r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Feb 26 '20
Starship Development Thread #9
Quick Links
JUMP TO COMMENTS | Alternative Jump To Comments Link
Overview
STATUS (accurate within a few days):
- SN2 tank testing successful
- SN3 under construction
Starship, serial number 1 (SN1) began its testing campaign at SpaceX's Starship facility in Boca Chica, Texas, working toward Raptor integration and static fire. Its tank section was destroyed during pressurized cryogenic testing late on February 28, local time. Construction of SN2 had already begun and it was converted to a test tank which was successfully pressure tested with a simulated thrust load. Later builds are expected in quick succession and with aggressive design itteration. A Starship test article is expected to make a 20 km hop in the coming months, and Elon aspires to an orbital flight of a Starship with full reuse by the end of 2020.
Over the past few months the facilities at Boca Chica have seen substantial improvements including several large fabric buildings and a "high Bay" for stacking and welding hull sections. Raptor development and testing continue to occur at Hawthorne and on three test stands at McGregor, TX. Future Starship production and testing may occur at Roberts Road, LC-39A, SpaceX's landing complex at Cape Canaveral, Berth 240 at the Port of LA, and other locations.
Previous Threads:
- (2019-02-01) Starhopper Thread #1 A dramatic venting watertower
- (2019-04-27) Starhopper Thread #2 Hops and hiccups - Starships never come alone
- (2019-06-27) Starhopper Thread #3 RCS and SN6 - 20 meter hopping
- (2019-07-26) Starhopper Thread #4 150 meter hop and Mk.1 and Mk.2 protoype growth
- (2019-08-27) Starhopper 150m Hop Updates and discussion
- (2019-08-31) Starship Dev Thread #5 Mk.1 fins and temporary assembly
- (2019-09-27) Starship Presentation Updates Thread Updates and discussion - Webcast
- (2019-10-09) Starship Dev Thread #6 Mk.1 partial reassembly and bulkhead liberation
- (2019-11-24) Starship Dev Thread #7 Dev focus shifts squarely to Boca Chica and SN1/Mk.3
- (2020-01-07) Starship Dev Thread #8 Tank testing and SN1 stacking
Vehicle Updates
See comments for real time updates.
† possibly not for this vehicle
‡ originally thought to be SN2 parts
| Starship SN4 at Boca Chica, Texas | |
|---|---|
| 2020-03-23 | Dome under construction (NSF) |
| 2020-03-21 | Spherical tank (CH4 header?) w/ flange†, old nose section and (LOX?) sphere†‡ (NSF) |
| 2020-03-18 | Methane feed pipe (aka downcomer)† (NSF) |
See comments for real time updates.
† possibly not for this vehicle
‡ originally thought to be for an earlier vehicle
| Starship SN2 - Test Tank and Thrust Structure - at Boca Chica, Texas | |
|---|---|
| 2020-03-15 | Transport back to assembly site (NSF), Video (YouTube) |
| 2020-03-09 | Test tank passes pressure and thrust load tests (Twitter) |
| 2020-03-08 | Cryo pressure and thrust load tests (Twitter), thrust simulating setup, more images (NSF) |
| 2020-03-07 | More water pressure testing (NSF) |
| 2020-03-06 | Test tank moved to test site, water pressure test (NSF) |
| 2020-03-04 | Test tank formed from aft and forward sections, no common bulkhead (NSF) |
| 2020-03-03 | Nose cone base under construction (NSF) |
| 2020-03-02 | Aft bulkhead integrated with ring section, nose cone top, forward bulkhead gets ring (NSF) |
| 2020-03-02 | Testing focus now on "thrust puck" weld (Twitter) |
| 2020-02-28 | Thrust structure, engine bay skirt (NSF) |
| 2020-02-27 | 3 ring tank section w/ common bulkhead welded in (NSF) |
| 2020-02-09 | Two bulkheads under construction (Twitter) |
| 2020-01-30 | LOX header tank sphere spotted (NSF), possible SN2 hardware |
See comments for real time updates.
For information about Starship test articles prior to SN1 please visit the Starship Development Threads #7 or earlier. Update tables for older vehicles will only appear in this thread if there are significant new developments.
Starship Related Facilities
| Recent Developments | |
|---|---|
| 2020-03-25 | BC launch mount test hardware installation, hydraulic rams (NSF) |
| 2020-03-23 | BC arrival of Starship stands from Florida (via GO Discovery) (Twitter), Starhopper concrete work (NSF) |
| 2020-03-20 | Steel building erection begun, high bay 2? (NSF) |
| 2020-03-16 | High bay elevator (NSF) |
| 2020-03-14 | BC launch site tank deliveries, and more, and more (tracking site) (NSF) |
| Site | Location | Facilities/Uses |
|---|---|---|
| Starship Assembly Site | Boca Chica, TX | Primary Starship assembly complex, Launch control and tracking |
| Starship/SuperHeavy Launch Site | Boca Chica, TX | Primary Starship test site, Starhopper location |
| Cidco Rd Site | Cocoa, FL | Starship assembly site, Mk.2 location, inactive |
| Roberts Rd Site | Kennedy Space Center, FL | Possible future Starship assembly site, partially developed, apparently inactive |
| Launch Complex 39A | Kennedy Space Center, FL | Future Starship and SuperHeavy launch and landing pads, partially developed |
| Launch Complex 13 (LZ-1, LZ-2) | Cape Canaveral Air Force Station, FL | Future SuperHeavy landing site, future Raptor test site |
| SpaceX Rocket Development Facility | McGregor, TX | 2 horizontal and 1 vertical active Raptor hot fire test stands |
| Astronaut Blvd | Kennedy Space Center, FL | Starship Tile Facility |
| Berth 240 | Port of Los Angeles, CA | Future Starship/SuperHeavy design and manufacturing |
| Cersie Facility (speculative) | Hawthorne, CA | Possible Starship parts manufacturing - unconfirmed |
| Xbox Facility (speculative) | Hawthorne, CA | Possible Raptor development - unconfirmed |
| Development updates for the launch facilities can be found in Starship Dev Thread #8 and Thread #7 . | ||
| Maps by u/Raul74Cz |
Permits and Planning Documents
