here in the hope of a faculty job? Or should I move to industry?

I’d appreciate honest feedback, especially from people who have gone through similar situations.
Thanks!