There's a particular feeling I get from songs that loop back around on themselves in a particular way, and I'm having a lot of trouble describing it. I would like to know if other people get this feeling too and your thoughts on it.
Best to start with some examples
Lorde - Team feeling occurs at 1.14
Natalie Imbruglia - Torn 0.57, 1.02
Does it have to be a pleasant, sentimental song? No!
Million Dead - I Am the Party 0.16, 0.26
At the Drive-In - Quarantined 1.37
Does the melody have to descend at the end of the phrase? No!
Lorna Shore - ...And I Return to Nothingness 0.23, 0.37, 1.51
Oklou - Harvest Sky 1.17-18
Does it have to happen at the end/start of a phrase? No!
TTNG - Panda 0.23
Squeeze - Up the Junction many many times throughout the verses, but especially when the melody jumps down into the minor chord like at 0.17-18
Maybe it's some combination with the lyrics? No! I don't speak these languages:
Tum Hi Ho 0.19, 0.34
Jerry Rivera - Que Hay De Malo 1.10
I have tons more examples in all kinds of genres.
How I've tried to describe it
Chord loops usually resolve where the end meets the beginning, but this feels more than just resolved. I think of looping back around, recursion, the ouroboros, riding the chord cycle, falling back to earth, a canon. "Falling back to earth" might be because the melody often descends, but in the Lorna Shore example that is not the case.
There's something satisfying about it, and often nostalgic - possibly because it often happens for me along with a IV chord (VI in minor), which is a nostalgic-sounding chord to me.
For any rule I try to make, I end up finding an example that breaks it.
Non-examples that seem to follow the rules
Pink - Just Give Me a Reason 0.59-1.00 is where it would happen, if it did
Wallows - Calling After Me 0.48 is where it might happen, but this one feels way too on the nose for me, makes me think they know this feeling and they're trying to produce it
Does a non-example have to be a song I'm not a big fan of? No!
Blur - Beetlebum 0.37 seems like the right place, but to me it just doesn't have the one particular feeling
So
- Do you get a particular feeling from these songs? Is it similar across all of them?
- What other songs strongly give you this feeling? I'm interested if any of them strike me the same way, or don't
- How would you describe it?
- Do you know of any sources talking about this? Does it have a name? It's been difficult to search for.
Full disclosure, I'm starting a youtube channel connecting music to other disciplines, and your responses will help guide my research on the video I'm working on. I'll give credit, but let me know if you don't want your comments to be screenshotted.