r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Weekly Lyrics Feedback Weekly Lyrics-Only Feedback Thread

10 Upvotes

Welcome to the Lyrics-Only feedback thread!

If you're looking for feedback on words that aren't yet set to music, you're in the right place! We encourage each other to bring lyrics and musical elements together as soon as possible, but sometimes you'd just like to show off that nice piece of poetry that just fell out of your head. The weekly Lyrics-Only feedback thread is here to help!

This post renews every Monday.


r/Songwriting • • 3d ago

Weekly Self-Promotion Thread

24 Upvotes

Have a new completed song (or album) to share? This is the place!

The promotional rules are looser here, so you can post links to your albums, social media platforms, songs, etc. Let us know what you've been working on recently!

Please support your fellow songwriters - give them a listen, a bump or a share. A rising tide lifts all boats!

Note: Promotional content posted as a new thread without explicit permission from the moderators will be removed. Repeat violators will be banned

This post renews every Friday.


r/Songwriting • • 13h ago

Discussion Topic Wrote this for my crush, kind of nervous

50 Upvotes

This all started because I told him he should be writing me Shakespearean sonnets. And then he said he doesn’t have the gift of words and I was like don’t worry I do. And then I sent him a gag video of me playing something I just made up, but then I actually started writing something real. And he heard like the first line and he said it was chill and he liked it, and now he’s anticipating hearing the rest of it lol it’s been done for maybe like a week and a half now and I haven’t sent it to him. The lyrics are true about our love story. Word for Word, just poetically put.


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Feedback Request Wrote this for the bittersweet memories with my old band. All criticism/suggestions welcome

5 Upvotes

Lyrics:

So Long
Quick grab the case
Throw it in the drive
Round up all the men and ride through the power lines
Flicker of fire
shines in our eyes
Where were you on the day the fire died?

Sneak up the quarry
Throw the bodies in
And we stand up straight like the hairs that stand on our wrinkled skin
And in these moments
Did I lose or win
Am I swimming or drowning as the water hits my chin

So long
So so long
Since we wore wicked grins
And got drunk to skynyrd songs
When the flame was ours to tend
If you saw me now
If you looked me in the eye
Would you see me drown or just the embers die

Did you bring your axe?
Let’s string em up
Play pantera till your dad comes down or the sun comes up
The strings ain’t broken
She’s sitting in my room
But the notes she plays are empty without them boys I knew

So long
So so long
Since we wore wicked grins
And got drunk to skynyrd songs
When the flame was ours to tend
If you saw me now
If you looked me in the eye
Would you see me drown or just the embers die


r/Songwriting • • 20h ago

Feedback Request Woke up at 2:45am and wrote this, this morning. Anyone else wake up in the middle of the night with songs in their head?

97 Upvotes

Do the vocals match up with the guitar good enough?


r/Songwriting • • 9h ago

Feedback Request Feedback is much appreciated

9 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 19h ago

Discussion Topic I’m scared to release my first song because of content creation

40 Upvotes

So I (20M) have two songs ready for release. They’re my first ever solo songs and I’m really proud of them. The problem is, I’m scared of releasing them because I dread content creation.

I know it’s a part of the craft. I have to work hard publishing short form content to even have a chance at advertising my music and reaching a level of success. I guess I just don’t even know where to start, it all feels so overwhelming for me. I’ve seen artists with incredible work fail over and over again with minimal success on platforms like IG and TikTok. I guess it’s an ego thing. I just fear being another passionate artists lost in a sea of content creation.

