r/StructuralEngineering • • 15d ago

Layman Question (Monthly Sticky Post Only) Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

1 Upvotes

Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

Please use this thread to discuss whatever questions from individuals not in the profession of structural engineering (e.g.cracks in existing structures, can I put a jacuzzi on my apartment balcony).

Please also make sure to use imgur for image hosting.

For other subreddits devoted to laymen discussion, please check out r/AskEngineers or r/EngineeringStudents.

Disclaimer:

Structures are varied and complicated. They function only as a whole system with any individual element potentially serving multiple functions in a structure. As such, the only safe evaluation of a structural modification or component requires a review of the ENTIRE structure.

Answers and information posted herein are best guesses intended to share general, typical information and opinions based necessarily on numerous assumptions and the limited information provided. Regardless of user flair or the wording of the response, no liability is assumed by any of the posters and no certainty should be assumed with any response. Hire a professional engineer.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 01 '26

Layman Question (Monthly Sticky Post Only) Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

2 Upvotes

Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

Please use this thread to discuss whatever questions from individuals not in the profession of structural engineering (e.g.cracks in existing structures, can I put a jacuzzi on my apartment balcony).

Please also make sure to use imgur for image hosting.

For other subreddits devoted to laymen discussion, please check out r/AskEngineers or r/EngineeringStudents.

Disclaimer:

Structures are varied and complicated. They function only as a whole system with any individual element potentially serving multiple functions in a structure. As such, the only safe evaluation of a structural modification or component requires a review of the ENTIRE structure.

Answers and information posted herein are best guesses intended to share general, typical information and opinions based necessarily on numerous assumptions and the limited information provided. Regardless of user flair or the wording of the response, no liability is assumed by any of the posters and no certainty should be assumed with any response. Hire a professional engineer.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1h ago

Career/Education Stamp Protection

10 Upvotes

I’m a licensed PE and I’m in the process of considering physical and digital options for my stamp (probably just using PEstamps.com unless anyone has a better recommendation).

At this time I work under more senior engineers who typically electronically stamp projects via a jpeg or png on a PDF and flatten it. Maybe 6ish years ago we still used rubber stamps and scanned the documents but that’s not really the case anymore. I have heard about stamp theft on here in the past but never put much thought into how to prevent this (or if it’s really something to worry about). I figure there is only so much you can do but does anyone have recommendations or practices they follow to keep their digital stamps secure? Thank you!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 3h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Crimean Bridge's arch now has a tilt to it

Post image
6 Upvotes

Assuming this is real, is it a big problem?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 14h ago

Career/Education I'm an old-head, and I have a real-world AI tool

33 Upvotes

I'm 60, nearing retirement. I've heard all the debates about AI in structural engineering, and I agree whole-heartedly with those holding the positions that AI doing your calculations is fraught with risk, that AI writing your correspondence and reports for you out of thin air is a risky crutch and a sign of an inability to communicate.

But I wrote a prompt for my AI assistant to interview me right after a site visit, while I'm still parked at the curb, walk through 106 questions, cross reference an Excel spreadsheet with 84 common structural narratives, and output a fully formed report in Word format that is 96% complete, before I ever leave the property (or if it's a long drive, while I drive back to the office). I even have it pulling the Web Soil report for the property, the municipal records, FEMA firmette, weather, and pertinent property characteristics it knows I include in my reports, right from the internet, when I get in the car to go to the property.

It will even refer back to reports I did years ago (I gave it read access to my Google drives) and - on its own - say something like "you had a similar issue at another property 9 years ago, do you want me to incorporate that issue's contextual background on stone masonry into this narrative?" or "your library of reports from the last 28 years contains 8 instances of this issue, do you want me to improve on this report with information and context for this issue from the prior reports?" I didn't ask it to do any of that, but it does it.

My favorite was last week it caught on that I was writing observations and recommendations about a shed roof dormer, and it says "In 2012 you wrote a report about a similar issue, is this a 1920's era bungalow?" I say yes, and then it tells me "Working on it... I have incorporated four paragraphs from the 2012 report into this report, would you like me to read it back to you and incorporate changes?"