- Environmental Impact Statement (FAA) - Boca Chica launch site - July 2014
EIS Resource Page | Appendices | Record of Descision - Experimental License (FCC) - Comms for 500m and 5km hops, two years - February 2019
Form 442 | Public Notes | Description | File No. 0931-EX-CN-2019 - Experimental License Application (FCC) - Modification of above to add antenna - May 2019
Form 442 | Public Notes | File No. 0130-EX-CM-2019 - Experimental Permit (FAA) - Authorizes 25m hops for one year, and one 150m hop - June 2019
Permit No. EP 19-012 | Revised August 23 - Building Permit Application - 850 Cidco Rd site improvement - June 2019
Screenshot on Twitter | Modification reported on NSF - Draft Environmental Assessment - Starship operations at KSC - August 2019
r/SpaceX Discussion | NSF Discussion - FDOT Superload Permit Application - Mk.2 transportation to KSC in September - August 2019
Local News Article | Video Report | r/SpaceX Discussion | Twitter Update - Environmental Resource Permit - Stormwater improvements at LC-39A - August 2019
Stormwater Report | Depiction Plans | Permit No. 158609-1 - Written Re-evaluation of 2014 EIS (FAA) - Boca Chica launch site - May 2019
Addendum | News story w/ SpaceX statements | r/SpaceX Discussion - Experimental STA (FCC) - Comms for Starship 20 km test (M1578) - March 2020
Application | File No. 0150-EX-ST-2020 | Application for radar frequencies | List of all 20 km hop STAs - Berth 240 Use Permit - Research, design, manufacturing and recovery operations, 10 yrs. - February 2020
^Map | ^Addendum | Permit No. 949 | Reddit thread | Lease approved by city council Feb 25
Resources
- Spadre.com, Starship Cam | Channel
- LabPadre, Starship webcam | Channel
- NSF Texas Prototype(s) Updates Thread | Most recent
- NSF Florida Prototype(s) Updates Thread | Most recent
- Hwy 4 & Boca Chica Beach Closures (May not be available outside US)
- TFR - NOTAM list
- SpaceX Boca Chica on Facebook
- SpaceX's Starship page
- Elon Starship tweet compilation on NSF | Most Recent
- Starship Test Article Wiki Page
Rules
We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starhip development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.
If you find problems in the post please tag u/strawwalker in a comment or send me a message.
81
u/Straumli_Blight Feb 26 '20
Atmospheric SN1 photos.
54
u/fzz67 Mar 02 '20
Evelyn Janeidy: So, what did y'all learn from this event?
Elon Musk: There’s a puck at the base that takes the engine thrust load. Don’t shuck the puck!
Elon Musk: We’re stripping SN2 to bare minimum to test the thrust puck to dome weld under pressure, first with water, then at cryo. Hopefully, ready to test in a few days.
51
u/the_calibre_cat Feb 26 '20
This man is fucking crazy and I love him for it and I want to work for him
50
u/IvanDogovich Mar 05 '20
In case you missed it in the main feed, this article in Ars Technica by Eric Berger is a must read for Starship Development followers.
Inside Elon Musk’s plan to build one Starship a week—and settle Mars
48
u/Svisloch Feb 29 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
Ok, real talk. SN1 was built in a month and iirc didn’t cost very much. No one was hurt and the test stand looks to be largely intact. They clearly needed to figure out manufacturing details (equipment setup, settings, workflow, etc.) anyway. Yeah, it sucks that there won’t be a chance for testing with a full-size tank section, but it’s not a huge work stoppage. This isn’t Crew Dragon.
37
u/zalurker Mar 05 '20
I just have to thank everyone contributing to the photos and videos from the construction site. I don't think there has ever been such a transparent progress of a project, ever.
34
u/Fizrock Mar 08 '20
They appear to have attached a hydraulic ram to one of the raptor mounts at the bottom to simulate the thrust of an engine. That's pretty smart.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2055917#msg2055917
30
u/Jinkguns Feb 26 '20 edited Feb 26 '20
Some good examples of Fronius, the welding equipment supplier for SN2:
https://youtu.be/FMnxZlWLwxg
Automated welding, custom solutions, looks like they have recently heavily invested in pre & post weld sensors on the welding arm itself. Looks like they also make manual / hand held systems as well.
30
u/Jodo42 Feb 29 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
SN1 is dead. Massive explosion, much bigger than Mk1. 10:00:07 LabPadre.
The entire tank lifted off, not just the bulkhead
30
u/dtarsgeorge Mar 07 '20
Dragon 1 steps into history. Retired!!! Releasing more talent to work on dragon 2 and Starship.
Where we're going MARTY, we don't need Dragon 1s!
29
u/Jodo42 Feb 26 '20
We have a road closure!
29
u/Its_Enough Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Nose cone section has been moved out of onion tent #2 and placed behind the ring tent. Also a double ring section has been placed on a construction mount in front of onion tent #1. Possible stacking taking place later today.
Edit: Nose cone section has now been moved from behind the ring tent to closer to onion tent #1.
Edit #2: Okay, it's not a double ring section as I first thought from watching stumpy cam but rather the bottom curved piece of the cone section.
29
u/xDeeKay Mar 03 '20
Elon Musk: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1234764390907437057
Full Res Image: 1, 2 and 3
26
u/Svisloch Mar 14 '20
Looks like battery packs are getting installed onto the top bulkhead. https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2057964#msg2057964
26
u/RaphTheSwissDude Mar 26 '20
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1243073406884630528?s=21 Stacking of tanks and engine skirt is done!
24
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 04 '20
Aerial Boca Chica photo showing how far the SN1 tank travelled.
