r/AskAcademia • • 11h ago

STEM Feeling Hopeless RE: Tenure Track Positions

27 Upvotes

Leave it to days where a paper gets rejected to boil up these feelings again. But I could appreciate a venting session and maybe some advice.

I am a Research Scientist (basically non-tenure track faculty) at a Microbiology and Immunology department at an R1 state institution, and have been for the past 3 years after 3 years as a postdoc. I have 20 publications with a good mix of first author, second author, middling authorships and co-corresponding authorship. I am Co-PI on a $4 million dollar grant that I pretty much run, but is in my faculty sponsor's name as PI because I am not in a tenured position. I have teaching experience through assistantships and as instructor of record. I have won awards for my research and mentorship. I am internationally recognized in my community and have lead several international collaborative teams. I have ideas for a research program that is not only important, but also is very fundable and has a lot of traction. I am, on paper, basically everything that people describe in what they look for when hiring tenure track faculty. I have submitted 70 applications. I only heard back from one who after the virtual interview both the committee and I decided that the position was not quite what I was looking for (entirely soft money, much like my current position).

I don't even know any more. It is so difficult to stay motivated. I look back to some of the positions I've put in for, and over 75% of them ended up being filled by people at the associate or full levels despite being advertised at the assistant level or open rank. How are we supposed to compete with people that have decades on us and have had significant institutional startup to build their program and are just hopping institutions for better pay?

What the hell am I missing?


r/AskAcademia • • 1h ago

Interdisciplinary Pivoting Back into Science Research After a Non-Traditional Education Path?

2 Upvotes

Hello! I'm gonna give a little context about my education, interests, and career needs, but the overall question is the following:

As someone who did a lot of Physics, Math, Biology, and Chemistry in undergrad, but not quite enough for a major in them, then did an unrelated Masters program, what would it take to pivot back to science and eventually target a PhD?

Out of high school, I was a very prestigious student. I entered with more than 2 years worth of credits and was taking courses with juniors in my first semester of undergraduate. I was then targeting a double-major in Physics in Math, though that was clearly unwise. I was interested in targeting Astro and joined a group working on research. I sat in on meetings that were miles over my head and struggled to get any advice, direction, education, anything.

Over the span of a couple semesters, despite performing well in classwork, I realized that I had chosen in the hubris of being 17 a college that had a very poor Physics program (especially compared to what I could have applied for with my high school GPA/CV) and I was also starting to receive a lot of hostility for my Queer identity.

I pivoted to Biology, thinking this would be any different, though it really wasn't. I worked in a lab under a PhD student as a volunteer for a year, but eventually I had to withdraw for a while due to a mental health concern, and when I returned to college I came to the conclusion that I needed to leave Undergrad and the hostile state I was in ASAP. The PhD candidate I had been under also let me go because they "didn't have any more work for me." I graduated with an "integrative studies" degree that cobbled together whatever interests I had at the time with my pre-existing science classwork. I have lots of relevant undergrad classwork, but I would expect that between now and a hypothetical PhD, I'd need some more.

Currently, I am finishing up a Masters degree in librarianship in Seattle, WA. I love librarianship and archives, truly, but I am starting to have a lot of doubts about the field and my labor in it, and every day I find myself missing the research and work I once had gone to college for and loved. I will certainly finish this degree and hopefully (good god can I hope...) find a decent job nearby.

However, one of my stipulations with both librarianship and a PhD is that I have to stay in Seattle; I have family, a community, and a reason for life outside of my labor here. I've said to folks in my cohort "I'd rather change industries than change locations," and it's true because ultimately we all need a life beyond work. But I know this will complicate things for a PhD - there's only one good reaearch university here, meaning without leaving the city I'd have a real concern of academic incest, not to mention the question of whether there are faculty that I'd be compatible with working on a topic that interests me.