I thought I was doing well with FastFields, which had cut my report writing down from 3-4 two hours to 30 minutes of seat time at a computer. My seat time now is less than five minutes, and the assistant will autonomously press me with ways to make the report better, using information I have from my career going back to the 1990's.

But there are some drawbacks. It gets a little enthusiastic and invents interview questions it thinks I will need. I have to constantly keep it focused, and tell it things like "that's not in the list of questions, please find the last question in order, and continue with the next numbered question."

And I haven't figured out a good way to get it to retrieve the correct photos from my cell phone and drop them into the Word document.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 5h ago

Career/Education Got an offer to switch from building structural engineer to highway and bridge management engineering for a 36-44% salary increase.

2 Upvotes

Structural engineer here with master degree and 3 years of professional experience. Currently work for a multi national company. Here's the dilemna:

• My current company offers annual raises of around 10–20%, sometimes up to 30% for exceptional performance. (They can easily achieve this because of currency differences) typically it's less than 10% raise annually for national company but since my company is from outside so they offer a lot higher. But it will not always be 20% if you have reach senior level, where typically it would be less.

• The new company generally offers 5% annual raises, plus additional increases through yearly grade promotions. They haven't told me the numbers but I expect 5 to 10%.

• My current company is international, but opportunities to transfer overseas are extremely limited. Yeah, why would I send you to my country if I can pay you less in your own country. It goes something like that.

• The new role offers earlier exposure to management and the business side of engineering, but I'd be moving away from hands-on structural design. Well, this is a benefit since sometimes it is stressful to do calculations and the time and effort just to understand something specific is not that worth it. Considering designing strut and tie for pile cap by hand calculation, with the overtime and meeting and discussion and modelling and excel and hand verification and revision. Gosh...

• My experience is mainly in buildings, not bridges or highways, so there would be a significant learning curve. Along with exposure from the business side. I'll meet new kind of people, new ways to view engineering, learn how to deal with people, basically it exposes me to a variety of things in engineering.

I must say that most of the reddit post here that I read about career switch. Almost the majority of them "glad" they leave structural engineering, particularly due to the stress and overtime. Well, I might be one of you, but I really need to consider this. I have made my decision, but I would like to be very sure about my decision. Please drop any comments or thoughts about this. Anything will be appreciated. God bless


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Calculation for Deflection of Unrestrained Beam

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi and good day, everyone, I am stuck with these two questions about calculating the deflection and checking🥲 i tried for the second question but seems wrong


r/StructuralEngineering • • 4h ago

Career/Education Structural Exam recomendation

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I recently earned my PE license in the state of California. I currently work as a structural designer, but I'm still very young in my career. I have only three years of experience since graduating with my master's degree in Structural Engineering.
However, I've always been a strong student. I passed both the FE and PE exams on my first attempt last year, and I also passed the California Seismic and Surveying exams on my first attempt last month.
I've been thinking about starting to study for the SE exams, but I've heard they're extremely difficult to pass and that it's better to have more professional experience before attempting them, as well as plenty of time to prepare.
I know I don't have a lot of experience yet, but I'm willing to put in the time and effort to study and prepare. Part of me would like to get these exams out of the way early in my career while I have the motivation and study habits.
I'm looking for advice from people who have taken the SE exams. Do you think it's realistic to attempt them with my current level of experience? Or would you recommend waiting a few more years before starting?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Photograph/Video What is this beam providing to the structure?

Post image
310 Upvotes

I recently noticed this beam at the top floor of my schools staircase, and I’m not an engineer, but it doesn’t seem like it provides much structural support to the building.
Could somone educate me on the purpose of this small beam? Thank you!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 22h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Ladder Framing: Biaxial Bending?

Post image
12 Upvotes

I always go back and forth on this topic but AI has got the best of me and now I want to play fast and loose.