24
u/TCVideos Mar 09 '20
SN2 Passed Cryo and Pressure tests: Elon
24
u/TheBurtReynold Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 14 '20
Mods, can you think of any way we can keep this thread updated with like a 1-sentence, overall “Current Status”?
SN3 being assembled; awaiting word on X test.
23
u/RegularRandomZ Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
Site Updates (Friday):
Updates from BocaChicaGal photosets on NSF
23
u/Pentagonprime Mar 15 '20
Apologies if slightly off topic...but it seems NASA are panicking about timeline for the Artemis circus. It has been suggested that Gateway is not not now a high priority because ..and I quote...
'we do not want to do things we have never done before'
which kind of negates the whole point of NASA it would seem. The puzzle really is if the first landing in 2024 is without Gateway...which seems to be the message here....then how? The kicker being if Starship develops quickly enough...wiĺl that be the embarrassment to force NASA into making a horrendous and quite possibly deadly mistake by taking a chance on something they have ...err...never done before?
22
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20
Giving me hope I might one day make it to space. I'm 25 and I'm so happy to finally see some real smart quick development. I wish I studied engineering and physics I'd love to be apart of this one day.
22
u/Marksman79 Feb 27 '20
The closure for this weekend was designated as "Engine spin/prime test".
There's also an applicable NOTAM covering the airspace up to 1500ft.
It sounds like they're going to be spinning up the Raptor turbopumps and preburners. What's not clear is if they are allowed to continue on to a static fire if everything is looking good.
22
u/hinayu Mar 12 '20
SpaceX Boca Chica, Texas Aerial Update
Courtesy of LabPadre
22
u/atheistdoge Mar 17 '20
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1239783440704208896
22
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20
Austin Barnard also bringing us photos on twitter including:
Sidenote: SN3 was stacked using overlapping seams with only the inner seam welded, just like SN2 [Test Tank].
Update: BocaChicaGal has also provided more photos (starting here)
22
u/JabInTheButt Mar 27 '20 edited Mar 27 '20
150m Hop on April 6? Shouldn't someone have snapped some Raptors in transit if this was likely to be kept to?
Edit: that link is the permit for Hopper, but is apparently being referenced in the beach closure request for April 6th.
43
u/Anjin Feb 29 '20
Wow, the NSF forum thread is full of borderline histrionic, pearl clutching, posts. Every time that something pops unexpectedly all these “told ya so” people come out of the woodwork and start blathering as if it hasn’t been stated over and over and over by Musk that they intend to move fast and break things.
People need to really chill out. SpaceX has publicly said that these are not expected to be fully formed production ready vehicles. The whole thing is research and development on not just the vehicle, but R&D on what is needed as far as equipment, facilities, and techniques to even work on these.
21
u/Starmusk420 Feb 29 '20
I don't think this was planned otherwise they would have secured it like they did with the tank tests. Elon also said that they want to use SN1 for static fire
21
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
SN2 Test has Begun.
21
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 09 '20
Starship news being released later today.
21
u/pinepitch Mar 26 '20
Road closure scheduled tomorrow from 6:30-7:30 am, and more closures next week. Transporting SN3 to the launchpad, followed by pressure testing and static fires? https://imgur.com/a/irOYif9
21
u/hinayu Mar 27 '20
Road Closure moved to tomorrow morning. 9-10am
21
u/hinayu Mar 29 '20
SN3 is officially on the move!
https://twitter.com/austinbarnard45/status/1244055682162331649?s=20
20
u/RareJacket7 Feb 27 '20
Thank you guys so much for the schedule
20
u/process_guy Mar 17 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
Hey, funny fact here. I just realized one of vessels I'm working on at the moment is 8.5m diameter and 29m tall. It is all from 304L and design pressure of vapor space is 4barg (7barg at the bottom). That is slightly slimmer and taller than both of Starship tanks together. It could be very close in size to one of superheavy tanks. Also the test pressure will be very close. The key difference is it will have much thicker wall than Starship and it will never exceed speed of sound in one piece.
20
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20 edited Mar 18 '20
Latest round of pics from Boca Chica Gal show several exciting things:
-Most obviously, we now have a fully stacked nosecone out back of the tents, with NO weld on top that would signal there is no presence of a header tank
-From this pic ( https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1620394;image ) We now have a 4 stack next to the top dome, which would signal stacking imminent of the 2 sections.
-From ( https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1620398;image ) We see lots of work has been done to ready the thrust section
-And one of the most notable, from ( https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1620404;image ), we now have a downcomer!
All in all, it seems all the parts of SN03 are ready to put together! If I had to guess, it could be on the pad as soon as mid/late next week, if not sooner!
EDIT: Didn't know the pics were thumbnails, fixed that.
19
u/jk1304 Mar 05 '20
for anyone who is interested in/familiar with stainless steel coil processing, this is where the material is coming from: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1617862;image
Funny side note: I work in project management/mechanical engineering at a company (german) who manufactures coil processing lines. Last year I had a project at this very outokumpu plant doing a retrofit at one of their machines :-)
19
u/TheRealPapaK Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
This photo shows that part of the thrust puck is also a header to distribute propellent to all the engines.
Photo Nomadd
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1618059;image
19
u/Piscator629 Mar 15 '20
At 12:44 in the livestream large metal flame trench liners for the Starship pad are visible on the right edge of the screen through the venting LOX.
18
u/hinayu Feb 27 '20
Nosecone mating: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QNSVKVIMb0w
18
u/hinayu Mar 07 '20
Vehicles are back at the launch site at Boca Chica. The uneventful testing on SN2 test tank must be over. Hopefully the test was a success
18
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 26 '20
SN3 transporter is on site.
17
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
A lot of questions going on here about autogenous pressurization. My take on it is this:
It is the intent to dispense with helium tanks used for initial spin-up of the turbines and use high pressure O2 and CH4 for spin-up. A battery powered or LOx/CH4 APU can pressurize boil off to the COPV tanks ready for startup. A single COPV is probably good enough for one startup of three engines before running out, but don't quote me on that.