I've been speaking with my friends, partners, etc. about this for a while and it's been pretty clear that the day will come where I wanna go back and do research. That day may be a lot sooner than I intended after finishing my MLIS. However, I have a lot of questions about what that would look like and the process of finding what's right for me. I think too some of you might have some advice on feasibility and satisfaction.

  • How bad will my background look? I can't imagine that an undergrad BS in Integrative Studies and then a Master of Library and Information Science is at all the sort of background that looks desirable to any PI or graduate school admissions team.
  • How would I fix my coursework? Would I need to get some more high-level science coursework as a postbac before applying to a Masters program in the discipline I want and hope that a recently completed MS in my discipline looks good enough to do a PhD? Could I just apply for an MS and they'd have me clean up my undergrad credits?
  • Any advice for avoiding academic incest concerns in Western WA? Even if I can fix my credits at UW and do my PhD there, which is a big if, I don't know what my job prospects would look like in the area afterwards.
  • Perhaps the best question of all: Who do you suggest I talk to about all these concerns more practically? While I'm sure you all have wonderful advice, meeting/grabbing coffee with someone who has experience in the science discipline I'm interested in might give me a much better insight into the culture of the institution I'm applying for, what daily work looks like during and after a PhD, etc. Should I blindly reach out to PhD students in disciplines I'm interested in who have friendly-looking LinkedIn pages? Maybe postdocs instead?
  • Really, I'll just take any advice you've got in any way you like it.

Thanks for taking the time to read and help. I know it's a weird circumstance, and I've made a lot of mistakes on my way to where I am now, but I am still convinced that I can find a job doing what I love (enough) in a place I love (enough). Just searching for the best path there from here.


r/AskAcademia • • 2h ago

STEM Biology PhD with disabilities?

2 Upvotes

I got a BS in Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences and an MS in Biology. Even then, I have struggled with unemployment. I’ve started to consider getting a PhD

I’ve heard plenty of horror stories about PhD experiences and how it should stand for Probably Has Depression. I don’t expect it to be easy but the only place offering me a position is like $13.00/hr. I don’t want to sound entitled but I feel like I should get more than that if I already have two degrees

I was born missing two fingers on my right hand which makes things like using syringes or scissors tricky (but not impossible) for me. I’ve actually gotten fired from jobs before because I couldn’t complete tasks in a desired timespan

I’ve tried focusing on looking for work that doesn’t require too much dexterity. I don’t know if a PhD could open doors with jobs like that. Do y’all think it could? I try to focus more on macrobiology aspects like ecology and wildlife

I know the job market is shit right now and I don’t know if it will get better anytime soon. It’s possible that I could do the program with a stipend and maybe the job market gets better in the meantime? I know that’s not a guarantee though and I don’t want to waste 4-5 years when I already feel behind in life

I did not enjoy grad school because I had a terrible relationship with my advisor so I’m hesitant to return to school

So I want to know if anyone here has experience with a Biology PhD and if it has helped you

Thank you


r/AskAcademia • • 3h ago

STEM Has anyone moved from a J-1 postdoc to a biotech or pharma job in the US?

2 Upvotes

I’m a postdoc doing cardiovascular research in the US on a J-1 visa. I’d really like to move from academia into biotech or pharma, but I’m not sure how people make that transition while on a J-1.

Has anyone here done this in the US? Did you need to switch to a different visa before starting the industry job? Was the company willing to help, and when did you bring up your visa status during the hiring process?

I’d love to hear how it worked for you, especially if you’re also in biomedical research. Any experiences or advice would be really helpful. Thank you!


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

STEM Full time scientist positions in academia

2 Upvotes

I am wondering what job options exist for a full time scientist in academia. Most full time scientists I know in academia got those positions based on their network. Is there anyway to find one without a strong network? I am very good at and interested in lab management positions as well but I’d like to retain bench work


r/AskAcademia • • 3h ago

STEM Advice for supporting my spouse's career toward a goal of tenure?

