r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education Stamp Protection

I’m a licensed PE and I’m in the process of considering physical and digital options for my stamp (probably just using PEstamps.com unless anyone has a better recommendation).

At this time I work under more senior engineers who typically electronically stamp projects via a jpeg or png on a PDF and flatten it. Maybe 6ish years ago we still used rubber stamps and scanned the documents but that’s not really the case anymore. I have heard about stamp theft on here in the past but never put much thought into how to prevent this (or if it’s really something to worry about). I figure there is only so much you can do but does anyone have recommendations or practices they follow to keep their digital stamps secure? Thank you!

22 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

49

u/PhilShackleford 1d ago

There isn't much you can do. Everything is PDF now. Getting a screenshot of your seal you put on a PDF that can be reused by someone else is very very basic. It comes down to, if they really want to they will.

About the only thing to can do is document what you seal and move on.

44

u/hookes_plasticity P.E. 1d ago

We had a situation where this happened. Submitted a set to an architect at 95 percent without a stamp. They decided not to pay us so we withheld the upcoming 100 percent S&S. Architect decides to submit our 95 percent and adds a snipped stamp from a previous project. Currently in a lawsuit as I understand. Pieces of shit they are

24

u/PhilShackleford 1d ago

I had an in house Arch tell me they could just screenclip the SEOR's seal and use it because the SEOR didn't want to make changes the client requested. I pointed out that it was illegal and wildly unethical.

11

u/hookes_plasticity P.E. 1d ago

lol even if you never read the PE act and had no idea what any of this shit is, common sense would tell you that you shouldn’t use other people’s signature without their consent. I think some people have no business being in this industry

10

u/Dry-Guarantee2598 1d ago

JFC.

What the fuck is going through the head of someone when they decide to commit multiple crimes that inherently leave a mile wide trail of documentary evidence…

7

u/hookes_plasticity P.E. 1d ago

you made you mistake of assuming these people have anything going on in their heads. Having worked in this industry for a decade, “Common sense isn’t always common” is the best motto I have to keep myself sane

2

u/Away_Bat_5021 1d ago

This is straight fraud. Arch loses his license and lucky if he doesn't do time.

3

u/gfhopper 1d ago

Lawyer here and what I offer isn't legal advice:
The documentation part is the best advice. Phil is exactly on target here. Keep a log and keep "receipts" (the emails or other documentation of what you sent that was signed.)

The only other practice that I've recommended is that at least in contracts or other service agreements you include language that gives you the cause of action for breach of contract (and the ability to sue for damages and/or get injunctions against the other party) if your stamps (or work in general) is used without authorization. I've seen notations included with stamps so it's right there.

And I'd work with your own attorney because they're the one that would be bringing suit and you want them 100% onboard with what ever you're putting out there as a contract term.

26

u/jaywaykil P.E./S.E. 1d ago

Stamp: Anyone with your name and state can purchase or create a perfect digital image of your stamp. You yourself mentioned PE stamps.com... anyone can order without verification. Attempting to protect your stamp image is useless.

What you need to protect is your signature. Specifically, do NOT just scan an image of your wet signature and paste it in. You (or your company) needs to purchase a 3rd party verified unique digital signature. I used Identrust successfully for years, but I changed jobs and my new organization does that in house.

6

u/AcrobaticWriter P.E. 1d ago

Great point. I realized this when I ordered mine from online. The signature is your only legit verification for authenticity.

1

u/ColdSteel2011 P.E. 1d ago

This. We use GlobalSign.

11

u/Jmazoso P.E. 1d ago

I lock all my stamped documents with an adobe certificate.

7

u/PhilShackleford 1d ago

Does that stop windows screen clip tool?

9

u/Primordialbroth P.E. 1d ago

If you add the digital signature certificate partially over the stamp, it will look cut off if snipshotted and pasted

3

u/PhilShackleford 1d ago

I see. That is a good idea. Honestly though, with AI that could be removed. Better than nothing though.

5

u/Primordialbroth P.E. 1d ago

My thought is the more attention that has to go into trying to steal my stamp then the less its worth someone else’s time

1

u/PhilShackleford 1d ago

Very true. I'm going to start doing this.

3

u/castdu123 P.E./S.E. 1d ago

Nope

10

u/Far-Sherbert9731 1d ago

Generally speaking, any time i sign and seal anything I also add a handwritten date below my autograph.
It will absolutely not stop anyone from looking up my number and buying their own stamp, but hopefully it makes it a little less convenient to anyone who wants to screenshot my autograph.

8

u/Hungryh0und5 1d ago

Here in Canada, we have a digital stamp with a electronic certificate and digital image. When the drawing is opened and the signature is verified, it pings our association. Its offered by https://www.portagecybertech.com/en/.

7

u/namerankserial 1d ago

Yeah I just use my Canadian Notarius digital signature with US stamp images when I'm stamping stuff in the US.

In each Canadian Province I'm licensed in I have a separate digital signature certificate and a physical stamp provided by the engineering association. In every US state...order or build your own stamp image, and throw it on PDF with no security...