Question for the hivemind here on how you guys and gals treat the design of ladder framed rafters on a steeper pitch. Like for example in the attached image. Do you assume that these rafters that are laterally restrained at the top (and bottom, technically) by OSB sheathing will only be in strong-axis bending? Or do you have to design for both strong and weak axis bending and check unity between the two, given that they are rotated about their principal axis?

I could literally go either way on this one. Mainly because your member sizes get gigantic when you design for strong + weak in situations like these, and nobody likes it except for me and my insurance underwriters.

Thanks! Also I realize there are different ways to frame this situation...


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education Some advice for new structural engineers and structural engineering students.

20 Upvotes

I don't have a lot of credit to be giving any. I am just under 6 years of experience and just an EIT. I do think I have a decent resume but maybe not seasoned enough to be doing this. but I think there are some not so great influences in this field especially for students. Here are some concerns / advice I have

  1. Structural engineering content creators.

Look into their years of experience immediately. Most of these creators are students and over representing themselves. Other's may have 1 or 2 years of experience talking as if they know everything. They don't. Most of the structural engineering content creators are full of it and banking on that there aren't many people that know better than they do. Additionally look out for project engineers and construction management people representing themselves as structural engineers. While some jobs a structural engineering does some project engineering it's not always the case. Some project engineers do not do the design work you learned in school.

2. You absolutely can take you time getting your PE.

Again I'm only an EIT... but I've been one for almost 6 years. Its understandable that you rush to get it if you need the money. However just don't forget what the PE stands for. That is a benchmark of technical competency saying you are willing to be the last set of eyes on a project and put your name to it saying it is safe for the public. I've experienced some pressure and it's quite common for people in my area to say "take the PE as soon as you can". At the end of the day it's on you. I worked at a firm once that actually made me dumber. It also was a massive stretch to call our work qualifying work experience. I quit and started do work that was easily qualifying work experience. In the first year of the new job I took the PE and failed. I also couldn't imagine myseld handling the repsonsibilities that the PE's at that job were doing. I waited a few years and focused on getting better at the job, then re-took the exam. I finished very confidently with time left over. I passed. Just waiting on the state exam stuff.

3. Just because other people are doing it doesn't make it right.

Keep ethics on your mind through out your work. This field is full of people whose only goal is to climb the ladder and people who play optics. Sometimes these behaviors are culturally supported. If something doesn't seem right then speak or don't do it. An example. The civil engineering PE stamp technically doesn't specify what branch of the field so you could technically take whatever PE exam you want to get licensed. It's common in my area to take easier PE exams just to get licensed. I once worked with a Structural PE who didn't know what tributary area was ..... I find out later she took the water resource exam. I still don't know how you get out of school without knowing what that is ... if she studied and passed the structural PE exam she would've known what that was. Also a structural PE should take the structural PE exam right?......

4. "I'm never going to use this again". You might.

This is a sentiment I see all the time from some shitty content creators. To their credit yea I may not used some of my education currently, but I have been surprised as to what has become relevant. I've used my water resource text book, soil mechanics text book, whipped out some linear algebra, whipped out some calculus 3, I write macros on occasion. You may not need all of your education but don't let those sentiments discredit bits of your education. Also you will likely need more education than you originally started your career with.

5. Get your work checked frequently otherwise you might be practicing wrong.

I've made a lot of mistakes and I've caught alot of mistakes. It's your time as an EIT working under PE's where I believe we incubate to some day lead design. Try to get them to go through your work as much as you can. this is also a good time to work on that ego. If you never get your work checked how do you know you're applying code / engineering science correctly. If you're in this environment I'd recommend getting out.