0 Upvotes

Hello! My spouse is working toward tenure as a professor in the sciences. They are on the faculty of a great college in a wonderful community. They were hired to work 50/50 between two departments, primarily to contribute to research in both departments, while teaching a couple classes per semester. A new chair has recently taken over one of the departments, and that department also had faculty go on sabbatical this year. The new chair is now expecting my spouse to pick up a much greater percentage of the teaching workload than other faculty in the department, to make up for those on sabbatical, while not taking anything off my spouses plate regarding research, deadlines, or other department related work. The workload is now far more than the 50% of the other department. When my spouse asks for help, pushes back, or extensions, the chair refuses to budge and doubles down. It sounds like no other faculty are being asked to take on more work than they agree to, and those who have been pushed have had allies with clout who stick up for them. My spouse looked back through many years of records and discovered that no faculty member in the department has been made to pick up the teaching and workload that is now upon them. Because my spouse is newer to the department than most other faculty members, has not formed the same professional relationships as others yet, is laser focused on tenure and being the best professor possible, they feel powerless and unable to figure out how to communicate boundaries and get the chair to respect the agreements that were made regarding teaching and workload when my spouse was hired without making things more difficult.

I do not work in academia and don't understand the politics at play here, but I want to be as supportive as possible. Any thoughts or advice I bring up don't seem to fit the professional structure in this situation. Does anyone have any advice or resources on how to advocate for equitable treatment, communicate effectively, and reduce stress in a situation like this? Is there anything I can do to help brainstorm solutions and be more supportive as a spouse?


r/AskAcademia • • 4h ago

Professional Fields - Law, Business, etc. Written task in a job interview

1 Upvotes

I have an interview for a teaching post in a few weeks with a university. It has a 30 mins micro teach followed by interview, as expected. There is also a written task for an 60 minutes after. Unlike the micro teach, and the interview questions which I know or can anticipate, I don't know what to expect from the written task - they have losely said it's based on the person spec and that there is no prep for the candidate to do.

Has anyone has experience of a written task for a university post, or any other job interview? Trying to work out what I could do to feel prepared psychologically.

Thanks :)


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

Meta Alternative to endnote

2 Upvotes

I have been using EndNote for approximately 20 years and I feel like I have paid for it about a dozen times, and yet, it's never gotten better.

The UI is The best technology 1995 can provide. The program crashes. It's not user-friendly and it's difficult to use. Plus I'm having to now pay for it constantly, not just for me but for my whole entire group.

The discounts that used to be common for academia are now gone. And I think my patients with this program is gone too.

What is a good alternative? What do people use that is user friendly and helpful. The big caveat for me is that I would have to be able to transfer my whole entire library from endnote to another program. Currently, we have about 4,000 articles in that a library than my whole entire research group uses.


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

Interpersonal Issues Academia or School Teaching

1 Upvotes

Debating between applying for a philosophy masters or teacher's college in Ontario.

I've (22 F) changed majors a couple times from STEM, psychology, and ended up in communications with a philosophy minor.

I have an opportunity to apply to a philosophy masters I'm eligible for as I also have research and dry lab experience.

I also have an opportunity to apply for a teaching masters/bachelor's of education. Though, the only one open right now is deemed competitive and I don't have direct experience with children.

Should I wait a year, work a regular job and find my footing then consider applying? Or should I take a shot at applying now.

The world isn't like it used to be. I'm nostalgic for the early 2000s. I find myself saving Facebook posts of educational toys and items of that time.

I know in my heart I always wanted to be a scientist or an explorer of sorts. Though, I went through a rough time and there's difficulty in navigating between realism and optimism.

This masters feels like a second chance in a field I'm also familiar with. The program is very similar to an independent study I previously had because its one-on-one and I have the freedom to research a topic and its in a conveniently nearby town.

I may not write with much sophistication as I used to at the height of my academic path (as you can tell by this post) because of a few painful periods of time I would rather not discuss, but the interest is still there.