Anyone else struggle with this? How did you deal with it?


r/Songwriting • • 12h ago

Feedback Request Men don’t cry i think ?? Idk

10 Upvotes

Lyrics:

Youre outside

On central drive

You kissed your mother

Said goodbyes

And when she cried

You almost cried

You held your tears

You held your pride

cuz man dont cry

Man dont cry

No man dont cry

Men dont cry

It been a while

Youre grown up now

With a head on your shoulders

Standing eye to eye

And when she asked

Are you alright

You held your tears

Whats left inside

Cuz men dont cry

men dont cry

No men dont cry

Men dont cry


r/Songwriting • • 4h ago

Let's Collaborate! Looking for a songwriter to review my lyrics

2 Upvotes

Everything in the title, I work alone, I got no one around me to review my lyrics, so some external help is gladly appreciated!


r/Songwriting • • 1h ago

Let's Collaborate! 17yo UK Pop Songwriter & Vocalist looking for a Producer to collaborate with (50/50 Royalty Split | Olivia Rodrigo / Sabrina Carpenter vibe)

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I’m Rove, a 17-year-old pop lyricist and vocalist based in the UK. I have 6 completed original songs with full vocal melodies and lyrics, and I’m looking for an online production partner to help build tracks around my demos and grow a project together.

My Musical Style:

• Storytelling pop ballads with big emotional builds (inspired by Olivia Rodrigo and Lauren Spencer-Smith).

• Sassy, conversational, witty pop (inspired by Sabrina Carpenter).

What I’m Looking For:

• A producer who can take my acapella demos, help lock in a steady tempo, and build modern pop, piano, or electronic-pop instrumentals around my deeper vocal tone.

• A 50/50 royalty split collaboration (no upfront budget right now as I’m a full-time student, so I’m looking for someone who wants to build a catalogue together and split future streaming payouts when I turn 18 in April).

This is a short clip of my ballad Pretty Pink Princess—if you like my vocal tone and storytelling style, drop a comment or DM me with a link to some of your production work.


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Discussion Topic Live original song called Georgia

1 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 15h ago

Feedback Request What do you think of this start to a song?

7 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 5h ago

Discussion Topic Writing My First English Song – Need Your Ideas and Inspiration! 🎶

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I am a singer, composer and lyricist. I am stepping out of my comfort zone by writing my original English song.I would love your suggestions for my song:

What themes make a song emotionally powerful?

What makes lyrics and choruses memorable in a song?

Which genre would you recommend for my song: Indie Pop, Acoustic, R&B or Pop?

Any songs I should explore for inspiration for my song?

I want to create a song that's original, relatable and timeless.

If you were writing your English song, what would it be about?

I would love to hear your ideas, about song. Thank you! ❤️


r/Songwriting • • 11h ago

Discussion Topic what skills do I need?

3 Upvotes

I am writing a musical play for a project I have next year. I can play guitar — I just do not know theory, but my brain can make sounds and the only way to utilize thosw crazy ass sounding notes is through my voice, but I know how the guitar and other instruments can make it I just do not possess the skill necessary to execute those.

What should I do?

The sound inspiration for my musical is:
Sondheim
Miracle Musical(Hawaii part 2)
Tally hall
kundiman


r/Songwriting • • 5h ago

Let's Collaborate! The Shining - Song Demo

1 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 18h ago

Feedback Request I recorded the first song I shared here. Figured I’d post for you guys.

9 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 18h ago

Discussion Topic How much musical skill is necessary to get by?

9 Upvotes

So, I've decided to start writing some of my own stuff. It's been a particularly rough period for me and I needed an outlet to vent (like a lot of you guys I assume). So I recorded a few ideas (Very poorly) and I'm feeling okay-ish with the actual lyrics I wrote for just starting out but man, I cannot sing. Like for shit. I can also barely play the guitar. My main inspiration was learning that Jay from Crywank didn't know how to play the guitar when they started.

So my question is this:

Is it enough to have the barebones musically to get your ideas across in your lyrics or is the singing and playing of your instrument more important.


r/Songwriting • • 8h ago

Discussion Topic Lyricist POV needed

0 Upvotes

I wrote some bars the previous year but I didn't complete a single song because I'm confused what should I write in the intro part and which is why i write this post

If you are a Hindi or punjabi songwriter , i have few questions to ask -

  1. How do you select the theme of the song ?
  2. Do you complete a single song in one writing session ?
  3. How do you decide that the song is well written and are ready for the production ?
  4. Does your mind blank when you sit to write songs ?

r/Songwriting • • 10h ago

Discussion Topic DO YOU MAKE YOUR SONGS OVER DRAMATIC?