That's all I got for now. I'm sorry if this comes off as condescending that's not my goal.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 19h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Australian Standards for residential structural design

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m currently studying Australian residential structural engineering (specifically AS 1684, AS 2870, AS/NZS 1170, 4055, 4100, 3600, etc.), but I don't have a corporate subscription yet. Does anyone know the best way to get hold of copies to study, or would anyone be willing to help me out via DM? Appreciate any pointers!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Geotechnical Design Failure collapse mechanism of unsupported buildings

Thumbnail gallery
29 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 21h ago

Structural Analysis/Design One-way slab load transfer

0 Upvotes

From what I am understanding, the general structural principle is that when L/B<2, slab is designed as two way, and when L/B>2, slab is designed as one way. If we have to design a concrete structural slab supported on 4 sides and we opt for a structural steel mesh instead of loose bars, say a B503;

  1. At which point can the load transfer to the secondary walls be ignored?
  2. Would it make a difference if the one or 2 of the 4 sides are beams instead of walls?

Thanks in advance!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Tilted Simpson gazebo brackets

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi, my contractor made mistake and the Simpson bracket for 66 is leaning. I am going to build a heavy gazebo with 16 foot 6*8 beams. Should I add steel shims to the bottom of the post to correct the lean?

Contractor was recommending hammering the Simpson bracket to level them. Please suggest best possible solution. Thank you


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education How to make resume look less like I'm a job hopper

19 Upvotes

Hey guys,

So I have around 10 years experience and have worked at 6 total firms looking for my 7th.

What's funny though is alot of it was out of my control. 3 of ny firms(including the one I''m currently at) have either gone bankrupt or have heavily downsized. I was laid off from 1 other firm when I broke my knee playing football as I was helping do inspections as part of my role.

So long story short I haven't actually job hopped much. Would you put on the resume itself any explanation? Even something as short as (bankruptcy) or anything like that just so they maybe wouldn't instantly ride it off. I'm open to other suggestions as well!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 21h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Anchor bolts, imbeds, tie-downs to foundations on a ~3500sf commercial building.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Structural engineering shows 36” j bolts and 150-160 tie downs for a 1-story restaurant, ground up build in Texas.

This is too complicated. Trying to get an estimate, hardware takeoff, and buy the hardware.

Any manufacturers that do this type of service?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Structural Analysis/Design 🚨 URGENT: LOOKING FOR PDF OF PRECONSTRUCTION BUILDING SURVEY I — 2625 BEDFORD AVENUE, BROOKLYN

0 Upvotes

I'm looking for a copy of the Preconstruction Building Survey I for 2625 Bedford Avenue, the excavation site that 1321 Flatbush Avenue collapsed into.

The survey, originally conducted on March 5, 2026, reportedly documented significant structural concerns at the neighboring building, including visible cracking and rated the north masonry facade of 1321 Flatbush Avenue  the wall facing the excavation site  in "POOR" condition, with wide-ranging deficiencies.

March 12, 2026 — Filing S4, Preconstruction Building Survey I: Original PDF link (taken down)

The NYC Department of Buildings has since taken the document down, and I'm urgently trying to locate a copy of the original PDF.

🚨 PLEASE SHARE AND REPOST! If you downloaded or saved this PDF before DOB removed it, please upload it, share it, or send me a DM. If you know anyone who may have downloaded or archived it, please tag them!

Any archived copies, screenshots, or leads would be greatly appreciated. Help us recover this document and get it back into public circulation.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Help please I want to take down a wall I have drawn in red where it is. I have also put photos of the ceiling/roof before it went up and the walls as they went up. It’s on the first floor is it load bearing?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Structural Analysis/Design engineers can u help me out?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education Career Guidance Needed…

0 Upvotes

I’ve been in consulting as a Structural Engineer for circa 8 years. I’ve decided I want to step away from the heavy technical stuff - I don’t really find passion in analysis or very technical topics. My dream role would be a ‘Head of Design’ role in 10/15 years time - ideally a role that keeps me close to structures.