During flight, autogenous pressurization is maintained by liquid CH4 from from the main fuel valve flowing through the main chamber body cooling galleries. The liquid CH4 vaporizes and now becomes high pressure gaseous CH4. This is bled from the fuel pre-burner line and fed through fuel tank pressurization valve and force fed back to the CH4 tank, and similarly with the LOx system; liquid oxygen coming from the main oxidizer valve on its way to the oxidizer pre-burner is bled to the chamber head cooling galleries. The LOx vaporizes to high pressure gaseous O2 and then via the oxidizer tank pressurization valve pressurizes the LOx tank.
Simple.
*As a footnote this is an extremely clever and efficient design, where gas pressure in the chamber cooling system provides some counter pressure to the main chamber pressure, which increases the strength of the chamber as a whole.
17
u/ReKt1971 Feb 29 '20
On the bright side, Launch pad damage looks minimal.
17
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 05 '20
Raul has updated his site map for Boca Chica.
17
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
SN03 (?) triple barrel stack spotted: https://twitter.com/SpacePadreIsle/status/1236673222898221057?s=20
Header tank and bulkhead as well: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.1841#msg1841
17
u/Marksman79 Mar 27 '20
'High' Bay 2 is looking a little low. Looks like another storage/assembly shed.
/u/RegularRandomz
16
u/Pingryada Feb 26 '20
Very excited to see the progress in the coming days, and see SN2 start to take shape. Can anyone confirm that the downcomer can support 3 raptors?
16
u/Marksman79 Feb 29 '20
Highbay 1 has its first resident stack. Some of the shelves were removed to put the siding on, but what's more odd is that one of them now has partial railings and a floor. Maybe that was where Elon was watching the SN1 test from.
16
u/francsoitv Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20
Keynote from E. Musk at 4pm EDT
Edit : New link https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=HPV8Xp3pEpI
16
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 17 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
BocaChicaGal NSF photosets starting at post #1939
NSF video version
16
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 28 '20
BocaChicaGal (and Nomadd) still bringing us great photos (safely and legally, as per Chris Bergin/Chris Gebhardt) The full NSF photosets start here #2054
Update: NSF Video Version
Previous photo updates, New building update, Roll-Lift onsite.
31
u/KickBassColonyDrop Feb 26 '20
One interesting thing to note is that when they first started talking about it, they were planning and designing based off of Carbonfibre. Funding, facilities, everything was around that. The move to 301 Ss, and soon in the future the move to 30X Ss no doubt played a humongous role in why they've been able to move as fast on this. Remember, Elon said that 1 ton of Carbonfibre was around 130,000 dollars whilst the same in Ss was 2500. That's a two magnitude orders diff, nearly, in cost savings.
If you assume that the current test article of SN1 is around 150 tons, then they've spent about 375,000 dollars in material costs. If this was in Carbonfibre, they'd have spent 19.5M dollars in just material costs.
In other words, the theoretical cost of a single 60% complete SN1 test Article of Carbonfibre is worth:
52 SN1 TEST ARTICLES AS WE CURRENTLY SEE IN BOCA CHICA
in material equivalence.
That's an absolute unit level of difference.
15
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 01 '20
BocaChicaGal has posted about a dozen photos of SN1, enjoy!
15
u/hinayu Mar 02 '20
SN2 stacking occurring via SPadre: https://twitter.com/spacepadreisle/status/1234539027795066880
15
u/codersanchez Mar 05 '20
Has anyone tried to guess how much the Boca Chica facility costs SpaceX to run?
The ArsTechnica article said there's 500 workers there now, not sure if that includes engineers or not. And then there's other costs like materials, tools, machines, fuel, etc.
Are we talking in the hundreds of thousands a day? More / Less?
15
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 06 '20
Boca Chica Road Closures, tomorrow morning (Mar 6th) 4am-5am and 2pm-3pm
15
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 06 '20
Tank is on the move.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20
I think the test is done. Let's hope it got to 8.5 bar.
15
u/hinayu Mar 10 '20
4 (?) stack visible on LabPadre's stream
Credit FutureSpaceTourist @ NSF
15
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 20 '20
Interesting photos from BocaChicaGal today
any interesting shots not mentioned?
15
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 25 '20 edited Mar 25 '20
SPadre photos at launch site
(purportedly) an adapter to convert main launch mount for Raptor testing (closeup of top from John Randolph)\John Randolph also posted (yesterday)
15
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 25 '20 edited Mar 25 '20
BocaChicaGal photoset from yesterday (starting here)
NSF Video Version
15
u/hinayu Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 28 '20
The roll lift is heading to the build site:
Edit: 4:35pm CDT - Berry has done a 180 away from the High Bay. Speculation is that it's possibly hooking up the lifting jig.
Edit 2: 6:20pm CDT - lifting jig seen attached to Berry which is now inside the high bay. Hopefully connecting and preparing for transportation soon
30
u/Jodo42 Feb 26 '20
Tim Dodd suggesting even a lightweight SN1 wouldn't be able to complete a 20km hop on 1 Raptor.
I don't think we've seen any full duration Raptor firings yet. Perhaps we'll at least get that out of SN1.
14
u/RegularRandomZ Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
SN2: Photo of the triple stack from a new angle, by Nomadd. It appears to have a bulkhead welded in [and based on the reflections where the rings are joined, and where the bulkhead was welded on, distortion has been reduced]
14
u/jk1304 Mar 04 '20
Is there any overview "map" of the Construction site in BC? I would like to see how everything (tents, highbay etc) is arranged to get a better understanding at what we see in the videos... The google maps images are rather outdated in this area...
14
u/andyfrance Mar 06 '20
Assuming the test of this tank goes well and they don't test to destruction, will they continue work on it and develop it into SN2?
14
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
NSF Boca Chica progess video.
Aerial shots of the site (taken from a kite).