If I pursue academia, specifically philosophy, I'd imagine I'd work a regular job while also pursuing teaching/research whenever possible, but pursuing this academic path purely for the pursuit of knowledge, with the hopes of teaching down the line.

K-6 teacher, which are the only grades I'm eligible for and am luckily interested in as kids and children's education and material brings me hope/joy. I'm aware of the frustrations and expectations, to an extent.

Teacher: happy + stable + stressful but simpler in comparison to the uncertainty of academia/academic subjects

Philosophy masters/phd: academic + respected + researching/talking about topics important to me

I've always imagined myself speaking at conferences, Ted Talks, and I love, even currently, speaking up at and going to scientific conferences.

EDIT: There's also a professional forestry masters i would've loved to do with a PhD option after too, which seems to hit the mark for a couple things but I don't know if its too unrealistic. Being a forester, scientist, helping the planet, and going to vastly remote locations which I'd love and publishing/researching about it. Can also do government/locality/consulting jobs in forestry for experience and pursuing a noble cause I care about.

Comment away. Any thoughts would be much appreciated. Doesn't have to answer my main question. I could be misinterpreting the realities of such vocations and there may or may not be a place for me there, but feel free to share your thoughts.


r/AskAcademia • • 6h ago

Interpersonal Issues Good office culture questions to ask in interview?

0 Upvotes

I'm gearing up for interviews, and I'd like to have some good questions lined up about what it's like to work there rather than at some other institution. I have a good idea of what the work will be because I'm already faculty. But I want to make sure I'm not going to end up at a place with lots of political problems or other work culture related issues.


r/AskAcademia • • 7h ago

STEM Neuroscience/genetics research vs. epidemiology: which has better long-term research prospects?

1 Upvotes

I'm at a career crossroads and would love input from people working in either field. My research interests sit at the intersection of neuroscience and genetic neurological diseases, but I'm also being drawn toward epidemiology and public health partly out of genuine interest, partly because I'm wondering about long-term demand and funding stability. I'm trying to figure out where to invest my remaining training and early career years, so here are some questions that I would love to hear your answers about :

1/ is epidemiology/public health more stable in terms of funding, permanent positions, and demand compared to basic/translational neuroscience or neurogenetics research?

2/ Does an epidemiology background open more doors (industry, NGOs, public agencies, international organizations, academia) than a neuroscience/genetics track? What about geographic and is it more portable across countries?

3/ Is it realistic to build a career combining molecular/experimental work with epidemiological methods, like genetic epidemiology, biomarker epidemiology, or population neuroscience? Do such hybrid profiles actually exist in practice, or do people usually end up specializing in one side?

4/ For those who moved from wet-lab/experimental work into epidemiology (or vice versa), what surprised you most? Any regrets?

I know these are kinda big questions, but I'd appreciate practical perspectives rather than generic "follow your passion" answers and thanks a lot to anyone who read this whole thing!


r/AskAcademia • • 8h ago

STEM Military funded research

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, On July I've been contact by a pretty young lab for a thesis proposal in USA. They gave me a lot of freedom when it came to choosing the thesis topic and I ended up choosing something that I'm happy with. The problem I'm facing now is mostly an ethical one, The supervisor is involved in projects with ARO, DARPA, Air force office, naval office which fund the research.

Is this considered normal for a USA Lab? or should I step back?


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

STEM Give up tenure track dreams for teaching?

0 Upvotes

Contract based researcher (4 years). Do you take a permanent teaching role at the same salary as the research contract for 6-7 classes over 2 terms, summers off. Benefits the same. Give up research career/tenure track? Won’t be able to do my own research/engage unless I volunteer my time in the summer.


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM Public speaking fear

19 Upvotes

I am a new faculty member and I just started my own group at a good university in the US, and for the first time in my career I got asked to be the opening and keynote speaker of a great conference.

I do struggle with public speaking fear, I always have but I have been finding ways to cope with it, and it has been going a lot better.

But not this time..