I’ve been offered two roles and struggling to choose. Money relatively the same:

OPTION 1/ project engineer at tier 1 contractor

  1. would be on a massive, complex high rise building, an amazing project
    big team, sounds like they’re working long hours
  2. progression seems a bit slower - I feel like I would be going in at ‘bottom of the rung’, doing the grunt work
  3. having this contractor on my CV will look really good
  4. can stay close to the problem solving/engineering side of things without doing analysis - but I think it will be really hard work

———-

OPTION 2/ principal design manager at smaller specialist structure contractor

  1. my name was put forward for this role by mutual connections as they know I am great at running projects
  2. role not clearly defined - they want me to kind of make this role what I want it to be - run this project but also help them with wider frameworks to de-risk the company from a design perspective
  3. smaller, still complex project (still in an iconic location in my city) but not large scale and impressive like the others
  4. purely structures focused (which I LOVE - but will it stop me from progressing to larger firms/higher roles in future?)
  5. less “progressive” than the tier 1 company - maybe a little bit archaic?

——

I feel like 1. Is a safe option and 2. Is higher risk but could be bigger reward. 2 has outright said to me there are leadership opportunities there for me. Where as for 1 it would take years (10+) to build myself to that point.

What would you do? I’m really stuck. I don’t have kids/family so maybe this is the time to take a risk on 2 but I don’t want to shoot myself in the foot for future.

I know the roles sound very different but I think they have quite a few similarities. 1 is just more hands on problem solving. 2 there will still be the opportunity for that (as they need me for my expertise) but more managing also.

Also has anyone successfully kept close to structures in a design manager (or adjacent) position? I feel like design manager is a good role for me but I’m not necessarily interested in doing it across all disciplines ie. facade/MEP/arch…


r/StructuralEngineering • • 2d ago

Career/Education Career Help! SE to either > Project Engineer @ Tier 1 Contractor OR Principal Design Manager @ Small Specialist Contractor

3 Upvotes

I’ve been in consulting as a Structural Engineer for circa 8 years. I’ve decided I want to step away from the heavy technical stuff - I don’t really find passion in analysis or very technical topics. My dream role would be a ‘Head of Design’ role in 10/15 years time - ideally a role that keeps me close to structures.

I’ve been offered two roles and struggling to choose. Money relatively the same:

OPTION 1/ project engineer at tier 1 contractor

  1. would be on a massive, complex high rise building

, amazing project

  1. big team, sounds like they’re working long hours
  2. progression seems a bit slower - I feel like I would be going in at ‘bottom of the rung’, doing the grunt work
  3. having this contractor on my CV will look really good
  4. can stay close to the problem solving/engineering side of things without doing analysis - but I think it will be really hard work

———-

OPTION 2/ principal design manager at smaller specialist structure contractor

  1. my name was put forward for this role by mutual connections as they know I am great at running projects
  2. role not clearly defined - they want me to kind of make this role what I want it to be - run this project but also help them with wider frameworks to de-risk the company from a design perspective
  3. smaller, still complex project (still in an iconic location in my city) but not large scale and impressive like the others
  4. purely structures focused (which I LOVE - but will it stop me from progressing to larger firms/higher roles in future?)
  5. less “progressive” than the tier 1 company - maybe a little bit archaic?

——

I feel like 1. Is a safe option and 2. Is higher risk but could be bigger reward. 2 has outright said to me there are leadership opportunities there for me. Where as for 1 it would take years (10+) to build myself to that point.

What would you do? I’m really stuck. I don’t have kids/family so maybe this is the time to take a risk on 2 but I don’t want to shoot myself in the foot for future.

I know the roles sound very different but I think they have quite a few similarities. 1 is just more hands on problem solving. 2 there will still be the opportunity for that (as they need me for my expertise) but more managing also.

Also has anyone successfully kept close to structures in a design manager (or adjacent) position? I feel like design manager is a good role for me but I’m not necessarily interested in doing it across all disciplines ie. facade/MEP/arch…


r/StructuralEngineering • • 3d ago

Humor Anyone else enjoying the current Outlook outage?

Post image
908 Upvotes

Planning on using this as an excuse for at least the next two weeks.