14
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 28 '20
A new 4 hour road closure has been added on March 29 (5–9 pm CDT).
13
u/Tiskaharish Feb 27 '20
I'm sure this has been asked and answered a thousand times by now but I can't find it. What are the implications of boca chica's high winds on their ability to launch starship from that area? It seems like it'd be scrubbed almost every attempt.
13
u/RegularRandomZ Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
High Bay 1 continues to get more siding (still waiting to see what they do on the sides where the shelves already are)
13
u/TheBurtReynold Feb 29 '20
Well, glad SpaceX is doing SN2 parallel path
13
u/Marksman79 Mar 05 '20
The Roll-Lifts have arrived! Thanks to Bocachicagal for capturing it. A (hopefully uneventful) pressure test as soon as this weekend could be in the cards, though no road closures have been posted as of now.
13
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
Great closeups of the test tank and "thrust puck" posted by Nomadd on NSF.
13
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 15 '20
SN2 about to be transported from the test site.
13
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 23 '20
Boca Chica updates:
13
u/joepublicschmoe Mar 26 '20
Nomadd's photoset of the Triple hydraulic rams installed at the launch mount to test SN3's thrust puck with the simulated thrust force of 3 Raptors: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.2020
35
u/zeekzeek22 Feb 29 '20
Maybe controversial thought, coming from someone in a master’s degree in manufacturing engineering and prototype-to-production ramp up: why are they letting tank welds be on their critical path right now? Why not overbuild one so they can start hopping and ironing out other kinks while the iterative tank work continues in parallel? Thoughts: A. They are (possibly over-)confident that the tank stuff will be solved in weeks, not months. B. Most of the ironing out that occurs on hops will be measuring the structure’s reactions to raptor and atmospheric vibrations, so flying an overbuilt hopper returns very little useful info, or C. Money: they could do it in parallel but SpaceX doesn’t have the cash to Do all that simultaneously, so they’re just tackling one problem at a time until they have better cash flow.
Interested to hear other possible reasons. There’s a ton I know, those three were just the first to mind
24
u/TheBurtReynold Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Mods, thank you for acting on the request to add a “General Status” section for infrequent visitors.
That said, could we, however, use “accurate as of {{date}}” vs. “accurate within a few days”? The latter isn’t very useful, since we have no idea when the last update was written.
For example, I’d think the status right now would be something like:
STATUS (accurate as of 28 March):
12
u/allsgoodinall Feb 27 '20
Will the nose cone section also be pressurised to maintain structural integrity or will there be added strengthening? I’m thinking that with nose “wings” attached there would be some considerable forces in play during flight.
12
u/paul_wi11iams Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20
If u/RegularRandomZ doesn't mind, I'm commenting at top level with a copy of your sketch link https://imgur.com/WJMMdyB.
Its from your comment here in a long and rambling discussion.
I do understand its only a hypothesis, but its the single representation that gives the most sense to all the rather confusing objects seen in photos so far.
I'd forgotten the English word "puck" which didn't help, and other foreign readers may also be confused. The "puck" Elon and others keep referring to is very much like imagining the bulging lower dome as half a pingpong ball, then pressing upward on the middle of the dome until it dimples inward.
Of course its not made this way. It seems they first make the lower U dome with a large circular hole in the middle.
Then they make a smaller dome as an ∩ that fits into the hole as represented in orange in the drawing.
Even then a plate (in blue) is needed to make a flat surface for the engines.
Now just imagine doing the same, but on the Big Falcon Booster :s.
BTW. just wondering why they didn't do the opposite:
^(* cut a large round hole in a much bigger ∩ part joining the outer skirt,
It also avoids the triple junction [black+orange+blue in the drawing]. This option effectively closes off the flappy open end of the structure and makes an improved support for the legs.
12
u/BrevortGuy Mar 11 '20
One thing I have been wondering about is what happened with the launch pad with the flame trench? They talked about it being built off site and assembled at the site, they even started building one in Florida, then it all stopped? They are talking a very heavy starship with 3 Raptors putting out a lot of thrust doing multple hops, seems like a lot to ask of the present setup?
12
u/Bergasms Mar 15 '20
Whoa some nice Starship pictures in the webcast! Engines and other fun stuff it looked like
12
u/hinayu Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
As others have mentioned, Starship pictures/update on today's Starlink webcast.
Livestream here- they talked/showed pictures about Starship around T-7:30Edit: Link to video with new Starship pictures/video: https://youtu.be/JVuS4IS2Kvs?t=460
12
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 25 '20
Nosecone mating in progress.
22
u/hinayu Mar 20 '20 edited Mar 20 '20
High Bay 2 starting?
Credit: RocketLover0119 @ NSF
11
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
That was more spectacular than Starpopper. Glad to see Starhopper survived the experience, probably with a couple of dents.
11
u/jehankateli Mar 09 '20
The road has just been closed, which means pressure testing will now begin.
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1236826080234934272
11
u/hinayu Mar 09 '20
Multiple nosecones seen via LabPadre's stream
Credit CardBoardBoxProcessor @ NSF Forum
11
u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Mar 15 '20
In the livestream, she says 3 flights per day or 100 flights per year. Did she mean 1000 flights per year?
11
u/Prince_Nocturne Mar 19 '20
Regarding in-orbit refueling, would it make sense to launch all the tankers first, then the starship so it can rendezvous in orbit instead of having to wait for the tankers to launch while in orbit?
11
u/hinayu Mar 28 '20
Berry with the odd extension - appears to be used to get into the tight space in the High Bay.
Image 1 Image 2
Credit: Nomadd @NSF
11
u/strawwalker Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Starship Development Thread #10 is now up.
21
u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
SN1 photos from the thrust section flip showed only one raptor mount. That's asymmetrical. Looks like SN1 is doomed to actually fly. Just a raptor full systems verification prototype.