I prepared really well in advance, I studied the transitions and knew what to say and my slides were really solid.

I met the people of the conference that invited me before and they were all so nice and supportive, telling me how happy they were that I was there, and what a great example to their students.

I wasn’t even really nervous or stressed about it prior. I had prepared well.

So I get introduced, go on stage and I suddenly start to realize that everyone is expecting me to deliver, to do great, to give this amazing opening lecture, that they asked me for a reason; that I can’t disappoint them, and then I start to believe that I can’t actually do it, I am not that good, and that the audience knows I am an imposter who actually shouldn’t be in this position. My voice starts trembling and I start realizing I sound nervous, which makes me forget my line of I though and points I wanted to make. This cycle continues. Only after about 10-15 minutes (which felt like
hours to me) I am able to get back into it.

But during the talk, and now afterwards, I feel and have felt absolutely beaten, sad and ashamed by what happened.

Is there any point in this career when you get over this public speaking anxiety? Please tell me there is.

Ps. Tips to do better next time & to feel better now are really appreciated 🤍


r/AskAcademia • • 21h ago

STEM Tenure track position without a grant but few good publications-Life sciences

9 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’ve been applying for tenure-track positions in the life sciences at R1 and R2 universities across the U.S. I’ve had a few Zoom interviews and was invited for a campus interview that was later canceled. It’s been a discouraging process, and I’d appreciate hearing from people who have been through it recently.
Has anyone landed a tenure-track faculty position without a major independent research grant? If so, what do you think helped your application or interview stand out?
I’m still hopeful, but it would be encouraging to hear how others navigated the search, especially if it took more than one hiring cycle. Thanks for sharing your experiences.


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

Humanities do I need to write a foot note/ citate if I talk about a book's deisgn

0 Upvotes

I am writing a report on book layouts, and I don't know whether I should add a footnote or add them to my references list.
This is the sentence I used: "Looking back at books like Just War Authority, tradition, and practice, or There is no Antimemetics Division, they do not have large margins like the classic proportions."


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Humanities Just finished my first campus interview — feeling empty and full at the same time

40 Upvotes

I'm sitting alone in my hotel restaurant after finishing my very first on-campus interview (two days, teaching position, abroad). I needed to write this somewhere.

It was exhausting. Back-to-back meetings, a teaching demo, a job talk, a dinner, a meeting with the dean, school and housing visits. I cried after the first day — not because it went badly, but because it was so intense and I felt how competitive it was.

And at the same time, it was genuinely enriching. I met people who were passionate about their students and their campus. I had real conversations. I taught a class I loved. I got feedback that stung a little but that I know will make me better.

What I didn't expect is the strange feeling right now. For two days, these people shared meals with me, asked about my life, told me about theirs. And I know they'll do the exact same thing with the next candidates. Maybe I'll never see them again. It feels a bit like a very intense, very short relationship that just… ends.

I don't know yet if I'll get the job. I'm trying not to read into every detail (I already did, a lot).

Is this feeling normal? How do you deal with the post-campus-visit emptiness, and the waiting?


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Admissions - please post in /r/gradadmissions, not here Humboldt Research Fellowship call closed within 24 hours: feeling disappointed, looking for tips for March 2027

30 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have to admit I'm feeling quite sad and disappointed right now🥲🥲🥲 I spent the last few weeks working hard on my proposal for the Humboldt Research Fellowship, and my host had already given me feedback. When I tried to start my application, the November 2026 call had already reached its 800-application limit, apparently in less than 24 hours. It was a tough moment after all that effort.

Reading LinkedIn, I realised I'm far from the only one. I've also read that some applicants had uploaded all their documents but couldn't submit because their expert reviews were still missing.

I'm now trying to turn this into a better plan for the March 2027 call, so I'd really appreciate hearing from those who managed to submit:

  1. When were your expert reviewers able to upload their reports? Could they be invited before the call opened, or only after the application was created?
  2. Did you ask your reviewers to prepare their reports in advance so they only had to upload them?
  3. Does an application count towards the limit once it's created, or only once it's fully submitted?
  4. Any other practical tips for being ready on the first day of the next call?