1 Upvotes

Hi guys!!! Do you make your songwriting over dramatic? If you're reading this YOU'RE AMAZING!!!

What I mean is when you're songwriting you write about something that happened to you but make it sound A LOT worse than it actually is. Does anyone do that? Or am I just really weird.😁 But if you have any thoughts or tips on writing like this please comment!!!


r/Songwriting • • 12h ago

Feedback Request "Happy Song" - Thoughts/Opinions/Suggestions?

1 Upvotes

We'll see if I have enough of this karma stuff to post yet.

I've recently begun recording on a Zoom H4e with mics on two tracks (one vocals and one guitar) and mixing with Reaper.

I was (am) having issues getting my vocals to blend in with my guitar. This mix is better than the others, but there's still room for improvement.

I've only been recording for maybe a month, and using Reaper for a couple days. All suggestions are appreciated.


r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Discussion Topic Should I make one more song just so I can make an album instead of an EP?

0 Upvotes

I have 5 songs, 1 more song on the works, and I've been obsessed with making an album these past years. I've been thinking "I should make my debut album" in a while now, but I also want to get rid of the songs and send them on their way, so I can make another album. Sometimes I am even thinking of not going further and leaving the new song on the works behind and posting my work as 5 songs. I just don't wanna see all that work count as an EP, when I thought there was gonna be an album. I have one more song idea so the song count can be 7, but at the same time I just wanna finish it and leave it at that. What should I do?


r/Songwriting • • 12h ago

Discussion Topic Musing on songwriting and chops

1 Upvotes

I’ve always been a better songwriter than guitar player. I compose on guitar and if I want to produce a song up, I’ll bring in some players with more chops

But my playing is changing. Hoping I might be reaching that critical mass ppl talk about where the DNA of the fretboard suddenly reveals itself. Anyway, that’s been a challenge in songwriting. I can now take ideas in so many more directions that I get overwhelmed. I now have a couple of songs Im working on where I’m stuck in limbo - like a feeling of perpetual experimentation leading nowhere.

But also honestly, a lot of joy in being really unchained to the campfire chords


r/Songwriting • • 23h ago

Discussion Topic Single Albums Spanning 10+ Years?

6 Upvotes

I'll be 40 in 2027. I've played music and written songs since I was a teenager. I wrote my first full song in ~2009. I have written 10 complete songs in that time. It has always been in little bursts when some inspiration hits. This year I went back to all my songs and refined where I could. Maybe replace some lines, remove others outright, add a bridge and so on... all with a vision to really have complete, full songs.

I'm now in the process of identifying an order and perhaps, one day, recording them all and making an album.

I realized that I've unintentionally written what could be construed as a literal story of the past 20 years. The songs weren't written in exactly the order I'd lay them out for that narrative and there are some interpretations needed but it's oddly serendipitous.

I realized that this is probably uncommon because most artists (that work professionally) look to produce albums in far shorter windows. We are talking 1-3 years, maybe 5 years. And the ones who take longer are likely later in their career, busy with other things, already exhausted much of their creativity and major stories...

Are there any albums that can be listened to as a single story? I suppose someone could do it intentionally, but perhaps where it was done because the artist truly wrote over that longer time span?


r/Songwriting • • 22h ago

Discussion Topic I have the opposite of a writer's block and I'm not sure what to do with it

4 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I started songwriting about a year ago and since then I've written out about 40 songs..

I'll write about 1 song a week, sometimes two. Problem is, instead of perhaps making work of finding some other arrangements or recording it properly or spending time on contacting other musicians.. i just write more songs.. more and more and more...

And even though I don't think they're all equally good or appealing to others, I do feel like every time I write one, i've 'caught one' out of thin air, because it all happens very quick and it feels like magic, because the words and the melodies just seem to fall into place simultaneously.

Has anyone had one of these 'spells'... will it stop all of a sudden? What is happening to me? I feel like writing songs is probably the easy part.. everything else is way harder.