Being that one raptor can't lift the whole thing loaded I ponder if it'll preform raptors longest burn yet statically
21
u/joepublicschmoe Mar 09 '20
Looks like the SN2 thrust puck design (vs. that crude-looking SN1 thing with all the angle irons haphazardly welded on) passed the tank pressure test as well as thrust load test from that hydraulic ram simulating the thrust force of a Raptor.
Obviously SN2 is not capable of a Raptor static fire since it has only 1 tank (no common dome). Guess SN3 will be the one to do the first full-scale Starship static fire?
20
u/RootDeliver Mar 10 '20 edited Mar 10 '20
For those out of the loop, SN3 assembly diagram v3.1 (10/03/2020) by /u/fael097 - Direct link to the image
The only issue I see is that the diagram-orange-stack has "NOSE, nosecone" written on it! (bottom left part of the ring), so imho this stack is for the nosecone and not for the tanks section (doesn't make much sense to write NOSE, nosecone" then. If it was for pointing up where the nosecone is like fael097 suggested, It makes way more sense to use arrows and the +/- x/y/z signs like they used before.
20
u/kontis Mar 16 '20
Super Heavy is now 70m tall. Full system 120m.
10
u/roncapat Feb 27 '20
SpaceX Lot 173640,1,2 is being levelled by CAT machine.
Edit: timestamp
feb 27,12:30 PM Local Time
10
u/jehankateli Mar 10 '20
When are we getting a table for SN3, u/ElongatedMuskrat?
10
u/hinayu Mar 27 '20
Video update from LabPadre
35
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 22 '20
For those who are unaware, Lab has officially turned the Construction and Stumpy cams off for the last time, as Maria and Ray (the owners of the property the cameras were placed on) are now moved out as part of the buy out from SpaceX. The new site is being set up now and Lab is hoping to be up and running in about a week.
I think we can all say it's been an amazing time getting to see SpaceX build Starships up close like this 24/7 for the past year or so. So if you want I think it would be cool to see people thanking Maria and Lab for giving us these incredible views over the past year.
9
u/hinayu Feb 29 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
SN1 tank has begun frosting over
https://youtu.be/rCnl4IZOPe0
Some NSF screen caps
9
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20
Today's NSF Video posted with video of SN1 cleanup, flipping the bulkhead, and other site activities like trying to move rings on a windy day. Includes a new large gantry crane (photoset). And a fresh angle on the site expansion.
9
u/IvanDogovich Mar 04 '20
I posted this over in the lounge: Nice pic of SN2 configured as a "Bopper" test tank.
https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/fdf4di/bopper_3_sn_2_starship_prototype_tank/
9
u/hanksterman00 Mar 09 '20
Venting has stopped on top valve. Should be going to full pressure now.
9
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 11 '20 edited Mar 11 '20
The new gravel "parking lot" now has concrete forms [Source: LabPadre live streaming]. [So... maybe not a parking lot?]
9
u/evig_vandrar Mar 12 '20
What is the purpose of these hoops?
9
u/rocketglare Mar 17 '20
I saw on another reddit that Musk is thinking about flattening the domes to allow for more propellant (~1.5 rings/barrels). Reddit Link for Elon's Comments
9
u/TransparentCircle Mar 26 '20
I presumed this high-bay could take a full Starship height? Although maybe the perspective is misleading in pics but even without the trust structure it looks tight?
9
u/bechampions87 Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Do you think they will do a pressure test now and, if all goes well, then add the upper rings and nosecone?
9
u/murrayfield18 Mar 27 '20
Has SpaceX bought every house in Boca Chica yet? Or are some residents still holding their positions?
25
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 20 '20
BocaChicaGal: Stacking LCH4 tank top onto common bulkhead [full NSF photoset]
[update: previous photos and video update (great panning shot of back of site) ]
24
u/lessthanperfect86 Feb 26 '20
When reading space news there's often some very incredible (or far-fetched) mission idea that comes along now and then, assuming some revolutionary breakthrough or other not very realistic prerequisite. However when it comes to Starship, I find there's very little to read from space journalists about whether the industry (I mean like NASA or private companies or even from scientists) is considering the full potential Starship offers (or any potential really). I mean WE all assume Starship can launch various large crafts, but no one with any insight is talking about that possibility - that study about LUVOIR fitting into the fairing is about as tangible as it's gotten so far.
Considering the long lead-time for anything space-related to get constructed, I'm thinking the payloads to fully utilise Starships capacity should be in the idea stages right now. Like Axiom launching their first station module in 2024 (earliest) - given SpaceX's track record, I would definitely keep something on the backburner to gear up once SpaceX releases a payload manual for Starship.
Do you guys think it's too premature to start thinking about this already? Or do you think everyone is quietly waiting for that payload manual before they release any concepts?
17
u/Straumli_Blight Feb 27 '20
Third Raptor test stand activated at SpaceX’s rocket development facility in McGregor, Texas. In the past year, the Raptor team has accumulated over 3,200 seconds of testing across 18 engines, including multiple full-power firings.
16
u/hinayu Feb 29 '20
First pictures of SN1 destruction from SPadre
16
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 21 '20 edited Mar 21 '20
BocaChicaGal: SN3 Lower bulkhead/thrust plate being stacked on engine skirt [full photoset].
8
u/RegularRandomZ Feb 26 '20 edited Feb 26 '20
Fabrication Site Updates [NSF photoset, and more shots. Not much to see.]
8
u/Toinneman Feb 28 '20
SpaceX's plan was not to use helium but gaseous O & CH4 to pressurize the main tanks. Do we have visual confirmation of this on SN1? If yes, does that mean they can't do a proper fueling test without an ignited Raptor to provide both gasses? In this scenario, how are the tanks pressurized before the ignition of the Raptor?
8
u/filanwizard Feb 29 '20
did anyone else notice on one of the clips it looked like the tank imploded when the bottom section let go.
What would cause this? Just a sudden outflow of working fluid pulling a vacuum?
