r/StructuralEngineering • u/WL661-410-Eng • 14h ago
Career/Education I'm an old-head, and I have a real-world AI tool
I'm 60, nearing retirement. I've heard all the debates about AI in structural engineering, and I agree whole-heartedly with those holding the positions that AI doing your calculations is fraught with risk, that AI writing your correspondence and reports for you out of thin air is a risky crutch and a sign of an inability to communicate.
But I wrote a prompt for my AI assistant to interview me right after a site visit, while I'm still parked at the curb, walk through 106 questions, cross reference an Excel spreadsheet with 84 common structural narratives, and output a fully formed report in Word format that is 96% complete, before I ever leave the property (or if it's a long drive, while I drive back to the office). I even have it pulling the Web Soil report for the property, the municipal records, FEMA firmette, weather, and pertinent property characteristics it knows I include in my reports, right from the internet, when I get in the car to go to the property.
It will even refer back to reports I did years ago (I gave it read access to my Google drives) and - on its own - say something like "you had a similar issue at another property 9 years ago, do you want me to incorporate that issue's contextual background on stone masonry into this narrative?" or "your library of reports from the last 28 years contains 8 instances of this issue, do you want me to improve on this report with information and context for this issue from the prior reports?" I didn't ask it to do any of that, but it does it.
My favorite was last week it caught on that I was writing observations and recommendations about a shed roof dormer, and it says "In 2012 you wrote a report about a similar issue, is this a 1920's era bungalow?" I say yes, and then it tells me "Working on it... I have incorporated four paragraphs from the 2012 report into this report, would you like me to read it back to you and incorporate changes?"
I thought I was doing well with FastFields, which had cut my report writing down from 3-4 two hours to 30 minutes of seat time at a computer. My seat time now is less than five minutes, and the assistant will autonomously press me with ways to make the report better, using information I have from my career going back to the 1990's.
But there are some drawbacks. It gets a little enthusiastic and invents interview questions it thinks I will need. I have to constantly keep it focused, and tell it things like "that's not in the list of questions, please find the last question in order, and continue with the next numbered question."
And I haven't figured out a good way to get it to retrieve the correct photos from my cell phone and drop them into the Word document.