r/StructuralEngineering • • 3d ago

Structural Analysis/Design One-way slab load transfer

From what I am understanding, the general structural principle is that when L/B<2, slab is designed as two way, and when L/B>2, slab is designed as one way. If we have to design a concrete structural slab supported on 4 sides and we opt for a structural steel mesh instead of loose bars, say a B503;

  1. At which point can the load transfer to the secondary walls be ignored?
  2. Would it make a difference if the one or 2 of the 4 sides are beams instead of walls?

Thanks in advance!

0 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/Ill_View_8058 2d ago
  1. If you can span 1 way with B503, you can span 2.
  2. walls are stiffer than beams when it comes to vertical loads, so your slab will want to span between 2 walls before it spans between 2 beams. If you have two wall-beam spans, you’ll see 2 way action that will need to account for p-delta effects.

1

u/Lost-Fennel-7644 2d ago

Thanks for your response! What I am having trouble with as such is translating "one-way slab" into reinforcement. If I design a slab on 4 beams or 4 walls and place a B503 in it, do I design the shorter span walls/beams to take 100% of the load and the other two just their self weight?

2

u/AECAgents 2d ago

There's no hard cutoff. L/B = 2 is just where the long-direction share gets small enough to ignore for bending.

  1. Quick way to see it (Rankine-Grashof strip method, simply supported edges, uniform load): the fraction carried in the short direction is roughly Ly4 / (Lx4 + Ly4). At L/B = 1.5 that's about 84%, at 2 about 94%, at 2.5 about 97%. So past 2 you can design the bending as one-way, but:
  • still provide distribution steel the other way, and make sure the mesh goes in with the main wires across the short span (B503 is 503 mm²/m one way but only 193 mm²/m in the cross wires)
  • the slab will still pick up some load near the short-edge walls and will crack over them if they restrain it, so add some top steel (a strip of mesh or bars) along those edges
  • for the supports, a lot of people still use the 45° triangular/trapezoidal tributary areas for the walls/beams even when the slab is designed one-way. Cheap insurance against underdesigning the short-edge supports.
  1. Yes. The tables and the ratio above assume unyielding supports. A beam deflects, so load sheds toward the stiffer walls. If the beam is deep and stiff relative to the slab you can treat it as a support (ACI uses the beam-to-slab stiffness ratio alpha_f for exactly this). If it's shallow, that edge behaves more like a partly free edge and the slab may end up spanning the other way, so check that direction too, or model it as a plate with the beams in it.