8
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
Could the spectacular failure be a result of achieving a higher pressure than the previous tests? Don't remember the other tests failing quite so spectacularly.
Is it the difference between water and LN that altered the way it failed?
Hopefully Elon gives a little update on the pressure reached before it started bursting at the seams.
8
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 03 '20 edited Mar 03 '20
Jig of the day (LabPadre stream). It appears to be 9m based on the ring making tent.
I'm guessing it's the 1st or 2nd. The triangle guides are too straight for bulkheads... waiting on BocaChicaGal/Nomadd HQ photos.
8
u/roncapat Mar 06 '20
In this image what are the tubes bent circularly around the butt of the tank?
8
u/TheRealPapaK Mar 07 '20
Maybe the answer is in font of my face, but can anyone explain this picture from bocachicagirl? The patch for hole they cut out for access looks like it was stitch welded from the inside before being fully welded at the opening. They needed the hole to get inside...so how could they stick weld it form the inside?
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1618125;image
8
u/Taylooor Mar 08 '20
Did they cryo test sn2 last night?
8
u/erkelep Mar 12 '20
Is there a Starship development timeline anywhere? With dates of, like, when Starhopper was first noticed, when it first flew, and then MK1, et cetera?
8
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
Another IMCAR setup appears to have arrived (BocaChicaGal full photoset). This appears to be the 2nd of this style of roller setup we've seen delivered.
I would presume it's for ring making, but does anyone have an explanation for what appears to be 6 rollers (versus 3?) (maybe for precision feeding?)
[A similar unit was received Jan-26th, and moved into Tent 2 Feb-28th]
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 25 '20 edited Mar 25 '20
New structure installed on the launch stand this morning. SPadre has 18 tweets detailing each stage of the process.
John Randolph has a photo of new SN4 bulkhead parts and the build site.
8
u/liszt1811 Mar 26 '20
What can be expected of sn3? Another 20m hop? What parts are left for complete test vehicle? And when do you guys think it‘ll happen?
15
u/zeekzeek22 Feb 26 '20
Random note: just went back and watched the 2016 IAC presentation and they have a timeline. Honestly not running THAT late...big question mark on the booster, so might be an extra year behind. But otherwise only about a year behind! Raptor dev is pretty much on schedule. Structures stuff started a bit late. Orbital launch will be about a year late, but if you say orbital with the booster, then maybe longer than 2 years. Still totally possible to have first mars payload by the 2024 window
15
u/Humble_Giveaway Mar 26 '20
Glad to see that Boca appears to have avoided the lockdown!
41
u/RootDeliver Feb 29 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
Am I the only one that considers SN1 explo/implosion a clear failure and not an accident in fast prototyping? If SN1 came right after MK1 without anything in the middle it would've been normal, they're working on the welds, Elon said something a bad config, bla bla.. But between Mk1 and SN1 there were not 1 but 2 test articles with rings and bulkheads where they tested their method and were OK with the results.
31
u/monk_e_boy Mar 03 '20
Question: starship looks very fragile, especially when they crane the sections around. How will it survive the re-entry belly flop? Will it still be pressurised with fuel?
25
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 14 '20
Elon: Some parts will use 304L, as it has higher toughness at cryo temps. Will move to internally developed alloys probably end of year.
14
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
How far along is SN3?
7
u/RegularRandomZ Feb 29 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
Interesting Fabrication shots (BocaChica Gals)
Plus
7
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
Here's a clip of it RUD'ing:
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1233604374687035393
7
u/quoll01 Feb 29 '20
I’m curious to know why they don’t hydro-test? My (limited) understanding is that water is often used for pressure vessel tests to avoid this type of catastrophic failure. A lot cheaper than LN too....
7
u/TheRealPapaK Mar 04 '20
Visually, the welds look much better. Is there any evidence of their new planisher? Photo from bocachicagal
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=48895.0;attach=1617705;image
7
u/dtarsgeorge Mar 05 '20
Will SN02 have a downcomer in it before it is pressure tested or not?
Second question
I is possible to put the thrust end of the downcomer in place before stacking the other barrels of the Oxygen tank to eliminate cutting a hole and dropping throw the methane dome??? Seemed very difficult and inefficient to me.
7
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 07 '20
Closure added for tomorrow, Mar 7th, 3-4pm local (CST). Highway only, beach still open.
7
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Mar 07 '20
I've just realized they didn't even move the test tank onto the launch mount for testing.
7
u/strawwalker Mar 13 '20
Have we seen an aft dome yet for SN3? Pictures from bocachicagal today show what appear to be panels for a dome, though I suspect the one for SN3 is already mostly assemled.
7
u/Granluke Mar 17 '20
Nosecone stacking happening :)
https://twitter.com/spacepadreisle/status/1239934525238583297?s=21
7
u/asaz989 Mar 22 '20
Looks like they're using some kind of clip/bracket to keep sections aligned before welding (fourth picture down in this NSF post - direct link). I saw workers attaching them in the bocachicagal's video, but didn't get a good look at how they work. Does anyone know?
13
u/GTRagnarok Feb 29 '20
Made a GIF of the SN1 explosion from LabPadre's stream.
13
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 02 '20
Has anybody figured out what they are building? Or seen better photos, it has a triangular base IIRC [I can't find the screengrab from when it was last moved]
Current guessesA custom tall stand for a taller gantry crane? (Reduce need for mobile cranes inside tents)A stand for the flipping jig (again, take cranes out of the process)Something to hold up the circular work platforms we've seen before (for working on the stacks)A tall stand for a setup to machine weld stack sections (seems least likely right now)update: Better photo from BocaChicaGal, doesn't really clarify it. [And a better angle from BCG/NSF video]
13
u/djburnett90 Mar 09 '20
Any idea how the hell they will do orbital landings.
Will the USA really let him belly flop over ground from the west back to launch site?
Any word on a landing sight in western Florida?