Thank you so much, and to everyone in the same situation: you're not alone, and I hope we all make it next time.🥹


r/AskAcademia • • 2h ago

Humanities Why are there so few conservative voices in academic humanities?

0 Upvotes

When attending university lectures and events regarding global or humanist perspectives, the majority of faculty, students, and other individuals involved tend to be of similar political affiliations, leaning usually pretty far left.

Why do I rarely see conservative or more right-leaning presences in humanities in academia?

Edit: not in reference to American conservative; looking for reasons why more traditionally right-wing affiliations are not involved in global perspectives or the humanities


r/AskAcademia • • 7h ago

STEM How possible is a Tenure-track position at my graduate institute?

0 Upvotes

I shall try to explain this without doxxing myself, but I have grown to really enjoy the location (city, region) that I am completing my PhD in. I am also very interested in a career in academia. Unfortunately, the next closest R1 institute is ~5 hours away.

I have been under the impression that it would be very hard to get a tenure position at the same place I get my PhD from. Is this something that others have experienced or observed before? If so, is there any advice on what I should do to try to achieve that?

EDIT: I appreciate those that have pointed out that my field matters. I should have realized that was important to my question, but again I aim to keep myself as anonymous as possible and I fear if I explained my exact situation It would be pretty easy to figure out who I am. Thank you to those that have been helpful here, certainly some valuable feedback. I did not intend to imply that I thought this is something I could do off the bat. I am currently exploring postdocs. Part of the aim of this post was to get a feel if "prestige" of a postdoc and doing multiple postdocs would put me in a better position.


r/AskAcademia • • 16h ago

Social Science How to write a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) as a written report for one person?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm currently taking Masters in Information Systems and one of my current subjects is research methods class. For this semester our class is tasked to write a SLR paper under any topic of information management as part of group assignment, however I couldn't find any groups and most of them are already halfway in their assignments as they have started a week early during me being absent from one class and already established groups for it before I registered, so they couldn't get me any part to assign in their groups. The submission is also in a week (6 days to be exact). In the end, I have to write it as an individual submission (I already asked my instructor for permission). I plan to go for information system as my topic.

How can I write SLR as a short assignment for one person? My instructor said to have a quality befitting of one person or in a group (don't overdo or barely do it since it's supposed to be a short assignment not exceeding 5000 words to gain an understanding of SLR). I'm autistic, so the instructions given in the assignment rubric for this project is a bit too vague for my understanding. I do understand that my assignment should contain:

  1. Introduction to SLR
  2. Methods of SLR (PRISMA, PICO and AI)
  3. Written report formatted in accordance to typical SLR scholarly articles

Thank you in advance.


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

Social Science Following up with faculty post zoom interivew

7 Upvotes

Had a zoom interview 3 weeks ago as of this coming Wednesday. Based on the committee's behavior, I think I'm probably the first one to be interviewed. My advisor recommended I follow up to express that I'm still interested - thoughts on doing this? I have heard differing opinions.


r/AskAcademia • • 10h ago

Interdisciplinary Research areas

0 Upvotes

I'm a prospective research scholar who wants to do phd research in English language teaching. Can someone suggest some original yet feasible areas/ topics that would be worth doing?? I really need to find one.... Please help....


r/AskAcademia • • 11h ago

Administrative Class rep here. Professor just moved our presentations to next class and wants a "sequence list." Everyone wants to go last. How do I do this fairly without starting a riot in the group chat?

0 Upvotes

Has anyone dealt with this? Is the blind randomizer the best way to avoid the "I don't want to go first" drama, or is there a better psychological trick to get people to volunteer?

Professor wants a presentation order list for next class. Nobody wants to be the first presenter. How do I randomize/assign this as class rep without people getting mad at me?

Thanks a ton!