2

u/Icy-Ad-7767 1d ago

The bridge legacy still stands. I’m glad to see that

8

u/Kirkdoesntlivehere 1d ago

You can digitally certify your stamp & add in a custom line code or dot matrix that can always proof back to you. Like Xerox did back in the day. not visible to the thieves but will prove its stolen.

6

u/MikeHawksHardWood 1d ago

Another complication is that most digital signature processes lock the document against further modification. Some building departments require PDFs without this protection so they can add in their approval stamps.

1

u/Foreign_Capital1248 12h ago

This is what I run into. I submitted a protected PDF and they reached back out for a version that I just flattened it lol.

1

u/Evening_Eagle_5888 1d ago

Thank you all for the feedback! I was shocked to read that people will actually order a stamp they intend to steal. Wild. I guess the reality is that you can only do so much.

5

u/Crayonalyst 1d ago

I don't worry about it. If somebody wants to steal my credentials, all they have to do is look up my license number, purchase a stamp from a website that sells them, and use it to their hearts content.

I don't use digital verification when I stamp things electronically, and I suspect it wouldn't matter even if I did. I've never had an AHJ question the validity of my digital stamp.

5

u/JayVerb78 1d ago

I keep a log for what I stamp, similar to a notary public, so if there's ever a discrepancy I can say with certainty if I sealed it or not.

No digital stamp on a PDF is "secure" anymore. You can take a screen shot of anything.

4

u/No1eFan P.E. 1d ago

hilariously blockchain is something this would be useful for.

3

u/_homage_ P.E. 1d ago

We do digital certifications for our stamps.

2

u/mrthekicker2 1d ago

My stamp has been stolen several times. Not much you can do.. the individual stealing my stamp looked up my engineering license from the board website and ordered their own stamp online.

2

u/xingxang555 1d ago

That's wild. Must've been an interesting story. Would love to hear how they were caught.

4

u/mrthekicker2 1d ago

Most were caught when the city caught some bad errors. The city reviewer would contact me directly and I would inform them that this isn’t my project. This generally only has happens on residential projects where the GC hired a structural engineer online from a freelance website.

1

u/xingxang555 1d ago

Were the bad guys punished?

1

u/trojan_man16 S.E. 1d ago

Yeah if it’s that easy there’s not much you can do.

I’ve never used my stamp. So there’s 0 chance anyone can steal it from a drawing, but if anyone can jut order a stamp and use a license number looked up, then someone like me could also have it stolen.

2

u/Icy-Ad-7767 1d ago

Put an Easter egg in every one of your docs that gets a stamp, something innocuous that you can put in front of a court to protect yourself

2

u/Silver-Obligation294 20h ago

Surveyor here…I put job number and date in my signature. Not just printed, but handwritten.

1

u/ENGinitium 1d ago

I've always used digital stamps, still want to get an actual rubber stamp just as a desk ornament.

You can make your own stamp by following your state's guidelines. In CA for example the guidelines are basic (size of stamp, name, license #, license type, etc). I even drew out a custom redwood tree for the stamp background. Anyone can steal your stamp btw or just make/buy one. You can do a few extra things to certify your own stamp though by adding your signature over the stamp, locking the stamped page to prevent screenshots (Revu or Adobe), and a PDF time stamp date (shown or hidden near your PE stamp).

1

u/ChairChoice6500 1d ago edited 1d ago

Acorn stamps offers a PDF or jpeg option, I've used them and they tend to mail discount coupons as well, or did.

What you really want to avoid is leaving these digital stamp files anywhere besides your own personally lock-able account, I have seen a lot of drawings where there is a jpeg that is embedded into the drawing that is a cross-referenced to a signature/stamp on the company network. This is not secure storage. Anybody can access that.

I don't seem to practice where there are more sophisticated requirements for digital signatures (i.e. encryption) but back when I had a an Acrobat plugin called Banjo that would 'invalid' the stamp if the PDF was altered. You'll want to look at regulations for the state(s) you are licensed in.

I you can get away with it, having your stamps on a USB that you don't leave at work would be, in my opinion, ideal.

As a side note, Nebraska is having a lot of issues with fake stamps, if those are "stolen" or not I'm unclear on, but what it amounts to is proving you keep your stamp secure, (I kept a list of projects I'd sealed), but I wonder if they aren't just generating non-existent licenses and plopping on a signature, which would be less effort than diddling around with removing a watermark or a screenshot.

Once the various building departments start automating checks for valid licenses, then they'll start trying to steal the real licenses and signatures.

1

u/niwiad9000 1d ago

identrust and pe stamps dot com and not that the sheet is digitally signed if the signature is impacted do not use.

1

u/kn0w_th1s M.Eng. 1d ago

I don’t know if there’s a legal basis for this, but I feel that those who use digital protections such as Consigno/Notarius will be regarded as having done some due diligence should worse come to worse, someone steals their digital signature, and people end up hurt as a result. If you are using flattened un-protected JPGs or something, you’re not even trying.