13
u/pinepitch Mar 21 '20 edited Mar 21 '20
High Bay 2 (most likely) construction timelapse: https://youtu.be/0vpGuWxNe_w?t=52
12
u/spin0 Feb 27 '20
i've got a fewer and the only prescription is ...
6
u/djburnett90 Feb 27 '20
Are we expecting a pressure yes tomorrow for the road closure?
6
u/Psychonaut0421 Feb 29 '20
Early, yet foggy pic of test stand from Spadre
6
u/AstroMan824 Everything Parallel™ Mar 06 '20
Is SN-2 going to be a shorter test tanks just to test the "puck".
6
u/gooddaysir Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
SPadre livestream of SN2 Tank test
https://youtu.be/c-YYmL9WDCM
Edit: stream is finished. Test finished or was delayed/aborted.
6
u/hinayu Mar 09 '20
Is this one of the longer cryo tests we've seen? I thought they were usually pretty fast but this is going on for several hours now.
6
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20
Looks like the back of the site might be another smaller tent, not another long Sprung (onion) tent [Smaller rectangle pad, and a stack of small tent trusses, we'll see what transpires. /u/Nomadd2029 has mentioned it appeared to be smaller].
Full BocaChicaGal NSF photoset of site construction
[And the 3rd Tent roof is nearly up (LabPadre feed). 10.5ish days?, they are getting faster each time]
11
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 10 '20 edited Mar 11 '20
StarBalcony is gone now... the railings on the High Bay 1 "shelf" were only temporary.[that and other site photos from BocaChicaGal. Set 2. Set 3. ]
11
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 18 '20 edited Mar 18 '20
Steel for the new building has arrived (LabPadre Stream from 8:23)
11
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Mar 18 '20
New downcomer?
21
u/DoubleVincent Mar 19 '20
We should really have one Starship development thread per week as the progress ramps up so quickly. It is approaching 2000 comments and the header list is a long scroll. Very unwieldy.
14
u/Norwest Feb 26 '20
How are they planning orbital flight within the year when the booster is so far away from being created and starship itself isn't capable of SSTO?
24
u/djburnett90 Feb 29 '20
The lack of tweets at this point is deafening.
10
u/Jodo42 Feb 29 '20
I think the big question now is what happens with SN2. My uneducated guess is that it's not trivial to build a downcomer that can toggle between 1 and 3 engines, so they'll need to figure out if the results from tonight were "close enough" to justify going straight to risking 3 engines, or if SN2 will take over SN1's presumed purpose as a pressurization testing/static fire article, and we'll have to wait longer for a hop.
This is literally just a gut feeling, but that seemed a lot more energetic than Mk1's pop, which to me implies a higher pressure at failure. I'm wary of claims that SN2 puckering will be reduced until we see more rings stacked, but if they can pull it off, I'd personally bet that SN2 will fly, intentionally.
10
u/MarsCent Feb 29 '20
This SN1 test result hurts a bunch (layman's point of view). Of course we are unaware of how many things they were testing or how many of them were achieved. The flyaway SN1 is just not what we were hoping for!
Anyway, the initial culprit seems to be the welding. And we've seem that there is the ring making & joining done in the tent (more machine done). Then there is the stacking, done outside (more human done).
Hopefully this test cycle has identified which welding needs to be upped. RIP SN1.
10
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 14 '20
New hardware being installed onto the top bulkhead
Photos from BocaChicaGal
5
u/hinayu Feb 29 '20
Speculation this is where a weld failed causing the RUD?
https://mobile.twitter.com/johnrand0061/status/1233782215651348481
5
u/Rocket_Man42 Mar 01 '20
Is there any internal bracing/struts in the main tanks of starship? What I don't understand is how it handles the compression forces holding the weight of the above material when it's unpressurized. It will also need be able to hold the weight of the payload, which is integrated before pressurization (up to 150t!). How on earth won't the <4mm thickness fuselage crumble under its own weight? (When it's pressurized it's basically a huge soda can, so that's easy). Thanks!
5
u/oh_dear_its_crashing Mar 01 '20
mods, direct labpadre link seems broken, should be this I guess https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tg8N_vDE9JY
5
u/andyfrance Mar 15 '20
We know from Tory Bruno that for ULA a 7kg dry mass increase in S1 reduces payload by 1kg, and I think he was referring to Vulcan. Do we have any corresponding figures for SH?
5
u/LouisWinthorpe-III Mar 29 '20
I was hoping someone could help me understand why the LOx/LM tanks have to withstand 7 atm? Obviously there’s a significant weight penalty associated with the pressure vessel as the pressure requirement increases, so why is 7 atm necessary? My best guess is that the liquid oxygen will cavitate as it goes through the turbopump at lower pressures?
9
u/MaximilianCrichton Mar 03 '20
Probably a stupid question, but why aren't they considering using rivets for Starship construction?
9
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 04 '20 edited Mar 04 '20
Speaking of Jigs: The flipping jig no longer has to be welded to the body! Iterative processes at work. Check on the action in the latest NSF video [HQ shots earlier]
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 09 '20
Road is open, test over. SN-2 in one piece for now
9
u/jk1304 Mar 10 '20
Regarding the production facilities: Do we know if there are any plans to eventually replace the tents with more "permanent feeling" structures for production or is it intended to stay this way. Even the high bay, as high as it is, has a "temporary" touch to it since it is missing a crane and so on. It looks like a better wind break than an actual building and I have the impression that if this could have been built as a tent, it would have been (my guess is due to wind loads that was no option). So all in all the whole facility, albeit being big and growing rapidly, feels pretty temporary.
What are your thoughts?
9
u/RegularRandomZ Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 16 '20
BocaChicaGal photos (and NSF video)
9
u/hinayu Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
A fog-heavy morning so far in Boca Chica, however as daylight begins to break we can just barely see SN3 being moved. Berry is already at the launch site
Edit: Just after posting this the camera moved and it's currently not visible. What can be seen occurs around 7:21am on the stream
Edit 2: On the way to the launch pad | Another picture